Love the simplicity. Cheap, fast and quite frankly the others on YT are over engineered/designed relative to its usage. Most of us are not cabinet makers or work in a surgical operating room with tools to even make their complicated components. Thanks.
I literally just returned a dust deputy $54. I thought that was overpriced, turns out I needed the super dust deputy $150 Not happening. Now it’s figure out what I can scrounge up . You did it for the good of us all the other cheep guys ..This is a great idea , I have everything ( free ) A+ , simple build . Thanks
Awesome video! I've seen so many separator builds where people are custom building designer buckets, secondary and tertiary filtration systems, even toroidal spiral inlet hoses. THIS VIDEO is the one I've wanted to see where using parts on hand you made an effective separator without a ton of time or materials. THANK YOU!
You measured the set-up's efficiency, what I would like to comment on is the work-time / usefulness ratio, it's fantastic - a really worthwhile addition to a workshop for amazingly little time and money. I am going to make the exact same. Thanks.
I am making one of these right now and this helped a lot. Be aware that chlorine buckets are vented and don't make a tight seal. There is a slight gap between the lid and bucket. Round surgical tubing makes a great gasket.
If it hadn't been said before, I'll say it now...how effective to actually use shop vac attachments vs buying PVC fittings for the build. Like many, I have lots of attachments I never use but are set for the larger diameter hoses. Save a few $$ using them up vs searching for and having to modify PVC elbows. Kudo's for showing the build as I haven't as yet built one but paid over $40 for a kit from Rockler "in the event of" but recently bought PVC fittings I'll take back. Having an inground pool that I've over 20 leftover 100# pail buckets w screw on lids great for storage, I'll be using one as it's heavier for a base but better wall construction also. Key thing is the extra vacuum cleaner also. Great video
What a good idea. I did the same thing (with the exact same bucket) and I really like it. It’s really easy to do and will help to preserve my shop vac. I burn the motor of my previous one cause I didn’t use bag (too much dust and wood). Now i can use bag in the shop vac without having to change it two time per day. Thank you very much.
I'm just about to make one of these from another vid I watched. I was trying to find that vid again when yours popped up, and I'm glad it did. Your method is so much easier, and I have spare parts from broken vacuum cleaners I can use. Cheers!
Holy cow, given what this is, 98% interception before the vac is pretty impressive if you ask me! GREAT video, one of the shortest, most to the point cyclone separator vids I've watched. Great job, my man.
Very cool, something that may make it even more efficient is to maybe add a little metal screen to the port going in to your main vacuum. Very cool design though. I used to see vacuum parts like this at the thrift stores all the time. I have to start looking for them again. Thanks for the cool idea.
Using the wand end was a great idea ! The norm has been to scribe cut the end of a tube or block of wood to the radius of the bucket which took some time. I made mine that way and it wasn't any more efficient than the simple way you did yours. I also used the hot melt glue gun and it has held up great, and quick too. Jeff
I've made a very simple separator the same way and the only draw back I found was the shop vac attachment that is cut into the side of the bucket gets clogged pretty easy if a large piece gets sucked up. I fixed that by flushing up the attachment to the inside curve of the bucked. And I found I liked it so much I cut the bottom of my bucket out leaving a 1 inch lip all the way around and secured it to the lid of another and bucket then just snap it on and it doubles your dust catching capacity haha love the videos by the way!
I was kinda worried about that as well, I do plan on just using it for the CNC so there shouldn't be to much load on it but making it flush would be a easy fix. Thanks for watching!
Thanks for the video, I made an identical setup out of a 5gal pail with excellent results. I used tape for the inlet seal just to test it & was amazed. I have seen many people that add a baffle plate but I can not see it helping much. I am considering placing the bucket on a 55gal drum & may use the base of the bucket as a baffle. Time for some trial & error. Thx again
You can increase th efficiency by adding a baffle, made of wood or plastic, inside the bucket and above the port where dust enters. You make a hole in the middle for the outlet, with this the particles that are flying and normally doesnt settle down fast are trapped below the baffle and spin around the walls falling. The clean air stays in the middle. Thanks for this easy to make method.
