Another bad thing, which B-Rad didn't say, is that normal people in order to play with 2 evolutions must be level 54* of the King's Journey, which is difficult to obtain without spending money, and even spending it is hard.
If a game's pro players are discontented and finds playing your game like a chore, it's a clear sign your game is turning to shit. These devs need to wake up.
Dagger dutchess was the first time I felt like I literally couldn’t compete unless I got a card. I’ve leveled the Egor mortar miner deck to max and I’m banking everything from here on out. The problem I run into is everytime I get close to maxing a deck the meta changes and as a F2P player you just have to take the L and accept you’re not gonna do as well
Yep when dagger duchess was at its peak you couldnt win unless you had it and if you didnt have it then you would be at a big disadvantage and would most likely lose even if the opponent was worse
I thought Miner poison was too strong, and was kind of glad DD should have killed it. Then I played against it with hog EQ. It freaking killed the hog instantly.
Ya dagger Dutchess was the first time I felt a huge disadvantage if u didn't have it.. I'm a top 3 k player b4 now it shifted me to top 9k because I don't have it maxed
@@matthewcadden1967 yeah and it made so many win conditions bad, i play mk wallbreakers and my miner got countered by duchess, wallbreakers got countered by it. It was impossible to get damage with my win conditions
your comment seems very comforting i quit cr it's been 2 years wisest decision i ever made because it became pay 2 win, if u look at any other supercell games all of them are pay 2 win, they launch game free then so everyone stays at a level and then they monetize every single thing. you have to pay 200£ every month to stay relevant otherwise you'll be left behind
@@BenCH417same. I was literally addicted to the game. I had withdrawal symptoms, up until the point dagger dutchess was introduced. I played three games, understood how broken the tower troop was, immediately deleted and never played again. No easier fix for my addiction.
I'll give an example, CR should learn from this. Yesterday in Brawl Stars i bought my first brawl pass that costed money. It's the first time in ever (and i've been playing since 2019) i've bought something for real money in the game. Now, the normal price for it i consider too expensive and the Brawl Pass+ (the equivalent to Diamond pass) is even more expensive. I wouldn't have bought it IF NOT for a discount it was on for half the price.
Once they gutted the pass, that was the end of my spending. They would have to pay me to get one of their deals at this point lol. Just save ur money. It's only a matter of time until it's all made worthless with Another level increase.
What can you even buy in clash royale for thousands of euros? I feel like 400-600 euros at most is enough to max everything in the game, what were you even buying?
Clash Royale is supposed to be a strategic game where its one policy is that "No card is supposed to be the best." I always wanted new cards to be added, but not Champions, Evolutions and Tower Troops along with changing the season pass. They treated it like Clash of Clans when it's a game of competition, not war.
@@kerolokerokeroloI think the majority left when they introduced level 15. You had grinded so hard to get level 14 just so they could pull the rug from under you.
One more thing I want to add is that the book of books (etc) are listed at $20 but have an outrageous 10x value...so a book of books is worth $200?? That's absolutely mental.
They’re sacrificing short-term profits for long-term profit. If they just returned clash royale before tower troops and added skins (like B-rad said), people would naturally spend money
The decline would’ve been delayed if they were smart about it. Team Fortress, CSGO, and other games are in the same stage of decline but the games have been surviving for more than a decade, clash royale have not made it through a full decade yet
@@Gab12345BR there was card collection day and then war day. Didn’t rlly give good rewards tho and as the word “clash” was common between cr and coc their logic was to put war in the game too
if they keep thinking: " oh you don't like the game i don't care, lose 1 player like you isn't a big deal, there are millions more" then they gonna lose the rest
@@Jeff_boii I dont think they make that much money from it anyways… if clash royale revenue is small then creator code profit is small too Clash royale needs to listen to the public and youtubers
Message for every pro players and youtubers : can you just make a tweet, make a video to just say STOP, like Riley, Ian, Mohamed, Viiper…. I was a French competitive player back in the days but I’m done with this shit, IM DONE and I’m never coming back
The top players cannot boycott because they make money off the game’s competitive ladder. B-rad’s different because he’s a content creator and not a professional player (we don’t watch for his skills)
I’m in league 9 and in the middle of the season they nerfed 3 of my cards and my tower troop. It’s insane if I can’t even play my deck for more than a month. Feels like I have to do this all the time. No fun at all. Now to be competitive I need to spend a ton of money to win. And I don’t even mind spending some cash. But this is no longer fun.
