The Monarchy exists as the symbolic representation of the UK, it would be a mistake for him to place blame and guilt on every single citizen of the UK. He could believe it 100% but he should not be putting that on the British public.
My point is that since we are subjects we are under the authority of the monarchy and so why wouldn't the King "put that on the British public?" We are the subjects!@@brettyates7054
No, our past was great and our present is a failure, contrary to what people today think that our past was terrible and our present is great. they should apologise to the indigenous Brits for the state of things now
The King has no reason to apologise for anything. The British Empire bought justice, liberty and progress to many. It was first in all of history to abolish slavery (1808) and actively fight against it.
Agree absolutely. My husband was a pilot during the 1950s and the 1960s. He said he saw Africa at its best - British Colonial Africa where everything worked, there was education, health care, very little crime, justice and above all, fair play.
@@raynename1041 Slavery and the slave trade has existed throughout the world since the dawn of time and still exists in some places and cultures today, eg. parts of Africa, throughout the Islamic world and China. The USSR was built on slavery and collapsed when the gulags were abolished. In 1808, The British Empire was first major power in history to abolish slavery throughout its realms and has actively fought it ever since; that is something to be proud of.
@@freeman8128 The damage was already done and people are still affected by it till date. Try and turn slave trade round on Africans. The whole of the European empire were a very evil empire. I would be proud and gloat if the British abolish slave trade without taking part, however they took part and they were one of the major factors at the time. So them abolishing it first doesn’t mean anything to me. The British abolished it after they had gained tremendous from the slave trade, and they had murdered a lot of the African natives.
I am a South African. Family members of mine died in concentration camps during the Anglo Boer War. I do not expect King Charles to apologize for that. He was not born yet and nor was I. I will remember my family with no anger to Britain today. I also have Jewish ancestors, but I do not hold Germans today responsible for what happened during Hilter's reign. All I want today's Brits and Germans to do today, is not let it happen today.
He represents an institution that has caused so many mental and physical damage to the world. No one is asking the British public but the leadership. They are now supporting the cleansing of the Palestinians, evil acts
It's unimaginable it could happen again right? Except The way some are acting today we could easily see it happening again. Obviously old racial and religious bigotry are still alive in the hearts of many TODAY.
I am a Nigerian and I live in Nigeria, I don't think his majesty King Charles III should apologise. The British may have been violent in their crackdown of the Mau Mau rebellion in the 1950s. The Mau Mau themselves killed thousands of their fellow Kenyans and 199 British people ie 167 soldiers and policemen and 32 civilians in Kenya. The Mau Mau were not freedom fighters but were terrorists, even Jomo Kenyatta, Tom Mboya and others never supported them.
I'm British, and I've just been sorting out some of the documents belonging to my late parents. My father was a civil engineer, who built a hospital in Ibaden in the 1950s. There are some thankyou letters for their help in fundraising to equip the hospital with new equipment. Lots of history. Overall, the UK's good influences outweigh the bad.
Speak for yourself idiot I want an apology for the atrocities the British did to my country. Came in, killed, looted, and left a disaster. This is the exact problem with us Africans, the Jews will never forget the Holocaust or 911 but you want us forget the barbaric acts of the British on my country
Should italy now apologise for the roman invasion ? Should Norway and Scandinavia apologise for the viking invasion ? Should the Spanish apologies for their wars ? HISTORY
Has the Japanese imperial empire ever apologized for slaughtering millions in Burma the Philippines and Korea, and what the Japanese did in Nanjing China in 1938 was so horrific it's even been called the forgotten holocaust 🙄
@@shareluv7 Throughout the years you'll sometimes see an American president lay a wreath in Hiroshima on the anniversary of the A bomb attack but you'll never see a Japanese prime minister lay a wreath in Nanjing China were one of the most vile and sadistic crimes against humanity took place 🙄
@@shareluv7 Maybe you missed Obama laying a wreath in Hiroshima in 2016 and saying that the memory of Hiroshima must never fade, tell me when was the last time a Japanese prime minister layed a wreath in Nanjing and said sorry 🤔
I am South African and thousands of women and children died during the Anglo Boer War with inhumane atrocities against women and children in the concentration camps. No need to apologise as long as we don't forget the history and never repeat the same mistakes. No apology will bring back the dead but will only keep alive and nurture the hatred between people.
