This is Why Ten Hag isn't playing Amad Diallo...
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- JerseyFIFA Link in Instagram Bio: / atlantisfootball
(USE CODE: ATLANTIS)
SUB to the PATREON (7 day FREE TRIAL): patreon.com/AtlantisFootball572
This is Why Ten Hag isn't playing Amad...
Recent Videos:
Kobbie Mainoo is a COMPLETE Midfielder: • Kobbie Mainoo is a COM...
Why Dalot is CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED: • Why Dalot is CRIMINALL...
How Hojlund is Developing into the Complete Striker: • Hojlund is Evolving in...
What Ten Hag Got Right & Wrong vs Aston Villa: • What Ten Hag Got RIGHT...
0:00-0:30- Intro
0:31-1:37- Why isn't Amad playing?
1:38-1:56- Promo
1:57-3:37- The Conflict
3:38-3:58- Mathys Tel
3:59-10:11- Ten Hag's Youth Strategy
Email: atlantisfootball96@gmail.com
Instagram: @AtlantisFootball
Twitter: @atlantis861
I must state that in NO way, shape or form am I intending to infringe rights of the copyright holder. Content used is strictly for research/reviewing purposes and to help educate. All under the Fair Use law.
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use."
If you ever wish for more information on visual or auditory terms, please click the link below:
is.gd/wvjoCp - กีฬา
JerseyFIFA Link in Instagram Bio: instagram.com/atlantisfootball/
(USE CODE: ATLANTIS)
SUB to the PATREON (7 day FREE TRIAL): patreon.com/AtlantisFootball572
Recent Videos:
Kobbie Mainoo is a COMPLETE Midfielder:th-cam.com/video/uqp_hiWdp8k/w-d-xo.html
Why Dalot is CRIMINALLY UNDERRATED: th-cam.com/video/cVGorT__VC4/w-d-xo.html
How Hojlund is Developing into the Complete Striker: th-cam.com/video/6-EbBh-PnZY/w-d-xo.html
What Ten Hag Got Right & Wrong vs Aston Villa: th-cam.com/video/sSQ5ssFr6cY/w-d-xo.html
I think you've let your frustration at the Fulham result get the better of you. There are several factors you've not considered.
Firstly and most importantly for young players to develop they need game time. Not just 5-10 minutes at the end of games.
Elanga and Garner are playing well now. But it took 10 games of playing 90 minutes every week for them to get into this form. You just don't get that luxury at a club like United. If you have an average game then 10% of the fanbase call for you to be dropped, 2 or 3 average games and you have 50-60% calling for you to be replaced. Garner and Elanga would not be the players they are now if they stayed at United.
Secondly, teams need a level of experience. Especially in the EPL. Elanga and Garner were allowed to leave to give more time to Garnacho and Mainoo. We probably wouldn't have the latter playing so well without selling the former. You can't have two academy players with less than 20 starts between them anchoring your midfield. So you couldn't really start Garner and Mainoo together.
Thirdly, you are ignoring the will of the young players. They want to play regularly, and they know they are more likely to be able to do that at other clubs either on loan or on a permanent deal. Alvaro Fernandez knows he has two players ahead of him, while also knowing he needs regular game time to continue to develop and have a chance of fulfilling his potential. His agent approached the club to ask for a loan move away to aid his development. Also I watched him many times last season while on loan in the championship. He's very good going forward, but is too much of a liability in defence right now. He has a tendency to switch off and not track his man. He's also a little weak and is brushed aside too easily. He's tall so he doesn't have a low center of gravity, but he hasn't filled out yet. Which makes it hard for him to go shoulder to shoulder with grown men. That's why I agreed with a loan to a less physical league which would allow him to actually practice getting more physical with his opponent while he fills out. Having spoken with a few people connected with the United Academy there is a lot, and I mean a lot of expectations on young Harry Amass. They think he could be very special and might even breakthrough to the first team before he's 18. So there could well be some future planning with letting Fernandez leave to make space for a potentially more talented player a couple of years younger than him. Much like the club did with letting Garner and Elanga leave to make space for Mainoo and Garnacho.
Ultimately having a bloated squad is the issue, creating less chances for our youth to play meaning we need to send them on loan or sell them for them to get the game time needed to develop.
As for Amad and Antony, while I'd much rather see Amad start and it is frustrating watching Antony. There are reasons beyond EtH protecting his reputation which I think you have missed. For a start Amad has spent a long time out injured and will need to ease himself back in. He was injured during preseason so he didn't have the chance to get himself into condition before his injury. So he will need to not only build up strength and confidence, but fitness as well.
From a tactical point of view EtH needs his RW player to stay wide in the build up. With Rashford drifting on the left the player on the right needs to keep the width to make space in attack. Antony does this very well and knows what EtH wants. He has the patience to stay wide and hold his position, even if that means he gets limited time on the ball. Amad is less patient and tends to play narrower which causes issues for the team structure, especially in build up play. Amad is probably more of a No.10 than a wide player, and that is why he has a tendency to drift in-field. He wants to get on the ball too much. He will have to learn to stick closer to the manager's instructions if he is going to get more chances in the team.
