Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account and use code CHATSPORTS for $20 off your first purchase! Check out gametime.co for last minute tickets.
I said last year that the QB was the only thing that would hold the offense back. He couldn't get the ball to the recovers because he couldn't throw thar far.
Thats the dumbest trade I've ever heard. A guy who's coming off a season ending injury w/ an additional knee procedure and hasn't even played a snap in the regular season, is not worth a top 5 pick.
Anything not to draft a Black Quarterback is the Giants mindset it seems. And bye the way we need some damn Cheerleaders to look @ if we're gonna lose every Sunday Mara. 🏈
Gotta be the dumbest shit ever if I’m John Mara and both of those QBS are off the board I’m signing Sam darnold and taking Travis hunter simple as that!
@@manofsteel9716 in this scenario the Vikings would re-sign Darnold. I agree with taking Travis Hunter, though. I’d rather pay Cousins cheap for a couple of seasons and draft the future QB in 2026. That said, I’d rather have Ward or Sanders than McCarthy.
Mel is a jackass if he thinks any team is going to trade a number one for an unproven QB who has one less year on rookie contract that how to seasoning ending injury. Any team that does that trade the gm should be fired immediately.
That's why they'll continue to lose. This is a new NFL and mobile QBs not just black is what it is now. Black QBs do dominate the mobile QBs tho. They want Eli part 2. That's why they hired Joe Schein. Eli twin. Lol.
If Mara does this when Cam or Shudder is there for them at #3 well then we have to start to investigate Mara & his reluctantly to draft a black QB!!!!!!! We need Shudder or Cam to get this franchise headed in the right direction. They better not trade for McCarthy if Ward or Shudder is available to us at 3.
Sure lets trade a hot to trot #3 pick for a QB who hasnt played for an entire season and has suffered a torn meniscus in his right knee during the preseason, makes perfect sense. WTF, I knew they would F it up.
like it’s not rocket science 😂😂😂 i don’t even know why people are entertaining jj for the 3rd pick. i’d take him for our second and something else but not for the 3rd
@tdmidas289 don't know don't follow him and don't want him the Giants can make it happen when it comes down to it because I don't think Cleveland is taking a quarterback because they signed what's his name to a contract
@@juanharris3171all I know if you put cam or Shedeur on that team that JJ had they still win and they put up better numbers than JJ especially Cam Ward
@gcode2543 lol what a joke, JJ didn't have Restrepo or Travis. JJ made more NFL throws in one game TCU than both Ward and Sanders made in their entire careers
@@EUGENE304 idc what his tape shows, he’s not better than Cam Ward and if you think Cam couldn’t have had a better season than JJ it’s you that haven’t watched tape
FUN FACT: JJ McCarthy Senior Season Games with 150 or less passing yards: 7 Games with 300 passing yards: 1 Michigan literally beat Penn State in a game where McCarthy had 0 2nd half pass attempts! Michigan won with McCarthy, but NOT BECAUSE of McCarthy. He is mediocre at best.
Is this a Joe Schoen move? He should be fired after paying DJ then letting SB go to a divisional rival. It’s their choice, yet I can’t say I like it. Cam Ward or it’s a fail. JJ to me is damaged goods until he proves otherwise. A meniscus tear is nothing to take lightly.
This kid is awful im sorry but after i saw his bowl game performance i couldn't believe the hype around this guy he couldnt make a solid pass past 10 yards.... an the fact hes injured an looks like a pencil i wouldnt be surprised to see this kid hurt again very soon especially if he were to play right now. He's only 21 an needs to put on some size an we have no idea how hes gunna perform after injury an if kevins sayin hes so good why tf would he trade him LOL.
If the Giants miss out on saunders or Ward go get Travis hunter then go after Jalen milroe that guy is a beast at QB and has speed yo I would draft jalen
Giants aren't that dumb. That rumor had to come from Minny. U can keep boy wonder not interested. Rather draft Mccord, Dart or Kourke over him. Joe has to take a stand here, ignore the noise and make the right decision. No desperate moves. No matter what.
That wouldn't be true at all. This is a team that finished the season at 14 - 3 with another QB in place. If the vikes fail to win a ring the situation becomes what does that team need outside of QB to get them over the hump? A window to win is very short so why would the vikes disturb what already seems to work with Sam. It wasn't what was expected but it happened. Good problem to have for the vikes.
