The saddest thing for me is, Rash doesn't know what the infection is. He's a criminal, so he doesn't engage with society or learn what's happening outside. When he got infected, he was probably scared, and confused, not knowing what was going on. But when he saw Willow then, he might've thought there was hope for him. His best friend had come back for him. But after seeing her walk away, he must've been terrified. Everyone had abandoned him, he had been locked in that room for who knows how long. Everyone left him, and when he saw his best friend leave too, that's heartbreaking.
According to the piggy wiki the piggy virus will give loss of control and aggression (also head twitching, pupil expansion, and eye color change.) So rash could see what he's doing but can't control himself, sad.
What I thought what happened was Rash escaped prison before Willow and when finding shelter he got scratched, so he reluctantly locked himself in the room to protect Willow when she came by.
@@BaconHairDefaults i think Tigry and Rash were hiding in Leo’s laundromat, but Tigry had to lock rash up. That’s why Tigry looks sad. Everyone in his life threw him to curb like he was nothing, but the one person who even acknowledged him is now gone.
I certainly remember those days playing with my old friends having fun always abusing a glitch that is now sadly patched to this day, sadly my old friends I don’t know what happened to them. Crazy piggy went all this way to become one of the most played horror games in Roblox win the bloxys a couple of times and have one of the greatest storylines ever.
I like the scene when pony gave doggy the potion because it brings back nostalgia! Back then we didn’t know who gave him the potion. And the camera movement is so good!
Well maybe zizzy is not dead right? Last time we saw her was I think in her head. She might be infected or maybe not infected. She properly got a new boy friend if she was alive -_-
Probably unintentional since book 2 wasn't planned to be a thing at the time but that would explain why Pony asked Zizzy if we were infected when we met them back in carnival
That cutscene revealed so much. Rash is infected Daisy is delta and is infected. (if you dont believe me she's got the delta accessories) TSP creation How pony infected doggy How willow escaped jail How tigry was found Zizzy and pony knew each other since childhood.
@@eljugasodemanzana8390 Daisy Isn't Delta, Delta has orange/Insolence eyes, Daisy Is probably just apart of the group Delta Is in like she's a General.
Ikr, we think Willow is just some lost cause, now we know what happened to her. Everybody she knew who cared about her fell prey to an infection, we can’t call her a jerk knowing all this happened to her.
I think I figured the whole piggy timeline out Hesit - Allys - House - Station - 3:11 scene - Gallery - 3:33 scene - Forest - School - Hospital - Foxy locked in cage - Metro - Distorted Memory - Carnival - City - Mall - Outpost - Plant - Allys ending - Store - Refinery - Distraction - Safe place - Sewers - Factory - Port - Ship - Docks - Temple - Camp So heres my reasoning I think that the events of Heist and Allys happened way before the Piggy book 1 story even started Reason 2 : TSP known as The silver paw I think the events of 3:11 happened between station and gallery before they gave it to doggy in 3:33 Reason 3 : I think that the events of Distorted Memory Happened While we were at carnival Because at the end of the Distorted memory Ending cutscene we can see that geroge / Georgie Wakes up in the place we found him in chapter 10 And I doubt that he woke up in chapter 10 So he must have woken up from the nightmare before the events of chapter 9
piggy is so sad when you really think . its even sadder when you realise that its all over now . and the memories that came with it? i swear 2021 ruined every memory...
you mean 1 also there is gonna be a chapter 3 not confirmed but probally there is gonna be a chapter 3 where it explains alot and back stories and i dont think minitoon would just abadon piggy i mean it got so many awards also he put so much time and effort into the game i dont think he would abadon it but the rest of the story will be moving on to uhh the new game forgot the name i will never play it cuz i dont wanna also i will just play piggy.
