My father taught me this song as a child. It is how he showed me that all humans are God's children. Wish we could make all of America listen today. *sending out love to anyone reading*
It is the prime motivator for Farcical Opinionated Xenophobic noise to keep their audience base of ignoramuses attuned. They think Fox's Alt-Right Taint, [or F.AR.T. for short...as presented daily by tucker and friends]...1 in 8 Americans of voting age choose F.O.X.'s F.A.R.T.s daily and are 12% of the country's source of common scents...albeit flammable. (see El Paso)
While beautifully composed, this remains one of the most TERRIFYINGLY ACCURATE songs ever written. "Carefully Taught" is a great moral warning either on its own or as part of the total South Pacific musical.
YES WATCH THE WHOLE PLAY AND THE SONG COMES INTO CONTEXT BECAUSE HE FALLS IN LOVE WITH AN ASIAN WOMAN. MANY VIET NAM SOLDIERS HAD VIET NAM KIDS! IT ALL COMES WITH THE YEARS AND THE TERRITOY OF GUYS MESSING WITH WOMEN AND IT HAPPENED. REALLY MADE ME CRY. WATCH IT. HIGH SCHOOLS WOULD PUT ON THAT PLAY TO MAKE MONEY FOR THE PROM NIGHT BACK IN THE DAY.
@@johnsmith1474 The ideas expressed in the song, though, are true now. And were true 700 years ago. And were probably true 70,000 years ago. The thought is timeless.
Oh, thank you, Mandy! I am sobbing right now. How did this country, this world, become so divisive? The words to both these songs are so relevant, now more than ever. I never thought, in my lifetime, that hatred would still be tolerated. Bless you!
This song was written in 1953. Therefore things haven't "become divisive" they WERE divided from day one and as a matter of fact are far less divided today. Your instincts are horribly clueless & distorted.
@@johnsmith1474 I agree to disagree. South Pacific opened in 1949, just after WWII, so I know the world was split apart. R & H had to fight to keep this song in the show. Yes, there has always been hate and division, and we could argue whether there is more or less, now. Your last sentence is insulting.
I have tried to teach my children to question what they hear and to think for themselves. Only time will tell if a few children or maybe grandchildren, can save us from repeating, over and over again the mistakes of our past. I do not think that God can help us. I think that we need to help ourselves.
Whether you are atheist or believer, you are responsible for your actions and change. To expect god (whatever you perceive god to be) to do it for you is abrogating your responsibility as a human being. I am an agnostic - I just don't know. But I do know hate is learned!
I HAVE BEEN THROUGH SO MUCH SINCE MY EARLY YEARS AND CAN STILL REMEMBER ALL OF IT. I HAD A BLACK BOYFRIEND WHEN I HAD AN OPERATION IN THE NYC HOSPITAL . I FORGOT HIS NAME BUT IF I REALLY THOUGHT BACK I WOULD REMEMBER. I WAS 10 HE WAS TEN. WE WERE BOTH STUCK ON THE SAME FLOOR AND HE HAD THE BED NEXT TO MINE. ANY WAY WE HAD A BLACK MAID ELIZABETH AND EVE MY FRIEND HAD A BLACK MAID NAMED MARY . EVE'S MOTHER WORKED AND SO DID MINE. ALL THE OLDER SIBLINGS WERE AT THEIR JOBS OR IN THE NAVY. THE MAIDS WOULD COOK ,CLEAN AND DO THE WASH. WHEN I WAS A TEENAGER MY NEXT DOOR NEIGHBOR WAS REALLY COOL. AND HE WAS BLACK. WE WOULD HANG OUT ALL THE TIME TOGETHER. I REALLY MISS MARVIN GAYE. I'M GOING TO LISTEBN TO HIM NOW.
I only recognized this man from Criminal Minds but I listened to Sunday in the Park with George for so long. And now he’s on social media lowkey popular again but like... omg i love him 100% more after making the vocal connection. Also love that he sang Children will Listen, a song Bernadette Peters also sang :) amazing.
