How Israel uses 'hasbara' to shift narratives in its favour | The Stream
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- 'Hasbara.' Does that ring a bell? It's Hebrew for "explanation", but it's also a strategic communication method used to influence perceptions and tilt narratives in favour of Israel. Amid one of our darkest chapters, we're witnessing a livestreamed "genocide", bombings of schools and hospitals, targeting of humanitarian workers and journalists, and rampant human rights violations. Despite these facts, many still question them and align with Israel's defence. Why? Partly due to a meticulously crafted technique that shapes public opinion and geopolitical outcomes. Today, we'll delve into Israel's intricate art of shaping perceptions.
Presenter: Anelise Borges
Guests:
Jennine Khalik - Journalist and researcher
Katie Bogen - Doctoral student and author
Matt Lieb - Comedian
#palestine #israel #aljazeeraenglish #journalism #gaza #manipulation #genocide #stream #propaganda #israelhamaswar #israelwar
I wanted to thank al-jazeerah for inviting younger and influential people to discuss this topic. I am familiar with each of these speakers from their contributions to Palestine analysis via social media
I think the young woman from Australia articulates so clearly and in such a heartfelt way exactly why women and all kinds of diasporic and minority communities all over the world have come to feel such a strong empathy for and anger on behalf what Palestinians have been enduring for all these decades-- not just the violence but the complete silencing and erasure with it; trying to sweep the proverbial ashes and bones under the rug.
All humanity is with the Palestinian people now!!
All three guests great warriors of humanity and truth! Thank you all!
@@TheNagualWilliam Indeed, this issue has become the litmus of humanity itself, both collectively and as individuals. To surrender to Nazioni$m is to revert to b€$tia£ity.
She Does
@@TheNagualWilliam you are sadly mistaken and you either knowingly or unknowingly support islamic fascism.
Katie Bogen & Matt Lieb you are the kind of Jews we love and fortunately there are many of you and the numbers are growing. Thank you for telling the truth and working for justice.
“Europe's Alliance with Israel, Aiding the Occupation”- written by Irish journalist David Cronin . Shows that the EU's close relationship with Israel has legitimised actions such as the ill-treatment of prisoners and the Gaza invasion.
@@adammsa5303 children slaughtered you mean
No one likes you adam you might wanna check around..19xx all over
@@blackey0078 so you have the right to slaughter children and their mother, I wonder why you haven't tested peace for the past 2 thousand years ago, Israel is the squatters of the human world or the cuckoo bird no difference, inhuman world you are creating, all from Eastern Europe 💔
@@blackey0078'firsties' is not a license to occupy or oppress or starve or imprison or massacre
@@blackey0078use your brain please.
WONDERFUL and highly informative segment---I found Jennine particularly charming, VERY intelligent and well-spoken! The sadness in her face, at times, was a reminder of the heavy load of emotional trauma that these ones carry within themselves.
Hasbara as a "playbook," has a significant influence on peoples' perception and action against injustice.
Thank you AJ!
Mark Perlmutter, a Jewish orthopedic surgeon from the US, volunteered in Gaza: "As Surgeons, We Have Never Seen Cruelty Like Israel's Genocide in Gaza."
"We found evidence of horrifying violence deliberately directed at civilians and even children. A three-year-old boy shot in the head, a 12-year-old girl shot through the chest, an ICU nurse shot through the abdomen, all by some of the best-trained marksmen in the world.."
Evil in it's complete form.
That is why it is called war. In war everything is possible. It is no surprise
@abahfelix4782 no, there are rules. That's why phrases like 'WAR CRIMES' exist.
@@abahfelix4782of course it is one, against civilians targets
@@abahfelix4782 so by that logic all israelis are fair game right? Especially you?
For any American or other English-speaking audience I highly recommend Matt's podcast "Bad Hasbara" which is hosted by him along with Gabor Mate's son; and it is both hilarious but also really functions like a support-group for a lot of Jewish and Muslim Americans; it's really great.
@@prismpyre7653 Jarjar bink’s not us
@@prismpyre7653 also with adding that Bad Hasbara is the most moral podcast in the world!
@@OhDearOhDear69watermelons US
The podcast is, indeed, a good listen!
Where?
Thank you AL Jazeera. Thank you for exposing lies of Israel
Islam is a sneaky snake.
😂😂😂😂
great post
@@JackFieldBand👌😂😂🤣🤣..
When has the state of Israeli ever told the truth!?
We love you Palestinians thank you so much for showing us the light the whole world is eyes wide Open I pray for the voice and the victory of Palestinians to be heard seen and felt.
