it always impresses me how even if you started listening to their music through the studio versions, when you start listening to live versions you really aren't sacrificing any quality. the only difference is a rough edge that make the music more interesting.
Long ago and oh so far away I fell in love with you before the second show Your guitar makes such a sad, sad sound But you’re not really there, it’s just the radio Don’t you remember when you told me you loved me baby?
listen to the lyrics: Long ago, and oh so far away I fell in love with you before the second show Your guitar makes such a sad, sad sound But you're not really there, it's just the radio Don't you remember when you told me you loved me baby? Those lyrics, plus how Frank hugs his guitar and walks up to Gee while he's singing the last line and just stares at him... MAJOR Frerard, i swear. i mean, it's just such a deep moment... i can't even describe it...
"But it's not you, just the radio. Don't you remenber when you love me baby?" And look how Frank gets surprised, and goes where is Gerard and just embraces his guitar while looking to Gee, is so, lovely.
My heart is aching so bad😭😭❤ The feels! And when Frank walks over to Gerard when he sings "But you're not really there. Its just the radio" It's almost like showing him, 'I'm here'❤❤😭💔
Excuse me while I hurl myself off a bridge because those lyrics and Frank’s reaction. The way he holds his guitar to his chest. The way he goes over to Gerard. And the way he keeps looking at him throughout the song. JUST KILL ME WHY DON’T YOU.OH M Y DGOSD ADSFKJ I’M CRYING I’m supposed to be doing a project right now but I seen this and OMFG I DSJFKL I CAN’T EXPRESS MY FEELINGS RIGHT NOW FDJSK
@illumi zoldyck no one’s disrespecting anyone. people speculate on celebrities’ relationships literally all the time. it’s not like people here are personally harassing the guys about it. why are you so bothered by it? lmao
@illumi zoldyck i promise you the guys aren’t losing sleep over people speculating about them in the comments of a random youtube video from 2011, or in any space on the internet that they aren’t even a part of for that matter. relax man lmao
Superstar Long ago, and, oh, so far away I fell in love with you before the second show. Your guitar, it sounds so sweet and clear, But you're not really here. It's just the radio. Don't you remember you told me you love me baby? You said you'd be coming back this way again baby. Baby, baby, baby, baby, oh, baby. I love you, i really do. Loneliness is such a sad affair, and i can hardly wait To be with you again. What to say, to make you come again? Come back to me again, and play your sad guitar. Don't you remember you told me you love me baby? You said you'd be coming back this way again baby. Baby, baby, baby, baby, oh, baby. I love you, i really do. Don't you remember you told me you love me baby? You said you'd be coming back this way again baby. Baby, baby, baby, baby, oh, baby. I love you, i really do.
I do believe he sings this for Lyn-z. That said, can you imagine how painful it is to see Frank walking over him to a song that may not be for him at all?
This is a conflicting story since people say he sings this for Lyn-Z at home when Gerard has actually said he never sings at home since it makes it uncomfortable. Therefore, whether it is for Frank or Lyn-Z is fair game for either of the two here since there was no official clarification from Gerard himself.
IM WATCHING THIS BECAUSE I LIVE IN NEWCASTLE..I was only 7 when this happened tho I wish I could see them live. The music just isn’t the same as when they’re live. There’s just so much more energy and emotion❤️❤️❤️
The point where Gerard says "Your guitar makes such a sad sad sound... But you're not really there, it's just the radio" and Frank _immediately_ abandons what he's doing and walks over to Gerard, clutching his guitar to his chest... Yeah, that bit...
Seems like Frank nods and say "Yes, Sure"? Looks like Gee smiles back ( look at chick movement, you can see when his face is still faceline is different)
To everyone complaining that this isn't Neil Diamond, it's the Carpenters, yes we know and so does Gerard. The song BEFORE this that he sang part of was Sweet Caroline. I've seen the video, he got the whole audience singing it. This must've come right after that, hence the "Fuckin' Neil Diamond" comment. Just clearing that up :)
the fact that frank and gerard played close to you, another song by the carpenters during a show back in 2005...i don’t know man this seems like it was something personal between them
At the start, the way all the things happened, gerard singing this apart of them, privately, like this was so painful. Then immediately mikey moves from gerard frank comes to gerard, slowly becoming near to gee while hugging his guitar and the emotions that all that express, gerard don't even look at frank, this was so personal and sad for both, the reaction of them is just really sad, and at the end of that frank wipes something of his face, a tear?, pretty sure they have a story, they loved each other, and this makes me crY evERYTIME I WATCH IT and the people that say is for Lyn-z, okay obviously they're not gonna say "sure, it was for frank", but it has no sense when you realize the song and how actually gerard CHANGED the lyrics to a sad way, lynz and gee are fucking married, why this must'd be a sad moment?
