I apologize for the delayed response. For some reason, your comment was just delivered. This pie is so good and super easy to make. Thank you so much for watching! ~Andrea
Hi, Andrea! That Butterfinger pie looks amazing! I love how easy this is: simple dump everything into a bowl, mix, put into the pie shell, and chill. I think the brown and black colors are very appropriate for fall, too. Thanks for sharing!
Hi Parnell! I didn't even think about the pie being fall colors, but you're right 😁. I love a good no bake pie and this one is so good. If taste like you put in a lot more effort then you did. Thanks so much for watching! I hope you have a wonderful weekend! ~Andrea
Oh Andrea, i love Butterfingers and now got the recipe to make it , thank you for sharing..😀 stay safe with all these hurricanes....💋 to Harrison ....Hugs to you and Howard
Oh, Jill it's so good! As a Butterfinger fan I really think you'll like it. Hugs to you and I'll be sure to give Harrison a big kiss from you. Have a wonderful day! ~Andrea
I do have a few recipes that use sweetened condensed milk, but I haven’t tried it with this recipe before. I would imagine that it wouldn’t be as light (airy) but I’m not sure. I would love to know how it turns out should you decide to try it. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
You are already winning because you have Butterfingers on hand, lol! I hope you enjoy the pie as much as we do. Thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful weekend! ~Andrea
That looked sooo good! I LOVE Butterfingers! I’m all about how easy that looked! The hardest part would be, letting it chill!🙃 Are you guys getting in on the hurricanes? My gosh, it just seems like you guys keep getting hit with one after another!? Stay safe! Have a great rest of the week & weekend!😊💜
Hi Kathy! Thankfully we are not in the path of the hurricanes. The only thing we're getting is cloudy and dreary looking weather. If you love Butterfingers, you'd definitely enjoy this pie. You can make it at night before bed, that way you don't have to suffer through it chilling. I do that sometimes 😁. Thanks so much for watching and I hope y'all have a wonderful and safe weekend! ~Andrea
Hi Becky! The recipe is listed in the description box. You’ll need 1 cup of powdered sugar and a half cup of peanut butter. I hope you enjoy it. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
I’ve never tried it with Snickers, but I’m sure it would probably be fine. Snickers tend get hard when refrigerated, so you may have to let the pie sit out a bit before you eat it. I do have a Snickers recipe coming out on Thursday that might interest you. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
Butterfingers are peanut butter based and I love the flavor it adds to the pie. You can leave it out if you'd prefer. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
Man this looks too good. 🔥
If you are a Butterfinger lover, you’ll definitely love this pie! Thanks for watching! ~Andrea
Looks yummy 😋
Thank you so much for watching! ~Andrea
That looks delicious
Thank you! I appreciate you watching! ~Andrea
I saw this and started salivating!😋
I'm so glad you enjoyed the recipe. Butterfingers are one of my favorite candy bars. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
This looks AMAZING
Thank you so much! I hope you enjoy it as much as we do. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
This looks really good! I think I have all the ingredients except the candy. I’m gonna give this a try over the weekend! TFS
It's so good! I really hope you enjoy it as much as we do. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
Looks delish!!!
Thank you! I appreciate you watching! ~Andrea
This looks so delicious
It’s so good! We absolutely love it. Thanks so much for stopping by today! ~Andrea
We made this for Thanksgiving 2024 it was so easy and tasted amazing. We added Oreos and toffee heath bits so good!
Oh and we used a Graham cracker pie crust😊
I'm so glad you all enjoyed it! Adding Oreos and toffee heath bits sounds incredible. Thanks for letting me know! ~Andrea
Looks like a winner going to make this pie wish me luck 🤞
I hope you enjoy it. It's one of my faves! Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
Yum! That looks really decadent.
Thank you, Anthony! It’s so good. I hope you like it should you decide to give it a try. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
Looks very yummy
I apologize for the delayed response. For some reason, your comment was just delivered. This pie is so good and super easy to make. Thank you so much for watching! ~Andrea
Yummy that looks so good 😋
It really is good and very easy to make! Thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful day! ~Andrea
Wow that looks so tasty 😋
It really was and a cinch to make! Thanks for watching! ~Andrea
OMG I made this & it was amazing!
I’m so glad you enjoyed the pie! Thanks for taking the time to let me know! ~Andrea
Oh my my! Absolute deliciousness! Have a great week, Andrea!
Thank you, Kory! Same to you! ~Andrea
Looks so goos
Thank you so much! I appreciate you watching! ~Andrea
This recipe was amazing I tried it today very rich thank
You so much
I’m so glad you enjoyed it! Thank you so much for taking the time to let me know. Have a wonderful week ahead! ~Andrea
This looks incredible! I love all the ingredients and the no bake aspect - well that has me!
I love no bake desserts! This one tastes like you put a lot of effort into making it, but it’s so simple. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
That looks wonderful!