@@tdmidas289 If he was in this year’s draft he would be the first quarterback taken. I can understand and I can certainly see why you support Sanders and Ward but neither one of them really have a first round grade on them, especially Sanders. I wouldn’t trade my third overall pick no matter what but I would draft McCarthy over Sanders
@Ijustinsultedyou I think a 3rd overall plus extra would be worth it for JJ. He's got a years worth of studying in an offense that made Sam Darnold relevant again. He's had a year to get accustomed to the differences between college and pro ball. As minor as those factors may be, it's still experience, and if he's as equally as good or better than Sanders & Ward, he would be an easy trade for me.
@@rvanemburg78 Yeah but there’s just one hangup and it’s a major one. He would be coming to the Giants and Brian Daboll. He’ll be coming to an organization that has an owner, that’s struggling to be an owner. He would be coming to an organization that has a GM that was never a GM before and is displaying evidence of that. He would be coming to an organization that has a head coach that was never a head coach before but got the job because of what everyone thought was great offensive play calling but now he’s been exposed as a fraud in that even after calling plays all year long this year.
You were wrong on last years draft as Daniels is clearly the best of that draft. Even Cliff Kingsbury, who interviewed for Chicago's OC position. He said that Daniels was the best and should go #1. They disagree, and let Olive walk. Now, who's the best QB in the playoffs, Daniels, and Washington has totally changed the franchise because of DQ, Kliff, and Daniels. Also, Daniels also said that McCarthy is hands down the better QB than those in this draft. So, I would definitely make the trade. Last year's QB draft class have all trained together except for Caleb Williams. So the other five are friends and talk regularly. If the agree that JJ is better then I believe them and coach McConnell. So I'd make the trade.
Make sure you are all caught up on everything Giants by checking out our latest Giants Now TH-cam videos: - PERFECT New York Giants Offseason Plan - th-cam.com/video/OIitioqAkyk/w-d-xo.html - Hire Antonio Pierce As Defensive Coordinator? | New York Giants Rumors - th-cam.com/video/zhI3cBW7MrE/w-d-xo.html - New York Giants Mock Draft 5.0 🚨 1st Of NFL Offseason With #3 Pick - th-cam.com/video/DRkc-1hu2pI/w-d-xo.html
I would only do a pick swap and JJ Mcarthy. So we still have a pick in the first round and build this team. I can understand why this trade would happen though.
I would trade for him but not the 3rd overall pick. I would trade our 2nd round pick though. Injury and unknown in the nfl, I think Vikings might consider trading him despite not being offered a 1st round 2025 pick.
Need more of today's New York Giants Now by Chat Sports with host Marshall Green? Subscribe now to get daily doses of insider rumors and more: www.youtube.com/@nygiantstv?sub_confirmation=1
JJ is not HIM I hope they do not do that dude is going to be a bust as well. He is not even better than Daniel Jones OMFG Giants are the Knicks of old SMH
I don't want this, and also I think Minnesota would be stupid to do this. If they sign Darnold as everyone projects them to (and why would Darnold want to leave? He had the best season of his career) you can have a guy for the short term that has proven you can win games with, keep JJ around and develop him and if he develops into what you envisioned when you traded up to pick him in the top 10, you have a chance to have a really good QB situation for a long time. And with that means you have a chance to contend for a while. Unless you're gonna rock with Darnold that whole time since he is young-ish. But I would caution Minnesota with that; going into 2022 the Giants did not view DJ as a long term answer, DJ had a career year (you always have to be careful of players who have career years in contract years anyways), they change their minds and give him that extension and you saw what that led to. Not that Minnesota would necessarily bottom out the way the Giants have but still
@@davidriedy5977 I think Mel said trade the 3rd pick for JJ the Vikings will laugh at the Giants and pick Travis Hunter a one in a lifetime player with the 3rd pick. If it's not for a second round pick the Vikings can keep him. That's if Cam and Sanders go 1 and 2. Jefferson and Travis Hunter in the same team is insane.
D NO way in HECK. Injured as a rookie. Is he a candidate for injury not as mobile as he should be does not wrk for the nyg line as it sits. Is he coming off injury to soon. As we know without knees your career is numbered as a QB. Ya modern medical is good but a knee, no way you can convince me he is 100% as he was. Let say this if he got injured in college his draft stock would have been late first or even mid second round, most of the time a QB is actually passed on and we'll I just don't trust the injury. We need a real QB mobile QB not one that is not and we know nothing of his injury as to the future. Injury prone as I said l. All arrows point to that.
