Update from original comment:"Fake" “She Loves You", was recorded on July 1st 1963. Most of these ersatz stereo recordings, are a combination of that date, along with February 1964 (Paris) ,when they recorded "She Liebe Dich" in typical Beatles stereo at that time, with one side vocals and the other the instrumental. So obviously the vocals in German have been opted out out for the English vocals. Easy enough to do; and to be honest, sometimes I really like it Rick Bloom (Drums/Vocals)
Fab listeners! This is the '63 British smash hit Beatles recording, "She Loves You," in the right speaker, and the backing track of the January '64 recording of "Sie Lieb Dich," the German version, also recorded by the Beatles, in the left speakers. The "Yeah Yeah Yeah" from the German version is in each of the refrains as well. It's all there in the left speaker, from the far more "dry" sound of George's guitar and his more prominent voice in the "Yeah, Yeah, Yeahs," to Ringo's fills and splash cymbal at at the top of the song and again at 1:05, to George's slightly different descending guitar pattern in between "with a love like that, you know you should be glad" the two times he plays it during the coda. (In the hit version, he plays the descending notes - G, F# E - straight, and in the German version, he syncopates it a bit, probably to make it interesting since the band recorded "She Loves You" within a week of writing it, and by January '64 they had all played it a zillion times.) Clever, interesting mashup, but...not the long-lost stereo version of the '63 "She Loves You."
Josh Max I know my Beatles but only somebody like yourself and BFHeroes Bulgaria who obviously done their research know what they are talking about and hats off to both of you and all other Beatle historians
Josh Max As far as "She Loves You" / "Sie Liebt Dich" synch-ups go, this is the best I've heard so far, because the two channels don't drift out of time with each other -- thanks to modern digital editing, that can be fixed. But one thing that can't be fixed is hearing the echo of the German vocals in the background. To fix that, you would need some pretty advanced processing to filter out the German echo and then to artificially recreate echo of the English vocals.
apparently someone is claiming that the backing track for Sie Liebt Dich is the same backing track used for She Loves You. That person is defending that premise so strongly.
@@vwestlife -- I honestly can't hear the German vocals at all, so i guess they did a pretty good job. And i'm listening on an expensive pair of Grado cans.
AGREED! There are a couple issues with this version, but still much preferable to the Giles mix. If he could combine the techniques used here, with the AI technology demixing, and software to keep everything on beat and in sync, he should be able to do something totally stellar.
Quite easy to do, just cobble together the Mono/fake Stereo version with the right channel of the german sung version of that song, re-recorded on a new twin track master in France in January 1964. As the latter was a totally new recorded master, both recordings won't quite fit on top of each other in certain parts, hence the slight delays from time to time, but with the right editing tools and a good liquid audio software you can easily re-create a stereo mix from these. There is no original STEREO or TWIN TRACK mastertape of this song, it has been erased after the mono master-mix for the single had been done in 1963. The only TWIN TRACK master that still exists at the EMI archive is the newly recorded german vocals & instrumental backing track tape that was done in Paris at the PATHÉ-EMI Studios in January 1964 for the German single (that was mono) and the much later released version of this song in its original TWIN TRACK STEREO mix.
Wow, pretty darn good! For a minute there, I almost believed you had the lost stereo track. It sounds like you took the released mono version and created 2 tracks. On one of the tracks you used some software to remove the vocals and put that track on the right and the maybe some mid frequency filters to punch up the vocals on the track on the left. Still sounds good though. Definitely better than the english/german combo deals.
Billboard Top 100 Hits of 1964 has a true stereo mix. I've tried posting it a few times but it keeps being flagged. It's definitely not a sync-up, and definitely jives with other Beatles stereo mixes of the day.
Fooser Tom Considering the time frame, does that mean that Billboard mix (which obviously I've never heard) have vocals on one track/channel and the instrumentation on the other, with a bit of leakage? This particular post we're commenting on is one of the better paste-ups I've ever heard, but I'd certainly be curious to hear those tracks isolated...well, I guess it's something for me to track down...thanks for the info (and tease)
Why don't they just get Ringo and Paul to get into the studio, and have them record new Drum/Bass parts? Once the parts are recorded, they can fuse them together with the Mono mix, with the new parts on the left channel and the Mono on the right. It would take minimal effort, and god knows they could milk the fuck out of it with a DVD release documenting how it was done and so forth.
