Einstein's theory breaks down in 02 places ..!! watch this
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ม.ค. 2023
- In this video the professor #neildegrassetyson at the podcast of #joerogan explains where the theory of Albert Einstein's (General Relativity) breaks down. It becomes invalid in the #blackhole and the #bigbang. Watch the video for the full details.
Neil deGrasse Tyson is an #american #astrophysicist , #author, and #science #communicator. Tyson studied at #harvarduniversity , the University of #texas at #austin , and #columbiauniversity . From 1991 to 1994, he was a #postdoctoral #research associate at #princetonuniversity .
#alberteinstein was a German born #theoretical #physicist, widely acknowledged to be one of the #greatest and most #influential #physicists of all time. #einstein is best known for #developing the theory of #relativity, but he also made important contributions to the development of the #theory of #quantum #mechanics ....
#shorts #short #brain #science #sciencefacts #scienceexperiment #scientist #medicine #health #healthy #healthylifestyle #mentality #mental #scientific #medical #culture #education #astrology #astronomy #technology #explore #biology #chemistry #biochemistry #sourse #universe #consciousness #entertainment #physics #uk #england #usa #us #canada #germany #hongkong #unitedstates #unitedkingdom #australia #switzerland #newzealand #norway #singapore #austria #denmark #sweden #ireland #netherlands #france #spain #belgium #finland #italy #japan #southkorea #unitedarabemirates #dubai #portugal #southafrica #greece #czech #czechia - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[#SHORTS CLIP] ครูอึ้ง กรรมการอึ้ง ฮ่าๆ l ซานิเบาได้เบา l One Playground](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qeBTuMJs4t0/mqdefault.jpg)
“ Once we accept our limits, we go beyond them.” - Albert Einstein.
r/whooooooosh
@@Qbop okay but who acted oblivious to what they said though 😭
What limit ?
He gave us a gift, we need to add to it. Maybe the next Einstein is born already
And he lived by those words, Einstein wasn't satisfied with his general theory of reletivity himself. He was working on improving it up until his deathbed eventually he ran out of time and had to put his pencil down.
For context: Joe asked what song Neil listens to while working out.
Hahaha
Why isn't this blowing up 🤣
@@arghachowdhury cause it isn’t funny
Awe yes, make a Brotha out to be a clown when he shows he's WAY more intelligent than you.
😂
“Ok, your total comes to $12.54… Debit or credit?”
Crebit
@@your_dad_18 carsh
@@v1per-x499I pay using sea shells.
Gun
@@v1per-x499Derbit
"Bears probably hibernate in black holes" - Joe Rogan
Jamie pull that video of a bear hibernating in a black hole.
Y’all stop 😂😂😂
😂😂
Our world is a simulation God isn't real so people say God created all universe and time but God's not real so this is a simulation of sleeping but us seeing what would of happened if this all real time
Joe's rightly afraid of Big angry bears. He's not afraid of anything. So where the hell else would they come from? Gotta be black holes.
This is actually one of the more interesting things Neil has said. So many people think that the center of a black hole is infinitely dense/small, and they think that the universe was the same when it was a singularity. We just dont know, is the real answer.
No, the real answer is: We don't know ... yet 😉
Exactly. Better to be humble and just say I don't know.
@@DarkoStantic
Yes. It seems an impossible situation to answer.
We dont even know what causes gravity. People give way to much credit to intellectuals
@@travislovelace7619 Gravity is just mass bending space.
And he did it all without computers, calculators, or AI
Tensor geometry doesn't need computers, or AI. Also, you don't need calculators for math. Not at all. Whatever the calculator does, you can do, just slower.
@@shifatmat so you're just agreeing then
That’s not as impressive as you think it is
@@shifatmat you had to say something, don't you?
@@shifatmat 🤓
I came here for comments about NDT's talkativeness and you guys never disappoint 😂😂
Bruh same 😂
Wish my parents could say the same😔
He is a liar and or a moron
It's kinda boring now.
It's never been funny once
mans starting beef with einstein 💀
Easy to say when he have all the information and tech to do that. Einstein did it like a real man and could beat this kiddo up
All scientists say this
Well, if we are at Wendy's "Where's the Beef? LOL yep that's Tyson poking Einstein.