It’s so good and very simple to make. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
Hi, Andrea! That Butterfinger pie looks amazing! I love how easy this is: simple dump everything into a bowl, mix, put into the pie shell, and chill. I think the brown and black colors are very appropriate for fall, too. Thanks for sharing!
Hi Parnell! I didn't even think about the pie being fall colors, but you're right 😁. I love a good no bake pie and this one is so good. If taste like you put in a lot more effort then you did. Thanks so much for watching! I hope you have a wonderful weekend! ~Andrea
Oh Andrea, i love Butterfingers and now got the recipe to make it , thank you for sharing..😀 stay safe with all these hurricanes....💋 to Harrison ....Hugs to you and Howard
Oh, Jill it's so good! As a Butterfinger fan I really think you'll like it. Hugs to you and I'll be sure to give Harrison a big kiss from you. Have a wonderful day! ~Andrea
That pie looks so delicious!
It truly is a simple and tasty pie! Very rich. Thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful weekend! ~Andrea
Can you use a can of sweetened condensed milk instead of powdered sugar? That's usually how I do no bake pies. Can't wait to try!
I do have a few recipes that use sweetened condensed milk, but I haven’t tried it with this recipe before. I would imagine that it wouldn’t be as light (airy) but I’m not sure. I would love to know how it turns out should you decide to try it. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
@@FoodamentaryAdventuresinFood You're very welcome! If I try, I will report back! Proud new fan of your channel! 💞🌟
that does look good you just gain a new support 😊
I’m so happy you enjoyed the video! Thank you for subscribing to our channel! ~Andrea
Now I love me some Butterfingers the pie looks good. How was the sweetness?
It’s not too sweet. The peanut butter really balances out the sweetness. It’s worth giving it a try. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
This pie IS delicious! I used to make it every holiday and am going to do it again. You guys won’t be disappointed ❤
Thank you for your kind words! I’m so glad you and your family enjoy it as much as I do. Thanks for watching and Happy Thanksgiving! ~Andrea
@@FoodamentaryAdventuresinFood Happy Thanksgiving to you, too!!!
Woah I almost missed this one.
It's sooo good! Howard isn't a huge chocolate person and he loves this pie. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea 😊
Looks really good. Wonder if snickers with a drizzle of caramel on top would work instead of Butterfingers candy?
I think that would be amazing! I love Snickers. Great idea. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
I legit have all the ingredients except the cream cheese. 😢 definitely making a store run. Lol. Great video
You are already winning because you have Butterfingers on hand, lol! I hope you enjoy the pie as much as we do. Thank you so much for watching. Have a wonderful weekend! ~Andrea
Oh my, that looks amazing Andrea! I love butterfingers and I love cream cheese. I love Oreo crusts too! 😋
It’s insanely delicious! You’d love it. Thanks so much for watching, Alicia!
That looked sooo good! I LOVE Butterfingers! I’m all about how easy that looked! The hardest part would be, letting it chill!🙃
Are you guys getting in on the hurricanes? My gosh, it just seems like you guys keep getting hit with one after another!? Stay safe! Have a great rest of the week & weekend!😊💜
Hi Kathy! Thankfully we are not in the path of the hurricanes. The only thing we're getting is cloudy and dreary looking weather. If you love Butterfingers, you'd definitely enjoy this pie. You can make it at night before bed, that way you don't have to suffer through it chilling. I do that sometimes 😁. Thanks so much for watching and I hope y'all have a wonderful and safe weekend! ~Andrea
Foodamentary: Adventures in Food -Great idea about making this before bed. Yes, that would make the agony of waiting much easier! Thanks!
@@kathyconger2188 glad I could help, lol!
I'd like to know measurements of how much you use of the peanut butter and powdered sugar
Hi Becky! The recipe is listed in the description box. You’ll need 1 cup of powdered sugar and a half cup of peanut butter. I hope you enjoy it. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
Can this recipe be done with snickers I don't care for butter fingers. Would it turn out the same
I’ve never tried it with Snickers, but I’m sure it would probably be fine. Snickers tend get hard when refrigerated, so you may have to let the pie sit out a bit before you eat it. I do have a Snickers recipe coming out on Thursday that might interest you. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
Would it taste ok without the powdered sugar?
It would probably taste okay, but it won’t be very sweet. I’d love to know your thoughts if decide to skip the sugar. Thanks for watching! ~Andrea
I saw earlier someone else making this and they didn't use peanut butter. Why use peanut butter its not in a butterfinger candy bar ? Just asking?
Butterfingers are peanut butter based and I love the flavor it adds to the pie. You can leave it out if you'd prefer. Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea
I’m afraid to make this because I might not be willing to share.😝❤️
It's okay to be selfish sometimes, lol! Thanks so much for watching! ~Andrea 😊