Ok, I've been listening to this again and I'm beginning to believe you may have the real thing or worked this in Pro Tools. What is the story? Can you give me a high quality MP3?
Giant Paul here plays with his thumb on She Loves you and all the other videos he uses a pick and he's the size of George not 6 inches taller. Who is this Man?
Hi BF Heroes of Bulgaria, I've been collecting Beatles records since I bought my first copy of the Canadian Love Me Do and discovered it was slower and missing the tambourine. Now I will agree with the majority that a true stereo mix of this song has never been put out and all those on youtube are well constructed from 2 different recordings. However, that touted fairytale of stolen or erased tapes is pure poppy cock. EMI throws nothing away. That line was created to quash any public feedback. For years it was believed that How Do You Do It was lost, then all of a sudden, there it was. Then it was said that the Ringo version of Love Me Do on the Past Masters was derived from a pristine vinyl source. I have a German single and a German EP both with Ringo's version. There is also a Brazilian EP with that version. If EMI had REALLY discarded the master, they could have borrowed one from one of their subsidiaries. Bottom line is they still have the tapes and when they are ready they will issue it. Anyone that believes those repeated lies, I have a roller skate key for sale. Someone once said, "The bigger the lie, the more people will believe it" How True!.
***** My cousin's friend's flatmate insists that her uncle was the janitor for EMI who heisted the two-track master tape, but then subsequently lost it in a card game during an evening's drunken revelry.
Classic Junk Well, my friend's aunt's grandfather's dog, who once shat on EMI's doorstep, intimated through a series of coordinated barks interpreted by Jeremy Paxman that she'd heard the story was complete rubbish. The two-track SLY master was likely inadvertently recorded over, as many associated with EMI contend.
Here Paul is taller then George and he plays his Hofner with his thumb. Other Videos he's the same height as George playing the same song with a pick. The Beatles were a Brand Name for a Musical Group that had many Different people playing them. How many people? Only their controllers know. Is Paul today Paul? He has been Paul longer then the rest of them. Is the real Paul the guy we first saw on Ed Sullivan. No. He was just one and two of the. Many people were Paul in the early years because there were so many musicians around at that time in England. Let's see if we can fool the people and change the Band Mates on multiple occasions. They did fool most of us. Now all we have to do is find out which person was who and when. Makes for a great story that we will probably never know the whole Shabang. I'd rather have it like it was for nearly 60 years of life, but there are too many strange things about the Greatest Music Group of all time. Paul was like stretch Armstrong. 5'8'' Small Paul. 6'2" Tall Paul. One thing. Whom ever was Paul was a Fantastic Bass Player and deserves the right to be called one of the greatest.
Fake, how? No stereo master currently exists, so of course it's going to be "fake." Any Beatles fan that's looking at this video knows that. This was created by a true Beatles fan to try to fix that gap of not having an original stereo version. You think you're jumping in here and slapping some knowledge on unsuspecting fans? Dumbass. We already know all this.
Still the Very Best early Beatles song, in my opinion. I loved it at age 13, And I still rate it no. 1.
Update from original comment:"Fake"
“She Loves You", was recorded on July 1st 1963. Most of these ersatz stereo recordings, are a combination of that date, along with February 1964 (Paris) ,when they recorded "She Liebe Dich" in typical Beatles stereo at that time, with one side vocals and the other the instrumental. So obviously the vocals in German have been opted out out for the English vocals. Easy enough to do; and to be honest, sometimes I really like it
Rick Bloom (Drums/Vocals)
Happy birthday, 🎂 dear Mr.John Lennon!!!
Has to be the greatest 3 minute pop single ever!! (IMHO)
Fab listeners!
This is the '63 British smash hit Beatles recording, "She Loves You," in the right speaker, and the backing track of the January '64 recording of "Sie Lieb Dich," the German version, also recorded by the Beatles, in the left speakers. The "Yeah Yeah Yeah" from the German version is in each of the refrains as well.
