No one will doubt the strength of gem and jj. Them don’t need to lip-sync. Them are considered walking CDs by Asian listeners. Even when them are in bad condition...like having a cold, etc., them will not lip-sync.
I can tell you guys with confidence that GEM was singing live. However…. It’s very common that the TV stations love to do editing after the events before publishing the videos. Many times, the edited version is not as good or as natural as the original track. Unfortunately we have to live with the staff who edit and publish it. 😄
I came here for musical education LMAO. Despite not being a singer in any form, I love how this channel educates me about music and makes me aware of different techniques that singers use and their unique styles! This channel is really inspiring! Thanks for producing such wonderful content!
That won't help. She's too biased. She just wanted to use her reaction to pick on top singers to show off how good she was. I realized that when she reacted to 張宇 last time. There is a term in Chinese for this kind: 碰瓷。
來自天堂的魔鬼 is my favourite GEM song. Written by her and arranged by Lupo Groinig. Sad that she doesn't have ownership of this song and many of her other songs. Might not see her perform those songs again on screen. 😥😥
@@onosakuya8687 Yep, that was in the contract. I heard some countries in the EU, it is illegal to put that in the contract. However, in the US and Hong Kong it is legal. So depends on the regulations of the region.
@@Junispro31 I hope she did, I wasn't following. However, I think rights don't apply to what you sing in concerts. But if GEM records and sells a disc of the concert... 🤔🤔
If I remember correctly, GEM has a condition concerning her jaw which makes her hard to position her mouth in a certain way. Which is probably why it looks like lip-syncing. However, there is definitely post production editing due to this being a China program as they really strive for perfection during these shows.
What if you try to look for audience recorded "live" versions instead of the versions edited by TV? Fans usually record and release more unedited footage when they are in the audience at these events
If you think about that is a great points to push up her professional skill, so she can attractive more view points, I was thinking for long time. Finally, I got the result. She is going to find some points to push up their business. They are doing a business. That's it!
Speaking about audience number, GEM breaks a record recently as a female singer in organising concerts in China. She extends the consecutive number of days from 2 to 3 in both Guangzhou and Shenzhen sports stadium. She was able to attract a total of 330,000 people for her recent 10 days of concert at 4 Chinese cities only. You may base on an average of 33,000 plus audience if using her recent concert video clips in future.
@@dashingno6 Go check the fan made one if you aren't hater. The teacher are doing a business reaction. She have to found the selling point to push up her viewing points. Also , this is a CG video editing on top, so it will be late a little bit when you are playing the video. I don't think you are stubie like that? Ha! Ha!
Actually Gem has done a live cover of “Amazing grace “ which is the one that everyone knew. You could find it on TH-cam. I highly recommend to you . Cause that more easy for you to relate and understand her magic.
I think the song lyrics about the head being blown away is meant to convey the meaning of one’s mind being blown 🤯 instead of a bloody sene of murder 😂
@user-ts6no6qt1l: Yes, she is professional on some where, she is earning some money on her own business. Why don't she get the original video from G.E.M. or fans made one? The teacher are doing a business reaction. She have to found the selling point to push up her viewing points. Go check the fan made one. Also , this is a CG video editing on top, so it will be late a little bit when you are playing the video. I did video editing on videos, so I know the problem. I think you learn some more on that. Ha! Ha!
Should remind Rosette that GEM’s presence in Asia is like Taylor Swift. She is a singer-song writer who composes almost 100% of her songs and writes the lyrics. It will save her further questions in future reviews.
You really compare gem with Taylor swift. I’m not a fan of either and I even dislike both but despite that I can say Gem is nothing like Taylor swift when it comes to impact and showmanship. Be realistic ffs
And the part she handed mic to audience few times. You saying they pre-recorded her not singing and handing mic also I can tell you. Its just post editing desync not lipsync. I challenge you. Do a MR REMOVED too
8:19 很欣賞老師說的。就事論事。
而且也讓我長知識，原來可以這麽多後製及做法。
痾...其實後製這些動作 不是說不好
畢竟不管是演唱會還是一些演出
舉辦單位(歌手)總是想把最好的一面呈現出來
這點沒有所謂誰對誰錯
甚至演唱會你也不想花了錢去聽了個寂寞吧？
看看某男團、唱得亂七八糟還不接受各種批評？呵呵.....
