Everything Wrong With Hereditary In 13 Minutes Or Less
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Hereditary is freaky, creepy, original, and features some great performances. But it still has sins!
There was a slightly different version of this sins video that was apparently too gross or graphic or something, so we made some tweaks. But if you want to see that mostly-the-same original version, you can do so here: • Everything Wrong With ...
Next week: punching sins and adventure/fantasy sins.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins... •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/...
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.lib...
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com...
I'm just realizing now that the person who was putting the ridiculous amount of nuts in the cake was probably someone in the cult....
Wow you could be right.
Interesting
Everything was planned by the cult. The party was set by the cult, the cake, everything
@@prestons4988 "the cake is a lie" some AI warned us long ago
Joy Montgomery how’d you find that out?
7:12 I actually like Peter's cry on this scene. It reminds me of how children cry and to see a teenager in such shock and go through such trauma that he would regress to a child's mental state, I think that, if it was the actor's choice, it was brilliant
MAKE IT FUCKIN STOP
100%
Yeah so true
Dude, i've cried as a teenager, i've even straight up openly wept much like Peter was doing, but that's definitely awkward enough and weird enough of a cry that it's worth a sin. Hell, it SOUNDED fake as hell even without the overdramatic way he buried his face in Steve's chest. If i were directing this i'd have felt the need to do another.
@@Silentbob1494 nah I cry exactly spot on to that man lmao.
they not having a epipen every second of the day is the biggest sin of the movie
everyone with severe allergy carries one
i dont :/ havent taken it out of the house in months
@@yourname7176 I get that you're suicidal but damn
It’s feasible, I once misplaced my epipen and it took months for me to notice it was missing. Luckily I noticed when looking for something else, not when having a reaction.
I thought Charlie not asking absolutely everyone “does this have nuts” was strange, though. She’s 13, I knew to do that when I was 7.
I have a peanut allergy and I’ve never carried one with me, most people are smart enough to check before they eat
Just watched this movie and I'm so glad you pointed out the epipen sin. Like what family NEVER carries an epipen?
A family that doesn't have any deadly allergies?
@@krustykrab34 Except they did lol.
@@hehno4226 but did u see their house ???
Right? Like you’d think they’d make her carry one with her at all times (especially before sending her to a party with her older brother) or at least they’d have 1 or 2 stashed in the cars glovebox for emergencies or whatever
I have an epipen and I can confirm we never brought it anywhere I haven’t seen one in 5+ years
my man couldn't find actual sins
max magana FACTS
Exactly what I was thinking...
But they did
@@cbb3480 I- 🤦♀️🤦♀️
@@cbb3480 Now you sound even more stupid.
HE MEANT GENUINE SINS!
Liftoach Pandemonium means “Open up Hell”. Liftoach means “to open up” Pandemonium is Latin for “many demons” and is the namesake for the capital of Hell in John Milton’s “Paradise Lost”. That’s the beauty of Ari Asters writing and direction, he doesn’t give you all of the answers because he wants you to dive deeper, and create curiosity around his films.
It works, too! I saw Hereditary for the first time about a year ago and still think about it about once a week. I feel like I’ve watched every single video about it on TH-cam and STILL find new things I didn’t know before. He’s a genius
@@gabriellaberman im doing that rn :D
some of these sins were just straight up dumb. like the minute of Annie crying was raw emotion, i thought it was the perfect mix of guilt, anxiety, and fear.
This channel is satire
@@gonzacollao It being satire doesn't negate every criticism.
@@unblorbosyourshows9635 no, but it explains why some sins (if not every one of them) are so dumb. Like if extreme realism and verisimilitude were absolutely mandatory in a work of fiction...
Alot of the sins are just bs. If you watch the videos some sins will deadass be "scene dose not contain a lap dance". Although some sins have to do with plot holes of the movie (like how did Annie's body phase into the attic at the end), most of them are just goofs.
@@gonzacollao since when did it switch to satire? it's always been serious. but now he tries to find things that arent wrong wrong
Not removing a sin for the decapitation scene is a sin
Ikr
I think a sin should have been removed for Peters reaction. That was the most grueling part.
EddieWilliamBrooks I mean it was an amazing performance by Toni Collette, but my god it was super dragged out.
TRIS *sin
@@MidconStudios Was not dragged out lol.
"GEEET OOUUUT!"
Wrong horror movie.
*ding
Do everything wrong with Bird Box
ScarlettP Netflix will probably strike it down within minutes, BUT FUCK EM
good idea
@@ლ.ლ-ნ7ძ Netflix will welcome it. More people talking about Birdbox is a good thing for Netflix.
I don't think he even does EWW videos on Netflix movies.
It was shown in theaters though
!!! something I only just noticed the 4th time round watching this film. She doesn't read out the words from the paper because she has already read them out before waking up steve and Peter! After the dream fight scene between Annie and Peter and she wakes up in bed gasping, it cuts to a pan of her bedroom and steve is asleep in bed. If you turn up the volume to the loudest setting and press your ear up against the speaker, you can hear in the background of the scene Annie reading out the names written on the paper! and you can see there is a light shining out from underneath the bathroom?/closet door? not sure what that room is but yeah she's in there with the candle lit and she reads out the words Satony, Paimon, something pandemonium and another word I've forgotten. But yeah super cool never noticed it before and always wondered why and how she was able to conduct the seance without getting things started like Joan said she needed to do. but pause the film right after you listen because you don't want your ear up against the speaker listening to her whisper to Peter in the next shot.