Great video. I think I will put a piece of aquarium carbon filter at the top suction line, in the bucket. That stuff doesn't restrict air flow and should trap the other 3-4%. I love design won't cost a penny to use stuff around shop that I already have with little fabrication. Perfect and simple. Thanks
I think this is my guide, favorite build so far. I'll add baffles to get the finer stuff out and I may never need a new filter for my vacuum. ha ha Thanks for sharing.
I made one of your bucket collector it works great !!! I have it on my shop vac to use on my Radial arm saw . I just installed into my shop I am on TH-cam as well ! Thanks for sharing your idea Best Regards BobLee
Great and fast little project, I have all kinds of shop vac parts like that as well since I have burned up one shop vac already (took a few years of abuse) I wonder if I can make this work with a square kitty litter bucket. We will soon find out.
A thien baffle would help a lot with the seperation in that set up, simple scrap wood circle, pretty sure a 10 9/16 would be the diameter and take 1.125" off 270° or 3/4of the diameter and put the last 1/4 below the inlet
I used the same attachment to create a separator. The problem is when the pieces are too big for the hole. They block the suction and will collapse the container. I even cut the inside of it away as much as possible and it still clogs. Just keep this in mind.
Nice, quick design Ryan, but it needs to go a step further. Yea, I made a Thien separator like this and can confirm that the baffle makes a big difference in the fine stuff. Also, one of the biggest challenges for this baffleless design is that as the debris builds up inside the bucket, the swirling air starts swirling and agitating the already captured debris, which then gets sucked into the vac's filter, oops. Even with my Thien version, I noticed this when I checked the bucket capacity after a bunch of use, and saw that the debris was getting piled up pretty high/close to the baffle, which calms the air in the lower chamber. Without the baffle, the debris will obviously short-circuit the separation in short order.
I've seen other "20 minute dust separators" on TH-cam... the difference with yours is that it looks as though you really were able to make it in 20 minutes! :o) The pool chemical bucket is a great idea; it looks to be much stronger than the hardware store buckets most folks are using, and the screw lid is a real winner! Now... who do I know with a pool?
I wonder how well this will work if its scaled up. I've got the 2ph harbor freight dust collector you see all over youtube. It uses 4inch hose, and I don't think they make shop vac accessories that big. So I'm thinking about recreating your idea using a 32gallon trash can and some 4inch aluminum duct.
Very Clever using the vacuum pieces for inlet/outlet. Where did you come up with the tall/screw lid bucket?? How well did the hot glue work on the dissimilar plastics??
very sweet and smart. Let us know how the bucket handles the vaccum in the future, will it deform ? anyway, this is flabbesgastingly killer when faced with all the cyclone DIY videos out there... keep on trucking !
i made one but it doesn’t work. at least 50% gets past it and ends up in the vac. the port on the lid just extends down straight about an ins or so and i used a 5 gallon bucket. what’s wrong here?
Love the simplicity. Cheap, fast and quite frankly the others on YT are over engineered/designed relative to its usage. Most of us are not cabinet makers or work in a surgical operating room with tools to even make their complicated components. Thanks.
I literally just returned a dust deputy $54. I thought that was overpriced, turns out I needed the super dust deputy $150 Not happening.
Now it’s figure out what I can scrounge up . You did it for the good of us all the other cheep guys ..This is a great idea , I have everything ( free ) A+ , simple build . Thanks
Thanks. Finally a dust separator that is not over engineered to death. This is very achievable and in my price range. Great job!
Awesome video! I've seen so many separator builds where people are custom building designer buckets, secondary and tertiary filtration systems, even toroidal spiral inlet hoses. THIS VIDEO is the one I've wanted to see where using parts on hand you made an effective separator without a ton of time or materials. THANK YOU!
Glad it could help!
Thanks for watching
Ryan
i second this comment
Easy, Simple, Cheap. What more can you ask for in a cyclone separator. Great job Ryan!!!