他們那樣對得起花錢去聽演唱會的人嗎？
Rozette老師也說其實這些都沒什麼
她比較有看法感想的主要都是在技巧、技術、音色上
說真的、Rozette老師自己本身在唱歌上也是很厲害的
所以也當然會有自己的見解跟詮釋歌曲的不同
但無倫是國內國外、流行歌、復古歌、爵士還是唱跳
都擺脫不了本來該有的技巧技術層面
所以我認為Rozette老師講解的真的都非常好。
可以看最近GEM在香港大球場的Amazing Grace，現場0修音
鄧紫棋的存在也超棒
老師的講話本身就是一門藝術
不能認同更多👍🏼
評論區一大堆自以為是 好似好撚叻嘅自滿行為
No one will doubt the strength of gem and jj. Them don’t need to lip-sync. Them are considered walking CDs by Asian listeners.
Even when them are in bad condition...like having a cold, etc., them will not lip-sync.
9:05
支持你們❤我是GEM的鐵粉，對我而言她是最棒最好的！但我也喜歡你們的點評，真的客觀。如果換做我來點評西方歌手，帶著不認識他們的來歷要做點評也一定會被罵翻的。很開心你們有喜歡她的表演❤演唱本來就不是比賽或考試，每場有好有壞，即便世界最偉大的人也有人討厭，而即使世界最糟糕的人也會有人愛他，希望你們不要被惡評擊倒，Rozette老師很厲害，希望可以有更多紫棋的影片❤❤🎉
❤
邓紫棋真的是为数不多能驾驭多种曲风的歌手 希望她可以在国际舞台有更大的成就
謝謝！
老師怎麼能一句就聽出來，也太厲害
建議可以去看有現場翻拍的版本 證明GEM 的確沒對嘴唱，但是影片大多都有後製的居多是沒錯
不可能用飯拍的啦 飯拍音質聽了太痛苦了
老師：Jayyyyyyyy!!!!!!!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
怎麼覺得看這個比歌手2024還精采啊?
講真的啦...那些某國的歌場選秀節目的評審
誇張了說就是根本沒什麼資格就是....
甚至有些是連唱歌都不會，一個不懂唱歌的人去當歌唱評審？
更別說其他一些歌手當評審，他們連自己能力也就那樣而已
也能去當評審？當然我知道他們也只是去賺錢的
但是........評審評審....他們不知道當他們在舞台上當評審時
破壞了多少真正有能力歌唱者的夢
那些某國的歌唱節目甚至有些都是內定的
有些都是為了讓節目效果更好，什麼吵架、被評審直接用火辣用詞噴臉
這樣真的好嗎？？？為什麼Rozette老師以前沒現在有名？
因為更多人看了她的影片才知道什麼叫"中立&客觀"而有"技術"的評論
跟那些為了賺錢而譁眾取寵胡說八道一堆的評審好幾百倍。
真的❤。認同。陸綜追求的效果跟流量，劇本跟做假只是日常😂
聲樂老師是專業人士
她的評價也都是聽到什麼給出什麼評價
就像老師說的她知道鄧紫棋的演唱實力
但是大陸節目更重視的是視聽的感受
有時候製作團隊真的會過多後製
專業的交給專業
喜歡鄧紫棋的就繼續喜歡
超理解老師想表達的
很多人喜歡把某些字眼當正純正或純反面的意思
其實根本不是這樣
敲碗鄧紫棋翻唱的存在！！
GEM的上下顎是天生合不成的，她吃東西也有小問題，曾經想做手術，但最終放棄。所以人們覺得她含着水唱歌，她自己也知道。但也因為這樣成為個人特有的風格。她對嘴比不對嘴難😊，我並不是GEM的粉絲，但我知道事實並尊敬她
I can tell you guys with confidence that GEM was singing live. However…. It’s very common that the TV stations love to do editing after the events before publishing the videos. Many times, the edited version is not as good or as natural as the original track. Unfortunately we have to live with the staff who edit and publish it. 😄
‘’來自天堂的魔鬼‘’的講評，深刻感受到老師對音樂的熱愛！😊
老師太厲害了，我一點也分不到😂，耳朵不夠靈敏，眼睛不夠仔細，專業的還真是專業的
I came here for musical education LMAO. Despite not being a singer in any form, I love how this channel educates me about music and makes me aware of different techniques that singers use and their unique styles! This channel is really inspiring! Thanks for producing such wonderful content!
