This version with the band was more jazzy. First take was gorgeous with the harmonies and the MV is well their MV. I listened to the MV. Blown away. The first take. Way better with the separation of the voices. This one, awesome. Three versions of the same song…but feels all good and different. The feels. Much respect
Maya is the queen of soul. Chisa's VOCAL ACROBATICS are TOP-TIER. Her musical knowledge and capabilities are wide and amazing. All XG members are the BEST and CERTIFIED DOPE. Vocals on point. Dance queens, Rap queens, Vocals queens, Fashion queens Visual queens Trilingual queens. 🔥🧨⚡💣💖💘💝👍👊👏💪 #XG #WINTERWITHOUTYOU #XPOP #JPOP #KPOP #GLOBALPOP
I think you should watch the MV for support. And watch the F1rst Take you won’t get flagged. The reason why we ask to react to the MV is that they made changes on both live versions
He's going to watch the MV even if it's just in his free time... It's his choice to react however he wants and he explained why he chose this video to react to and it's valid.
I dunno, jumping to the last one ruins the build of each version being better than the last. I wouldn't want to miss the experience of enjoying the it's live version without getting the experience of being overwhelmed by the first two,
@@BrettMurphynorthps for a lot of songs I'd agree with you. But there's just something about how the vocals pop off in this performance that I feel would just hit different if it was your first time hearing the song. Either way there's no real "right way" to experience any given song.
@@citizenshoop I agree but they miss out on watching the MV and then saying, this song is great! Then, they watch the first take and go dang it can't get better than this. Right? Then they get to the live version on go. OMG HOW DOES IT KEEP GETTING BETTER!!!!!
My brotha you hit it right on the nose. The band jazzed it up funky like. XG went XTRA with this version. I love when they slightly change it up so you know they are the real deal. Ain't no recordings being fed to us. B-E-A-U-TIFUL 😊💗👍
I don't care if you react to the MV or not, but you should definitely still watch it even if it's on your own time because it's insanely beautiful and even though I love the It's Live version, the MV/studio version of the song is my fave because it transports me right back to the late 90s.
XG performing with a live band is amazing and very well done and I'm really hoping we get more of because it's something heavily with their voices and range as performers and vocalists
XG doing vocal gymnastics on this track is just so good. Yes tears were shed when the beautiful MV for WWY dropped. It's so aesthetically pleasing - but when the VOX line came out to play, we were all in the ground. 😅 This reaction was so good. Favorite part : Maya! Mayaaaa! Helllooo? 😅😂 YES. That's our MaknACE MAYA. #XG #XGALX #ALPHAZ
mando, you gotta react to their hesonoo + xgene performance video! you gotta do it someday, it's good and very on the artistic side of choreo and video
Of course the girls killed this but that First Take is different. You don't have to react to it but you owe it to yourself to watch it. IMO, it's a better version. Nice reaction ✌🏾
![XG - “WINTER WITHOUT YOU” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] Reaction #XG #XGALX #ALPHAZ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qBeKbB_RhP4/mqdefault.jpg)
![XG - “WINTER WITHOUT YOU” Band LIVE Concert [it's Live] Reaction #XG #XGALX #ALPHAZ](/img/tr.png)
This version with the band was more jazzy. First take was gorgeous with the harmonies and the MV is well their MV. I listened to the MV. Blown away. The first take. Way better with the separation of the voices. This one, awesome. Three versions of the same song…but feels all good and different. The feels. Much respect
In my opinion, XG is the best girl group right now! They never miss! Every single is masterpiece!
I 2nd in motion!
Yepppp!!!
7:56 😄 I think we all had the same reaction when we heard Maya's amazing part. Jaw dropping. ❤
All 3 versions are excellent!!! Each with a different vibe.
Maya is the queen of soul. Chisa's VOCAL ACROBATICS are TOP-TIER. Her musical knowledge and capabilities are wide and amazing. All XG members are the BEST and CERTIFIED DOPE. Vocals on point. Dance queens, Rap queens, Vocals queens, Fashion queens Visual queens Trilingual queens. 🔥🧨⚡💣💖💘💝👍👊👏💪
#XG #WINTERWITHOUTYOU #XPOP #JPOP #KPOP #GLOBALPOP
XG is the best right now. They need to get their flowers.
No auto tune, No MELODYNE effects. XG is the OG 🔥⚡🧨!
