It would be more meaningful if the subs were separated into SSK, SSN/SSGN, and SSBN. SSKs are going to be the very quietest, much quieter than any SSNs.
I love the lack of comments from Americans on the Number 1 boat. Anything to do with one of these Swedish boats sinking a US Nuclear powered carrier during war games, then surfacing in the middle of the fleet 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
the way why the Gotland became so legend is the fact, that the Navy fully underestimated the capabilities of the Gotland... "cost efficient" means not less capable, this was the lesson the Swedish told the US Navy in a very obvious way. Well done, Sweden.
There will always be disagreement because every sub on the list can be quieter or noisier that any other on the list depending on the running configuration. Generally battery only is the quietest but speed and duration is the least. A nuclear sub on quiet running with very slow speeds of under 5 knots and passive nuclear reactor cooling can be just as quiet as a diesel electric on battery...and then only slightly noisier when switching to active reactor cooling and higher speeds.
A Chilean Scorpene class sunk "high value surface ships" during a US Navy drill too, and the class is known for ending drills without being detected. This channel is more and more bulshit every day. Oh, the Triomphant class is well known for radiating about 40 dB... A collision with the English equivalent happened once because they couldn't detect each other.
It is unlikely the Kilo story is true - recently a Chinese Kilo was detected at range by a Royal Navy Type 23 frigate - the Royal navy can detect this class. So the story is probably Russian misinformation.
@@XavierLeFrancais *_"the classic popular believing that an engine with moving parts is quieter than a reactor without moving parts....funny"_* Do you understand how a submarine works? Look, I'll give you a quick rundown. In a conventional, diesel electric submarine the diesels are only used on the surface to charge batteries and for surface running. Underwater, it runs on batteries and uses the electric motors. You couldn't run the diesels underwater because they'd use up all the air onboard and you'd still have to get rid of the exhaust gasses. On a nuclear submarine, the batteries are charged by a generator powered by a turbine that uses steam generated by the nuclear reactor. And that happens independently of whether it's running on the surface or not. So, you're probably wondering why the diesel electric is quieter. The fact is that the diesel electric can be completely silent, sitting on the bottom and making zero noise because nothing is running. The nuclear powered submarine can't do that because the pumps have to run continuously to cool the reactor. Both types of submarines use rafting but even then, there will be sound emissions from the nuclear boat.
@@thethirdman225 ...outside of the reactor...parts who are the same as for all kind energies: transmission of the energy produced to the alternator. So no difference on that level.
This must be either a Chinese or American channel. There's no mention of the Royal Navy's Astute class attack boats. They are acknowledged by their peers as the quietest boats going.
@@Mittelalterfreak93 Military capabilities are always manipulated to benefit those who are responsible for communicating them. Just like the hysteria of hypersonic missiles. Defense department wants resources to develop better missiles raise the warning bells. Another example I served on US submarines we never went anywhere as quietly as we could and we went several places where you would have thought we should have. Even many of the crew don’t realize the full capabilities of the equipment they use.
Not even close on this one. The Russian subs are so noisy they shouldn't be anywhere near this list. The US subs are better but still make more noise than other subs not on this list.
This video is diferent from other your video...not the flag not the country name so we must stay and watch entire video and dont lose a second to hear when you tell us from what country they are...
Pretty meaningless really. An SSK on battery is about as quite as it gets, on diesel about as noisy as it can get. The Astute class SSN is about as quite as it gets for an SSN and is about the best hunter killer of other SSN's out there.
@@jonny2954 as far as I know non magnetic hull isn’t main feature in about 90% of the subs being in service today. It’s quite expencive to have a non magnetic steel hull and even more to have a titanium one.
I agree. Kilo as the quietest SSK? nah, not even close. The list should be full of many great nation's diesel boats leaving no nuclear, but that's not fun for a video right?
@@briant5685 Russian Su 57 and China's J20 aircraft both claim stealth capability but aren't. Japan had to purchase aip systems, Sterling engines for their Soryu submarines from Saab, to improve stealth capacity, yes anything is possible, but highly unlikely. Thanks
ridiculous. yasen and seawolf are fighters, they are by definition better than strategists-virginif and ohio, they swim deeper, they are smaller, okay diesel-and they do not have turbines - but why write nonsense
Seawolf was quieter than most of these. Where do you get your intel and lay down your evidence? You can’t compare diesel , nuclear and hydrogen submarines.
@@XavierLeFrancais A nuclear reactor needs cooling 100% of the time, which means that, whether it's moving or not, the cooling pumps will always be running. A diesel electric can switch off completely and have no machinery running at all, rendering it completely silent.
@@thethirdman225 make a pump silent is much easier than an making an thermal explosion engine quiet. And witching off the engine means lose of manoeuvrability and speed (witch is tactically a drawback) beside you have a very shorter time & range before going to the surface just for oxygen...witch makes it highly repearable...nope a diesel sub is no match in capabilities for an nuke sub. Every SSBN in the world is nuke propulsion. That's not just an coincidence. It's just better.