i remember when evolutions came out... i commented under one of your video's that this is where i quit (which i did). once the integrity of a game is ruined like that, it only goes downhill. now its a p2w scamfest that fanboys try to defend. its the fault of the customers giving these companies a pass. fk them dont buy it, they will change, vote with your wallet
I hate how mobile games are so infected with this p2w mentality. I'm so fed up that I just quit all of them. every game that I played eventually had the same fate
I just don’t understand, Clash Royale at its core is probably my favorite game of all time and nowadays I barely play it. Like I literally play Pokemon Go you’d think that no one could handle a game worse than Niantic and then you see CR just being 10x worse. It makes no sense when Brawl Stars is just killing it every update now. I’m going to actually disagree I don’t think champions were the downfall of CR I think it was when they stopped monthly balance changes. Pair that with the horrendous monetization and it’s just terrible. We waited for what 4 months for little prince to get nerfed and now it’s finally nerfed but they nerfed it to the ground to the point I found out only 15% of decks right now in GC even use a champion like are we kidding how do u let this happen. The worst part is I think the concepts for all the updates were really smart I like the idea of Champions, evolutions (other than zap, damage dealing spells never should have gotten evolutions, maybe defensive towers too) and tower troops (even if they were like 4 years too late) but they managed to implement them all so badly. Like champions were fine but lvl 14 was implemented with the whole slash Royale controversy, then saying u could only unlock champions when u hit king tower 14 which I was fine with but now you don’t even need to so what was the point of lvl 14 or 15. Then you release evos with only 4 evolutions like funneling the same decks when realistically 6-8 should’ve been released at the start minimum to make the meta ok. Then the fact they’re impossible to get, why would they make it u get one shard every 2 king levels at that rate it should be a full new evo. Then finally make it so there’s only one new tower troop making it impossible to balance when realistically they should’ve started with 3 new ones plus the princess. I don’t know where all the dev time is going bc these updates take forever and release nothing. Then the absolute worst part is the lack of transparency like they told us we’d get a roadmap, never happened. I don’t ever see the CR community managers on twitter, can’t say the same about CoC and BS who are always talking to the community. Finally if you still aren’t convinced just watch a brawl talk and you’ll notice the difference then realize there’s one every two months. Yup it’s night and day
But this month supercell ruined the game 1.Change logo 2.Evolution Goblin barrel that is completely useless 3.Goblin queen's journey 4.3 brand new cards realesed that are in the shop and later then getting an emergency nerf 5.Goblin queen's journey is litterally stupid like for every hundered trophies you kinda get stupid rewards
yeah that comment at around 20:00 is really what's making me lose interest in the game. Last season I grinned to royal champion and couldn't get any further. I wanted to play a different deck, but that's literally the only deck I have that has almost all level 15 cards. I just can't try anything else, because I will lose every time. Clash of clans keeps me coming back because when I get bored of an attack strategy, I can just try another army composition to freshen it up for me.
I know the feeling, I got stuck at royal champ in 3 different seasons but I finally hit ult champ for the first time this season, the day after I maxxed dagger duchess. Coincidence?
@@AJ_77602 nerf didn’t do anything, I was worried about maxing it when I heard the nerf but it’s still much better than the other towers. I hate tower troops so much but it’s the only way to push ladder
@@Karma0917I completely agree, i haven’t even played ladder much since the nerf (because of the goblin mode im being forced to play. so that’s somewhat good to know for me I guess, but I totally agree. Tower troops as a whole are just awful.
The only thing i want is 1- make level caps at arenas, im arena 15 and im sick of getting lvl 13 cards 2- make restrictions on offers, like the firecracker evo offers, if you havent reached spooky town you should not be able to buy the offer, same should apply on the champion offers that appear on arena 11 3- of course remove lvl 15 and make evo shards easier to get for f2ps 4- bring back wild cards in the season shop Don't hate me if I missed something
Clash royale devs belike:Oh we should add lvl 16 and get rid of the books and evo shards in the season shops als dont forgot 1 full old evolution for only 100$ also make it 20x value
Hey Morten will you be down for a protest of the monetization of Clash Royale with some other popular youtube streamers as well. I was thinking everyone should not buy any new shop offers or even the pass royale for the first week of the next month or something like that. The best way to hurt supercell is to hurt their pockets.
@@jakepeng9962 I would like that but I don't think it is very realistic since people do want the broken stuff and will eventually spending money on the game. I wish they don't but I can't really blame it if they do
@@Lkyseven I would like that but I don't think it is very realistic since people do want the broken stuff and will eventually spending money on the game. I wish they don't but I can't really blame it if they do
It’s sad to see a game I would play daily with classmates in 2018 is dying from turning p2w, I literally only play this game from nostalgia from 2017-2018
My way to play was I would get stuck from not buying the meta and would use a max level potion and just speed run to the top. But I havnt seen those potions in stock for over a year so I'll be done for in the future.
I agree with B-rad on almost everything but this game has always been very p2w. I think there's a lot of nostalgia talking when you don't remember how unfair and broken legendaries were upon released, not having Princess when it was released and broken was as frustrating if not more than facing double evolution and DD. I also think the new mechanics are cool, it's why I came back to the game. They just gotta tame down the p2w levelling system and be better with balancing, cosmetics should be the primary monetisation strategy anyway
if you were skilled, you could do classic challenges and 500 gems in tournaments and max in a couple of years at lvl 14. Now, the ceiling is about as high as Everest and impossible to be attained feasibly in a relevant amount of time.
Are you really comparing getting 1 legendary every like 6 months and that being broken, and another thing is getting evos, tower troops, lvl 15, in a 1 year period...?
The monetization got much better after 2017 and it remained good till 2022 ish before becoming p2w again. Obviously you could always pay for progression but everything was obtainable in a reasonable amount of time even for f2p now f2p have to wait like 3-4 months or so to get one evolution. That's crazy to me.
Yeah, legendary in first original Clas Royale really didn't make the game worst. It's not P2W. The Players who didn't have Legendary can counter it by using any cards that have exist the game. But right now, counter Evo cards is hard for F2P Players.
Like I put as a comment on B-rad's video: "Building a community is the most important thing in all of this. Without your community you are absolutely nothing no matter how awesome your game is. This rule is true no matter the size or funding of your studio. If you lose the faith of your players then you lose everything. You are never above your community and you are never too important to spend time responding to them. The moment you think you are they will show you how untrue that really is. Don't forget that. " - Thor Hall, AKA PirateSoftware
I’ve played this game sense I was in 7th grade all the way up until a year ago or two I’m a junior in college, this used to be one of my favorite games ever, Idk who the slimy disgusting, stinking, goofy, cr*ck smoking developers r now but they have absolutely destroyed this once amazing competitive game u could play for hours or with ur friends, now it’s all about that money money money, and they r so stupid with how they do it that it doesn’t even work, like how stupid r the developers, idk what fake green they r smoking but they r tweaked tf out, I have never seen a game be so amazing to a joke and a parody of itself so fast it’s insane, and I’m truly just disappointed and sad, it’s just like how Disney destroyed Star Wars, some new ppl came in, absolutely on that Heisenberg blue crystal, just like everyone at Disney and absolutely destroyed this amazing game.