Please try to check Gem Tang live performance at HK stadium with Amazing Grace
老師可以聽聽Gem香港大球場唱amazing Grace嘅現場，差不多是清唱！
GEM唱LIVE功力無懈可撃, 老師真的真的要拿"Gem香港大球場唱amazing Grace及西班牙版GLORIA嘅LIVE點評點評
老師可聽聽gem香港大球場這板本th-cam.com/video/cOTmvgbkOsc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=gw5jy0ON3da1fJ4e
Gem這次演唱勁嘅唔只現場0修音清唱完美稳定，而係當時現場環境因素！頂住幾萬個被怒火引爆的球迷，還可以有這樣完美水準表現！由出場前全場噓聲震天到開唱幾秒全場安靜，唱完全場起立鼓掌！！真的服！！
That won't help. She's too biased. She just wanted to use her reaction to pick on top singers to show off how good she was. I realized that when she reacted to 張宇 last time. There is a term in Chinese for this kind: 碰瓷。
推薦老師re她唱在時光音樂會唱的讓世界暫停一分鐘 很獨樹一幟
你不是第一個離開的人 也很讚
老師請繼續評論 很喜歡❤讓我聽了平時不會接觸到的東西
希望找live的 節目不管怎樣都喜歡修一下
或是飯拍的
阿GEM的飯拍從出道至今沒上萬也上千條片了，這頻道只會找音源清晰的節目版，然後說對嘴了後製了，然後黑子就來了
@@ans-n3n 飯拍的音質聽了很痛苦啊
Naurrrrr she's on fire no matter what she made 😎🔥🔥
想跟你們説一件事，近幾年在中國所有經過錄製的，無論真唱假唱，其實都不止錄一次，有時候會要求歌手現場唱個兩三次，加上後期修音跟剪接，對不上只能怪節目吧😅以我所知天空沒有極限的現場至少唱了整整兩遍，作為fans的我絕對信任，但想跟你們說的是，錄製的現場演唱，以我了解全部歌手都是一樣的做法，同一首歌錄好幾次讓節目組去挑他們要哪一段，當然你們可以懷疑，但我只能説她不可能也不會假唱，而這條影片也無從考究。如果你們很執著現場演唱的感覺，建議去找那種真現場直播，比如是各大跨年演唱會，那些比較真的能看到是否為真唱喔
這不是作為fans的辨解，而是想要澄清，至少她出道這麼多年以來，狀態好壞她都是扎扎實實地去唱，你們願意找也會找到比較不好狀態的時候，她也是一樣真唱，對於她被冤枉是對嘴的我表示很難過，希望你們能看到原因。還有一點是，GEM現在對版權很執着，首先這跟CD版本差蠻多的，再來就是也不會為了一個現象特地去錄一個音給節目播，以她對版權的執著怎麼可能會留給節目，現場唱就好了啊，這也是她不可能也不會假唱的原因，望知悉。
沒錯，這可能是他們不太了解中國在製作節目的方式
th-cam.com/video/LJQBRnYscPQ/w-d-xo.html 七年前華晨宇【齊天大聖】 3:00秒開始就發現影片段落的穿幫，上一顆鏡頭跟下一顆鏡頭居然踩在不一樣的箱子上🤣🤣
這並不是最近而又非地域性的發生，自專業錄音室面世工藝數碼化視影藝節目娛樂行業上所有畫、音、特技、剪接、編輯都是有所謂修音修改加插，所謂‘完美’才推出去面世見大家。音樂畫面修輯完可以更濃縮順暢精彩呈現。
實力還是普通歌手現場的確很难每場粉丝來自世界不同地付費看演出 100%每首像CD一樣，很吃歌手身體嗓子時長難度發揮都是肉體，為了不辜負現場觀眾我相信都是真唱（春晚流水控時不能出錯大型節目例外）同一首很多歌手都會在現場與網上聽曲時有一點小小不一樣唱法，現場有小失误大家都不介意支持度，喜欢依舊喜欢不介意也無必要假唱不然請歌手來幹嘛。如果要聽CD品質不如留在家聽，但去到現場假唱為了粉丝割韭菜那就過份了。節目因時效性不及Live show 可以重錄反覆修改加插達至最好的面相狀態才推出。
