The Lovely Bones - Jack Realizes the Truth (Full scene) HD 2009
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- This is the full scene from The Lovely Bones where Jack Salmon realizes the truth about his daughter Suzie's killer George Harvey.
Judging from the Demographics of you guys watching this video, I think a lot of you may enjoy my main channel (links below). I am a British guy who lives in Korea. I make travel-related vlogging videos about living In Korea focusing on Culture, Food and travel exploring Korea.
Main Channel - / kairuinkorea
@KairuinKorea
Film synopsis - Film Description: Fourteen-year-old Susie Salmon (Saoirse Ronan) is just experiencing the pangs of first love when she's viciously murdered by her neighbor Mr. Harvey (Stanley Tucci), a predatory wolf in J.C. Penney clothing. As her family slowly begins drifting apart while struggling to make sense of their loss, Susie bravely attempts to find her footing in the hereafter. Meanwhile, down on earth, Mr. Harvey is feeling confident that he's covered his tracks well enough to get away with the crime, and begins honing in on his next victim -- Susie's younger sister, Lindsey (Rose McIver), who's beginning to suspect that he's not the harmless suburbanite he portrays himself to be. Director Peter Jackson reteams with King Kong and Lord of the Rings trilogy co-screenwriters Philippa Boyens and Fran Walsh to adapt Alice Sebold's bestselling novel for the big screen.
I studied this film for A level Film and I loved the entire film and could not find the full scene anywhere on the internet so I uploaded it for everybody to enjoy and maybe other film students will choose to study this clip also.
I uploaded this on my original account about 2 years ago but took it down when i wanted to start a serious channel without any copyright infringement. Thank you for watching, hope you enjoy
Judging from the Demographics of you guys watching this video, I think a lot of you may enjoy my main channel (links below). I am a British guy who lives in Korea. I make travel-related vlogging videos about living In Korea focusing on Culture, Food and travel exploring Korea.
Main Channel - th-cam.com/users/KairuinKorea
It’s to do with de-flowering. The offender de-flowered the girl and the dead flowers make reference to that.
@@Teddy-ez9qq no actually Suzie took a photo of Mr. Pervey in front of that rose bush & the dad saw it but the mum took no notice, this is Suzie’s way of letting him know he’s right. @3:35
😊😊😊
@@MsTinkerbelle87 i think it could be a nice mix of the 2 ideas in this scene showing a really strong connection
The "where IS she" part hurts me so badly everytime because he thinks she's maybe alive but she's dead
pretty sure he was asking where her remains were
Mr harvey is susie salmon killer
He was asking where her body was
I can feel his pain
He is very aware she is dead. She had been giving him messages and hints from the afterlife by then.
She whispered "Dad"...
This movie a Masterpiece, emotional, deep...
lol why the facepalm?
+Tickmayham42 why would you watch a scene off of a movie you dislike?
Just listen to the music in this episode.
Sry for my bad english
Your opinion doesn't matter. You're the only one here. There are many people who love this movie and you can't change that. No matter how hard you try, your attempts are futile. Your opinion doesn't matter.
+Tickmayham42 It's great that you understand. I'm sorry if i offended you in anyway.
Jack: You're a hunter?
Mr. Harvey: Yes, children. I mean, ducks. I hunt ducks.
Jam Lym he said children?
Dysha Brown no he didn't say children. He was just being sarcastic.
Eric Boyles o
Jam Lym this made me laugh so much
😭
The part where the flower bloomed in his palm made me cry so hard!!
Me too💔
off course
it actually made me wonder how the hell it's happening and why it should make any sense
And The Wild Bean Appears it was just a vision
And The Wild Bean Appears I think that it's just a symbol. It represents her daughter that is still there, in his memories and his heart, and the hope to find her killer.
Tucci and Wahlberg are both brilliant in this scene. Tucci is so cold, apathetic and evil. Wahlberg is so hurt, angry, and filled with vengeance after he realizes that Harvey killed his beautiful daughter.
wtf that's tucci wow what a transformation I thought that was just another actor I should really use imbd more often
+alex arellano but then again you can tell by his voice
Do you mean apathetic?
