Current sophomore baritone From Carmel, And I am Just shell Shocked on How Good this looked. They Killed it. Intro Gave me Goosebumps after hearing What I Play as our intro in Tribute 2020. Completely Amazing.
Colin Harding plus they learn the show in about half the time we have and are normally a thousand times more perfect, but hey, the number look kinda similar right ;)
I’m from Carroll High School from ft Wayne Indiana and I must say this was great. Their 2021 show “expansion” might be better though it’s really good. I saw it at BOA in Dayton OH and they won visual, music, and GE and then they won BOA (they’re a well funded school compared to us too)
@@Brian-rj1un yeah I’m jealous coming from a school we’re dads make our props 🤣🤣🥲🥲y’all just have a huge black wall that costed 200k I’d imagine LMAO nice work though 👍👍
My HS marching band is playing after Carmel this Saturday at the BOA competition so I went and looked for some of Carmel's performances and holy crap we're gonna be so bad compared to them, especially since we perform right after- this left me speechless, Carmel has such an amazing and talented marching band
Zach Zuber while visually they were very clean, to me Carmel’s show is just kind of bland and easy to me. (I’m not trying to put down the crazy amount of work these kids put into their show.) But Vista Ridges performance was phenomenal and so much more enjoyable for me than carmels and in my opinion just better.
@@ImChazo I think if u understood the show more you would like It. I didnt like it the first time i saw it but when it was explained and what passages were being used and how crazy it was then you would realise the difficulty in the show
Who tf decided that 210 bpm was a reasonable tempo for marching band??? Yes, they pulled it off beautifully, but that looked like a marcher's worst nightmare.
James Kaprowski I would say that it’s from 8:04 to the end of the first movement was the most difficult part but I’m sure other people have different opinions.
@@hypervolt9987 Excellent sleuthing. In professional arts circles, the lack of clarity in conveying this story would be unacceptable. But because marching bands do shows without words, suddenly it seems to give designers carte blanche to be lazy in conveying basic narrative elements. Band show designers need to be reeled in and made accountable for their choices, just like the professional world of entertainment. But somehow they convince students that they don't need to explain the narrative elements, or the progression of action, (sometimes there is none), and students are sheeple who put up with abstractions and capricious design whims.
@@hypervolt9987 "Up for interpretation" is a lazy designer's racket. Nothing in the arts is up to interpretation at its core observation. You try and get production financing in the performing arts and say your production is "up to interpretation"? In television and film? In large scale outdoor rock concerts? Musicals? The producers will laugh you out of the building. Marching arts should be no different. The dramatic action of this show is unclear. The only thing up to interpretation is the designer's resume.
Man I would have loved to see this show go head to head visually against FloMo In week 15 and or see how they would have faired musically against the Texas 2018 6a State Gold Vista Ridge! We shall never know 😡
This school is pretty amazing, but i favor this show over their 2021 show. For me i just see too many flaws in their latest one. Good job Carmel HS though
Yeah my boy Spencer Waybright best baritone of all time! Don't @ me
Weloc if i could retweet a comment i would
Show starts at 3:23
Current sophomore baritone From Carmel, And I am Just shell Shocked on How Good this looked. They Killed it. Intro Gave me Goosebumps after hearing What I Play as our intro in Tribute 2020. Completely Amazing.
Another Carmel sophomore bari here, this show pops off ungodly hard
@@tetris1848 Another Carmel baritone here. Was a junior that year. Best show ever. Best year ever. Fax no printer
Stop clapping so I can hear the show!
Anthony Kladke haha sorry about that, some of my family members don’t know show etiquette:(
@@evanmickel9347 in my show this past season almost everyone clapped over top a mellophone solo at the end of our 3rd movement so...
They are so in tune! Their director worked with our band during the summer and it was a fantastic experience.
which director?
@@fairlygeneric8573 Michael Pote, director of Carmel bands.
what band?
Them:Getting the same scored as DCI corps
Schools in my towns:50.34
Colin Harding DCI scores a lot harder than BOA does
@@samuelherrmann6109 good point
Colin Harding plus they learn the show in about half the time we have and are normally a thousand times more perfect, but hey, the number look kinda similar right ;)
I’m from Carroll High School from ft Wayne Indiana and I must say this was great. Their 2021 show “expansion” might be better though it’s really good. I saw it at BOA in Dayton OH and they won visual, music, and GE and then they won BOA (they’re a well funded school compared to us too)
Thanks! I'm on snare at Carmel and our 2021 show "The Expanse" sounds really awesome!
@@Brian-rj1un yeah I’m jealous coming from a school we’re dads make our props 🤣🤣🥲🥲y’all just have a huge black wall that costed 200k I’d imagine LMAO nice work though 👍👍
@@chandlergd4055 hey, dads do make our props. We just bought the supplies and the dads put ours together.
@@Brian-rj1un oh whatttt our bd told us that one of the reason you guys win a lot is because you guys buy props? Huh
@@chandlergd4055 we buy the materials and volenteers put them together
This is another knock it out of the park show !!!
My HS marching band is playing after Carmel this Saturday at the BOA competition so I went and looked for some of Carmel's performances and holy crap we're gonna be so bad compared to them, especially since we perform right after- this left me speechless, Carmel has such an amazing and talented marching band
Oh yeah… We’re in for a challenge 😐
Also- HI AL!!!