The saddest bit is when Willow goes back to where William was to see if he came back and when she went to the lake and hugged his scarf as it was all she had left of him
RE SADD osea Nos cuentan la historia de Willow y es super triste,Resumen:Willow necesitaba comida para alimentar a su hermano para eso necesitaba ayuda de todos, ponny encontro comida que dio a willow, dandose cuenta que se fue, al esto ella fue arrestada por doggy y el oficial, pero vio que un oficial estaba infectado y dejo la llave con la que escapo, luego vio a su amigo rash infectado y ya tenia que ir por un equipo nuevo, ayudando al equipo que ahora la conocemos como la TSP, luego ella por venganza obligo a pony infectarnos y infectar a doggy, pero como somos inmunes cuando nos dieron la pocion no nos afecto cuando ponny iba a darselo a doggy doggy desperto por eso ladra y se ve como ponny le da la pocion doggy le golpea la mano tirando la botella rompiendola, al esto ponny se sentia triste y dejo La TSP y luego vino por Zizzy quien habia dejado, obvio willow no estaba satisfecho ya que extrañaba a su hermano, y nos podemos dar cuenta que en el cap 11, Willow ve una cara familiar y es triste ya que se dio cuenta que Daysi Habia sido infectada..., al esto ya se podia dar cuenta que si su hermano estaba en busca de daysi igualmente se habria infectado como ella
1:44 if you look to the right, you can see Poley running into a table Plus Doggy sleeps on his side on a thin bench? I mean, we are playing a game based off of peppa pig so we are equally as weird. *Too shay*
@Keaton Richards it is Poley, even the player's journey mention him at the refinery page, some skins has a different aspect on book 2 but they still being same ones
maybe we will get that question in future update maybe in book 3 if there is one? it might take a while like a year cuz we got the "who infected doggy" answer in about a year almost 2
This is like a music video but also like a recap of the story so far which saddens me to know I have to relive these harsh feelings but it brings a tear to my eyes with the song
This was one of the best chapters ever, and one of the saddest ones, sad because willow has lost everyone that she loved, her parents, william, and daisy, but we might see william again
most unlikely that william returns he is just a kid the chances that he got infected are super high cuz he is just a kid and i don't think he can survive on his own as a kid he might maybe he found somone else they worked togother but that is very unlikely
i won twice the 1st time minitoon shut down the server ruining my cutscene and 2nd the menu overlapped the cutscene ruining it thank you for this video
One thing I’m wondering is if we are imagining this or something because you never see player in parts where the player was there in cutscenes like where willow gets arrested or when doggy gets infected.
What happened: Rash is infected Tigry was homeless Pony obviously tried to infect the player (duh) Pony leaves tsp Daisy is infected, it’s what willow was looking at
There’s a edit after the 2 theories I have. Please read it after reading my theories The ending was actually interesting. And why it was interesting, is that donkey Soldier. Willow was looking at the soldier. Why? You might say “That was daisy dude!” Or maybe she thought it was daisy. Uh oh theory time I have 2 theories. 1: Willow thought she was daisy, but actually it wasn’t daisy. Look at the hand. There are fingers. And if you don’t know, male characters in piggy have normal hands. But with female characters, they have these weird looking hands like willow. So, maybe that wasn’t daisy. 2: Maybe that donkey soldier reminded willow about daisy. Idk how to explain this so ye you get the point Ok, so people maybe right about the soldier being daisy, but I don’t want this ending up as a argument so uh ye Also daisy is not delta because there isn’t the purple thing on the arm lol
The rule of the hands don't always applies with all the characters, just most of them Besides, that soldier had red eyes just like the skin in the shop, so most likely is the actual Daisy
The hands may be a mistake about mini because he was doing the Chapter fast and he just put daisy's head in one of the soldiers model and forgot about fingers lol
So... what happened to Billy anyways? Was he part of TSP? Because you don't see him with the group?
Idk
Billy was with rash and infected I think
Idk
He got Infected before T.S.P was a thing.
He is infected because of tenuosflea’s video
The saddest thing for me is, Rash doesn't know what the infection is. He's a criminal, so he doesn't engage with society or learn what's happening outside. When he got infected, he was probably scared, and confused, not knowing what was going on. But when he saw Willow then, he might've thought there was hope for him. His best friend had come back for him. But after seeing her walk away, he must've been terrified. Everyone had abandoned him, he had been locked in that room for who knows how long. Everyone left him, and when he saw his best friend leave too, that's heartbreaking.
Holy jesus you’re right. That just makes this 10x sadder…
According to the piggy wiki the piggy virus will give loss of control and aggression (also head twitching, pupil expansion, and eye color change.) So rash could see what he's doing but can't control himself, sad.
What I thought what happened was Rash escaped prison before Willow and when finding shelter he got scratched, so he reluctantly locked himself in the room to protect Willow when she came by.