@@fabianaguilar1358What? Einstein literally said all of this. Its not a competition.
Imagine Neil meeting Einstein and trying to lecture him
Tesla would be way better.
He wouldn't dare do that, look up him interviewing Stephen Hawkins, he was like a fanboy just excited to be there, lol
Neil is closer to Einstein than you are to Neil. And that’s an undeniable fact. So I’m sure they would have a good conversation
@HoustonSwisha It's the opposite, Neil is closer to us than to Einstein. :)))
Wouldn't go well... He was notorious for his ability to just avoid people in general
Cashier: “Again, will you be using debit or credit”
Lmao
Ok I get this is a joke but card readers don't care which it is, it just scans and charges you
😂😂😂😂
Sir, this is a Wendy's.
I was waiting for someone to comment this lol
unoriginal, find a new joke
@@slavemasta Sir, this is a Wendy's.
Fool
@@jonm5246 even less funny the second time
This music plays constantly whenever neil degrasse tyson speaks, even when he orders a 10 piece chicken mcnugget meal from McDonald's.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 lmfaooo
😂😂😂😂
Lol😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂
Maybe he has infinite McNuggets, and his black hole is where it all breaks down. 😂😂😂
Jamie: "Alright man, you finished ? The podcast ended 4 hours ago I wanna go home ".
😂😂
😂
You’ve noticed that Joe wasn’t shown once in this video? That’s bc Joe had already went home, the podcast ended hours ago they just couldn’t get him to shut up and leave so everyone else just got up and left, and let the video record while Neil just sat there and kept going, he didn’t even notice everyone was gone he was just lost in his own words
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
XDDDD
This is after Joe just asked how is his dog doing.
Buzz off tool.
😂😂😂😂
“Sir… did you want fries with that?”
Supersize him.
I could stare at that graph for hours. It is beyond beauty, it makes me want to stand up, quit what I'm doing and go study physics immediately..
Imagine what that genius would come up with if he had the knowledge that we have today
Who knows, maybe he would be a content creator.
We wouldn't have the knowledge today without him. His role during his time was essential to get us as humans here
We have too many distractions these days, people had alot of time to focus back then and it was driven by passion,now everything revolves around money.
He created the knowledge we have today hahaha we’re working from his equations 😂😂😂
He would be to distracted by his smart phone playing on social media and making TikTok videos
'Don't quote me." -- Albert Einstein
Says the guy who literally just quoted Albert Einstein..
@@spankedbacon6396 Bahahaha 🤣🤣🤣🤣🎯 excellent reply bro
“Hoes will be hoes” - Albert Einstein
@@spankedbacon6396 its as if he was making a joke or something
When you have to explain the joke, it's ruined... 💩 🤐
You just have to sit down and listen to whatever the person on the video is saying (from literally any video on the internet) when this background music comes up. :))
Lmfaoooo
The singularity exists in the equations, we actually don’t know what happens at the center of the black hole because we can never see past it’s horizon. - that’s why singularity’s are theoretical.
Imagine how wild it would be if Einstien could be on JRE.
German accent:
...but enough vith ze physics. Let's talk chemistry, ya? So, Joe tell me about zis DMT thing?
"Wer bist du und warum rauchst du so einen fetten Blunt?"
@@no.7893wahrscheinlich würde er "fetten Blunt" sagen 😂
Einstein wasn't the chatty type of person if i recall correctly. There is a recording of him giving a lecture to the most important politicians in the world and he seemed a littl3 annoyed that he has to do 101 lectures isntead of an actual work. It would probably went like this: what is your theory about? I don't have time dude, just read about it and leave me alone"
@@liskowalski771 All the more reason that he should enjoy some bluntsmoken with Joe
Love being fascinated by things I don't understand 💪🏽
Neil is also fascinated while he's talking about these things. Because he's knowledge is on the same line as yours. 😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Well it's a simple thing. Acc to Einstein's general relativity theory, the mass of the center of a black hole would be infinite.
That's problematic
“You get black holes from Einstein”💀
Einstein's theory predicted black holes. His theory does not work in the centre of the black hole. There is always going to be limits to our knowledge.