On June 12, 2016, the day of the Orlando, FL massacre, I listened to this beautiful rendition by Mandy Patinkin. Today I post it on my Facebook page and hope it gives a message and heart to all! Thank you for posting!
Susan Wallace YES!! I heard it for THE VERY FIRST TIME LAST NIGHT!! (04/18/2018), the original version, and it chilled me to the bone! The idea of the song sounds as if yes, this is how racism was taught to the very young. The children listen, as well as watvh and pick up on how their parents and other relatives react to and treat people that are different from them, and follow suit
I was raised in a Chicago immigrant family. The culture was racist. I was racist until I saw South Pacific when I was in high school. That movie changed my life. I wanted the adventure, travel, romance the movie portrayed. I joined the Air Force and chose Asia as my duty station. I had to go to the islands. I had to see that world. And I lived that movie. I visited the islands, had the adventures, met the wacky people in the military, and remembered this song when I met the locals. My friends considered them "slopes" and other racist names and it always pissed me off. After the Air Force, I tried to go back to my old life, but it was impossible. I backpacked around the world until I met my "Liat". A Tonkinese. The same people I fought. The song is right on. The biases I met were as strong against my race as my buddies were against them and they were all "carefully taught" as children. It is getting worse.
Children WILL listen! Rogers and Hammerstein emphasized this first in 1949 with "You've Got To Be Carefully Taught" from the original Broadway musical "South Pacific." This combination of two very important songs addressed these issues ... the problem is "Parent's Don't Listen." How can they? They listened to their own prejudiced parents....And we wonder what provokes "Bullying'!
Andy, you are so Right. I only looked up this song because Sen.Blumenthal mentioned it on C-Span During House meeting on Hate Crimes juice department Eric Treene.
kathleen knight - no, this is the dark side of humanity, has always existed, "original sin" so to speak. "As we know better, we can do better" Maya Anjelou
South Pacific the motion picture, a musical, taught acceptance in a time where the world had been very stired up by thousands of GI's taking home brides of every nationality.
You've got to be taught To hate and fear, You've got to be taught From year to year, It's got to be drummed In your dear little ear You've got to be carefully taught. You've got to be taught to be afraid Of people whose eyes are oddly made, And people whose skin is a diff'rent shade, You've got to be carefully taught.You've got to be taught before it's too late, Before you are six or seven or eight, To hate all the people your relatives hate, You've got to be carefully taught!
Both songs are so poignant today. Children Will Listen from Stephen Sondheim's Into The Woods has a special place and truth for me. I was privileged enough to be in the production in community theater and (as part of the ensemble) sang that song. The entire play is all about overcoming fear and doing what's right. It was a sentimental treat to find this beautiful performance.
It's so true. Unfortunately we're still in a period of transition where our intellect and our inventiveness are being held back by our animal instincts. We humans are social animals and social animals rely on their immediate group for protection and companionship. Anything that approaches that group - including a strange member of the same species - is perceived as a threat and either chased away or killed. So humans are still doing exactly the same thing as every other herd animal on this planet has done for millennia - terrified of "them", whoever "they" might be and therefore trying to ensure that "they" are shunned and segregated. Given enough time, we may achieve a balance and eventually our better impulses will win - but we may not have that much time left.
I NEVER KNEW MANDY POTAMKIN COULD SING SO BEAUTIFULLY. THAT WAS EXCEPTIONAL! SHIT YEAH. DID ANYBODY GET IT? THIS WAS FROM THE YEAR I WAS BORN 1958 FROM THE PLAY SOUTH PACIFIC.
Mandy Patinkin is a fine actor and singer. He was great in DAED LIKE ME. Wished he had done the role of ARTIE in WAREHOUSE 13 . Had been interestiing - maybe in a REMAKE?
