Love how the definition of subcompact & compact have changed over the last 15-20 years. Some compacts are now called subcompacts & some mid-sized are now called compacts. I compared everything in this segment back in 2022 & determined for myself that the Mazda CX-30 was easily the #1 best small crossover in its size/price segment. I have had my 2022 CX-30 CE AWD for about one year now, and zero build quality issues or problems to report.
Yes, as European I watch this and I'm wondering, how cars that are 10 inches longer then VW Golf or Toyota Corolla can be called sub-compact. Here sub-compact SUV are usually 160-165 inch long and you can find even smaller crossovers like Toyota Aygo X which is just 145 inch long.
how the heck are you two soooooo good at this? you both talk to the camera like you are talking to me?!! as a guy who does camera work and commercials - i'm ALWAYS impressed seeing someone doing a much better job than I do. wow. love you both. and, you are helpful. always check you out when looking for cars for the familly !!! thanks. keep up the great work.
Thanks again for another great Top 5 Review!!! My partner and I got a CX-30 last year and it is WONDERFUL!! It is smaller but it is just the two of us so the back seat is rarely used. I think of it more like a BMW X2 type of sub compact crossover. It is definitely more sporty than the rest and with this turbo it is really fun to drive. I think the VW seems cool also, but the interior of the Mazda is so much more luxurious! What happened when VW had interiors like that???
CX30 All the way. Top notch quality, naturally aspirated and no CVT. Rear seat is fine for average sized people and cargo area has plenty of space. We love ours!
I'd agree but for two things. I noticed the older CX-30s are quiet but two 2024 models I recently test drove had rattles in the overhead somewhere. I couldn't believe what I was hearing. Also, I am 6'1" tall guy with a thicc booty and the lower part of the seat's bolsters stick me in the thighs bad, no matter how I try to tilt the seat.
I totally agree with you for your number 1 pick, I've owned 3, a 2015, 2019, and now a 2021 Outdoor, I changed my '19 for a '21 for the 2.5L, I absolutely love it, keep up the excellent work, I love your channel
Once again… accurate compilation. The Subaru doesn’t surprise me. It probably represents the best overall in terms of equipment and price. And it looks fun and adventurous, especially as they still offer a manual (albeit only on the smaller power plant). That’s what I’d choose. Thanks for putting these top five videos together. Great idea.
Own a CX30 and think it drives just great. I would pass on the Corolla Cross until the hybrid comes out, and then reassess how much it helped it. thanks for leaving the lackluster HRV off the list.
I was almost sure that the Crosstrek would rank up there. You should know that the '22 edition of this video was a big reason why I bought my '23 Crosstrek Sport!💚
I just bought a Seltos, though i strongly considered the Crosstrek. Mazda and toyota did not let us test drive due to lack of stock. Boiled down to warranty, dealer location and the fact that I always lose my car in parking lots. Not many Seltos yet but crosstreks everywhere here in Quebec. I have been very happy with my choice and thanks to motormouth for their videos. Helped alot with my research.
Try attaching a Montreal Canadiens flag to your driver's door window when you go shopping. You can buy them at any Canadian Tire, or Sporting Goods store. Salut!🇨🇦
Hi,Jean I have an interesting the Seltos X-Line , What model did you pick ? And how's the vehicle, After years, Any complain ? Because I haven't been drive Korean vehicle before ! Thanks !
@jackyleung9001 hello, I got the turbo top trim last year. I wanted the extra power and the extra comfy seats. Some littlecpetcpeeves include lack of dual climate zones, and lack of power lift gate. Otherwise, I am very happy with my purchase. Having the extra large navigation is not that big a deal since we use android auto for everything most times. My first crossover and cannot imagine going back to something smaller. Its great for 2 plus gear. If you have a bigger family with more stuff, you may want to pay attention to storage space.
Thanks for another great video!!! We got the 2023 Crosstrek Sport with the 2.5L a few months ago and absolutely are well pleased with the car !!! These videos are so helpful and very informative!! So much appreciated!!!
Tried them all except for Mazda and ended up with Honda HR-V 2023 with optional AWD. So far so good. Subaru is great too but I don't need a full AWD mostly driving on good roads.
I really loved the Taos when I checked one out. It fits me great even though I'm taller and wider. I got scared off though when I found out that some Taos's have a dying for no reason problem and VW still hasn't figured out what the issue is. Note: It's not all the Taos that die suddenly, but the ones that do, are in the shop having everything replaced, like whole fuel systems, new Control Modules etc and they still die while driving along for no reason.
great list! my only complaint would be that the Taos, even though its a fantastic SUV I would never choose it because of VW reliability problems... plus I already chose with my manual Transmission Crosstrek and couldn´t be happier!
I am a Mazda lover & didn’t think I’d ever drive anything else, but I’m surprised it even made the list. I 100% agree with every positive thing you said about the Mazda, but the technology/info system is same as my 2016 Mazda 6! CX in my price range lacks Bose speakers or even power lift gate which I could live without, but I’m not paying that much to go backwards in 2023! BTW - I’m 70 years old & think it’s outdated!😂
Ive tested all but the VW. Mazda and Subaru are the top 2 easily. Power, comfort, tech, and AWD standard. Subcompact really is for 1 or 2 people with small friends or kids. If you plan on lugging more than that get a standard SUV. Good video.
I had owned two Subaru Foresters in the past, so I thought I'd gravitate toward the Crosstrek. However, I ended up with a Mazda CX-30, and I just love to drive this car. The interior just looks so much nicer than what I had been used to. Size is a big factor so I'm glad for this subcompact category of vehicles (condo garage is tight). I would be very interested if Mazda comes out with a hybrid CX-30.