Return to previous Pass Royale, increase lucky drop percentages, if you want the new season Evo you can pay, but if you want it for free you can get it next season and same for the rest of Evos in future, delete the new game mode and put it as a special season challenge cuz it's better than play for 3 days and then it's dead. Completely delete lvl 15 and wild cards cuz it's crap. Add 2v2 game mode as a test and if is good then turn it into a competitive game mode. Fix the season store, balance the tower troops, create new competitive stuff, add some new cards at least one every 3 months or something and please erase at least 50% of store offers, is crazy how you need to spend almost 1000 dollars to buy everything. That's it, no more P2W, at least I'll be a P2F so supercell can still winning millions and not kill the game at all. And no, I'm not a noobie who has been playing for 2 months, I'm a lvl 67 player with Evos, tower troops, CRL and ladder badge, been playing for 6 years now and I couldn't be more disappointed about this game rn.
New dev recruit: i will work for 24/7 and make this game new feature to both fp2 and paid users... I will make evolution ez to get for f2p CR HR: wakanda shit are you? Get the duck off of my studio Another recruit : make the shitty offers 10x value and put 20 dollars for every item in store and I will work only 4 days per month CR HR: you are hired!!!!!!
All the content creators of supercell games need to unite against the corrupt company and support clash with eric ,B-rad and many others standing against Supercell
Its wild watching people who profit off of the game complain about the game chargning things. All these content creators were stoked when creator codes came out, but now they have a problem with the game monetizing everything? You guys helped encourage it fr
I had uninstalled last year only when I got to know as a f2p player evolutions can't be unlocked and tower troops can't be used. I just came back this time for three new cards but would uninstall pretty soon.
i started a new f2p account 8 months ago. the account is now lvl 32 with tower lvl 11 to put it in perspective. reaching lvl 9 cards took me 2 weeks. reaching lvl 11 cards took me 8 months. tournament ready took 8 months reaching max level will take like 5 years💀
Very based that now even the German community draws attention towards the bad state of the game. For a long time I thought they just riding the CR devs and pretending everything was fine (looking at you, Bigspin). Thanks Morten
Agreed with your thoughts, but was hella cool playing you this season you beat me you were playing giant graveyard and I had xbow inferno trying to roll some normal giant players
I think that adding a new route only with the Princess and King Towers, without that green queen, without upgraded cards, and without tower level 15, or it would be limited to a place that is difficult to reach, and also only with classic cards without Exploding Goblin, Goblin Machine, and even the spell. If he wants players, even without heroes, why not?!
I quit this game in early 2020 thinking that with time I might want to come back to it. Now looking at the current state of all of clash. I’m glad I got out while I could
Coming here from clash of clans. Looks like were jumping into your sinking ship very soon. I cant stand the monetization in Coc now. Its making me sick with all these equipments
Cr devs team is also shit at balancing cards. They would buff the card without any reason. For instance, the buff on prince and ram rider which dumb as hell to get player to buy an evolution that is underwhelming. That is just straight up stupid.
I thought i finally caught as a f2p when i got everything maxed out when they gave out like 1.6mil gold during the chess event, but since evolution and tower troops and lvl 15 for cards came out, im back where i am 2 years ago
It's terrible for the casual player too because I was just getting used to the meta. It was mid season and I was cruising ... now everything is different, and I don't have wild cards for upgrades. I stopped playing again, and I'm already doing other things so I'm not going to stop doing them to go back and play Clash. I know me. I won't open the game for another two years (because of this update).
If you notice, they release a P2W OP card or evolution, then once everyone has purchased it, they nerf it and release a new over powered card that everyone rushes to buy, repeat, then repeat again
I thought it was dumb that if you had 15 princess tower, you were still getting princesses way more often from the tower troop chests than the cannoneer and dagger duchess.
It was dumb that you were getting princesses in the first place, since you don't need them to drop at all to upgrade. They drop only because if they didn't, it'll be too easy to unlock Dagger Duchess and Cannoneer.
@@jakeextreme4108 back when it was just cannoneer, I did the help and support in clash royale just asking why I was getting so many princesses from the tower troop chests and they told me it was a 3:1 ratio. A 75% chance to get cards you already had maxed and a 25% chance to get the new tower troop. That’s so blatantly scummy.
@@JRokk Even if you don't have maxed Tower Princess, you can get her cards from the tower troop chest. As far as I'm aware, you can't upgrade her to specific level until you upgrade your King to that level, so the Princess as a drop is absolutely useless at any point in the game Thanks supercell, you could've just decreased the amount of tower troop chests
Game has become near impossible for me after playing it for years. The few level 15 cards I have are near useless as the meta shifted away from them long ago due to dagger douchess and most of my matches being against people with 2 evos is pain
Getting epic and legendary wild cards in the season shop was huge, most people get gold common and rare wild cards in the drops, it’s so hard to upgrade or max a new legendary without money like 20 legendaries takes months or a legendary lucky drop where you’re hoping for a book of legendaries or book of books
10:40 exactly. I used to buy all the battle passes in clash Royale but when the game started getting worse and the nurff happened i haven't spent a single cent on the game. Im disappointed where CR has come.
Morten, I have seen your channel for quite some years, and you were the youtuber to go when i wanted to up my game. I find your content very valuable, but always found something was off because you tried so hard to mantain the channel family friendly. This is the first time one of your videos has some care free feeling, and I could not love this video more than I am doing it. You were trying so hard to maintain some dignity in the name of clash royale, but if you, a true follower and exponent of the game, is not able to defend it anymore, then no one could. Hope more videos with this relaxing and more "friendly" vibe are to come. Love your channel, and looking forward to see you upload squad busters videos :)
I was gonna reinstall it a while ago, but the game seems so unrecognizable that i don't wanna play it. And i hate having to scroll through my shop cuz its just filled with offers top to bottom
Im not even gonna hold you Clash royale and Brawl stars from a F2P perspective are entire UNIVERSES you cannot compare them in the slightest, take the recent "thumbsupforbrawl" event for example EVERYONE got 5 *FREE* LEGENDARY STARDROPS just because the community used some small funny thumbs up emote.