He loves answering questions that nobody asked! 😂
😂😂😂😂
Joe asked him he's favourite song and after a 20min rant this is his answer
what a man
He is just anticipating, mind reading.
The world would've been worse off for not having asked those questions.
The universe is not obliged to make sense to us, it just is, whether we’ll ever understand it or not.
No, the universe needs to make sense or else I’m going to beat it up
I mean, in the grand scheme of things, we're just another blip on the radar
We can barely grasp the size of stars and galaxies, distances and speed of universal expansion. That's enough for me
Ok joe dirt.
If the universe doesn't oblige Imma bitch slap it
The Theory of relativity is like the middle of understanding it explains the here and now cause and effect brilliantly but can not tell you the start or the end.
What if the start and the end are the same thing.. what if a black hole is the catalyst for universe creation in another dimension..
Eternal?
That's what Neil is saying. 1
@@jakecharlie9574 The universe that black holes create would be smaller or thinner than the one they occupy.
We exist in a diluted version of our source.
The waitress: Sooo....no sugar in your coffee then.
Me nodding along saying “yup” while not knowing wtf he’s taking about
Joe: "So what you're saying is, you can't divide an Elk by 0?"
Exactly
The hell i cant
Technically you can divide by 0 the problem is the result can be anything. Literally anything. Mathematically, any fucking thing.
*Bear noises intensify*
@@K0wp3R ya infinity ♾️
"Soooo....do you wanna do DMT or not?! It's been 3 days...."
-actual JRE interview question to NGT
You know his only regret was creating E=mc2 (I was to lazy to go thru my key board to find the squared button)
the only 2 singular points in the universe that can't be calculated.. because that's where reality breaks. they are the same point. one becomes the other. one reality collapses to birth another. infinite loop.
Could be correct....yet unprovablele
But what started the loop?
Black holes are god pressing the delete key.
😂
more like copy paste
Or the compile button
I like that analogy. Lol
no. black holes are not holes. they’re celestial bodies just like the earth or the sun. just a lot smaller and denser. still spherical from what i’ve understood. there’s no deletion of matter
I truly wish Einstein were alive to chat with Mr Degrasse lol.
Wouldn't get a word in
@@nigelnyoni8265 who
@@jamestoney24Einstein obviously. NDT doesn't shut up because he's a massive narcissist who loves the sound of his own voice.
@@oskahuxley6322 i agree
@@nigelnyoni8265 hahahaha why don't you have million likes 😅😅😅
Actually, the singularity in the theory of relativity refers to a point in space and time where the laws of physics as we understand them break down. It's not that we are dividing by zero or that the theory becomes meaningless, but rather that our current understanding of physics cannot explain what is happening at that point.
I can answer that question for you. Time stops in a black hole because motion stops. Shit is so dense atoms don't spin
@@kingtutsirai994some black holes have spin.
Neil's shower thoughts have got to be fkn wild lol
For anyone that doesn’t know, dividing by zero is “undefined”
The calculator can't handle that. But if you approach 0 the number goes actually to infinity
But the limit is still undefined because if you approach zero from the negative side, it approaches negative infinity...so if you say 1/0 = infinity you risk being off by twice the magnitude of the "infinity" referenced
Why not infinity?
@@zulkifliali8832 it's both positive and negative infinity, hence undefined
The moment your algebra teacher slaps you upside the head for forgetting to account for a discontinuity.
“Sir, this is a bagel shop”
Whoa........so original
@@logicman4837 I know right?
@@TheHamsterMaster have u ever told a joke that's not yours, brah?
@@andrianerhan9471 hell yeah
🤣🤣🤣
This is Neil's idea of pillow talk
Which is where we find wormholes
I find the Black Hole Big Bang Theory very interesting. We may never find out some things about our Universe, but in the meanwhile we have intriguing mysteries to solve.
The big bang has been disproven by the images of the James Webb Space Telescope.
@@aeronblitz9347 that thing is bad ass. But I don’t believe it’s disproved big bang…yet 🤔🤷♂️ pls elaborate…
@@aeronblitz9347 How so?
