Thanks for the info. People who had lived through that period would not talk much about it. I guess talking about it is to relive that period of bad experience. The other reason is outsiders would not understand their fear, torments, desperation they had gone through. Thanks for "The Story of Hong Kong Coastal Defence”, though I cannot share the emotional elements, I came to appreciate devotion of these people, mostly young, who took a boring boat trip to lay down their lives for a place we loved so much. Where are we? What are we?
2. Communication was limited to wired phone, once cut by enemy then out of contact, officer were on there own. 3. Invasion came after dark using boats from closest point to Saukiwan, not easy to judge situations. 4. There was a ship stationed at Hkg harbour, but took all white people, bankers, non combat person to Singapore for safety reason, assuming Japanese won’t go there.
1. 1950 Canadian soldiers were new recruits age between 17 to 25, none of them had any battlefield experience, during several weeks training, mostly receive basic knowledge of solider without limited firearms practice. Small bore rifle was used not the standard.303 Lee Enfield rifle. Those from Quebec speak French, need interpretation from colleague. Also told fighting with small Japanese as short as monkeys, war will end soon.
網上講座傳送門 👉 5:37
0:00
多謝教授，令我仿佛身歴其境，亦要向捐軀士兵們致敬。
鄺博士的精彩演繹把十八日香港攻防戰清楚地陳列出來，攻守双方的得失也分析得明明白白，問答部分也能指出當時戰鬥的盲點。這是一塲精彩的研討會👏👏
真係分析得好好
鄺智文教授喺香港眾多歷史學家演講最精彩的一位！他對二戰的研究亦深入落實可靠❤
😂
p
十分珍貴的史料, 謝謝!
Thanks for the info.
People who had lived through that period would not talk much about it.
I guess talking about it is to relive that period of bad experience.
The other reason is outsiders would not understand their fear, torments, desperation they had gone through.
Thanks for "The Story of Hong Kong Coastal Defence”, though I cannot share the emotional elements, I came to appreciate devotion of these people, mostly young, who took a boring boat trip to lay down their lives for a place we loved so much.
Where are we? What are we?
聽聽吓竟然聽完🫨
全部聽哂😌
好少咁嘅純軍事討論
精彩
感謝海防博物館上載講座，內容很精彩。但有個意見想反映一下：我見到你們很悉心透過不同鏡頭去記錄講座，但講座中很大部分時間鄺博士是透過螢幕（地圖或ppt）去表達，但我不明白為何總是要急不及待地轉回講者的大頭畫面，此舉讓人懊惱，因為講者其實多次用滑鼠箭咀指示地圖但鏡頭卻跟不上，既然已有雙畫面並列的格式，請保留內容螢幕的放送，講者的全大頭畫面可意減少，對我來說，我寧願全是內容畫面（後期製作功夫更少），因為講者的聲音和內容螢幕的資料是最重要，講者的大頭可以作為輔助。再次感謝你們的工作。
同意！
Agree
同意！正是小弟的感覺，講者講解時觀眾能清楚看到不同的地圖是最重要，不是講者的面孔。
唔見官方有回應嘅？
@05:39 Start 開始
高添強先生講述最精彩, 因應年紀及他接觸曾經參與抗戰長者, 親身由長者口述歷史中, 帶出戰事給現在香港人感受, 使社會更受關注！
再發展有關剛發現文獻...太多！
不知哪裡可看到高先生的講述?
香港測量師學會-2021年12月免費出2份“軍事遺址”位置報告, 更吸引一般想認識該戰事讀者！
事戈 係
我都睇緊，加油！！
2. Communication was limited to wired phone, once cut by enemy then out of contact, officer were on there own.
3. Invasion came after dark using boats from closest point to Saukiwan, not easy to judge situations.
4. There was a ship stationed at Hkg harbour, but took all white people, bankers, non combat person to Singapore for safety reason, assuming Japanese won’t go there.
曾經訪問曾參防衛香港華人長者, 早開戰前已察覺, 很多日本人在香港, 郊遊/釣魚等活動中, 搜集香港守軍建築位置, 可惜或教授, 以年紀未能接觸仍身體健全可細心憶述戰史-防衛華人長者 ;
非要搵外藉軍官長者知最多, 當時接觸市面最能察覺-日本間諜人士
律政司被拘都仲有秘書
長見識了
請教授講授19年及後的歷史
P
做的不错
我都係浸會大學歷史系畢業，2005年
呢個副教授未聽過嘅，侯勵英呢
未聽過就上網查下啦😅
1. 1950 Canadian soldiers were new recruits age between 17 to 25, none of them had any battlefield experience, during several weeks training, mostly receive basic knowledge of solider without limited firearms practice. Small bore rifle was used not the standard.303 Lee Enfield rifle. Those from Quebec speak French, need interpretation from colleague. Also told fighting with small Japanese as short as monkeys, war will end soon.
英軍英雄
勇者無所 懼
當年全香港總人口一定超越日軍人數，點解平民唔岀去幫手作戰，戰時啲平民當時做緊咩？
平民上戰場只會送死或者阻住打仗
豫湘桂大會戰
日稱：（一號作戰）
巨大的影響，日軍雖達到目的卻是一場空
（中國國民黨軍隊最虛弱裝備處於抗日戰爭最差的時刻）
（1）破壞美軍在華空軍基地（2）打通大陸交通線（3）打擊國軍力量
國軍一路敗退，失地千里
國民政府盛衰的轉捩點（1）國軍衰敗：
湯恩伯：戰將竟成為“水旱蝗湯”（2）郭沫若：“甲申三百年祭”。士氣低落
（3）英美蘇看輕國軍：中美關係轉差，英美要求蘇聯參戰（4）中共趁機做大：國共兩黨勢力從此逆轉
方德萬（Hans Van de Ven）：“國民政府成敗的轉捩點。”
新界發生炮戰，末有近距离尽地戰，更無肉博戰，双方伤忙不祥。
當時香港算是孤島一個、守得一日、守不到一年😅
😭
施永青
你是'否可信！
开场20多分钟都在讲废话
第26分钟开始吧，此人讲话废话达到惊人比例
You are free to quit any time if you felt impatient.
@@Mic_withMac哈哈，发出来还不让人说
尊重歷史 向英軍加拿大軍致敬！🇬🇧🇨🇦
Can you talk about 10000 unexplained deaths in hk in 2019. A lot of people said CCP agents did that.