Thank you for pointing that out!
I've also noticed that the word Pandemonium was written on a wall in the house at some point! Perhaps this is to prove that whatever these forces are have been present throughout the entire period that the family has lived in the house?
9:34 Awesome touch of detail with the kid filming in the background while Peter has his freak out in class!
That crying scene should NOT be a sin...! It was such a terrific acting and absolutely depicts pain of a mother who's daughter dies in such a horrific way.
That nut allergy is absolutely nuts
You tried, buddy.....you tried
Seeing you 4 times
@@danielsappel9552 No, you tried
@@vAqeii holy shit
Leave
Creepy people staring at you across the street of the schoolyard is the most realistic part in the movie.
childhood much?
I feel like essential in horror films to show the premeditation of what's going to happen
This movie is the kind that makes you sprint up the stairs when you turn off the lights
Uhm, no
@@yorshka6955 um yes, nigga.
@@8Tproducer i watched it and it was boring and made no sense
@@yorshka6955 Low IQ
@@yorshka6955 ok allow me to explain. You wake up at midnight, and you get the munchies, so so go downstairs to your kitchen and grab a snack or two. And then you walk up the stairs and for SOME REASON, you feel as if there was a demon breathing on your back, so what does any human do, fuckin run.
petition to change “movie sim timer” to “movie timer” because we know how long the video is but i wanna know what time in the movie we’re at
yeah
That is actually very true
*signs petition*
THE SCARIEST PART OF THE MOVIE-THE NAKED CULT MEMBERS
Fully agree!! They are the reason i had to stop watching the movie in the middle of the night & turn it back on in the day time in a well lit room lol
Those old naked people gave me a few sleepless nights lol
Lmao that was like the least scariest part for me lol
@Dylan Bundren yea maybe
It was the funniest part of the Movie in my opinion. When the Mother elevated slowly into the Treehouse i couldn't stop laughing. It was just silly
Saw this movie a while back but that "cluck scare" bit still made me jump and pause the vid for at least 10 minutes before I could continue watching.
i literally paused the movie and collected myself
I like that they still used a few jump scares, but they were still emotionally charged rather than plain old ones.
Seriously? Jump scare sounds are the lamest shit and shouldn't ever be in horror movies.
@@jeffboyd8139 ok ceo of horror movies
Same
1. Toni Collette appearing in Peter’s room on the corner ceiling
2. Toni Collette had the most freakishly scary float scene across the ceiling
3. Toni Collette banging her head upside down on the ceiling
But the scariest of them all is the Academy not even acknowledging her performance in the movie with an Oscar nom.
This movie was so set apart from any horror movies I’ve seen😭I wasn’t ready
Blair Assani I had never heard of it or seen a trailer before seeing it , I had only seen the clip at the dinner table that’s all, so when watching the film I had no idea wth was happening
Agreed 100%
it’s a masterpiece isn’t it! No relying on jump scares, the insanely good acting that seems to capture grief at its ugliest, the hints and Easter eggs, aw man it’s the movie I’m going to use as a reference for horror from now on
yeah, no doubt the scariest movie ive seen
Its tuff
Toni Collette's scream when she found her in the car and when she was wailing on the floor after DESTROYED me. I cried so hard I had to rewind it to watch it again and then pause it. It was amazing! She's a killer actress.
Annie rocking on the bedroom floor, screaming praying for death, that hit an emotional nerve. I did the very same many times after my mother died from a tragic accident
When did a child with food allergy become a cliché?
And also the creep at the funeral shouldn’t count as a sin, it’s an important element to the plot.
There’s plenty of more stuff you got wrong in this video, I just don’t got time to point them all out.
A 'child with a severe allergy that plays an important part in future drama' thing has been done a fair bit. It's usually set up innocuously like it was in this movie, with either someone shown/mentioning the double-checking of ingredients, or a warning given to someone regarding it. The dramatic portion involving the cliche is almost always it's a bit stupid, since anyone with a known history of severe allergies would have an epipen or they (or those around them) would know better than to eat food of questionable origin. Sometimes it's an incompetent/ignorant/unprepared caregiver (formerly absentee parent, overworked parent, sibling, or friend of some sort). It's usually played to make the one they're with 'realize what is really important' or something similar, as they panic about it. It's a subset to the general trope of 'irresponsible person's charge dies or nearly dies due to ignorance of risk, or neglect'; a rather broad trope in storytelling in general.
In this case it's kind of a double-layer, since both the brother (who just wanted her out of the way and carelessly told her to eat some random treat), and the mother (who suspected the party wasn't going to be entirely aboveboard to begin with, but basically forced her son to take his little sister anyway) fit the end result; kid suffers allergic reaction, then actually dies, though the death wasn't directly the result of the first incident. It's a bit different in that respect.
So give me an example of any type of film or literature that has the use of allergies to set up in important turning point in the movie.