純粹個人看法😂
不可能？有證據嗎？沒有的話萬一真打呢，你要磕頭謝罪嗎
@@dashingno6 那先請你拿出她在假唱的證據吧，不要拿著一段經過剪輯畫面，經過節目修音製作過的來評判喔謝謝😊如果你不願意相信，那至少從客觀的角度跟你説單憑這段影片是不足以考究的。
推薦紫棋近期在香港大球場現場直播唱的Amazing Grace和西班牙語版的Gloria
來自天堂的魔鬼 is my favourite GEM song. Written by her and arranged by Lupo Groinig. Sad that she doesn't have ownership of this song and many of her other songs. Might not see her perform those songs again on screen. 😥😥
even is she write this song but still don't have ownership of this song？😮
@@onosakuya8687 Yep, that was in the contract. I heard some countries in the EU, it is illegal to put that in the contract. However, in the US and Hong Kong it is legal. So depends on the regulations of the region.
@@mage9825 GEM got the rights back again if I'm not mistaken
@mage9825 In her latest tour I AM GLORIA this song is included in the performances
@@Junispro31 I hope she did, I wasn't following. However, I think rights don't apply to what you sing in concerts. But if GEM records and sells a disc of the concert... 🤔🤔
為了「但我記旋律比她準😜」這句給「👍🏻」了！
兩位可愛的老師！！👍🏻🫡🤗
橘子老師的個性真是「真」得很可愛！也很有愛心、很幽默～🥰
杰凱老師也幽默得可愛～🥳
這版本不是他們自己找的，是粉絲推薦的，然而這版本不論是人為問題還是技術問題，這都是一次真實的對「這版本」的評價，在情可以相信歌手不會假唱，在理這個呈獻就是有假唱疑點。
他們做的這系列一直都是評價對該影片的初體驗，不會事先去調查影片裏的歌手/歌曲/舞台。
所以一直在澄清和合理化該版本的粉絲或觀眾真的大可不必，我作為一直以來的觀眾（雖然沒訂閱）可不想這系列以後作評論時要顧慮粉絲而綁手綁腳
I excited for the upcoming GEM reaction even tho Rozette already listen to versions of that song 5, 6 times lol.
如果唔係她提點，一般人應該都難以相信！要來回咁睇先會睇到問題所在！感謝妳又學識多樣嘢！
其實老師講左佢聽過GEM的live，亦認同GEM能夠唱live，老師只係指出唔係每次表演都可以由歌手選擇唱live
很喜欢看GEM唱歌享受的样子，仿佛自信，尽在掌握的样子😊
跨年的时候江苏卫视全是没修音的，看的我爽死了
Your subtitles translated are very funny 😂
這個年代的華語樂壇，GEM就是TOP，她經過很多訓練，從寫不完的溫柔開始注意到她....
老師也太厲害了吧,雖不懂中文但也還是聽得出來~~~
我真的都好奇為什麼你們都習慣打出"阿~雖然她不懂中文"之類的話？
奇怪了......你真的知道她在評論什麼嗎？
不管你是國內國外還是流行歌復古歌老歌什麼歌
都一定有基本的技術技巧音色
這些跟你是唱什麼歌詞完全無關阿......