I would consider that trade because with the new coaching changes that's going to happen i have a feeling there is going to be alot of movement if the draft board as well.
Personally - I have no problem with this trade. I wanted the Giants to draft JJ McCarthy last season at this time and I was some what disappointed they took Malik Nabors, Bu I understood why. Now they got a chance to have their cake and eat it too. If he was in the draft this year - He probably would be the best QB in the draft. If JJ could have that big of a success in Michigan with the wide outs he had there, Imagine what kind of success he would have with Nabors. Besides - If the Giants don't make this deal, Chances are the Dallas Cowboys will and he'll give big blue trouble for years. Does any Giants fan want to take a chance on that ? In a way - I think it would make more sense for the Giants to trade down with the Vikings for JJ McCarthy and get an additional 2nd round pick. That way - They'd get some draft capital as well as a QB while the Vikings have a shot at getting Travis Hunter.
This whole rumor is driven by the national media. The Vikings have no intention of trading McCarthy. They spent the 10th overall pick on him just last year! It’s far more likely that they franchise tag Darnold and trade him this offseason. This will provide the Vikings with $76 million in cap space to improve upon an already good roster.
Another way to look at it is that the Giants would never be able to draft JJ and Nabers last year. So if they end up with both this year does really matter. As long as they don’t give up too much. The #34 pick is my limit.
Give me Hunter and Dart. Quick question...why would they trade their "franchise" qb to us, if they believe in him so much? And if Cam and Sanders is taken, then wouldn't we take Travis Heisman? And for my last question... Why would we give away the number 3 pick for an injured quarterback?... If he get injured again for whatever reason that will really set us back this is a dumb take, which is kind of weird for me to say about you Marshall
@@saraxiong There is plenty of QB options without trading away the 3rd pick for a QB that never played in the NFL with a bad knee. Vikings will be in terrible next year with their QB situation,Sam Darnold is having a career year and will come back to earth next year. Wait Vikings sure are desperate for a QB as they sign Daniel Jones who maybe your starter next year. Try again beautiful. I love eating you up.😃
@ Ward is a better QB than all 3 of your QB’S. Giants will be just fine. Speaking of Clowns,How many super bowl have the Vikings won? None! 0-4 record. 🤡So keep your ugly attitude as the only thing you got is outside beauty Even Daniel Jones spanked the Vikings in the playoffs. 🤣😂🤣The Giants will win another Super Bowl before your Vikings win their first.
It's crazy idk where these rumors are coming from this fan base was begging leadership not to draft him at 6 after the top 3 QBs were gone but 1 year later we're going trade the 3 pick for him after having 2 surgeries on his knee and barely seeing him play? what are we doing?
This could be the GM Joe Schoen and HC Brian Daboll second shot to get JJ McCarthy. They had no chance to get JJ from the last NFL draft. This could be their last shot to get JJ in a trade with the Minnesota Vikings, if the Vikings keep JJ.
It would absolutely be the final nail in the franchise coffin. Why draft JJ at 6 last year when we can take him a year later at #3 after he misses whole year with major injury
He was a consensus 2nd rounder until the college season ended and the PR machine went into overdrive and he ended up 1st round. Now he’s missed an entire year. He hasn’t taken a snap since the preseason and coming off knee surgery. No guarantee he could even start this year.
I would definitely reach out to see if the Vikings are interested in trading JJ. My opening offer would be not be including a 1 st round pick. Maybe multiple draft picks. Like a couple 3rd rounders. Or even as high a 2nd rounder. But, the 3rd overall pick is too high.
Hi Marshall, I found a video very informative. My pic would be Travis Hunter if both quarterbacks are off the board at one and two maybe that’s why I’m not a GM and then pick up a quarterback in the second round imagine Malik Nabers and Travis Hunter on the other side, it would more than rival the Eagles Brown and Smith. With a decent quarterback and running back I think would be a pretty good shape, my opinion.
I would trade for JJ if Ward is gone off the board. However, I would pick Travis Hunter with the 3rd pick & I would give Minny a 2nd & 3rd round pick for JJ. That’s still two picks for JJ. But not the 3rd overall pick
If they passed on him last year and essentially draft him with the #3 a year later after he didn’t take a snap due to injury Schoen should have been fired.
Would you trade #3 pick for JJ McCarthy? A for Accept | D for Decline
Hard decision im fine with what ever happens they should do it if cam ward and sheduar sanders are gone
D
Sorry, no. I'm taking Travis Hunter & signing Fields or someone as a temporary QB. There's no way McCarthy is worth the 3rd overall pick.
