H1B to Green Card Tragedy | And The BEST Solution is...
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ธ.ค. 2021
- Previous video Exposing H1B Misuse in America | Who’s Responsible For This Mess? • Exposing H1B Misuse in...
/ desiamericanprofessor
📈 Get 2 FREE Stocks in US (valued up to $1400): www.webull.com/activity?invit...
I use WeBull & Fidelity for stock trading
#uscis #greencardbacklog #h1bdelay
This would be a terrible model for employees and employers.
1. There are more startups that need H1B talent than 6-7 MAANG level companies. They cannot even afford 10k for H1B lite. Current expenses are in the range of 6-7K
2. H1B lite basically states that a BTech engineer from IIT is less important/valuable than MS from USA. I have done MS from USA and I can tell you that it is not the case.
3. An employer who wants to hire mechanical BTech from IIT probably won't hire because they cannot afford 50K for H1B pro. It would be a lose lose case.
This model will in fact deny chances for employers and employees to succeed.
Dr is mandated to sell USA MS and PHD programs for Indian students ...the new money making machine for all outdated USA Universities .....Follow Elon Musk he tells degree is a waste and he don't care to hire
I married my long time gf and getting green card. happy not be in the h1b rat race lol
Well played
It’s crazy to introduce levels to a temporary visa category such as H1B. Instead eliminate H1B and mandate green card as the only means to work more than 180 days. So, only those who qualify for their green cards from their country of origin can move to US to work more than 180 days. You can have all of the criteria described in the video applied for their green card applications. This then works best for both job seekers in US and international job seekers!
That's a good idea cause otherwise some companies can exploit their h1b visa workers since they know the employee can't quit since they don't have their greencard promised.
Prof thanks for your time and effort, much appreciated. The tiers you proposed for H1b isn’t that essentially what the EB categories (1,2,3) entail as of today.
Life in European Union is much better and balanced than in US, provided you put effort in learning languages
Hi
Really?
@@rdse2552 absolutely not lol
They are more difficult
This is a great video, unfortunately no such reforms are going to happen in US anytime soon.
Hi Sir, can you make a statistical analysis of how all of these reforms would actually affect the green card wait lines and also, dont they consider diversity as a factor when giving out h1bs. Maybe green card wait lines is just an issue for few countries. They also have investment visa for the people who can afford right? So how does the h1b pro makes sense?
Brilliant suggestions 👌
We can keep proposing such solutions. Nothing will change.
Appreciate you taking the time to think through this, but unfortunately what’s the use. They don’t seem to move to at least a merit based system in the first place . Every year ideas and bills get proposed , nothing happens ultimately
the reason is that those who need reforms are not citizens and do not vote
True that, professor.
That is unfortunately the price we have to pay to be an immigrant
@@DesiAmericanProfessor but every year thousands of Indian become citizens after a long wait. Dont they count to politicians or indians forget about the cause after citizenship
@@DesiAmericanProfessor there is a huge indian lobby that is needed during elections for which the administrators are ready to dance in their wedding as well . These guys are supposed to negotiate . Bunch of nitwits have taken citizenship but are sitting uselessly and watching the tamasha !!
My Opinion is why such a competition just because we are Indian born , is someone born in UK can decide to move to US (because he has a Job there) and get his green card in 1 year , what makes Indian born applicant different , why should they require advance phd degrees to get to the same situation as other people
I really liked the initial proposal of Trump of wage based green card/H1B , sort applications based on wage that companies are willing to pay them and invite them (end of story) . US directly gets benefited from the taxes they would collect and since the salaries are sorted you can pretty much be sure that no company is trying to bring in cheap labour
Very true. Why do we need to qualify all these stringent criterias only for us to wait in line for 10-12 years for a greencard when other countries like Australia or uk and even other less developed countries than india like bangladesh,nepal bhutan get easier access to gc. It's extremely discriminatory and almost racist. It's almost a human rights violation since they have made no reform in h1b visas so that companies can prey and international lawyers and uscis can financially profit from indian visa holders.
