It’s June 2022 post release of C/C, both John and Colin are no longer with the band . I find something is grossly lacking in the band, but they go on and the fans are happy that thay made something after 12 years
@@arunsabherwal6256 Their new album is awesome but I think Steven made a mistake in not inviting Colin back for the album and for not bringing John W back for the tour. It is what it is. I would rather have a partial PT than no PT.
So heart-warming to see a band's fans not hating on an alternate vocalist. This track is my favourite PT track of all time, and so often overlooked - this version is heavenly! Danke für's Posten!
I sat in the room with a view The girl in the photograph knew Can't you see? Why is she laughing at me? I stumbled through the dark unaware The face in the hall isn't there Tomorrow has gone Where do the voices come from? Watching the leaves as they blew Lost in the room with a view Climb the walls You did not know me at all I fell through a hole in the floor The audience cried out for more Fade away It's just another day Hit heaven far too high.
Wesley's vocals are truly great and almost make it a different song, but while both versions are fantastic in their own right, I have to say I really liked how Steven's much more ethereal interpretation beautifully enhanced the song's dream-like texture. And of course, needless to say, Harrison's drums are a fantastic addition as well.
This song, this version, takes me to a place of calm and peace. Peace I could never find elsewhere. Calmness almost catatonic in intensity. AHHHHHHH . . . .
I love Porcupine Tree in any of their versions. I love other experiments with Steve Wilson behind (like for example i Blackfield) too. This piece of music is simply wonderful. Thank you for posting it!
I absolutely love Steven Wilson's voice, but John Wesley's voice is out of this world. A very irish voice that gives me goosebumps every time I hear it. I darn miss this guy in the band!
@@JGJ505They're different. Wilson's voice is better for darker atmospheres filled with anguish and regret, whereas Wesley's is more bluesy, warm and sexy.
When hear the voice, that tells me to stay........When I hear that voice, that tells me it's not, ....Not just another day,..... Floating along the ceiling, .. Floating on the edge, ... I can still hear the voice , . .That tells me to stay......Look to the light and walk on through.... Hold the night that tells me it's true... Just speak to the stranger, who holds all the clues, .. Spinning top minds just come along through........Lets all just stay, ... Lets not just fadeaway.......................
At their best Porcupine Tree are nothing short of majestic. I certaiBands of this stnly hope that they return some day. They are missed !!!! Bands of this stature are rare in today's world of pap dressed up as little more than product ot be shifted and profited from.
Jonh Wesley has never been given his due for his contributions to the band, and the best version of this song (with Gavin). I hope they will bring him back, along with Colin (but that's another story) 🤔
John Wesley's vocals just took the song to a whole different level.
really..?!
I prefer SW voice...
How do you know the op meant a better level? 😉
Great alternate version...does he sing on anything else?
@@nickmeyer6777 he did a great job in "my ashes" live in tillburg... check that out...
John Wesley makes Porcupine Tree reach a higher level when they are on a concert. A perfect band with a magic admixture.
Sono d'accordo, la bellezza di una band è data dall'alchimia che si crea tra i musicisti, non dalla tecnica o altro.
It’s June 2022 post release of C/C, both John and Colin are no longer with the band . I find something is grossly lacking in the band, but they go on and the fans are happy that thay made something after 12 years
@@arunsabherwal6256 Their new album is awesome but I think Steven made a mistake in not inviting Colin back for the album and for not bringing John W back for the tour. It is what it is. I would rather have a partial PT than no PT.
Amazing performance by John Wesley as always, he is so talented... We miss you friend.
This version should be on the spotify
I Miss PT
Johns vocal .....Wow!!!! Loved this track before... But adore this version
Totally absolutely agree with you...just brilliant.
Everything I've heard by PT sounds so much better live. JW gives them another dimension.
Possibly my favorite PT song ever, with Wes on vocals. Sublime.
Pfffffff... 25 years and never got tired of them...if not Pink Floyd this is the Rock band of all time..
Porcupine Tree is Definitively Better Than Pink Floyd...
@@qntristan Your opinion
@@human678 My opinion
Definitely better than Pink Floyd.
QnTristran
….apples and bowling balls, neighbor…
So heart-warming to see a band's fans not hating on an alternate vocalist. This track is my favourite PT track of all time, and so often overlooked - this version is heavenly! Danke für's Posten!
It startled me, but Wesley was always a good secondary vocalist, and I think I like the live version of My Ashes better because of him.
I love Jon Wesley and I’m so sad he is not touring with PT
Wes is an excellent vocalist. Checkout his solo work, it’s all excellent in both playing and vocals.
Świetny wokal! Bije Stivena!
Wesley is loved ❤❤❤❤❤
John's vocals... just amazing!
this is pure magic
I forgot when I wrote this, think was high as hell, cheers
Watched this over and over again. Completely love this version
John's vocals are incredible here. God, I love Up The Downstairs version, but this one is just HEAVENLY!
In a word and meaning this is sublime.
Wow love JW voice... perfection to PT.. 😉
What I wouldn’t do to have the opportunity to see this band live before I die.
are you a member of the website?
RAH is my plan on his next tour.
Me too Brother
I was blessed to be able to see them live in New York six times between 2006-2010. Every moment was catharsis. Wouldn’t trade it for the world.
I was fortunate to see them at radio city during their last tour . They were amazing, hope they reunite someday.
hey guess what
I sat in the room with a view
The girl in the photograph knew
Can't you see?
Why is she laughing at me?
I stumbled through the dark unaware
The face in the hall isn't there
Tomorrow has gone
Where do the voices come from?
Watching the leaves as they blew
Lost in the room with a view
Climb the walls
You did not know me at all
I fell through a hole in the floor
The audience cried out for more
Fade away
It's just another day
Hit heaven far too high.