她為什麼會聽不出來？她又不需要知道你唱什麼歌詞
她聽的是屬於她專業的歌唱地方
為什麼老是在說她不懂中文還聽得出來..........到底是？？？
開心見到你地有咁多gem既視頻
越来越喜欢她了，真的好同情达理啊！
只能说我某种程度上认同老师说的。因为中国制作的节目，除了现场直播，几乎都很少听出“现场感”。就算没有修音，也会后期把一些其它的声音去掉。就好像之前评的JJ在《梦想的声音》唱的歌，也是这样的情况。
虽然这种纯享版可以减少听歌者被干扰，但我更愿意听到“现场感”，我会更喜欢找演唱会的演出来听。如果要听无干扰版本，那去听原本的音源就好了啊。
為什麼這個老師這麼多次的制作視頻都不用, G.E.M. 原裝自拍同飯拍無加CG 效果的MV? 又無看呀？你知唔知道加CG 後的MV 還delate㗎? 因為她們為的是推薦自己有多專業? 她們在做商業视頻! 有些不專業的觀衆, 愚蠢的黑粉, 人家唱錯歌詞呀. 聰明一點都明白為什麼! 好有基心的老師團隊. 慢慢妳會發現這個老師同團隊不喜歡鄧還是在做戲. 也太好笑他們的愚蠢!.
If I remember correctly, GEM has a condition concerning her jaw which makes her hard to position her mouth in a certain way. Which is probably why it looks like lip-syncing.
However, there is definitely post production editing due to this being a China program as they really strive for perfection during these shows.
GEM is a GEM
推荐老师 GEM的 hell 和 gloria
hell：th-cam.com/video/SMiqPoP82z4/w-d-xo.htmlsi=5FE0kY-pNdn5gWWM
gloria：th-cam.com/video/WgK3Euy_Vfo/w-d-xo.htmlsi=fh1c4FbKNwdYmRoA
都是现场哦
希望多react我是歌手时候唱的歌，《你把我灌醉》《存在》《我要我们在一起》
還有 如果沒有你 你不是真正的快樂
gem❤❤❤
that is so real. and that is G.E.M!!
老师讲魔鬼那首讲到好激情激动
What if you try to look for audience recorded "live" versions instead of the versions edited by TV? Fans usually record and release more unedited footage when they are in the audience at these events
If you think about that is a great points to push up her professional skill, so she can attractive more view points, I was thinking for long time. Finally, I got the result. She is going to find some points to push up their business. They are doing a business. That's it!
老師太厲害了👍
那麼細膩的地方都看的出來
好厲害，一聽就知道有後制，但其實最美之夜這個跨年有些片段會被拿去做MV，所以都會後制過，可能在現場是真的沒還音，所以不用為這個吵架，這個只有她本人才會知道有沒有對嘴，還有GEM現在這個哭腔跟鼻腔是她故意創造出來的一個風格，她以前唱歌不是這樣的，慢慢地找出自己的特色，這個就變成他的標誌了，而且運用的很自如，GEM的歌幾乎都是她自己作詞作曲
可是rap部分因为这个鼻音很多人反馈听不懂歌词
@@Peachu_n_Goma_Home 沒差，風格就這樣，周杰倫也是
她不是聼出來的，她是看出來的。
不是他們專業. 為什麼這個老師這麼多次的制作視頻都不用, G.E.M. 原裝自拍同飯拍無加CG 效果的MV? 又無看呀？你知唔知道加CG 後的MV delate㗎? 因為她們為的是推薦自己有多專業? 她們在做商業视頻! 有些不專業的觀衆, 愚蠢的黑粉, 人家唱錯歌詞呀. 聰明一點都明白為什麼! 好有機心的老師團隊. 慢慢妳會發現這個老師同團隊不喜歡鄧還是在做戲. 也太好笑他們的愚蠢!
@@knobknobbiwah4784 我比較好奇的是，香港為什麼連打字都用粵語？根本看不懂….
有誰跟我一樣看了其中一個樂評後追完整個頻道的，這老師好強..
希望 可以點評閩南語歌曲看看～
例如 二姐江惠的歌
這老師眼睛耳朵 真是專業
并不是耳朵，而是觉得有点对嘴形，觉得视频中张嘴的程度和麦距所呈现的跟音频不太一致
@@lilili7798 你傻了嗎？是耳朵好嗎？別拿你的程度跟老師比
@user-oi7mu1qi9i: 為什麼這個老師這麼多次的制作視頻都不用, G.E.M. 原裝自拍同飯拍無加CG 效果的MV? 又無看呀？你知唔知道加CG 後的MV 還delate㗎? 因為她們為的是推薦自己有多專業? 她們在做商業视頻! 有些不專業的觀衆, 愚蠢的黑粉, 人家唱錯歌詞呀. 聰明一點都明白為什麼! 好有基心的老師團隊. 慢慢妳會發現這個老師同團隊不喜歡鄧還是在做戲. 也太好笑他們的愚蠢!.
g.e.m is sung live
簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍
遇廣告看完看🈵
Speaking about audience number, GEM breaks a record recently as a female singer in organising concerts in China. She extends the consecutive number of days from 2 to 3 in both Guangzhou and Shenzhen sports stadium. She was able to attract a total of 330,000 people for her recent 10 days of concert at 4 Chinese cities only. You may base on an average of 33,000 plus audience if using her recent concert video clips in future.