Bee no, Thomas is really clever and has a very sophisticated vocabulary.
S Sh then you mean emphatic?
what a sick man the way he was looking at her while she was saying look Dad and riding her bike and he realizes by that moment it was him who killed his daughter Susie. that's so sad and messed up :(
Yeah, yeah, he is sick because he just looks at this girl, what a terrible man!
lol looking at someone doesn't mean jack lol
oooh19 he was look at her in a predatory way, that's how he connected the dots
Мартин Лютер guess you didn’t see that look of lust on his face
oooh19 it actually does..
For me, the dead blooms on that shrub represent all the beautiful young lives this man stole... The look of horror on Jack's face in this scene is just so heartbreaking and intense...
exactly and maybe that’s why susie saw her flower as alive in her dimension because she thought she was alive
@@lilithjade4363 My biggest fear.. Being stuck in limbo 😟
U sound like my english teacher
Also maybe when he cut off the flower and gave it to the family, it was like he was saying their daughter would be next. But maybe I’m just stretching it
@@DNLTE a reference to ' deflowering ' maybe ( i haven't watched the movie in awhile so idk )
"It's all about patience, waiting hours in the dark. I'm an outdoorsmen." Also a serial killer. no big deal tho.
Don't forget psychotic.
@@brandyyolidio4213 Jesus.... This is horrible, thanks God or angels or whoever.whatever that you;re alive.... You showed immense wit at that age...
Yeah people like to ignore the obvious sometimes.
Boasting has a way of saying way more than is being said. While said person is uttering one thing, the way in which it is spoken (the energy behind those words) get translated otherwise. As words are supported by intent and body language, that never lies.
And to think this actually happens in real life...😔
All the time 😢
Is it a true story
That breaks my heart
🤨
That was true???
Mark Wahlberg is a good actor. No mistake - he's done genuinely great work over his career. However, the moment he realises Harvey is his daughters murderer is one of the finest moments an actor has ever performed. The look in his eyes is pure horror, it's absolutely amazing.
This film absolutely kills me on such an emotional level. It's amazing and heartbreaking.
[STARS]TyranT To me, Markie Mark's best performance was in the Happening. Oscar worthy.
You're not special because you analyzed this
Keegan LaMotte nobody said he or she is
[STARS]TyranT yep, I agree. It was truly the finest
He was great in The Fighter, Patriot's Day and Lone Survivor.
How I see this scene: Jack has started to realize that the murderer might not be a stranger, but maybe someone familiar. It is the unnerving thought most people probably don't want to think about. You push it away, until you need to consider it. He starts to see beyond Mr. Harvey's nice neighbor image and that's why he approaches him. To see his reaction. Finally he sees the roses and one of them starting to bloom, which is a straight reminder of Susie. The decayed rose is a symbol of something beautiful and sweet dying. Susie is like that decayed rose and she is there in Mr. Harvey's garden. The shock we see on Jack's face is because he knows then he has overlooked the red flags. He has not really seen Mr. Harvey at all. Until this moment he has mostly seemed like a nice guy, a harmless neighbor, even a bit pathetic. But once you really look at him you will understand the danger in that nice, but strange kind of a guy's image. Truth is he lives alone, he acts a bit strange and unusual, you never see him with anybody, he is always so nice but what do you actually know about him... And this is the most shocking thing of all, because then Jack realizes that he doesn't know him at all. He could be anything or anyone. The roses remind him of that day when they were admiring the roses with his wife and it is then he remembers seeing his interest in Susie in the way he glances at her. This subconscious warning sign now emerges and Jack is shocked he didn't fully understand it before. He can't escape it anymore. He needs to look at Mr. Harvey and think if he could be the one responsible, when he sees his reactions. First avoiding the encounter, then talking nonchalantly about being a hunter, the way he seems uncomfortable and wary of his sudden interest in him, the way he talks and looks at Jack like he is almost arrogant, boastful of something. When Jack watches him and sees the things on display he realizes Mr. Harvey acts guilty. There is fear and knowledge, even curiousity in his eyes when he looks at Jack and like a cherry on top you see him almost smirking at him straight to his face before rushing off. And it is right then when Jack knows this man knows what happened to his daughter. It was all there in his reactions. Jack only needed to watch him, to truly see this man and finally acknowledge the gut-wrenching thought that he had been too afraid to see all the signs that were always there.
riskybubble
Until I read your analysis, I had extreme difficulty finding the best way to describe this emotional and gut-wrenching scene. Well put, well said, and thanks very much.