Take the guesswork out of buying tickets with Gametime. Download the Gametime app, create an account and use code CHATSPORTS for $20 off your first purchase! Check out gametime.co for last minute tickets.
Big freaking D
Two words…FUCK NO!
Yes he's not gonna see no playing time ???
☺️
I would trade a 2nd round pick at most
Facts
2nd and 5th no more
Exactly!!
And I would want it to be next years second, we have a really good second round pick this year.
LoL hysterical
They better fucking not trade the 3rd overall also mel is the same guy that said the giants shouldn’t cut DJ I don’t trust this man at all
@@pokemoore5550 facts 💯
@pokemoore5550 Same. I see the Kiper Boy as a mix of Gettleman and Pat Shumur back in the 2010's.
FACTS!
@@SonicSupremeSGT3 That's an insult to Gettleman and Shumur. Kiper is way, WAY dumber than those two.........
I said last year that the QB was the only thing that would hold the offense back. He couldn't get the ball to the recovers because he couldn't throw thar far.
Only way I would give up our third pick for JJ McCarthy if the Vikings also threw in their first round pick
Still wouldn't be worth it...........
I definitely agree with that.
I could agree with that.
Quit smoking crack
Agree
Thats the dumbest trade I've ever heard. A guy who's coming off a season ending injury w/ an additional knee procedure and hasn't even played a snap in the regular season, is not worth a top 5 pick.
Kipper is a clown 😂
An a$$ clown
Anything not to draft a Black Quarterback is the Giants mindset it seems. And bye the way we need some damn Cheerleaders to look @ if we're gonna lose every Sunday Mara. 🏈
Facts lol they take pride and not drafting a blk quarterback
@@dextersmart5289 black blue or brown. JJ McCarthy is better than sanders and ward. It’s that simple.
I agree
@@blazinrounds230 He's damaged goods in year 2 and nobody knows what he's gonna be like post injury so he damn sure better be worth any risk.
@ that’s what compensatory picks are for
Wait, so if Cam and Sanders go 1 and 2. You are going to trade the third pick to the Vikings. So Travis Hunter and Jefferson on the same team.
Gotta be the dumbest shit ever if I’m John Mara and both of those QBS are off the board I’m signing Sam darnold and taking Travis hunter simple as that!
@@manofsteel9716 in this scenario the Vikings would re-sign Darnold. I agree with taking Travis Hunter, though. I’d rather pay Cousins cheap for a couple of seasons and draft the future QB in 2026. That said, I’d rather have Ward or Sanders than McCarthy.
If ward or sanders not there I’d take Travis then Milroe or dart in the 2nd
They may need to trade up 8 slots or so for Milroe. He's worth it.
@@marcsilverberg1060no he isn’t. Milroe sucks. Great rb maybe lmfao he ain’t it fam.
I agree with you
Cutlets ? Does he still get a guaranteed roster spot since Dabs loves him ?
@ dabs doesn’t love him, he is an ERFA in 2025 and at best he makes practice squad for Giants in 2025.
Mel is a jackass if he thinks any team is going to trade a number one for an unproven QB who has one less year on rookie contract that how to seasoning ending injury.
Any team that does that trade the gm should be fired immediately.
Is It me or would this move suggest that the owner isn't a fan of black QBs ?
Same thing I was thinking
That's why they'll continue to lose. This is a new NFL and mobile QBs not just black is what it is now. Black QBs do dominate the mobile QBs tho. They want Eli part 2. That's why they hired Joe Schein. Eli twin. Lol.
YES!!!!!!!
If Mara does this when Cam or Shudder is there for them at #3 well then we have to start to investigate Mara & his reluctantly to draft a black QB!!!!!!! We need Shudder or Cam to get this franchise headed in the right direction. They better not trade for McCarthy if Ward or Shudder is available to us at 3.
Ward and shauder wont be avail at 3. We tyrod ffs. He didnt want to resign. You ppl make up the worst conspiracy theorys
Sure lets trade a hot to trot #3 pick for a QB who hasnt played for an entire season and has suffered a torn meniscus in his right knee during the preseason, makes perfect sense.
WTF, I knew they would F it up.
You are so right brither
like it’s not rocket science 😂😂😂 i don’t even know why people are entertaining jj for the 3rd pick. i’d take him for our second and something else but not for the 3rd
They’re not giving a 1st round pick for him ! Not #3 anyway !! No way !