That is most likely the reason he doesn't have the manager's trust in the same way as Antony does. Certainly more so than the manager feeling the pressure for "his" signing to be a success.
@@Shappy86 mate it’s nothing to do with the Fulham game I recorded that a month ago.
Also you’ve written an essay here mate it’s gonna take about 5 mins for me to read
@@AtlantisFootball How do you create these videos ? I have a lot of unpopular opinions that have come to reality I wish I could document them like this
From what I've seen Ten Hag isn't so good at knowing which players are going to adapt to the premier league but is pretty good at working out which youth players are good enough.
I've no issues with any of the youth players he's sold/loaned out. I'd rather we had a decent level of churn than have players hanging round the club for years.
Alvaro Fernandez and Amad Diallo don't need Ten Hag's greenlight to be considered good enough...Ten Hag just has favourites.
So tell me then how not having a left back is better than having young left back. Im literally dying to know your reply, also explain how playing lindelof is better than a natural left back like Fernandez.
@@shashikumar-lc6qh The LB situation is weird. As far as I know Malacia was expected back in early Feb so the call was taken to let Reguilon and Fernandez leave.
Malacia then suffered a setback (which I believe the club are furious about as he was using a private trainer vs following their programme) which has left us short. Would also imagine financial pressures came into that decision too.
@@shashikumar-lc6qhnot only the manager’s responsibility, medical team fucked up badly and told him he wouldn’t need Reguillon
@DavidC-fk2wg the thing with the Malacia/Shaw thing is you always need 3 even if it's someone to promote from the youth team which they don't have so why were they allowed to go 🤦🏿♂️
Yeah Elanga is better than Anthony but that doesn't mean he should still be at MU, he just nota top 4 club level player. The better argument is we should have bought a better player than Anthony in the first place in which case the argument of keeping Elanga at MU is mute
Yeah but it doesn’t mean he should still be at United if Pellistri and Antony were the other options.
Stop talking out of your feelings mate.elanga is average. Moments football ìs not good enough
@@craigmillington1258 he’s stil better than Antony and Pellistri tho isn’t he. Much better
But is Elanga really that much better? Players tend to do well elsewhere. Antony was pretty decent before we bought him. To say Elanga is better is very short sighted.
@@AtlantisFootballNo. He looks good at a team near the bottom of the league.
Cannot understand the choice not to play Amad or give him proper minutes since being back from injury
Look toward Omari Forson's contract renewal, there lies the answer...
Amad can have same youth impact as mainoo in attack
Woah. Your channel is blowing up. I remember the time you had like 20k subs and I thought you deserved more.
Thanks bro 🙏🏼 any other videos you’d like to see
It’s more about the system the manager wants to implement vs the players. When you speak about players like Elanga, yes he’s good, that’s why a regular in the national team, but his style is not link up, rather meant for low block teams like forest. Amad needs some more time to adjust to the system, he was playing in another club and was injured since he came back, so the progress halted. He’s being given time recently in games and it’s up to him to show his qualities. Regarding Alvarez, you’re right, the staff should’ve considered Shaw being prone to injury and we wouldn’t have faced this issue. Cheers.
amrabat has the quality to play the LB/CDM interchangeable Cryuff type role - he's probably just not quite quick enough tracking back to do this against the top teams though
A manager who wanted to sign Adrien Rabiot and Aunautovic, I don’t think I expect less from him.
I mean when he was told the money he has at that time
They were the only viable options, until the fans pressured the club into spending more.
Youve no understanding of the situation/what you are talking about
That's no excuse. Why can't he scout a gem from Brazil or France or somewhere. Any United manager who suggests Arnautovic should be sacked@@VirkStar321
On Elanga, he had opportunities past 2 seasons before leaving and didn't do much. He is flourishing in a new environment. Garner, similar situation in that at time of sale we had a full compliment of internationals ahead of him,. Both NEEDED to leave to get regular game time (at a lower level with lower expectations) to develop. They both stay at United, they do not develop, it is as simple as that.
Alvaro slight head scratcher given the LB situation but you can't argue the logic for he and Mengi, when everyone is fit, Alvaro was 3rd choice and Mengi wasn't even on the radar.
Football isn't played on a computer somewhere.Keep hearing this notion of "squad player" bandied about. In a bloated squad where you have fringe players who haven't made the grade, they need to go so United can benefit from a fee and the players benefit from regular game time and development.
The current all conquering U18s squad? If we are lucky we will see 2-3 of them join the first team on a regular basis. Most will not make it at United. That is reality.
Completely missed the point. Elanga is better than Antony and Pellistri isn’t he
@@AtlantisFootball Wrong, my point is perfectly valid.
You are simply being revisionist.
Before leaving ManUtd: Anthony Elanga across 21/22 and 22/23: 52 games, 4 goals, 4 assists.