Thanks Richard!
You measured the set-up's efficiency, what I would like to comment on is the work-time / usefulness ratio, it's fantastic - a really worthwhile addition to a workshop for amazingly little time and money. I am going to make the exact same. Thanks.
I am making one of these right now and this helped a lot. Be aware that chlorine buckets are vented and don't make a tight seal. There is a slight gap between the lid and bucket. Round surgical tubing makes a great gasket.
If it hadn't been said before, I'll say it now...how effective to actually use shop vac attachments vs buying PVC fittings for the build. Like many, I have lots of attachments I never use but are set for the larger diameter hoses. Save a few $$ using them up vs searching for and having to modify PVC elbows. Kudo's for showing the build as I haven't as yet built one but paid over $40 for a kit from Rockler "in the event of" but recently bought PVC fittings I'll take back. Having an inground pool that I've over 20 leftover 100# pail buckets w screw on lids great for storage, I'll be using one as it's heavier for a base but better wall construction also. Key thing is the extra vacuum cleaner also. Great video
What a good idea. I did the same thing (with the exact same bucket) and I really like it. It’s really easy to do and will help to preserve my shop vac. I burn the motor of my previous one cause I didn’t use bag (too much dust and wood). Now i can use bag in the shop vac without having to change it two time per day. Thank you very much.
This is by far the best set up for a DIY cyclone shop vac vacuum. "easy peasy" and it works
I'm just about to make one of these from another vid I watched. I was trying to find that vid again when yours popped up, and I'm glad it did. Your method is so much easier, and I have spare parts from broken vacuum cleaners I can use. Cheers!
A simple and extremely effective dust collector. This will be on my to-do list.
Thanks for sharing
Looks like it works as good as some I’ve seen that took days to build, well done 👍
Awesome investment of time. In 20min 97% of efficiency. Well done! Regards from Barcelona.
Thanks!
Simple... effective... cheap... what else can I hope? I'm going to do that "apparatus" right now! The best part: the efficiency test, 97%! Thanks Sir!
Holy cow, given what this is, 98% interception before the vac is pretty impressive if you ask me! GREAT video, one of the shortest, most to the point cyclone separator vids I've watched. Great job, my man.
That's what I call simple and effective way to get things done ! Love it. Well done.
just made one last night ! So easy I could not believe how fast I made it ! Works beautifully too ! Thanks for the idea ! Keep makin cool stuff !
Exactly what I been looking for have the same bucket and basically the same adapters laying around nicely done
Nice attention to detail even for a quick build. I like the "upcycle" of the shop vac parts.
Thanks!
3
Thank you, Sir. This has been on my to-do list for a while... ever since I saw how crazy expensive cyclone separators are online. You did a fine job.
Thank you! There do seem little pricey for what they are...
DAM....Not only is this a great build...You made use of all parts and attachments i never use !!! GOOD JOB.. THANKS !!
Perfect DIY cyclone. It does the job, least amount of time, parts are laying around and ready to go.
Built it, works great, been using it for months. Cheap and furious, as we say in our parts. Thanks a bunch.
nice!!
Simple, direct, that is awesome build and wonderful use of the parts you had on hand.
Thanks!
I'm glad to see someone actually measured the efficiency of one of tjese instead of just looking in the bucket and filter. Nice job!
Very cool, something that may make it even more efficient is to maybe add a little metal screen to the port going in to your main vacuum. Very cool design though. I used to see vacuum parts like this at the thrift stores all the time. I have to start looking for them again. Thanks for the cool idea.
Love how simple this turned out. I've been thinking about making one for myself and its really easy to over-complicate it. Well done!
That's what I'm talkn bout.Cheap, fast an easy. Gonna work great in my little 12x16 shop. Great idea with parts at hand. Keep up the great work
Using the wand end was a great idea ! The norm has been to scribe cut the end of a tube or block of wood to the radius of the bucket which took some time. I made mine that way and it wasn't any more efficient than the simple way you did yours. I also used the hot melt glue gun and it has held up great, and quick too.