@@geewhiz317 Well according to the big bang, the further you look back in time, the farther back in time you see which means the less developed the far galaxies must look as their light hasnt reached us when they were formed. But the images show the exact same level of complexity all across the universe despite how far we look, which means that the big bang is false
@@justiniswebb9 Well according to the big bang, the further you look back in time, the farther back in time you see which means the less developed the far galaxies must look as their light hasnt reached us when they were formed. But the images show the exact same level of complexity all across the universe despite how far we look, which means that the big bang is false
Trying to even comprehend infinity is ridiculously infinite
they called einsteins e=mc2 bullshit but found out later on he was right he was a man way ahead of his time
I think they also called his theory of General Relativity was BS since he said gravity could bend space-time. Einstein don't f*ck with this guy........Tyson's trying. LOL
"Uhh sir this is a wendys"
The funny thing about science and the nature of our universe is the more questions we get answered the more we have to ask
It just becomes an infinite regression
The more you know, the more you know that there's more to know. Kinda thing.
But new set of questions were already there. It's just that we could not frame it. Ex: Newton Vs Lebniz idea of space is still being wandered same way but we now include ideas of relativity + quantum + some string theory. What do you think?
@@terran236 But you die at the end of the day…They can’t cure cancer or aids u don’t expect them solve anything because truth be told everything is solved it’s just that we are too dumb to understand it and never will.
Oh absolutely. I mean, even if we could come up with a Unified Theory of Everything and explain every physical question, then we run into the question of, "why is it that?"
If it worked everywhere, it would be Einstein’s Law of Relativity.
No, a law is just the depiction of a relationship between two or more variables, very often represented as mathematical equations. A law is not better, more general or more precise than a theory, in fact, there could be several laws being part of a theory. A scientific theory Is a thorough explanation of a phenomenon, and it goes way beyond a simple law.
There are no laws. They call it Newton's law of gravitation but it's still not the correct theory of gravitation
Yeah… laws are patterns we can prove. Theories are more following the known to start poking at the unknown.
Blackhole is simple a swirl in the water. I invite you to see a swirl in a swiming pool. It has shadow, the light doesnt get to botom of the pool. Its just that, and scientist ar fliping imaginong so much stuff, like why the light disapear in that place with no mass 🤦
@@gonzalogomez8508 in what place with no mass? You do now that water is mass, right? And that light behaves in a different way in a void than it does when going through air or water? You need to do more research, shadows are literally matter getting in the way of light, water is matter, so what's wrong with shadows on water?
Sir, this is Starbucks.
Would you like to order?
"Sir, can I see your resume now?"
Neil is the Steven Segal of science 😂
Joe: so did you learn all this while on mushrooms or was it Acid.
Neil: yes
Young Einstein looks like Shia Lebouf
Whenever I see one of these clips I always imagine NDT saying it to his mrs while she's trying to get to sleep next to him lol
Key and Peele 🤣🤣🤣
That’s funny imma gonna steal your joke
The fact that we will never know what created the universe is really mind boggling 🤯
@Confessions Of A Movie Freak that requires you to have faith in a religion we're talking things that can be proven
@Confessions Of A Movie Freak something had to create that too
@Confessions Of A Movie Freak we can go back and forth all day. Just know everything has a creator, creator, creator, creator, creator, etc
Allah who ?
@@legnuminamerica that is for the creations, not The Creator, it is just our human/mortal brain that can't handle such an idea, so we can't accept it.
I always loved space and such, and I am lucky to believe in a faith that explains it.
I recommend you to read about its science, not for religion's sake or asking you to become religious since tbh neither am I, but just to wonder how did "they" know such things 1400+ years ago?.
even if someone would say "it is
not true" for the sake of not accepting religion. at least for me, I would rather be knowing this truth than die ignorant, because I know we are going nowhere with this science in my lifetime sadly.
The cashier who told niel his debit card declined: 😐
When the next Einstein comes along, then we'll get some more answers. Until then, we'll just have to wait.
Wow - the background music is so creative and original.
What song is it?
Plzz tell me
@@IshRohit it’s called Paris - Else
"once you go black, you'll never go back" - Albert Einstein
a man of true culture.
Why do you need to go back? - Albert Einstein
Once you go white you know you went right, Once you go black we don't want you back!!! See dumbasses we can ryme too.
A quote said by black people and no one else.