Thank you for posting this. I covered this in history at school. Just as importantly, I have seen some excellent documentaries about the Boer War on TV in recent times. There were some terrible things done to the Boers and it is a shameful part of our history. I reckon that Britain should be giving a home to Boer descendants if they would like to come here and start a new life. From what I have read, life in South Africa can be pretty rough for the whites who are left. That would be more valuable than any apology.
I am a 74 year old PROUD English woman., we should never apologise FOR something that happened before ANY of us were alive, for things we never did. NO NEVER EVER.🇬🇧
@@DonatusOkechukwuOkoli-zc7nz The precedent line to the English and Scottish thrones was thrown out during the Dutch military coup of 1689. They took Ireland as well in 1691. After the forced merger with Scotland in 1707 they brought in a junior European royal line, the Hanoverians in 1714. There are 48 people in Europe ,all descended from Charles I, with a better claim to our throne than the usurpers. Charles of Sondersburg-Glucksberg is 49th in line to our throne.
@@serene5986 Is it just white empires you have a problem with but the Japanese imperial empire that slaughtered millions in Burma the Philippines and Korea, and what the Japanese did in Nanjing China in the 1930s was so horrific it's even been called the forgotten holocaust 🙄 but do they get a pass because they weren't white?
@@serene5986 To be fair the population of India boomed under British rule, and the British also stopped the barbaric act of Suttee were the Indians would throw the widow of the deceased husband on the bonfire with him...
@@WotsisFace I think it's all about getting as much as they can from our country, on saying this our governments are fools and will give in, but who is it that pays? You and me !
Of course he shouldn't apologise. England was just doing what every other powerful country did. Even with slavery (and we were the first empire to abolish it, at great cost to ourselves). The North Africans dragged us off as slaves, which is why we had to build up our navy and wrote "Rule, Britannia".
Nana is accurately correct regarding history .... slavery existed thousands of years ago .... Again correct the "Industrial Revolution" actually gave us the wealth of prosperity ...
@@IBTU When Britain advocated for slavery to be abolished and it was, White people are not responsible for slavery it was Black people who enslaved their own people and are trying to push their guilt onto White's! We Owe them Nothing!
If Britain had not stepped in at great loss of life by our soldiers Kenya would be about as done as South Africa is today. Our former colonies have done very well for themselves good for them but look at the rest of Africa constant wars and no respect for anyone. Would Kenya like to be without Electricity 24 hours a day. OUR KING HAS NOTHING TO APOLOGIZE FOR TO ANYONE.
Perhaps the French should apologise for invading this land, starving those that resisted by burning their fields, and carving up the country for their cronies.
It is about time that these individuals join the modern society and realise that history belongs in the past... The future is the way forward and she should stop stirring the effluent. ..for the want of a more appropriate word... She appears to be making a good living on this drivel..
The only people who have a right to apologise are those responsible. The idea that someone generations removed has the right or ability to apologise for actions committed long before their birth is close to hubris. In any case it is impossible to apologise to people long dead... because they are not alive to hear anything. This strange quadrille of one bunch of people claiming they they have the right to demand another bunch crawl to them as, perhaps, they imagine their long dead relatives once were forced to genuflect is surreal. What's done is done. What needs to be done is the issue. Harking on about history takes focus away from sorting out the future. There is something elementally negative and self-defeating in this perverse exchange of hopeless negativity.
NO, King Charles, nor any Caucasian person alive today, DOES NOT and SHOULD NOT apologize for sins committed by predecessors. They are not responsible for anything so they do not owe anyone anything.