Because - Best solution - stop and cancel ALL H1B applications and holders from body shop companies such as Wipro, Infosys, Cognizant etc.
That’s where the backlog and fake numbers come from
Even for wage based Indian Consulting companies have shown inflated salaries during the visa application.
Appreciate the ideas but 75k for H1B pro is easy in this day and age. Consulting companies in east and west coast charge clients 180k to 200k for each H1B. They pay candidate 60k to 100k i.e. taking a commission of 50%+. Companies can easily pay this fees from the employee's future earnings.
What is new on the table Sir? This is same typical Eb1/2/3 with another worst versions.
May be another solution is to open up workforce trety with all highly-inter-dependent countries for easy flexible movement of skilled human capitals. Like USA-canada already have.
As post pandemic, tables are now started turning and USA is getting most beneficiary. As, the nomad, WFH and remote work culture are getting stronger and stronger, corporations trending to most optimised cost effective solutions.
Instead of solving for a problem and making it more streamlined you are adding more complexities.. Its a capitalist economy so every equation has a dollar impact but what about more knowledgeable and experienced candidates.. most companies this days really don't care about degree instead only about telent ..
In ur last video you mentioned that Desi consultancy charge for h1b fee, now let's say they can charge 50k to employees for processing the h1b pro category 😀....
It also don't solve spouse issue of h1b !!!
I agree. The lottery system is total injustice. It's more on luck than talent. In my company SE, TL, STL working on medicaid system applied for H1B 4 year's back and SE got picked up and TL and STL are still waiting. This is one of the scenarios.
I am not totally sure if a price increase alone would cut it. The problem here are the individuals who are willing to 'pay' to get their H-1B visas, knowing full well it's illegal. What's stopping these desi consultancies to give options to these same individuals to pay $50k so that they can secure this top-tier H-1B.
Unpopular opinion, there doesn't need to be any change to the H-1B, but EB GC laws. For starters, consultancies that deploy people on 3rd party sites should be barred from applying for EB GCs. This will automatically restrict them from being able to extend visas beyond the 6-year mark. For individuals, a clear path to GC would be to get an FTE or go back in 6 years. Everybody wins.
Family based spillover to employment based has happed which helps to reduce the backlog.
Hi sir, is there any visa for which I can stay for long time in the usa for business ? I am from India
Ok opinion.. im dating an American, I'm Australian, not full time working (yet) but employed. Bachelor of business in hotel and resort management. Which visa should I look into in your opinion.. there are SOOOOO many.. hard to get work sponsorship too 😞
Bro u can get good job in Australia, then why did u come to USA in the first place?
Sir could you tell us about the job opportunities and scope of a Certified Management Account (CMA USA) in America?
A hypothetical idea for law makers published to get hundreds and thousands of 10+ minutes from general viewers who actually have nothing to do with it!
everything begins from an idea
@@DesiAmericanProfessor
Keeping that universal truth aside, being a great fan of your presentation, I am suggesting to avoid publishing such ideas from this channel where overseas general viewers come to get practical solutions.
This video is for U.S. Law makers and congressmen, it's not really meant for an average applicant.
obviously, the situation is so bad that people stuck in backlog cannot do anything
@@DesiAmericanProfessor they always return back home , India is as good as US now with all Tech available and better in work life balance and can live like they Own
REMEMBER :
The he who(company or individual or say a country in itself) creates jobs will always be on the upper hand of everything as against those who for really work their asses off for the employers.
Don't ask me what's wrong or right with that, but that is how the DAMN WORLD WORKS!!
true right?
@@DesiAmericanProfessor Dear Professor Chaitanya is green card guaranteed if one is able to do his phd from a top US university.
Nope bro ,though u might get a easy way of eb1@@siddiqueansari1675
Is this solution going to be a money spinner for gov?? Or are we saying lets go ahead n do phd’s instead masters or bachelors ? Country needs who work n deliver not only Who does R&Ds. E1-5 have its own education needs.. not sure just adding money to it will solve. Also a cook needed, a home keeper and agricultural worker.. all of them have lives n GC wishes..