@@jonathanlewis6240 So nice to hear that! Made my day. Thank you for your message :)
HOLY MOLEY YOU SUMMED THIS UP SO PERFECTLY AND MADE ME ENJOY THIS SCENE 100 times more!!!! Great Job
Oh gosh, thank you SO much for this! I’ve been trying to find youtubers explain the movie for this certain part because it confused me so much on how he put the pieces together, the flashbacks didn’t really help that much! 😅 Thank you so much!
Well said.
It made me so mad that in the end they never found the safe in the pit
ruby craig i did too but i think its more realistic that way.
Ikr it didn't make sense. Three people saw him dump it and the police were raiding his house because of the evidence the sister found. Then he went missing. Why didn't the three people say anything?
@@AGolfHitter it's just like real life
The police focus all on 1 thing while not looking at other things
Im sure they later realized she was in the safe. Once news broke that they found his book and he fled Im sure they reported that he went to dump it before leaving. They’d never get the remains but they knew where she was in the end.
Oh I’m most definitely sure they found it and her body was properly buried considering he was under their radar and numerous people knew he put that safe in that hole. Susie was aight.
This movie is completely sick but a masterpiece to me. My own dad can’t watch it because he can’t imagine how the father feels. To see my dad so emotional over a movie makes me realize just how good it is.
My dad too, it made him so angry
And how much your dad LOVES you!! 💜
Yeah I was traumatized for days
My 30 year old son just watched this and was extremely upset. I had read the book and seen the movie years ago. He told me that he couldn't understand reasons why someone would do this to a child. I worked for the Missouri Department of Corrections at a sex offenders camp, I have seen it all
My dad don’t care about me he’s dead now
is it just me or did jackson try to make harvey look like an old version of jeffery dalmer?
Jobs and Taxes yes....those glasses and hair colour. Except that Dahmer was younger than Mr.Harwey
Dahmer with contact lems
Apparently Stanley Tucci hated his character so much he requested to have a fake tan, contacts and a wig so he could look as different as possible and not have to associate himself with the character. I guess the modelling of this look was after Dalmer though cause you're right
Jobs and Taxes, So true
Jobs and Taxes more like a less taller version of Ed kemper. Even has the moustache.
"I think it's time for you to go home now....go on home."
#shitmurdererssay
Ashley Miller lmaooo
Ashley Miller lmao
i'll keep this in mind
r/shitmurderssay
truee
That would have been embarrassing if he hadn't done it
😂😂😂 i was all sad after watching this clip and then busted out laughing when i read your comment haha
Murdered the girl.
apple bee ‘wrong neighbour mr’
apple bee and raped
Chris Jarma I think in the movie it was just murder
The fact that he's making a trap to get the other Salmon girl, while talking to her father is disgusting
After everything he's taken from this family, he wants to take more
I think it’s cuz he really resented the sister. I loved every time she glared at him to make him feel uneasy. She stomped on his cheeky grins.
I think it's also because he's been repressing the urge for so long that once he ooofed Susie he got into a point where he couldn't stop.
The cup George chose to fill had no bottom.
Guys like him don’t care about human life or feelings
@@antizoom6855 fyi the movie doesn’t say it but he raped Susie then killed her. He’s a sexual predator. He gets the itch and makes sure he satisfy’s it
Stanley Tucci did PHENOMENAL in this film. He should have won the Oscar for Best Supporting in 2010!
Love the Tucc.
Amiee Dawn nope. Christoph Waltz deserved it much more.
What role was Christoph Waltz in that he won an Oscar?
Dei H Inglorious Bastards- Hans Landa
@@mannysaurus19 Eh Christoph was great in Bastards but for Tucci to embody a merciless, evil piece of shit was phenomenal.