Excellent commentary. Nana really shown like the sun on this. We need to never forget the sins of our past to not repeat them. And we need to correct and cease our current wrongs.
Things were done in the past which should not have, on the other side of the coin African and other people have been exposed to technology which has enriched their lives. Will the Italians apologise for the Roman empire? Russia for the Stalinist system and the cold war? the list is endless.
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
Why not get the french and germans and the other Europeans to THANK THE BRIRISH EMPIRE for liberating them three times?
Well spoken
Because they didn't
The Monarchy exists as the symbolic representation of the UK, it would be a mistake for him to place blame and guilt on every single citizen of the UK. He could believe it 100% but he should not be putting that on the British public.
Are we not subjects to the authority of the monarchy showing loyalty and allegiance?
None of us living was there. I won't apologise for my ancestors.
@@martynblackburn9632 what's your point? It doesn't seem to follow logically from my statement.
My point is that since we are subjects we are under the authority of the monarchy and so why wouldn't the King "put that on the British public?" We are the subjects!@@brettyates7054
@@martynblackburn9632idiot
No, our past was great and our present is a failure, contrary to what people today think that our past was terrible and our present is great. they should apologise to the indigenous Brits for the state of things now
The blame is on the politicians
The King has no reason to apologise for anything.
The British Empire bought justice, liberty and progress to many. It was first in all of history to abolish slavery (1808) and actively fight against it.
What?
Agree absolutely. My husband was a pilot during the 1950s and the 1960s. He said he saw Africa at its best - British Colonial Africa where everything worked, there was education, health care, very little crime, justice and above all, fair play.
The slave trade shouldn’t have started in the first place. Why are you proud because Britain was the first to abolish slave trade?
@@raynename1041 Slavery and the slave trade has existed throughout the world since the dawn of time and still exists in some places and cultures today, eg. parts of Africa, throughout the Islamic world and China. The USSR was built on slavery and collapsed when the gulags were abolished. In 1808, The British Empire was first major power in history to abolish slavery throughout its realms and has actively fought it ever since; that is something to be proud of.
@@freeman8128 The damage was already done and people are still affected by it till date. Try and turn slave trade round on Africans. The whole of the European empire were a very evil empire. I would be proud and gloat if the British abolish slave trade without taking part, however they took part and they were one of the major factors at the time. So them abolishing it first doesn’t mean anything to me.
The British abolished it after they had gained tremendous from the slave trade, and they had murdered a lot of the African natives.
Question, Should King Charles apologise?
Answer, no.
YES to Meghan markle 😅
@@phillipcarter8045 Why would he apologise to a b list actress?
Apologize no, abdicate yes.
@@Beauloqs Being replaced by?
I am a South African. Family members of mine died in concentration camps during the Anglo Boer War. I do not expect King Charles to apologize for that. He was not born yet and nor was I. I will remember my family with no anger to Britain today. I also have Jewish ancestors, but I do not hold Germans today responsible for what happened during Hilter's reign. All I want today's Brits and Germans to do today, is not let it happen today.
He represents an institution that has caused so many mental and physical damage to the world. No one is asking the British public but the leadership. They are now supporting the cleansing of the Palestinians, evil acts
It's unimaginable it could happen again right? Except The way some are acting today we could easily see it happening again. Obviously old racial and religious bigotry are still alive in the hearts of many TODAY.
No.
Absolutely not.
The British Empire was a modernising force for good.
I am a Nigerian and I live in Nigeria, I don't think his majesty King Charles III should apologise.
The British may have been violent in their crackdown of the Mau Mau rebellion in the 1950s.
The Mau Mau themselves killed thousands of their fellow Kenyans and 199 British people ie 167 soldiers and policemen and 32 civilians in Kenya.
The Mau Mau were not freedom fighters but were terrorists, even Jomo Kenyatta, Tom Mboya and others never supported them.