@@BaconHairDefaults i think Tigry and Rash were hiding in Leo’s laundromat, but Tigry had to lock rash up. That’s why Tigry looks sad. Everyone in his life threw him to curb like he was nothing, but the one person who even acknowledged him is now gone.
@@Blueshandle yeah, probably he was shaking because he was scared.
2:56
The fact that pony and zizzy have been together since they were kids is very heartwarming
Awwwe
can explain why pony was so emotional when zizzy got infected
@@henryofwinchesterkingofeng5377 will zizzy come back?
@@gorho9269 hope so
@@gorho9269 probably as a part of the insolence
I was crying when William left, it reminds me that friends are always there for us, and that we shouldn’t leave them during troubling times.
Leasson learned: never give a pie to a friend
@@crazydude2687 HAHAH WHY DID I ACTUALLY LAUGH AT THIS-
@@crazydude2687 I was about to cry and I saw this XD
But he was not a friend, he was a brother
@@tomasgetze4330._.
I am crying.
I never thought a random game about pig would be so sad and epic :']
Remember the days where the house was the only chapter and the piggy was a 2D image of peppa pig? Me neither, I wasn’t there, but boy I wish I was.
I certainly remember those days playing with my old friends having fun always abusing a glitch that is now sadly patched to this day, sadly my old friends I don’t know what happened to them. Crazy piggy went all this way to become one of the most played horror games in Roblox win the bloxys a couple of times and have one of the greatest storylines ever.
It’s not even about a pig anymore, and that is sad. Rip penny lol
@@bacondoesstuff_ yes i know
But its what started it all i guess
I like the scene when pony gave doggy the potion because it brings back nostalgia! Back then we didn’t know who gave him the potion. And the camera movement is so good!
👀
Yea you right my man
That was such a great reveal, too! Jesus, that shocked me so badly Minitoon really knows how to present his reveals
Sorry for the correction but back then everyone thought Doggy wasn’t an officer and we all thought that Doggy* drank the potion *except some people*
Some of us thought it was doggy who did it himself.
People can’t call Pony a wimp because Zizzy died, since they’ve been childhood friends, so it’s even sadder that Zizzy got infected
Well maybe zizzy is not dead right? Last time we saw her was I think in her head. She might be infected or maybe not infected. She properly got a new boy friend if she was alive -_-
at the distraction chapter she met tio. so it could be possible she is part of the insolence right now
Even sadder that she nevee got to see her little sisters grow up
Probably unintentional since book 2 wasn't planned to be a thing at the time but that would explain why Pony asked Zizzy if we were infected when we met them back in carnival
That literally what pony said in the chapter 11 savior ending
@@Jonathan10z bruh?
@@theratwhotookyourteeth8514 wdym bruh
@@Jonathan10z idk
That cutscene revealed so much.
Rash is infected
Daisy is delta and is infected. (if you dont believe me she's got the delta accessories)
TSP creation
How pony infected doggy
How willow escaped jail
How tigry was found
Zizzy and pony knew each other since childhood.
That's not Daisy.
@@eljugasodemanzana8390 then why did Willow look so sad when she saw her
@@eljugasodemanzana8390 it is daisy
@@jadenplays389 because he looked like Daisy, then Willow remembered her
@@eljugasodemanzana8390 Daisy Isn't Delta, Delta has orange/Insolence eyes, Daisy Is probably just apart of the group Delta Is in like she's a General.
BIG F in the chat for Daisy, everyone thought she'd live, but NOPE.
F
F
H3ADY: *makes maps where daisy assists the player*
Heist: I’m aboutta end this man’s whole career.
Someone actually predicted that willow was looking at daisy infected but I forgot they’re name
@@Rawan20111 yeah
Is no one gonna talk about how poley got stuck on the table ? It was just..
*chefs kiss*
1:42
willow: looking at key
Poley: walking mindlessly into a table
Daisy being infected the end is so emotional
Ikr, we think Willow is just some lost cause, now we know what happened to her. Everybody she knew who cared about her fell prey to an infection, we can’t call her a jerk knowing all this happened to her.