Couldn't agree more. I personally believe they did have something I can see it being written all over their faces. It's just their dynamic which is very unique and also very complicated for the most part.
OMG this is so sad. G is definitely singing this to Frank, they have (hopefully still do) a really special relationship. I'll bet they did fall for each other by the 2nd show, it's what made MCR so fuckin' special - the lyrics, the passion, the confusion, the joys, and the pain. It looks like the song is an understanding of I love you but... Frank walks to the back and Mikey and Ray look like they are cautiously watching him. He walks hugging his guitar staring at G. The sad thing is, G never looks at him, not even at the end when he stands up. Not until during Famous...then he looks at Frank a lot. I think G is too afraid to commit and it tore him apart, I think that's what the depression, pills, and alcoholism are about, and I wish he'd just stop. I'm not one that thinks there was sex between these two, I think there was real love - and I think it broke/breaks both of them. But that's just what I see.
"Long ago and oh so far away I fell in love with you before the second show Your guitar makes such a sad, sad sound But you’re not really there, it’s just the radio Don’t you remember when you told me you loved me baby?" HUGE FRERARD MOMENT HERE HELLO I'M SCREAMING
Inclusive este tema viene seguido del My Chemical Romance - I'm Not Okay - LIVE IN HIGH QUALITY - NEWCASTLE 2011 y la sonrisa que se hacen uno al otro .... no puedo con todo esto .... #FreradForEver
Frank nods at 0:57 This video is weird because usually if Gerard plays a song for LynZ, Frank would just be backstage or just standing there watching him sing but, during this song, he walked up to Gerard and hugged his guitar. This video will always be a mystery.
Watching all the videos from this concert and Gee looks so... tired. His performance is amazing but it seems like his energy is low. I wonder if he was okay :(
huh, never thought he'd sing this song on stage. Even if it's all broken and weird, it's still a loaded moment. Good to see Frank looking out for him there
At the beginning, he's singing a part from the song Superstar by The Carpenters, a song that Lynz has him sing for her when she's down I just, all these feels ; v ;
I swear, that's the second time I've thought that that "in-between songs" keyboard (at the beginning here, and just before Hang 'Em High at their iTunes Festival 2011 show) was gonna be "Jetset Life"
Notice how when Gerard sings superstar hes not facing anyone hes turned away like he couldn't bring himself 3 face the others and mikey frank and ray are all looking at him concerned 😥my heart
i dont know for you guys but i feel like there’s something in his voice in the start and end of Last Words, like if he’s hurt or something. like the cover right before made him feel something special and sad yknow ?
Everyone: FRERARD?! Or he could just be moved by one of his best friends singing a sad sounding song in a beautiful and sad way, he’s always very moved when Gerard sings Cancer too, stop reading into it 💀
Guys, I know they're both married and have kids which is very respectable and they're very happy but Frank and Gerard could be Ex boyfriends who are still close and that's normal people can be friends with their ex's right?
Panic! AtTheFallØutRømance yes, the video where thy hugged calld "my chemical romance-bulletproof heart-trent FM arena nottingham- 19th feb 2011" and where thy smiled "my chemical romance- im not okay - LIVE IN HIGH QUALITY-NEWCASTLE 2011
Guys the song was made for Mikey... as he was planning to leave the band, Gerard wrote the song as a way to show that he still wants Mikey in the band. I don't know about all the Lyn-z and Frerard stuff.
