Agreed. Not to mention he also did what the original Rusty to the Boulder and subsequent remakes (as far as I know) didn't: making Thumper an actual character, not just a machine with a face. Seriously, you could have had Thumper be a generic faceless machine (or even get rid of him and replace with with workmen drilling) from the original story and there'd be no difference whatsoever.
Maybe Rusty and The Boulder was unrealistic, But unlike Thomas The Jet Engine, RaTB had so much seriousness in it. At no point did they take TTJE seriously, and I guess it’s because Britt Alcroft had returned from Us and TATMR, this Mitton could no longer make Thomas more serious.
Interesting take on 'Rusty & the Boulder'. I liked how you gave other characters parts to play and Thumper some speaking roles. Plus the way you brought the accident into the scene was a big surprise. Well done :) .
This was a nice realistic take on one of the show's most unrealistic episodes. Having the boulder simply roll down the incline makes much more sense than having it roll all across the railway. And I like that the boulder was just left where it landed instead of being moved to a hill near the line - that was just a recipe for disaster, as your two Boulder episodes from TEOS season 5 proved!
I missed the premiere, but I'll say this. I don't know how you did it, but you made one of the best episodes in the show even better and more realistic! This was an amazing video, and I can't wait to see what you'll adapt next.
Rusty and the boulder is my favorite episode of season 5! I love your RWS style adaptation of the story especially the Boulder which is my favorite part of the story! ❤❤❤❤
As much as I love the chaotic nature of rusty and the boulder I always did find it weird that the Boulder was able to travel so far in the actual episode. Even if you believe the theory that the Boulder was possessed and actively trying to demolish the construction disturbing its land, how would it have gotten through any of the tunnels on the railway?
This is an amazing remake that not only gives the story more realism but can provide continuity to how the Blue Mountain Quarry was constructed and how it could've fit into the RWS if Christopher or Wilbert made one more book!
This is a good little RWS style take on this episode. Sure the boulder's "Rock and Roll" rampage is short, but it's terrifying to see a boulder like this coming at you. You did a good job here. Especially in the new trainz game that you're using for future Trainz related video. Well done!
Hey Thomas1! Thanks for all these videos you've made over the years. I'd say 3 times over they've kept me smiling in probably the hardest times of my life. This ones no different with the pandemic and a flunked year in university. You may or may not know this, but your content actually helps people in some capacity. PS: if I were to throw any ideas around I'd suggest a continuation of NWR origins only of the Skarloey railway.
this was released a day after my birthday which is may 9th, idk why i just found this interesting Love this video, keep it up with these rws style adaptions
@@a.r.productions I remember it on discovery kids since u was born Un 2002 to 2005. This episode was shown in 2002, 2003 and 2005 along with All At Sea And Bye George!. The channel shows the episodes in wrong order (But not in the new series and cgi).
Rusty and the Boulder was always a top favorite Season 5 episode. I really liked Thumper so much, i was over the moon when i got the ERTL Thumper one Christmas. I love the episode, it was actually the first episode i watched when i started watching again. This more realistic Adaptation was superb!
1:28 peter Sam: HEY! narrator: peter Sam was so lurched up by what he just heard he flew right at his friend, (he smashes into some wooden stacks) but missed & crashed into a large delivery of planks Peter sam: (snaps) You said you would help me live this down , I was nearly relegated to spare engine until I can learn to be patient!
Great Job I love it Rusty and The boulder is my one of my favorite Episodes in the Classic Series the Ending give Goosebumps every time can you Toby And The Floor Next
I have a question do you do more NWR Origins videos but instead of Northwestern engines can you do origin videos for the skarloey and mid Sodor Railway please
If you ever consider make a 3rd season for NWR Origins The character's I would want to see is Spencer, Deisel, Deisel 10 and Phill Bogaston (Diesel 10 and Phill Bogaston before death)
I’d also like RWS adaptions of snow, cranky bugs, James and the trouble with trees, lady hatts birthday party, Gordon and the gremlin, bye George, baa, put upon Percy, something in the air, Thomas speech and the old slow coach, Thomas and the rumors, sir Topham hatts holiday, make someone happy,
The fact that you made realistic versions of Rusty & the Boulder and Thomas & the Jet Engine, the 2 most unrealistic episodes in the show, astounds me
Agreed. Not to mention he also did what the original Rusty to the Boulder and subsequent remakes (as far as I know) didn't: making Thumper an actual character, not just a machine with a face. Seriously, you could have had Thumper be a generic faceless machine (or even get rid of him and replace with with workmen drilling) from the original story and there'd be no difference whatsoever.
@@TheKingOfPoop123 yeah I love that, Thumper deserves to be given more of a personality. T1E2H3 was thinking 2 steps ahead like he always does
@Jon Aschenbrenner ooh I’ll need to check that out, it sounds awesome
Maybe Rusty and The Boulder was unrealistic, But unlike Thomas The Jet Engine, RaTB had so much seriousness in it. At no point did they take TTJE seriously, and I guess it’s because Britt Alcroft had returned from Us and TATMR, this Mitton could no longer make Thomas more serious.