This movie had my anxiety through the roof! Especially when the sister was in his house trying to find evidence to proof he killed her....so sad but so good!😩
Monique Shaw he did not kill her
@@igertlee8790 he did
Patricia Vicente ohhh I thought he was talking about the sis
I was totally stressed out right then too.
sameeee
The fact that Jack never gave up on Susie is the most heart breaking thing
Even after her death, he kept fighting to bring her justice
I like to think a decade-and-a-half later (this is 1973), Jack is still alive and brings Susie's story to _Unsolved Mysteries_ 📺
What creeps me out is that Mark's character was unknowingly helping Mr Harvey with this trap he was gonna use on his own daughter. 😨😱😵
Stickerz yes and rape and kill her 😫😩 she was a fighter though I truly think she was the one that would’ve challenged him regardless
Can you elaborate on where this is shown in the movie? Or is it only mentioned in the novel? It’s been a while since I’ve seen the movie and I don’t remember if the movie showed that his intention was to use this on his other daughter
@@RuSsHeR1 the day she was going for her run he went to his car and put his trap in the back the same one he was building here, along with it he laid out a blanket and put a hammer, tape, a saw, and other stuff to use on her.
Mr. Harvey was watching the sister and Susie narrates that he was getting the “itch” again and it shows him drawing up this new “project” in his notebook. Then it shows him putting it together here in this scene.
@Stickerz that thought totally chilled me too.
Me too; he would have felt so terrible had his other daughter been killed. That poor family. I didn't like how the mom kept telling Jack to stop; my mom would have been looking for me no matter what the cops said; not run away. This poor man having to raise his children alone kills me.
He only watered the flowers to spy on Susie. When she went missing he stopped. Thats how he figured out the killer.
The fact that Harvey wanted, not one, but *both* of Jack’s daughters always gets to me. Him alone wanting Susie was heartbreaking then he found it necessary to lay eyes on her sister. And the expression upon Jack’s face as he’s realizing he’s looking his little girls’ murderer in his eyes will forever be a tearjerker. This movie just goes to show that parents won’t stop when it comes to their children. They will not rest, they will not eat, until their children are safe or are brought to justice.
-
-
Edit: I’m just not realizing that the flashbacks are from each others POV, (Harvey’s and Jack’s) Jack’s POV, he’s noticing the predatory look on Harvey’s face but doesn’t pay no mind to it or just doesn’t see it the way most people would. Harvey is obviously paying more mind to Susie as she was his latest victim. All the pieces are finally coming together...
@be a man lol ouch. i’m sorry that you feel that way and feel like people wouldn’t do whatever it takes for you to be safe, but not everyone grew up the way you did. Where i come from, including the people around me, they’re ready to put down their lives for their kids. i’m not saying they should have to because no one should ever have to feel like that, but thats just the kind of world we live in.
edit: also tf does you being in foster care have to do with anything that i commented 2 years ago????
This comment is three years old but I never realized the switch of their POV..wow
Wow I never looked at it that way but it makes total sense. The flashbacks of Susie in the back taking pictures and calling to her parents is what Harvey was seeing from his POV. I always thought it was just Jack’s POV or a 3rd person view of that whole scene. You opened my eyes to a new way to interpret that scene!
I’m just now realizing up until he finally got Susie he never cut those rose bushes anymore..He was using that as a plotting scheme
Thank God for Icicles
TomthatiscalledTom right!? Bless you, winter.
TomthatiscalledTom yesss
Alex Sunlit lmfao
TomthatiscalledTom and cliffs
I was so salty when I thought it didn't actually kill him
I cried at least 30 times throughout this movie lol the tears just wouldn't stop its so sad
I'm an old U.S. Marine combat vet and retired engineer who isn't prone to showing emotions but even my eyes welled up a couple times in this movie.
@anathemaizz
Woah.. wasn't expecting any of those videos in his favorites.
Ugh, same here! When that safe goes down in the hole it breaks my heart every time.
anathemaizzy huh what which ones I can't see them
Fucking nonce
The part that made me cry is when she closed her eyes and said dad and the flower started blooming in his hand that really touched my heart❤😢.