@@XavierLeFrancais *_”make a pump silent is much easier than making an thermal explosion engine quiet.”_* How quiet you can make a pump is beside the point. You said nuclear boats don’t have moving parts. Now you’re saying pumps are quieter, implying that they do, indeed have moving parts. Apart from that, I’ve already told you, diesel electrics don’t use the diesels underwater. They can run for days without surfacing. Diesel electrics make muck quieter Hunter-killer subs than nuclear boats. Look up the adventures of the Australian submarine, HMAS Waller, which got into the baffles of a Los Angeles class sub off Hawaii and pinged the crap out of it. I’ve tried to give you the benefit of the doubt here but you’re making it difficult for me to remain polite.
The deadliest sub (and don’t recal him ever saying much so that counts for silence ) was David fairclough the super sub wow that’s going back a long way though I’m sure he was a Liverpool player I think It was so long ago though
The French 'Scorpene Class' Submarines is very Sikent
The Suffren is sad to have been forgotten.
Suffren was so quiet it was forgotten
@@jayvhoncalma3458 haha! but yes the suffren class to be forgotten is nonsense. one of the most advanced sub class in the world.
It would be more meaningful if the subs were separated into SSK, SSN/SSGN, and SSBN. SSKs are going to be the very quietest, much quieter than any SSNs.
It wasn't even a good attempt. It reminded me of those videos about fighters which present all their design specs and pick "the best" from that...
Clickbait. This video wants you to believe that they have classified data and performance specs on these submarines. I don't think so.
Very bias 🇬🇧 so going for the Astute. Have to say though, the Yasen M is looking like a kickass sub, especially once armed with Zircon!
Lada is like much more improved version of exported “Warsawianka”. More silent and more capable
French Baracuda Class Missing ......???
It's About quietest.
@@looser359
Yes, true, so, French Baracuda Class Missing ......???
Frenchbashing?
Yes, that’s why Aussies ditched it 😂😂😂
Boreis, Barracuda are missing!!
This video is super cool!
I love the lack of comments from Americans on the Number 1 boat.
Anything to do with one of these Swedish boats sinking a US Nuclear powered carrier during war games, then surfacing in the middle of the fleet 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I like this powerful submarines
What about the type 214?
They are just the exportversion of the type 212
@@KingElmo83And not as good. Afaik not from amagnetic steel
Astute is so quiet the U.S are unhappy the U.K. won't share their stealth coating technology.
the way why the Gotland became so legend is the fact, that the Navy fully underestimated the capabilities of the Gotland... "cost efficient" means not less capable, this was the lesson the Swedish told the US Navy in a very obvious way. Well done, Sweden.
Yassen class submarine also have pump jet.
The best and most quietest U-Boot is the German 212CD. 🖖👍😉
nice dream
I ❤️ russian subs like deltaclass,borirclass and typhoon class 😌❣️
Ya
@J. B. ❣️🇨🇳
Russian subs are the best.
Me too 😎🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@m84as17 mean 😎😎🚩
Nice videos
Amur class Submarines:
This Video was pretty old
There will always be disagreement because every sub on the list can be quieter or noisier that any other on the list depending on the running configuration. Generally battery only is the quietest but speed and duration is the least. A nuclear sub on quiet running with very slow speeds of under 5 knots and passive nuclear reactor cooling can be just as quiet as a diesel electric on battery...and then only slightly noisier when switching to active reactor cooling and higher speeds.
I like Ohio Class Submarines and Sea Wolf Class Submarines
👍👍👍👍
The walrus class is so quiet, this channel has not heard of it....😅
What about the Collins?
1st like and 1st comment
2th like and 2th comment
,🥈🥈🏆🎇🎆
Borei
Baracuda
Triomphant
Type 039
Yuan
Scorpion
Type 214
Where are they ????
It's Triomphant
@@shamanbhattacharyya9285 thanks
also no mention to the Walrus class submarine that sunk a US carrier and other vessels in a excersise like the Gotland class that is in the list.
A Chilean Scorpene class sunk "high value surface ships" during a US Navy drill too, and the class is known for ending drills without being detected. This channel is more and more bulshit every day. Oh, the Triomphant class is well known for radiating about 40 dB... A collision with the English equivalent happened once because they couldn't detect each other.
@@DarkDutch007 At least gotland is in the list
US Seawolf are most expensive and silent follow by Russian Borei, Yassen and UK Dreadnought class
Are french baracuda class submarine are not as good stealthy?
they are extremely stealthy.
Where is barracuda nuclear powered submarine.....??
🙊
Noisy
@@elpafishing Nope
It hasn't been built yet.