@@BETA00009 and ghetto crackheads
Just put the fries in the bag cuh
The one limit is the center of a tootsie-pop
Siri taught me as a kid that you can't divide by 0
Edit: Holy shit thanks for likes and the math war in the comments. Lastly, before more people acuse me of being a kid, I'm 19 years old. I can literally legally drink alcohol now.
Exactly, Infinity. Cell division..
that’s a limit my boy
@@chhefs310 Bro there is bigger infinities then other infinities. The limit is being able to travel the whole universe from one spot. #Ophanim
The fact is, most cant comprehend that equation. Maybe they dont want you to know. How will they know. They will never know.
Infinity as a number is 1/0 so the only way to mathematically make it make sense is to divide by 0
Neil just whips out that "divide by zero"
It's sort of accurate tho, division by 0 gets anything as a result. That's why it's undefined, it's because we have no clue what the outcome is. In that way, a division by 0 at the singlularity means anything can happend. The math holds up (if 0*a =0*b then a can be anything and b can be any other thing. Divide by 0 and you get a =b which is the actual problem and why we can't divide by 0, cause a and b can be any thing you can possibly think of)
Sir, this is a mcdonalds
I’m watching family feud and I see him
I think the reason for this is that, under Einstein’s theory of gravity, only an infinitely small point (volume = 0) could reverse the flow of something which has a mass of 0 (light).
Einstein did not have a theory of gravity. General Relativity _describes_ gravity as the curvature of spacetime caused by the presence of mass and energy. This curvature influences the motion of objects in the vicinity of massive objects, giving _rise to the familiar effects of gravity_
I know the answers to both questions. But I promised my talking fish I would never tell! 😂
Please tell us Sir. The world needs you 😋😀😂
Spill 😂
The why files vibes.
Does make a diference?
Is it a hard to keep the secret?
Is it worth it?
Are you happy?
Someone has "WHY" vibes?
Now we need to figure out how our current understanding of math is incorrect.
Einstein looks like Pablo Escobar'S father.
Maths class punishments - Divide by Zero .
Math is not a plural.
I’m kinda drunk rn but like… what if those two places are the same thing
All matter is a black hole
Woooww!!
I'm stoned and I abide
@hdgw629dha24hs what do you do to escape yours
@hdgw629dha24hs some people use alcohol, others drugs, others fried or sugary foods, videogames, jesus, etc..
**plot twist there were multiple big bangs
If Albert einstein had computers, calculators, or the cheat codes we had today. We would’ve been traveling through space already. 😂
I feel like Dr Tyson gets a kick out of saying " it has limits"
He hates Einstein...
@@CashCowz962 it's not hate dear, rather the key to scientific advancement. His curiosity and constructive criticism will lead to some new developments. Same as Einstein denied Newtonian theories and see what he came up with.
Not hate , but he jelous
@@Y.R.U.gahhhh blks hate whites in Amerixa now and want to destroy everything whites have created...the question is..will they turn America into Haiti and Africa?...
@@smarteye4249 what theories has he invented ever? Most of what he talk about have been found to be wrong anyway...
This topic is best discussed after a few grams of shrooms.
Or kilograms even.
But if you want to soar across the cosmos… Gigatons
Only problem is, in no time you‘ll find yourselves digressing and talking about bears instead.
He had me at big bang theory 😂
I’m dumb so I pretend everyone else is too.
Edward Witten enters the room.
Overrated af
Who is that? Or what's the reference?
@@recipoldinasty I suspect the same
Einstein took us so far. Fields Medal recipient Eric Witten, advances the narrative with String Theory.
With his string theory? Which turned out to be futile
100 years later and still nobody is any wiser
It really isn't a sprint, we will likely never know.
It’s the one of the big issues with Einsteins theory. It’s worked so well in our applications we stopped advancing. But even Einstein knew the theory wasn’t done. He was still searching for the unifying field theory when he died.
No…the concept of the Singularity does not invalidate the theory of relativity because the Singularity concept as it is currently framed is not supported by evidence.
"Why you salty, bro?" - Albert Einstein, probably
Doesn't matter much to me because I'm just passing through this moment in time 🤣
But when you die you’ll be right back as something or someone new
@@g0atcrypto no he'll be dead buried inside the ground
@@_agent47_ his body will be but not the energy his body holds
@@g0atcrypto bro once a person dies, all their cells start to die too, and after a while, they just turn into mush.