BTW, thanks for the reply to my opinion, it was very in depth and thought out.
I've seen it a few times, but the only one I can recall offhand is 'The Game Plan'. (the movie with Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson) I thought of going into detail about it in my previous post, but it's not exactly a popular film and I didn't want to spoil an important plot point in it regardless. You asked though, so I'm mentioning it now.
As I said, it's really more that it's a specific subset of a trope, a version of it that has been done enough times now that in some people's minds anyway, like myself and CinemaSins, think of it as a cliche. Any time I hear about a character (esp. a child) having an allergy or some other health issue that can lead to a dramatic result if something goes wrong due to ineptitude, ignorance or carelessness, I pretty much expect it to happen later on in the story. It's blatant foreshadowing. Most just can't/don't set it up with enough subtlety to slip by without people going "well that came out of nowhere'. Something like a split-second view of an epipen in a drawer, or a medical alert bracelet that isn't focused on, or maybe the character(s) paying a bit of extra attention to nutrition information or ingredients list without explaining it aloud. Things that someone might spot if they're looking for it, but could easily be passed off as unimportant props or filler actions to pad out scenes and make them more natural.
Thing is, the trope calls for the minder of the person with the medical concern to be made aware of the issue in no uncertain terms (I.E. "They must never come in contact with X"), and the minder just not paying attention at a critical moment due to other priorities. It's a bit of a catch-22 situation from a storytelling point of view. In order for it to work as a device in the story, the relevant people (including the viewers incidentally) must be clearly informed of the possible danger, but in so doing largely spoils the drama and surprise of the now inevitable (from the audience's perspective) event. It's dramatic to the characters on screen, but we see it coming a mile away, since it's generally bad form to make a big deal about something only to have it come to nothing, and being subtle about it just doesn't work in the context of how it's to be used. That doesn't mean it can't be an effective tool when used correctly, with the right setting and characters, but it's a pretty obvious and blunt-force method (like a sledgehammer) regardless of how well it works.
And thank *you* for a civil response to an opinion that appears to run counter to your PoV XD
“But this channel is just satire” /s. I don’t get why this channel is as popular as it is, it’s just pure lazy garbage criticism
@@edvartsen1685 They have literally admitted to not being critics but aholes. What more do you want them to say they don't think they are pointing out genuine flaws. If you dislike that then stop watching there videos.
"Nobody admits anything they've done"
I'm going to sin you for not sinning them on the irony of her saying this while not realising she was the cause of this by making Peter take the girl to the party.
Thank You
But the son and the movie brings that up Jeremy doing it would just be redundant
But that's... that's the point. That's the point of the rant. There's a reason they had her say that line, and part of it is that _she_ refuses to take responsibility. It's not the film's fault if you can't read subtext.
Yves I’m confused. Why is the movie’s character development with that line sin worthy?
He did. He said " united states of annie" and took a jab at politicians shifting blame. Must be over ur head
Most of these aren't even sins or faults of the movie.
The mom thinks the high school party is a school barbecue, since that's what Peter tells her, that's why she makes him take Charlie
Please do Everything Wrong With Venom (2018).
"This movie exists" because of Sony and their licensing shenanigans.
No no do Venom (1946)...
"If you look really hard you can see Spider-Man in this shot."
Lost Legend bruh there would be like 20 sins venom was fucking fantastic
Little Insane Moments Venom was by no means fantastic. Horrible writing and The first 30 minutes were boring and useless. But the movie was great and fun to watch. Not fantastic though.
One thing that always annoys me about movies is how nobody ever seems to remember to "stop, drop and roll" when they're on fire.
I don't feel any of this is supernatural. I think the hereditary traits refers to the mental illness that is in the family. Annie's father with lethal depression, the mother's DID and schizophrenia - the brother taking his life when he realized he'd inherited his mother's multiple personalities within himself...Annie's psychotic break comes after finding Charlie's body. To make the gruesome death and her own negligence (no epi-pen, pushing going to the "school party") make "sense" she created a whole delusion of the cult and the creepy needed rituals. Peters break, happening since that dreaded night, peaks at finding his father dead. He becomes enveloped in hallucination, justifying killing his mother and arranging the little sisters beloved tree house to give her life again through sacrificing himself having bought into some of the delusion his mother had been pushing. Authorities would find the bodies, link the deaths and desecration to Peter and he would be locked up in a psych ward for good. Catatonic. My opinion. Alex Wolff is an amazing performer who didn't get near enough credit for his work in this.
3:51 then again, Paimon wants a male vessel. So this may be what he wants to happen.
9:08, the art pieces and dollhouse metaphors are meant to show the concept of things being controlled by an outside force. The picture within a picture could also fit that.
If this film had been not about the supernatural and just a raw representation of what happens when a teenaged boy accidentally gruesomely murders his sister, it would have been WAY creepier. That middle portion had me riveted and super shaken up, but it sort of made me feel better and made me laugh by the near-end and then the actual end I was just entirely confused.
Toni Collettte is brilliant. This film was a missed opportunity to show her talent with more drama and psychological horror.