I'm British, and I've just been sorting out some of the documents belonging to my late parents. My father was a civil engineer, who built a hospital in Ibaden in the 1950s. There are some thankyou letters for their help in fundraising to equip the hospital with new equipment. Lots of history. Overall, the UK's good influences outweigh the bad.
The British empire murdered over 100 million men women and children worldwide
Speak for yourself idiot
I want an apology for the atrocities the British did to my country. Came in, killed, looted, and left a disaster. This is the exact problem with us Africans, the Jews will never forget the Holocaust or 911 but you want us forget the barbaric acts of the British on my country
In India British Empire stole trillions and killed 50 million of Indians
I thank you sir, for the kind education ... :)
Have a wonderful day ...
What the King should do is to tell them to go to work and not beg for free money
He should be out working instead of proroguing Parliament for his own designs.
The hypocracy, think of the hypocracy.
Do as I say and don’t do has I do
Should italy now apologise for the roman invasion ? Should Norway and Scandinavia apologise for the viking invasion ? Should the Spanish apologies for their wars ? HISTORY
Whataboutery.
No that would be silly. None of the Italians today are guilty of anything.
Stop asking stupid questions Robo. None of those things attack or humiliate the English people so the answer is of course..NO.
@@martynblackburn9632Surely the core argument is itself whataboutism.
'What about the empire'....
@@87stevanwhy is it a stupid question , do only certain countries deserve consideration in your world
The Crown is above politics. King Charles lll should not be apologizing for anything Britain, its Empire or what his predecessors did.
Has the Japanese imperial empire ever apologized for slaughtering millions in Burma the Philippines and Korea, and what the Japanese did in Nanjing China in 1938 was so horrific it's even been called the forgotten holocaust 🙄
And Thais.
@@tooyoungtobeold8756 And on the borders and just inside of India....
The Japanese apologised for Pearl Harbour...I saw the video. Who apologised for Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
Maybe I missed it.
@@shareluv7 Throughout the years you'll sometimes see an American president lay a wreath in Hiroshima on the anniversary of the A bomb attack but you'll never see a Japanese prime minister lay a wreath in Nanjing China were one of the most vile and sadistic crimes against humanity took place 🙄
@@shareluv7 Maybe you missed Obama laying a wreath in Hiroshima in 2016 and saying that the memory of Hiroshima must never fade, tell me when was the last time a Japanese prime minister layed a wreath in Nanjing and said sorry 🤔
Well said Nana and Ben👏👏👏👏
Absolutely not
I am South African and thousands of women and children died during the Anglo Boer War with inhumane atrocities against women and children in the concentration camps. No need to apologise as long as we don't forget the history and never repeat the same mistakes. No apology will bring back the dead but will only keep alive and nurture the hatred between people.
Very true my friend, let's all move forward and strive for a peaceful world
Thank you for posting this. I covered this in history at school. Just as importantly, I have seen some excellent documentaries about the Boer War on TV in recent times. There were some terrible things done to the Boers and it is a shameful part of our history.
I reckon that Britain should be giving a home to Boer descendants if they would like to come here and start a new life. From what I have read, life in South Africa can be pretty rough for the whites who are left. That would be more valuable than any apology.
100% No
No way. All this apologising for events long ago is stupid. Should the romans or the French apologise to UK
Time is relative. There is a war going on right now in the mid east. Should we just forget about it once it's over just because it is history?
Never. The past is the past, move on.
Well said
NO IT'S HISTORY
I am a 74 year old PROUD English woman., we should never apologise FOR something that happened before ANY of us were alive, for things we never did. NO NEVER EVER.🇬🇧
NO!
Have the Barbary pirates apologised?
Nobody should,
No .
The King has NOTHING to apologise for.
Nothing to see here move on?
As a Nigerian who lives in Nigeria I agree with you, a 100%.
Other than his forebears usurping our throne.
@@stephfoxwell4620 Sir, I have encountered you a couple of times before.
Ursurp, how do you mean?
@@DonatusOkechukwuOkoli-zc7nz The precedent line to the English and Scottish thrones was thrown out during the Dutch military coup of 1689.
