Don't make Geoff stay in one lane! He's in ALLLLLLLL the lanes...and that's where he belongs! This is a great reaction to a great cover of a great song by a great group. F*ck the lanes LOL
Being a bass singer with a similar range to Geoff, I am still in awe with his ability to use them all the way he does. I sung along and couldn't do it the way he does. Geoff is amazing at what he does. Yeah, I know, it's a multitrack recording, but have heard him do the same live! A lot of bass singers can cover the range Geoff does, just not in the same way!
Are you familiar with “Fiddler On The Roof,” the classic musical the original version of this song, “If I Were A Rich Man,” is from? It’s excellent, funny and tragic. And I like that they nod to Gwen Stefani’s semi-cover of it.
12:01 He basically went from a chest-fry note to a chest note. And then they added some massive reverb to make the bass sound much grander. The note where Layne and Geoff was on cam is indeed a subharmonic as well!! I love this arrangement so much. 16:34 Those notes by Cesar ads so much as well.
At 12:01 Geoff went down to a chest-fry, but the distorted sounds afterwards are all done by lane….he is using a technique called throat bass which he has already used in multiple of their covers, like the Moana medley or „we don’t talk about Bruno“….
@@primlan8214 the deep sounds at 12:03 and 12:04 before he pauses are definitely Layne doing throat bass….maybe we are talking about different things here
9:16 To answer your question: Yes, there is a subharmonic note there. An F1 to be specific (the same low note he throws in here and there throughout the whole song. They just made it super subtle. But it‘s definitely there.
I think what you’re hearing at the part you were confused on, where it sounds like Geoff is almost chewing the bass notes, is a mix of three things: Geoff’s lead notes that drop into bass range, the actual bass line by Geoff and three bass drum kicks from Layne. They all hit at the same point and it sounds just a little muddled so it’s hard to pick out, but that’s what I hear.
I loved this one....all of the runs were awesome...Ashley's run up to the mountain peak and back down was incredible....That high note Geoff hit was near my head voice, and I am a tenor....I am in awe everytime I hear him.
Ashley Diane??? Where have you BEEN? You don't knock or ring the doorbell, you explode my door into bits and I don't care, I just smile and say it's so nice to meet you 😁❤️. Curious to see what she does from here 👍.
I knew you would enjoy this one so much ! Couldn’t wait to see your reaction to Geoff and Ashley 😁 Didn’t hear the scales thing that Layne did until you pointed it out, how CAN YOU hear everything at once ? You genius 🎵👏
I loved the look on your face when Geoff went high, you paused it, then played again and Geoff went low! I laugh everytime I watch this! Good job overall!!
You want runs that hit every note going up and back down, VoicePlay is the place to go. I love the more ethereal voice echoes in the background and enhanced vocals. Thanks for your reaction.
This is so much more upbeat than the original, and the orig is very close to my heart, but this makes me wonder what the movie would be like w/ such a change throughout... lol poor Topol
LOL. All the lanes ARE Geoff'sI 🤣 So much here as usual. Layne needs to sing more! Ashley's run - holy shit. And Geoff dropping octaves like it's nothing, after flying way up in the sky first, with almost no break between! He really went up there! Cesar all over the place, same for Eli. This one just did so much! Major props to the arrangement. Just. Wow.
Such a marvelous rendition of this song. Love Geoff and Voice Play and Ashley is great. There are no lanes for Geoff. Don't think there was a sub you missed.
Love your reactions! VoicePlay’s latest mini isn’t just sound effects. Please start with Mr. Sandman, their latest. Just old fashioned barbershop type fun!
OK, I somehow missed this entire song and all the reactions months ago, but brilliant reaction, Qofy, even tho I’m saying it way late! Love that you caught those overtones.
Thank you for reacting to this, you are my favorite reactor 🙏 I actually put a comment on that video showing all the low notes in case you’re interested,
You look like you were having so much fun. It’s great when a song brings joy! Just so you know, I have watched this video many times so I watched you instead of them. 💖 loved it!