Point based system in other countries like Canada is permanent residency and not temporary non-immigrant visas. That's why perhaps they have a more wholistic "assimilation" oriented approach (where did you get experience, for example) and do not care to get into the weeds of what papers you wrote. Comparing H1B system w/ a point based system is apples & oranges. US should still have a point based system for permanent residency.
I would prefer Canada 🇨🇦 instead fighting for a PR card.
can youtube be monetized on h1b or f1. I believe not but then there are many such you tubers doing so.
not on h1b, I think on f1 is ok. I am not sure what such people do, but I think they probably monetize their channels in their home country and not in the US.
I was lucky not to have paid these huge fees for my GC.
Argument is that this structure only helps rich companies and not startups.
Certain future , no green card ! Wow brilliant !
Wow does your future rely on getting a green card when you’ve accepted a temporary job/contract?
6 years is plenty of time to get an American citizen in and trained to no longer need a temporary person! Read the word again …. TEMPORARY!!! Contract work is not forever!!
Now uk also use point base system
Nice!!! Present this to the Congress, no use otherwise.
I highly appreciate your videos and information ,messages conveyed by them.
Loads of love and support from Chandigarh ✌✌🙏🏻🙏🏻💐💐
yes he is amazing he wont lie to the people he is for reality
This is an advice to policy makers not us. Tell us what we can do to get a GC fast.
HELLO SIR ,
MY BROTHER QUALIFIED GRE TODAY WITH GOOD SCORE .HE IS APPLIED FOR UNIVERSITY BELONGS TO TEXCESS CAN YOU HELP US REGARDING THE FURTHER PROCESS.KINDLY REPLAY US SIR.
American dream kabka khatam ho gaya hai......late 90s early 20s mai... :/
Imaginary explanations
What is the point of giving level based solution to us ? USCIS should take the action rite
It doesn't need to reach congress for decision making. Quite easy to filter these thoughts in the initial phase.The idea should be to ease immigration laws not make them cumbersome.
what about average highly skilled people,..? whose worth is not 50K.$
I guess the problem is that the Congress is not interesting in finding solution
Why would they even consider you and your problem? You are an international citizen. You come and go, not stay there. Like alien.
Why “reduced for universities”?
Oh that’s right! You’re a professor at a university so that helps YOU out! Got it
Win95 don't remember command even
Are you football 🏈 or baseball ⚾ fan?
Great Sir!! you got a great solution to have a pathway to get green-card easily for top notch candidates. The cap is now populating by mediocre professionals and general degree holders. This is why, high end immigrants not choosing US to come anymore. Your solution is right on the money. Advantages to those who are top and really needed by the US companies. One issue might be here that people will not choose to come in H1b Lite as there is no hope for them. Rather take options to go to Canada or other countries where options to become permanent is there.
Many such solutions and even better ones have been proposed and none managed to clear Congress … long story short if a candidate is going to be stuck in EB2 or 3 then do not come to usa… the time in our lives is worth much more than a green card
true! It doesnt matter what he is saying because there are hundreds of these solutions floating and nobody gives a damn. Lets be practical - USCIS is not listening to Mr Chaitanya lol
Actually an excellent recommendation.. practical.. and as mentioned it can be the beginning of an Idea.
University of Texas at Arlington
Summer intake 2022
My b.com computer is completed with the 59% 2nd division, osmania university Hyderabad ,can I get in state tution fee , scholarship stem course like ms in supply chain management or ms in digital marketing ?
great and easy solution 😂😂
👍
I think h1b standard needs to be better and broader since h1b lite will not lead to a greencard. Why? Cause many indian parents that are rich pay big bucks for their kids to get into a private usa uni. Hence making h1b standard only for usa masters graduates is discriminatory and biased. Moroever many indian students with masters and phd from indian universities are more qualified and skilled than their us counterparts. Just cause someone studied in usa doesn't automatically mean they are smarter or more qualified. For example india's CAT is harder than GMAT. Hence i think the h1b standard should also include anyone with a masters degree/phd from indian unis, those with two masters or someone that's highly skilled and possess a lot of knowledge in their field(like for those with l1b visas) or those that know other foreign languages.