They took Ireland as well in 1691.
After the forced merger with Scotland in 1707 they brought in a junior European royal line, the Hanoverians in 1714.
There are 48 people in Europe ,all descended from Charles I, with a better claim to our throne than the usurpers.
Charles of Sondersburg-Glucksberg is 49th in line to our throne.
The people of overseas countrys should pay the British Government for educating them.
NEVER
No way should that happen. God Save the King
The prat needs to abdicate, if you need an example of his appalling judgment here's one....
No .. should other countries apologise for their savage behaviour too in conflicts and wars ? Why always just uk ?
NO & NO
No
Absolutely not.
I hope he doesn't start apologising for slavery and all that crap....... Don't apologise for me, I had nothing to do with it.
No !
Sorry leads to cash.🃏🐰🕳️
Big Fat BRITISH NO!!!...We apologise for nothing...
Categorically not. We, as humans, we grow and learn.
Unlike in the Middle East 😊
@djdoolittle1315 haha, topical, real, and hilarious. You mate just gave me a genuine laugh 🤣
No he should not ever say sorry this is getting stupid
No No No.
NO WAY SHOULD HE DO THAT.
No, he should not.
No he should not. Stop all this BS now.
No, because the world is a better place because of Britain and apologise to who and for what.
Never
Never say never again
@@phillipcarter8045 Not in my name
To be fair the Turkish ottoman empire lasted a lot longer and was a lot more brutal than the British empire could ever be or ever hope to be...
Well worth a read:
Who sympathizes with the Palestinians and how? Andrzej Koraszewski
What's that got to do with British actions??
@@serene5986 Is it just white empires you have a problem with but the Japanese imperial empire that slaughtered millions in Burma the Philippines and Korea, and what the Japanese did in Nanjing China in the 1930s was so horrific it's even been called the forgotten holocaust 🙄 but do they get a pass because they weren't white?
@@serene5986 It's call history. Read it.
@@serene5986 To be fair the population of India boomed under British rule, and the British also stopped the barbaric act of Suttee were the Indians would throw the widow of the deceased husband on the bonfire with him...
What are they going to do with an apology from people who weren’t even directly responsible?
Firstly the apologies then the demand for money!
This is what's it is all about!
@@mikelane4896 it has to be money, right? I can’t see any other motive.
@@WotsisFace I think it's all about getting as much as they can from our country, on saying this our governments are fools and will give in, but who is it that pays? You and me !
@@mikelane4896 I know it’s mad. And I don’t think anybody who was even involved in that are still alive, on either side!
Didn't watch the ridiculous video, but the answer to your ridiculous question is "No"
By his argument Portugal, the biggest European slave trader, should be wealthier than Germany and Scandinavia.
NO
NO OUR KING SHOULD NOT APOLOGISE. AND NOT GIVE THEM MONEY 🇬🇧
Not in my name
Iam kenyan and I we don’t want an apology.. we want genuine friendship
We are British. We are polite, but unfriendly.
,unfortunately, the more people try to make us feel guilty for our very existence , the less inclined we are to feel friendly
Genuine friendship doesn’t exist. Only interest.
Great - agree.
Don't apologise for me you fool.
No No No!
Yes...if every other country in the world apologies for their past misdeeds !
Absolutely. But all these countries that want us to apologise to don’t seem to do any wrongs!! Am I missing something?
Of course he shouldn't apologise. England was just doing what every other powerful country did. Even with slavery (and we were the first empire to abolish it, at great cost to ourselves). The North Africans dragged us off as slaves, which is why we had to build up our navy and wrote "Rule, Britannia".
nope, you get conquer or become conqueror that what world work at least at that time
Nope. 😊
Absolutely not. By that logic, Italy and France should apologise for conquering and ruling Britain.
No way José
Treason
For what reason
No apology is required
If he apologies he should be removed as a coward
Hi. No, it in the past move on.