This was extremely well directed and well written. Another phenomenal adaptation mate.
Interesting take on 'Rusty & the Boulder'. I liked how you gave other characters parts to play and Thumper some speaking roles. Plus the way you brought the accident into the scene was a big surprise. Well done :) .
This was a nice realistic take on one of the show's most unrealistic episodes. Having the boulder simply roll down the incline makes much more sense than having it roll all across the railway. And I like that the boulder was just left where it landed instead of being moved to a hill near the line - that was just a recipe for disaster, as your two Boulder episodes from TEOS season 5 proved!
though I wish it was still perfectly round.
I am looking forward to an expanded adaptation of “bye, George” made by you.
@Jason Sembrano Dude if T1E2H3 can make 2 better ghost stories than Timothy ever will be then he could definitely handle an Anti-Railway Steam Roller.
@@ToQ_Ichigo Ehhhh Night express to Vicarstown is just a Good Jumpscare.
The Timothy Trilogy is just better written.
@@Nephalem2002 It really wasn’t. But alright.
Rusty and the boulder has always been such a BOLD story, I think it’s the closest we’ve got to Indiana Jones lmao; can’t wait to see this
Yet it has way more seriousness in it than Indiana Jones. Its way more spirital as well.
“bold”
No its even BOULDER
That pun tho
I missed the premiere, but I'll say this.
I don't know how you did it, but you made one of the best episodes in the show even better and more realistic! This was an amazing video, and I can't wait to see what you'll adapt next.
You really proved that this episode can be canon in the Railway Series lore!! I'm thoroughly impressed!!
Rusty and the boulder is my favorite episode of season 5! I love your RWS style adaptation of the story especially the Boulder which is my favorite part of the story! ❤❤❤❤
As much as I love the chaotic nature of rusty and the boulder I always did find it weird that the Boulder was able to travel so far in the actual episode. Even if you believe the theory that the Boulder was possessed and actively trying to demolish the construction disturbing its land, how would it have gotten through any of the tunnels on the railway?
I like how straight to the point this was compared to the over exaggerated action in the TVS version. Great video
This is absolutely stunning. You just keep getting better and better. Keep up the good work.
This is an amazing remake that not only gives the story more realism but can provide continuity to how the Blue Mountain Quarry was constructed and how it could've fit into the RWS if Christopher or Wilbert made one more book!
Now that you mention it, this would explain why they relocated to the Blue Mountain Quarry.
This is a good little RWS style take on this episode. Sure the boulder's "Rock and Roll" rampage is short, but it's terrifying to see a boulder like this coming at you. You did a good job here. Especially in the new trainz game that you're using for future Trainz related video. Well done!
I like the episodes you did with boulder in The Engine of Sodor stories, I couldn't stop watching it over and over
I love this story! Absolutely amazing. Excellent work
Hey Thomas1! Thanks for all these videos you've made over the years. I'd say 3 times over they've kept me smiling in probably the hardest times of my life. This ones no different with the pandemic and a flunked year in university. You may or may not know this, but your content actually helps people in some capacity.
PS: if I were to throw any ideas around I'd suggest a continuation of NWR origins only of the Skarloey railway.
I really liked this one. Keep up the great work!!
I like how this is longer than the actual episode.
this was released a day after my birthday which is may 9th, idk why i just found this interesting
Love this video, keep it up with these rws style adaptions
You should do a version of Thomas, Percy and the Dragon in the style of an RSW story. Like how Wilber Awdry would have written it
kinnda already did that
th-cam.com/video/x96n79zk9HM/w-d-xo.html
I agree. It's like a sequel to Ghost Train.
"Railseries way." Sounds cool.
@@evelynjiles22 oh my God I love your videos
No you should do a Season 8-24 RWS styled episodes I hate the Classics
great job as always, this is one of my favourite episodes in thomas and friends!
This brings me back Season 4 vibes, This is how to make Thomas great
This makes SO MUCH sense than the original episode!
I love how Boulder is portrait here as a gigant Rock in the Mountains perfect
I look forward to seeing how this will be pulled off. It must have been quite difficult to adapt this in the same way Awdry would have written it.
That was a really good adaptation!
I'm looking forward to seeing Railway Series adaptations of "Something In The Air", "James and the Trouble with Trees" and "Busy Going Backwards".
Such an awesome take on the story really enjoyed it great work good sir
We should have left this part of the island... ALONE.
Most chilling line from Alec Baldwin. I love how you tried to re create the effect.
When I was little I never understood that.
@@andresmarcelojaralerner3326
Same with me as I grew older I began to appreciate it. Ahh the beauty of classic Thomas :D
@@a.r.productions I remember it on discovery kids since u was born Un 2002 to 2005. This episode was shown in 2002, 2003 and 2005 along with All At Sea And Bye George!. The channel shows the episodes in wrong order (But not in the new series and cgi).
@@a.r.productions This remake had to incluye the fat controller instead of mr percival because mr percvial arrived on season 9.