Charles Barrett - because it sheds light onto the darkness inherent in our nature, where few are brave enough to look at their reflection in broken mirrors
Years ago, I needed a job..I had newly arrived in Athens, Greece at the end of August, to 'finish a dream' ... the only position I could find at that late date, was in a private school...not far from where I was staying....it was owned and operated by a group of Palestinians...I hesitated for a minute but said to myself - 'the students are kids...they need an education. I'm a teacher, I needed a job.' well, the kids were just wonderful... I was assigned as the 3rd grade 'homeroom' teacher and also the 11th and 12 grade Science teacher. I was only there a few days when I realized that these kids were 'being carefully taught to hate' by their parents. It was a sad lesson to learn. I did my best to help change minds...I may have succeeded in 25% of my students. None knew that I was 'one of the tribe' that they thought they hated....I never told them either...just showed lots of love and caring. what an experience it was..... i could write a book about my two years there....
I wanted to let you know I don't have sound for this video. I've just played another video and went back to this one and so I know it's not a browser issue.
Now more than ever."O ye recipients of the favours of God! In this new and wondrous Age, the unshakeable foundation is the teaching of sciences and arts. According to explicit Holy Texts, every child must be taught crafts and arts, to the degree that is needful. Wherefore, in every city and village, schools must be established and every child in that city or village is to engage in study to the necessary degree." -'Abdu'l-Bahá
@@juliebiddle1636 date of this song is the 1940s during the USA Pacific War towards the end of World War 2,,,after Pearl Harbour,,,in the musical “South Pacific” the song describes how our white christian society teaches racism and hate,,,the white singer is in love with a girl from the Pacific islands,,,he is stating that hate and racism are “carefully taught when you are 6 or 7 or 8,,,,,and why is our society like this. He is calling out the teaching of this as evil. Love is love. Live and let live.
As an American Jew, I always thought of this as a cautionary song; now I think other groups hear the same words and use them as inspiration in training their children to hate me & my people 😢
To each his own, of course. But as I noted elsewhere, during the time he starred in multiple Broadway shows, he was considered one of, if not the, greatest male talent of our generation. Yes, he has a very unique style, so I understand why you said what you did, but what you might consider over the top, I (and many others) find extraordinarily emotionally moving.
+tomaf Some churches don't applause after a performance. I think it may have something to do with the fact that the person is honoring God and to clap would indicate that the performance was to please the people. I don't quite get it myself. From personal experience, usually, people just say "amen" quietly if the performance was good, but nobody did, so maybe this was a funeral or something.
Reading that the father of the murderer at the school in the Texas high school in May of 2018 is both Pro-Trump and Pro-NRA and left his guns available from his son to use - this medley tells a lot.
In USA 2023, with the sanctioned rise of HATE Made Normal, triggered through the ideological values of certain politicals: this has sadly become even 'more' relevant! 😪❤🩹💙 'Carefully Taught' from Rogers and Hammerstein's '1949'!! lyrics in musical South Pacific.
Simply unbearable. The wobbly vibrato. The whining tone. The over-the-top, whimpering sentimentality. What became of "Sunday in the Park with George's" Seurat? Please, Mandy, for your own good and ours, give up singing.
![🎤 ไปกันต่อออ! จับฉลากร้องเพลง x P’ #XXSIVK [EP.2] (1/2) เพลงของใครจึ้งสุดน้าา 💓🎤 #MXFRUIT](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mLI_K0sAS4o/mqdefault.jpg)
My father taught me this song as a child. It is how he showed me that all humans are God's children. Wish we could make all of America listen today. *sending out love to anyone reading*
Boy, do we need everyone to listen to this more than ever.
Mine too.... I was blessed....
my grandmother taught it to me. I listened.
mine too. the greatest generation.
How lovely. You had a good father. Love back to you❤
Okay mixing South Pacific and Into The Woods together was such a brilliant idea. And he sings so beautifully.
This needs to be aired on prime time regularly; I think people have forgotten the message.
It is the prime motivator for Farcical Opinionated Xenophobic noise to keep their audience base of ignoramuses attuned. They think Fox's Alt-Right Taint, [or F.AR.T. for short...as presented daily by tucker and friends]...1 in 8 Americans of voting age choose F.O.X.'s F.A.R.T.s daily and are 12% of the country's source of common scents...albeit flammable. (see El Paso)
While beautifully composed, this remains one of the most TERRIFYINGLY ACCURATE songs ever written. "Carefully Taught" is a great moral warning either on its own or as part of the total South Pacific musical.