Regime change to the apartheid Israel
🇵🇸💩🤮🚽💀
Empathy is the real superpower and the driving force for tomorrow's big changes which will ensure that international law is upheld whilst all support for the upholding of an unlawful occupation is not!
Stop dreaming. Most Westerners don't care about Gaza. They don't like terrorists or primitive populations who use words like "martyr" and who veil their women.
Thank you Al Jazeera for bringing this to light.
I'm not Jewish and I was conditioned by this hasbara, too. Through what I read and learned in school, and heard around me, I grew believing Israelis made the desert bloom, and all the rest
It means a lot to us that you see the truth now. The Zionists have been forcibly displacing and evicting us from our land and private properties for about 100 years. I grew up as a fugitive in a UN camp for Palestinian refugees in Lebanon, even though I come from a wealthy family. The Zionists stole our properties and killed my great-grandfather on his own land. Back then, before Israel was created, my family had properties, money, and a company in Palestine. My great- grandfather was a Lemon farmer and exported every season tons of it to Europe. But everything was taken, so we lived a miserable, hard life with no rights.
Lol what? You sound like a flat earther? conditioned?
@@maxenglish3328 not really
It requires emotional growth to admit such a thing publicly. Thank you for doing so. Welcome to the pro-Palestinian side.
I used to believe the pro palestinian side. I started reading old newspapers from 1947. Found out Israel never lied and the Palestinians constantly lie to support their nerrative.
All of you are young humane beautiful intellects. I am so proud of you all. There is hope for humanity. To be educated is to think, analyze the facts and reach conclusion irrespective of the propaganda. Kudos to all of you.
Hasbara - Manufacturing Consent.
Noam Chomsky, get well soon.
The Jewish journalist Antony Loewenstein wrote well documented book “The Palestine Laboratory “. A good resource to learn more about the conflict related to Palestine land
@@adammsa5303 Al Jazeera did a lovely documentary this week on him and his fathers relationship through his anti Zionist awakening
Not hamas .all world is against Izrael
One of the blessed fact on this planet. ❤
You don't know what you're talking about😂
No, stop dreaming. What genocide? If Israel wanted to commit genocide, there would not be 35,000 deaths (more than half being armed terrorists...), but 350,000. Enough nonsense and manipulation.
@@Dynamatrix2000 Pretty sure you are the one in dreamland matey. But you'll only find out exactly how internationally despised Israel has become when you leave your sad and illegitimate Middle East bubble.
The whole world loves❤️ Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤️
and Jews❤️, they are good and kind people.
Who we don’t like is rapists, full of hate psychopatic liers 🫵🫵🫵🫵🤨🤨🤨🤨
Free Palestin!! stop genocide!
Islamic societies are never free. Freedom is Haram.
YE Free Palestin FROM HAM=ASS ANIMALS
What genocide? If Israel wanted to commit genocide, there would not be 35,000 deaths (more than half being armed terrorists...), but 350,000. Enough nonsense and manipulation.
"There is no 'Palestine.' So, how can you free it?," Mosab Hassan Yousef, son of Hamas founder, who left Hamas and its evil.
This is not about land but about Jew hatred. Always go back to the source.
Also, screw all you Jew haters.
@@LadyMaven Sorry, your antisemitism accusation card has expired on Oct 7th. Also, nice try using a drug-addled former Hamas member as your source of lies. Abby Martin did a better shakedown on him, considering that his response is personally threatening her and her family. Typical fascists.
I am totally against my country (USA) supporting the state of Israeli in any way!
Many voters and public figures are voting 3rd party, even media hosts are saying they'll vote for Jill Stein or they'll consider Jill or West. Trump said he'd finish the job, "the genocide." I'm hoping the a.n.s.w.e.r.colaition can get Jill, Cornel, and Claudia to promote the strongest candidate. Voters can make a difference and break the hold that military, corporate and foreign political figures that serve their own intersts or act as US President. I didn't vote for Netanyahu. Trump, Biden, & Netanyahu are war criminals. Harris said she's iron clad tight with Israel, and she receives billions in lobbiest so she'll serve Netanyahu, not the victims of a genocide and not the United States citizens.
Matt Lieb is a treasure
Excellent panel
One has to agree albeit regretfully
@@durranaiktf does that mean
In our millions and our billions we are all Palestinian 🇵🇸🇮🇪
🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
🇵🇸💞🇲🇪🇧🇦🇸🇮🇦🇱🇷🇸🇭🇷 Sloboda Državi Palestini 🇵🇸 🖐🏻🖐🏿🖐 Kraj cionističkoj ILEGALNOJ OKUPACIJI .
