I love how the vocal line (Nayeon, Jeongyeon and Jihyo) are supporting the other members.. i love how nayeon helped sana, and how jeongyeon tried to support jihyo in some of her parts... twice fighting
I'm not the biggest twice fan but I don't get why Jihyo gets hate for her singing. From this video it's clear that's she's able to sing her parts and to a pretty good standard.
Bc "she's from Twice" :/ + JYP doesn't emphasise on vocal technique but for Jihyo to be able to sing that well despite JYP's teaching of "half-air, half-sound" technique (which is a pretty bad technique for your voice) really is amazing.
Ocean Wave It's not that the technique is bad but I would say it doesn't suit everyone. For example, I think Sistar Soyou is perfect example of natural half-air half-sound singer. In Twice I believe only Mina and maybe Tzuyu has this type of voice.
Jihyo actually has really good singing technique and vocal support but her voice type is mezzo-soprano so it's harder for her to hit those higher notes compared to someone like Yuju who is a full lyric soprano. IMO she gets hate because she can't always hit her high notes that are outside of her vocal range but because she has the best technique and is the "power vocal" of the group she's the main vocalist and is given those notes.
I personally love Momo's voice. Even though it's a bit nasal, the parts that are given to her to sing, have been strategically chosen so that her voice sounds great and she gives it her all!
Well, people keep saying that why nayeon sing when it comes to others' part. Look at it cearly, you can see that she sings to support the member's voices. She lets jihyo and mina sing bc their voices are quite stable(tzuyu's voice is okay too but i think she forgot to sing), you can see that the rest lost confident when they sing alone, especially when the song is completely off vocal.
Bobo! You wont get scared of you think you can sing that well, you can prove to yourself that haters are wrong. So if youre scared before someone hates you, it means youre nothing to prove! Nation's Garbage Group indeed!
@@jeffersond.c.5464 garbage panga ikaw utak pagong, galingan mo muna sumayaw bago ka gumanyan ganyan awit na sayawan yan kpop tugtog tas step pang zumba
@@jeffersond.c.5464 Basically if someone gets bullied for their singing then they won't get sad? I wonder why bullying is such a big issue in schools and stuff. CAUSE IT LOWERS SOMEONE'S SELF CONFIDENCE YOU IDIOT! YOU ARE THE TOXIC AND GARBAGE PERSON IN THIS COMMENT SECTION
watching ICSM encores before watching this one makes me realize how the hate towards them really affect them and without onces' presence there (no audience's allowed), it made them less confident. all they could see now is hate, and i wish everyone will stop judging them based on only several bad encores out of many good encores. ICSM was out of their range especially, nayeon's. the others like mina, momo, dahyun, chaeyoung, why didnt they sing? imo i think bc theyre losing their confidence bit by bit. if u watch their previous encores y'all will realize how clear and stable their vocals are during encores. and yes, haters suck. please, i miss twice's old confidence. i would love to see twice enjoying the encore stages, but still singing bc they look genuinely happy. before a ICSM encore stage, nayeon had a speech and she looked like she was out of breath and almost faint. they look tired during ICSM encore. so note this; TWICE CAN SING LIVE, and their previous encore stages proof it; twice are losing their confidence (clearly) so i hope hate is going to stop and they can sing at the encores like they used to, AND ALSO JYP, pls give them songs that fit their range. i think ive written a pretty long paragraph, but anyways, STAN TWICE AND ONCES, KEEP SUPPORTING OUR QUEENS. they deserve the world and love as much as we can give them. i wanna hug them so bad and tell them that they've done a great job and we're proud of them. anyways, have a nice day 🍭
she's just trying to help the other members sing they part, because i think except nayeon, jihyo, jeongyeon, and mina, the other member isn't confident to sing they part
look how momo enjoyed herself here. But now because of the haters and hate comments now they only look so pressurized to hit every note perfectly. Back then they were singing so freely.