我放«天空»的飯拍連結上來，百分百GEM現場唱的：
th-cam.com/video/CIda3GjL7MI/w-d-xo.htmlfeature=shared
後製做了什麼我不知道，但GEM當時必然現場唱了的，因為若是GEM假唱，早在錄製完後一定有現場觀眾出來爆料的，這麼好的黑材料不拿出來不符合人性；可是從來沒有人指出她在現場假唱！
阿GEM從未成年出道至今，多的是飯拍，頻道管理人若是要找百分百無後製的，大可以去找飯拍版！GEM自小在港參加歌唱比賽，她唱現場的經驗超過她出道年資，廿幾歲就唱了過百場演唱會，就算近日泉州演唱會一直咳，還是真唱！這麼個歌手，當時必然唱現場！
@@fzs7046其實有些人就是很想有意無意地胡亂加插假唱罪名來侮辱人，他們就算看了這些fans cam明知是真唱，也會繼續拍些reaction暗示人家是假唱來博取眼球！不是第一次了，懂的都懂😊
不是他們專業. 為什麼這個老師這麼多次的制作視頻都不用, G.E.M. 原裝自拍同飯拍無加CG 效果的MV? 又無看呀？你知唔知道加CG 後的MV 還delate㗎? 因為她們為的是推薦自己有多專業? 她們在做商業视頻! 有些不專業的觀衆, 愚蠢的黑粉, 人家唱錯歌詞呀. 聰明一點都明白為什麼! 好有機心的老師團隊. 慢慢妳會發現這個老師同團隊不喜歡鄧還是在做戲. 也太好笑他們的愚蠢!
我挺喜歡GEM也覺得這個老師沒講錯什麼，她本來就認同鄧的實力覺得她唱得好，只是這場最後呈現在她眼前是這個樣子，叫她去看其他場沒有必要阿...評論區裡部分鄧粉真的是信仰高高高高高到好敗路人緣...
You guys should try to watch review and react to their guess who's the original singer show
推薦老師去評論 gem今年在時光音樂會的歌
大部分都是他自己的歌 還有少部分翻唱
很值得去探討 會更了解她如何詮釋歌曲 更多的是情感的表達 而不是唱功的表現
时光音樂會修音更誇張，沒有現場感
等到花儿也谢了
老师真的很厉害.
老师可以reaction邓紫棋在最近全球巡演的一些现场！！或者时光音乐会的
你想說什麼？老師並沒有否認GEM有唱現場的能力好嗎？但就討論這首歌而已，這首歌就不是現場，是對嘴的，說很多次的，對嘴沒有什麼不好，也不會因為這首歌不是現場就否認GEM的現場實力好嗎？別這麼急著澄清
@@dashingno6 這首不是對嘴，是後期沒修好
@@dashingno6 是後製問題吧 GEM怎麼可能對嘴= =
後製肯定有，但G.E.M.一定不會對嘴
怎麼一定，怎麼保證，有證明嗎？還是你是哪位音樂大師，不然你嘴巴說出來的保證，挺好笑的
@@dashingno6那你怎保證她有對嘴？有證據嗎？
@@dashingno6 愚蠢的黑粉, 人家唱錯歌詞呀. 無看呀？原裝自拍同飯拍無加CG 效果的MV又無看呀？ 聰明一點唔得呀？ 笑死!.
@@dashingno6 Go check the fan made one if you aren't hater. The teacher are doing a business reaction. She have to found the selling point to push up her viewing points. Also , this is a CG video editing on top, so it will be late a little bit when you are playing the video. I don't think you are stubie like that? Ha! Ha!