“Missed”? This is one of the more brilliant horror films of all time. Her talent was put on full display. Not only that, but for this to be Ari Aster’s directorial debut is astounding, not many directors ever first movie was a hit. Only this is beyond a hit, it’s a masterpiece
Lvl. 100 Nut Allergy
Where's your mustache?
3:05 give a sin to CinemaSins for calling Peter Charlie!!
This movies was my second favorite movie of the year behind Infinity War, truthfully, this movie scared the shit outta me couldn’t sleep properly for 3 days after no movie has ever had an effect on me like that it was so damn good
clearly you havent seen spiderman into the spiderverse
2face_gaming that movie isn’t scary.....
@@FloatingkittenUwU infinity war is? Wat?
@@FloatingkittenUwU he's saying it's good 😂 first guy didn't mention it in his fav movies of the year.
Behind what?
i feel sorry for the guy who had to write the obituary
Thank you for acknowledging the allergic reaction as a scary thing itself and talking about the importance of epipens and all that; it doesn't seem like a big deal but for me to hear a mainstream channel addressing this feels really big for me :)
Honestly, everyone was so tense in the cinema watching this. And then during the scenes where Annie is on the ceiling crawling like a crazy person, we all lost it and laughed like mad. It just seemed and looked so ridiculous! One of my best movie experiences tbh
That shit was creepy as hell I still think about that shit lmao
i get that it made a lot of people laugh, but honestly scared the shit out of me
One thing that 100% should've been counted as a sin was that scene where Peter bashed his face against his desk in class and had a whole fucking meltdown, but the fact that he didn't *go to the hospital.* What he did could've 100% been considered a seizure or some shit but all they did was worry about his NOSE?? Even though he was UNCONSCIOUS??? And they had to carry him to his BED????? Ridiculous
You added a sin because she didn't ask anyone if there were nuts in the cake? *WHAT?*
CinemaSins: *Everything Wrong With Hereditary*
*30 mins later*
Me: Sooo... when is the video supposed to start?
You legit point out anything that you can see and say sin, like how is foreshadowing a sin?
Goddess 18 why tho
@@lukeswin117 cus foreshadowing is usually way too obvious and cliché
Leyla Keyne Except almost every time he calls it out it’s not obvious until the end of the film/second watch. and in that case he should say poorly executed foreshadowing not foreshadowing as a whole technique
@@lukeswin117 fair point
lukeswin11 he only did that because he probably didn’t even understand like the concept completely of the movie
In the moment that weird things started happening I would call a priest, especially if I discover that my mother is part of a cult
The "funeral creep" was actually a member of the cult that appeared towards the end of the film, naked in the house.
“Baldness is hereditary" that part made me laugh so hard I stopped being scared for a min
That car scene... awesome 👌👌👌
That American Beauty reference at the end was priceless! :)
One of the best movies of 2018. Its low sin count is proof of that.
Oh, and the ridiculous train of events is why it probably took so long for the plan to work in my opinion. Great video guys!
the dad is a psychologist but doesn't think his son who knocked off his sistes head needs any professional help??? his sat scores are more important. where are the cops? he knocked off his sisters head and drove away. this doesn't warrant a house call? why did they call charlie charlie, and you know not the actual male child born 3 - 4 years earlier? the girl peter likes served NO purpose in the movie. i figure she must be a friend of the director. when the movie has to be explained by the director/writer AFTER it's over that means the movie isnt finished.
Can you do an everything wrong with “Summer Of 84”?
Nightmare Files everything but it’s soundtrack
God I'd love that
Yessss I wanna see that
Too much of an indie film.
@@lh9591 Le Matos killed it like always
The big flaw for me was the mother thinking it was a good idea for her 13 year old to go to a high school party. They should've at least had the son going to a neighbors house or friend's house and then a party happened to be going on
Parents are like that
I found so dumb the way the movie was all the time making Annie "see things" but end up being everything just part of the cult.
The dinner scene where Annie freaked out on Peter made me so mad, like bitch YOU made him take her. Not his fault you used your youngest child to stop your oldest from having fun at a party.
I liked the style and pacing of the movie, the acting was great, especially by Toni Collette. But the thing that made it so insanely unbelievable wasn't the demon, ghosts, or weird cult shit. Is was that a *literal* doctor, Steve was a medical professional, did not make sure everyone carried an epipen on their person at all times. Nor did he make sure that one was in the glove compartment of both cars? What kind of fucking doctor does that? His own child has a deadly nut allergy and what, his family of four has only a single epipen between them all that they apparently constantly misplace? I had a friend in jr high with a deadly nut allergy and each of her TEACHERS had an epipen, but this doctor/father couldn't scrape up an extra one for his wife's car? It was honestly some of the most unbelievable writing I've seen in 30 damn years.
he's a psychiatrist/psychologist, not like a phsysiologist or smth like that.
This is month old comment but like THANK YOU I just watched this recently for the first time and that little bit is the only thing that pisses me off in this movie.
Your child has a very serious allergy and you DON’T make sure she has an epipen on her at all times!? Or at least make sure SOMEBODY has one!? What the fuck kind of shit patenting is that? If it were my kids going out I’d probably ask over 20 times if they had an epipen. That is the only thing that frustrated me the most about this moment.
@@sweetiejunebug4642 Psychiatrist prescribes drugs, btw. Not the same thing.