So funny I test drove both of those having driven Mazda 3’s for over 8 years! The CX-30 had LESS space than my 3 hatchback so I went with the Crosstrek. It didn’t take much convincing because I was specifically going for space upgrade adding a new member of the fam. However the interior of mazdas is super cushy and feels quality, and I’ll miss the wheel heating amenity. It’s a matter of preference for lifestyle, do you want something sportier/roadster feeling? Then the Mazda. But the Crosstrek for adventure and space. The all wheel drive for the Crosstrek definitely took the cake, my Mazdas didn’t handle the same. 😊
I took for a test drive VW Taos, Mazda CX-30 and Subaru Crosstrek. I like Mazda the most because of: 1) transmission, 2) noise isolation 3) rear seats comfort for my 10y daughter. Taos and Crosstrek have almost no cushion on rear seats
You two do such a great job. I've been looking at the Crosstrek for years. And the larger motor has really helped with my decision. I must say of all the subs mentioned I think the CX-30 is easily the nicest looking. Add in sporty and an automatic trans. That complicates things.... Thanks for the awesome content!
2021 Seltos owner (picked up in Nov 20)...SX with the turbo and DCT. 43k miles, no repair work at all. Even same tires! Great little car. Highway trips at 80mpg, frequent city driving (DC, Balt, Philly), hilly back country roads - easily handles all. NO CVT. Tried the Crosstrek back then, that busy interior, uncomfy seating (I'm 6ft 1 and 230lbs), and the dead dead dead steering turned me away. I know many don't like the DCT. I love it as it reminds me of my manual driving days a little. It eventually adapts to your driving style, but I get why some don't like it. Neighbor's Taos ('23...) has been sent back to the shop 3X in 8 months. NOPE. It's the same old VW problems. Just wanted to give a longer term report on the Seltos. (edit: the '24s no longer have the DCT...)
purchased my ‘23 crosstrek sport in october. absolutely in love with it! i don’t really mind the cvt and it does also come with a manual trans 8 speed if you wanna spice things up a bit. great gas mileage (i mainly drive highway but it’s great for main roads as well) and i never have any issues with cargo space!
Crosstrek 2.5 Outdoor and Mazda CX-30 2.5T are still the ones to beat for me. One has top notch full-size AWD, the other one is an "MX-5 in subcompact SUV clothing".
Well put! Unfortunately Australia has not and is not getting the bigger 2.5 lt engine. Therefore between the 2, the CX30 in 2.5 takes the cake if driving is paramount.
One of my friends got the Taos. I am impressed by how spacious it is, and the presentation is very modern. The sound system also sounds very good. On the downside the cargo capacity is good but not great, and I can't get over the fake exhaust design at the back. However it's overall a good option in my opinion.
I have one and I love it- I have the SEL - it luxurious feeling yet affordable. I hate “suvs” and it just feels like a durable sedan. I do have three kids and I will say that the space for myself is not big enough and will probably get a Tiguan or Subaru ascent w a third row options going forward. The only thing that I’m not loving is the electrics can get glitchy , and the front seat passenger is not electric 🙃 but a manual. Overall great gas mileage, if I had one less child I would feel the space was perfect lol (truck does for a double stroller) overall look is sporty and fun. I have the blue with thick black trim - and I wish that had this color and trim in a Tiguan
I just bought #4, the VW Taos. I splurged for the top SEL trim. I am pleased with my purchase and enjoy that it has more of an engaging drive, not a box on 4 wheels. Mazda does not have wireless CarPlay in the CX30 currently, that's a deal breaker. No CVT under any circumstance.
there are many good wireless adapters for 100$, it really shouldn't be a deal breaker... of course it can still impact your decision, but calling it a deal breaker is a reach
Just got a 2024 Highline Taos - the size is unbelievable! I’m just over six feet and I can easily sit behind myself. The sunroof is giant and the drive - I assume they have improved the turbo lag because it’s barely noticeable now. May not be the absolute best value but the drive is fun and it’s not the same as everything else on the road. As my daily commuter - love it.
I like the look of the Seltos, but last year the KIA dealer would only sell me one if I was willing to pay $3500 (USD) over MSRP. That was a deal breaker for me.
scalperships are really ruining the buying experience. Regardless of demand. But be surprised when its a buyers market they still try to scalp you. What goes around comes around, it won't be a sellers market forever.
Thank you for the effort put on your research, but may I ask if the reliability, maintenance cost, gas mileage are being considered in your research. There is no doubt about the quality of vehicles like Toyota, Honda, Lexus and Acura, but Kia? VW? Mazda?
Thanks for this video! My top 2 are Subaru Crosstrek and Toyota Corolla Cross. I can't decide which one 😩. Looking for safe, reliable car with decent gas mileage. I'm looking to keep it for the long haul. Under $25,000.
i have a 2023 crosstrek sport! absolutely love it. was torn between the corolla cross as well, but they never had any in stock for me to even test drive! so i settled and am very happy with my purchase ☺️
Also test drove the Corolla cross AWD and found it lacked power and was a bit noisy. Also no height adjustment on the passenger seat which sits very low. We will test drive the hybrid when it becomes available.
Good review, looking to buy a 2024 subcompact for our son, the Crosstrek Sport is currently what’s at the top of our list along with maybe the Mazda CX-30. In the 2024 model year, Subaru has phased out the manual transmission on all Crosstreks.
FANTASTIC video from you two and great selections of top 5 plus some honorable mentions. This is the segment I drive in - have a CX-3, have test driven a Taos, CX-30 and Seltos. Didn’t love any of them TBH but might wait to compare the Corolla Cross Hybrid against the CX-50 hybrid next year. If they make a CX-30 hybrid, DONE DEAL!!!
Thank you for the great video Good informative and I’m sure it helps lots people who looking for their next car I’m waiting for 2025 seltos When are we going to have in Canada?
Ordered my 2023 Crosstrek Outdoor on Mon thanks in part to your reviews. It just drives so well, safe, quiet but not the fastest. It looks a bit dated, not as nice as some competitirs but it just works on many levels like AWD for winter.