I think this idea should reach to a Senator or a Representative. This seems to be a very flexible idea.
Lotteries are fair.
This might not work out as the MS course in 50% of the US universities are below the standard to the Bachelor of Engineering degrees in most of the Indian Universities and 90% of the MS students have no work experience.
not true, an average americcan university is far better than an average university in India
@@DesiAmericanProfessor not true , I think most USA MS education is a waste of time and money except few positions there a requirement of R&D .This is an expensive ticket to migrate to USA in form of student visa
@@DesiAmericanProfessor Correct 💯
@@DesiAmericanProfessor sir, an average us uni is better than even IITs
Please run for senator.
He is saying all this becoz he got his citizenship.. otherwise he would be a part of h1b lite surely …as phd holders also need to proof their contribution to the society and the universities..
yes sure, I have published in the best of the scientific journals, won teaching awards, won best paper research awards, surely I go to h1b lite.
@@DesiAmericanProfessor and that is contribution to the society ???🤔🤔.A PhD should be about improving society, not chasing academic kudos..
@@DesiAmericanProfessor this reply is enough to refute your reply , sorry man that's the truth
Professor, I thought your solution would be something for candidates to adopt but your solution is actually for the government to implement. But anyway thank you for your effort.
there isn't much normal people can do without having voting rights
This is you are proposing.. to Government.. why will they listen to you?
Will pay $100000000000 for green card
Original ideas. Original thinking. Respect that...
This is terrible solution! You've basically renamed eb1,2,3 as pro-light... Money for gc is terrible, $50k anyone will shell out that much of cash to get gc, current system is best
Too simplistic! If it is not your area of expertise, please try to refrain from analyzing it and presenting solutions. If you really want to change U.S. laws, quit your job, go into politics and run for congressman. Then you can try to change laws.
This is not a fish market
This is discrimination
Seems like you belong to h1b lite 😅😅
H1B for sale. Need to realize this will disproportionately impact non tech firms needing long term or lifelong employees. I think US should let the states create their own priority occupation needs for issuing IV/NIV visas and feds should perform the background. This mimics the system in Canada where provinces nominate their foreign workers.
Also, I find it very objectionable when you keep referring "desi firms". Consider wordsmithing.
I don't really get this who we Indians are to propose and literally bother US lawmakers to bring amendments or even demand them to mould or bend the rules just for the sake of where we find our interests to work for us the most. Even if law doesn't allow that, we need to get'em twisted a bit and that in a primarily and majorly a nation owned by a whole different section of humanity the GOOD/BAD the White Skinned Social Animals.
Moreover, I find my colleagues in Bay Area always squabbling US law makers and govt. here be it like The Trump's or say Biden's not to considering, we Indians as a special category for Green cards or say the H1B centralised concerns and that being well aware of the fact that no matter what we do here or how for long we stay here, We fortunately or woefully always remain AT THEIR (AMERICANS) DISPOSAL.
We chose USA to come here out of our own will, US never called us by its own. WE HOLD NO RIGHTS TO DEMAND HERE IN STATES FOR RULES TO GET TREATED FAST AND LOOSE FOR MATTERS LIKE H1B OR GREEN CARD.
I AM SOUNDING HARSH, BUT SOMEWHERE THIS IS THE ONLY REALITY.
WHY DO YOU THINK MR. PROFESSOR US SHALL EVEN CONSIDER YOU PROPOSING THEM??
I MEAN WHY??
well said. Will address this comment in another video. Also it is Dr. not Mr :)
@@DesiAmericanProfessor and sorry for not addressing you as Dr. my sincere apologies!!