You have a point, but...
Dumb question: why would you put something that important in a glove box where it could freeze or be badly damaged by heat? :) Doesn't mom have a purse?
Winds of March Journey/Perry tribute band - Epipens do come in carrying cases for things like cars and desks, etc. And since the son was taking his sister out and wouldn’t have a bag of any kind, tossing an epipen in the glove compartment or in his sweater pocket before leaving would’ve just made sense. I honestly think the huge plot hole of a family of four that includes a medical professional only has one epipen that they constantly misplace, has taken the top spot for me on my list of annoying movie things that would never happen in real life lol. It use to be how in SAW a doctor at the top of his field didn’t notice the dead body in the room with him was not in fact dead, but this epipen thing honestly is even more unbelievable to me lmao.
So the cops were never called after the daughter got beheaded. The funeral home didn't think to report or question that the daughter was beheaded?!
Huge plot hole that was left out.
Ok ok, there were some sins I agreed with and some I didnt, but you have to understand, that Charlie... is Paimon. And that blue light thing is Charlie/Paimon.
Also the last sin and the second last sin go hand and hand
The way he cries is killing me lol
This movie fucking terrified me so much lmaoo
Peter's mole deserves five sins, at least.
If someone or some aspect of this movie doesn't get Oscar Noms, I'm coming for the nomination committee's necks. ON GOD
Burnt Nike Sock If Toni Colette doesn’t at least get one, I will shit my pants and throw a fit.
@@Drewbibski we should as a society in rebellion, collectively shit our pants and throw a fit.
Burnt Nike Sock The same with A Star Is Born
I didn't understand this movie when I saw it.
Now I understand it even less!
The best one was “Ahhhh aunt Lydia!” *ding!* Plus “Gabriel Burn” ofcourse! 🔥 😂
unpopular opinion but the part where Peter was screaming "mommy" at the end when she's banging her head against the attic, which lots of people laugh at, is just as visceral as annie crying when Charlie dies. when you're a teen and have graduated to "mom", something has to be SERIOUSLY wrong for you to revert to a child-like state and call your mom "mommy". and his crying during the dinner scene sounds exactly like teenage boys. reverse ding.
Most of these sins had nothing to do with the movie, most of them were things that were referenced you made? This horror movie is one of the best in YEARS! If you’re not really into horror movie don’t review them. You’re not paying attention to context or anything. 🙄
Movies are good or not. So horror is for fans only? I hate horror as a genre for the simple reason that all horror plots are fully driven by stupidity and dumb choices made by characters, I make an exception when films like this one get rave reviews, and it totally absolutely fit into why I don't like horror in general: dumb characters making dumb choices. It has nice cinematography and that's all good I can say about it. It has far less sins than I could see so I guess Jeremy did like the film.
Everyone says toni collette was robbed but she WAS nominated for an oscar just for another film unlike poor gabriel byrne whos NEVER even been nom'd lol
After a thorough search of the comments I’m surprised that nobody (including Jeremy) mentioned the impossibility of have a head cleanly decapitating someone? At how fast Peter was going her head should have been looking like uncooked ground beef instead of looking like it was cut by a chop saw lmao
I know somebody that lost their head in a motorcycle accident but that’s a little different.
Anyone else scroll through the comments while watching?
Maritia Pollard yes because I don’t really like horror movies but I like watching cinemasins and I’m in bed and it’s dark.
send help.
No, now be quiet I’m trying to watch the video 🤫
I feel so called out right now
I am SO glad that he removed so many sins for Toni Collette's acting. She was just PHENOMENAL!
The fact that you guys didn’t remove 500 sins for one of the most flooring death scenes in modern cinema is worth 500 in itself.
This movie is absolutely legendary!
i feel like some sins should have been taken off epically for many of peter and annie's scenes like their acting was AMAZING
Been a horror fan for over 30 years. One of the best horror flicks in the recent past, if ever. As another commenter said, the only sin was Toni Collette not getting an oscar for one of the most intense performace ever seen.
At 3:07 this dude called peter Charlie, that’s a sin right there
I laughed out loud when Peter started crying near the end of the movie. I'm sure that wasn't the message the creators were going for in that scene, but I couldn't help myself.
KC ~ Karyn his cry was hilarious. Made me laugh too.
biggest sin is toni collette not getting nominated for an oscar
That was one of the biggest snubs of this year.
Ally R fact
I can watch her in about anything, and consider her one of the finest actresses going, but the constant screaming and scenery-chewing here is not her finest hour.
@@AdamqK you really wouldn't scream and cry if you saw a child's (and in this case, her daughter's) decapitated head on the ground? You wouldn't go crazy in those situations. She did a very nice job, but of course everyone is entitled to their own opinions, and I respect yours. Have a wonderful day!
@@brodyschum There are five stages of grief. She did one. Throughout the entire film. Surprising for an actress capable of such subtlety, but when you're in a film in which everything comes to screaming (quite literally) halt for a shouting, yelling family therapy session (just when I kept thinking, "Ah, NOW things will start getting interesting") that, I guess, the timbre of things. Have a marvellous day!
you didnt even take a sin of for the amazing acting when Peter just realized he accidently got his sister killed *ding*
Viewers are never right though **Ding**
Did we watch the same performance from the former Naked Brother? An Oscar is not in his future.