You two are so smoothly professional. Glad you made it to Quebec. How’s your French?! Will try to buy a new car this summer. Like the new hybrid Honda CR-V, Mazda CX-5, Lexus NX 350 hybrid and Hyundai Santa Fe and Tucson for test drives. I keep maintaining my 175,000 mile Acura TL 2003, that has served me very well. Oh yeah, I’ll try the RDX and TLX as well!
This is the other suby in our driveway…’18 limited. It is my daily driver…188km highway drive five days a week. I drive no faster than 100kmh…gas is too expensive to drive any faster. Always get 7.0l/100km or less. In warm weather mileage is better. 6.9 on this last tank and we have full on winter here. Great car but I wish they would put in 8 way power seats with lumbar support in the top trim instead of the 6 way seats.
Since you two can't really tell, yet, how new(2023) models will actually hold up/be reliable years after purchase, it would be interesting to do a segment on past models. Let's say for example, the 5 best(engine life, durability, maintenance...) sub compact suvs from 2017. I'd be curious which have held up, which have under performed and which seem most reliable after 5 years. Customer feedback, documented issues, recalls... Taking a look back at how a certain vehicle brand or model has done in prior years before buying a new one can be quite helpful when deciding to purchase. Maybe you guys have already done this and I just haven't seen it. If so, I apologize. Just thought it would be valuable insight for viewers/car buyers to see and learn from. Thanks for the segment.
It would be hard for car reviewers to do that. They get to evaluate brand new cars as they are released to put out information to the public. It's not like they buy the cars they review and keep a fleet of them for long term testing and review.
@@bwillan In no way did I entertain the thought that they bought and kept each and every car they've reviewed. Just seems you'd have more than just initial opinions. Rather, compiled data and track records from owner experiences and hands on use by them. It would definitely be a different format to look back and reveal how vehicles have done 5 or so years down the road as compared to what they normally do. They wouldn't need to even test drive models. More so, take a look back at which models have held up and which haven't. What they do is valuable and informative for new car buyers. But unforeseen problems do arise occasionally and it would be interesting to hear their candid breakdown of which models "broke down" for the used car market and it's buyers too. Especially when it comes to a new model release or a new generation of a existing vehicle that has sold well. Not a complaint about what they currently do. Maybe just wishful thinking.
Hey Zack and Andrea, Love your content. I have been following you content since I landed here in Toronto. Which car would you suggest for a newcomer with 2 kids, preschooler and infant.
I test drove the xx-30 was looking for a slight space upgrade but the cx-30 had 3 square feet LESS space than my Mazda 3 hatchback. I was disappointed tbh
I think the Buick Encore GX is a great little sub compact. Did you folks drive one of these? They are very well appointed and the price point is not bad either.
I just bought the Mazda CX-30 and have previously owned two VW Golfs. I test drove the VW Taos and Subaru Crosstrek before landing on the Mazda CX-30. I couldn’t get over all the cheap plastic interior of the Taos and the jerky ride. The Crosstrek was great in every way but I wasn’t as impressed with the interior look and feel. The seats were snug but not as comfy as I’d expect it to be and the car overall felt very utilitarian, like a workhorse, and less of a fun car to ride. I went with the CX-30 for the more luxury and high end interior design along with the minimalist dash-I don’t like a huge screen and too many gadgets in my vehicle. It’s a beautifully designed car inside and outside. It also had the highest horsepower at 186 compared to the others. The ride was smooth; cabin noise was silent; and handling was top notch well above all the others in its class! My only complaints about the CX-30 are 1) Too many blind spots and 2) the gas tank is too small-I’m always filling up gas, which is a complaint I read about from other reviewers before I made the purchase. It’s still worth it!
Good reviews of the subcompact class...Subaru Crosstrek is a great #1 choice, but the the 2.5l should be the base engine and a 2.0L turbo should be the optional choice.
As today would go with Subaru 2.5l, was waiting for Corola but Toyata doesn't care about noise.... my wife has RAV-4 its so freaking loud but its so hard to kill that sh...., just goes and goes already for 17 years without any any small hiccup , craaaazy. Nice list as always, thank you!
@@mariselaramirez1091 I live in asia here hyundai and kia are very reliable the news ones are used as taxis and go up to 500,000, 700,000 and 900,000 kilometers without major issues they are very reliable and durable roads are shit here weather sucks and still these are manage to come out on top if thats not great idk what is. The korean made Kia and Hyundai are special just like JDM korean craftsmanship exists and lastly hondas are popular but have problems in third world countries in traffic the dual clutch tranmissions overheat and expensive new ones need to be installed, but none the less toyota, honda, hyundai and kia and 4 of the most reliable brands. Kia and hyundai transmissions are well built there are not any clutch replacement cases like with honda eg. Honda vezel and grace cars need proper maintanance or they overheat and wear out due to stop and go traffic.
I really liked the test drive of the 2023 Subaru Limited Trim recently, I currently drive a 14 Civic LX. Price is pretty good for what you get for sure. Am considering it but hoping to test drive a 2023 Kia Seltos and see how that one goes.
I'm from Malaysia.. now I know why the corolla cross in my country still doesn't have EPB and only uses the foot brake. Maybe the difference from the Warranty. In Malaysia, Toyota provides a 5-year warranty with unlimited mileage. And also for the hybrid spec, an 8-year warranty is given for the battery.
I absolutely love my 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Premium, (Special Edition in Desert Khaki.) I have had it since February, and have enjoyed it more every single time I drive it. Money well spent! 😊
I cant find test drive Mazda CX 30. Please, let us know if any road noise , hwy driving. I tried Corolla Cross and did not like at all! So noisy..Thanks
your mpg ratings are in US gallons. Our 2021 Forester gets as good mpg as the crosscheck. We have done over 800 km on a few tanks now, using 53-55 liters. This was highway driving with some through mountains here in BC
I checked out a new 2024 Hyundai Kona with that same screen as the Kia Seltos, for the gauges and infotainment. In low morning or afternoon sun, you can't see those screens for beans... Seriously, they didn't put some kind of hood around them to help keep the sun out and even with them on full bright they suck on bright days. Live long analogue gauges...