@@kkdarling9018 OMG LMAO HIIIIII
@@alnotyourpal what band are you? just curious because i’m from indiana too so i’ve probably seen ur show
@@nickdeig6315 Beavercreek!
@@alnotyourpal thanks 😊! my band is castle highschool btw if you’ve ever heard of us
5:37 wdym the flutes are all perfect I literally have no idea what you're talking about
Epic gamer moment
Dang you killed it in boa I loved that experience
I wonder how the rankings would have differed if the Texas bands were here
I know Texas bands are very good, but I thought Carmels performance was very good from both a musical and visual standpoint
Zach Zuber while visually they were very clean, to me Carmel’s show is just kind of bland and easy to me. (I’m not trying to put down the crazy amount of work these kids put into their show.) But Vista Ridges performance was phenomenal and so much more enjoyable for me than carmels and in my opinion just better.
Zach Zuber Again I’m not a judge so this mostly just my opinion lol
I can respect your opinion
@@ImChazo I think if u understood the show more you would like It. I didnt like it the first time i saw it but when it was explained and what passages were being used and how crazy it was then you would realise the difficulty in the show
very nice:0
i wish i went there, they seem so great:
97.35
Love!!!!!!!!!!!
What did they spell at the start?
Carmel
Who tf decided that 210 bpm was a reasonable tempo for marching band??? Yes, they pulled it off beautifully, but that looked like a marcher's worst nightmare.
James Kaprowski I marched baritone in this show and I can confirm that it was very difficult
Hypervolt This year has been a lot of fun so far, we still have a lot of work to do.
Hypervolt Thanks Hayden!
@@grantherrmann6325 Do you remember which part of the show was the hardest?
James Kaprowski I would say that it’s from 8:04 to the end of the first movement was the most difficult part but I’m sure other people have different opinions.
Does Carmel march all grade levels?
Niraj Koneru yep! freshman sophomore junior and senior! we don’t do auditions or anything, all are welcome in the ensemble :)
Nice, I'm from mason, gonna be a sophomore this year. We're hoping to get top 5 again. It's gonna be a long road
Niraj Koneru that’s awesome! you guys consistently kill it, love your shows, i’ll keep an eye out for you guys this season :)
5:00 - 5:20
What songs/pieces were played?
Ring Cycle by Wagner, and I think another piece but that was 4 years ago now so it’s escaping me.
It says at the beginning of the vid, ring cycle and mahler's 2nd
What happens in this show? Where does the ship go? And why?
Jesu Spectre omg hi lol
@@deanfreiman5842 Hi.
@@hypervolt9987 Excellent sleuthing. In professional arts circles, the lack of clarity in conveying this story would be unacceptable. But because marching bands do shows without words, suddenly it seems to give designers carte blanche to be lazy in conveying basic narrative elements. Band show designers need to be reeled in and made accountable for their choices, just like the professional world of entertainment. But somehow they convince students that they don't need to explain the narrative elements, or the progression of action, (sometimes there is none), and students are sheeple who put up with abstractions and capricious design whims.
@@hypervolt9987 "Sort of show, and don't tell anything to clarify" and "interpret my paycheck."
@@hypervolt9987 "Up for interpretation" is a lazy designer's racket. Nothing in the arts is up to interpretation at its core observation. You try and get production financing in the performing arts and say your production is "up to interpretation"? In television and film? In large scale outdoor rock concerts? Musicals? The producers will laugh you out of the building. Marching arts should be no different. The dramatic action of this show is unclear. The only thing up to interpretation is the designer's resume.
Man I would have loved to see this show go head to head visually against FloMo In week 15 and or see how they would have faired musically against the Texas 2018 6a State Gold Vista Ridge! We shall never know 😡
Ligma
jkidfn joe mama
How did they move the ship
@@hypervolt9987 we had designated prop movers for the show, as well as some guard during parts of the show
Lol my schools too poor to consistently compete at grand nats
It’s a privilege to get to go at all, my school hasn’t ever been, last time we went to super regionals was 2014
Eclipse 384 lmao for my school it was 2001 I think
My school just sucks lmao, at our last 3 competitions we have gotten last
Crazy high band fees, fundraisers that are measured in the 10s of thousands of dollars, and living fairly close to Lucas Oil get you that privilege.
Bourbon county bruh
🤦♀️
This school is pretty amazing, but i favor this show over their 2021 show.
For me i just see too many flaws in their latest one. Good job Carmel HS though
Coming from Carmel, I agree. This will forever be our greatest show
As someone who performed both, I think our semi-final performance 2021 was better than finals, and may have just been as good as 2018
This show could be played by 6th graders. I’m still mad that they win every year
Captain Crusader man you salty
Same bro
Captain Crusader the sound quality is very very bad as my father leaned it against glass, so all you hear is echoes, sorry about that!
I agree, not saying they ain’t work hard but........I don’t see any sort of difficulty at all in this show
Donnie i think that’s a little unfair, it was a hard show for all of us.
Worst of the 3 thy won
*5
@@joesmith9920 *6
@@muukas3453 true true