He just sat there? How is that good acting LMAOOOOO
@@terrycrews6179 Thats realism. He was in complete shock. How would you react?
Terry Crews that’s how real people act. At least most people. It’s unbelievably common to be pretty much paralyzed in fear after something traumatic.
Yes the 1.5 minutes of crying was a lot but you should have played the sounds Toni Collette was making. She sounded legitimately heartbroken and it made me feel awful inside. She truly nailed it with that scene and I can’t believe you sinned it. *reverse ding*
Saturn crying hysterically after seeing your beheaded daughter in your car is overreacting?
Saturn you are a dumbass
Saturn wow ur so edgy for calling the screams of a heartbroken, grieving mother an overreaction. so badass, dude. also the “hurr durr it’s fiction” excuse doesn’t really work here because, believe it or not, fiction reflects parts of reality! so aside from the demon parts of this film, the dysfunctional family losing a beloved member probably warrants a reaction similar to this.
@@saturn469 watch out dude might cut yourself on all that edge
Saturn get a new shtick lol You weirdos don’t get bored of being anonymously douchey online?
That mother’s scream when she found dead Charlie was 100000000 times scarier than the rest of the exorcist crap
Nigel Fletcher bull. Fucking. SHIIIIT
Nigel Fletcher beautiful acting bro, also the mom in the top corner or the ant was the scariest part for me
Not a chance.
Hard disagree. I didn't have to cover my face with a pillow when she screamed. The other stuff, however...
Agreed. That was borderline traumatic she sounded so excruciating
You didn’t remove a sin for the camera’s zoom in on Peter’s gut wrenching expression after Charlie is decapitated. That was a brilliant scene
People really look and act like that in real life after they witness something mind breaking like that, iv seen it happen, its quite horrible and i think thats why that scene was so powerful, its just feels real.
@@sparkonyx1075 very real. Great acting throughout this movie.
RuleofVicus Can you please go ahead and give examples?
RuleofVicus This movie was incredible.
@RuleofVicus I mean at least that scene in particular was unique i dont think i can name another movie that portrayed traumatic shock like that, otherwise 90 % of people in the comments wouldnt be mentioning that scene.
I’m taking away the sin for the 1.5 minutes of crying. That was actually heartbreaking and made my cold dead heart feel something.
It was so unsettling. A lot of this movie was actually super disturbing and it shook me.
The first time I saw this the scene felt like it lasted forever. I’m usually not bothered by horror movies, but this almost made me leave the theater. So good, but so hard to watch.
it’s not even heartbreaking, it’s funny
@@saturn469 Careful you might cut yourself on that edge
I cried so much :(
It broke my heart when Peter was screaming “Please Mommy!” Over and over.
it's almost like all of us can relate to him in that moment. It feels too real
I laughed my ass off
@@demonicoymonstruoso wow so edgy and cool
@@yagirl177 It blows my mind how people can find that scene funny. Peter has literally been through the most ungodly emotional shit after Charlie dying, seeing his dad's burnt corpse, and his possessed mother chasing him. No wonder his mind was fucked and for a moment it was that of a child's calling for his mother as a last resort.
I can see it but he went through the worst shit he could’ve so not funny just sad
5:30 no mention of that "next morning" scene, that scene turned my stomach in so many ways...the way it was done, the acting from the son, realising what he's done and just waiting in horror for the moment when his actions are discovered, that absolutely raw emotion of the mom screaming/crying...just...DAMN!
Exactly. The dread and shock on Peter's face after "it" happens was crazy. When he tries to make himself look in the rearview mirror but couldn't.
TheDRMISTERY Yeah, I think the commenter meant that it should have just been noted or even had a sin removed.
@@mochabearry yeeap. I mean he DID remove a sin earlier for the moms acting but god damn, that scene and the acting of everyone in it (even the father tbh) just COMPLETELY sold it, 100 sins removed worthy for sure.
this movie was too perfect
Stopped watching after that.
Charlie's Head: Aight, imma head out
pun intended?
“Head out” HAH
@@kaitlynlozano5104 didn't even realize there was an subtle pun there, yes now that is le pun
Saw that scene coming from miles away
Curtis Kumfer Obvislee Charlie dod not see that pole from miles away
I think I was actually red faced pissed when I first watched the movie and she sent her young daughter with her high school son to a high school party. I blame her really.
Same, at least partially. That's why at the dinner scene she gets up to leave when Peter mentions that. She knows she was at fault too.
I cant imagine a teen boy not arguing really against taking his 13 year old sister to a party where he wanted to hook up and get high. If they were closer in age, maybe. Charlie was so so young and backwards. Any teen boy would argue, and I think even Charlie would fight harder to not go.
I'm a huge fan of this film and I know that Peter told Annie he was going to a BBQ get together for school kids. So...idk.
Well, it’s likely that the demon forced her to do that.
SAME!