And was poor on the eye test.
Elanga's emergence this season proves my point that he has had the chance to go away, play at a good level and thrive.
There was nothing over those 2 seasons to suggest we should keep Elanga.
What’s the name of your podcast?
The video is obsolete because he always did not want to play Ahmad, and now Ahmad had proved him that he should be included in the best11, he is on the same level as Garnacho, Mainoo, Dalot, Bissaka. He is also better than the supposed stars like Bruno and Rashford.
gonna play him a lot more from now on haha
Ten Hag as done brilliant things for the youth. ! Sacking him would be the stupidest thing. Plastics calling for him to be sacked is beyond foolish!
Iqbal played really good in the pre-season, wasn't given a proper chance. even if he thought Iqbal wasn't suited for first team could have sold him for a lot more money if he was given some play time.
atlantis my man, you have a valid point on antony and amad, and what i understand.. is that you think this season is already a right off. but be on ten hag's shoes, if he is looking for redemption, looking to keep his job, hoping he doesn't end like porter or jose, why should he start kids or players that he doesn't trust, and who will take the blame if those kids take a batter? we saw when we play these kids against wrexham friendlies, most of them aren't good enough to start. i don't think its time to experiment, especially if the top 4 race is still strong, still in the FAcup (not saying we have a chance), like he said, we take every game as a final!!!. we have to play the mctominays, like we had to play weghorst last season, has long as it gets us the results
Hannibal, and Alvaro were the only standouts
And ten hag still loaned them out. I don’t doubt how he nurtures talent from the youth. Besides, he has a high standard on the academy. He tries to bring in one outstanding player from there per year. That’s something I’ll never question him on
@@bear566 He plays Antony who has 0 assist 0 goal. The bald fraud has to be sued.
@@sunglee3935 what does that have to do with what i just said?
@@bear566 he ignores academy talent to play Antony who is the worst player in PL
@@sunglee3935 he doesn't ignore academy talent, we have already two of them starting. and those two are bloody good. so he will only bring those forth who will have such an impact on the first team. and he will obviously back his signing. not everyone in the academy is the next giggs or scholes
The Alvaro Fernandes issue baffles me especially when our left backs were injured. Does ten hag know what he’s doing?
No
Nuh-uh. Nein. Noooooope.
Dude. Seen Alvaro play for Benfica. You guys can have him back.
@@JuanitoBender we’ve seen him in a good team, we’ll take him thanks
Amad proved himself in the championship and at Rangers. Give him a chance.
Doesn't make sense ,Amad can win him games. Nothing matters more for a managers reputed . Amad should play on the right and Garnacho on the left
Rashford out
This is the video I needed for this weekend. Absolutely world class
Thanks bro 🙏🏼
I have always said that Amad needs mote playing time,also Dan Gore. Hope ETH wises up soon. We need a disciplined manager like ETH.
You want us to keep so much deadwood
Just sell all those old players and give youth who are actually good
Like mainoo a chance
Very wise words
Well said! Key analysis.
Thanks bro, any other videos you want to see?
I really agree with you bro on players like Dan Gore and Alvero Fernández who are far better than the liabilities players we've in the squad now and injury prone the like of Luke Shaw etc
Frankly speaking Rashford was too casual a feeling that we have already won the game,no fighting spirit at all
There is one big aspect that many seem to miss:
In ETH system Left IF has DEFENSIVE DUTIES! Antony is quite good there. Has not really saw Diallos skills there.. but it might be the reason
Mate that’s the whole point I haven’t missed it. He hasn’t seen him there because he hasn’t played him
@@AtlantisFootball he plays him there every day in practice
@@joni.sirvio8867 practice day? He has to give him game time. He hasn’t
@@AtlantisFootballthey play, workout, train etc together everyday all day. He might have better view than us. Diallo surely is attacking vice really good. Defencive side was just my guess, because i cannot see it either. Only people in Carrington can.
@@joni.sirvio8867 it’s not mate, you’re just trying to rationalise bad decisions. He’s not playing him because he signed Antony and would rather try to play him into form than Amad. Amad 100% should be starting over Antony no debate
Nah that's a bit harsh on Pellistri, he's better than the likes of Elanga and Dan James for sure. He even starts for his NT. Not saying he's a top player or something but he is not bad.