@ smart man hope this nonsense talk is just clickbait
@@ThUnDeRThUnDeR125why not ? He’s a year younger than sheduer and ward and would have been drafted higher than both
I don't want him I want ward or sanders
yeah I'm with you
But if we can't get cam or sanders is jj a could pick up?
If he was in this year’s draft he would go above both of them. Neither one of them have a first round grade on them really, especially Sanders
@tdmidas289 don't know don't follow him and don't want him the Giants can make it happen when it comes down to it because I don't think Cleveland is taking a quarterback because they signed what's his name to a contract
Cam Ward all day
Anything not to draft a black QB 🤦🏾♂️
Schoen ain’t takin sorry ass JJ LMAOOO…..
JJ a champion, and they wouldn't have won it without him.
@@juanharris3171all I know if you put cam or Shedeur on that team that JJ had they still win and they put up better numbers than JJ especially Cam Ward
@gcode2543 lol what a joke, JJ didn't have Restrepo or Travis. JJ made more NFL throws in one game TCU than both Ward and Sanders made in their entire careers
@gcode2543 Clearly you didn't watch JJ's michigan tape from the last 2 yrs
@@EUGENE304 idc what his tape shows, he’s not better than Cam Ward and if you think Cam couldn’t have had a better season than JJ it’s you that haven’t watched tape
Thanks!
No way! Please No
I would love JJ but I don’t believe the Vikes are going to trade him.
I've said that for years I don't see a team like the Patriots or Giants ever going all in on a black QB
JJ is a dink and dunker. Not accurate to tight windows.
JJ McCarthy isn’t worth the third pick the draft after the Giants went 1-13. Without massive offensive line help McCarthy does nothing here.
Honestly don’t see how anyone says McCarthys tape is better than Sanders…that’s just wild imo tbh
McCarthy won. Plane and simple. He did what was asked of him. How can you penalize him for being on the best run team
I’m not trading that pick for him. Trade the 2nd & 3 round picks for him and draft Travis Hunter
FUN FACT: JJ McCarthy Senior Season
Games with 150 or less passing yards: 7
Games with 300 passing yards: 1
Michigan literally beat Penn State in a game where McCarthy had 0 2nd half pass attempts!
Michigan won with McCarthy, but NOT BECAUSE of McCarthy. He is mediocre at best.
You did watch how terrible Michigan was this year cause no qb right?
@ Michigan lost 10 Offensive starters my guy 😅 10! They struggled in every category. You can’t be serious.
So we didn’t draft him with the 6 pick last year, so we’re gonna trade a 3rd pick this year. That’ll be the dumbest move Giant can make.
D
@@marcorodriguez6619 you quite obviously didn’t watch this video. And you don’t understand how fucking stupid you sound saying that.
You didn’t know Daniel sucked at the time
He got a bum knee ….cmon cut it out….KIPER IS A CLOWN 🤡
Is this a Joe Schoen move?
He should be fired after paying DJ then letting SB go to a divisional rival.
It’s their choice, yet I can’t say I like it.
Cam Ward or it’s a fail.
JJ to me is damaged goods until he proves otherwise. A meniscus tear is nothing to take lightly.
No. A year without plying coming off an all season ending injury.
New sub here. Love your quick straight forward approach and insights.
But Marshall the question should be: Is JJ McCarthy better than Travis Hunter????
That's a dumb question. A qb wins you games a cb doesnt. It's a bad trade but Hunter isnt gonna change our team alot.
This kid is awful im sorry but after i saw his bowl game performance i couldn't believe the hype around this guy he couldnt make a solid pass past 10 yards.... an the fact hes injured an looks like a pencil i wouldnt be surprised to see this kid hurt again very soon especially if he were to play right now. He's only 21 an needs to put on some size an we have no idea how hes gunna perform after injury an if kevins sayin hes so good why tf would he trade him LOL.
I'll be 100% DONE! With the Giants if they trade that pick!
Why trade for a player not better than Daniel Jones?
If the Giants miss out on saunders or Ward go get Travis hunter then go after Jalen milroe that guy is a beast at QB and has speed yo I would draft jalen
I don't think Milroe would make it to round 2 because of this QB class. They'd have to trade up after 1st pick.
would be the dumbest decision of our lives
Trading #3 for JJ is outrageous
Giants aren't that dumb. That rumor had to come from Minny. U can keep boy wonder not interested. Rather draft Mccord, Dart or Kourke over him. Joe has to take a stand here, ignore the noise and make the right decision. No desperate moves. No matter what.