Very accurate description on the "road noise" issue with the Toyota Corolla Cross. After road test comparison with the Seltos, I went for the Kia model. So smooth and quiet drive. Loaded with safety and tech features which other brands only give for their top models. Huge cargo space also ticked the box for me. Longer warranty is the icing. The HR-V? Honda's design group could have done a better job
As a recent "retiree" we want to downsize a bit, thus the subcompact interest. Like everyone else 95% of our driving is local, but one thing not really covered in your review, is which model is most comfortable over a longer drive? My RAV4 is not very comfortable past a couple of hours, but my (dont laugh) Journey before it was extremely comfortable and the rare 7-8 hour drives were quite bearable. So, any recommendations?
Debating between toyota cross and Subaru Crosstek. Waiting for 2023s to show up. Toyota wants to add a $1500 fee to keep the dealership open. Don't like that.
I bought a 2021 Subaru CrossTrek Outdoor; very happy with it except for the cost of regular maintenance (every 6000 miles or 6 months irrespective of mileage); for my first 2 years I've being doing less than 6000 miles every 6 months. I traded in a 2016 Toyota AWD Rav4. Earlier this year my wife wanted a new car and we were leaning towards a 2023 AWD Toyota Cross (we were trading in a 2015 Corolla sedan), Mazda CX-30, or Nissan Qashqai. We ended up with the Nissan AWD Qashqai; she didn't like the ride of the Corolla Cross (and it would have taken over 12 months to get one!) or the Mazda CX-30 (she found the ride harsh).
Please talk about the safety ratings for the cars you are reviewing. Safety is one of my key decision drivers. Thanks!
Love how the definition of subcompact & compact have changed over the last 15-20 years. Some compacts are now called subcompacts & some mid-sized are now called compacts. I compared everything in this segment back in 2022 & determined for myself that the Mazda CX-30 was easily the #1 best small crossover in its size/price segment. I have had my 2022 CX-30 CE AWD for about one year now, and zero build quality issues or problems to report.
Yes, as European I watch this and I'm wondering, how cars that are 10 inches longer then VW Golf or Toyota Corolla can be called sub-compact. Here sub-compact SUV are usually 160-165 inch long and you can find even smaller crossovers like Toyota Aygo X which is just 145 inch long.
how the heck are you two soooooo good at this? you both talk to the camera like you are talking to me?!! as a guy who does camera work and commercials - i'm ALWAYS impressed seeing someone doing a much better job than I do. wow. love you both. and, you are helpful. always check you out when looking for cars for the familly !!! thanks. keep up the great work.
Wow, thanks for the kind words!
They sound do the 5’oclock news each night. Let’s throw it over to Bob for a look at this week’s commute forecast.
Thanks again for another great Top 5 Review!!! My partner and I got a CX-30 last year and it is WONDERFUL!! It is smaller but it is just the two of us so the back seat is rarely used. I think of it more like a BMW X2 type of sub compact crossover. It is definitely more sporty than the rest and with this turbo it is really fun to drive. I think the VW seems cool also, but the interior of the Mazda is so much more luxurious! What happened when VW had interiors like that???
CX30 All the way. Top notch quality, naturally aspirated and no CVT. Rear seat is fine for average sized people and cargo area has plenty of space. We love ours!
Love how it looks and drives but the mpg makes me unsure
MPG sucks!! Mazda needs to get in the hybrid game already
Mazda is the shit end of Japanese cars.
I'd agree but for two things. I noticed the older CX-30s are quiet but two 2024 models I recently test drove had rattles in the overhead somewhere. I couldn't believe what I was hearing. Also, I am 6'1" tall guy with a thicc booty and the lower part of the seat's bolsters stick me in the thighs bad, no matter how I try to tilt the seat.
I totally agree with you for your number 1 pick, I've owned 3, a 2015, 2019, and now a 2021 Outdoor, I changed my '19 for a '21 for the 2.5L, I absolutely love it, keep up the excellent work, I love your channel
Thank you, glad you are enjoying the content!
Once again… accurate compilation. The Subaru doesn’t surprise me. It probably represents the best overall in terms of equipment and price. And it looks fun and adventurous, especially as they still offer a manual (albeit only on the smaller power plant). That’s what I’d choose. Thanks for putting these top five videos together. Great idea.
I waited 2 and a half months for my Crosstrek, but it was worth it!
We’re considering buying the Crosstrek Sport in 2024.
Have had a Seltos SX for a year and a half, no problems, great car. Another good review guys.
Own a CX30 and think it drives just great. I would pass on the Corolla Cross until the hybrid comes out, and then reassess how much it helped it. thanks for leaving the lackluster HRV off the list.
I was almost sure that the Crosstrek would rank up there. You should know that the '22 edition of this video was a big reason why I bought my '23 Crosstrek Sport!💚
I just bought a Seltos, though i strongly considered the Crosstrek. Mazda and toyota did not let us test drive due to lack of stock. Boiled down to warranty, dealer location and the fact that I always lose my car in parking lots. Not many Seltos yet but crosstreks everywhere here in Quebec. I have been very happy with my choice and thanks to motormouth for their videos. Helped alot with my research.
Try attaching a Montreal Canadiens flag to your driver's door window when you go shopping. You can buy them at any Canadian Tire, or Sporting Goods store. Salut!🇨🇦
Wow, no test drive allowed??? Talk about a way to run customers away.
@@daklight2792 they did not care. They already had months of customers waiting for them. Gotta love that pandemic supply disruption.