Nah he’s defo not better than Elanga. He doesn’t start for Forest
We talk about youth for years and over the 10 years ive watched united only rashford mctominay Garnacho and mainoo have actually look good i remember garner getting a game in pre season and he just didnt look up to it ten hag said it himself he only gives chances to players who he think are good enough Antony only started 1 of our 7 most recent games
For me,i think Ten hag really thought Luke Shaw would be at the club for long and Malacia would be happy to play second fiddle. Player like Alvaro needs time to develop and its better if its with a full transfer because a club will have an obligation to play him. Often,loan players are overlooked and arent well cared of. But Shaw would never be fit,we know that. Now,everything looks silly when we dont have a left back to play for.Amad for me was unlucky,he got injured for long and when he came back,Rashford,garnacho and Hojlund played well as front three. I think the reason he played antony yesterday is coz of his defensive output,whereasfor Amad,he doesnt know wat he is gonna get.For me,the worst thing we do is in possession of ball,we hsve no shape whatsoever. For me,Ten hag knows he isnt safe and i feel he isnt long term option for Ineos. He was also involved in transfers and is also to be blamed for. From current list,we have only be only Dalot,Garnacho,Maino,Bruno,Mount,Shaw,Martinez,Onana,Hojlund,Rashford(maybe),Amad(maybe) who looks to be of the quality we need in the squad. Thats 11 players and out of which,3 are questionable. The type of squad that is being created in these two years is below average and Ten hag needs to be blamed for this aswell. We need a new striker,a winger,2 quality midgielders,a whole new defdnse. Atleast 10 newplayers in squad and 5 in starting eleven. Its scary how far we are. Its 500million investment when they say we dint even have an option to buy striker due to ffp regulation. We are atleast 3 season behind,so sad.
So again, your point comes down to the structure. We have had non football people running the club, doing negotiations, giving out hefty contracts to players without it being based on performance. The 500mil spend is not on ETH, but on the people in charge of transfers. Antony didn’t set his price, neither did Ajax initially, we could’ve got Antony and Licha for 40 mil. The men in charge waited till last minute, where obviously Ajax didn’t want to sell. Case was also the same case, last minute desperate signing instead of knowing the targets and following them in a window that lasts 2 months. It’s insane to judge a manager on the incompetence of the hierarchy.
Amad Diallo plays 1 game and wins united a semi final position against Liverpool he won bith balls for the 4th and 3rd goal not to mention scored the 4th goal from quite an angle......He is way better technically than Rashford and Antony who seems to think of over 1000 things to do on the ball. We need to play Mount , Mainoo & Erickson against Liverpool. No Bruno or Mcslow or Rash
Ten Hag is gonna cost us a Permanent Solution on that Right Wing.
You can see Amad's first instinct is to stretch the Pitch and stay as wide as possible this sometimes frustrates me cause i think closer to the box he can do more damage but...i think link up play and creativity is just a Natural thing to him but in a Team like Man UTD, individualism is the only way to break into the Team like if he scores two games in a row Ten Hag will never drop him that's how desperate he is.
Alvaro Fernandez Transfer still makes me really mad, look at what Liverpool have done with Bradley, Alvaro Fernandez was supposed to be the future very technical and Physicality will always come with age...
If they mess up Daniel Gore i will dm Sr Jim Ratcliffe himself and ask why.
Simple reason why we sell the homework talent cow people want to buy them and plus its pure profit on the FFP books. Look at how many players has left on a free.
This is mostly down to the board not Erik Ten Haag
No it’s not because Ten Hag decides which players are good enough for the first team. Nothing to do with FFP, the sales are so small in value it doesn’t even make much difference
Amad isn't homegrown though,we spent 37mil on him
I don't understand Eric ten Hag on his decisions of substitutions.
Everytime he does that the team looses.
A
He should try Antony as a left back
What are your thoughts on the Amad situation?
He should leave like pellestri to save his career. Ten hag is biased and favors Antony no matter how bad Antony is.
Should be sold, along side Pellistri and Antony, let’s be truthful to ourselves those guys don’t have a guaranteed future here. With INEOS coming in and United already escaped FFP issues ahead of the summer, they will most likely look for much more better RW players to fill up that position which will make these players drop further the pecking order regardless of if ETH is or isn’t the manager by then.
Amad is good technically but ten hag will play Antony ahead of him. And no matter how bad rashford is, he won’t be dropped. He should go to Spain where it’s not as physical and more technical
At this rate, I think ETH may not even be able to find his X1 next season. Tell me if you can identify that. We have been so poor
Anthony just edges elanga for me.. just a bit more composed and have a better IQ... but Amad is a baller just needs minutes
Nah no way, Antony’s got the worse football IQ of any player in that United squad. Antony is only a baller in lower leagues not the PL. Elanga is far better
Surely Antony is not fit for purpose if Utd play transition based football. Think Antony would do well if we opt to play high up controlling possession, creating spaces and playing vertically without needing to cover much ground.
You say things as if they are factual!
@@AtlantisFootball I think Antony could be decent in a limited role at a smaller premier league club with less pressure on him. I don't think he or Elanga were ever of the quality to make this team and neither have even given flashes at this level.
Amad, Antony, Palistri are very weird recruit for me. Antony is about 35m not 80+
Amad and Palistri were teeangers who were not even regulars in their former clubs. Respectfully, “small” clubs and yet utd paid over 30 for each.
We need better players than antony, pellistri, amad, and forson..maybe we can good business with napoli for kvara for our left forward and start put garnacho in right forward
I hope tenhag may be see this video
ETH doesn't make these decisions he asked about malasia and shaw before they sold Regulon was told they will be fit for the rest of the season .