@@thethirdman225 wtf 😂.... Bro.... Sufferen class and baracuda class are same.... Just type "sufferen class" and search in wiki
Please indicate the country
2 view and comment
The most silent is the black hole kilo project 636.
Whose listening?
Dolphin class?
Are similar to type 212
Where is the reis class
It is unlikely the Kilo story is true - recently a Chinese Kilo was detected at range by a Royal Navy Type 23 frigate - the Royal navy can detect this class. So the story is probably Russian misinformation.
Sea wolf class ❤
Our Seawolf class subs are the quietest & most technologically advanced subs in the world.
Christ. Another one with a woody for the fu**ing Seawolf. It's a nuke. It will ALWAYS be noisier than a diesel electric.
@@thethirdman225 the classic popular believing that an engine with moving parts is quieter than a reactor without moving parts....funny
@@XavierLeFrancais
*_"the classic popular believing that an engine with moving parts is quieter than a reactor without moving parts....funny"_*
Do you understand how a submarine works?
Look, I'll give you a quick rundown. In a conventional, diesel electric submarine the diesels are only used on the surface to charge batteries and for surface running. Underwater, it runs on batteries and uses the electric motors. You couldn't run the diesels underwater because they'd use up all the air onboard and you'd still have to get rid of the exhaust gasses.
On a nuclear submarine, the batteries are charged by a generator powered by a turbine that uses steam generated by the nuclear reactor. And that happens independently of whether it's running on the surface or not.
So, you're probably wondering why the diesel electric is quieter. The fact is that the diesel electric can be completely silent, sitting on the bottom and making zero noise because nothing is running. The nuclear powered submarine can't do that because the pumps have to run continuously to cool the reactor.
Both types of submarines use rafting but even then, there will be sound emissions from the nuclear boat.
@@XavierLeFrancais Nuclear reactors _do_ have moving parts.
@@thethirdman225 ...outside of the reactor...parts who are the same as for all kind energies: transmission of the energy produced to the alternator. So no difference on that level.
This must be either a Chinese or American channel. There's no mention of the Royal Navy's Astute class attack boats. They are acknowledged by their peers as the quietest boats going.
It's in 3rd place.
Is anyone of the subs mentioned in vid used by indian navy???
No but there is one that going to be use by Pakistan 🇵🇰🦁🇵🇰🦁🇵🇰🦁🦁🇵🇰⚔️⚔️🔪🔪🐄🇮🇳🐄🇮🇳
@@PakistaniPunjabi always welcome Pakistan... Peace between india and pak
@@PakistaniPunjabi lmao
@ADITYA KUMAR murdabad hindustan murdabad hindustan Pakistan 🦁🇵🇰🇵🇰 zindabad
I don't understand why many countries reducing submarine length
Try manouvering a 150m long sub in coastal waters around e.g. the Baltic.
Where is the duck class?
They have no idea which are the quietest as at least US subs almost never run as silently as they can. Just so no one knows how quiet they are.
They are so silent they crash into things.
Rule of thumb: The known capabilities of military hardware are understated. Except for North Korea, then you have to reduce them by half.
@@Mittelalterfreak93 Military capabilities are always manipulated to benefit those who are responsible for communicating them. Just like the hysteria of hypersonic missiles. Defense department wants resources to develop better missiles raise the warning bells. Another example I served on US submarines we never went anywhere as quietly as we could and we went several places where you would have thought we should have. Even many of the crew don’t realize the full capabilities of the equipment they use.
SSNs will never be as quiet as SSKs.
By what metric do you rank these submarines? You're just guessing stuff. I could go off about what is and isn't but that's just wasting energy
you forget the dutch walrus class
bof....
Where is Triomphant class ? This list is bullshit
Not even close on this one. The Russian subs are so noisy they shouldn't be anywhere near this list. The US subs are better but still make more noise than other subs not on this list.
Country name.........
Victoria class is more quiet than all Nuclear powered subs on the list.
Ha Ha good one. They are absolutely quiet after decommissioning.
Gotland ftw.
95 db is very noisy
No French subs in the list ? Strange....
This video is diferent from other your video...not the flag not the country name so we must stay and watch entire video and dont lose a second to hear when you tell us from what country they are...
Pretty meaningless really. An SSK on battery is about as quite as it gets, on diesel about as noisy as it can get. The Astute class SSN is about as quite as it gets for an SSN and is about the best hunter killer of other SSN's out there.
Seawolf be like. Bruh
Type-214?
Are the exportversion of 212, just a different name
Αre you sure the 212 is second more stealthy? I think that 214 is even more stealthy than 212.
214 is a export model and lacks the too critical stuff.
@@jonny2954 of course it’s an export model. How could it not be? Can you be more specific about what it lacks?
@@Rousseau4469 Non-magnetic hull. And other classified technologies.