I cried when daisy was on the floor, it just reminds me she has no clue what's happening. So sad
I didn’t cry-
It was not really sad I only cry at piggy if I see bunny my FAC character die :< so I made this channel for her :D
Pony left tsp
I think I figured the whole piggy timeline out
Hesit - Allys - House - Station - 3:11 scene - Gallery - 3:33 scene - Forest - School - Hospital - Foxy locked in cage - Metro - Distorted Memory - Carnival - City - Mall - Outpost - Plant - Allys ending - Store - Refinery - Distraction - Safe place - Sewers - Factory - Port - Ship - Docks - Temple - Camp
So heres my reasoning I think that the events of Heist and Allys happened way before the Piggy book 1 story even started
Reason 2 : TSP known as The silver paw I think the events of 3:11 happened between station and gallery before they gave it to doggy in 3:33
Reason 3 : I think that the events of Distorted Memory Happened While we were at carnival Because at the end of the Distorted memory Ending cutscene we can see that geroge / Georgie Wakes up in the place we found him in chapter 10 And I doubt that he woke up in chapter 10 So he must have woken up from the nightmare before the events of chapter 9
Who here agrees? Even tho it we might have already knew when this all happened
@@Welp_streams yeah other people already knew before you did
kl
This made me cry…😭😭😭 such a beautiful ending and this was a flashback, right?
i guess so
Why would kids even cry to a roblox game
@The275 I cried because this happens in real life
piggy is so sad when you really think . its even sadder when you realise that its all over now . and the memories that came with it? i swear 2021 ruined every memory...
that Last Scene really crushed me -------> 4:19 😢
THIS REVEALS SO MUCH
3:24 of the music is cool. It’s like a movie!
This is the saddest thing ever in my opinion. The way Willows brother was gone, and how much Pony missed Zizzy, this cutscene is heartbreaking.
Pony: *Looks at family photo*
Willow: WASSUP
Pony: WTF-
This is so sad and thank you for giving us the ending (toxicjim) those games in one more subscriber!
This was an awesome chapter and I really liked the distorted memory chapter so this a good remastered version but focusing on a different person
When I watched cutscenes of heist it was soo sad 😔
Oh god, Daisy was actually infected she dosent have the insolence eyes, Oh poor willow
Maybe William's also infected
Cause She Is Infected By a non insolence person
what is insolence eye how does it affect infection
So somebody’s been living under a rock about the insolence
@@haz_gaming6636 :o
This is just sad despite only 2 more chapters until the official end of Piggy
you mean 1 also there is gonna be a chapter 3 not confirmed but probally there is gonna be a chapter 3 where it explains alot and back stories and i dont think minitoon would just abadon piggy i mean it got so many awards also he put so much time and effort into the game i dont think he would abadon it but the rest of the story will be moving on to uhh the new game forgot the name i will never play it cuz i dont wanna also i will just play piggy.
Can’t forget intercity;)
@@putiksgaming6548 his second game in Piggy's roblox is called intercity and minitoon said that's book 3
@@juanzambrano9202 ooooooooh
The saddest bit is when Willow goes back to where William was to see if he came back and when she went to the lake and hugged his scarf as it was all she had left of him
RE SADD osea Nos cuentan la historia de Willow y es super triste,Resumen:Willow necesitaba comida para alimentar a su hermano para eso necesitaba ayuda de todos, ponny encontro comida que dio a willow, dandose cuenta que se fue, al esto ella fue arrestada por doggy y el oficial, pero vio que un oficial estaba infectado y dejo la llave con la que escapo, luego vio a su amigo rash infectado y ya tenia que ir por un equipo nuevo, ayudando al equipo que ahora la conocemos como la TSP, luego ella por venganza obligo a pony infectarnos y infectar a doggy, pero como somos inmunes cuando nos dieron la pocion no nos afecto cuando ponny iba a darselo a doggy doggy desperto por eso ladra y se ve como ponny le da la pocion doggy le golpea la mano tirando la botella rompiendola, al esto ponny se sentia triste y dejo La TSP y luego vino por Zizzy quien habia dejado, obvio willow no estaba satisfecho ya que extrañaba a su hermano, y nos podemos dar cuenta que en el cap 11, Willow ve una cara familiar y es triste ya que se dio cuenta que Daysi Habia sido infectada..., al esto ya se podia dar cuenta que si su hermano estaba en busca de daysi igualmente se habria infectado como ella
Pony*
Daisy
I almost cried to this
Me to
😭
I did
I cried
i didn't
im a monster
It has been 1 year since this great chapter with the best ending in Piggy was released.