A lot of cheap sins here. You know this movie was legendary
@@billie3752 name a better horror movie from the last 20 years. No bullshit
@@billie3752 Yeah, I knew you were delusional
@@diogocosta238 the American funny games, saw, Frankensteins army was fun
Horror movies have been on the decline tho
And hereditary is evidence of that; it's a good horror movie(6.5/10 I'd say) but everyone's praising it bc there hasnt really been anything amazing recently
@@billie3752 I don't agree. I think Hereditary is so good that it could stand as a normal movie (no horror) on it's own because of its acting
@@diogocosta238 yeah Toni's acting was phenomenal
Paimon had been in Charlie since she was a baby nursed nursed by her grandmother, which is why she had the “cluck” compulsion and was always building her “toys” with empty pill bottles and bird heads (because putting a head on a new body is basically what Paimon does - like the mannequin with Charlie’s head in the treehouse). Before Charlie, the grandmother had tried to put Paimon into her own son, Annie’s brother Charles, but he mistook the voice of Paimon as schizophrenia and killed himself. After Charlie’s death, Paimon sort of hangs out haunting Peter, but Peter’s too strong for a direct possession (“Peter! GET OUT!”) , so he arranges for the dad to die in front of Annie so that she is finally weak enough to possess. It is seeing his father burned and his mother decapitate herself that traumatized him enough to throw himself from the attic window, and as his soul leaves his body Paimon is finally able to take it for himself.
Meredith Hagan I totally agree for the most part, but one pedantic thing I’d say is that Annie’s brother was definitely aware of what his mum was doing, explaining the “putting people inside of him” group therapy comment, but was perhaps recognised as being schizophrenic, thus dismissed by other people when in reality he was begging for help.
Good. But is there a reason why you commented this? You wanted people to know how well you've understood the movie or something?
Going into depth like this makes me want a prequel
Swachchhanda Dahal It’s called “expressing your opinion” which is kinda the purpose behind the TH-cam comment section
My apologies.. I didn't realize she is actually expressing her opinion about the flaws in the movie..
Everything wrong with hereditary: *The fact that Toni Colette didn’t get an Oscar*
Toni Colette was great in this movie. She was also good in "In her shoes" and "Little miss sunshine", she's very convincing actress.
Or at least get nominated
@@JohnMarston1900 yeah
Oscars are bs tho
the oscar don't like horror movies
Sister? Dead
Cult? Controlling
Friends? Fake
god?in need of vessel
Son?Possessed
Hotel?Trivago
Lmfaoo nice XD
💀🤣🤣🤣
Dick? Out
Grape?Surgery
Movie?Sinned
The actors in this movie did great tho u got to admit it
No just no....😠😠
@@lisatrappedmeinygsbasement848 lmao it was some of the best acting of 2018 which other movie had better acting?
yeah they did.
XXX the only bad acting if you could call it “bad” was Peter’s crying in some scenes that’s it
Fat Pie Wolff was great when he realized he killed his sister
The moment when he was driving fast and his little sisters head got knocked off by the pole,and he’s just sittin there wanting to look but NOT WANTING TO at the same time is one of the most chilling moments in movies of 2018 hands down👏🏾👏🏾
Definitely. I felt like my breathing and my heart stopped at that moment waiting to see what he would do.
I think i was never shocked more by a movie😱
@chrissy christoff Cause maybe "liveleak" stuff is real shit and this is just fiction and not real. Ever think of that?
I totally would have taken a sin off for that.
@chrissy christoff because is fiction? come on in other times it was a show to go see real people kill each other, being decapitated, hung, etc. Those were some more violent times, nothing compared with these actual days
Everybody is saying that Charlie should have known better to ask about nuts. The girl did not say a total of 20 words in the whole movie and probably had terrible social anxiety; I highly doubt she would have asked. And it is also clearly set up that she loves chocolate so much that she often forgets to even check if there is nuts in her chocolate bars.
Carson Wilson also since she’d basically BEEN the spirit of Paimon since birth, charlie has no real identity. why would she stop herself from what Paimon and the cult had been planning all along? sure she was struggling when she was choking but that’s pretty much a human instinct- but I don’t think she had a soul so could not protect herself from danger in that way
@Frisbee 'n' Cookies In a different comment section someone explained that Paimon can possess others when they are about to die, or when they are mentally broken. For instance, the mother in the film claims she gave Charlie when she was a baby to the grandma, so she would feed her. The grandmother, had already tried putting Paimons spirit in her son and husband, so she starved baby Charlie to the point of almost dying, so that Paimon could take over. Charlie was long dead.. Its just that the demon prefers a male body (god, knows why) that this whole movie took place
Carson Wilson and she was possessed by a demon
She didnt have an allergy u see her eat nuts. It was just a device to kill the girl
She was eating Penut M&M's when she was busy building her creepy toys in the bedroom
Peter didn’t get possessed cause the mom didn’t let the grandma in his early life smh y’all pay attention
True but, with the far reach of the cult, it's strange it took thirteen years to get back to Peter
@@kingayy9267 they all tried. Joan's son AND grandson DIED too 😉😉
And that actually works for you?! It's a spirit for God's sake!