@@jonny2954 as far as I know non magnetic hull isn’t main feature in about 90% of the subs being in service today. It’s quite expencive to have a non magnetic steel hull and even more to have a titanium one.
The video is about how silent the submarines are, you’d think to put their decibels in the list of subs you continue to cut to. Low effort, bad video
Quiet subs are good and fine , until someone just pings.
……..and reveal their own presence and position 😳😳😳. Movies are not real life.
dont but this
😎😎😎
Outdated list, too many newer subs missing
I agree. Kilo as the quietest SSK? nah, not even close. The list should be full of many great nation's diesel boats leaving no nuclear, but that's not fun for a video right?
@@jasonmckay2769 true, this is far more exciting
Oml I hate this new feature with you tube honestly Add the dislike number back, btw I liked the video I'm just saying because it's annoying
Bias content!!??🤪
美國要不要我幫助研究核潛艇
No Chinese boats. Well, they are known to be noisy
ALL nuclear boats are noisy. Some are noisier than others.
Where is french barracuda class sub?? It's one of the best silent killer sub in the world
They are new that's probly why is didn't make the lists
It doesn't exist yet.
@@thethirdman225 lol, two subs already in the water. One already commissioned and the second one to be commissioned this year…
@@brunol-p_g8800 Says you over a year later.
@@thethirdman225 it was already in commission in the French Navy when you wrote your comment a year ago.
A212>Gotland
Are you saying that A212 is better than Gotland.
@@villejansson6871 Yeah
@@emhyrvaremreis4540 Bro the gotland sunk the ronald reagan.
@@villejansson6871You mean CVN-76?
@@emhyrvaremreis4540 huh
You missed Chinese Type39B Yuan class submarine
Nope
China, does not have stealth subs, they too noisy
@@Johnjohn-rr5dn their type 94 are going to be stealthy
@@briant5685 Russian Su 57 and China's J20 aircraft both claim stealth capability but aren't. Japan had to purchase aip systems, Sterling engines for their Soryu submarines from Saab, to improve stealth capacity, yes anything is possible, but highly unlikely. Thanks
This seems like a Chinese phishing operation for loose lips. Snippets of facts but poor assessment.
ships miles fröm $höre v v
ridiculous. yasen and seawolf are fighters, they are by definition better than strategists-virginif and ohio, they swim deeper, they are smaller, okay diesel-and they do not have turbines - but why write nonsense
Russian subs are the best in the world.
No chance.. British astute class is better than any hunter killer sub Russia has got
This video is not about the best submarine, it's about the most silent one.
Are they fuck there cheap poorly designed obsolete tech loud they wouldn’t last 2 mins in A real war
Seawolf was quieter than most of these. Where do you get your intel and lay down your evidence? You can’t compare diesel , nuclear and hydrogen submarines.
It's not quieter than a diesel electric and never will be.
@@thethirdman225 with an engine in the sub with moving parts making a lot of noise....sure....
@@XavierLeFrancais A nuclear reactor needs cooling 100% of the time, which means that, whether it's moving or not, the cooling pumps will always be running. A diesel electric can switch off completely and have no machinery running at all, rendering it completely silent.
@@thethirdman225 make a pump silent is much easier than an making an thermal explosion engine quiet. And witching off the engine means lose of manoeuvrability and speed (witch is tactically a drawback) beside you have a very shorter time & range before going to the surface just for oxygen...witch makes it highly repearable...nope a diesel sub is no match in capabilities for an nuke sub. Every SSBN in the world is nuke propulsion. That's not just an coincidence. It's just better.
@@XavierLeFrancais
*_”make a pump silent is much easier than making an thermal explosion engine quiet.”_*
How quiet you can make a pump is beside the point. You said nuclear boats don’t have moving parts. Now you’re saying pumps are quieter, implying that they do, indeed have moving parts. Apart from that, I’ve already told you, diesel electrics don’t use the diesels underwater. They can run for days without surfacing. Diesel electrics make muck quieter Hunter-killer subs than nuclear boats. Look up the adventures of the Australian submarine, HMAS Waller, which got into the baffles of a Los Angeles class sub off Hawaii and pinged the crap out of it.
I’ve tried to give you the benefit of the doubt here but you’re making it difficult for me to remain polite.
Is the Gotland class here?
The deadliest sub (and don’t recal him ever saying much so that counts for silence ) was David fairclough the super sub wow that’s going back a long way though I’m sure he was a Liverpool player I think It was so long ago though
Where's the Aussie Collins class sub?
It's wank marra. But you will soon have some badass kit. In my honest opinion you're government should try buy both subs offered
Since such infos are classified, how can they be of public domain ? 😁
S 80 ??????
Thanks.
American sonarman said that improved kilo is too silent and they find her presence by absence of natural ocean sound.
That's a common tactic: using holes in the back scatter to detect a submarine.