Super comparison fellas. This is the best explanation I have heard. I have come to the conclusion over the years that I would rather have two mid-range mid-layers than one super one. Allows me to layer better for what I need.
They will be very similar in actual warmth, the Cirque is thicker so you'll have a warmer "feel" but the Aerolite will hold similar heat with less bulk.
The Kelvin Lite Down is going to be quite different from the Cirque... It will be warmer, but less breathable since it is a down insulation layer. The Kelvin Lite Down is not our favorite piece due to the loud/crunchy face fabric, but it does function quite well. For me, I would go with the Cirque or Aerolite before I went with the Kelvin Lite Down. I like to go with synthetic options if I want to be at all active in the jacket, and I want my down jacket to be thick and warm for times when I am not moving. Hope this helps - Brady
@@gearfool thanks for the info. I’m looking at a synthetic vs down option for times when I am not moving. I have my active layers covered, so now looking for a static option.
@@readyme For what it's worth, I would recommend basing your synthetic vs down decision on the likelihood of moisture and precipitation in the region you'll be adventuring. The warmth-to-weight ratio of down insulation really can't be beat and it's increased packability is an added bonus. With that being said, perhaps synthetic insulation is the way to go for your region if there's a lot of moisture...or frequent possibility thereof. - Forest
These are the four pieces I’ve been considering. I’m looking for a mid layer over my Sitka base layers to go under my outer puffy when super cold and to be my outer layer when my heavier puffy isn’t needed.
Commenting on an older video so apologies; with a windbreaker would you say the Ambient is warmer than the Cirque Lite? It does have a higher listed Insulation rating 100/60.
You're good! I'd say the Cirque lite will be a slightly better windbreaker than the ambient, but the ambient will be a bit warmer in non-windy conditions depending on which weight you choose.
I think most people will agree that the aerolite is a bit warmer, but the Cirque will have better DWR treatment, and it'll probably be more abrasion resistant. However, both will serve the same purpose. I like the aerolite myself due to the small pack size. -Brady
SG thinks you should strip down to base when stalking :) but then again, western high altitude, rifle long range hunting Sheep hunting, long range hunters are their base, fast and light.
![เปิดใจ “ต้นหอม ศกุนตลา” หลังโดนพาดพิงธุรกิจที่เคยทำ และผลกระทบทำถูกปลดฟ้าผ่า! | แฉ 24 ต.ค.67 [2/3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vCi5OIqlxaE/mqdefault.jpg)
Super comparison fellas. This is the best explanation I have heard. I have come to the conclusion over the years that I would rather have two mid-range mid-layers than one super one. Allows me to layer better for what I need.
Hi Craig. Thanks for the comment! We agree. There's a lot of versatility and performance variation in the mid-layer category. - Forest
Which would you say is warmer the Cirque regular or Kelvin
They will be very similar in actual warmth, the Cirque is thicker so you'll have a warmer "feel" but the Aerolite will hold similar heat with less bulk.
I’d like to see a direct comparison between the SG Cirque and the Sitka Kelvin Lite Down Jacket as outmost layers.
The Kelvin Lite Down is going to be quite different from the Cirque... It will be warmer, but less breathable since it is a down insulation layer. The Kelvin Lite Down is not our favorite piece due to the loud/crunchy face fabric, but it does function quite well. For me, I would go with the Cirque or Aerolite before I went with the Kelvin Lite Down. I like to go with synthetic options if I want to be at all active in the jacket, and I want my down jacket to be thick and warm for times when I am not moving. Hope this helps - Brady
@@gearfool thanks for the info. I’m looking at a synthetic vs down option for times when I am not moving. I have my active layers covered, so now looking for a static option.
@@readyme For what it's worth, I would recommend basing your synthetic vs down decision on the likelihood of moisture and precipitation in the region you'll be adventuring. The warmth-to-weight ratio of down insulation really can't be beat and it's increased packability is an added bonus. With that being said, perhaps synthetic insulation is the way to go for your region if there's a lot of moisture...or frequent possibility thereof. - Forest
These are the four pieces I’ve been considering. I’m looking for a mid layer over my Sitka base layers to go under my outer puffy when super cold and to be my outer layer when my heavier puffy isn’t needed.
I think the Ambient, or Cirque Lite will both be great options. The Cirque Lite will be a little warmer, the Ambient will be a little more breathable.
Perfect. Thanks brotha!
Commenting on an older video so apologies; with a windbreaker would you say the Ambient is warmer than the Cirque Lite? It does have a higher listed Insulation rating 100/60.
You're good! I'd say the Cirque lite will be a slightly better windbreaker than the ambient, but the ambient will be a bit warmer in non-windy conditions depending on which weight you choose.
Luv these kind of reviews ,,,keep em coming,,,,please…
Thanks for the comment, Michael!
Always watching! good information!!! What hoodies you wearing in the vid? Looking for a warm weather hoody
Hi Chris. We appreciate it! I'm wearing the SITKA Core Lightweight Hoody in this video, and Brady is wearing the SITKA Heavyweight Hoody. - Forest
Between the Cirque and the Aerolite which is warmer? Which one is more abrasion resistant?
I think most people will agree that the aerolite is a bit warmer, but the Cirque will have better DWR treatment, and it'll probably be more abrasion resistant. However, both will serve the same purpose. I like the aerolite myself due to the small pack size. -Brady
SG thinks you should strip down to base when stalking :) but then again, western high altitude, rifle long range hunting Sheep hunting, long range hunters are their base, fast and light.