Hyesung looked like he straight out came out of a manhwa. I just can't... Great at singing and performing, handsome, great body proportions, polite and kind. Just kill me already TT TT
I mean seriously, how is it possible to sing perfect like this? It's really flawless, but I'm quite sure it is live. They should be famous not just because of being the oldest idol group but because of their perfect live singing .
korean people generally have an assumption that idol groups can't sing. they don't even bother listening to the song, but when they do, they get surprised by their vocal skills (they have zero understanding how much idol groups practice to be out in public)
it's so sad CD version already. But LIVE versions make it more painful. One of the main reasons why I love Shinhwa's vocals so much. They might not have the best vocals, but I love their unique tones, their ways of conveying emotions, challenging unique sounds, and how they sings from their heart each time. They don't sound generic to me, they sounds different every time, just like the human emotions.
you are so right - i think that's why new fans keep coming - you always get the 'feels' when they sing (esp) live -they are not perfect (adorable dorks) but they are always sincere that's why changjos love them dearly...shinhwa fighting!!!
The album released on Jan 2nd, & Shinhwa first performed it on mcountdown on 12th. This is their 3rd comeback stage & 3rd HEAVEN perf after MCD & KBS stages ..
amazing...each performance keeps getting better. LOVE THE SONG!!! Awesome vocals and raps, very moving and touching. shinhwa my love!!! 6 handsome men, age like fine wine 😍😙💋❤
I really love this song..that very moment they released it the first time..i fell inlove with it..the music, the sound...it just touched my heart💖 its so warm..and now watching them sing it live....it just sound so much better😍😍😍 I Love you SHINHWA!! I LOVE YOU ERIC OPPA😍😍😍
i was thinking maybe its because it was their first stage so the cameraman might have made a mistake thinking it was hye sung's part as he held up the mic to sing
I'm feeling you all with the camera work thing, when someone is singing, most especially if its my wannie, focus the goddam cam on him, geez!😩 still, shinhwa sarangheyo! 😜
MBC tends to not give enough air time for two full songs, so generally, the non-title track gets shorten. Usually they cut out the bridge and in this case, it's dongwan's part :)
![SHINHWA (신화) - HEAVEN [Music Bank COMEBACK / 2017.01.13]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0NlxI8vCE_g/mqdefault.jpg)
![SHINHWA (신화) - HEAVEN [Music Bank COMEBACK / 2017.01.13]](/img/tr.png)
![[SHINHWA - Heaven] Comeback Stage | M COUNTDOWN 170112 EP.506](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cTFit042hg4/mqdefault.jpg)
![ตีสิบเดย์ [FULL] | เปิดใจ "อาจารย์ เบียร์ ฅนตื่นธรรม" นักสนทนาธรรมสายดุดัน!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vqaBI_mnoDk/mqdefault.jpg)
100% live, Shinhwa is the real legend
Hyesung looked like he straight out came out of a manhwa. I just can't...
Great at singing and performing, handsome, great body proportions, polite and kind. Just kill me already TT TT
I mean seriously, how is it possible to sing perfect like this? It's really flawless, but I'm quite sure it is live. They should be famous not just because of being the oldest idol group but because of their perfect live singing .
Right? They don't get enough credit for their artistry and skills.
korean people generally have an assumption that idol groups can't sing. they don't even bother listening to the song, but when they do, they get surprised by their vocal skills (they have zero understanding how much idol groups practice to be out in public)
king of singing live
THEIR VOCALS ... GOOSEBUMPS
언제오나 ㅠㅠ
Hyesung always gives me the feels with his voice here especially but dongwan God damn this song fits them so perfectly it gives me so much feels 😍
it's so sad CD version already. But LIVE versions make it more painful. One of the main reasons why I love Shinhwa's vocals so much. They might not have the best vocals, but I love their unique tones, their ways of conveying emotions, challenging unique sounds, and how they sings from their heart each time. They don't sound generic to me, they sounds different every time, just like the human emotions.
you are so right - i think that's why new fans keep coming - you always get the 'feels' when they sing (esp) live -they are not perfect (adorable dorks) but they are always sincere that's why changjos love them dearly...shinhwa fighting!!!
