Just a reminder it's okay to like both. The thumbnail wasn't meant to stir up hate just to compare the first 10 of one vs the first 10 of the other because it's interesting to see how far Mihoyo has come. Like comparing elements of Elden Ring to the Souls games one has the benefit of coming later but it doesn't change the fact that both are incredible :D
In the beginning of Silver Wolf's trailer, she's actually playing a character called Haxxor Bunny in Honkai Impact 3rd, which is basically who Silver Wolf is. So she's playing herself in another Hoyo game. There's an entire lore built around the different versions of characters that appear in Hoyoverse games, and all but two characters that you saw here are originally from Honkai Impact.
@@makotoyuki3869 I can see that argument with Feixiao but not with Acheron, but if that’s the case then the Sparkles Trailer exists ( my current 3 place one ) it’s still higher quality and it has a lot better music.
About the character trailers, IMO In terms of music: GI > HSR In terms of animation/dynamics: HSR > GI But as always, there are some exceptions and honestly, in general both have pretty good trailers
While honkai star rail is turn based. Not all the honkai games are. Honkai gakuen 2 is a side scrolled beat-em-up While honkai impact 3rd is a 3d action game. You can actually see a bit of honkai impact 3rd gameplay in the beginning of silverwolf's trailer.
March 7th is the name that was given to her as that was the day she was found encased in ice, Serval and Gepard are siblings which explains why he was singing her song at the end of his trailer Bailu is your basic healer, Yanqing is considered one of the worst characters in the game, Himeko and Luocha’s Japanese VAs voice characters in two other Hoyoverse games, Honkai Impact 3rd and Genshin with Himeko’s VA voicing a character with the same name and Lisa and Luocha’s VA voicing Otto Apocalypse and Kamisato Ayato in those games, Jing Yuan’s English VA does Cyno in Genshin, he’s also a vtuber named Cy Yu, Silver Wolf wasn’t playing Star Rail, she was playing Honkai Impact 3rd and using the version of her in that game, Haxxor Bunny. Can’t wait to see your reactions to the other characters
Neat. I've never actually seen the older trailers. They're definitely not as good as the later ones, which are far more cinematic and stylized and well put-together, but these old ares are still pretty cool.
Oh boi you shouldn't make a thumbnail like that.. the bad bloods on both community are shaking right now.. even tho both games are from mihoyo both community are always at war.
I guess I didn't realize the level of animosity there was between the communities. My thought was just comparing between demos and trailers but I've definitely learned from this.
Yes, on one side you have the Genshin fanboys, and on the other side you have the Genshin haters who moved to Star Rail when it came out and now just hate Genshin for whatever reason, plus the other side that has a superiority complex, since the launch of Star Rail this fight has been going on when both games are better in some aspects than each other, it's a very silly but inevitable fight as you may have seen in some comments, it is better to ignore them and try not to call them out.
Watching the trailers from the context of also playing the game, it's about even. While the production quality in general has gone up over time for Hoyo, Star Rail was in part created explicitly to have a sandbox to develop and play with where creating content and messing with the engine would be safer and simpler. It takes significantly less work to produce a functioning character for this game (the design process also seems more streamlined) and as a result more effort can go into their trailer and cutscenes. (This doesn't mean I think Star Rail is a lesser game either in creativity or end results, just that it's distinctly easier to create stunning visuals for it. Some of the tweaks used to fit those into the game setting are also creative and add little easter eggs such as using certain characters allowing you to get camera angles on bosses and see parts of their bodies not intentionally visible. Plenty of work and care went into this, but it's still easier to get more flash for the same buck.)
I love these trailers, they always make me smile both becouse of the quality and just all the small references. For example, Silver Wolf is playing Honkai Impact 3rd in her trailer as Haxxor Bunny, the character she's based on. Also keep in mind that u'll see almost always a character's ultimate in a trailer, for example Himeko's orbital cannon IS what she uses ingame as well.
Thumbnail is fine, both games are fine. Except when they're not. Thing is, a content creator has gotta eat and part of that is adding a level of draw to their product. Getting clicks isn't easy, almost like fishing. It helps to use... I know the word is something. I think it starts with a B. It's obvious for anyone watching your videos that you are very much enjoying both and we're glad you are.
Since we have started Genshin and HSR demos, I recommend the Zenless Zone Zero character trailers/demos as well :) There are less of them too since ZZZ is the newest shiny project from Hoyo lol
This. I'm also someone who loves all kinds of games and I know I'll love both of these when I play them. But I guess for the sake of peace it's better not to draw any comparisons at all.
@@GrimGrooves2 I think it's okay to make targeted comparisons, but "which game is better" is a really touchy subject between Genshin and HSR. Definitely the animation quality and music in the early Genshin demos are not as high as the later Genshin demos or the HSR trailers.