I would sooner than the Patriots a draft pick for Joe Milton.
@davissinclair4945 No there some solid prospects in this draft. U just have to find them.
The Vikings had him in house for a year . If they trade him, obviously they don't feel the same about his ability !!!
He’s had a torn acl all year dip shit.
That wouldn't be true at all. This is a team that finished the season at 14 - 3 with another QB in place. If the vikes fail to win a ring the situation becomes what does that team need outside of QB to get them over the hump? A window to win is very short so why would the vikes disturb what already seems to work with Sam. It wasn't what was expected but it happened. Good problem to have for the vikes.
If we can not get Cam Ward in the first round, then get hunter in the 1st and get Jaxson Dart in the 2nd
BIG BLUE JUST DOS NOT LIKE BLACL QB
Tyrod Taylor.
U dum
That would be the dumbest move ever. He's not better than Shaduer or Cam. Why would they trade a top 3 pick for a number 6 coming off of an injury??
Jj would not be number 2 in this draft😂. Bro played college football in literally the perfect situation
@@tdmidas289 If he was in this year’s draft he would be the first quarterback taken. I can understand and I can certainly see why you support Sanders and Ward but neither one of them really have a first round grade on them, especially Sanders. I wouldn’t trade my third overall pick no matter what but I would draft McCarthy over Sanders
You’re right. He would be #1
He would by a long shot be the first qb on this draft.
@Ijustinsultedyou I think a 3rd overall plus extra would be worth it for JJ. He's got a years worth of studying in an offense that made Sam Darnold relevant again. He's had a year to get accustomed to the differences between college and pro ball. As minor as those factors may be, it's still experience, and if he's as equally as good or better than Sanders & Ward, he would be an easy trade for me.
@@rvanemburg78 Yeah but there’s just one hangup and it’s a major one. He would be coming to the Giants and Brian Daboll. He’ll be coming to an organization that has an owner, that’s struggling to be an owner. He would be coming to an organization that has a GM that was never a GM before and is displaying evidence of that. He would be coming to an organization that has a head coach that was never a head coach before but got the job because of what everyone thought was great offensive play calling but now he’s been exposed as a fraud in that even after calling plays all year long this year.
You were wrong on last years draft as Daniels is clearly the best of that draft. Even Cliff Kingsbury, who interviewed for Chicago's OC position. He said that Daniels was the best and should go #1. They disagree, and let Olive walk. Now, who's the best QB in the playoffs, Daniels, and Washington has totally changed the franchise because of DQ, Kliff, and Daniels. Also, Daniels also said that McCarthy is hands down the better QB than those in this draft. So, I would definitely make the trade. Last year's QB draft class have all trained together except for Caleb Williams. So the other five are friends and talk regularly. If the agree that JJ is better then I believe them and coach McConnell. So I'd make the trade.
Calling it done on the eval after 1 year? Wild
Make sure you are all caught up on everything Giants by checking out our latest Giants Now TH-cam videos:
- PERFECT New York Giants Offseason Plan - th-cam.com/video/OIitioqAkyk/w-d-xo.html
- Hire Antonio Pierce As Defensive Coordinator? | New York Giants Rumors - th-cam.com/video/zhI3cBW7MrE/w-d-xo.html
- New York Giants Mock Draft 5.0 🚨 1st Of NFL Offseason With #3 Pick - th-cam.com/video/DRkc-1hu2pI/w-d-xo.html
Isn’t he coming off an ACL tear? Hard pass…..
If Sanders had a different last name he'd be the CLEAR #1. The hate is comical at this point!
I would only do a pick swap and JJ Mcarthy. So we still have a pick in the first round and build this team. I can understand why this trade would happen though.
Absolutely trade our #3 foe McCarthy. He would be better than either Sanders or Ward. But the Vikes will not go for it. He is their future.
They better not do that bs
I mean I am a huge giants fan but guys 8 think JJ McCarthy is great I think we should get him
If that was a plan why that trade didn’t take place for DJ. But anyway I’m pass that and instead want Ward and/or Sanders.
I would make the trade if sanders off the board, I would trade the 2026 draft, not this year draft.