Wen he starts famous last words, his voice sounds so Sad wen he said “ Now I no” he said it so sadly. I also think this song was meant for his Wife but I think he Realizes it was more for frank 🥺 they truly did have something... but then it was to scary to say and Now it’s risky to say it Bc they have kids and r both married🥺
I think Gerard sang the song in the beginning by The Carpenters because he was angry, and Lyn-Z sings that to him when he's angry. I know this because I saw a comment that said this the first time I watched this video, which was 2 years ago.
Eu acho que vou chora alguém me segura. Se alguém ainda tinha dúvidas sobre o relacionamento deles essas dúvidas acabaram aqui, essa parte do inicio foi a coisa mais óbvia que eu já vi...só não ve quem não quer
@@Evaxxk Não sei se gostaria muito disso, talvez isso atrapalhasse um pouco a vida deles e eu não quero isso, eu quero eles felizes, mas Morro de curiosidade pra saber oq realmente aconteceu entre eles
He changed the words "sweet and clear" to "sad sad sound" I AM CRYING
You can hear him smile when he says that too
:'(((((
:(
That's a fucking moment between Frank and Gerard,
I don't care what you say.
Omg this moment where Frank hugs his guitar and walks over to Gee and these lyrics... I can't even... *cries
mikey's face oh my god he looks so worried i'm crying
frank getting sentimental and walking over to gee during the "don't you remember you told me you loved me baby" part, hmm
let me just say that I love your icon
I love yours too!
Teyana Joy Kent IKR
IKR THIS ALWAYS MAKES ME CRY
frank smiled at gerard after he finished the song
The way that he sings this is so eerie and makes me really sad. Don't even get me started on Frank hugging his guitar.
like i might be imagining this but it looks like frank nods at gerard when he sings the "don't you remember when you told me you love me baby" part?
right! I thought i was the only one who saw it!
Yass! Same. I was wondering if anyone would mention it
❤👏❤👏😭
gaylien nope i saW IT TOO
STOP
it always impresses me how even if you started listening to their music through the studio versions, when you start listening to live versions you really aren't sacrificing any quality. the only difference is a rough edge that make the music more interesting.
Long ago and oh so far away I fell in love with you before the second show Your guitar makes such a sad, sad sound But you’re not really there, it’s just the radio Don’t you remember when you told me you loved me baby?
@@sfdrexj7185 or was
Superstar - The Carpenters
OMG THANK YOU
listen to the lyrics:
Long ago, and oh so far away
I fell in love with you before the second show
Your guitar makes such a sad, sad sound
But you're not really there, it's just the radio
Don't you remember when you told me you loved me baby?
Those lyrics, plus how Frank hugs his guitar and walks up to Gee while he's singing the last line and just stares at him...
MAJOR Frerard, i swear. i mean, it's just such a deep moment... i can't even describe it...
"But it's not you, just the radio. Don't you remenber when you love me baby?" And look how Frank gets surprised, and goes where is Gerard and just embraces his guitar while looking to Gee, is so, lovely.
the sad part is that frank is staring at gee all the time while he's doing nothing...
The way frank walks over when he says remember when you loved me and hugs his guitar!!! help me 😭😭
imagine how painful it must be for frank to walk over to gerard for a song that might not even be for him..
trashy ash Keyword: might
I'm pretty sure it was for him.
was it for him?
@@sistert0sleep I hope so because there's a chance it could've been for lynz :/
ALRIGHT WHO STARTED CHOPPING THE ONIONS JFC
+InfinityOnHigh sorry i just wanted to make some fuckin soup
radrtiero FFFF
It was Shrek.
My heart is aching so bad😭😭❤ The feels!
And when Frank walks over to Gerard when he sings "But you're not really there. Its just the radio" It's almost like showing him, 'I'm here'❤❤😭💔
Abbigail Barrows frerard is real
OMG imma cry jfc😭😭
3:16 it seems like Mikey just interpose in Gerard's way
lol
Mikey No Likey
HOW THE TABLES HAVE TURNED
Mikey know everything
i just want to cry all my tears
Excuse me while I hurl myself off a bridge because those lyrics and Frank’s reaction. The way he holds his guitar to his chest. The way he goes over to Gerard. And the way he keeps looking at him throughout the song. JUST KILL ME WHY DON’T YOU.OH M Y DGOSD ADSFKJ I’M CRYING I’m supposed to be doing a project right now but I seen this and OMFG I DSJFKL I CAN’T EXPRESS MY FEELINGS RIGHT NOW FDJSK
maybe he IS singing about his wife, but Frank obviously feel da fRERARD
As you can see,Frank was fixing his guitar strings and then he goes to gee to enjoy the moment. Just beautyful.