Agreed. It's such and accurate observation of bigotry.
I remember it from my childhood. I just introduced my daughter to it. She is a teacher and was saying that her students are so free and loving.
It rings true today, August 2020
South Pacific opened in 1949. WWII was still very fresh in people's minds. More than 65 years and we still have not learned its lesson.
YES WATCH THE WHOLE PLAY AND THE SONG COMES INTO CONTEXT BECAUSE HE FALLS IN LOVE WITH AN ASIAN WOMAN. MANY VIET NAM SOLDIERS HAD VIET NAM KIDS! IT ALL COMES WITH THE YEARS AND THE TERRITOY OF GUYS MESSING WITH WOMEN AND IT HAPPENED. REALLY MADE ME CRY. WATCH IT. HIGH SCHOOLS WOULD PUT ON THAT PLAY TO MAKE MONEY FOR THE PROM NIGHT BACK IN THE DAY.
This is a cautionary tale of our lives today, in 2020.
And now in 2023..I love this song.
He IS PRAYYYYYYIN WHILE SINGING THIS! BEAUTIFUL!
Absolute perfection - a performance full of artistry and humanity. What a uniquely talented artist he is!
A beautiful voice singing a very important message for our times.
The song is 70 years old.
@@johnsmith1474 The ideas expressed in the song, though, are true now. And were true 700 years ago. And were probably true 70,000 years ago. The thought is timeless.
@@johnsmith1474 Yes, and it's a shame that we are back in those times again. You never learn.
Da-damn... these songs are perfect together. Even more perfect with Mandy singing them
We need to hear this as much today, as ever
This is exactly why I found myself in tears listening to this video!!
Absolutely! What is being done to children today, is horrible. This song needs to be played.
Oh, thank you, Mandy! I am sobbing right now. How did this country, this world, become so divisive? The words to both these songs are so relevant, now more than ever. I never thought, in my lifetime, that hatred would still be tolerated. Bless you!
This song was written in 1953. Therefore things haven't "become divisive" they WERE divided from day one and as a matter of fact are far less divided today. Your instincts are horribly clueless & distorted.
@@johnsmith1474 I agree to disagree. South Pacific opened in 1949, just after WWII, so I know the world was split apart. R & H had to fight to keep this song in the show. Yes, there has always been hate and division, and we could argue whether there is more or less, now. Your last sentence is insulting.
What a spellbinding rendition. A glorious voice.
Saw him sing this in Lawrence, KS, April 1, 2024.
Mandy, you can make anything at all sound so beautiful!
More relevant now than ever. Thank you Mandy...
I have tried to teach my children to question what they hear and to think for themselves. Only time will tell if a few children or maybe grandchildren, can save us from repeating, over and over again the mistakes of our past. I do not think that God can help us. I think that we need to help ourselves.
Whether you are atheist or believer, you are responsible for your actions and change. To expect god (whatever you perceive god to be) to do it for you is abrogating your responsibility as a human being.
I am an agnostic - I just don't know. But I do know hate is learned!
@@morganrobinson3066 ??????
@@josephhapp9 HATE IS LEARNED WHY THE QUESTION MARKS!
I HAVE BEEN THROUGH SO MUCH SINCE MY EARLY YEARS AND CAN STILL REMEMBER ALL OF IT. I HAD A BLACK BOYFRIEND WHEN I HAD AN OPERATION IN THE NYC HOSPITAL . I FORGOT HIS NAME BUT IF I REALLY THOUGHT BACK I WOULD REMEMBER. I WAS 10 HE WAS TEN. WE WERE BOTH STUCK ON THE SAME FLOOR AND HE HAD THE BED NEXT TO MINE. ANY WAY WE HAD A BLACK MAID ELIZABETH AND EVE MY FRIEND HAD A BLACK MAID NAMED MARY . EVE'S MOTHER WORKED AND SO DID MINE. ALL THE OLDER SIBLINGS WERE AT THEIR JOBS OR IN THE NAVY. THE MAIDS WOULD COOK ,CLEAN AND DO THE WASH. WHEN I WAS A TEENAGER MY NEXT DOOR NEIGHBOR WAS REALLY COOL. AND HE WAS BLACK. WE WOULD HANG OUT ALL THE TIME TOGETHER. I REALLY MISS MARVIN GAYE. I'M GOING TO LISTEBN TO HIM NOW.