I’ve wanted to push to Ultimate Champion for months but I don’t have a single fully max deck so I just don’t have the motivation to push and get to like league 3 or 4 and stop playing
Actually i used to think that evolution could only be unlocked at level 15 and had something to do with mastery but it turned out it was completely different. Level 15 was just some shit that cr devs team thought to gain money and evolution has nothing to do with mastery.😓
They removed other items from other aspects of the game, like fewer coins from the chest, clan reward nerfs, and removal of some season shop offers and wild cards.
Have anyone noticed who ever buy the battle pass they get advantage in refilling the stamina in game keep eye on the card stamina point and ull see they play High point stamina card together at once which is impossible to do it but only battle pass player ull see play it
![mortenroyale[ENG]](http://yt3.ggpht.com/tSoPLjQ22J4gssHsAGgy90wuJ1_RCZdnxH1Dp9wLDTiAeMfum3SZ20nxCXt6h7mITfAcI747zg=s48-c-k-c0x00ffffff-no-rj)
Everyone has beef with CR at this point 💀
You can take the pro out and its still true
@@cbxjr bruh i didn't realize I typed pro
Tag hasn't made anything about it
And rightly so I'm glad people are speaking about greedy companies
@@honeyboom4175 yet
Another bad thing, which B-Rad didn't say, is that normal people in order to play with 2 evolutions must be level 54* of the King's Journey, which is difficult to obtain without spending money, and even spending it is hard.
I agree
You know what worse , if you invest in the wrong evo , you fkup
I think it's lvl54 I'm not sure though
Lvl 54
I'm there without spending any money
Supercell is playing limbo with how low these updates are going
THIS IS A GD REFERENCE🗣️🔥
And what's sad is that there is another evolution coming. They teased it today.
@@niademiogundana24 Source?
I laughed at this.
@@WailingFriend Clash royale's official X account
Evolutions, champions, and tower troops took a lot of strategy out of the game. Its basically rock paper scissors now
It's been rock paper scissors 😂
the game now is way more matchup dependent than ever before. og cr was hard to master. now is just dumb, every new season has a broken card
@@brunoc330 every card releease in last 2 year has been a disaster
Playing cr is like playing R.P.S but you dont have for example rock
It's always been rock paper and scissors. The problem is not the mechanics but the balancing and how p2w it is
If a game's pro players are discontented and finds playing your game like a chore, it's a clear sign your game is turning to shit. These devs need to wake up.
it's turning into Overwatch and no one will stop it to it deformation
Community managers*** there I fixed your comment.
Dagger dutchess was the first time I felt like I literally couldn’t compete unless I got a card. I’ve leveled the Egor mortar miner deck to max and I’m banking everything from here on out. The problem I run into is everytime I get close to maxing a deck the meta changes and as a F2P player you just have to take the L and accept you’re not gonna do as well
Yep when dagger duchess was at its peak you couldnt win unless you had it and if you didnt have it then you would be at a big disadvantage and would most likely lose even if the opponent was worse
@@shlimey04 yep. Truly game breaking
I thought Miner poison was too strong, and was kind of glad DD should have killed it. Then I played against it with hog EQ. It freaking killed the hog instantly.
Ya dagger Dutchess was the first time I felt a huge disadvantage if u didn't have it.. I'm a top 3 k player b4 now it shifted me to top 9k because I don't have it maxed
@@matthewcadden1967 yeah and it made so many win conditions bad, i play mk wallbreakers and my miner got countered by duchess, wallbreakers got countered by it. It was impossible to get damage with my win conditions
That's why Clash Royale theme now is Goblin
(They robbed their player)
LoL
Jews
Probably the ceo is a joo
@@paiwandibrahim3978 you ok?
Greedy Goblins Greedy Jews
Clash royale answer: $2 for the "stop crying" emote
LOOOOOL AIN'T BUYING THAT
Probably you work for them!!
4$ actually
I was a serious player for 7 years, left soon after level 15, glad to know I made the right choice.
your comment seems very comforting i quit cr it's been 2 years wisest decision i ever made because it became pay 2 win, if u look at any other supercell games all of them are pay 2 win, they launch game free then so everyone stays at a level and then they monetize every single thing. you have to pay 200£ every month to stay relevant otherwise you'll be left behind
Same
I joined you a bit late,but lm glad i did.Nothing got me more courage to quit until dagger tower update.
@@BenCH417same. I was literally addicted to the game. I had withdrawal symptoms, up until the point dagger dutchess was introduced. I played three games, understood how broken the tower troop was, immediately deleted and never played again.
No easier fix for my addiction.
Me too bro!!! Best decision ever!!
Making things more expensive doesn’t make you more money
Yeah supercell never thinks of this, 500 people buy $50 shit offers or 50000 people buy $3-5 actual reasonable offers
This is literally supported with the data too. CR now almost makes same revenue as Hayday.
@@Haillightmodeexactly . Supercell has a shitty business model because they will have no customer retention if they keep the bs up
They be losing money hayday is making more money than clash royale its literally dead
I'll give an example, CR should learn from this.
Yesterday in Brawl Stars i bought my first brawl pass that costed money. It's the first time in ever (and i've been playing since 2019)
i've bought something for real money in the game.
Now, the normal price for it i consider too expensive and the Brawl Pass+ (the equivalent to Diamond pass) is even more expensive.
I wouldn't have bought it IF NOT for a discount it was on for half the price.
I stopped spending money on this game years ago. It’s a total scam at this point
im very thankful i never spent money on this cash grab. miss the old game devs
Bro, ×10 value ... I don't see any scam here 🤓
@@matheothiebaut3030 I hope you realize that they just say stuff is “10x” or “5x” it’s not actually that value, they just say that so you’ll buy it
You stopped spending but you still playing that crap? Why
@@mrwannabe00 because it is fun and I have a good clan and I’m a beast at the game
I spent thousands of euro’s. And now I feel stupid. No more pass royale.