It makes me sad that I haven't seen them live when they were still a band and probably never will :(
guess what
@@youtakingthepissmate8510 lol
They are back aakdjjwjwkwl
good news
That's sad that this comment was written five years ago and she is probably out of fandom :(
THE FRERARD IS SO OBVIUSLY!!!
Frank fucking nodded when gee sang "don't you remember when you said you loved me baby"
I'M NOT O FUCKING KAY
you can't tell me that gerard and frank didn't had something after this
*before
@@Ella-gj7vr I think she means "after watching this video"
@illumi zoldyck and? they’ve known each other long before that
@illumi zoldyck no one’s disrespecting anyone. people speculate on celebrities’ relationships literally all the time. it’s not like people here are personally harassing the guys about it. why are you so bothered by it? lmao
@illumi zoldyck i promise you the guys aren’t losing sleep over people speculating about them in the comments of a random youtube video from 2011, or in any space on the internet that they aren’t even a part of for that matter. relax man lmao
the 'superstar' part is pure magic. his voice is so amazing I can't help but cry each time I hear it.
Superstar
Long ago, and, oh, so far away
I fell in love with you before the second show.
Your guitar, it sounds so sweet and clear,
But you're not really here.
It's just the radio.
Don't you remember you told me you love me baby?
You said you'd be coming back this way again baby.
Baby, baby, baby, baby, oh, baby.
I love you, i really do.
Loneliness is such a sad affair, and i can hardly wait
To be with you again.
What to say, to make you come again?
Come back to me again, and play your sad guitar.
Don't you remember you told me you love me baby?
You said you'd be coming back this way again baby.
Baby, baby, baby, baby, oh, baby.
I love you, i really do.
Don't you remember you told me you love me baby?
You said you'd be coming back this way again baby.
Baby, baby, baby, baby, oh, baby.
I love you, i really do.
ray and mikey are just looking at them like wtf
"Don't u remember when u told me u love me baby?"
*Cries*
2018 still not okey
Can you hear that? It's my heart shattering
I find this video, especially the beginning, so beautiful. :'(
man i actually cried
Can i just cry all over my room? This is so intense, i cant even...
From time to time I just come here to watch this video to get sad... My heart aches everytime :(
I do believe he sings this for Lyn-z.
That said, can you imagine how painful it is to see Frank walking over him to a song that may not be for him at all?
A. F. Nascimento Bro... 💔
but lyn-z plays the bass..?
Duck.. you hurt me so much...
Thanks auto correct.. I was gonna say duck with an f
This is a conflicting story since people say he sings this for Lyn-Z at home when Gerard has actually said he never sings at home since it makes it uncomfortable. Therefore, whether it is for Frank or Lyn-Z is fair game for either of the two here since there was no official clarification from Gerard himself.
IM WATCHING THIS BECAUSE I LIVE IN NEWCASTLE..I was only 7 when this happened tho I wish I could see them live. The music just isn’t the same as when they’re live. There’s just so much more energy and emotion❤️❤️❤️
I know I'm late but the song is actually Superstar by The Carpenters just for those who would like to know
In the Frerad💔 😭 #frerard2018
God.. Almost crying here.
So many emotions..
I just...oh good *cries*
The point where Gerard says "Your guitar makes such a sad sad sound... But you're not really there, it's just the radio" and Frank _immediately_ abandons what he's doing and walks over to Gerard, clutching his guitar to his chest...
Yeah, that bit...
THE FRERARD THO
this so is intense and overwhelming i want to cry
Seems like Frank nods and say "Yes, Sure"?
Looks like Gee smiles back ( look at chick movement, you can see when his face is still faceline is different)
Yes, I`ve seen that too. G looked at him when he got up and they smiled at each other.