@@Spaceysgurl no paimon needs the human host to be someone in leigh's bloodline aka annie charlie or peter (with peter being ideal bc he's male) so the cult wouldn't have used any other members families. i'd assume joan was most likely lying about her son and grandson just to get annie to do the seance - in the scene just before it when annie runs into her in the car park you can see in her car boot she's just bought a chalk board like the one the grandson writes on, suggesting the seance was fake
@@kingayy9267 since I saw the movie, I investigated more about Paimond, his favorite hosts are teenage males, but he takes females when he's in a really weak state. And Paimond didn't get inside Peter directly when Charlie died 'cause he needs a Queen to guide him to male bodies. So, Ellen get possessed by Paimond and transfered to Charlie (feeding her) but when Charlie died he stayed like in a "Limbo", so when Annie was her weakest mentally point she get possessed, so Annie could torment her own child, so he can go really mentally insane and get possessed by Paimond. That's what actually Ellen did with Annie's brother, she tormented him enough to get possessed but she went too far and he committed suicide. I wish I explained it clear, sorry my English
I’m watching this because I’m too scared to watch the actual movie
Tayla good call. This movie gave me a couple of sleepless nights.
Adriana Ramirez Davila same
It's really not that scary. The movie's boring mostly for the first hour and a half, and the last 30 minutes are laughably dumb.
It’s fucked up, watched it today and nearly died
@@rpsyco I agree.
Reverse sins should've been given with Peter's scenes in the classroom. Seeing his reflection smiling at him evily, and especially the possession scene were both fucking terrifying!
And the fact that the actor for Peter actually slammed his head on that desk! Amazing dedication should of been recognized 😩
I wanted 5 sins removed for the decapitation scene. 1 for Alex Wolff's ptsd, 1 for Toni Collette's shrieking, 1 for Gabriel Byrne's silent coping while trying to help his wife, and 2 for Ari Aster's balls for killing Charlie so horrifically and then showing her MANGLED, DECAPITATED HEAD crawling with ants.
Fucking awesome film.
Fuckin 20 should’ve been taken off for her crying after the death. That was some of the best acting of the year
No you
If you didn’t think The Witch or Heredetary were top tier modern horror movies, what DO you consider to be good examples of modern horror?
Brenden A. Baughman I really like hereditary but wasn’t a huge fan of the witch. Idk if you’d quite consider it “horror” per se but I think Us was a damn near perfect movie
No you if you enjoyed get out you’ll probably have a good time with Us
He did take 3 sleeping pills so, that’s probably why he didn’t wake up.
It's frustrating watching these vids and seeing something clocked just because the viewer didn't understand. But like, the clip of him downing 3 pills even plays in this vid, they're asking things and also playing the answer for it XD
Dan Williams yes it’s concluded in this video but he adds a sin for him not waking up during the scene where he’s sleeping. It’s not unreasonable that someone wouldn’t wake up from noise after taking three sleeping pills.
@@allismiff whyd you type that? you are saying the same thing he just did
ytu
If everyone asks for Bird Box to be sinned, he will do it.
I kinda wanna see that sinned, how about you?
I want to sin in a camel's butt
@@Mo-wi8go do you believe in and support Sharia Law? or are you intelligent?
@@douglasmcdonald6967 I just like to throw rocks
Overrated movie, it doesnt need any more attention so I hope they never do it.
I’d like to see birdboxed sinned. Overrated as hell
9:16 there are some theories that the whole movie takes place in one of Annie's miniatures, and that could be the glare from the magnifying class she has.
Yeah that’s one of the worst theories for this movie
@@BradySchall then name a better one
@@azurdlywisterious My opinion is the whole film is shown as a dollhouse because it's clear that Annie uses the doll houses as a way to "take control" of situations in her life, just like how the cult and King Paimon is constantly taking control of their lives. It wouldn't be surprising if the magnifying glass motif is used but instead of Annie's magnifying glass it's King Paimons as he moves the chess pieces to enact his plan to get put into Peter's body.
i think the doll house serves more like a symbolism of how the whole family is just a pawn of Paimon
@@azurdlywisterious there are several grounded theories about the light being a symbol for paimon guiding people to where he wants them
Toni Collette's extraordinary performance makes up for at least 80 sins
@@Mo-wi8go Dude what?
@Muhammad. Idiot
@MadelineTopper That's a stretch
Cam defiantly deserves a nomination.
I'm not familiar with the "child in a horror film that has an allergy that will factor in the plot later" cliche.
The Culkin kid in _Signs_ has asthma and the little sister has OCD. That's just one movie I can recall though
Yeah, it stood out as unique to me. I’ve never seen realistic deathly allergies in another movie, now that I think about it.
There are quite a few.
@@JustKelso1993 Yes! Even I can remember watching at least 2 horror films that have kids with allergies, but I barely remember what they are. That's why I'm unsure if it can be classified as cliche, or just a plot device.
@@Tartharus Fair. Probably more of a plot device but a very cliche one lol
The scene when she bangs her head against the attic door is super super SUPER creepy 😰
It is very fucking creepy.
I had nightmares for days after seeing that
@@deathbystars4999 yeah... and The sound starts before you know what it is .. I thought she was hitting the door with something..but not her freaking head😆
@@bangtanlove6811 What I didn't understand was why did the possessed mom just go and close the damn attic door?
cyber girl 83 same! How inhumanly fast she does it is so terrifying