Hi,Jean I have an interesting the Seltos X-Line , What model did you pick ? And how's the vehicle, After years, Any complain ? Because I haven't been drive Korean vehicle before ! Thanks !
@jackyleung9001 hello, I got the turbo top trim last year. I wanted the extra power and the extra comfy seats. Some littlecpetcpeeves include lack of dual climate zones, and lack of power lift gate. Otherwise, I am very happy with my purchase. Having the extra large navigation is not that big a deal since we use android auto for everything most times. My first crossover and cannot imagine going back to something smaller. Its great for 2 plus gear. If you have a bigger family with more stuff, you may want to pay attention to storage space.
Got 2022 Taos - highline. I LOVE mine so much (in Cornflower Blue too!)
Thanks for another great video!!! We got the 2023 Crosstrek Sport with the 2.5L a few months ago and absolutely are well pleased with the car !!! These videos are so helpful and very informative!! So much appreciated!!!
I brought Taos Comfortline in this amazing blue a few months ago and your reviews of it and the rest in the class were super helpful and enjoyable.
Just went from a 2017 HRV to a 2023 Seltos EX. Love all the updated features like the 10.25 screen and safety features. Thanks for the review.
Thank you for your comment. I am seriously considering the 2024 Seltos. Currently driving a Honda Ridgeline, which I love, but it is a pig on gas.
Tried them all except for Mazda and ended up with Honda HR-V 2023 with optional AWD. So far so good. Subaru is great too but I don't need a full AWD mostly driving on good roads.
I'm considering the 2024 HR-V. What's the road noise like on the highway? One reviewer said it's terrible and thought it was due to the tires.
I bought the Taos 2023! the family loves the back seat.
I really loved the Taos when I checked one out. It fits me great even though I'm taller and wider. I got scared off though when I found out that some Taos's have a dying for no reason problem and VW still hasn't figured out what the issue is.
Note: It's not all the Taos that die suddenly, but the ones that do, are in the shop having everything replaced, like whole fuel systems, new Control Modules etc and they still die while driving along for no reason.
great list! my only complaint would be that the Taos, even though its a fantastic SUV I would never choose it because of VW reliability problems... plus I already chose with my manual Transmission Crosstrek and couldn´t be happier!
What about warranty???
Consumer reports shredded the Taos and I was actually thinking of one but I bet once its off warranty it could be a nightmare
@@MrVictoria69consumer reports is total bs, bunch of clowns. Taos is ranked no.1 in this class by both Edmunds and Forbes.
I am a Mazda lover & didn’t think I’d ever drive anything else, but I’m surprised it even made the list. I 100% agree with every positive thing you said about the Mazda, but the technology/info system is same as my 2016 Mazda 6! CX in my price range lacks Bose speakers or even power lift gate which I could live without, but I’m not paying that much to go backwards in 2023! BTW - I’m 70 years old & think it’s outdated!😂
I also am a Mazda lover and the outdated info system is a dealbreaker for me.
@@grinsley - For me, the Mazda infotainment system is second only to BMW's.
idk why you surprised, cx-30 is one of the best in class according to all the reviews. small gas tank is the only thing why i hesitate to get it
I have a 2023 CX-5 love the vehicle,but hate the infotainment system.
Ive tested all but the VW. Mazda and Subaru are the top 2 easily. Power, comfort, tech, and AWD standard. Subcompact really is for 1 or 2 people with small friends or kids. If you plan on lugging more than that get a standard SUV. Good video.
Then try out Taos and see for yourself.
You guys are an awesome team, thanks gif some common sense that’s useful and considerate
Greetings from Cape Town South Africa 🇿🇦
Good stuff. I'd like to hear your thoughts on longevity - an important consideration for many. Would the Subaru outlast the Toyota, for example?
I had owned two Subaru Foresters in the past, so I thought I'd gravitate toward the Crosstrek. However, I ended up with a Mazda CX-30, and I just love to drive this car. The interior just looks so much nicer than what I had been used to. Size is a big factor so I'm glad for this subcompact category of vehicles (condo garage is tight). I would be very interested if Mazda comes out with a hybrid CX-30.
The Forester wilderness trim got some nice interior and exterior tho.
So funny I test drove both of those having driven Mazda 3’s for over 8 years! The CX-30 had LESS space than my 3 hatchback so I went with the Crosstrek. It didn’t take much convincing because I was specifically going for space upgrade adding a new member of the fam. However the interior of mazdas is super cushy and feels quality, and I’ll miss the wheel heating amenity. It’s a matter of preference for lifestyle, do you want something sportier/roadster feeling? Then the Mazda. But the Crosstrek for adventure and space. The all wheel drive for the Crosstrek definitely took the cake, my Mazdas didn’t handle the same. 😊
And coming from the forester I can totally see why you’d pick the cx-30, interior wise they are super comparable
I took for a test drive VW Taos, Mazda CX-30 and Subaru Crosstrek. I like Mazda the most because of: 1) transmission, 2) noise isolation 3) rear seats comfort for my 10y daughter.
Taos and Crosstrek have almost no cushion on rear seats
Imagine your daughter hit puberty and have to suffer in the back seat 💺🪑💺🪑
You two do such a great job. I've been looking at the Crosstrek for years. And the larger motor has really helped with my decision. I must say of all the subs mentioned I think the CX-30 is easily the nicest looking. Add in sporty and an automatic trans. That complicates things.... Thanks for the awesome content!
another great video, thanks folks for your work!
Thanks for watching, glad you liked it!