That was wrong and not his fault
He does make these decisions because he is the manager. If he wanted them to stay they would stay lmao
I think we need to take our utd rose tinted glasses off when analysing these players and the manager.
1. We want utd to go back to winning trophies. NONE of the players sold/loaned are world beaters even with the increased game time. Elanga, Garner, Hannibal. (Exception is probably Kovar, he would have made a good No.2 goalie).
2. Let's not forget that the manager watches these kids up close. He understands their way of life around training, recovery, mental fortitude etc.
He has given Garnancho and Mainoo a chance because they were miles ahead of the other youth players.
3. The answer to better players at the moment is probably hoping our under 18s kick on and form a new class of 2025/26/27 and the transfer market. The other youth players are just not good enough to compete with the big boys in England and Europe.
Now Antony value is around 15m
i rather we play the youngsters like Amad, Gore in the league now to build up their experience. I do not think we should play in ECL next season and get slaughtered. I rather we qualify for win the European Conference league next season to build momentum. James Garner is our great loss. If we have a midfield of Garner and Mainoo, it would be intelligent and vibrant. Garner also worked well with Dylan Levitt. Would love to have these 3 with Camisero. Another thing I cannot figure out is why left Brandon Willams out on loan when we have no left back now
I can see Diallo thriving in a more controlled possession system which we dont play.
Diallo doesn't have the physical attributes to play this counter attacking brand of football we are currently playing or the heavy metal football we aspire to one day play. He isn't as electric as Rashford and Garnacho.
Rashford and Bruno don't have the physicality either 😂
@@zinedinezidane4771 They do for counter attacking imo but Rashford especially doesn't have the work rate and endurance for the heavy metal football ETH is aspiring to play.
Both of Bruno and Rashford would be useless in a control/possession based system. Bruno lacks the tactical discipline and wonders out of midfield and Rashford lacks the decision making.
@@-_-DatDude oh sorry I get you now. And agree with everything you just said.
Not seeing it mate. Eth is 50 50 to get the sack. If he gets 4th , long shot, or wins the fa cup he goes to 75 25. Garnacho and mainoo are 2 young players now in first 11. Thats alot in one season. He's spent half a season with Bruno , Rash Casi and Eriksen being half the players they were last season, and 3 of hist first choice back 4 being injured ( awb, Shaw, Martinez) and you think it's the perfect time to throw in some more youth team? never going to happen.
It is the perfect time to throw in the youth players becahse the first team players ahead of them clearly aren’t good enough
@@AtlantisFootball disagree. Too Big a gamble when 4th is undecided and fa cup could be won with one good game. Fergie called this " the business end of the season" the previous 11 months is about getting to this stage , still in with a chance, with your tactics,squad, injuries, match fitness, as good as it can be, ready for the final 6 weeks. This is where you can win the treble, or nothing at all.
I want him to succeed, but some of his decisions baffle me, in game management, substitutes and starting xi(Forson over Diallo, most recently) and players sold, Makes me doubt that he's the right man long term.
You said on your video that Luke Shaw doesnt have the dynamic ball carrying ability of Alvaro Fernandez?! WTF!? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 How has your channel got 86k subscribers with analysis like that?! Thats literally Luke Shaws game, hes one of the best at it (cause his defending is hardly elite). You then tell us that a team that has never played with wing-backs doesnt have a decent left wing-back option (?!), whilst blaming EtH for off the field decisions based on bringing in money so Utd can sign people/arent charged with FFP rule breaches... You dont have any idea what you are talking about.
And to help you with your video title (because you dont know what you are talking about...). Amad has just been unlucky this season... he would have got games earlier on this season when Antony was out with the r*pe allegation but he was injured, and then Garnacho has made the RW his own, and has been un-droppable... Then came Omari Forson's contract renewal/negotiations and because he is stalling over signing a contract, hes been introduced ahead of schedule to the first team, ahead of Amad currently (which i dont agree with) purely to entice him to sign a new deal so he doesnt go to a rival for free in the Summer... Know what you are talking about before you make a video like an expert... im embarrassed for you...
Mate you’re talking complete nonsense. Luke Shaw ranks below the 30th percentile for all of his ball carryong metrics in his fbref report 🤣🤣
But “it’s his game”. Literally go check his fbref report 🤡
Ranks 9th for progressive carries, 33rd for carries into the final third and 16th for carries into the penalty area 👍🏼
“And “I don’t know what I’m talking about”
Commented on 5 of my other videos lmao, but “I don’t know what I’m talking about” you’re a fan bro 🤣
The board sold these players not ETH
Great video, just don't agree with your opinion especially on the youth players. Garner and Elanga aren't exactly lightning up the league. Antony has barely been part of the team this season.
Edit: starting with Ferguson's last five or six seasons, how many young players have come through the United system and are (were) top above average to elite level? If you can't count up to five, then there is your problem. Otherwise you are just painting Erik black for players he never had a say over when they were brought in.