Jeff
I've made a very simple separator the same way and the only draw back I found was the shop vac attachment that is cut into the side of the bucket gets clogged pretty easy if a large piece gets sucked up. I fixed that by flushing up the attachment to the inside curve of the bucked. And I found I liked it so much I cut the bottom of my bucket out leaving a 1 inch lip all the way around and secured it to the lid of another and bucket then just snap it on and it doubles your dust catching capacity haha love the videos by the way!
I was kinda worried about that as well, I do plan on just using it for the CNC so there shouldn't be to much load on it but making it flush would be a easy fix. Thanks for watching!
WOW! Super simple and a LOT easier than building the Frein separator.
Thanks for the video, I made an identical setup out of a 5gal pail with excellent results. I used tape for the inlet seal just to test it & was amazed. I have seen many people that add a baffle plate but I can not see it helping much. I am considering placing the bucket on a 55gal drum & may use the base of the bucket as a baffle. Time for some trial & error.
Thx again
+David Waegele nice! I think a baffle might help with some of the finer dust.
Thanks for watching
Ryan
You can increase th efficiency by adding a baffle, made of wood or plastic, inside the bucket and above the port where dust enters. You make a hole in the middle for the outlet, with this the particles that are flying and normally doesnt settle down fast are trapped below the baffle and spin around the walls falling. The clean air stays in the middle. Thanks for this easy to make method.
Simple, simple, simple! Using shop vac parts genius.
That is awesome! You've inspired me to try this out in my shop. Thanks for the video! You're content is always impressive.
Impressive results from such a quick build. Great project and thanks for the video.
How simple it is! Thanks I need to start right away instead of going to
Home depot to buy all connectors.
Well done. Nice utilization of easy to come by components. I am going to build one the first chance I get.
Great video. I think I will put a piece of aquarium carbon filter at the top suction line, in the bucket. That stuff doesn't restrict air flow and should trap the other 3-4%. I love design won't cost a penny to use stuff around shop that I already have with little fabrication. Perfect and simple. Thanks
Nice simple solution. Now know what I'm going to spend an hour on this afternoon. Hot glue was a great idea for sealing it up.
I think this is my guide, favorite build so far. I'll add baffles to get the finer stuff out and I may never need a new filter for my vacuum. ha ha Thanks for sharing.
Best cyclone video on TH-cam. I'm making one just like this... thanks man!
I made one of your bucket collector it works great !!! I have it on my shop vac to use on my Radial arm saw . I just installed into my shop I am on TH-cam as well ! Thanks for sharing your idea Best Regards BobLee
Thanks for sharing, I made my separator today with just a few modifications and it works great.
I bet it you use the original deep bucket you get even more efficiency. Great vid - Thanks!
YESSS, that hose attachment thingy for the inlet! That's what I need to use.
Great video quick, easy, efficient and inexpensive.
Very well done
Nice easy cyclone! I like it.
I Did It similar one. Works great. No dust in the filter.
It's a wonderful cyclone ♪
Great job ! No need for twin buckets, thanks for sharing
I've made mine using your model and it worked perfectly. Thank you so much.
+Garaplus nice! Glad it worked for you:)
Awesome idea... I paid way to much for my dust deputy 👎... Your videos rocks!
Great job. Super efficient and super simple.
Great and fast little project, I have all kinds of shop vac parts like that as well since I have burned up one shop vac already (took a few years of abuse) I wonder if I can make this work with a square kitty litter bucket. We will soon find out.
A thien baffle would help a lot with the seperation in that set up, simple scrap wood circle, pretty sure a 10 9/16 would be the diameter and take 1.125" off 270° or 3/4of the diameter and put the last 1/4 below the inlet
THAT was awesome. Cheers! Chris.
I used the same attachment to create a separator. The problem is when the pieces are too big for the hole. They block the suction and will collapse the container. I even cut the inside of it away as much as possible and it still clogs. Just keep this in mind.