2021 Seltos owner (picked up in Nov 20)...SX with the turbo and DCT. 43k miles, no repair work at all. Even same tires! Great little car. Highway trips at 80mpg, frequent city driving (DC, Balt, Philly), hilly back country roads - easily handles all. NO CVT. Tried the Crosstrek back then, that busy interior, uncomfy seating (I'm 6ft 1 and 230lbs), and the dead dead dead steering turned me away. I know many don't like the DCT. I love it as it reminds me of my manual driving days a little. It eventually adapts to your driving style, but I get why some don't like it. Neighbor's Taos ('23...) has been sent back to the shop 3X in 8 months. NOPE. It's the same old VW problems. Just wanted to give a longer term report on the Seltos. (edit: the '24s no longer have the DCT...)
purchased my ‘23 crosstrek sport in october. absolutely in love with it! i don’t really mind the cvt and it does also come with a manual trans 8 speed if you wanna spice things up a bit. great gas mileage (i mainly drive highway but it’s great for main roads as well) and i never have any issues with cargo space!
I love your reviews, this is no different. What car are you sitting in doing this video?
Crosstrek 2.5 Outdoor and Mazda CX-30 2.5T are still the ones to beat for me. One has top notch full-size AWD, the other one is an "MX-5 in subcompact SUV clothing".
Well put! Unfortunately Australia has not and is not getting the bigger 2.5 lt engine. Therefore between the 2, the CX30 in 2.5 takes the cake if driving is paramount.
One of my friends got the Taos. I am impressed by how spacious it is, and the presentation is very modern. The sound system also sounds very good. On the downside the cargo capacity is good but not great, and I can't get over the fake exhaust design at the back. However it's overall a good option in my opinion.
I have one and I love it- I have the SEL - it luxurious feeling yet affordable. I hate “suvs” and it just feels like a durable sedan. I do have three kids and I will say that the space for myself is not big enough and will probably get a Tiguan or Subaru ascent w a third row options going forward. The only thing that I’m not loving is the electrics can get glitchy , and the front seat passenger is not electric 🙃 but a manual. Overall great gas mileage, if I had one less child I would feel the space was perfect lol (truck does for a double stroller) overall look is sporty and fun. I have the blue with thick black trim - and I wish that had this color and trim in a Tiguan
I just bought #4, the VW Taos. I splurged for the top SEL trim. I am pleased with my purchase and enjoy that it has more of an engaging drive, not a box on 4 wheels. Mazda does not have wireless CarPlay in the CX30 currently, that's a deal breaker. No CVT under any circumstance.
there are many good wireless adapters for 100$, it really shouldn't be a deal breaker... of course it can still impact your decision, but calling it a deal breaker is a reach
Just got a 2024 Highline Taos - the size is unbelievable! I’m just over six feet and I can easily sit behind myself. The sunroof is giant and the drive - I assume they have improved the turbo lag because it’s barely noticeable now. May not be the absolute best value but the drive is fun and it’s not the same as everything else on the road. As my daily commuter - love it.
I like the look of the Seltos, but last year the KIA dealer would only sell me one if I was willing to pay $3500 (USD) over MSRP. That was a deal breaker for me.
scalperships are really ruining the buying experience. Regardless of demand. But be surprised when its a buyers market they still try to scalp you. What goes around comes around, it won't be a sellers market forever.
Crash tests and safety ratings should be included as well.
Nice video, really like your videos. Could you also do a top 5 for medium SUVs with 7-8 passenger seating and then also a luxury SUV comparison
You guys do a great job. Thank you!
Thank you very much!
I'm torn between the Seltos SX or the Crosstrek Sport. Part of me also wants to step up to a Sportage EX Hybrid though.
Stay 10 foot pole away from Korean cars. Japanese all the way.
I would have to go with the Mazda CX 30, N/A… THANKS FOR THE EXCELLENT DETAILED UPDATES.
Thanks for watching!
I’m taking the crosstreck good job as always with the reviews, you guys are awesome thank you.😊
Thank you for the effort put on your research, but may I ask if the reliability, maintenance cost, gas mileage are being considered in your research. There is no doubt about the quality of vehicles like Toyota, Honda, Lexus and Acura, but Kia? VW? Mazda?
Thanks for this video!
My top 2 are Subaru Crosstrek and Toyota Corolla Cross. I can't decide which one 😩. Looking for safe, reliable car with decent gas mileage. I'm looking to keep it for the long haul. Under $25,000.
i have a 2023 crosstrek sport! absolutely love it. was torn between the corolla cross as well, but they never had any in stock for me to even test drive! so i settled and am very happy with my purchase ☺️
We were looking at Honda HRV in the US and the dealers were marking them up a lot.
Also test drove the Corolla cross AWD and found it lacked power and was a bit noisy. Also no height adjustment on the passenger seat which sits very low. We will test drive the hybrid when it becomes available.
I wouldn’t overlook the Trailblazer. Looks good, spacious and good value. Definitely less bland than most of the others.
Good review, looking to buy a 2024 subcompact for our son, the Crosstrek Sport is currently what’s at the top of our list along with maybe the Mazda CX-30. In the 2024 model year, Subaru has phased out the manual transmission on all Crosstreks.
FANTASTIC video from you two and great selections of top 5 plus some honorable mentions. This is the segment I drive in - have a CX-3, have test driven a Taos, CX-30 and Seltos. Didn’t love any of them TBH but might wait to compare the Corolla Cross Hybrid against the CX-50 hybrid next year. If they make a CX-30 hybrid, DONE DEAL!!!
CX-30? What did you not like about it?
@@ms.b9093 well he wants a hybrid, so probably gas mileage.
Excellent job. I'd really consider the Toyota Corolla Cross hybrid for its reliability and resale value.
I think I’m the only person who would love a Taos with a 6 speed MT. But then again my daily is a Mk 7 Golf GTI. 😂
Thank you for the great video Good informative and I’m sure it helps lots people who looking for their next car I’m waiting for 2025 seltos
When are we going to have in Canada?
Ordered the Crosstrek, should be here next fall. It will be a 24 which is a re-design. Great video!