Manchester United are selling so low. Talking about it is damned near triggering. Loaning Alvaro Fernandez with an option/obligation to buy is just losing out on easy value.
He'd be worth £20m easy.
Selling McTominay for cheap would've been better than selling Garner.
Edit: And I like what McTominay has done off the bench particularly. He's not clinical, but his timing is good
Triggering 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 don’t let your anxiety, generational trauma or pronouns get in too much of a twist .
You don’t know ball talking about garner 😂😂😂 that guy is average asf
Amad played for sunderland in the championship real mens football and he smashed it ten hag as no idea how good teams in the championship are
He doesn't really have anything to gain by playing Anthony at this point, because he isn't likely to start performing all of a sudden. It's better to play Amad and if that's successful he at least made the right decision. Any future employer will recognize that. It's about being realistic and do what's best in the current situation.
Some players are good with the ball, but poor off the ball.
Alvoro and reguillon was an error to let go and even Ten hag accept that, but seeing mainoo and garnacho i understand why he let the others go. Gardner and elanga and not at that level. I don't understand the want to replace Ten hag? Give me the name of someone better right now? And changing manager again will remove everything put in place right now. He also help in the youth set up,so i stil think Ten hag is the man for the job.
@ 9.07 mins, "we are Manchester City" 😂
He said "we aren't Man City"
I don't get what you are saying,ten hag said if young players wants play, they have to prove that they are better than the first team
Well how can they prove they are better if he doesn’t play them
He can’t just throw in everyone! He has to do it slowly! I think players like Elanga, Hannibal, Pellistri , Garner are just not good enough 😊. I however agree on mistakes that Ten is making especially not giving the other goalie a chance 😢.
The thing with EtH is that he promotes youngsters only if they are immediately brilliant. Such is the case with Garnacho and Mainoo. But if they don’t have an immediate impact on the team, they won’t get too many chances. He would prefer loaning them out and hope that others will develop them.
And not even then they are going to have assured a regular starter position or even a regular sub. As is the case with Amad.
But what annoys me beyond everything is the loaning of Alvaro Fernandez in the winter. I don’t remember if in the summer he was loaned out before or after Shaw’s injury, but in the winter he should’ve been brought back.
And that’s on him. Plus, Alvaro is way more competent with the ball than both Shaw and Malacia and also inverts in the center. He showcased this skills in the summer so it beats me why EtH would not even consider him as a future player for us and loan him with an obligation to buy. That’s mainly on him and not on the board.
It's Garnacho not Anthony that's keeping Amad out. I don't think Amad is trusted defensively.
It’s not that. Antony shouldn’t be trusted going forward. This is literally how relegation sides think. He’s not playing Anad because he signed Antony
GG
I have feeling yin recorded this a while back…
I mean did say it in the video. Was only a month ago the second part
People need to seriously relax about this Anthony signing, no one knows if any player is actually going to adapt in the Premier League
Yes they do if they play like he has been playing
We should be banned from signing youngsters,amad was considered a superior prospect than kulusevski in the Atlanta academy,the mistake he made was agreeing to the move,kulusevski got thousands of minutes of constructive gametime in Atlanta then Juventus to develop his game and even then it took a move to spurs to get to a high enough level,we should send him to a prem clu to increase his value then cash in,l think if soton get promoted back,they might be a good option,they have a good squad but lack any good wingers,Leeds he can't get into their wing positions and maybe Leicester although l,m not sure he,s better than mavidudi and fatawa coz l,ve just not watched him much
Kulusevski only played a handful of games for Atalanta, but played on loan for Parma.
Amad clearly still has that potential, you can see it nearly every time he gets the chance to play but he is running out of time to actually develop it.
And now we have to sell greenwood for less than 20 mil when he should really be 80mill +
What are you talking about them not being wing backs a wing back is a different role to a fullback. Malacia definitely is not a left sided centre back hes a pretty standard fullback
I’m not talking about wing backs I’m talking about full backs
@@AtlantisFootball you said wingbacks stating malacia and Shaw are better as left centre backs. Check your own video from 5:38. I wouldn't have said anything if you said fullback.
@@TheChidmas my bad, but even still that’s still the same role as an inverted full back isn’t it. Not a traditional wing back
@@AtlantisFootballthere are three types of inverted full backs, Walker who becomes a centre back, Cancelo slides into DM and becomes a playmaker and Ndogi and Dalot moves into midfield but attacks the space between the fullback and centreback of the opposition. Shaw has been more constrained but I would say he's played both a traditional fullback and played both as the left centre back and the attacking inverted fullback at times. Wingback can be incredibly attacking like Grimaldo and Frimpong who I don't see as defenders since their position is very much as a winger. Prior to Ten Hag coming Shaw was a fullback in every sense. I disagree with your assessment of his profile same with malacia. I would say he plays him as a fullback not a wingback
@@TheChidmas right but he is playing as an inverted full back but in a back 5. In possession and out of possession
Last year was Enzo Le Fee and Kocku....