It's all there in the left speaker, from the far more "dry" sound of George's guitar and his more prominent voice in the "Yeah, Yeah, Yeahs," to Ringo's fills and splash cymbal at at the top of the song and again at 1:05, to George's slightly different descending guitar pattern in between "with a love like that, you know you should be glad" the two times he plays it during the coda. (In the hit version, he plays the descending notes - G, F# E - straight, and in the German version, he syncopates it a bit, probably to make it interesting since the band recorded "She Loves You" within a week of writing it, and by January '64 they had all played it a zillion times.)
Clever, interesting mashup, but...not the long-lost stereo version of the '63 "She Loves You."
Josh Max I know my Beatles but only somebody like yourself and BFHeroes Bulgaria who obviously done their research know what they are talking about and hats off to both of you and all other Beatle historians
Josh Max As far as "She Loves You" / "Sie Liebt Dich" synch-ups go, this is the best I've heard so far, because the two channels don't drift out of time with each other -- thanks to modern digital editing, that can be fixed. But one thing that can't be fixed is hearing the echo of the German vocals in the background. To fix that, you would need some pretty advanced processing to filter out the German echo and then to artificially recreate echo of the English vocals.
apparently someone is claiming that the backing track for Sie Liebt Dich is the same backing track used for She Loves You. That person is defending that premise so strongly.
@@vwestlife -- I honestly can't hear the German vocals at all, so i guess they did a pretty good job. And i'm listening on an expensive pair of Grado cans.
Much better than the 2023 mix version. Sounds way truer stereo. Tell Giles to learn from this video.
AGREED! There are a couple issues with this version, but still much preferable to the Giles mix. If he could combine the techniques used here, with the AI technology demixing, and software to keep everything on beat and in sync, he should be able to do something totally stellar.
Excellent!
sounds great
cool
Quite easy to do, just cobble together the Mono/fake Stereo version with the right channel of the german sung version of that song, re-recorded on a new twin track master in France in January 1964. As the latter was a totally new recorded master, both recordings won't quite fit on top of each other in certain parts, hence the slight delays from time to time, but with the right editing tools and a good liquid audio software you can easily re-create a stereo mix from these. There is no original STEREO or TWIN TRACK mastertape of this song, it has been erased after the mono master-mix for the single had been done in 1963. The only TWIN TRACK master that still exists at the EMI archive is the newly recorded german vocals & instrumental backing track tape that was done in Paris at the PATHÉ-EMI Studios in January 1964 for the German single (that was mono) and the much later released version of this song in its original TWIN TRACK STEREO mix.
A melhor banda do mundo
Uau...a cada producao voce se supera.gratíssima pelos sonssss🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉😊
The very original Beatles boys❤
WONDERFUL VIDEO WITH THE BEATLES HD IMAGES AND GOOD SOUND QUALITY
#video #beatles #youtube #beatlemania #HD #shelovesyou
Love this song
Good job
Wow, pretty darn good! For a minute there, I almost believed you had the lost stereo track. It sounds like you took the released mono version and created 2 tracks. On one of the tracks you used some software to remove the vocals and put that track on the right and the maybe some mid frequency filters to punch up the vocals on the track on the left. Still sounds good though. Definitely better than the english/german combo deals.
Amadisimos beatles!
nice
Best boy band world ever John a genius
This my friend I cannot tell you! :)
This mash-up is pretty good. Sounds a lot better than Giles Martin's new AI assisted remix.
Show
Billboard Top 100 Hits of 1964 has a true stereo mix. I've tried posting it a few times but it keeps being flagged. It's definitely not a sync-up, and definitely jives with other Beatles stereo mixes of the day.
Fooser Tom Considering the time frame, does that mean that Billboard mix (which obviously I've never heard) have vocals on one track/channel and the instrumentation on the other, with a bit of leakage? This particular post we're commenting on is one of the better paste-ups I've ever heard, but I'd certainly be curious to hear those tracks isolated...well, I guess it's something for me to track down...thanks for the info (and tease)
This claim is 100% false. Please post your evidence that this mysterious true stereo mix exists.
Лучше, чем ничего...
Это Самое лучшее! ;)
Queria muito saber o nome deste cantor.... fiquei impressionada com a sua voz.... mas está difícil de achar o nome dele pois não sei coreano.
Nothing more to say ...Paul's Left hand is so Exciting !!!!!!!!!!
Paul was only about 5'8" in this year. Small Paul. But wait. Look he's a giant. Who is this Paul?