Some of them didn’t need her help though like we didn’t need to sing during Jeongyeon’s part or Sana they can both sing great on their own and it’s kinda not fair to the rappers when they can never do their parts in their own
Some members did good tho. This perf. Showed that jihyo had some super stable and powerful voice so with nayeons being stable. Other members like mina always had that unstable voice even before so its super normal to hear her voice crack, just hoping they'd improve more.! MORE TWICEFUL YEARRRRRR TO COME!
i must let you know signeul bonae shigneul bonae well the other group sing together and not only the VOCAL LINE who sing duh... even the vocal line sing just "fine"
0:20 Nayeon was wearing the pins in her hair.*green ones*.it was before blackpink debut.and they say that jennie is the trend trendsetter of them.correct me if iam wrong.becuase she wasnt the first one to wear them
Matt DB87 but in this encore the vocals are not great :)))) admit it rather than avoid it. For now they are just eye candies. Well hope in the future they will improve.
If you want to compare, I think its best to compare this with the original audio. I do think the vocal in this encore is not good especially when they don't have to dance at all. The voice is shaky and off tune in some parts :). But they r still young, couple of years and they will improve. I seriously didn't try to put any hate, just my 2 cent opinion :).
I just dont understand why Nayeon always save the other member.. She sing when its Sana,Momo etc part but when Jihyo or Mina are singing she keeps in silent.. then once trying to say they all singing live.. but where?? I need to hear all of their voice not only Nayeon..
The whole vibe was really different from the first win they won from Cheer Up. Then TT era was the time they start to embrace that they're going to get a lot of award. Plus, this is the only time I saw Mina dance "extrovertedly"😂😌
why does everyone so pissy about twice lipsyncing or "cant sing"? like does it really effect you? are you jealous they're more successful than your faves? lmao.
jeanne may urmaneta and so does other kpop idols what makes them different its not like they could keep singing live with those squeeze schedule try putting yourself on their shoes
![[예능연구소 직캠] 트와이스 왓 이즈 러브? 1위 앵콜 @쇼!음악중심_20180421 What is Love? TWICE in 4K](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QHqG0sl393Q/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MMF2016] Twice - TT, 트와이스 - TT, MBC Music Festival 20161231](/img/n.gif)
I love how the vocal line (Nayeon, Jeongyeon and Jihyo) are supporting the other members.. i love how nayeon helped sana, and how jeongyeon tried to support jihyo in some of her parts... twice fighting
Agree. Only Jeongyeon, Jihyo and Nayeon sing in the chorus part
sana is also stable
Nayeon Jihyo and Jungyeon are the best singers
Yeeees
true
Because that's the vocal line? I'm sorry if you didn't know then but they're supposed to be the best singers of TWICE
All of then are singers tho🥰
The problem is Jeongyeon barely get a line
I'm not the biggest twice fan but I don't get why Jihyo gets hate for her singing. From this video it's clear that's she's able to sing her parts and to a pretty good standard.
under standard
Bc "she's from Twice" :/ + JYP doesn't emphasise on vocal technique but for Jihyo to be able to sing that well despite JYP's teaching of "half-air, half-sound" technique (which is a pretty bad technique for your voice) really is amazing.
Ocean Wave It's not that the technique is bad but I would say it doesn't suit everyone. For example, I think Sistar Soyou is perfect example of natural half-air half-sound singer. In Twice I believe only Mina and maybe Tzuyu has this type of voice.
Jihyo actually has really good singing technique and vocal support but her voice type is mezzo-soprano so it's harder for her to hit those higher notes compared to someone like Yuju who is a full lyric soprano. IMO she gets hate because she can't always hit her high notes that are outside of her vocal range but because she has the best technique and is the "power vocal" of the group she's the main vocalist and is given those notes.
people say they cant SING? bruh the world’s definitely seen worse.
I personally love Momo's voice. Even though it's a bit nasal, the parts that are given to her to sing, have been strategically chosen so that her voice sounds great and she gives it her all!
Well, people keep saying that why nayeon sing when it comes to others' part. Look at it cearly, you can see that she sings to support the member's voices. She lets jihyo and mina sing bc their voices are quite stable(tzuyu's voice is okay too but i think she forgot to sing), you can see that the rest lost confident when they sing alone, especially when the song is completely off vocal.
2:14 i mean then why did she sing here lol i’m pretty sure jeongyeon can sing without support
@@maelat3703 yeah that was kinda annoying she kept doing that especially when they didn’t need her help
@@echouniverse I mean it's just an encore stage?