@@nedimlim6523 From the river to the sea. 🗝
The article recently published in the reknowned and peer-reviewed medical journal "The Lancet" describes the horrific consequences of this political agenda. They state that a consevative estimate for the number of deaths through the months long agression is 7-9% of the population.
Free Palestine from Israeli occupation
Oct 6, you had land to build your country. You lost your chance. Palestine never will be a country.
Palestine will be a country inshallah
Islamic societies are never free. Freedom is Haram.
@@Kokokhan-km1hq ameen
@@axelpar9034Palestine is a country recognised by 145 UN member states. There was peace before European zionazis began colonising it.
Not only hasbara but TH-cam also deleted comments that favourable to Palestine
Not only that. I have answered to some sick hasbara trolls in two cases the video suddenly disappeared and i could't find it even at the search line
99.9% of my comments are being deleted by ytb, they hate truth be told, so imagine the number of videos being wiped out that show the horrific crimes of israel against the Palestinians
same here. even if im not saying anything explicit they still often get deleted. its a scary feeling when the censorship starts happening to you...
Yes, they shadowban comments. Many of my comments have dissapeared.
Israel has lost the war, and the Israeli settler colonial project is failing.
The world agrees - Pstinians have brought it upon themselves. no ceasefire, no evacuation, more 2 thousand pounders!
Joke, keep dreaming.
@@Michaelxx2inkids with mortar are destroying the so called the most advanced army in the world, do you know why? I tell you why, because Israel is a lie and not true, if it wasn't for Palestine, you probably Uganda national by now, your a serpent.
Dream on, little one
I have never seen a losing country that managed to kill 10 times more soldiers on the other side..
Israel in collapse’: 46,000 businesses forced to close since 7 Oct. Hebrew newspaper Maariv reported on 10 July, referring to Israel as a “country in collapse.”
Keep dreaming
@@kunalreang10keep falling
@@TheBadgerr Neverrr
@@kunalreang10Cry more
barbies on every corner...
Heartiest thanks to aljajira for the optimistic news telecast .Free Palestine 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸..
Thank you for speaking out the truth about Netanyahu we can no trust him 😢😢
Is that the world's Most moral podcast's co host matt liebbb?????!!! also, FREE PALESTINE!!!!!!
Is there any doubt left that there are only two different factions of Zio NOT-Z:
Those who are denying the existence of Palestinian and those who are insisting to make Palestinians nonexistence.
*Rest* *in* *Power* *Aaron* *Bushnell* I will never forget you and your last words of " *Free* *Palestine* "
Germany was also fighting terrorism during WW2
The world agrees - Pstinians have brought it upon themselves. no ceasefire, no evacuation, more 2 thousand pounders!
Now grmany join with their partners.
@@Michaelxx2inwhat is your motivation?
@@mohammadmatin8030 I live is Israel and I work in the Kheil HaAvir installing the fuses on the 2000+1000+500 pounders. I then watch the news to enjoy the results. 38.000 successes.
@@mohammadmatin8030 seeing the young and the legless
ICJ says Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories is illegal.
The UN's top court has said Israel's occupation of Palestinian territories is against international law, in a landmark opinion.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) said Israel should stop settlement activity in the occupied West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza and end its "illegal" occupation of those areas as soon as possible.
The United Nations could and should have declared the occupation of all of Palestinian land in 1948 was Illegal. It was Illegal under its own original charter of "SELF DETERMINATION"
Calling Israel a country is like saying
a Burglar owns your house.
There s one and only one solution to the Palestinian question and that is:-
ONE STATE where all :Palestinian ;Jew and all whose faith draws them to Jerusalem and those of no faith can live peaceful prosperous lives which is what Palestine and Palestinians wanted before 1948.
This has proved impossible not because Arabs hate Jews or Jews hate Arabs but
BECAUSE ZIONISTS HATE BOTH
After Oct-7 issues have shown all the world that Israeli cruelty is in a different level.
It is systematic and also it was reflected their language.
Example:
There is no word as human-animal in a language rather than Israeli has, even German
There is no word as hasbara "art of deception" in a language rather than Israeli has
this is from another comment: Israeli recognition as state stated in the resolution no 181 and 194 in one condition if it recognise Palestine and allow the refugees back to their home and villages, without this condition, the Israeli recognition is a null and void.
So the ICJ putting a question mark on Israeli existence, and resolution 194 gives Palestinian refugees rights of returns, these two conditions only make israel to exist and Israel by law is not an state.