@@dashingno6 不需要音樂大師就能肯定了 因為是錄製節目 必修音
老師很可愛！滿喜歡看她講解的。
Jay , 其實老師那麼喜歡黃霄雲跟林俊傑， 他倆有唱過同一首歌： 我們的愛， 黃霄雲有一段比賽的版本， 但其實它有唱過林俊傑的版本，但找不到現場版， 也可以用比賽的版本跟林俊傑一起做reaction , 相信老師一定會很喜歡， 我是黃霄雲的粉絲
物理的 my head is blown away 是吧哈哈哈......笑死了，不过真的很喜欢这首歌，以前总听的。
後製:你們這樣是要我沒飯吃嗎? 我怕別人說我們沒事做啊!!
這老師真的超級猛的，其他評審根本不在同一級別😂
對呀，看完她的影片才知道原來自己是半聾
她說有多明顯的部分我也聽不到😂😂
End on a "high note", smart 😜
其實GEM 演唱的歌，很多都有歌迷的飯拍版本，可以拿出來比較。這首也有。
m.th-cam.com/video/wtDPek2vOfQ/w-d-xo.html&pp=ygUNR2VtIGJpbGliaWxpIA%3D%3D
推
這直拍也是聲音嘴型沒對上🤔，也是被換音源了吧。
Actually Gem has done a live cover of “Amazing grace “ which is the one that everyone knew. You could find it on TH-cam. I highly recommend to you . Cause that more easy for you to relate and understand her magic.
其實我認為最好的辦法，是在搜尋這場表演的字條後面加上一個 “fancam”，看看現場粉絲手機中的錄製，便知道到底是假唱？還是節目後期將音軌調換。
我個人比較偏向後者，因為依稀記得之前GEM在台灣演出《摩天動物園》的時候，明明直播或者fancam都是有一句唱錯歌詞的，但後期上傳的影片直接把那句調整了
這樣的操作的確是把我震驚了😂
其實不調也沒有所謂吧
站在發行方的角度，能調還是調吧，目的都是為了宣傳造勢，肯定得“萬無一失”。
強如陳奕迅出演唱會DVD也調音的，他10多年前節目上自己說的。
@@lorenzoxiong2611 是的，雖然會沒有了現場的感覺，但這是無可奈何的
不是他們專業. 為什麼這個老師這麼多次的制作視頻都不用, G.E.M. 原裝自拍同飯拍無加CG 效果的MV? 又無看呀？你知唔知道加CG 後的MV 還delate㗎? 因為她們為的是推薦自己有多專業? 她們在做商業视頻! 有些不專業的觀衆, 愚蠢的黑粉, 人家唱錯歌詞呀. 聰明一點都明白為什麼! 好有機心的老師團隊. 慢慢妳會發現這個老師同團隊不喜歡鄧還是在做戲. 也太好笑他們的愚蠢!
If Rosette listened till the end first, it’s not hard to tell that GEM was singing live. 😊
I think the song lyrics about the head being blown away is meant to convey the meaning of one’s mind being blown 🤯 instead of a bloody sene of murder 😂
I love when she was asking for validation. Adorable xD
老師肯定開了血輪眼
我身為中文母語者然後看不出來真羞愧😂
笑死我了 😂B站上面還一大堆人在那邊 "沒問題" "她本來咬字就這樣" "她天生的" "我不是GEM粉絲, 但嘴型沒問題" "這嘴形能發出這個音"😂😂😂😂
JAY 也是... 一開始就已經非常明顯了其實... 我首刷在B站看的, 本來在認真看老師, 用餘光都看到好像有點怪怪... 然後老師馬上就說了
一連說了這麼多個地方還"不明顯" 😅😅😅 我能理解老師為什麼 "Come ON!!!" 你😂
中國製作組的問題，可以去看看其他留言，我自己看其他歌手也是這樣的，希望可以解答你的疑問，我承認我是粉絲，但我不是沒有眼睛，也有了解過，紫棋的實力我們粉絲常看直播都知道。
@123BLueBee: 為什麼這個老師這麼多次的制作視頻都不用, G.E.M. 原裝自拍同飯拍無加CG 效果的MV? 又無看呀？你知唔知道加CG 後的MV 還delate㗎? 因為她們為的是什麼推薦自己有多專業? 她們在做商業视頻! 有些不專業的觀衆, 愚蠢的黑粉, 人家唱錯歌詞呀. 聰明一點都明白為什麼! 好有基心的老師團隊. 也太好笑他們的愚蠢!