@@아리리추 I know but we want to hear each member on their own yk 👌
this is literally different from their encore now, they just enjoy themselves here but now they looked scared because of the hate comments
True🥺
Because now the song is much higher n harder
Bobo! You wont get scared of you think you can sing that well, you can prove to yourself that haters are wrong. So if youre scared before someone hates you, it means youre nothing to prove!
Nation's Garbage Group indeed!
@@jeffersond.c.5464 garbage panga ikaw utak pagong, galingan mo muna sumayaw bago ka gumanyan ganyan awit na sayawan yan kpop tugtog tas step pang zumba
@@jeffersond.c.5464 Basically if someone gets bullied for their singing then they won't get sad? I wonder why bullying is such a big issue in schools and stuff. CAUSE IT LOWERS SOMEONE'S SELF CONFIDENCE YOU IDIOT! YOU ARE THE TOXIC AND GARBAGE PERSON IN THIS COMMENT SECTION
can we talk about how hyper our bunny is? nayeon you are so adorable
3:38 Tzuyu seeing her baby for the first time hahaha her expression is so cute!
jihyo was stable
and Nayeon
Nayeon is undefeated. hahaha
omg nayeon at 4:02; 4:03 so damn cute 😍
Nayeon tried to do her high ad-lib but she cracked so mina burst out laughing 😂😂😂🥰🥰
3:49
So cute😂😂😂🥰🥰🥰
nayeon & jihyo's voice! 😍😍
I had a dream that one day im faster than haters coming through twice videos.
haha you're right
STAN GAYS yeah..lol
STAN GAYS Love your profil pic 😂
STAN GAYS 哈哈哈哈~~~！
nayeon's live so great!!
Nayeon's crack voice HAHAHAHA omygod!! I love you Nayeon!! 😍❤ TWICE!! ❤😍
For me I think nayeon can actually singing a whole song👍😘 a great lead vocalist👍
Nayeon is saving the day
i need an unnie like her :')
Jeongyeon and jihyo too :( they barely get recognition
those salty thrice must me crying while trying to prove that this isn't live :p
dicathy2 u think this is good live singing? AHAHAHA
Elvis YZhi poor u thrice, get a life bitch.. 😂😂😂
I think this is good live singing. Plus they are up there having fun, not trying to do a serious performance.
sure it's live but half of them aren't singing in the first place lol...
Sophia Jin lemme see you sing nigga
watching ICSM encores before watching this one makes me realize how the hate towards them really affect them and without onces' presence there (no audience's allowed), it made them less confident. all they could see now is hate, and i wish everyone will stop judging them based on only several bad encores out of many good encores. ICSM was out of their range especially, nayeon's. the others like mina, momo, dahyun, chaeyoung, why didnt they sing? imo i think bc theyre losing their confidence bit by bit. if u watch their previous encores y'all will realize how clear and stable their vocals are during encores. and yes, haters suck. please, i miss twice's old confidence. i would love to see twice enjoying the encore stages, but still singing bc they look genuinely happy. before a ICSM encore stage, nayeon had a speech and she looked like she was out of breath and almost faint. they look tired during ICSM encore. so note this; TWICE CAN SING LIVE, and their previous encore stages proof it; twice are losing their confidence (clearly) so i hope hate is going to stop and they can sing at the encores like they used to, AND ALSO JYP, pls give them songs that fit their range. i think ive written a pretty long paragraph, but anyways, STAN TWICE AND ONCES, KEEP SUPPORTING OUR QUEENS. they deserve the world and love as much as we can give them. i wanna hug them so bad and tell them that they've done a great job and we're proud of them.
anyways,
have a nice day 🍭
totally agreed with you
Have you heard cheer up encore? An amazing encore unable to be compared to icsm
@@TinZzzzE yepp, also knock knock, yes or yes, alcohol free, many more actually :)
basically nayeon sing the whole song
she's just trying to help the other members sing they part, because i think except nayeon, jihyo, jeongyeon, and mina, the other member isn't confident to sing they part
This is like one of my fav encore stage from them. Glad there is a full HQ version of it. xD
Mina's voice is so clear in here 😍😍😍 i miss my mina's voice liveee😍😍
whoa, what a fun encore. I cant help but love them now
Antis after watched this video: I'mma pretend im not saw this, let's go back to m&m encore.