I’m back. God I love this song. Wesley sounds so incredible on this. One of my favorite PT songs ever. I want this played at my funeral…
CHRIST WHAT A VOICE!!!!!
"Steven Wilson" to this Day one of the most Underrated Guitarist in the World, with his Creative Riffs, Tones and Clean Guitar Playing!
Just love Steven Wilson. But I like this version better. This voice gives a whole new feeling to the song!
I prefer SW voice...
@@qntristan No one fucking cares or asked, stop commenting that on everyone's posts
I love porcupine tree this is the best band for ever ❤
Such an incredible rendition and a heart-wrenching song.
This song always calms me.
Wesley's vocals are truly great and almost make it a different song, but while both versions are fantastic in their own right, I have to say I really liked how Steven's much more ethereal interpretation beautifully enhanced the song's dream-like texture.
And of course, needless to say, Harrison's drums are a fantastic addition as well.
Wow. Whoever made this video did an amazing job. Thank you for posting.
Great!!! This is one of my favorite PT songs.
Fantastic song and vid! John's vocals are awesome!
No one replaces Wesley's unique voice. Man he just stood there and Did this Opus.P/T 4 EVER
I saw them in Zurich, Saint Julien and Vienne all in the space of 8 months. Fabulous each time. What talent.
I believe this was the first PT song I ever heard....love at first listen 🎶 😭 🤧
Awesome band awesome song awesome performance i love P.T.
Absolutely ♥♥♥♥♥ this band!
This is the sound of heaven! Every single time I hear this Masterpiece I have to cry.
my soul is like melting!
This song, this version, takes me to a place of calm and peace. Peace I could never find elsewhere. Calmness almost catatonic in intensity. AHHHHHHH . . . .
The voice of an angel . . .
The sound on this is stunning...it's not saturating at all.
Wow...this was really amazing live.
Absolutely love the XMII version of Fade away. Wes's voice is beautiful.
Poo
I want this to be played when I die !
That opening keyboard is heavenly....
I love Porcupine Tree in any of their versions. I love other experiments with Steve Wilson behind (like for example i Blackfield) too. This piece of music is simply wonderful. Thank you for posting it!
Wesley's voice next level. Period.SW your a F Genius 😂
Hit heaven far too high ...
Only the talent of PT can come up with such Brilliant lyric ...
This is so beautiful!!
I’m impressed big time!A little Floyd,Zeppelin,and tubular bells mike Ol field
Amazing. Fucking amazing.
I love love love !
Gaya Ariel Dream....... Shalom..
.
I absolutely love Steven Wilson's voice, but John Wesley's voice is out of this world. A very irish voice that gives me goosebumps every time I hear it. I darn miss this guy in the band!
Technically speaking Wes is a much better singer than Steven. A lot more reach too
@@JGJ505They're different. Wilson's voice is better for darker atmospheres filled with anguish and regret, whereas Wesley's is more bluesy, warm and sexy.
I am melting away ❤❤❤
When hear the voice, that tells me to stay........When I hear that voice, that tells me it's not, ....Not just another day,..... Floating along the ceiling, .. Floating on the edge, ... I can still hear the voice , . .That tells me to stay......Look to the light and walk on through.... Hold the night that tells me it's true... Just speak to the stranger, who holds all the clues, .. Spinning top minds just come along through........Lets all just stay, ... Lets not just fadeaway.......................
This is beautiful, my friend.
From the thoughts of one who'd had a near death experience? Beautifully written. Kudos.
one of my favourites.... fantastic....
Wesley is an excellent vocalist!!!
amazing ☆♡☆
hit heaven far too high
I love this version
What an even more beautiful version of a ethereal masterpiece 😭💚
At their best Porcupine Tree are nothing short of majestic. I certaiBands of this stnly hope that they return some day. They are missed !!!! Bands of this stature are rare in today's world of pap dressed up as little more than product ot be shifted and profited from.
fantastic version of a great song
Never noticed how much this melody recalls Richard Thompson’s “Night Comes In” from his ‘75 album.
Thank you for this incredible video
More beautiful than the original records.
the guitar! the vocals! cut right through me
Semplicemente meravigliosa
PT is Love
Excellent! Thanks for posting this gem.
I loop the song most times
Great!!!!
This is the XM II version... INCREDIBLE!!!
Thank you for uploading this
My god Steven needs to do a Ninet version of this song!
Like no 100. This is Magic man. PT is God
Porcupine Tree..... Wow. Steve Wilson is so talented.
Sublime!
Jonh Wesley has never been given his due for his contributions to the band, and the best version of this song (with Gavin). I hope they will bring him back, along with Colin (but that's another story) 🤔
Excellent! Thank you for sharing......
Incredibly beautiful
woooow!!!!awesome
Great upload! Love them 🖤
Awesome! love this track
Is this John Wesley on lead vocals? I like how he takes over lead vox for some songs/parts!
Yes. This version is on the XMII live album.
Wow.Glad I've found this👏
unglaubliche live performance. PT ist für mich derzeit die mit abstand beste band.
im melting listening to this song with the unfamiliar vocals
iam from iraq thank you steven 4 this great song
❤❤❤❤
Increíble.... por favor júntense y vengan a Chile...
Definitive line up of this band
2024 anyone?
John Wesley is legend
Love it
Sehr gut video!
Steven wilson
John Wesley
Gavin Harrison
Richard Barbieri
Colin Edwin
Chris Maitland
Solomon st. Jemain
great work on the video mate!
Alucinante
Awesome
Kamalgazi days.. I miss you..🤗
JOHN.....FUCKING....WESLEY
what would we do
without Porcupine Tree?