I only recognized this man from Criminal Minds but I listened to Sunday in the Park with George for so long. And now he’s on social media lowkey popular again but like... omg i love him 100% more after making the vocal connection. Also love that he sang Children will Listen, a song Bernadette Peters also sang :) amazing.
On June 12, 2016, the day of the Orlando, FL massacre, I listened to this beautiful rendition by Mandy Patinkin. Today I post it on my Facebook page and hope it gives a message and heart to all! Thank you for posting!
I did too. Good for you,.
Susan Wallace YES!! I heard it for THE VERY FIRST TIME LAST NIGHT!! (04/18/2018), the original version, and it chilled me to the bone! The idea of the song sounds as if yes, this is how racism was taught to the very young. The children listen, as well as watvh and pick up on how their parents and other relatives react to and treat people that are different from them, and follow suit
could not be more timely.. These songs keep playing in my head, during these times.
I was raised in a Chicago immigrant family. The culture was racist. I was racist until I saw South Pacific when I was in high school. That movie changed my life. I wanted the adventure, travel, romance the movie portrayed. I joined the Air Force and chose Asia as my duty station. I had to go to the islands. I had to see that world. And I lived that movie. I visited the islands, had the adventures, met the wacky people in the military, and remembered this song when I met the locals. My friends considered them "slopes" and other racist names and it always pissed me off. After the Air Force, I tried to go back to my old life, but it was impossible. I backpacked around the world until I met my "Liat". A Tonkinese. The same people I fought. The song is right on. The biases I met were as strong against my race as my buddies were against them and they were all "carefully taught" as children. It is getting worse.
Just shared this on my Facebook page after the horrific events in Charlottesville this past weekend.
Ground Hog Day - I shared it on FB in June, 2020
Children WILL listen! Rogers and Hammerstein emphasized this first in 1949 with "You've Got To Be Carefully Taught" from the original Broadway musical "South Pacific." This combination of two very important songs addressed these issues ... the problem is "Parent's Don't Listen." How can they? They listened to their own prejudiced parents....And we wonder what provokes "Bullying'!
Andy, you are so Right. I only looked up this song because Sen.Blumenthal mentioned it on C-Span During House meeting on Hate Crimes juice department Eric Treene.
Andy Schwartz - send your comment to Melania Trump please
.So far ahead of it's time (and not played in some theaters).....we are still trying to learn.
kathleen knight - no, this is the dark side of humanity, has always existed, "original sin" so to speak. "As we know better, we can do better" Maya Anjelou
South Pacific the motion picture, a musical, taught acceptance in a time where the world had been very stired up by thousands of GI's taking home brides of every nationality.
You've got to be taught
To hate and fear,
You've got to be taught
From year to year,
It's got to be drummed
In your dear little ear
You've got to be carefully taught.
You've got to be taught to be afraid
Of people whose eyes are oddly made,
And people whose skin is a diff'rent shade,
You've got to be carefully taught.You've got to be taught before it's too late,
Before you are six or seven or eight,
To hate all the people your relatives hate,
You've got to be carefully taught!
🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
I sang Carefully Taught to my children when they were small. Great rendition.
Perfect timing! Our priest such mentioned this very song and selected words in his homily Saturday night.
Ruth Niemaseck
While my favorite “voice” is baritone, Mandy Patinkin is a treasure in every sense of the word.
I never heard this version and I've never heard Mandy sing. It's a song I hear in my head. I'm going to find the full version before I sing it again.
