Let me know your theories in the comments! For more Stardew Valley videos check out my playlist at th-cam.com/play/PLg0HcWlu_ZQ611fFrSCxwgyTTcfg5hvVd.html
My theory is that the woman in the photo is Marnie’s sister (or niece) and Jas’ mom. Possibly the “Mona” in the cemetery. I think Shane is possibly related to Jas’ father owing to the similarity in appearance and his being named her godfather (sometimes done within families.) Jas maintains almost an older brother/younger sister dynamic with Shane and so he and Marnie could view each other as aunt and nephew as an extension of Jas’ family ties to Marnie, or possibly due to being an in-law and developing a familial relationship in that context. If he was the brother-in-law of Marnie’s niece, as an example, he’d kind of be her nephew in a very loose interpretation that might suddenly matter much more after losing family and moving in with her. Also some people are an “aunt” no matter how many generations fall in between, like all of my great and great-great aunts are just called Aunt/Auntie. Marnie could easily be the person Jas’ mom called Aunt Marnie and because of that simply be seen as Aunt Marnie by Jas even if the family relationships are more complicated. I do think the woman in the photo is Jas’ mother and a relation to Marnie though. She looks too young and different to be Marnie given how young Jas still is, but too much like Marnie to be coincidence.
I have a theory. I watched another video (for spoilers and thumbnail) where it shows Abigail is the daughter of the wizard. (P.s am not that long yet in the story) At first it seems far from the topic but there was a line the comment section pointed out of the wizard saying he thought everyone in the town was his child. Meaning he doesn't know his own child or probably he just sleep with many people in the town. A description for Abigail is her purple hair that is unnoticeable with inherited from the wizard. Jas is also purpled hair (most of the folks are also purpled hair lol). It could mean that jas could be also the daughter of the wizard. To also fuel this more is the fact that Marnie's house is close to the tower and why there is no biological connection between Shane , Jas and Marnie. It could mean Jas's mother was a close friend who probably rented Marnie's house and got pregnant with the wizards child. But a thing that could break this theory is Jas unable to see the junimos (or probably she did but I didn't see yet) Jas is always at the forest to play jump rope and Marnie seems not close with the wizard and on several occasions warn the player stay away from the tower. Children often listen to adult because of fear but since jas isn't afraid she must seen junimos as assurance. Plus Marnie's attitude could add up to her friend being a lover to the wizard.
@@SimGamesCorner sorry I was lil wrong but I only read those in the comments about him stating that actually there was another one which he stated he had a daughter with a local which is something I dunno yet cause am not that far at the game
@@SimGamesCorner but to add up to that is he doesn't know which local he hit off so Jas could also be a possibility or many more. Even Sebastian could be his child as his father wasn't introduced and Robin is a carpenter and cindersap woods would be a good place for tree hunting etc. Thanks for responding so nice of you
Let me know your theories in the comments! For more Stardew Valley videos check out my playlist at th-cam.com/play/PLg0HcWlu_ZQ611fFrSCxwgyTTcfg5hvVd.html
Well Marnie could have also been close friends with Jas’s parents and the parents could have taken Jas to the ranch when she was young for a visit.
That theory makes the most sense so far!!!
My theory is that the woman in the photo is Marnie’s sister (or niece) and Jas’ mom. Possibly the “Mona” in the cemetery. I think Shane is possibly related to Jas’ father owing to the similarity in appearance and his being named her godfather (sometimes done within families.) Jas maintains almost an older brother/younger sister dynamic with Shane and so he and Marnie could view each other as aunt and nephew as an extension of Jas’ family ties to Marnie, or possibly due to being an in-law and developing a familial relationship in that context. If he was the brother-in-law of Marnie’s niece, as an example, he’d kind of be her nephew in a very loose interpretation that might suddenly matter much more after losing family and moving in with her. Also some people are an “aunt” no matter how many generations fall in between, like all of my great and great-great aunts are just called Aunt/Auntie. Marnie could easily be the person Jas’ mom called Aunt Marnie and because of that simply be seen as Aunt Marnie by Jas even if the family relationships are more complicated. I do think the woman in the photo is Jas’ mother and a relation to Marnie though. She looks too young and different to be Marnie given how young Jas still is, but too much like Marnie to be coincidence.
Well thought out theory!! I like it!!👍
I had a different theory of the Wizard perhaps being the father of Jas and Shane? or even Abi even? I mean they all have the same hair color...
Most people believe that the Wizard is the father of Abigail but it is a possibility that it could be Jas
I have a theory. I watched another video (for spoilers and thumbnail) where it shows Abigail is the daughter of the wizard. (P.s am not that long yet in the story) At first it seems far from the topic but there was a line the comment section pointed out of the wizard saying he thought everyone in the town was his child. Meaning he doesn't know his own child or probably he just sleep with many people in the town. A description for Abigail is her purple hair that is unnoticeable with inherited from the wizard. Jas is also purpled hair (most of the folks are also purpled hair lol). It could mean that jas could be also the daughter of the wizard. To also fuel this more is the fact that Marnie's house is close to the tower and why there is no biological connection between Shane , Jas and Marnie. It could mean Jas's mother was a close friend who probably rented Marnie's house and got pregnant with the wizards child. But a thing that could break this theory is Jas unable to see the junimos (or probably she did but I didn't see yet) Jas is always at the forest to play jump rope and Marnie seems not close with the wizard and on several occasions warn the player stay away from the tower. Children often listen to adult because of fear but since jas isn't afraid she must seen junimos as assurance. Plus Marnie's attitude could add up to her friend being a lover to the wizard.
Very interesting. Didn't know he claimed everyone was his child.
@@SimGamesCorner sorry I was lil wrong but I only read those in the comments about him stating that actually there was another one which he stated he had a daughter with a local which is something I dunno yet cause am not that far at the game
@@tappytap3988 ahh okay. Yeah, he does claim he has a daughter in Pelican town. The clues point to Abby.
@@SimGamesCorner but to add up to that is he doesn't know which local he hit off so Jas could also be a possibility or many more. Even Sebastian could be his child as his father wasn't introduced and Robin is a carpenter and cindersap woods would be a good place for tree hunting etc. Thanks for responding so nice of you