Doesn't sound bad though, even if we're never ever getting a TRUE stereo version of the original recording we can at least pretend like this is one :P
Mono is the shit
Why don't they just get Ringo and Paul to get into the studio, and have them record new Drum/Bass parts? Once the parts are recorded, they can fuse them together with the Mono mix, with the new parts on the left channel and the Mono on the right. It would take minimal effort, and god knows they could milk the fuck out of it with a DVD release documenting how it was done and so forth.
electronically channelled stereo
Nope!
Ok, I've been listening to this again and I'm beginning to believe you may have the real thing or worked this in Pro Tools. What is the story? Can you give me a high quality MP3?
sounds too fast-- and i've heard this song a zillion times since 1964
wjm41259 It does sound a little watered-down.
wjm41259 This version is playing about 2% too fast.
Giant Paul here plays with his thumb on She Loves you and all the other videos he uses a pick and he's the size of George not 6 inches taller. Who is this Man?
Just stick with this version ;) !
Hi BF Heroes of Bulgaria, I've been collecting Beatles records since I bought my first copy of the Canadian Love Me Do and discovered it was slower and missing the tambourine. Now I will agree with the majority that a true stereo mix of this song has never been put out and all those on youtube are well constructed from 2 different recordings. However, that touted fairytale of stolen or erased tapes is pure poppy cock. EMI throws nothing away. That line was created to quash any public feedback. For years it was believed that How Do You Do It was lost, then all of a sudden, there it was. Then it was said that the Ringo version of Love Me Do on the Past Masters was derived from a pristine vinyl source. I have a German single and a German EP both with Ringo's version. There is also a Brazilian EP with that version. If EMI had REALLY discarded the master, they could have borrowed one from one of their subsidiaries. Bottom line is they still have the tapes and when they are ready they will issue it. Anyone that believes those repeated lies, I have a roller skate key for sale. Someone once said, "The bigger the lie, the more people will believe it" How True!.
You just pulled all that "knowledge" right out of your ass. It's all completely wrong, and ignorant of the music industry at the time.
They show ringo singing.
Слушайте на бобинах с запахом одеколона. Откроется кроличья нора.
Nice try. Why won't folks just accept that the master for SLY is gone?
***** My cousin's friend's flatmate insists that her uncle was the janitor for EMI who heisted the two-track master tape, but then subsequently lost it in a card game during an evening's drunken revelry.
Classic Junk Well, my friend's aunt's grandfather's dog, who once shat on EMI's doorstep, intimated through a series of coordinated barks interpreted by Jeremy Paxman that she'd heard the story was complete rubbish.
The two-track SLY master was likely inadvertently recorded over, as many associated with EMI contend.
Could be true? If it really was... :)
Here Paul is taller then George and he plays his Hofner with his thumb. Other Videos he's the same height as George playing the same song with a pick. The Beatles were a Brand Name for a Musical Group that had many Different people playing them. How many people? Only their controllers know. Is Paul today Paul? He has been Paul longer then the rest of them. Is the real Paul the guy we first saw on Ed Sullivan. No. He was just one and two of the. Many people were Paul in the early years because there were so many musicians around at that time in England. Let's see if we can fool the people and change the Band Mates on multiple occasions. They did fool most of us. Now all we have to do is find out which person was who and when. Makes for a great story that we will probably never know the whole Shabang. I'd rather have it like it was for nearly 60 years of life, but there are too many strange things about the Greatest Music Group of all time. Paul was like stretch Armstrong. 5'8'' Small Paul. 6'2" Tall Paul. One thing. Whom ever was Paul was a Fantastic Bass Player and deserves the right to be called one of the greatest.
Suppose the early Beatles were around today....they would totally destroy today's boy band, "One Direction". Just sayin'.
Another fake stereo job, man I am real sick of these stereo syncs. I'd like to see someone use Adobe software and make a DES version.
It sounds pretty stellar to me.
Fake
Fake, how? No stereo master currently exists, so of course it's going to be "fake." Any Beatles fan that's looking at this video knows that. This was created by a true Beatles fan to try to fix that gap of not having an original stereo version. You think you're jumping in here and slapping some knowledge on unsuspecting fans? Dumbass. We already know all this.