Thousands is crazy
1000s on Clash royale??? bro don't play any gatcha games in the future.
Once they gutted the pass, that was the end of my spending. They would have to pay me to get one of their deals at this point lol.
Just save ur money. It's only a matter of time until it's all made worthless with Another level increase.
@@mariomiceli9663I bought like 5 of their gold passes before it was nerfed heavily and now I don’t buy anything let alone even play the game
What can you even buy in clash royale for thousands of euros? I feel like 400-600 euros at most is enough to max everything in the game, what were you even buying?
Morten: This game is so crap forces you to spend money.
Morten: Make sure you use code morten when you do spend the money.
it was a comedic comment - and it was really funny ngl
@@xminty77man I feel like Morten was "hide your pain Harold" meme
Clash Royale is supposed to be a strategic game where its one policy is that "No card is supposed to be the best." I always wanted new cards to be added, but not Champions, Evolutions and Tower Troops along with changing the season pass. They treated it like Clash of Clans when it's a game of competition, not war.
Even coc is shit now, I left both the games last month
bro champions were good at least
Supercell is literally getting too desperate and I am starting to get pissed from it.
you have way more tolerance to frustation that average, because most of the people have already left the game.
I basically don't even play anymore. I only log in for free stuff.
@@genodedemon5109so true
@@genodedemon5109I wouldn’t even bother doing that much. Why continue to build a ship out, if it’s inevitably going to sink ?
@@kerolokerokeroloI think the majority left when they introduced level 15. You had grinded so hard to get level 14 just so they could pull the rug from under you.
One more thing I want to add is that the book of books (etc) are listed at $20 but have an outrageous 10x value...so a book of books is worth $200?? That's absolutely mental.
it's baffling how the game would be objectively 10x better if they just reverted the updates in past 1-2 years
No way... is it beginning of the end 😰
It’s the end of an end
the begining of the end was 2 years ago
We are in the end
Let's just hope this is the actual end, like just delete the game supercell, the Greediness is too obvious
Bro this game died long time ago before clan wars 2. Look at revenue... man's farming hayday pull in more than clash
The worst part is they are destroying their game to get money, when they could make a solid game and make money for 20+ years
They’re sacrificing short-term profits for long-term profit. If they just returned clash royale before tower troops and added skins (like B-rad said), people would naturally spend money
@@dannytran1587bro u swapped the profits, they sacrificed long term for short term
The model supercell is going towards is to just make new games when old ones are milked. If successful, they get high profits always.
There is a concept of 4 phases in "Product life cycle" in business. "Decline" phase has started for Clash Roayle
The decline would’ve been delayed if they were smart about it. Team Fortress, CSGO, and other games are in the same stage of decline but the games have been surviving for more than a decade, clash royale have not made it through a full decade yet
I've never thought morten would get tired of the game. What happened to the game man
It was easy to see this was coming for years
@@museishen2132yeah miner poison hasn't been fun
"Never say you've hit rock bottom. It can always be worse."
-Urinating Tree
Crazy how their game is dying and somehow super cell thinks “you know what would get out play base back? Upsell everything”
I have an idea…
CLAN WARS 3!!! 💀
@@addyupsytnot gonna lie if they do it right it MIGHT have a little good effect
@@addyupsyt how the old clan wars were? I can't remember it, I only remember about the clan chest
@@Gab12345BR there was card collection day and then war day. Didn’t rlly give good rewards tho and as the word “clash” was common between cr and coc their logic was to put war in the game too
This game wants me to type a slur in the chat and get banned, so I can find an excuse to not play this game anymore
if they keep thinking: " oh you don't like the game i don't care, lose 1 player like you isn't a big deal, there are millions more" then they gonna lose the rest
Creators are risking their creator codes for these so hope it ends up good
Who cares about codes if the game is gonna die then everyone VIEWS is dead
@@spicrown totally agree with you but creators need code for a little boost to their living
@@Jeff_boii I dont think they make that much money from it anyways… if clash royale revenue is small then creator code profit is small too
Clash royale needs to listen to the public and youtubers
Message for every pro players and youtubers : can you just make a tweet, make a video to just say STOP, like Riley, Ian, Mohamed, Viiper…. I was a French competitive player back in the days but I’m done with this shit, IM DONE and I’m never coming back
The top players cannot boycott because they make money off the game’s competitive ladder. B-rad’s different because he’s a content creator and not a professional player (we don’t watch for his skills)
@@dannytran1587i mean, Brad used to be, thank god he stepped back so he could be the one saying what everybody wants to say
i think they should make level 15 only obtainable behind a $2 paywall, i mean, NO GOLD, right?
Only some irl gold 😉
$2 for the first upgrade. it goes up after each purchase
@@elijahloby5400dont give them ideas 💀💀💀
I play less and less, I was a free to play competitive player but I can't do it anymore,one day I hope it will be possible again
same man
You know they messed up when even the pros and contact creators start getting frustrated 💀
I’m in league 9 and in the middle of the season they nerfed 3 of my cards and my tower troop. It’s insane if I can’t even play my deck for more than a month. Feels like I have to do this all the time. No fun at all. Now to be competitive I need to spend a ton of money to win. And I don’t even mind spending some cash. But this is no longer fun.
They should make pass royale 4.99 again then nobody can complain
they cant, money stops them from doing so
Oh yeah, because P2W is good if you only need to spend 5$ to even be able to play the game
It's not even worth 5 lol. They removed everything worth a crap. Basically paying 5 just for the Evo. They can keep it.
Clash of Clans still 5 dollars and still give you ton of magic items.