Will there be an updated version of this for 2024? I'm in the market for a new car (Canada) and I really enjoy your reviews :)
Ordered my 2023 Crosstrek Outdoor on Mon thanks in part to your reviews. It just drives so well, safe, quiet but not the fastest. It looks a bit dated, not as nice as some competitirs but it just works on many levels like AWD for winter.
Awesome, congratulations!
Subaru designs are usually more conservative, but they are more practical and timeless instead of looking dated in a few years!
You two are so smoothly professional. Glad you made it to Quebec. How’s your French?! Will try to buy a new car this summer. Like the new hybrid Honda CR-V, Mazda CX-5, Lexus NX 350 hybrid and Hyundai Santa Fe and Tucson for test drives. I keep maintaining my 175,000 mile Acura TL 2003, that has served me very well. Oh yeah, I’ll try the RDX and TLX as well!
Mazda makes you feel almost luxury class in top trims.
Metal an soft leather, sporty handling, sleek design.
but very small windows, poor vision, blind spot, rear view, can barely see sky, scenery.
This is the other suby in our driveway…’18 limited. It is my daily driver…188km highway drive five days a week. I drive no faster than 100kmh…gas is too expensive to drive any faster. Always get 7.0l/100km or less. In warm weather mileage is better. 6.9 on this last tank and we have full on winter here. Great car but I wish they would put in 8 way power seats with lumbar support in the top trim instead of the 6 way seats.
Since you two can't really tell, yet, how new(2023) models will actually hold up/be reliable years after purchase, it would be interesting to do a segment on past models. Let's say for example, the 5 best(engine life, durability, maintenance...) sub compact suvs from 2017. I'd be curious which have held up, which have under performed and which seem most reliable after 5 years. Customer feedback, documented issues, recalls... Taking a look back at how a certain vehicle brand or model has done in prior years before buying a new one can be quite helpful when deciding to purchase. Maybe you guys have already done this and I just haven't seen it. If so, I apologize. Just thought it would be valuable insight for viewers/car buyers to see and learn from. Thanks for the segment.
It would be hard for car reviewers to do that. They get to evaluate brand new cars as they are released to put out information to the public. It's not like they buy the cars they review and keep a fleet of them for long term testing and review.
@@bwillan In no way did I entertain the thought that they bought and kept each and every car they've reviewed. Just seems you'd have more than just initial opinions. Rather, compiled data and track records from owner experiences and hands on use by them. It would definitely be a different format to look back and reveal how vehicles have done 5 or so years down the road as compared to what they normally do. They wouldn't need to even test drive models. More so, take a look back at which models have held up and which haven't. What they do is valuable and informative for new car buyers. But unforeseen problems do arise occasionally and it would be interesting to hear their candid breakdown of which models "broke down" for the used car market and it's buyers too. Especially when it comes to a new model release or a new generation of a existing vehicle that has sold well. Not a complaint about what they currently do. Maybe just wishful thinking.
I love the 2 tone front of the toyota corolla cross. I like the clean look and the materials.
Hey Zack and Andrea,
Love your content. I have been following you content since I landed here in Toronto.
Which car would you suggest for a newcomer with 2 kids, preschooler and infant.
Turbo CX-30 or the very spacious Taos for me, if I was shopping for a subcompact CUV.
I test drove the xx-30 was looking for a slight space upgrade but the cx-30 had 3 square feet LESS space than my Mazda 3 hatchback. I was disappointed tbh
We're a Mazda Family, although we dont have a CX-30. But any of these recs that have a CVT are out in my book.
Great and insightful video! So glad I stumbled upon it. Y'all have convinced me on the CX-30! :D
I love your review videos. Can you tell me what kind of vehicle you both are sitting in?
I hope that you do a comparison of the Acura RDX, the Lexus NX, the Buick Envision and so on.
Just wondering which car are they sitting in while they speak? I love the interior!!
I think the Buick Encore GX is a great little sub compact. Did you folks drive one of these? They are very well appointed and the price point is not bad either.
Between this and yesterdays video do u guys have a change of clothes in the back? Great job folks. Ur on fire.
Both cx30 n crosstrek outdoor are my choices
I just bought the Mazda CX-30 and have previously owned two VW Golfs. I test drove the VW Taos and Subaru Crosstrek before landing on the Mazda CX-30. I couldn’t get over all the cheap plastic interior of the Taos and the jerky ride. The Crosstrek was great in every way but I wasn’t as impressed with the interior look and feel. The seats were snug but not as comfy as I’d expect it to be and the car overall felt very utilitarian, like a workhorse, and less of a fun car to ride. I went with the CX-30 for the more luxury and high end interior design along with the minimalist dash-I don’t like a huge screen and too many gadgets in my vehicle. It’s a beautifully designed car inside and outside. It also had the highest horsepower at 186 compared to the others. The ride was smooth; cabin noise was silent; and handling was top notch well above all the others in its class! My only complaints about the CX-30 are 1) Too many blind spots and 2) the gas tank is too small-I’m always filling up gas, which is a complaint I read about from other reviewers before I made the purchase. It’s still worth it!
I feel the same way about the Crosstrek. Leaning towards the Mazda. Do you still like yours?
I absolutely LOVE my CX-30. Sooooo fun to drive!
I live in MN I need great ground clearance and no CVT Any advice
We got the 23 crosstrek hybrid runs like a dream!
Good reviews of the subcompact class...Subaru Crosstrek is a great #1 choice, but the the 2.5l should be the base engine and a 2.0L turbo should be the optional choice.
As today would go with Subaru 2.5l, was waiting for Corola but Toyata doesn't care about noise.... my wife has RAV-4 its so freaking loud but its so hard to kill that sh...., just goes and goes already for 17 years without any any small hiccup , craaaazy. Nice list as always, thank you!
Great video! The beautiful blue colour that you showed in the Kia Seltos, where is that available?