Jihyo's vocal are everything
thier voices!! omo!! 😍😍😍
Mina's angelic voice
3:39 Tzuyu treats the trophy like a baby OMG! Let's make TWICE win more!!!
look how momo enjoyed herself here. But now because of the haters and hate comments now they only look so pressurized to hit every note perfectly. Back then they were singing so freely.
Mina was embarrass when she sing out of breath so Nayeon sing wrong purposely hahaha
Jeongyeon and Nayeon saving the day..they felt the others were insecure. They all can sing so well but they can be so nervous.
Some of them didn’t need her help though like we didn’t need to sing during Jeongyeon’s part or Sana they can both sing great on their own and it’s kinda not fair to the rappers when they can never do their parts in their own
Lmao deaf
I love how Nayeon support the other members
3Mix so stableeee
Some members did good tho. This perf. Showed that jihyo had some super stable and powerful voice so with nayeons being stable. Other members like mina always had that unstable voice even before so its super normal to hear her voice crack, just hoping they'd improve more.! MORE TWICEFUL YEARRRRRR TO COME!
This encore is a proof that TWICE isn't lip syncing 😏😏😏
yes they are
Jiha Azmee lols you sure?
any problem gurl? 😏
but mostly only the vocal line who sing 😏
i must let you know signeul bonae shigneul bonae well the other group sing together and not only the VOCAL LINE who sing duh... even the vocal line sing just "fine"
Jihyo’s runs omg😭
3:41 Moguri's Body roll
Mina reaction when she didn't hit the note lmao😂
What time?
@@jeansabroso694 start at 3:48. Both Nayeon's and Mina's voice cracked and they're laughing about it
0:59 cmon Nayeon XD
0:20 Nayeon was wearing the pins in her hair.*green ones*.it was before blackpink debut.and they say that jennie is the trend trendsetter of them.correct me if iam wrong.becuase she wasnt the first one to wear them
Mina confidence is everything ❤️
They should be more confident with their voices! Some of them look uncomfortable! C'min Twice! I know you can do it!
because of the haters thats why they are like that my poor babies
I WILL REMEMBER TODAY IS THE DAY TRUMP WON THE ELECTION CRIES*
SCAR lol cries with you!
shahad sha I mean its not as bad for me cause i dont live in the US but like i feel like ww3 is gonna start because of him
+SCAR I heard in CNN news that RUSSIA actually thinks that WW3 has already started -- Hence the cold war between US and RUSSIA..
Florence Doit OMO!! (OMG) really? O_O
Florence Doit haha and donald is trying to get close with russia but far with mexico
Are they imitating Dahyun's dance in TT mv?😂😂
happuy momoday i love you
Exactly 4 years ago..Today is Nov. 9, 2020..TWICE enjoy this encore than today..
because netizen critic twice😭
This needs to be seen by all the Thrice who are still saying Twice's vocals are bad. Twice's vocals are great!
Matt DB87 but in this encore the vocals are not great :)))) admit it rather than avoid it. For now they are just eye candies. Well hope in the future they will improve.
I honestly think they are. I guess people think differently about what are good vocals and what are not.
If you want to compare, I think its best to compare this with the original audio. I do think the vocal in this encore is not good especially when they don't have to dance at all. The voice is shaky and off tune in some parts :). But they r still young, couple of years and they will improve. I seriously didn't try to put any hate, just my 2 cent opinion :).
@@linhvo1790 I think you’re just deaf tbh 💀
@@linhvo1790 You are talking as if other female idols are of Mariah Carey's level. Most of them literally sound just like this in their encores.
This is the live ive been looking for... for mina's and nayeon part at the end.. 💝🔥😍
jihyo...vocal goalllssss♡♡♡♡♡
I wonder if the people that commented in this vid are still onces
Jeongyeon and Mina are the best
congratulations! Proud of you my girls! Philippines here!