Huh?
@@AtlantisFootball i appreciate very much your analysis. Both those players would be better than Mount. And you suggested well
I think ETH is in panic mode. He wants to save his job rather than doing what's best for the team and players.
Antony won't do anything more than he already has, Amad needs to play, this is mostly ETH last season at United, he hasn't used many of the youngsters who at least should have be given a chance in the first team, and kept playing all the under performing overpaid dead wood, this just shows ETH can't make the tough decisions when it comes to benching players and giving the youth any chance
Amad must be given a chance pl
Elanga isn’t even good
Agree. Elanga not real great. Teams play a lot different against Utd than they do against Notts Forest.
Amad is good but not strong enough to premier league l. Teg Hag is not stupid, some of you just comment rubbish as if u re new watching these Man Utd players. Elanga is good to go, some players out on loan for good performances, fitness and body building body is a good idea by Teg Hag
Elanga is bang average,,he is a perfect forest player not a united future
Not the point tho is it, Elanga is still better than Antony and Pellistri. Pellistri and Antony arent even PL standard
there is nothing good about this club, from the players to the manager, to the coaching staff, to the owners, all is not well and its going to take a long time to fix, in the mean time we will have to watch Liverpool and City clean up while we slumber in the mid table if were lucky
Alvaro, suffers the same problem as Amad, Antony and Malacia
Amad Diallo doesn’t play because he doesn’t track back and defend. As much as it pains me to say it even though Anthony has been contributing zero to the final third he does track back and does provide some form of defensive cover. During the Nottingham game you can see Bruno constantly getting on Amad’s case to track back and defend. This isn’t Amad’s strong suit so it doesn’t come naturally to him. That’s why he doesn’t play often.
That’s nothing to do with it. Amad has barely been given chances
@@AtlantisFootball not open to it then ok. 👌🏽 no worries. Not saying there aren’t any other reasons, not saying what you’re on about in the video is wrong either. The reality is none of us really know what’s going on in Ten Hag’s head anyway.
@@BaldursPicketFence Amad is more than capable of doing the defensive work rate, he did it for Sunderland last season. Also at a club like United that’s not really going to be why a right winger is preferred to another unless it’s a big game.
I’d say it’s likely because Ten Hag brought Antony in and his reputation hinges on his development rather than Amad
@@BaldursPicketFence if it was solely to do with tracking back he would have given him chances when he initially came back. Can’t show he is capable of doing it if ten Hag only gives him 20 mins here and there
Well I saw someone like him come on twice
I agree with everything you said except for Pellistri. He's doing great on loan. He recently scored and assisted against Barca in a 3-3 draw. He also can play wing back, he played that role for his country in the last World Cup. He wasn't given a fair chance at United. Unfortunately it seems Amad will suffer the same fate
Only in England and in particular at Manchester United are players themselves faulted for a lack of form, with no blame attributed to the man whose job it is to get them performing.
On the Continent the Manager/Head Coach is held responsible for the performance levels of his charges, and that's why Continental Clubs will always perform better than English Clubs, because they actually use their intellects.
Because he spent £85m on Antony.
What a joke. I like Ten Hag but this is a sackable offense on its own even if he didn't set the price. Antony is so one footed he should be registered disabled and the fact he smirks and smiles his way through his repulsive displays and gets upset when he is hooked shows what a horrid little cretin he is.
Throw in a lazy, sulking entitled arsewipe Rashford and a captain who throws his arms in the air like a petulant child everytime things don't go right and we can see why our dressing room is so toxic.
Give me an example where bad signings haunt managers like Atlantis is alluding to? He’s barely playing either of them
What are you talking about. Antony signing will defo haunt ten Hag when it comes to recruitment
@@AtlantisFootball you didn’t answer my question. You mentioned bad signings haunting managers in the past so give me an example of that happening?
Amad was injured most of the time
We are talking about the last 2 months
Unied true futur is garnacho pelsri hojland amad. Since mata we have not had a technical player amad is one der for even if his not ftting in to yhe team he gives me yhem exttra playiimg style like the Liverpool game united were able to play bruno at t back anyhonu leeft back cah amad
I think pellestri is underrate and under utilised
Quite onesided, over the top against Ten Hag. Not much supported by any evidence. And actually clearing up the youths in this way is good for both sides. If the manager does not think they fit in the team, they should be allowed to try elsewhere. It does not mean they are bad players, they may just be players fitting different style of play then is demanded.