To everyone complaining that this isn't Neil Diamond, it's the Carpenters, yes we know and so does Gerard. The song BEFORE this that he sang part of was Sweet Caroline. I've seen the video, he got the whole audience singing it. This must've come right after that, hence the "Fuckin' Neil Diamond" comment. Just clearing that up :)
That little segment just made me burst into tears.
They should cover that song, because damn, Gerard's voice...
PLOT TWIST Gerard was actually in love with the drummer ....
the fact that frank and gerard played close to you, another song by the carpenters during a show back in 2005...i don’t know man this seems like it was something personal between them
this is adorable...i did in fact cry
Obvious Frerard is obvious :3
I watched this beauty in HD.
At the start, the way all the things happened, gerard singing this apart of them, privately, like this was so painful. Then immediately mikey moves from gerard frank comes to gerard, slowly becoming near to gee while hugging his guitar and the emotions that all that express, gerard don't even look at frank, this was so personal and sad for both, the reaction of them is just really sad, and at the end of that frank wipes something of his face, a tear?, pretty sure they have a story, they loved each other, and this makes me crY evERYTIME I WATCH IT
and the people that say is for Lyn-z, okay obviously they're not gonna say "sure, it was for frank", but it has no sense when you realize the song and how actually gerard CHANGED the lyrics to a sad way, lynz and gee are fucking married, why this must'd be a sad moment?
Couldn't agree more. I personally believe they did have something I can see it being written all over their faces. It's just their dynamic which is very unique and also very complicated for the most part.
#TeamFrerard
OMG this is so sad. G is definitely singing this to Frank, they have (hopefully still do) a really special relationship. I'll bet they did fall for each other by the 2nd show, it's what made MCR so fuckin' special - the lyrics, the passion, the confusion, the joys, and the pain. It looks like the song is an understanding of I love you but... Frank walks to the back and Mikey and Ray look like they are cautiously watching him. He walks hugging his guitar staring at G. The sad thing is, G never looks at him, not even at the end when he stands up. Not until during Famous...then he looks at Frank a lot. I think G is too afraid to commit and it tore him apart, I think that's what the depression, pills, and alcoholism are about, and I wish he'd just stop. I'm not one that thinks there was sex between these two, I think there was real love - and I think it broke/breaks both of them. But that's just what I see.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏😭😭😭
Jaqui_0 ikr
I'm crying
Just watching and reading this on the 22nd, bawling my eyes out 👍
Da fuck lmao
Al inicio definitivamente Gee le canta a Frank, Dios, ese momento es tan doloroso y precioso a la vez
c'moon! you can shoot me but its real frerard
"Long ago and oh so far away
I fell in love with you before the second show
Your guitar makes such a sad, sad sound
But you’re not really there, it’s just the radio
Don’t you remember when you told me you loved me baby?"
HUGE FRERARD MOMENT HERE HELLO I'M SCREAMING
Inclusive este tema viene seguido del My Chemical Romance - I'm Not Okay - LIVE IN HIGH QUALITY - NEWCASTLE 2011 y la sonrisa que se hacen uno al otro .... no puedo con todo esto .... #FreradForEver
Danger Days was Gerard's best vocals
the best moment when Frank huging his guitar....
Frank nods at 0:57
This video is weird because usually if Gerard plays a song for LynZ, Frank would just be backstage or just standing there watching him sing but, during this song, he walked up to Gerard and hugged his guitar. This video will always be a mystery.
:D I didn't think anyone would even look at that comment, glad to know i'm not alone in this! (:
This song refers to the hardships of being famous and how you can't go home no matter what or give up. This is to us fans that he did all this for us.
ahhhhh! Frerard!!!!!!!! sooo fangirly right now!!!!
I love how this is clearly about frank and aghhhh
~mustache
Gee and Franks inside joke
Watching all the videos from this concert and Gee looks so... tired. His performance is amazing but it seems like his energy is low. I wonder if he was okay :(
ik this was a year ago but he was starving himself during danger day so nah
Awwh Superstar. He should totally do a cover of that song, it would be amazing.
He has. It is amazing. So amazing.
I know I saw yesterday he posted a recording of it he did a while back. So amazing!