Oh my god, Mark’s acting in this scene, the look in his eyes when it all clicks in his head, and him crying out “what did you do to my daughter” send chills down my spine. Such a fantastic actor. And Stanley Tucci, wow. He did a fantastic job. Both actors are just amazing. I wonder how icky playing that character made Tucci feel.
It made him feel awful. He couldn't imagine doing that to his own child or someone else's. He's such a sweetheart. He didn't even want to film the graphic part of the murder scene in the book because he felt gross and awful at the thought of doing that.
I love how Susie slowly closed her eyes and whispered dad as the as the flower that represents her vibrant than happy life that was taken away from her blooms before her Father's eyes then the realization slowly hits him that his bright happy and sweet little girl was killed by mr. Harvey
The actor who plays mr. Harvey hated playing a pedophile he didn't like it at all
Tucci felt the need to apologize to Saoirse after every scene;because of how dirty it made him feel initially he didn’t even want to do it,but I’m glad he did he nailed creepy and psychotic perfectly and the movie may have not lifted off as much if they casted someone else. I’ve also heard that some people can’t watch his other roles knowing how creepy he was in this movie and how much they resented the character,so it sorta impacted his film career,but I see it as one of his best performances,the look in his eyes when he starts planning again,was truly haunting; psychotic.well done , movie managed to choke me up;especially mark wahlburg’s scenes.
Acting was great in this movie, especially this scene
The look of realization @ 4:20 deserved an Oscar alone. I think this is one of Mark's best and underrated roles. Both him and Stan convey emotion in the scene so fucking intensely that you think it's real.
I guess when the murderer hears the horrific cry of a battered father his expression changes, its subtle here, but the hurting cry of the Father really was woeful, a cry of loss and death and pain. It's sad that people didn't see the fathers and mothers pain in this movie at all. Their dear child was murdered and even the child lost everything, oh if only audience could feel the pain of all.
Nikhil Sukumar you are absolutely right about how the audience doesn't see all the emotions presented. I watched 6 times in intervals to truly grasp many other emotions that I missed.
Eric Boyles very good way to understand a movie more. Thank you. I will try tjat tip. I Usually see only certain movies more than thrice. This movie I saw twice and it was different each time. Like different chapters. The director is head deep into the story and decided on applying various layers. Which means this movie helped us to understand the book or the story inside. Nice tip to stop and watch.
Nikhil Sukumar WHY? I SAW THEM...
Pawknee123 did you like it or understand it?
Nikhil Sukumar just read the book
The most unrealistic part of this is that door holding. Any father would have knocked it down easily with that rage
He made it so obvious at the end"I think it's time for you to go"Why? Is his wife worried sick?
Right that's so true he was too suspicious....
Recycled Teenager I think Mr. Harvey could tell by the way her dad was acting that he was very suspicious of him. Then when he turns to walk away, look at his face. He gives Jack a little smirk, as if too say yeah I raped and killed your daughter. what are you gonna do about it? Lol
If he WERE innocent, he would imagine that the dad is thinking some very crazy thoughts. He sees this crazy look in his eyes and thinks, "Oh my God, I think he's going to lunge at me any second. I should try to calm him down.. 'I think you should leave.' and then lock myself home."
Does that make sense to you? It makes sense to me.
I think it's time for you to go home now gone home now
@@jamielehman4934 Lol is NOT appropriate in this sentence
This scene is chilling. The acting is incredible.
yeah it is
That look in Mark Wahlberg’s eyes always breaks my heart 😢
The Dad's eyes can talk. Impressive acting.9
4:20 gives me chills and shakes me to the core. He deserves an acting reward for that shot alone.
4:30 if mark wahlberg looks like this you are definitely dead...
true true
“So let me in the fucking house”
Totomorte Lmaoo
Timm Weis 4:30
Timm Weis The "Fear" look
You can see it dawn on Jack’s face when he recalls the memory. Harvey was never paying attention to him. He was always watching Susie, who was behind him. That’s why he gave them flowers. It was an excuse to watch Susie.