@@kihada1611 As the description explains this was never a "which game is better" situation. Only comparing the first 10 demos vs trailers. But still I do apologize for unintentionally stoking fires between the communities, as I guess I just assumed we were all just fans of Mihoyo's work but it seems I was just being naive and will be sure to avoid doing so in the future.
My friend, please don’t feed the war pitting genshin and hsr against each other. It encourages the toxicity. The games r separate and even under the same company. Tired of the comparison of both of them
Hsr demos miles better than genshins in my opinion. Some of them just audio and video joy. These in first part are pretty weak, but quality of them will go up rapidly, and when you thinking - this is best trailer in the world, in next one they outdoing themselves again and again. Magic.
Both are great, but i completely agree with what Grim said; hsr just starts way further ahead because it came out later and they learned from genshin. At some point they just get like tied in terms of quality i would say.
Both are great since Fontaine and Natalan ones are so good. HSR (It count for ZZZ too) came out after 2 years of Genshin so they got good start compared to Genshin. Heck Even Hi3rd Early Versions Trailers are not that great. Now Both Honkai 3rd and Genshin trailers are so high quality And Quality will go up from here.
Just a reminder it's okay to like both. The thumbnail wasn't meant to stir up hate just to compare the first 10 of one vs the first 10 of the other because it's interesting to see how far Mihoyo has come. Like comparing elements of Elden Ring to the Souls games one has the benefit of coming later but it doesn't change the fact that both are incredible :D
The singing in Serval's trailer was actually done by her VA!
In the beginning of Silver Wolf's trailer, she's actually playing a character called Haxxor Bunny in Honkai Impact 3rd, which is basically who Silver Wolf is. So she's playing herself in another Hoyo game. There's an entire lore built around the different versions of characters that appear in Hoyoverse games, and all but two characters that you saw here are originally from Honkai Impact.
The only Honkai Star Rail character that is actually the same character from Honkai Impact is Welt. I wonder why he doesn't have an HSR trailer.
@@FayolaOnline..and Void Archives. 🎉
HSR came in later, so the first demos are better than genshin's firsy demos, but id say rn in terms of quality they are pretty tied
Not with Feixiao and Acheron, don’t get me Wrong the newest GI one is Amazing but it’s no where near the Big 2 of HSR currently.
@@The_CodFish69 They’re fantastic visually, but the music that plays in them are subpar.
@@makotoyuki3869 I can see that argument with Feixiao but not with Acheron, but if that’s the case then the Sparkles Trailer exists ( my current 3 place one ) it’s still higher quality and it has a lot better music.
About the character trailers, IMO
In terms of music:
GI > HSR
In terms of animation/dynamics:
HSR > GI
But as always, there are some exceptions and honestly, in general both have pretty good trailers
While honkai star rail is turn based. Not all the honkai games are.
Honkai gakuen 2 is a side scrolled beat-em-up While honkai impact 3rd is a 3d action game. You can actually see a bit of honkai impact 3rd gameplay in the beginning of silverwolf's trailer.
From Blade onwards the quality of the trailers just keep getting better and better! Can't wait to see you react to the rest :)
March 7th is the name that was given to her as that was the day she was found encased in ice, Serval and Gepard are siblings which explains why he was singing her song at the end of his trailer Bailu is your basic healer, Yanqing is considered one of the worst characters in the game, Himeko and Luocha’s Japanese VAs voice characters in two other Hoyoverse games, Honkai Impact 3rd and Genshin with Himeko’s VA voicing a character with the same name and Lisa and Luocha’s VA voicing Otto Apocalypse and Kamisato Ayato in those games, Jing Yuan’s English VA does Cyno in Genshin, he’s also a vtuber named Cy Yu, Silver Wolf wasn’t playing Star Rail, she was playing Honkai Impact 3rd and using the version of her in that game, Haxxor Bunny. Can’t wait to see your reactions to the other characters
I love both games, Genshin was the first for me so it has a special place in my heart, but Honkai is there as well
If these are good, the next batch will blow your mind 😅
after all the character trailers, you needs to watch the myriad ones !!
Heh, nice stopping point. I'd say, the next trailers(right after) are on another level comparatively. For me at least
Neat. I've never actually seen the older trailers. They're definitely not as good as the later ones, which are far more cinematic and stylized and well put-together, but these old ares are still pretty cool.
Can you react honkai star rail concert?
Give Part 2 from this video👍
Oh boi you shouldn't make a thumbnail like that.. the bad bloods on both community are shaking right now.. even tho both games are from mihoyo both community are always at war.
I guess I didn't realize the level of animosity there was between the communities. My thought was just comparing between demos and trailers but I've definitely learned from this.
Yes, on one side you have the Genshin fanboys, and on the other side you have the Genshin haters who moved to Star Rail when it came out and now just hate Genshin for whatever reason, plus the other side that has a superiority complex, since the launch of Star Rail this fight has been going on when both games are better in some aspects than each other, it's a very silly but inevitable fight as you may have seen in some comments, it is better to ignore them and try not to call them out.