@@knobknobbiwah4784 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
中國影片一堆純享後製，被改多少誰知道
相信老師的專業❤❤❤
@user-ts6no6qt1l: Yes, she is professional on some where, she is earning some money on her own business. Why don't she get the original video from G.E.M. or fans made one? The teacher are doing a business reaction. She have to found the selling point to push up her viewing points. Go check the fan made one. Also , this is a CG video editing on top, so it will be late a little bit when you are playing the video. I did video editing on videos, so I know the problem. I think you learn some more on that. Ha! Ha!
其實可以給老師這首歌在時光音樂會最後一期有個live bank的版本😂
2:31 尾音那邊，麥克風都拿掉了但還有聲音，很明顯
老师可能想表达的意思是：现场是真唱 但是节目放出来的时候可能会使用比现场更完美的版本替换原音轨
When GEM was sick, she also sung without using the pre-recorded sound. It mustn't the decision from GEM for the performance in this video
希望评论一些经典影视作品，爱如 铁血丹心，男儿当自强，等等！
我好愛這個老師
想听老师评价她的西班牙语版的启示录专辑里的歌
老師如此肯定，我也可以確定我的耳朵和眼睛壞了
她的歌99.9％都是她自已作曲作詞的，其實想聽真實版本不如播飯拍就好了！
老师真的很厉害，但也很好胜😂 我身为老师你竟然不相信我说的话，难以相信的表情
时光音乐会现场那个感觉真的是live欸
为老师的专业点赞👍
不是他們專業. 為什麼這個老師這麼多次的制作視頻都不用, G.E.M. 原裝自拍同飯拍無加CG 效果的MV? 又無看呀？你知唔知道加CG 後的MV 還delate㗎? 因為她們為的是推薦自己有多專業? 她們在做商業视頻! 有些不專業的觀衆, 愚蠢的黑粉, 人家唱錯歌詞呀. 聰明一點都明白為什麼! 好有機心的老師團隊. 慢慢妳會發現這個老師同團隊不喜歡鄧還是在做戲. 也太好笑他們的愚蠢!
我想認真看完的都應該知道老師想表達的是電視台播放出來的音源是有可能被剪輯過的，老師也多次的說過鄧紫棋的實力很好，我不覺得需要爭吵，之前也聲明過，老師只針對她所聽到的做說明，而且老師明顯是因為左邊的人沒聽出來而氣噗噗😂看了原因再回去帶著耳機聽明顯會發現正常的氣息斷掉了，就像是剪掉一樣不自然的消失，之前看左邊應該是有在從事類似工作，所以老師才會很訝異他沒聽出來
感覺的到老師在糾結的點，因為我看到02:55 這段的畫面的時候也有一點覺得畫面跟聲音對不上
但是多看幾次後發現好像又不是差太遠
我之前看過的中國歌唱節目，確實有音軌對不上的情況
但有可能是因為後期製作時的失誤就是了
可以聽看看鄧紫棋啟示錄那張專輯 全自創真的很棒❤雖然有些可能不好找現場的不過旋律是真的很讚
這也是我少數能一直播放的全專輯
recommend to use fan cams~~~
Should remind Rosette that GEM’s presence in Asia is like Taylor Swift. She is a singer-song writer who composes almost 100% of her songs and writes the lyrics. It will save her further questions in future reviews.
You really compare gem with Taylor swift. I’m not a fan of either and I even dislike both but despite that I can say Gem is nothing like Taylor swift when it comes to impact and showmanship. Be realistic ffs
@@darnna taylor swift can't sing..she's an idol...sorry to her deluded fans
今天了终于！！！！
And the part she handed mic to audience few times. You saying they pre-recorded her not singing and handing mic also
I can tell you. Its just post editing desync not lipsync. I challenge you. Do a MR REMOVED too
pleaseee review more a lin songs and vids , really would like to see you views on her