Btw, your "self" is an illusion created by your brain, so when you die, that "self" ceases to exist as well
@@_agent47_ at the moment of death a few grams is lost. His memories won’t come with him (they’re stored in Akashi records tho) but his spirit definitely leaves his body. Same thing happens when you astral travel
human brain has limits in this 4D world
I agree
3D*
@@gvardiecky9507 4d
@@j.c.2514 explain pls
@@exp0w_fpv I may be wrong. we are 3D?
Every scientist with a great passion for sharing their knowledge deserves my total admiration and respect.
Remember that Brooklyn 99 episode where Neil squats more than Terry 😂😂
😂
The number pie is seemingly infinite and is used to calculate a circle feels connected to the center of black holes being infinite as well
center of black hole is not infinite. why did you make that up?
Only assuming that a singularity is spherical
"infinite is the limit"
Oh, I see
Planet - Black hole to black hole journey 😂
Mankind will always have limits . No matter how brilliant the mind is.
"Only Fuachi's science has no limits."
: Neil Degrasshole ..
What?
😂
I feel like it's almost impossible to study something so far away, and actually be able to get every detail correct lol
What if we can simulate a black hole on a quantum computer
@@stefonny you'd have to understand how it works first, but maybe through lots of trial, but I'm not genius lol
"Jamie... pull up that video of a black hole wrestling a polar bear"
Like Einstein had the tech we have to test his theories 😂
Blackhole defies every law of physics.
it’s an unknown.
That's because we don't know everything about how matter and its complexities really work
Well, in and of itself it doesn't, what goes on inside of it does.
Einstein worked with what was known to him. The application of principles works within the given parameters. When you encounter different parameters the rules of the game change.
Get rid of the obnoxious music. AT LEAST turn it down.
That's why we need a theory of quantum gravity to explain how gravity works at a quantum level which can happen in certain very extreme conditions , as said in the video the singularity point of a black hole or the very beginning of the Universe the very first moments of the Big Bang and after the Big Bang there quantum fluctuations and dark matter played a big role into spreading the matter throughout space and solving the uniformities of the Universe thus allowing for the creation of galaxies and the space we know today ! And that's why the most promising theory is the String Theory
Neil: “huh? We’re dividing by zero at the singularity?”
Black Hole: “Satisfied with nothing; you don’t know the half of it.”
Actually saying we're divided by 0 is the best way to describe what happends. A division by 0 is "undefined" because we have no fucking clue what the outcome of a division by 0 is. It can be anything, mathematically. Think a/b =c as a =bc. If b is 0, then a is 0 and c is anything (cause whatever x 0 is 0) or it's absurd.
@@K0wp3R how about 0.0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001,
divide by that. not even your calculater can display 1 divided by that
@@jodainlafeuillee9103 sure. That just gets you "a lot". Anything but 0 is properly defined. Divide a by something close to zero but positive, assuming a is positive, it tends towards infinity which is just a lot. Divide by smth close to 0 but negative, that's negative infinity. So a lot but negative. Divide by 0 and we have no fucking clue what happends. It's simple math.
@@K0wp3R I believe zero can be represented as a variable and starting point. To be able to solve this problem we must first redefine what a zero is.
@@jodainlafeuillee9103 0 is the neutral element of addition, the only element so that a-a =0, and so that 0*a=0. That's the definition of 0, it's not changing any time soon
Thats because as soon as you hit singularity, you explode out the other side into the birth of a new universe. 0 is just the completion/beginning of the loop.
That's only a theory for anyone wondering, don't pass that on as a fact please
Nice one, even as a therory!
@@istvanbocsor7911 very true!
@@patrickfarrell979 But, mathematically speaking, it makes sense.
White hole 🤔
Joe asked if he wanted something to drink before getting interrupted:
Pov: you asked Neil where the bathroom is
I thought he was going to say, "despite Einstein's brilliance, I am smarter."
lol
He did not say that wtf 😭😭😭 you people have problems, what he said is the common synopsis of Einstein’s work, and how is he saying he’s smarter when he literally say no one knows the answer to it which is why there’s limitations ? Where’s this random Neil degrasse hate coming from?