@@kingki1953is 7 dollars now but they value went up with the things they give u unlike crs
i remember when evolutions came out... i commented under one of your video's that this is where i quit (which i did). once the integrity of a game is ruined like that, it only goes downhill. now its a p2w scamfest that fanboys try to defend. its the fault of the customers giving these companies a pass. fk them dont buy it, they will change, vote with your wallet
I hate how mobile games are so infected with this p2w mentality. I'm so fed up that I just quit all of them. every game that I played eventually had the same fate
@@brunoc330 Solution: Play single player games
@@siema14123some single player can be p2w too
They didn't make nearly as much as they'd expected but yep, woulda did a quick 180 if everyone refused to spend.
@@brunoc330 the only gamea i like from supercell is heyday and coc
I just don’t understand, Clash Royale at its core is probably my favorite game of all time and nowadays I barely play it. Like I literally play Pokemon Go you’d think that no one could handle a game worse than Niantic and then you see CR just being 10x worse. It makes no sense when Brawl Stars is just killing it every update now. I’m going to actually disagree I don’t think champions were the downfall of CR I think it was when they stopped monthly balance changes. Pair that with the horrendous monetization and it’s just terrible. We waited for what 4 months for little prince to get nerfed and now it’s finally nerfed but they nerfed it to the ground to the point I found out only 15% of decks right now in GC even use a champion like are we kidding how do u let this happen. The worst part is I think the concepts for all the updates were really smart I like the idea of Champions, evolutions (other than zap, damage dealing spells never should have gotten evolutions, maybe defensive towers too) and tower troops (even if they were like 4 years too late) but they managed to implement them all so badly. Like champions were fine but lvl 14 was implemented with the whole slash Royale controversy, then saying u could only unlock champions when u hit king tower 14 which I was fine with but now you don’t even need to so what was the point of lvl 14 or 15. Then you release evos with only 4 evolutions like funneling the same decks when realistically 6-8 should’ve been released at the start minimum to make the meta ok. Then the fact they’re impossible to get, why would they make it u get one shard every 2 king levels at that rate it should be a full new evo. Then finally make it so there’s only one new tower troop making it impossible to balance when realistically they should’ve started with 3 new ones plus the princess. I don’t know where all the dev time is going bc these updates take forever and release nothing. Then the absolute worst part is the lack of transparency like they told us we’d get a roadmap, never happened. I don’t ever see the CR community managers on twitter, can’t say the same about CoC and BS who are always talking to the community. Finally if you still aren’t convinced just watch a brawl talk and you’ll notice the difference then realize there’s one every two months. Yup it’s night and day
But this month supercell ruined the game
1.Change logo
2.Evolution Goblin barrel that is completely useless
3.Goblin queen's journey
4.3 brand new cards realesed that are in the shop and later then getting an emergency nerf
5.Goblin queen's journey is litterally stupid like for every hundered trophies you kinda get stupid rewards
When a Canadian gets angry at something, we better listen.
I wish that they gonna listen this time and fix the game , I l really love this game and I don’t want to lose it to this greedy developers
Its not the devs its supercell and the people in charge of whats getting added. The devs just do what these people tell them to do
Same but these piles of 💩 worship money
@@ismokequ8500nah it’s devs
@@ismokequ8500exactly
@@ismokequ8500 No, it's the devs. Do you think brawlstars and coc are not from supercell? Look at those 2 games. They are both f2p friendly
11:53 He forgot to mention they nerf all the progression and the masteries.
I gonna miss free 300 gems
@@J4ygaming615 they still are in the game
people forgot about removal of gems from the masteries.
you get 300 gems from masteries bro
@@Gab12345BR 150*
Another change is when they removed 300 gems away from the 2nd masteries tier 3 from each card.
yeah that comment at around 20:00 is really what's making me lose interest in the game. Last season I grinned to royal champion and couldn't get any further. I wanted to play a different deck, but that's literally the only deck I have that has almost all level 15 cards. I just can't try anything else, because I will lose every time. Clash of clans keeps me coming back because when I get bored of an attack strategy, I can just try another army composition to freshen it up for me.
I know the feeling, I got stuck at royal champ in 3 different seasons but I finally hit ult champ for the first time this season, the day after I maxxed dagger duchess. Coincidence?
@@Karma0917lol yeah mine was 14 for a while, finally got it to 15 and the nerf hit
@@AJ_77602 nerf didn’t do anything, I was worried about maxing it when I heard the nerf but it’s still much better than the other towers. I hate tower troops so much but it’s the only way to push ladder
@@Karma0917I completely agree, i haven’t even played ladder much since the nerf (because of the goblin mode im being forced to play. so that’s somewhat good to know for me I guess, but I totally agree. Tower troops as a whole are just awful.
Lets give it 1 star at app store
Clash Royale in dark ages
The only thing i want is
1- make level caps at arenas, im arena 15 and im sick of getting lvl 13 cards
2- make restrictions on offers, like the firecracker evo offers, if you havent reached spooky town you should not be able to buy the offer, same should apply on the champion offers that appear on arena 11
3- of course remove lvl 15 and make evo shards easier to get for f2ps
4- bring back wild cards in the season shop
Don't hate me if I missed something
Clash royale devs belike:Oh we should add lvl 16 and get rid of the books and evo shards in the season shops als dont forgot 1 full old evolution for only 100$ also make it 20x value
@@J4ygaming615 imagine if they actually do what you said 💀💀
@@anonymoususer554i bet they're going to do it
@@J4ygaming615 fr nothing is impossible for $U₽£R€ELL
@@J4ygaming615 nothing is impossible for $U₽£R€£LL
Hey Morten will you be down for a protest of the monetization of Clash Royale with some other popular youtube streamers as well. I was thinking everyone should not buy any new shop offers or even the pass royale for the first week of the next month or something like that. The best way to hurt supercell is to hurt their pockets.
Dont do time limits, they wil just wait the week or month.