Now that was very good! Had me at the edge on my seat there.
As a massive thumper fan: I approve wholeheartedly
Yes
Nice video. T1E2H3, you are quite creative. I remember the series’s episode and it was so funny. It was released in 1998, the same year I was born.
"Rusty and the Boulder can't work in the RWS."
T1E2H3: "Hold my Trainz."
Rusty and the Boulder was always a top favorite Season 5 episode. I really liked Thumper so much, i was over the moon when i got the ERTL Thumper one Christmas. I love the episode, it was actually the first episode i watched when i started watching again. This more realistic Adaptation was superb!
Awesome job man!
This is both better than the lazy models of the fat controller being in charge and the scooby doo boulder nonsense in the TVS.
Yeah
That explosion was banging
Can't wait for another excellent video!
Nice adaption. Keep up the good work. 👍
This is how you write a good Thomas episode
Yoooooo that thumper looks great
I enjoy the way you make all your video
I loved this!
One of my favorite episodes from Season 5! YES!!!
Nice one it really would have been cool to see as a Rws story.
Great job 👍
Yes you're back
Extremely well rewritten.
Excellent adaptation!
This was changed a bit in the TV adaptation, I liked the TV one more, but this is fine, you have my like T1E2H3
I used to have a Thomas wooden railway set of rusty and the boulder based from an episode
to me like that.
In short, we should have left this part of the island...alone.
Awesome video mate, best wishes. 👍🏻
I'm looking forward to your extended version of Put Upon Percy as well as James and the Trouble with Trees.
absolutely chilling!
I'm so excited!
Nice work on your own version of this story
Nice new editing
wait a minute that none of big boulder I don't think he's going to circle and any ball too
It looks great!
What message the bolder is trying to give Mr Percival and his engines
Great work.
Man, This Does Feel Like A Wilbert Awdry Written Story
A fantastic adaption of the original story, somehow I feel it’s better than the way the show did it. Much more contained and well, believable.
3:48
Duncan: (sobs) no, it’s my fault.
If I’d believe rusty from the start I wouldn’t have got thumper into trouble
As one big video for this year, can you rank every season in Thomas? (Or every season in the classic era if that is too much)
You finally posted a trainz thing again!
Nice video!
I think you did a good job, remaking the story.
1:28
peter Sam: HEY!
narrator: peter Sam was so lurched up by what he just heard he flew right at his friend,
(he smashes into some wooden stacks) but missed & crashed into a large delivery of planks
Peter sam: (snaps) You said you would help me live this down , I was nearly relegated to spare engine until I can learn to be patient!
Nice video. And I also do videos on Mac. And I’m guessing you used IMovie for editing, because I use IMovie to.
Great Job I love it Rusty and The boulder is my one of my favorite Episodes in the Classic Series the Ending give Goosebumps every time can you Toby And The Floor Next
If only Rusty would have the black design in the TV series.
And if it happen
The orange looks better
Amazing video and when did sir topen hat son start looking after the railway
Funny thing is I was listening too Narrow Gauge Horror Audio version of this story...
I really like this video, can I ask you haw do you make these videos?
Noice work :3
I'm gonna miss it. I'm sorry, but I'm sure it will be great!
I hope you don't mind but I'm going to have “more branch line engines” as part of my stories
Nice Job
The Bristol Aeroplane company limited
3:54 grid
3:55 grid
K I'm wondering how many deaths will be featured in this
3:10 Wow, those falling rocks look so real! How did you do it?
I wonder is if the viaduct would actually collapse like you said in your real injury or death on Sodor video.
ok so i want to know how to import rolling stoke like the ecperace choaches is trainz
I remember this episode
Can you do Top 10 Classic Series Songs
If only thumper had a speaking role in future series or maybe some reference to this episode
Oh so this is why the skarloey engines moved to the BMQ
you can fix the green wheels and face issue by downloading the new versions of the ng engines from wildnorwester's deviant art
I have a question do you do more NWR Origins videos but instead of Northwestern engines can you do origin videos for the skarloey and mid Sodor Railway please
Please do a Middle Engine rewrite
this seems very likely if rusty and the boulder was in rws
I have a good idea
A prequel series to the engines of sodor
Like we get to see the events with Phil bogasten and the other stuff
Good Job With The Video.
Am I the only one who thinks Rusty's scared/concerned face in this, looks like a Paul's Vids Shed 17 styled face.
If you ever consider make a 3rd season for NWR Origins The character's I would want to see is Spencer, Deisel, Deisel 10 and Phill Bogaston (Diesel 10 and Phill Bogaston before death)
He said he wouldn’t make a next season, and he would only make origins of charecters who appeared in the rws and only engines
Thomas1Edward2Henry3 can you upload James and the trouble with trees (adaptation)?
I’d also like RWS adaptions of snow, cranky bugs, James and the trouble with trees, lady hatts birthday party, Gordon and the gremlin, bye George, baa, put upon Percy, something in the air, Thomas speech and the old slow coach, Thomas and the rumors, sir Topham hatts holiday, make someone happy,