She literally DeeJay Young'ed that high note. Tell me she didn't sound like him when she hit it. 😂😂😂
Geoff and Ashley's runs were insane, Eli killed the high notes as usual, and Ceaser showed us his usual swag here
Geoff not only got in your lane, he full on cut you off and did a donut around you! 🤣 Great reaction as usual!
When Geoff finished his High-To-Low thing, QoFy looked so done😂😂😂😂😂🤣
His face!!! Priceless!!!
The look on your face was Priceless.
Don't make Geoff stay in one lane! He's in ALLLLLLLL the lanes...and that's where he belongs! This is a great reaction to a great cover of a great song by a great group. F*ck the lanes LOL
Being a bass singer with a similar range to Geoff, I am still in awe with his ability to use them all the way he does. I sung along and couldn't do it the way he does. Geoff is amazing at what he does. Yeah, I know, it's a multitrack recording, but have heard him do the same live! A lot of bass singers can cover the range Geoff does, just not in the same way!
Saying Geoff should stay "in his lane" is even funnier when Layne's the one who's made him leave it. 😉
Are you familiar with “Fiddler On The Roof,” the classic musical the original version of this song, “If I Were A Rich Man,” is from? It’s excellent, funny and tragic. And I like that they nod to Gwen Stefani’s semi-cover of it.
Costuming and Directory: Tony Wakim (and Layne Stein)
12:01 He basically went from a chest-fry note to a chest note. And then they added some massive reverb to make the bass sound much grander. The note where Layne and Geoff was on cam is indeed a subharmonic as well!! I love this arrangement so much.
16:34 Those notes by Cesar ads so much as well.
At 12:01 Geoff went down to a chest-fry, but the distorted sounds afterwards are all done by lane….he is using a technique called throat bass which he has already used in multiple of their covers, like the Moana medley or „we don’t talk about Bruno“….
@@allmygames2776 Not true 👍
@@primlan8214 the deep sounds at 12:03 and 12:04 before he pauses are definitely Layne doing throat bass….maybe we are talking about different things here
@@primlan8214 at 4:35 Layne is doing kicks with throat bass while Geoff his holding his chest-fry note
9:16 To answer your question: Yes, there is a subharmonic note there. An F1 to be specific (the same low note he throws in here and there throughout the whole song. They just made it super subtle. But it‘s definitely there.
huh thats interesting!
Thanks! Ashley deserves extra applause!! I just love her talents..and attitude 🤗☺️‼️
Your facial expressions between Ashley & Geoff are PRICELESS!!!
I think what you’re hearing at the part you were confused on, where it sounds like Geoff is almost chewing the bass notes, is a mix of three things: Geoff’s lead notes that drop into bass range, the actual bass line by Geoff and three bass drum kicks from Layne. They all hit at the same point and it sounds just a little muddled so it’s hard to pick out, but that’s what I hear.
It would have been funny if Geoff on his last riff, got to end, looked at the camera and said "What!" mimicking Ashley.
Great reaction Qofy!! I haven't heard anyone else mention the overtones...great catch.
Right?
Only one other that I’ve found. Peter Barber. One of the basses with Tomi P.
@@davidharman8263 i just watched his. Love his musical incite as well.
I’m learning from him after playing classically for 40+ years. Fresh ears...
Yo QoFY catches every slight subharmonics from geoff. And i love it. But great reaction boss, much love.
I loved this one....all of the runs were awesome...Ashley's run up to the mountain peak and back down was incredible....That high note Geoff hit was near my head voice, and I am a tenor....I am in awe everytime I hear him.
Ashley is awesome. Sassy!
You can definitely tell her jazz style. She and Cesar are similar in style. Just blew me away
everybody gangsta till the locall billionaire starts biddy biddy bumming
Ashley Diane??? Where have you BEEN? You don't knock or ring the doorbell, you explode my door into bits and I don't care, I just smile and say it's so nice to meet you 😁❤️. Curious to see what she does from here 👍.