This fact should be discussed every single time the "conflict" in the Middle East is mentioned.
EXACTLY.
Resolution is only as strong as it’s allies belief in it.
So glad that your now seeing and understanding for decades the sort of evil being done to Palestine's people. We as the world should be a shamed.
What evil??? They were leaving of the benefits, free water and electricity supply FROM ISRAEL, FREE MEDICAL TREATMENTS FROM ISRAEL,
And what did these sick psychos did in return?!!!!!!!
Monsters 🫵🫵🫵🫵🤨🤨🤨
@@DestroyHate. If Israel was being so generous, why were the Gazans not allowed to use their water, or build their own power plants?
or even import their own goods.
i remember seeing al jazeera documentaries 20 15 years ago about the tunnels having to be built to smuggle in food, fuel and medicines from egypt...
‘We invented the cherry tomato’ love you Matt Lieb
Hasbara SUS!
@@dustmighte most moral comment thread here, obviously
Fistbump my most moral co-commenter!
@@dustmighte 🤜 🤛
@OhDearOhDear69
Check out the Daniel Mate remix! 👍
"The most criminal army in the world"
Al Jazeera - real journalism.
I can see hasbara is in full effect on TH-cam comments right now
🙌Exceptional panel. Thank you, Anelise & AJ English. ❤️
Shukraan thank you AJ stream, may the Umah all of the Umah see eachother as such...
Shoutout to the BaDHasbara and GDF stay with us we need your voices, your reasoning to remind us what we've lost as a species to elevate the sacrifices all those who the world has lost for the sake of greed and superiority complexes.
I cannot recommend the Bad Hasbara podcast enough. It's hilarious and heartfelt and I've learned so much from it. Like Matt said, it's kind of like group therapy. It's been one of the things keeping me sane (ish) for the past 10 months.
The Most Moral Matt . Great to See him explain Hasbara
I have known this system since I started following the Palestinian horror. What I wonder is whether Western information is a victim of this or uses it in turn against its citizens.
Thank you
Fantastic reporting
HASBARA TROLLS IN THE CHAT!!
They're really wilding out🤣🤣
Do not reply to them tho. Get paid for it and also have lost all right to be heard
Free Palestine
israel on track to be next Soddom & gomorrha
All countries should seize economic or diplomatic relations with Israel. In fact, any relations with Israel will affect the reputation of any government.
interesting takes from those who were indoctrinated in their youth. horrifying story of harassment by the young journalist. reason and intelligence usurps. all of you demonstrate welcoming intellect and reason. thanks for what you do and remain vigilant.
And if you call out Israel for genocide then they twist it to their benefit by saying your anti jew ish as we all know that the US and England gave them that land that wasn’t theirs in the first place.
Hasbara = justifying (israeli crimes)
Oh please 😒 its a genocide!!!
I'm still waiting to see the long tunnels
Hasbara is Joseph Goebles on steroids.
😂😂
As one of most moral listener of most moral podcasters @Bad Hasbara @MattLieb, lets troll all hasbaras.
Couscous us? Ha! You wish hasbaras!
Thank you God! Unlike the Zionists, there are so many Jews, who care and fight for all humanity regardless of race, religion and creek. There is hope one day Zionism will end so and peace will prevail on that part of the world.
Who told you that, you keep sleeping and eat Domino pizza
Makes you think. Who else had an explicit ministry of propaganda?
I'm not sure the majority of Israeli's/ zionist/ Jew / supporters , can be reasoned with , but , most of us see reality. To me personaly , Israel and co have become the little girl who cried fire. In the end , it was her own demise .
Palestinians, we see you 😢
Liars, par excellence.
Cheaters, par excellence
Thieves, par excellence.
It's not sophisticated communication. Everyone sees through what is happening. Some or rather many simply feint to believe the lies because it suits their ideology or political agenda.
Free palestine
Great work, Israel has to be held accountable for this genocide & daily war crimes will not be forgotten! The Innocent Palestinians don't deserve to be punished for the actions of a terrorist group!
I will always remember those claims of compound under the hospital and the their list which was all lies. This is how they justified murder of thousand innocents.
They are liers
They are targeting innocent civilians 😢😢
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Islamic societies are never free. Freedom is Haram.
I'm not one but surprised by what is happening. What gets me is how dumb they think people are .that they can lie get exposed lie expose lie expose.lies lies and more lies . But can you blame them when there are dumb people actually still believing them .😢 and I'm sorry for calling people dumb .but seriously.what should you call them at this point....?
yup. totally and utterly brainwashed. it makes thankful i didn't grow up like that.