MOON JUNGHYUK LEE MINWOO KIM DONGWAN SHINHYESUNG PARKJUNGJAE LISUNHO SHIN HWA CHAN JO!
This song is growing on me thanks to Shinhwa's awesome live performances of it ..
when did this song released?
The album released on Jan 2nd, & Shinhwa first performed it on mcountdown on 12th. This is their 3rd comeback stage & 3rd HEAVEN perf after MCD & KBS stages ..
their live voice is always perfect!
Shinhwa's vocals and image are perfect but the MBC person controlling the cameras could've done a better job.
loll this comment 🙌👏 your right
amazing...each performance keeps getting better. LOVE THE SONG!!! Awesome vocals and raps, very moving and touching. shinhwa my love!!! 6 handsome men, age like fine wine 😍😙💋❤
their vocals & raps are HEAVEN!! love you so much SHINHWA SAN!!
This is a 100% live, amazing shinhwa!!!
와 이게 라이브라니 믿을수가 없다 진짜 ㄷㄷ
no one can beat their vocalist in term of harmony
동완오빠랑 민우오빠 서브보컬인데도 가창력 클라스보소 크
Heaven! No one can beat them. Shinhwa forever.
The stage is getting better and better !!!
Eriiiiiiccccc... Shinhwaaa 😍😍
I really love this song..that very moment they released it the first time..i fell inlove with it..the music, the sound...it just touched my heart💖 its so warm..and now watching them sing it live....it just sound so much better😍😍😍 I Love you SHINHWA!! I LOVE YOU ERIC OPPA😍😍😍
singing live = singing CD, only Shinhwa can do it. love you all....gorgeous voices
The one person who disliked this doesn't know what it's truly like to be in heaven.
Shinhwa the legends of Kpop 👍👍👍👍👍👍
너무멋있음..
fail cameraworks when it comes to Dongwan! 😔
they forget our oppayam 😢😢😢 hihihi
i was thinking maybe its because it was their first stage so the cameraman might have made a mistake thinking it was hye sung's part as he held up the mic to sing
ShinHwa is the best~
And the camera sucks =.=' Always filmed the wrong person when someone started singing =.='
SO THIS IS WHAT HEAVEN LOOKS AND SOUNDS LIKE
I'm feeling you all with the camera work thing, when someone is singing, most especially if its my wannie, focus the goddam cam on him, geez!😩 still, shinhwa sarangheyo! 😜
ELF here for support Shinhwa!!
Maurice Lester Szyslak Thank you ELF ^^
Very very very nice! Really touched
I am sorry but the camera work is kind of suck... my Oppayam 😭
Kim dong wan kills me with his wonderful voice 💔
Why didn't they film him 🙂
good job oppas
i miss them 😭
신혜성 💜💜😘😘
First of all, how dare they not film my oppayam 😣. second of all, what did you do to your hair oppayam😐?
shinhwa changjo!
Shinhwa! 😍😍😍
ik srsly this song is soooo good
i love you shinhwa
ellos son profecionales señores! :3
minwoo!!~
Eric
whoever thumbs down this video is doing that because of the bad cameraworks!!
should have been the title track instead...
❤❤❤❤❤❤
💚❤💜💚❤💜
💖😍😍💖
😭
😃😙😙😃😙😃😙
it HURTS! so bad~
literally laughing because of how awful the camera work is😂
did dongwan's part after jinnie was cut? TTTT
MBC tends to not give enough air time for two full songs, so generally, the non-title track gets shorten. Usually they cut out the bridge and in this case, it's dongwan's part :)
awhh thats sad the cam didnt work properly at dongwan's part and now dongwan's part was cut;; i like mubank better
That's my favorite part. 😕
is it only Hyesung wearing earphone?
metta chen Minwoo is wearing one. The left ear.
ah yeah. i didn't notice earlier. why didn't the others wear?
metta chen I'm not sure why.