David Gen dapat from the philippines pero oks na yan 😊
jihyo's vocals tho. damn sis
Pretty girl next to pretty girl next to pretty girl ❤️👑
They look more confident than recent encores they sound like heaven……they are talented but less confident these days
Minayeon so hyper hereeeee
Twice foreverr Love TWICE❤️
NAYEON
JEONGYEON
MOMO
SANA
JIHYO
MINA
DAHYUN
CHAEYOUNG
TZUYU
Nayeon Crack her voice at 3:49 HAHAHAHAHAH!
thats mina
i know thats mina. but nayeon sing also on that part. look at 3:52 jihyo and sana laugh at her,
@@toiletlove2712both mina and nayeon cracked their voice
Nayeon saves the day omg. 😂
they seem more enjoyable during their old stage encores than now
I just dont understand why Nayeon always save the other member.. She sing when its Sana,Momo etc part but when Jihyo or Mina are singing she keeps in silent.. then once trying to say they all singing live.. but where?? I need to hear all of their voice not only Nayeon..
takuya chanwoo bye 😂.
lol okay good you are careful tho
yes
takuya chanwoo watch music bank encore then, everyone sang there
have you seen the other encores? You just stick in this one..
i love you twiceee
3:48 what are you doing mina 😭🤣🤣🤣
That voice crack wass nayeon.. noth were singing but the crack came out when mina sto singing
I really love this encore stage! Good job Twice! 😘😍😘
TT no.1
Jihyo🎧😍😍
The whole vibe was really different from the first win they won from Cheer Up. Then TT era was the time they start to embrace that they're going to get a lot of award. Plus, this is the only time I saw Mina dance "extrovertedly"😂😌
They can sing live :) HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
TWICE IS TWICE.
[WORDSOFWISDOM]
#ONCEPH
Congratulations TWICE!!!!
wishing for a twice comeback where they can sing in their vocal ranges
They were literally better here. This is their best encore for me.
They are so cute haha
1:12 why are they like this Lmaoo I Stan crackheads
dahyuns just staring like its the only thing in the world thats precious
twice best girls
3:30 MINA 😂😂
and 3:50 XD
PlumPlumPia MiNayeon =))))
@@PlumPlumPiathats nayeon
Shuffle dance.❤
Mina's confident here 😥
Ji Hyo my Queen
I want all of their clothes/outfits!!!
why are all of the comments criticising/complementing their singing? Can't we just congratulate their win?
Mina, Sana Fighting ❤❤❤ Love you girls 😍😍😍 Momo too
I just became Once today. love them.
Nayeon was supporting the sub vocals(Sana, Momo, Tzuyu) duh. That's why they're called the SUB VOCALS tss
And when mina's line shes silent
Nayeon is so stable
She almost sing the whole song cause other members can't make their voices louder
😂😂😂😂😂😂
maybe it's like nayeon and jihyo can sing the whole song.
i miss this time:( they look so comfortable;))
Twice so good
not a fan but their songs are catchy af can't resist
1:12 OMD WHEN MINA DID THAT HIGH NOTE
I LOVE MINA'S FASHION SHOW SHOW LIVE OMY GOSHHHHHHHHHHHH
why does everyone so pissy about twice lipsyncing or "cant sing"? like does it really effect you? are you jealous they're more successful than your faves? lmao.
mahal ko kayo kahit sintunado kayo.
KAMENxRANGER lol 😂 Hahahahaha si Mina talaga e 😂
KAMENxRANGER haha love ko din sila kahit ganyan sila.
Maliban kay jihyo 😅😅😅
I wish it were the other members instead of Mina, Nayeon, and Jihyo lol.. i love twice but still
ナヨンってほんまに顔かわいいな、
Nayeon and jihyo
TWICE HAVE MANY LIP SYNC!!!
jeanne may urmaneta Have many lip sync? That does not even make sense lol
Huh?
jeanne may urmaneta and so does other kpop idols what makes them different its not like they could keep singing live with those squeeze schedule try putting yourself on their shoes
So?
My princessi I love you TWICE 😘😘😍
0:40 rowoon really been stand out, he can see perfectly wtout being bothered by people covering him to look at the front 😭😭🌌❤️
idk why people say they can't sing,, they sound plenty stable??