Watching this film again after so long this scene got even better. I love the expression on the dad's eyes. He's like "the answer was right in front of me the whole time." And it makes sense because victims often get killed by predators that they knew, and Harvey knew Susie long enough to make a connection with her in front of the parents, more specifically in Jack's presence. The dad was well aware that Harvey expressed an interest in his daughter. That was a passive moment that he never thought about twice much less realized until he picked up that flower. It was an instant reminder like "wow.. I actually had a conversation with this man before. He knows me and my family." So it was never about the dad getting an answer from the flower bloom. The bloom itself was an imaginary symbolic display of his wake up call which was his memory, and that's why this movie works so well. Father's instincts know how to put the pieces together. He knew that the police reports weren't going to find a damn thing, that he would have to listen for the answer and it would eventually come to him. The whole thing is sad.
That awkward moment when the dad of the girl you killed shows up at your house unexpectedly
Yes very uncomfortable
LMAOOOO
Your dad will always have a fatherly instinct about his babygirl especially if he raised her 💯
Mothers too.
I cant even imagine what Jack felt in this moment. I think this is the best scene in all movie.
Fear
@@raydiaz9218 Raw rage. Mr Harvey is the one that was scared.
the despair in his voice when he says "what did you do to my daughter" 😔
“I never got a chance to tell you about how sorry I am about your loss.” is the coldest line ever.
Her ghost scaring him is the only think that made the dad notice he was there. Good job Susie
That bicycle shadow creeped me out.
what even was that?
TheGoodFather It was the ghost of Susie. I saw how they did that in a behind-the-scenes video.
it's really interesting when she causes strange living world things. Like the rose blooming and the shadow
TheGoodFather I think the rose-blooming was symbolic of her father's remembering, not literal. Because the flower is brown when he drops it, and Mr. Harvey sees it as normal.
i get it. Whenever the interactions occur, theres only one witness. People hearing her echoing scream for example, or Harvey sensing her presence
I never normally like Mark Wahlberg but he does fantastic in this role. I hope he does some more dramatic roles in the future because he's wasted on those dumb action movies.
But they are hysterical. I do agree on him doing more drama movies tho, his acting is superb.
what the fuck you say to me? Was there any need to be so rude?
Boogie nights, the fighter, the departed, patriots day, deep water horizon, I heart Huckabees and the basket ball diaries are all good films. All actors/actresses have good movies, you just have to look.
Mystic River was awesome too
Dang...this guy played this role a little too good. If I see him in real life I'm gonna have to hurt him lol...and that hair😂😂😂😂awful
🤣😂🤪😂
He is like a Jeffrey Dahmer heterossexual old version
That is a sign of a top class actor 👏 credit to Mr.Tucci and Mr.Wahlberg
His character pissed me off so much, but it means he did his job well lol
@@J_larry oh yeah he also did it good and the terminal the bald airport vigilante
The music in this scene is so powerful, literally holding back the tears!
What’s it called
@@lexflexa3787 lovely bones soundtrack 3m1
@@lexflexa3787 it’s not the full one cause it was never released but this is a small version of it
I also love the symbolism from 1:32-1:45. Notice the distance between Jack and Mr. Harvey at the beginning of their walk and then again towards the end. Jack is catching up to (Or Catching onto) Mr. Harvey. He’s no longer invisible to Jack anymore. Love it... #ForSusie #AndForAllTheSusiesThatHaveNoVoice
I just got chills watching this...🌬
the realization on his face is heartbreaking, Mark Walberg was amazing in this film.
Mark was phenomenal here. Felt like my heart was being ripped out
Whispering
"Dad"
My heart just melted
Rocky R it’s like this movie is good and bad Bc she gets raped and killed but then she goes to heaven and gets justice for what happened to her and is finally up there with god and moves on
This is the most haunting movie I’ve ever seen. I thought about it for days after I saw it. The movie stays with you. It lingers. Quietly but menacingly over your head.
It always made me sad to think about what happened to Susie and that they never found her body then mr. Harvey just died without getting any form of punishment whatsoever for what he did to her and they never freaking found her body to even give her a proper burial that always bothered me everybody else gets to leave a happy life and grow up but never Susie which is the reality in this world a lot of kids don't get to grow up
I read the book a few years ago amazing novel
I recommend the book. It’s even better than the movie. I’m reading it again after about the sixth time through the years.