Oct 7...Israel must really be bad to have had that happen to them. Horrible things happen to horrible people, right??
if you bully someone for long enough, your delusional if you don't think they'll eventually snap and come at you fists swinging. you don't need a psychology degree to see that coming...
Knowledge is key..read up on some Chomsky, Avi Shloam, Pappe, Khalidi
Tell India to stop sending weapons to Israel
Thank you Al Jazeera.
I like the video but my like doesn't register.
What's going on ?
Yay Matt Lieb, Bad Hasbara p.cast Most Moral Cohost!
Edited to say Free flipping Palestine NOW!!
it's a lot like US propaganda.
"Manifest Destiny" is horrific to watch.
sure....waking up at noon every day and blaming whitey...sure...such a horrific existence.
@@BertGraef
Your are perfect person to feels your government are so horrible and many thanks to to ladies as much as the presenter.
The world wakes up. Make ready.
The truth is simple-- simply turn upside down every sentence of hasbara
Al jazeera doing the lord's work (if God was a journalist)
God spelled backwards = Dog! Dog = Hamas supporters! hahahahahah :)
Very informative, thank you 🙏
Whatever, 'Hasbara' was a total failure since OCT72023.
Thank you for sharing this helpful information
hasbara in the comments
say it with me:
HAS
BA
🐀
I knew it, but anyway thanks for your courageous report ❤❤
Israel should never have become a country abd cerrainly not labd that was already occupied by an indigenous people.
Why didn't Palestinians declare a State of Palestine in 1948 in the West Bank, Gaza with their capital in Jerusalem?
@@michaelw2288 because the British stole their weapons but not the Jewish ones
@@michaelw2288Palestinians had no army or airforce and zionazis attacked them before May 1948. Remember Deir Yassin.
I truly think it's forbidden for them to speak the truth.
Allah has forbidden you to inhabit the Promised Land. That is why Allah has abandoned them.
@@RickMartin-vk8vl
How does that explain why they lie so much? Are you saying that's who made them liars? You're not making sense.
@@HTownCharlieBrown
Let me guess? You’re an atheist? Whatever you are, in the words of famous British rockers Judas Priest: You’ve got Another Thing Coming.
New generation is our hope. Alas, older people would have...
❤❤❤❤🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸majority of the worlds population stands will Palestine and always has!!
As a Arab, I'm glad to know
MONDAY
TUESDAY
WEDNESDAY
THURSDAY
FRIDAY
SATURDAY
SUNDAY
we're actually part of Khamas...
😂🤣🤣
Palestine existed before Judea and Samaria.
Genesis 21.34 Abraham dwelled for a long time in Philistine.
Abraham migrated to Philistine 2000 BC from Babylon.
Abraham brought Isaacs brought Jacob.
Jacob and the twelve tribes migrated to Egypt Pharaoh and lived for 1000 years from 1900 to 921 BC when.
David 921 BC killed Goliath Jalut Palestine King and occupied Palestine.
Google, who was Goliath.
Nebuchadnezzar liberated Palestine 600 BC and took Jews to Babylon from where they scattered the world until.
The British mandate of Palestine 1921 and the Haganah forces established the second Palestine occupation.
Hundred years of atrocities against Palestinian people from the second Palestine occupation.
TH-cam, Haganah forces.
MORE DELUSIONAL THAN THE AYATOLLAH!
LOVE and Peace for ONE and ALL
Every isra helli knows how to be a better liar than being a good person.
If you can't stand lies then what do you do on this channel? It's the worst of all...
No one lies like Al-Jazeera.
I am SO SURPRISED that hasbara is in these comments talking trash about al jazeera as if we didn't know israel has been trying to discredit and literally destroy a.j. for YEARS.😳
@@GingerIndiana is it good to lie to cause chaos and kill?
@@JackFieldBand but much better than western media
Thieves likes netanyahu who change names will never be successful in the goals and aspirations
Never did I imagine the day Zios will be watching AJ videos. They banned it in your beloved country for a reason and ya'll sneaking over here? Monitzing yourselfs for AJ. Stop playing yourself
❤️🇵🇸✊🏽
Aye, GDF. I recognize that voice anywhere
🇺🇲🇵🇸
They all use the same talking points. They are systematic on their narrative.
Ignore Hasbara in comments. Like pro palestine comments for algorithm.
At least report them.All of the sane people should report these sick commenters. Although youtube the biggest hasbara would't harm them. Just saying