This comes from “South Pacific” by Rodgers and Hammerstein ,,,it will be in the full score with the dialogue cue in.
Two of my favorites. My parents were good role models.
Both songs are so poignant today. Children Will Listen from Stephen Sondheim's Into The Woods has a special place and truth for me. I was privileged enough to be in the production in community theater and (as part of the ensemble) sang that song. The entire play is all about overcoming fear and doing what's right. It was a sentimental treat to find this beautiful performance.
What a pity this brilliant performance is lost on 37 people.
This is why I love this man!
So appropriate today.
:'( heartbreakingly beautiful
Gives me the shivers.
I know that's right!
so moving and true
Love him & love that he sang one of the best songs ever
It's so true. Unfortunately we're still in a period of transition where our intellect and our inventiveness are being held back by our animal instincts. We humans are social animals and social animals rely on their immediate group for protection and companionship. Anything that approaches that group - including a strange member of the same species - is perceived as a threat and either chased away or killed. So humans are still doing exactly the same thing as every other herd animal on this planet has done for millennia - terrified of "them", whoever "they" might be and therefore trying to ensure that "they" are shunned and segregated. Given enough time, we may achieve a balance and eventually our better impulses will win - but we may not have that much time left.
The world needs this today.
He just sang it again on his channel. It is a wonderful rendition.
I am posting this on my FB page in light of Baton Rouge and Minn....
It is August 16, 2017 and these songs are more powerful than ever.
What a beautiful, moving performance. I love Mandy’s voice!
Love, Blessings, eyes to see, ears to hear, hands to fold in prayer and quietness of mind, sincerity of your best heart, to ALL! Terri s.
I NEVER KNEW MANDY POTAMKIN COULD SING SO BEAUTIFULLY. THAT WAS EXCEPTIONAL! SHIT YEAH. DID ANYBODY GET IT? THIS WAS FROM THE YEAR I WAS BORN 1958 FROM THE PLAY SOUTH PACIFIC.
He made a beautiful recording of South Pacific with Jose Carerras and Kiri Te Kanawa,
He has a channel. He just sang it again. It's still as beautiful.
Adding it to my Facebook after Dallas.
As beautiful as always, more timely than ever.
Great words to live by. Wonderful performance.
Mandy Patinkin is a fine actor and singer. He was great in DAED LIKE ME. Wished he had done the role of ARTIE in WAREHOUSE 13 . Had been interestiing - maybe in a REMAKE?
Enduring truth expressed in song.
Why is it heard so seldom?
Charles Barrett - because it sheds light onto the darkness inherent in our nature, where few are brave enough to look at their reflection in broken mirrors
Reposted 11/10/16. More careful now than ever.
Thank you, Mandy.
Years ago, I needed a job..I had newly arrived in Athens, Greece at the end of August, to 'finish a dream' ... the only position I could find at that late date, was in a private school...not far from where I was staying....it was owned and operated by a group of Palestinians...I hesitated for a minute but said to myself - 'the students are kids...they need an education. I'm a teacher, I needed a job.' well, the kids were just wonderful... I was assigned as the 3rd grade 'homeroom' teacher and also the 11th and 12 grade Science teacher. I was only there a few days when I realized that these kids were 'being carefully taught to hate' by their parents. It was a sad lesson to learn. I did my best to help change minds...I may have succeeded in 25% of my students. None knew that I was 'one of the tribe' that they thought they hated....I never told them either...just showed lots of love and caring. what an experience it was..... i could write a book about my two years there....
Mandy: “To learn how to Be”
Me: chills
I hope someone explained this song to the kids because kids may take things literally. 😊
Janae Clarice - this is not a song for kids but for adults so they don't f##k up their kids.
Timeless.
Magnificent ❣️❣️❣️❣️
I love his voice so much. He brings such emotion and meaning to the lyrics. Do you have a better copy?
Rodger’s and Hammerstein had the guts in the 50’ to include songs like this and Old Man River in their musicals. These songs were very controversial.
Great !!!
Hamilton fans: ...if you talk, you're gonna get SHOT!