Mark Wahlbergs eyes when the character realises is amazing, he doesn’t say a word and barely moves but just the look he has feels so real, you really feel his horror
I haven't even seen this movie and this scene got to me so hard. Crying.
Aiymuan Covington That's so very true it's the reality. In sixties till nineties many children were murdered by all sorts of murderers. Many parents and friends never got to know the truths behind it. And the worst part is that those deaths were so violent and against all human rights. Such things happened in those days like a normal thing. Children were smuggled into the European rackets. RIP little angels. Hope humanity has learnt.
Nikhil Sukumar what u mean that still happens now
@@alexgipson5363 Yes it still happens now, but I think what he means is back then Stranger Danger was first introduced so it was new to people, cops didn't really know how to solve these types of cases just like the cop in the movie that half-assed looked for Suzie. Now we are more educated on serial killers and we have the resources to show our kids what could happen.
Harvey is soooo flipping scary wtf!!
The scene where he tries to break the door down and screams "WHAT DID YOU DO TO MY DAUGHTER?!" Is so sad. You can hear the pain and sadness in his voice.💔
My dad made me watch this movie when I was little, to make me aware of child molesters and murderers. This movie still makes me cry to this day
Not the best parenting. 😂
“The art of concealment” absolutely gut wrenching quote
The music starting from 4:23 send chills down my spine. You can just feel the heartbreak Susie's father feels by listening to the music alone
I remember seeing this film and feeling utterly literally sick to my stomach..No other film has had the same effect on me. What a powerful scene.
I love this movie!
Especially how jack wouldnt srop looking for susie, and when Mr.Harvey was actually building the trap for Lindsay.
I think every scene Jack was in i loved!
How do you know that the trap was for the other daughter
Because in the movie after he killed susie he started to watch lindsey lue and watch her run with her dog and he got the urg to kill again so he built the trap and then when he saw Lindsey he asked the same thing that he asked Lindsey "you're the salmon girl right?" She had a feeling that he was going to do the same thing to her that he did tho get sister that's why she just started him down and he walked away plus the dog was barking
+Diamonique Grate thanks
Diamonique Grate I love that she's the one who found out that he's the serial killer.
This show truly scared me.
No matter how many times I watch this movie I still bawl my eyes out.
"I think it's time for you to go home now Mr. Salmon."
Now roast me: I absolutely love this movie, and I don't care how cheesy or poor it is for other people. It helped me cope when my grandma died last year.
Desirée Mena sorry
Desirée Mena That was peaceful to hear, it shows the other sides of death. We seldom think about the dead. We feel they vanish but actually they don't they are somewhere beautiful and peaceful. One life is precious hope your comment will educate others too.
Desirée Mena, I'm sorry for your loss. The movie does help to introduce another perspective on dying.
Desirée Mena they show you there own way that they are with you🙏💕
I love that her father never stopped looking for her 😭
For those of you who write, "i don't get how Jack finds out", here are the six most likely reasons:
1. Mr Harvey was always strange; one of the characters mentioned earlier that he's always been isolated.
2. Hastily telling him to leave and talking about the "art of concealment" (like tf? 0_0)
3. The current evidence at hand: "Susie wouldn't walk off with anyone, it had to be someone she knew."
4. The photos; Jack never considered Mr Harvey as a suspect.
5. The Camellias; Mr Harvey stopped watering them 'cause he used them to get a look at Susie.
6. The memory of their first meeting; Jack only just now noticed that Mr Harvey was eyeing up his daughter at the time.
But most importantly, it came from a father's gut instinct. When Jack watched Mr Harvey tightly tying up those sticks, you too would be upset thinking about what he could've done to her. It may be unrealistic, but even your dad would've had a similar experience. I hope this was helpful. This is my favorite scene. Everyone says Wahlberg shouldn't have been in this role but i feel that he did a way better job than Gosling would've done. The pure horror in his eyes and when he's yelling, "Where is she?!" is just heartbreaking. :'(
Yes, there are some scenes they could've done without or done better but still, a well executed movie.