She sings with Voices of Liberty at EPCOT and i think with Resolve as well
I knew you would enjoy this one so much ! Couldn’t wait to see your reaction to Geoff and Ashley 😁
Didn’t hear the scales thing that Layne did until you pointed it out, how CAN YOU hear everything at once ? You genius 🎵👏
I loved the look on your face when Geoff went high, you paused it, then played again and Geoff went low! I laugh everytime I watch this! Good job overall!!
Your analysis of the parts and harmonic interplay is the best I've seen of all these reaction videos.
You want runs that hit every note going up and back down, VoicePlay is the place to go. I love the more ethereal voice echoes in the background and enhanced vocals. Thanks for your reaction.
went back to listen again, because I think this one is under appreciated.... and totally LOVE your reaction. Ashley Diane is amazing.
My reaction is identical to yours even after a dozen times listening
This is so much more upbeat than the original, and the orig is very close to my heart, but this makes me wonder what the movie would be like w/ such a change throughout... lol poor Topol
Geoff's lane is 5 octaves wide!
LOL. All the lanes ARE Geoff'sI 🤣
So much here as usual.
Layne needs to sing more! Ashley's run - holy shit. And Geoff dropping octaves like it's nothing, after flying way up in the sky first, with almost no break between! He really went up there! Cesar all over the place, same for Eli. This one just did so much! Major props to the arrangement. Just. Wow.
Such a marvelous rendition of this song.
Love Geoff and Voice Play and Ashley is great.
There are no lanes for Geoff. Don't think there was a sub you missed.
At the point you were talking about missing one of Geoff's subs, while Layne was beatboxing, I think Geoff did the whistle that can be heard there
You should really watch Fiddler on the roof, if you haven't,, It is such a good movie with lots of music
Will do Marla
Looks like Cesar is 'channeling' Boy George.
Yes definitely it was a subharmonic note. Excellent catch, as well as the overtone at the beginning. Qofy on top of the game!
Thanks for that!
Now that's a reaction video! You really bring something special to the experience. Thanks again, for another awesome ride!
Glad you enjoyed it!
*chefs kiss*
Try to whistle and hum at the same time to get that sound. Similar to an overtone, just created differently.
They killed it and your reaction was well done as well. Thanks!
If you playback at .5 speed, Layne is beatboxing and seems like Geoff is doing some whistling at 9:15
Love your reactions! VoicePlay’s latest mini isn’t just sound effects. Please start with Mr. Sandman, their latest. Just old fashioned barbershop type fun!
I love your reactions. They always put a smile on my face and when you analyze different parts it's always interesting.
Glad you like them!
What was that? That was superb is what that was. This blew me away
OK, I somehow missed this entire song and all the reactions months ago, but brilliant reaction, Qofy, even tho I’m saying it way late! Love that you caught those overtones.
Absolute a great reaction.
Love your reactions, always top notch stuff🙏🏻
Appreciate that
You predicted her!
Geoff: “I’d build a big, tall house with rooms by the dozen…”
Crew: “Twelve!” 😂
VoicePlay is a great musical group that I enjoy a lot
that was the point of the ooo overtones
Thank you for reacting to this, you are my favorite reactor 🙏
I actually put a comment on that video showing all the low notes in case you’re interested,
Wow, thank you
Great reaction!! Thanks QyFy 😎👍
Thank you too!
You look like you were having so much fun. It’s great when a song brings joy! Just so you know, I have watched this video many times so I watched you instead of them. 💖 loved it!
Loved it 😍
I think the part were there's a whistle I think it was Geoff whistling
Think its Eli because Geoff is the bass, Layne is doing Beatbox and in the first breakdown you can see Eli pointing up as the whistle goes up
@@lenzj8968 actually, I think that’s Layne’s whistle. Listen to It Ain’t Me.
he can do the sub with his voice
The last is definitely a sub. He does the hand drop thing 🤣🤣
I was in Fiddler on the Roof three times
Great reaction 😊
🤩😊
please react to home frees cover of brothers in arms, tim goes insanely low