GET TWO QUARTERBACKS
Only if we get additional picks from the Vikings in round 2 or 3
I would trade for him but not the 3rd overall pick. I would trade our 2nd round pick though. Injury and unknown in the nfl, I think Vikings might consider trading him despite not being offered a 1st round 2025 pick.
Nope!
GET TRAVIS HUNTER TOO
how would you compare JJ vs Ward?
Need more of today's New York Giants Now by Chat Sports with host Marshall Green? Subscribe now to get daily doses of insider rumors and more: www.youtube.com/@nygiantstv?sub_confirmation=1
I would hate this team forever
That’s not happening. Come on now.
If we swap first round picks with Vikings and we get McCarthy fan, MAYBE. I don’t really like that, but MAYBE.
Thank you Marsh
I would trade if Cam Ward is not available when we pick
JJ is not HIM I hope they do not do that dude is going to be a bust as well. He is not even better than Daniel Jones OMFG Giants are the Knicks of old SMH
I don't want this, and also I think Minnesota would be stupid to do this. If they sign Darnold as everyone projects them to (and why would Darnold want to leave? He had the best season of his career) you can have a guy for the short term that has proven you can win games with, keep JJ around and develop him and if he develops into what you envisioned when you traded up to pick him in the top 10, you have a chance to have a really good QB situation for a long time. And with that means you have a chance to contend for a while. Unless you're gonna rock with Darnold that whole time since he is young-ish. But I would caution Minnesota with that; going into 2022 the Giants did not view DJ as a long term answer, DJ had a career year (you always have to be careful of players who have career years in contract years anyways), they change their minds and give him that extension and you saw what that led to. Not that Minnesota would necessarily bottom out the way the Giants have but still
@@davidriedy5977 I think Mel said trade the 3rd pick for JJ the Vikings will laugh at the Giants and pick Travis Hunter a one in a lifetime player with the 3rd pick. If it's not for a second round pick the Vikings can keep him. That's if Cam and Sanders go 1 and 2. Jefferson and Travis Hunter in the same team is insane.
Marshall I love your content. Keep up the good work my man. I ride and die with Big Blue. 😂
Thank God it was Mel saying this. He hasn't been right in my 50+ years of being a Giants fan 😢😂😮
If you're going that route, you draft Trav and trade Kayvon and a pick for JJ. Otherwise that would be fucking stupid.
well if Vikings are gr8 at QB eval, and they been around him for a year and already wanna dump him for #3. why would we even consider...
5th pick or later.... damaged goods too
Share today's Giants Now episode on Facebook!
D NO way in HECK. Injured as a rookie. Is he a candidate for injury not as mobile as he should be does not wrk for the nyg line as it sits. Is he coming off injury to soon. As we know without knees your career is numbered as a QB. Ya modern medical is good but a knee, no way you can convince me he is 100% as he was. Let say this if he got injured in college his draft stock would have been late first or even mid second round, most of the time a QB is actually passed on and we'll I just don't trust the injury. We need a real QB mobile QB not one that is not and we know nothing of his injury as to the future. Injury prone as I said l. All arrows point to that.
Marsh, NOOOOOOO!!!! DRAFT ONE WTF!
NO WAY Vikings are trading JJ after Sam's playoff performance.
I would consider that trade because with the new coaching changes that's going to happen i have a feeling there is going to be alot of movement if the draft board as well.
I'd go after JJ. 2nd rnder
Personally - I have no problem with this trade. I wanted the Giants to draft JJ McCarthy last season at this time and I was some what disappointed they took Malik Nabors, Bu I understood why. Now they got a chance to have their cake and eat it too. If he was in the draft this year - He probably would be the best QB in the draft. If JJ could have that big of a success in Michigan with the wide outs he had there, Imagine what kind of success he would have with Nabors. Besides - If the Giants don't make this deal, Chances are the Dallas Cowboys will and he'll give big blue trouble for years. Does any Giants fan want to take a chance on that ?
In a way - I think it would make more sense for the Giants to trade down with the Vikings for JJ McCarthy and get an additional 2nd round pick. That way - They'd get some draft capital as well as a QB while the Vikings have a shot at getting Travis Hunter.
Isn’t this the same guy who thought DJ was worth his contract?? Lol Enough said!! Lol 😂😂
absolutely no !!!! This makes no sense when you could of had him with the 6th pick
McCarthy was garbage. If the Giants wanted him, they would've gotten him last year.
This whole rumor is driven by the national media. The Vikings have no intention of trading McCarthy. They spent the 10th overall pick on him just last year! It’s far more likely that they franchise tag Darnold and trade him this offseason. This will provide the Vikings with $76 million in cap space to improve upon an already good roster.