That's true but doesn't it make sense to give priority to person who has an advanced degree from a US university working with US employer contributing to the economy, paying taxes vs someone from some low level desi consultancy in India with B.tech from an unknown college and would gonna be paid peanuts here
Prof sir is American citizen so he can propose the solution to his govt.It is his democratic right.I agree with u, for non US citizen, all one can do is follow the law of the land.
@@DesiAmericanProfessor 😂😂😂😂... Dr ?? Seriously? 😂😂😂.. You are demanding for a change in a law country where you were not even born and you call yourself a Dr?? Please Do that here in India we need people like you to come with solutions for all the problems we are facing here. Please talk about it.
Okay, I stopped watching after 5 minutes. Professor, it is easy to live in fantasyland. Granted that lottery system is bad. But, what you are proposing will never pass US congress. The reason is that giving out green cards based on employments is just one purpose of green cards and America’s technology advancement. There are other reasons America values and have reasons to worry about. For example green cards in following categories: Marriage based, refugee based, family reunification based, and high qualification based (EB1). There is no way, congress will rob Peter to pay Paul. Whatever mechanism you use, maximum number of green cards per year WILL NEVER increase (7% of overall quota for a country). Any mechanism to increase green card in employment based category will reduce numbers in other categories and create hardships in those categories. No one will stand for that either. Let us face it. Number of Indians wanting work based green cards is soooo large, America just cannot afford to give out that many green cards. America has already made up its mind. American companies will open more and more factories in India, and Indians returning from US will work in them. This will work. Asking for $50,000 fee for any visa is a non starter.
you are professor less visa agent more
Nonsense
Diversity is America’s strength. If systems like this are implemented. You’ll only have people with certain traits entering America. Which will not be good in the long run.
I’ve been working with genetic algorithms. And diversity in candidates solutions(exploration) is more important to reach better places than exploitation (focusing on point based systems)
The current immigration might not be beneficial to Indians. But it his highly beneficial to America.
Beneficial to America as it can use and throw Indians to replace them with young blood from India , without compromising its diversity having Indians overrun America.😂 since most Indians will die before they get their green cards. Knowing America’s rational policy they have the best of both worlds. It’s not going to change.
Why are we so proud about studying in the US and make products and services for them....we don't have policies in our own country to retain all the IQ which is being exported to the US for 7 decades now
Don't leave India and enrich Indian economy ... Solution to all problems
Sir your solution is considerable .... at least this solution should be discussed in parliament.... why don't you launch your political party... American janta party would be best name 💯
According to the American laws, anyone who didn't born in the US, can't contest the elections and can't run for the President's position.
That’s is wrong. One cannot become the president. No other post is restricted. You can even become the Vice President or governor of a state. Arnold Schwarzenegger was born in Austria and became a US citizen later. He then became the governor of California.
@@DesiAmericanProfessor wow nice.
I may suggest easy way for green card 😉. Many green card holder already back to India why😝 why it's too important then people 😡 return 😠 India 😤.
India is much better country to stay and enjoy. Why go to USA and do laundry and cook 😃
I think life in the US is amazing
What is amazing about US? Life is more than just food and a healthy body is more than clothing. Happy people are happy anywhere u throw them .
Completely disagree! Life in US is WAY better than India. Because quality of life is way better. You can’t pay me enough to go back to India. Even Ambani, the richest man in India, has extremely poor quality of life the moment he steps out of his luxurious home or corporate office. In other words, even if you are super rich in India, you are living inside a bubble. The infrastructure, air quality, higher education quality, healthcare quality, etc. are far superior in the US. The US is also the most innovative country in the world by a wide margin. The internet was initially developed because of funding from US government backed DARPA. The world’s leading companies such as Apple, Microsoft, Google, Meta, and others, are all American. God Bless America! God bless the greatest country in the world.
@@DesiAmericanProfessor india is a sinking ship... that's why many indians are desperate to leave india.