Exactly..this is not a combo of layton and herod BUT i own also red tobacco and carlisle but i they are also way different mancera is rugged and good in its own way and had cherry popebtobacco smell where as carlisle is a very pleasant and different version.. If you want to compare carlisle to something i think you should compare it to initio side effect..to me these are in the going in the same directing
Thank you for the review brother! I really love this scent especially in the first 3-4 hours but after about 8 hours it dries down into a kinda musty patchouli scent which I'm not a fan of. Just wondering do you get the same smell?
I love Carlisle. PdM have some amazing fragrances. Oajan, Carlisle, Layton (and the Eclusif), Herod, Percival are all amazing bangers and worth every penny, especially when you can get legit bottles below retail. In my Top 5 Houses for sure. I always get compliments when a wear any PdM fragrance.
Carlisle is my very first niche fragrance I get to try from a decant. Love the smell of it. I personally think this is a bit easier to wear than Red tobacco but nonetheless, they are really close like you mentioned brother. ❤️ the smell of this one
Fantastic review, Joy. Your views jibe with (and clarify) my own as to the comparison between Mancera Red Tobacco and Carlisle. Have you tried Chopard Makaki Oud? It opens similar to these with tobacco but at a much more controlled volume - potentially much more wearable in warms temps. It evolves to a more oud-y balance than even Red Tobacco. Matt of the 'Questioning Scents' YT channel has a great review of it.
Parfums de Marly has REFORMULATED Carlisle. I own an older formulation which has an alcohol concentration of 77%. The new formulation I see in stores has 81% alcohol. My formulation is a dark ORANGE / AMBER color. The new formulation is a very light, faint copper color. The new formulation does not last as long and it smells different. Parfums de Marly fragrances are ALWAYS getting reformulated and become much weaker than their ORIGINAL releases. Parfums de Marly HAS NOT been transparent when it comes to the reformulation of their fragrances. Herod, Layton & Oajan have also been reformulated and have 3%-4% more alcohol in newer batches.
@@pwj86772 You should spend less time worrying about my comments that I post on TH-cam and get a life. You spend all your time playing video games. I made my point about Parfums de Marly 5 months ago and I copied and pasted my point. Why would I re-type my point every time I make it? I made my point 5 months ago and it took very little time to include it in TH-cam videos and fragrance forums. I have moved on. People can make their own decisions about fragrances. You must work for Parfums de Marly and you want to protect the brand and hide the facts about their fragrances
@Joy Amin, Been waiting on this video lol. Would you prefer Carlise or Layton is the question? dont say both! -From: Miami, FL. Is that Givenchy Gentleman Only Intense? What a beautiful gem that I cannot find. I have Givenchy Gentleman 2017 (next to GGOI).
😱😱😱 A major tidying up 🧹 of the background is definitely” required. In the UK there’s a program called hoarders.. And the mass of hundreds of bottles in the background reminded me of that🤔🤔🤔
Exactly..this is not a combo of layton and herod BUT
i own also red tobacco and carlisle but i they are also way different mancera is rugged and good in its own way and had cherry popebtobacco smell where as carlisle is a very pleasant and different version.. If you want to compare carlisle to something i think you should compare it to initio side effect..to me these are in the going in the same directing
Carlisle great smell,long lasting,good for special occasions. Women's love this fragrance.
Which batch code u had?
@@AntiFanatik 2015
@@Jfbr1965 what year is that batch code? doesnt have any letters, only numbers
@@SPACEDOUT19 l have the old one from 2015
While I love many PdM fragrances, Carlisle has to be the flagship fragrance for PdM. I think it's a king's fragrance.
PDM is very expressive here in Cairo Joy !.. by the way nice polo shirt ;) .. have a good day bro..
Thank you for the review brother! I really love this scent especially in the first 3-4 hours but after about 8 hours it dries down into a kinda musty patchouli scent which I'm not a fan of. Just wondering do you get the same smell?