Simplest I've seen...so maybe I will actually finally make one! Thanks.
Very easy and very efficiency, good job!
That is awesome. I need to make one of those before I blow out my shop vac.
The good news is it won't take long:)
That is a great idea so simple and effective
Thanks!
Built one last week. Works great
Nice work man.
Leaves the fancier versions "in the dust". Way less time and just as efficient.
best part. cost was basically free. keep being awesome
James Foskey ini
Nice, quick design Ryan, but it needs to go a step further. Yea, I made a Thien separator like this and can confirm that the baffle makes a big difference in the fine stuff. Also, one of the biggest challenges for this baffleless design is that as the debris builds up inside the bucket, the swirling air starts swirling and agitating the already captured debris, which then gets sucked into the vac's filter, oops.
Even with my Thien version, I noticed this when I checked the bucket capacity after a bunch of use, and saw that the debris was getting piled up pretty high/close to the baffle, which calms the air in the lower chamber. Without the baffle, the debris will obviously short-circuit the separation in short order.
97% efficient and the price was right too.
Nice work. JimE
Thanks!
I've seen other "20 minute dust separators" on TH-cam... the difference with yours is that it looks as though you really were able to make it in 20 minutes! :o)
The pool chemical bucket is a great idea; it looks to be much stronger than the hardware store buckets most folks are using, and the screw lid is a real winner! Now... who do I know with a pool?
Ay mi madre q simple lo has echo. Grx.
Cheap, quick and efficient. Excellent! Thanks.
+AndyB thank you!
Great best efficiency
Love it!! Nice job.. I'll do that for my shop vac.
I wonder how well this will work if its scaled up. I've got the 2ph harbor freight dust collector you see all over youtube. It uses 4inch hose, and I don't think they make shop vac accessories that big. So I'm thinking about recreating your idea using a 32gallon trash can and some 4inch aluminum duct.
Would a crevice tool work in place of the other tool that you have???
truly easy. good work.
Nice , simple , cheap, love it.
Best video yet !
Love it, I have the same attachment, going to give this a shot
I'm late to the party on this video, but this is awesome. I'm definitely going to do this!
Phil
Very Clever using the vacuum pieces for inlet/outlet. Where did you come up with the tall/screw lid bucket?? How well did the hot glue work on the dissimilar plastics??
I have a problem with the buckets collapsing due to strong vacuum suction.
does your filter plug about the same rate with the finer dust particles?
Made one and It is working great. Thanks much
98% not bad at all its close enough for me
Mike Fulton - Demerit l? maricharimaol mmarichari 1s
very sweet and smart. Let us know how the bucket handles the vaccum in the future, will it deform ?
anyway, this is flabbesgastingly killer when faced with all the cyclone DIY videos out there...
keep on trucking !
Thanks! I'll post any problem I come across in the future.
Love it- I would've weighed the bucket then you wouldn't have to scoop it back out.
i've a common cyclone separator too but what if some dust goes anyway into the vacuum?? What's wrong??
Does it work for drywall dust
I make that thing but when i switch on vaccum and put my hand on the hose to check its working ..my bucket breaks into pieces need help plz
i made one but it doesn’t work. at least 50% gets past it and ends up in the vac.
the port on the lid just extends down straight about an ins or so and i used a 5 gallon bucket.
what’s wrong here?
Muito obrigado pela boa ideia . Quanto mais simples e eficiente . Vou compartilhar aqui no Brasil !!!
can it be used as a wet and dry?
Ayırıcı bir aparat yapmadınız. Peki, bir kısım toz makine pervanesine gitmez mi?
How well has this worked for you? Still replacing filters on a regular?
After vacuuming, maybe you can weight the whole pail , empty the pail, weigh again and find the delta. 😜. Great idea though
The power saw looks very handy, can somebody else tell me where can I buy it, and also its exact name. Thanks
That is great ! Thanks for the video.
Thanks for watching!
I can't find a scene on bucket where did you get it?