You can’t stop for a week you need to stop completely that’s the only way to send the message don’t do a half ass job of protesting gotta go full send
@@jakepeng9962 I would like that but I don't think it is very realistic since people do want the broken stuff and will eventually spending money on the game. I wish they don't but I can't really blame it if they do
@@Lkyseven I would like that but I don't think it is very realistic since people do want the broken stuff and will eventually spending money on the game. I wish they don't but I can't really blame it if they do
@@Lkysevenif creators don't spend and don't get the new thing, they are throwing away their wage. I think you should respect that more😅
It’s sad to see a game I would play daily with classmates in 2018 is dying from turning p2w, I literally only play this game from nostalgia from 2017-2018
My way to play was I would get stuck from not buying the meta and would use a max level potion and just speed run to the top. But I havnt seen those potions in stock for over a year so I'll be done for in the future.
The ultimate card of Clash Royale is your credit card...
I just can’t afford to keep up with this game anymore
I agree with B-rad on almost everything but this game has always been very p2w. I think there's a lot of nostalgia talking when you don't remember how unfair and broken legendaries were upon released, not having Princess when it was released and broken was as frustrating if not more than facing double evolution and DD.
I also think the new mechanics are cool, it's why I came back to the game. They just gotta tame down the p2w levelling system and be better with balancing, cosmetics should be the primary monetisation strategy anyway
if you were skilled, you could do classic challenges and 500 gems in tournaments and max in a couple of years at lvl 14. Now, the ceiling is about as high as Everest and impossible to be attained feasibly in a relevant amount of time.
Are you really comparing getting 1 legendary every like 6 months and that being broken, and another thing is getting evos, tower troops, lvl 15, in a 1 year period...?
@@carlosdasilva719 Also it was way less monetized
The monetization got much better after 2017 and it remained good till 2022 ish before becoming p2w again. Obviously you could always pay for progression but everything was obtainable in a reasonable amount of time even for f2p now f2p have to wait like 3-4 months or so to get one evolution. That's crazy to me.
Yeah, legendary in first original Clas Royale really didn't make the game worst. It's not P2W. The Players who didn't have Legendary can counter it by using any cards that have exist the game. But right now, counter Evo cards is hard for F2P Players.
Yeah I gave up pushing there's no point lvl 15 ruined competition
Like I put as a comment on B-rad's video:
"Building a community is the most important thing in all of this. Without your community you are absolutely nothing no matter how awesome your game is. This rule is true no matter the size or funding of your studio. If you lose the faith of your players then you lose everything.
You are never above your community and you are never too important to spend time responding to them. The moment you think you are they will show you how untrue that really is. Don't forget that.
" - Thor Hall, AKA PirateSoftware
I’ve played this game sense I was in 7th grade all the way up until a year ago or two I’m a junior in college, this used to be one of my favorite games ever, Idk who the slimy disgusting, stinking, goofy, cr*ck smoking developers r now but they have absolutely destroyed this once amazing competitive game u could play for hours or with ur friends, now it’s all about that money money money, and they r so stupid with how they do it that it doesn’t even work, like how stupid r the developers, idk what fake green they r smoking but they r tweaked tf out, I have never seen a game be so amazing to a joke and a parody of itself so fast it’s insane, and I’m truly just disappointed and sad, it’s just like how Disney destroyed Star Wars, some new ppl came in, absolutely on that Heisenberg blue crystal, just like everyone at Disney and absolutely destroyed this amazing game.
Return to previous Pass Royale, increase lucky drop percentages, if you want the new season Evo you can pay, but if you want it for free you can get it next season and same for the rest of Evos in future, delete the new game mode and put it as a special season challenge cuz it's better than play for 3 days and then it's dead. Completely delete lvl 15 and wild cards cuz it's crap. Add 2v2 game mode as a test and if is good then turn it into a competitive game mode. Fix the season store, balance the tower troops, create new competitive stuff, add some new cards at least one every 3 months or something and please erase at least 50% of store offers, is crazy how you need to spend almost 1000 dollars to buy everything. That's it, no more P2W, at least I'll be a P2F so supercell can still winning millions and not kill the game at all. And no, I'm not a noobie who has been playing for 2 months, I'm a lvl 67 player with Evos, tower troops, CRL and ladder badge, been playing for 6 years now and I couldn't be more disappointed about this game rn.
New dev recruit: i will work for 24/7 and make this game new feature to both fp2 and paid users... I will make evolution ez to get for f2p
CR HR: wakanda shit are you? Get the duck off of my studio
Another recruit : make the shitty offers 10x value and put 20 dollars for every item in store and I will work only 4 days per month
CR HR: you are hired!!!!!!
All the content creators of supercell games need to unite against the corrupt company and support clash with eric ,B-rad and many others standing against Supercell
our friend clash royale started taking drugs
Its wild watching people who profit off of the game complain about the game chargning things. All these content creators were stoked when creator codes came out, but now they have a problem with the game monetizing everything? You guys helped encourage it fr
I had uninstalled last year only when I got to know as a f2p player evolutions can't be unlocked and tower troops can't be used. I just came back this time for three new cards but would uninstall pretty soon.
Bro at this point, Supercell's HQ is about to be demolished by the goblin demolisher😂😂
i started a new f2p account 8 months ago. the account is now lvl 32 with tower lvl 11
to put it in perspective. reaching lvl 9 cards took me 2 weeks.
reaching lvl 11 cards took me 8 months. tournament ready took 8 months
reaching max level will take like 5 years💀
Very based that now even the German community draws attention towards the bad state of the game. For a long time I thought they just riding the CR devs and pretending everything was fine (looking at you, Bigspin). Thanks Morten
guys now that b-rad said something it opened the floodgates
Agreed with your thoughts, but was hella cool playing you this season you beat me you were playing giant graveyard and I had xbow inferno trying to roll some normal giant players
lvl 15 is the worst level
I think that adding a new route only with the Princess and King Towers, without that green queen, without upgraded cards, and without tower level 15, or it would be limited to a place that is difficult to reach, and also only with classic cards without Exploding Goblin, Goblin Machine, and even the spell. If he wants players, even without heroes, why not?!