Huh? Everything I said is supported by evidence. He is the one who decides who goes and stays in the squad. Fernandez and Elanga should 100% still be in the squad
This video is obsolete, Amad is a star, much much better than those great egos that bring nothing to the game week in week out. The moment he steps on the pitch you know how much he will bring to our play. Great, great against Liverpool like Mainoo, Garnacho and Dalot
How does that make the video obsolete
Maybe Amad is not good too
Injuries is really robbing us of how we play
Your worst video I have seen. The argument makes no sense to me. Why would Ten Hag play a player he believes is worse, something that could make him lose his job, so he can look "good" at the end of the season and have more control of transfers at his next job AFTER he gets fired from United, rather than play the "better" player that could actually get him what he needs to keep his job at Manchester United? That makes absolutely no sense. What do you think a manager is judged more on, finishing as high as possible in the league or how many times they played their most expensive player? And that is even ignoring the fact that Antony has been benched for several games straight, or that the manager does not negotiate player prices. Come on man.
Y'know what makes more sense than all this?! Ten Hag's Dutch.........and the Dutch are notoriously arrogant and pig headed when it comes to decision making (trust me, I've worked in Holland). Just look at what people said about Van Gaal and Cruyff, then understand that Ten Hag suffers from the same blinkered, narcissistic mentality....
When they're performing, everything's great! When they're not performing, everything goes to shit.....
It’s not worse vjdeo, you’ve not undestold anything I’ve said. Rewatch because I literally cover the points in the video.
He is playing him becahse his reputation depends on it
Come on man, it’s pretty simply. I don’t see how you’ve misunderstood it
He is not good enough for a top 15 side.
He’s barely played lol
@@AtlantisFootball and garnacho plays, it's about ability.
@@hama.fernandes no it’s not because players have to be given a chance. Amad is clearly good enough
@@AtlantisFootball
If you don't get a chance in a slim squad like united that means your ability is not there,we had elanga who was bad for us and a Top 6-7 side but can do wonders for a top 15 side, he's still q kid though he can definitely improve.
@@hama.fernandes no it doesn’t because he should be getting a chance but Ten Hag is favouring Antony over him
Welp
Shows he should
Funny enough when I saw the line up against Fulham I was like Amad must hand in his transfer request first thing in the morning...Ten Hag has absolutely abused the academy and slowed down so many of our youngsters careers...the Alvaro Fernandez/LB debacle alone is worth the sack for me...that's just gross mismanagement...I think SJR has to make the only sensible decision come summer...give him the LVG treatment no UCL no job simply put...besides there has been no signs of a plan of any kind in place on the pitch...we still play like we did under Ole only difference is we try to play more often from the back and the FBs invert but all in all everything is still TRASH
Mistake after mistake is no longer a mistake it is deliberate he has left the club wirh more useless players must be gone with murtaugh and arnold and the other saboteurs at united
Elanga had his chances and he was poor, no one would've kept him, from last seasons performances? Definitely under valued him though, but thats why them changes were needed at the club because they were fucking useless at best.
We should have kept him over Antony and Pellistri tho
@AtlantisFootball 100% agree but that's with hindsight, didnt think Antony was gonna be this poor and pellistri looked half decent coming on as a late sub
Out of all your videos, this has to be the worst one 😂. The idea that every decent youth player should be given a chance is ludicrous. Sending them on loans is also giving them a chance.
Mate you’’ve just misunderstood the whole video . No one said every youth player had to be given a chance did they.
We are talking about players who are sent on loan and then come back to the first team and are good enough to play in the squad but are then not given a chance. I don’t see how you’ve misunderstood that.
That James garner one is not ten hags fault because the club was broke and they needed money at the time.
Not true United allowed Pogba and Lingard to walk for free
@@tonyqwabe5873 Paul's maybe true but at the end of the day, Lingard wanted to stay while he could have gone to west ham the season before he left, he wanted to stay and was bad for the rest of that season.
Garner, Alvaro Fernandes and Amad should atleast have had squad roles.
Garner was sold off so that's impossible in his case, and he didn't prove to be a big influence at his new club. I agree about the others though.
Has never worked well with a star. He can only develop youth players. Out ten hag, then Antony straight after.
Sack Ten Hag and Rashford.
Not ur best video..Elanga en Garner just aren’t good enough so I disagree with u on that
But I agree that Alvaro Fernandez shouldn’t have been sold en that Amad deserves more minutes
In terms of Ten Hag not being able to identify talent I disagree with that bcs that’s exactly what he did at Ajax en he’s doing with Garnacho, Mainoo en Kambwala
Yes they definitely are good enough to be in the squad. Elanga is clearly better than Pellistri and Antony.
It’s not hard to see Garnacho and Mainoo’s Talent. That is the culture at Ajax not ten Hag. If he had a good talent ID he wouldn’t have let Garner and Fernandez leave
@@AtlantisFootball just bcas he’s better doesn’t mean he’s good enough bcas he isn’t
Elanga does well for Forest but everytime I see him play for them I see why he isn’t good enough for United
@@AtlantisFootball ok..what is the culture at United’s academy then??…bcas if we being honest most of them aren’t good enough
@@neozapolar5102 yes it does. Because that’s how you judge who stays in the squad. If Elanga is better than Antony and Pellistri then he should still be in the squad over them
Fernandez was poor at Granada and looked out of his depth.