@@GrimGrooves2yeah sadly thats the situation in both communities.. i suggest dont mentioning the other game if you want to react to each game.
These trailers are amazing but since ya like music a lot you should check out the Concert they released earlier this year.
Still waiting for all Arknights pv/trailers reaction
Watching the trailers from the context of also playing the game, it's about even. While the production quality in general has gone up over time for Hoyo, Star Rail was in part created explicitly to have a sandbox to develop and play with where creating content and messing with the engine would be safer and simpler. It takes significantly less work to produce a functioning character for this game (the design process also seems more streamlined) and as a result more effort can go into their trailer and cutscenes. (This doesn't mean I think Star Rail is a lesser game either in creativity or end results, just that it's distinctly easier to create stunning visuals for it. Some of the tweaks used to fit those into the game setting are also creative and add little easter eggs such as using certain characters allowing you to get camera angles on bosses and see parts of their bodies not intentionally visible. Plenty of work and care went into this, but it's still easier to get more flash for the same buck.)
I love these trailers, they always make me smile both becouse of the quality and just all the small references.
For example, Silver Wolf is playing Honkai Impact 3rd in her trailer as Haxxor Bunny, the character she's based on.
Also keep in mind that u'll see almost always a character's ultimate in a trailer, for example Himeko's orbital cannon IS what she uses ingame as well.
Thumbnail is fine, both games are fine.
Except when they're not.
Thing is, a content creator has gotta eat and part of that is adding a level of draw to their product. Getting clicks isn't easy, almost like fishing. It helps to use... I know the word is something. I think it starts with a B.
It's obvious for anyone watching your videos that you are very much enjoying both and we're glad you are.
Since we have started Genshin and HSR demos, I recommend the Zenless Zone Zero character trailers/demos as well :) There are less of them too since ZZZ is the newest shiny project from Hoyo lol
characters trailers are really good but you have to react someday to trailer versions, pretty good imo
Please don’t pit games against each other. It encourages toxicity in the game communities.
Forget Nation of War, this is the real nation of war lmao
And yes the thumbnail is a bait
Honestly I don’t understand the fuss 😂
I play genshin, HSR and WuWa also moba games.
Why argue over, you can just play whatever you want.
This. I'm also someone who loves all kinds of games and I know I'll love both of these when I play them. But I guess for the sake of peace it's better not to draw any comparisons at all.
@@GrimGrooves2 I think it's okay to make targeted comparisons, but "which game is better" is a really touchy subject between Genshin and HSR. Definitely the animation quality and music in the early Genshin demos are not as high as the later Genshin demos or the HSR trailers.
@@kihada1611 As the description explains this was never a "which game is better" situation. Only comparing the first 10 demos vs trailers. But still I do apologize for unintentionally stoking fires between the communities, as I guess I just assumed we were all just fans of Mihoyo's work but it seems I was just being naive and will be sure to avoid doing so in the future.
way better
you think these are insane? wait till you watch more. It gets better and better
Hsr demos are all boring lmao
"True, fck HSR. Boring ahh gameplay with their boring ahh story"
Not as boring as your world view
@@Jev_the_fluorescent_shrimpwho hurt you lil bro
@@Jev_the_fluorescent_shrimp cappin
No. Not better. Another Game...
My friend, please don’t feed the war pitting genshin and hsr against each other. It encourages the toxicity. The games r separate and even under the same company. Tired of the comparison of both of them
I expected more of this channel, but you made a clickable, attention grabbing thumbnail for the sake of views.
Hsr demos miles better than genshins in my opinion. Some of them just audio and video joy. These in first part are pretty weak, but quality of them will go up rapidly, and when you thinking - this is best trailer in the world, in next one they outdoing themselves again and again. Magic.
Extreme cope, hsr demos are nowhere near genshin
Both are great, but i completely agree with what Grim said; hsr just starts way further ahead because it came out later and they learned from genshin. At some point they just get like tied in terms of quality i would say.
Both are great since Fontaine and Natalan ones are so good.
HSR (It count for ZZZ too) came out after 2 years of Genshin so they got good start compared to Genshin. Heck Even Hi3rd Early Versions Trailers are not that great. Now Both Honkai 3rd and Genshin trailers are so high quality And Quality will go up from here.
@@Jev_the_fluorescent_shrimpYou forgot to take off your blindfold
@@Jev_the_fluorescent_shrimp least obvious rage bait
Visually? Yes. Musically? Absolutely not.
Oh!
Nah, hsr is NOWHERE near genshin. It's just flashy images and mid mainstream music, while genshin demos are unforgettable masterpieces
"Glazing at its finest"
As player of both games.
If you compare first genshin demo “kaeya” and first hsr char vid “march7”😂.
Def hsr win
@@jerryeljeremy7790 yeah hsr glazers are going crazy
@@edijuna3760 no it doesn't sorry
March sucks ass
@@Jev_the_fluorescent_shrimp yeah we can do this all day