I quit this game in early 2020 thinking that with time I might want to come back to it. Now looking at the current state of all of clash. I’m glad I got out while I could
Time to play Clash of Clans
Coming here from clash of clans. Looks like were jumping into your sinking ship very soon. I cant stand the monetization in Coc now. Its making me sick with all these equipments
I actually hate lucky drops. It’s removed rewards, and RNG based. Also they removed the free battle banner parts which just sucks.
Cr devs team is also shit at balancing cards. They would buff the card without any reason. For instance, the buff on prince and ram rider which dumb as hell to get player to buy an evolution that is underwhelming. That is just straight up stupid.
I thought i finally caught as a f2p when i got everything maxed out when they gave out like 1.6mil gold during the chess event, but since evolution and tower troops and lvl 15 for cards came out, im back where i am 2 years ago
It's terrible for the casual player too because I was just getting used to the meta. It was mid season and I was cruising ... now everything is different, and I don't have wild cards for upgrades.
I stopped playing again, and I'm already doing other things so I'm not going to stop doing them to go back and play Clash. I know me. I won't open the game for another two years (because of this update).
i think this goblin update might the end for me, i'm done
If you notice, they release a P2W OP card or evolution, then once everyone has purchased it, they nerf it and release a new over powered card that everyone rushes to buy, repeat, then repeat again
I thought it was dumb that if you had 15 princess tower, you were still getting princesses way more often from the tower troop chests than the cannoneer and dagger duchess.
It was dumb that you were getting princesses in the first place, since you don't need them to drop at all to upgrade. They drop only because if they didn't, it'll be too easy to unlock Dagger Duchess and Cannoneer.
And now they’re clogged with the goblin princess tower clone too 🤦
@@jakeextreme4108 back when it was just cannoneer, I did the help and support in clash royale just asking why I was getting so many princesses from the tower troop chests and they told me it was a 3:1 ratio. A 75% chance to get cards you already had maxed and a 25% chance to get the new tower troop. That’s so blatantly scummy.
@@JRokk Even if you don't have maxed Tower Princess, you can get her cards from the tower troop chest. As far as I'm aware, you can't upgrade her to specific level until you upgrade your King to that level, so the Princess as a drop is absolutely useless at any point in the game
Thanks supercell, you could've just decreased the amount of tower troop chests
Supercell will just watch this video and think: "I guess it's time we add level 16 to this game"
Clash Royale is taking path like war robot and pixel 3d
Game has become near impossible for me after playing it for years. The few level 15 cards I have are near useless as the meta shifted away from them long ago due to dagger douchess and most of my matches being against people with 2 evos is pain
Stopped playing this money grab of a game when they released level 13 troops. Best decision of my life 😂.
Getting epic and legendary wild cards in the season shop was huge, most people get gold common and rare wild cards in the drops, it’s so hard to upgrade or max a new legendary without money like 20 legendaries takes months or a legendary lucky drop where you’re hoping for a book of legendaries or book of books
10:40 exactly. I used to buy all the battle passes in clash Royale but when the game started getting worse and the nurff happened i haven't spent a single cent on the game. Im disappointed where CR has come.
Morten, I have seen your channel for quite some years, and you were the youtuber to go when i wanted to up my game. I find your content very valuable, but always found something was off because you tried so hard to mantain the channel family friendly. This is the first time one of your videos has some care free feeling, and I could not love this video more than I am doing it. You were trying so hard to maintain some dignity in the name of clash royale, but if you, a true follower and exponent of the game, is not able to defend it anymore, then no one could. Hope more videos with this relaxing and more "friendly" vibe are to come. Love your channel, and looking forward to see you upload squad busters videos :)
He forgot to even mention lv15
personally to im missing old maps. it was changed every diffrent month and it was pretty cool
With 100 bucks you can:
A) buy something necessary (like food or electricity)
B) buy Elden Ring+DLC
C) buy 4 evolutions on a now bad mobile game
I was gonna reinstall it a while ago, but the game seems so unrecognizable that i don't wanna play it. And i hate having to scroll through my shop cuz its just filled with offers top to bottom
Im not even gonna hold you
Clash royale and Brawl stars from a F2P perspective are entire UNIVERSES
you cannot compare them in the slightest, take the recent "thumbsupforbrawl" event for example
EVERYONE got 5 *FREE* LEGENDARY STARDROPS just because the community used some small funny thumbs up emote.
Wait for level 16 bruh the update we dont deserve but need keep that charcoal grill burning cuz level 17 is next after that
Economy with old pass was crazy. I was close to maxing out lvl 13. then lvl 14 came out. Like half a year later half of my cards were maxed again.
I remember the good old times when all you could do with money in cr was buy gems...
it all started when they added mega knight
I’ve wanted to push to Ultimate Champion for months but I don’t have a single fully max deck so I just don’t have the motivation to push and get to like league 3 or 4 and stop playing
Supercell wipe their tears with $100 bills
Now B-rad evolving himself for us
Actually i used to think that evolution could only be unlocked at level 15 and had something to do with mastery but it turned out it was completely different. Level 15 was just some shit that cr devs team thought to gain money and evolution has nothing to do with mastery.😓
They removed other items from other aspects of the game, like fewer coins from the chest, clan reward nerfs, and removal of some season shop offers and wild cards.
I've always felt like the game needs your money just for you to try the new update. Like the new update is literally just shop offers and that's it
I remember the e wizz challenge, playing with half the school, clash royale 2018 where good times, never imagined the game to get ruined like this 😢
Have anyone noticed who ever buy the battle pass they get advantage in refilling the stamina in game keep eye on the card stamina point and ull see they play High point stamina card together at once which is impossible to do it but only battle pass player ull see play it