Hei, Can I buy parfums de marly carlisle if I have herod ? How much similarity have between both parfums?
Hi joy, which fragrance of navitus is similar to perfume de marly carlisle? Thanks
Awesome as always! I learned some things today, you are the best!
I love Carlisle. PdM have some amazing fragrances. Oajan, Carlisle, Layton (and the Eclusif), Herod, Percival are all amazing bangers and worth every penny, especially when you can get legit bottles below retail. In my Top 5 Houses for sure. I always get compliments when a wear any PdM fragrance.
Carlisle is my very first niche fragrance I get to try from a decant. Love the smell of it. I personally think this is a bit easier to wear than Red tobacco but nonetheless, they are really close like you mentioned brother. ❤️ the smell of this one
I want 5 ml please let me know the price
Great review. I agree. Red Tobacco is the rougher littlw brothee of PDM Carlisle. The BEST Winter cold weather scent. Be safe
You are the best, cheers From Chile 🇨🇱
Did carlisle got reformulated on 2020??
Fantastic review, Joy. Your views jibe with (and clarify) my own as to the comparison between Mancera Red Tobacco and Carlisle. Have you tried Chopard Makaki Oud? It opens similar to these with tobacco but at a much more controlled volume - potentially much more wearable in warms temps. It evolves to a more oud-y balance than even Red Tobacco. Matt of the 'Questioning Scents' YT channel has a great review of it.
Great review and I enjoyed it and i like this fragrance and one of my 10 out of ten fragrances and have a blessed night
What are your other 10 out of 10 fragrances..im interested to know coz carlisle also ticks all the boxes for me
Love Carlisle. Bought a backup bottle which I don’t normally do as my collection is about 20 frags.
Parfums de Marly has REFORMULATED Carlisle. I own an older formulation which has an alcohol concentration of 77%. The new formulation I see in stores has 81% alcohol. My formulation is a dark ORANGE / AMBER color. The new formulation is a very light, faint copper color. The new formulation does not last as long and it smells different. Parfums de Marly fragrances are ALWAYS getting reformulated and become much weaker than their ORIGINAL releases. Parfums de Marly HAS NOT been transparent when it comes to the reformulation of their fragrances. Herod, Layton & Oajan have also been reformulated and have 3%-4% more alcohol in newer batches.
Oh god, the copy and paste guy
@@pwj86772 You should spend less time worrying about my comments that I post on TH-cam and get a life. You spend all your time playing video games. I made my point about Parfums de Marly 5 months ago and I copied and pasted my point. Why would I re-type my point every time I make it? I made my point 5 months ago and it took very little time to include it in TH-cam videos and fragrance forums. I have moved on. People can make their own decisions about fragrances. You must work for Parfums de Marly and you want to protect the brand and hide the facts about their fragrances
Are you demarly hater? Why you crying everywhere 😂😂
This is latte - pulls out a gallon of latte.. Hahahaha. Nice vid Joy ;)
Red Tobacco smoky??? I am not getting that at ll. Thanks for the review
Beautiful fragrace
@Joy Amin, Been waiting on this video lol. Would you prefer Carlise or Layton is the question? dont say both! -From: Miami, FL. Is that Givenchy Gentleman Only Intense? What a beautiful gem that I cannot find. I have Givenchy Gentleman 2017 (next to GGOI).
I have both,Carlisle is much better than layton.
😱😱😱 A major tidying up 🧹 of the background is definitely” required.
In the UK there’s a program called hoarders.. And the mass of hundreds of bottles in the background reminded me of that🤔🤔🤔
Thomas Kosmala no 4
Pleeeeeeease
i have Carlise, love it. In the same line as Black Orchi, in my opinion.
Same as thing I thought after 10 mins of dry down.. just amazing and exquisitely brilliant perfumery
I want this soooooo bad.. I tried Harod and was shocked I didn’t like it
Carlisle is much better than Herod, you will love it.
Where in Banga can you buy all this Niche Fragrances ??