This explains all the notes in the cells at the station!
4:15 Willow, what are you looking at ?
1:44 if you look to the right, you can see Poley running into a table
Plus Doggy sleeps on his side on a thin bench? I mean, we are playing a game based off of peppa pig so we are equally as weird. *Too shay*
@Keaton Richards it is Poley, even the player's journey mention him at the refinery page, some skins has a different aspect on book 2 but they still being same ones
@Keaton Richards that infected thing is just a redesign of poley
IT'S "Touché" NOT "Too shay"
the ending was so sad, i was going to cry poor willow.
Our theory was right, Willow saw Infected Daisy and that maked she sad
Willow probably saw infected daisy during the ending of camp but brushed it off when they asked if willow was ok
@yufzinmito THAT MADE SENSE DUDE
@yufzinmito wth, why she don't has the eye of insolence
@yufzinmito She's not Delta, Delta's sleeve is torn
@@nuggetgameing she wearing glove
I bet the next character focused chapter will be even more sad
I mean the cutscene will be shorter so it might not be as much
@@Mr_Cheeze-r8y I think some of the chapter 12 endings will be like 13 minutes long
@@MythicalProductionsOffical yeah maybe that's too long
@@TERRARlA one of the endings in book 2 is 10 minutes
@@MythicalProductionsOffical true
3:21 this scene suprised me back in 2021 when i didnt know pony infected doggy
It suprised all of us, i thought it was Mr p or sheepy.
@@eddienarrea3638me too i thought it was mr p
I like how poley just walks casually
Others: He is such. a spoiler.
Him: am I joke to you? 😡
I completed the chapter within one hour of it's release and I was so happy that I completed it.
ZIZZY AND PONY KNEW EACH OTHER SINCE CHILDHOOD WHAT?!?
That explains why it’s cannon pony x zizzy
Question: How did you get the text small?
this is probably the saddest ending in piggy
Yep definitely
It is
Breakout?
Dang bro Heist is now 3 years old
This is what true men cry at
i like how poley ran into the table
I watched the video and at the ending it made me cry from how sad it was I feel so sorry for willow
Wow dude they finnaly show pony as a tsp and I didn't know billy was part of them to
that's why willow said everything was fine while looking at something at the end of chapter 11
This chapter solved a lot of mysteries such as rash daisy pony giving doggy the potion but it opened one mystery up that is what happened to billy…?
maybe we will get that question in future update maybe in book 3 if there is one? it might take a while like a year cuz we got the "who infected doggy" answer in about a year almost 2
Willam: imma leave willow: I got you a pie
Well. We lost alot of good people.
Daisy
Doggy
and
Zizzy
They were amazing people of ours. But we will not forget them.
probally we will get all them back
Dont forget Bunny too.
That hits hard:(
Question:
If you finish the map will you then play as willow forever
No
This is like a music video but also like a recap of the story so far which saddens me to know I have to relive these harsh feelings but it brings a tear to my eyes with the song
When I escaped this map, after the cutscene I almost cried 😢
I'm crying because of the song 😭😭
thanks so much for making this when i escaped my screen was broken and i couldn’t see the cut scene.
hol up, willow just burned down the alleys?
You know in intercity where Willows room is blocked, willow just burned her little room that’s all
@@royaltyfandomx Oh, yeah thanks for reminding me of that, but i haven't seen it in game, but i've only heard of it
The music ties it all together, the music is beautiful
Pony looks so funny without a hat 3:47
im proud of participated and beated this map
Not me crying over a VIDEO GAME 😭
I'm crying 😭
That's so sad! 😫
😭😭😭 I cried when Willow was Talking to William
This was one of the best chapters ever, and one of the saddest ones, sad because willow has lost everyone that she loved, her parents, william, and daisy, but we might see william again
I think she was hoping seeing daisy and William alive in The north
@@Italozito4913 daisys infected
@@Coolyes379 i know ,-,
most unlikely that william returns he is just a kid the chances that he got infected are super high cuz he is just a kid and i don't think he can survive on his own as a kid he might maybe he found somone else they worked togother but that is very unlikely
@@putiksgaming6548 Tell this to georgie that survived the infection in his own in the city for a long time
3:29 this cutscene made me cry
The music the story everything about the ending cutscene makes me sad thing is that for some reason I'm not spilling tears. What's wrong with me?
man i thought it gonna show how she met tigry, katie, kitty, baren, felix, and philp
Filip*
What about pandy
Foxy.