Had kias for years I would definitely go for seltos. ❤
So you never had a problem? Like with transmission. My Honda is giving problems 💔
@@mariselaramirez1091 I live in asia here hyundai and kia are very reliable the news ones are used as taxis and go up to 500,000, 700,000 and 900,000 kilometers without major issues they are very reliable and durable roads are shit here weather sucks and still these are manage to come out on top if thats not great idk what is. The korean made Kia and Hyundai are special just like JDM korean craftsmanship exists and lastly hondas are popular but have problems in third world countries in traffic the dual clutch tranmissions overheat and expensive new ones need to be installed, but none the less toyota, honda, hyundai and kia and 4 of the most reliable brands. Kia and hyundai transmissions are well built there are not any clutch replacement cases like with honda eg. Honda vezel and grace cars need proper maintanance or they overheat and wear out due to stop and go traffic.
@@Omega-df5nv thank you so much . Didn’t know all this thank you 🙏
great review thanks. Big fan of the manual trans., Crosstrek.
I really liked the test drive of the 2023 Subaru Limited Trim recently, I currently drive a 14 Civic LX. Price is pretty good for what you get for sure. Am considering it but hoping to test drive a 2023 Kia Seltos and see how that one goes.
What car are you guys sitting in while doing the video?
I'm from Malaysia.. now I know why the corolla cross in my country still doesn't have EPB and only uses the foot brake. Maybe the difference from the Warranty. In Malaysia, Toyota provides a 5-year warranty with unlimited mileage. And also for the hybrid spec, an 8-year warranty is given for the battery.
I absolutely love my 2023 Subaru Crosstrek Premium, (Special Edition in Desert Khaki.) I have had it since February, and have enjoyed it more every single time I drive it. Money well spent! 😊
I bought a 2023 Mazda CX-30 two weeks ago. I love it so far.
I cant find test drive Mazda CX 30. Please, let us know if any road noise , hwy driving. I tried Corolla Cross and did not like at all! So noisy..Thanks
Hello to you both,
Great reviews on each model.
Thanks, glad you enjoyed it!
@@andreaspencer9813 I did thanks .
Very instructive thank you for your work
Hoping for a Kia Seltos hybrid review
I would love to get the Kiro or Kona because of choice different power train. Great video! ☕️☕️
Thank you, the Niro and the Kona are great choices.
@@andreaspencer9813 You are an very welcome Andrea! Yes I agree!
Great content
Thanks To you both
Your the best !
Thanks a lot, we are glad you enjoyed it!
corolla cross L AWD, cause its gonna be my first ever brand new car!
fyi...the Mazda CX-30 2.5 non-turbo went up to 191hp for 2023 (at least in the US)
i have seltos sx trim 2022and on the hyway the gas using 5,2 liter per 100 km and am very happy plus on the snow is perfect car
your mpg ratings are in US gallons. Our 2021 Forester gets as good mpg as the crosscheck. We have done over 800 km on a few tanks now, using 53-55 liters. This was highway driving with some through mountains here in BC
I checked out a new 2024 Hyundai Kona with that same screen as the Kia Seltos, for the gauges and infotainment. In low morning or afternoon sun, you can't see those screens for beans... Seriously, they didn't put some kind of hood around them to help keep the sun out and even with them on full bright they suck on bright days. Live long analogue gauges...
Very accurate description on the "road noise" issue with the Toyota Corolla Cross. After road test comparison with the Seltos, I went for the Kia model. So smooth and quiet drive. Loaded with safety and tech features which other brands only give for their top models. Huge cargo space also ticked the box for me. Longer warranty is the icing. The HR-V? Honda's design group could have done a better job
Especially since it had the magic seat and fuel tank under the front seats which were hard to beat in terms of packaging for cargo efficiency.
Chevy Trailblazer? I like the front passenger seat fold flat feature.
All cars should be able to have a fold flat front seat. But that's not enough to make it to top 5
@@davidjym The seat feature make it usable for a 6+ footer to be able to sleep in it at music fests and camp sites and keep dry in all weather.
@@KenSwiatek sounds like fun 😊
I have Nissan Rogue 2022 I normally get 46 miles per gallon Or 4.8 per 100 l But in the mountains I got 53.9 miles per gallon so 4.2 l per 100
How’s the acceleration merging into hways?
@@sunitjoshi3573 like driving a f18 not a problem a amazing rocket
Hello I booked the Eclipse Cross GT, but I am little confused. Can you give your expertise for Mitsubishi aswell.
As a recent "retiree" we want to downsize a bit, thus the subcompact interest. Like everyone else 95% of our driving is local, but one thing not really covered in your review, is which model is most comfortable over a longer drive? My RAV4 is not very comfortable past a couple of hours, but my (dont laugh) Journey before it was extremely comfortable and the rare 7-8 hour drives were quite bearable. So, any recommendations?
Thanks for the video. Really helpful. I wonder why the 2023 Nissan Qashqai didn't made in any list.
I wish we had the 2.5 L crosstrek in Australia I would buy it immediately.
Subaru for sure! But for long term ownership, the Corolla Cross.
Debating between toyota cross and Subaru Crosstek. Waiting for 2023s to show up. Toyota wants to add a $1500 fee to keep the dealership open. Don't like that.
I bought a 2021 Subaru CrossTrek Outdoor; very happy with it except for the cost of regular maintenance (every 6000 miles or 6 months irrespective of mileage); for my first 2 years I've being doing less than 6000 miles every 6 months. I traded in a 2016 Toyota AWD Rav4. Earlier this year my wife wanted a new car and we were leaning towards a 2023 AWD Toyota Cross (we were trading in a 2015 Corolla sedan), Mazda CX-30, or Nissan Qashqai. We ended up with the Nissan AWD Qashqai; she didn't like the ride of the Corolla Cross (and it would have taken over 12 months to get one!) or the Mazda CX-30 (she found the ride harsh).