Thanks for this! It kind of summed out some things I was wondering about (I’ve never actually seen the movie in full) but do you know what happens after this clip? It cuts off at an annoying moment, I want to know if Jack gets the door down
Thank you lmao this has been eating me for years wondering how lol
Thank you lmao this has been eating me for years wondering how lol
This whole scene was done to perfection from the flower bloom, to Jack having flashbacks of conversing with Harvey and the unusual amount of of staring he was ginging to Susie, to coming to the realization that he is indeed the murderer.
tucci made me hate this character so much, a truly phenomenal acting performance
This movie breaks my heart 😭 the fact that they portrayed the killer as a normal person just send chills down my spine... the man was their neighbor... and continued to be their neighbor.... like that shows that in real life these ppl can be anywhere ...
When he's telling the father of the girl he killed about what goes into hunting.... that's maybe the most stomach-churning moment in movie history for me.
The look of utter hopelessness, lost in Marks eyes is heartbreaking. And to see the change of those eyes as he realizes what is in front of him does not lessen the heartbreak because that hopelessness transforms into incompetence. There is nothing he can do to change what has happened.
Taking a dark haired actor and making them blonde and blue eyed instantly adds creepiness (see Jessica Alba in Fantastic Four creepy).
i always think of mark as a comedic and funny guy, but he killed it in this movie. and i've seen stan in so many movies he can play so many different types of parts whether it's funny or emotional or even an animated voice. saoirse also did so good in this movie she was perfect for the role of susie
I love how you can see it in his eyes. You can see the exact moment when he realized that Harvey murdered his daughter. This is my favorite scene from the entire movie.
The look that Mark had when he put the pieces together, is, I don’t know what word to use. That look isn’t something you can recreate. I love Marks other movies but I loved seeing him portray someone that in some unfortunate cases, is relatable to some fathers out there.
I don’t believe that Jack heard Susie. I think she gave him intuition.
I can't stop crying .... I love Susie Salmon
I recently re watched this movie just the other day, now that I have a child… it hits a little harder. I couldn’t help but ball my eyes out. The love a parent has for their child(ren) is unmatched man. Truly indescribable. And things like this happen everyday. I just pray for peace and protection over my family and babies, and for anyone that’s lost theirs.
such an epic scene... the actors did a great job.
Stanly Tucci looks like Ryan Gosling's dad
That stare resonates deep with me, although this is a movie, Mark did a great job. I have three daughters, and I hate to even imagine the fear, disgust, hatred, sadness, etc, of something ever happening to them.
Idk why some critics give this movie so much shit. It was one of the best of 2010 imo
You're a hunter?
Daughters. I mean, ducks.
How Wahlberg knew how to act in this scene is beyond my comprehension, but he sure nailed it. What a movie.
This is probably one his few best performances.
Kinda wished they showed more proof with it, the scenes are beautiful but they don’t really have a lot of proof behind them.
I would believed it more if Mr. Harvey contradicted himself about her death and her dad caught on, or something like that.
This might be one of the most brilliantly portrayed and written scenes in cinematic history....no detail was left out and every word has meaning...
The part where she finally sees her body sends me chills every time...
Body?
The fact he’s building the trap for the other little girl too breaks my heart
Anthony Broadwater realises the Truth
I’m reading this book…this movie has haunted me so bad…I need to find the goodness in the book…it feels like I didn’t get any closure… and the book is giving me the details I needed😢
I know right? Sadly this happens so much in real life and families don’t get closure 😢
I remember watching this on Netflix a long time ago it's so sad. Such a masterpiece.
His body language after he realised that Jack knew was full of guilt. I think this is a contradiction to what you’d expect from a serial killer as they are usually psychopaths, thus inherently unable to feel such emotions as guilt or regret. Being a father myself, this scene gives me the chills every time I see it.
This scene is acted splendidly. The facial expressions from both actors really sold it. The subtle realization that he is the one who killed his daughter is intense and the realization from the killer that he may be caught.
This movie is very moving. All actors were incredible. The music was beautiful. I weep every time I have watched it.
Am sure this is the pain all the families of missing Children/individuals feel. The whisper, the uncertainty, the feeling of not knowing. What hardship. 😢😢 This movie had a lot of flaws, but to anyone who has lost a loved one can relate... especially the whole afterlife element.