Actual South Pacific fans: ...WOW THIS SONG IS TRUE!!!!!
Please listen
Here in October 2023 thinking we are living in some alternate universe
👏👏👏👏👏💕
I wish he would perform this dressed as his character from Alien Nation.
I wanted to let you know I don't have sound for this video. I've just played another video and went back to this one and so I know it's not a browser issue.
Any idea why I there is no sound on this? I've played others on here, but this one doesn't have sound
Now more than ever."O ye recipients of the favours of God! In this new and wondrous Age, the unshakeable foundation is the teaching of sciences and arts. According to explicit Holy Texts, every child must be taught crafts and arts, to the degree that is needful. Wherefore, in every city and village, schools must be established and every child in that city or village is to engage in study to the necessary degree."
-'Abdu'l-Bahá
Did you listen to the words? This is about teaching children to hate & to become racists.
Liz Kauai - you wrote a sermon
Julie Biddle actually to NOT teach hate
@@juliebiddle1636 date of this song is the 1940s during the USA Pacific War towards the end of World War 2,,,after Pearl Harbour,,,in the musical “South Pacific” the song describes how our white christian society teaches racism and hate,,,the white singer is in love with a girl from the Pacific islands,,,he is stating that hate and racism are “carefully taught when you are 6 or 7 or 8,,,,,and why is our society like this.
He is calling out the teaching of this as evil.
Love is love.
Live and let live.
As an American Jew, I always thought of this as a cautionary song; now I think other groups hear the same words and use them as inspiration in training their children to hate me & my people 😢
Correct me if I am wrong, but didn't Streisand first put these two songs together on a concert tour she did?
Dang, not getting audio...
Why is the sound gone?
AUDIO GONE
The same presciently racially aware, Oscar Hammerstein who 20 years earlier penned Old Man River...
I always felt in his singing performances that he needed strong direction but suspect he would not take it - great voice but less is more
To each his own, of course. But as I noted elsewhere, during the time he starred in multiple Broadway shows, he was considered one of, if not the, greatest male talent of our generation. Yes, he has a very unique style, so I understand why you said what you did, but what you might consider over the top, I (and many others) find extraordinarily emotionally moving.
I'll just bet that Donald John Trump has never listened to this wonderful song.
He wouldn't understand it if he did.
He's a rabbi
31 people must have been 'carefully' taught
y no applause?
+tomaf Some churches don't applause after a performance. I think it may have something to do with the fact that the person is honoring God and to clap would indicate that the performance was to please the people. I don't quite get it myself. From personal experience, usually, people just say "amen" quietly if the performance was good, but nobody did, so maybe this was a funeral or something.
+tomaf It was a September 11 memorial concert. Out of respect, often at events like this, the audience will be reverently silent.
Kelli Butler
Reading that the father of the murderer at the school in the Texas high school in May of 2018 is both Pro-Trump and Pro-NRA and left his guns available from his son to use - this medley tells a lot.
In USA 2023, with the sanctioned rise of HATE Made Normal, triggered through the ideological values of certain politicals: this has sadly become even 'more' relevant! 😪❤🩹💙 'Carefully Taught' from Rogers and Hammerstein's '1949'!! lyrics in musical South Pacific.
I don’t think those words mean what you think they mean. Critical race theory.
You don't know what CRT is.
Just sayin'
To bad he walked off the set of Criminal Minds never to return.
ƁԼƛƇƘ MƠƠƝ - yes but now he is on Homeland which he loves & offers as a gift to us.
Terrible, his singing is terrible
And now the Children are being taught all about the God called Co vid 19
Simply unbearable. The wobbly vibrato. The whining tone. The over-the-top, whimpering sentimentality. What became of "Sunday in the Park with George's" Seurat? Please, Mandy, for your own good and ours, give up singing.
Karlheinz Stockhausen - adjust your hearing aid
Its a sentimental crying sobbing song.
Get over it.
Its called DELIVERY.
I think I hate this song.
what???
Rita Striemer - Filmtress Mu is a "hater" hope no kids to mess up