Nana is accurately correct regarding history .... slavery existed thousands of years ago ....
Again correct the "Industrial Revolution" actually gave us the wealth of prosperity ...
Not thousands of years, slavery was only stopped in 1807
@@IBTU When Britain advocated for slavery to be abolished and it was, White people are not responsible for slavery it was Black people who enslaved their own people and are trying to push their guilt onto White's! We Owe them Nothing!
@@IBTUYes, yes it has existed for thousands of years.
@@IBTU So slavery did not exist during the life and times of Jesus Christ ????? I think yes ..... and long before then as well ... my old friend
The British gave the the English language to the world. Surely a major gift to humankind?
STOP. BEING. WEAK.
Oh My God not again!!! 🙈🙄
If Britain had not stepped in at great loss of life by our soldiers Kenya would be about as done as South Africa is today. Our former colonies have done very well for themselves good for them but look at the rest of Africa constant wars and no respect for anyone. Would Kenya like to be without Electricity 24 hours a day. OUR KING HAS NOTHING TO APOLOGIZE FOR TO ANYONE.
The king who wants all his people dead
No way
No 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Roadhouse
King Charles doesn’t need to apologise
Absolutely not! Once you open that can, then a whole heap of other apologies and remedy payments would follow.
A lot depends on the desire of any given moment.
Perhaps the French should apologise for invading this land, starving those that resisted by burning their fields, and carving up the country for their cronies.
Im am so sick and tired of all of this! I just want to leave Britain. It is such a miserable place now.
Why has he prorogued Parliament?
Historical illiteracy sure causes problems for us today.
It is about time that these individuals join the modern society and realise that history belongs in the past... The future is the way forward and she should stop stirring the effluent. ..for the want of a more appropriate word... She appears to be making a good living on this drivel..
King Charles should instead apologize for his own behavior and that of his brother and other members of his family!
I suppose King Charles considers previous Monarchs of the United Kingdom and England to be part of his family ancestry.
The only people who have a right to apologise are those responsible. The idea that someone generations removed has the right or ability to apologise for actions committed long before their birth is close to hubris. In any case it is impossible to apologise to people long dead... because they are not alive to hear anything. This strange quadrille of one bunch of people claiming they they have the right to demand another bunch crawl to them as, perhaps, they imagine their long dead relatives once were forced to genuflect is surreal. What's done is done. What needs to be done is the issue. Harking on about history takes focus away from sorting out the future. There is something elementally negative and self-defeating in this perverse exchange of hopeless negativity.
No way 😮
Love listening to Nana in a good argument, she really keeps her wits about her. She should be on GB News much more!
Sort this country out Charles
Are you having a laugh??.. Charles is even more weak and anti English than his mother.
Not on behalf of the british people. It's on Charles head.
No no no no no
Its been dealt with in a court of law, and a pay-out was made.
Move On!
Should Nana apologise for her pimlico plumber stance on the V 💉
NANA 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
NEVER apologize for actions not your own.
Utterly ludicrous.
No fucking way
NO, King Charles, nor any Caucasian person alive today, DOES NOT and SHOULD NOT apologize for sins committed by predecessors. They are not responsible for anything so they do not owe anyone anything.
Sins ?
What sins?
@@stephfoxwell4620Exactly.
The OP doesn't get the point at all.
Maybe he should apologize to the British working classes.
Excellent commentary. Nana really shown like the sun on this. We need to never forget the sins of our past to not repeat them. And we need to correct and cease our current wrongs.
What sins?
@@tastypymp1287. Secret ones
Things were done in the past which should not have, on the other side of the coin African and other people have been exposed to technology which has enriched their lives. Will the Italians apologise for the Roman empire? Russia for the Stalinist system and the cold war? the list is endless.
No, but he will.
Is this woman for real!!
Zhe should apologise to Britain for creating this life threatening situation traitor
I’m sorry I’m sorry I’m sorry I’m sorry I’m sorry I’m sorry 😅