If he’s so great why would Minnesota get rid of him?
My only argument would be Darnold worked out better than they thought so difficult to move away from Darnold after his success.
Mel Kiperjr is a not very reliable source.
Another way to look at it is that the Giants would never be able to draft JJ and Nabers last year. So if they end up with both this year does really matter. As long as they don’t give up too much. The #34 pick is my limit.
Give me Hunter and Dart. Quick question...why would they trade their "franchise" qb to us, if they believe in him so much? And if Cam and Sanders is taken, then wouldn't we take Travis Heisman? And for my last question... Why would we give away the number 3 pick for an injured quarterback?... If he get injured again for whatever reason that will really set us back this is a dumb take, which is kind of weird for me to say about you Marshall
Lmao we ain’t trading McCarthy! Get over it! Good lord!
You can keep that bum! Not getting the Giants 3rd pick in the draft.
@ lmao we are keeping McCarthy! Keep your pick! Who’s more desperate for a qb? It ain’t us!
@@saraxiong There is plenty of QB options without trading away the 3rd pick for a QB that never played in the NFL with a bad knee. Vikings will be in terrible next year with their QB situation,Sam Darnold is having a career year and will come back to earth next year. Wait Vikings sure are desperate for a QB as they sign Daniel Jones who maybe your starter next year. Try again beautiful. I love eating you up.😃
@ yeah that’s what everyone said about this year too clown. 🤣 sorry to burst your bubble but our coach can develop a qb, unlike yours. 🤷🏻♀️😂
@ Ward is a better QB than all 3 of your QB’S. Giants will be just fine. Speaking of Clowns,How many super bowl have the Vikings won? None! 0-4 record. 🤡So keep your ugly attitude as the only thing you got is outside beauty Even Daniel Jones spanked the Vikings in the playoffs. 🤣😂🤣The Giants will win another Super Bowl before your Vikings win their first.
Unless we’re swapping picks with Minnesota, and getting McCarthy and other assets it’s not worth it at all
It's crazy idk where these rumors are coming from this fan base was begging leadership not to draft him at 6 after the top 3 QBs were gone but 1 year later we're going trade the 3 pick for him after having 2 surgeries on his knee and barely seeing him play? what are we doing?
But if they are gonna trade him..... That means hes not going to be better than Sam Darnold...
This could be the GM Joe Schoen and HC Brian Daboll second shot to get JJ McCarthy. They had no chance to get JJ from the last NFL draft. This could be their last shot to get JJ in a trade with the Minnesota Vikings, if the Vikings keep JJ.
It would absolutely be the final nail in the franchise coffin. Why draft JJ at 6 last year when we can take him a year later at #3 after he misses whole year with major injury
Giants could have picked him last draft and chose Malik. So, there is that....
Hell No.
He was a consensus 2nd rounder until the college season ended and the PR machine went into overdrive and he ended up 1st round. Now he’s missed an entire year. He hasn’t taken a snap since the preseason and coming off knee surgery. No guarantee he could even start this year.
These are the type of things the Giants do to keep the Giants where they’re at. None of this makes sense leverage wise.
I would definitely reach out to see if the Vikings are interested in trading JJ. My opening offer would be not be including a 1 st round pick. Maybe multiple draft picks. Like a couple 3rd rounders. Or even as high a 2nd rounder. But, the 3rd overall pick is too high.
So let me get this straight… he wasn’t worth a 6 overall pick last year but he’s worth 3 overall this year.. lol
Hi Marshall, I found a video very informative. My pic would be Travis Hunter if both quarterbacks are off the board at one and two maybe that’s why I’m not a GM and then pick up a quarterback in the second round imagine Malik Nabers and Travis Hunter on the other side, it would more than rival the Eagles Brown and Smith. With a decent quarterback and running back I think would be a pretty good shape, my opinion.
Trade 2nd &5th
I would trade for JJ if Ward is gone off the board. However, I would pick Travis Hunter with the 3rd pick & I would give Minny a 2nd & 3rd round pick for JJ. That’s still two picks for JJ. But not the 3rd overall pick
Only if the two QBs aren't available. But then again, Travis Hunter.....I don't know. If Cam Ward is available, gotta get him.
If they passed on him last year and essentially draft him with the #3 a year later after he didn’t take a snap due to injury Schoen should have been fired.