@@casique_dart8496 that’s felip.
@@xxx_mia_xxxx_renexxx5873 no foxy It's not Philip
i won twice the 1st time minitoon shut down the server ruining my cutscene and 2nd the menu overlapped the cutscene ruining it thank you for this video
IKR I GOT IT TO THE MENU RUINED IT WHEN I BEAT IT
So people in tsp are:
billy willow pony rash feilx foxy Katie kitty pandy baren phillip tigry
Willow burned down her home because it brought her back terrible memories of her childhood and she took the note that daisy left along with her
One thing I’m wondering is if we are imagining this or something because you never see player in parts where the player was there in cutscenes like where willow gets arrested or when doggy gets infected.
Because we escape as Willow, and if the cutscene tries to show the player it would show Willow instead
Makes sense thank you.
@@baldlisasimpson8976 bc this is a backstory we are not really there
What happened:
Rash is infected
Tigry was homeless
Pony obviously tried to infect the player (duh)
Pony leaves tsp
Daisy is infected, it’s what willow was looking at
Can’t believe I predicted Billy being apart of TSP in February.
Billy is in TSP boi he is sure buff he might be the one who own the rocket launcher back in the day so yeah
Wait delta MAYBE BILLY RAN AWAY TO SAVE RASH AND RAN AWAY TO DAISY BUT HE GOT INFECTED
2:04 R.I.P 🪦 Rash Chapter 1- Heist
I really want to know what the name of this song playing on the cutcene
Its called washed clean in the river
Love this!!!
Whats pony got?
Peppa pig episodes:
*There were cursed and heartbroken*
3:14 no doubt that plankton computer wife Karen
Green line black screen
Grey color
Looks like from the spongebob movie lol
guys the ending is sad right even the daisy part we will all miss daisy
We didn't really know daisy that much
this was the most saddest piggy cutscene i ever saw
me after i saw zizzy was still fine: phew :)
Me: when willow's friend daisy got infected: :[
me when william wolf was gone: ;((((((((((
I felt like this was chapter 12
i always get emotional by juat listening to this music
Hi I saw You made the opheebop Head love it btw but I was wondering could you make a cable crow head it's from the zardy mod
The ending was shocking.
There’s a edit after the 2 theories I have. Please read it after reading my theories
The ending was actually interesting. And why it was interesting, is that donkey Soldier. Willow was looking at the soldier. Why? You might say “That was daisy dude!” Or maybe she thought it was daisy. Uh oh theory time
I have 2 theories.
1: Willow thought she was daisy, but actually it wasn’t daisy. Look at the hand. There are fingers. And if you don’t know, male characters in piggy have normal hands. But with female characters, they have these weird looking hands like willow. So, maybe that wasn’t daisy.
2: Maybe that donkey soldier reminded willow about daisy. Idk how to explain this so ye you get the point
Ok, so people maybe right about the soldier being daisy, but I don’t want this ending up as a argument so uh ye
Also daisy is not delta because there isn’t the purple thing on the arm lol
I think minitoon made it Daisy, but accidentally did the male hands.
The rule of the hands don't always applies with all the characters, just most of them
Besides, that soldier had red eyes just like the skin in the shop, so most likely is the actual Daisy
The hands may be a mistake about mini because he was doing the Chapter fast and he just put daisy's head in one of the soldiers model and forgot about fingers lol
Good point you two.
Maybe it’s daisy
Ghosty: Am I a joke to you?
Nooo why daisy!!!! 🥺🥺🥺😢😢😢😢
😥 Poor Willow
I waiting for 12 chapter
3 book in 2022
No it’s going to be intercity
BEST CUTSCENE EVER!!!!!!!!!!
Yea
YEP BETTER THEN THE TRUE ENDING TOO
Poley: just runs into a table
wow soo a backstory that is sad and awsome too
At TIHS- ending piggy book chapter 12 l cry- l already Escape the chapter new piggy book and... it was so sad- :'( :
this ending made me cry A LOT
MY HART STOPPED WHEN I SAW DASY INFECTED 😩
this is so sad not only because her friends got infected but her foster mon or daisy got infected
Soooo goood