Bit of a crime that this is a Christmas song.... might have to break my no Christmas music til December 1st rule with this one lol
Worth it
I think you should watch the MV for support. And watch the F1rst Take you won’t get flagged. The reason why we ask to react to the MV is that they made changes on both live versions
He's going to watch the MV even if it's just in his free time... It's his choice to react however he wants and he explained why he chose this video to react to and it's valid.
Honestly I wish my first experience of WWY was it's live, so i think you made the right choice there. I'm kind of jealous.
frrrr
I dunno, jumping to the last one ruins the build of each version being better than the last. I wouldn't want to miss the experience of enjoying the it's live version without getting the experience of being overwhelmed by the first two,
@@BrettMurphynorthps for a lot of songs I'd agree with you. But there's just something about how the vocals pop off in this performance that I feel would just hit different if it was your first time hearing the song. Either way there's no real "right way" to experience any given song.
@@citizenshoop I agree but they miss out on watching the MV and then saying, this song is great! Then, they watch the first take and go dang it can't get better than this. Right? Then they get to the live version on go. OMG HOW DOES IT KEEP GETTING BETTER!!!!!
I love this version as well, but that first take version has me
Original version is different, so is first take. All 3 are different to each other. Please react. Not unless your worried about tearing up on all 3? 😂
I’m just happy you finally got to this song. 😂
first take version is really outta the world
Btw, watch the first take version, ABSOTIVELY AMAZING
XG❤
FRISSON...... every time.
I keep saying this I know but everyone, every time and Maya= undercover ace. 7x🔥👑's ❤.
THE MV IS SO PRETTY
I'm glad you reacted to this version first, so you can react to both of their First Take videos together
My brotha you hit it right on the nose. The band jazzed it up funky like. XG went XTRA with this version. I love when they slightly change it up so you know they are the real deal. Ain't no recordings being fed to us. B-E-A-U-TIFUL 😊💗👍
No worries bro I cried too lol. It's THAT beautiful of a song 😂
The First Take version of this song is the best but yeah absolutely immaculate vibes
I love your reaction ❤ this version is my favorite one. Live band with jazz flow and beautiful XG vocals. I almost cried too. It’s incredible
There we go lol. This version is top tier. It's cool that every version is a lil different
Gonna be in my 2024 top spotify songs ngl
I don't care if you react to the MV or not, but you should definitely still watch it even if it's on your own time because it's insanely beautiful and even though I love the It's Live version, the MV/studio version of the song is my fave because it transports me right back to the late 90s.
オリジナルはまさに極上のR&Bバラードで、このバンド・バージョンは少しジャズっぽい雰囲気が加えられてますけど、コレもまたホントに素晴らしいと思いました。XGちゃんたちらしいグルーヴ感がよく伝わってきて、歌声も極上、すべてが最高級ですよね😁
I feel like I'm in heaven listening to this song omg! it's so angelic!
I thought you would definitely like this song. Please also check out the MV and MV behind. You will cry again.
XG WWY the first take & it's live version 🔥 *noice*
XG performing with a live band is amazing and very well done and I'm really hoping we get more of because it's something heavily with their voices and range as performers and vocalists
XG doing vocal gymnastics on this track is just so good. Yes tears were shed when the beautiful MV for WWY dropped. It's so aesthetically pleasing - but when the VOX line came out to play, we were all in the ground. 😅
This reaction was so good.
Favorite part :
Maya! Mayaaaa! Helllooo? 😅😂
YES. That's our MaknACE MAYA.
#XG #XGALX #ALPHAZ
The vibe of the band add so much emotion to song❤
You need to watch the video if only because of Maya’s part. She sings it slightly differently and it’s so worth it.
HEY MANDO! 🖤✨
BRO I THOUGHT YOU DROPPED THEM ALREADY, I WAS WORRIED LOL WELCOME BACK!
Xg is my favorite girl group hands down
This and The First Take were amazing better than the original imo
Please react also to their live version of wwy at the first take studio 🤘
mando, you gotta react to their hesonoo + xgene performance video! you gotta do it someday, it's good and very on the artistic side of choreo and video
Watch the MV bro lol. It's also amazing.
🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺
Of course the girls killed this but that First Take is different. You don't have to react to it but you owe it to yourself to watch it. IMO, it's a better version.
Nice reaction ✌🏾
Bruh, stop making excuses and react to the MV, they deserve that much.
MV, MV, MV!
if it were any other group (le sserafim, aespa) he'd watch every single version including MV lollllll
bro skipped TFT??
XG❤