+Ana Dermanovic I am actually obsessed with it lol. His voice is so unique and just... idek😂
Omg I know, I love it so much D: He's my favourite singer ever
Omg when Frank walked to Gerard's side while hugging his guitar...
Makes me want to cry >.
Thank you for this comment !! Glad to see tht some people have common sense !
Oh my my my frank actually cried a lot especially in the end
huh, never thought he'd sing this song on stage. Even if it's all broken and weird, it's still a loaded moment. Good to see Frank looking out for him there
What a awesome night... wish I was there!!! ;/ ;D
Se me metió un frerard a los ojos
i think it's amazing that even though for now they are the killjoys they still play their old stuff
Aside from Superstar (😭😭❤), I really love the raw, live guitars in Famous Last Words!😍
At the beginning, he's singing a part from the song Superstar by The Carpenters, a song that Lynz has him sing for her when she's down
I just, all these feels ; v ;
Phenomenal camera!
The whole enitre time Gerard sings, he kneeling down to the picture of Bandit that he takes on stage.
This is so precious :')
I swear, that's the second time I've thought that that "in-between songs" keyboard (at the beginning here, and just before Hang 'Em High at their iTunes Festival 2011 show) was gonna be "Jetset Life"
😍😍😍 awesome perf!
Notice how when Gerard sings superstar hes not facing anyone hes turned away like he couldn't bring himself 3 face the others and mikey frank and ray are all looking at him concerned 😥my heart
there's so much frerard in this comment section, I'm concerned
i dont know for you guys but i feel like there’s something in his voice in the start and end of Last Words, like if he’s hurt or something.
like the cover right before made him feel something special and sad yknow ?
TEARS
@wedra B is Bandit its Just a short form :)
Everyone: FRERARD?!
Or he could just be moved by one of his best friends singing a sad sounding song in a beautiful and sad way, he’s always very moved when Gerard sings Cancer too, stop reading into it 💀
im crying
mikey looks so concerned during the neil diamond part
Guys, I know they're both married and have kids which is very respectable and they're very happy
but Frank and Gerard could be Ex boyfriends who are still close and that's normal people can be friends with their ex's right?
That intro best fits Demolition Lovers 💔😓😰
first this then at im not okay thy smiled at eachother and at the end off the whole concerd they hugged...
Panic! AtTheFallØutRømance yes, the video where thy hugged calld "my chemical romance-bulletproof heart-trent FM arena nottingham- 19th feb 2011" and where thy smiled "my chemical romance- im not okay - LIVE IN HIGH QUALITY-NEWCASTLE 2011
"Don't you remember you told me I love you, babe?"
best frerard :3
Guys the song was made for Mikey... as he was planning to leave the band, Gerard wrote the song as a way to show that he still wants Mikey in the band. I don't know about all the Lyn-z and Frerard stuff.
I think is because of the song gerard started to sing before famous last words
Gerard didn't write it, it's called "Superstar" by The Carpenters
Wen he starts famous last words, his voice sounds so Sad wen he said “ Now I no” he said it so sadly. I also think this song was meant for his Wife but I think he Realizes it was more for frank 🥺 they truly did have something... but then it was to scary to say and Now it’s risky to say it Bc they have kids and r both married🥺
they were married and had kids back then as well
I think Gerard sang the song in the beginning by The Carpenters because he was angry, and Lyn-Z sings that to him when he's angry. I know this because I saw a comment that said this the first time I watched this video, which was 2 years ago.
ParamoreLover19 and you believe all that you read in internet?
Eu acho que vou chora alguém me segura.
Se alguém ainda tinha dúvidas sobre o relacionamento deles essas dúvidas acabaram aqui, essa parte do inicio foi a coisa mais óbvia que eu já vi...só não ve quem não quer
amor renegado é uma merda né não
meu sonho era que a verdade sobre o passado desses dois caisse na midia
@@Evaxxk Não sei se gostaria muito disso, talvez isso atrapalhasse um pouco a vida deles e eu não quero isso, eu quero eles felizes, mas Morro de curiosidade pra saber oq realmente aconteceu entre eles
@@alecyohan362 eu tbm
aint this the same show where in the middle of HFFH frank starts singing the fresh prince of belle air theme ???