*A Critique of Western Psychology With Dr Francesca Bocca-Aldaqre* : Part 2 00:02 Stream begins with welcoming, and introducing the guest - Dr Francesca Bocca-Aldaqre 00:51 Precis of the Part-1 discussion : _Yes, Muslims did invent psychology_ _The discussion_ 01:26 What is psychology from an Islamic perspective ? 03:50 Discussing Dr Malik Babikr Badri Mohammed's view of the Western psychology as being "soulless" _[ book recommendation : "The Dilemma of Muslim Psychologists" by Malik B. Badri ]_ 05:36 The existence of soul as an ontological reality is key to Islamic psychology 06:32 What is the difference among different schools of psychology, or psychotherapy from an Islamic perspective ? 07:38 Epistemological foundation to Islamic psychology is different 10:31 How does a Muslim psychologist operate differently ? 12:42 The stark difference between contemporary Western materialist psychology, and Islamic psychology is the "absence of God" 17:28 Are there discoveries of contemporary psychology in the West still valid for Muslims, or are we looking for a parallel system ? 20:50 Why would some reputable psychologists seek to demonstrate that the maternal/motherly instinct is a fiction, and what's the motivation behind their such research works ? 23:05 What are the main points of the academics criticising the Western psychology about the decolonisation aspect ? 23:57 Eurocentrism has been taken as normativity, and its emphasising on individualism 27:54 Paul's concluding words 28:11 Thanking Dr Francesca Bocca-Aldaqre
This a revolutionary approach to psychology, a very positive one 😮 Please make sure Islamic Psychology is well protected from parasites and incompetents
MaashaAllah, this discussion is incredibly insightful and much needed in our community. It’s inspiring to see experts merging Islamic principles with psychology to address the challenges we face today. Truly, the Islamic society is in dire need of such initiatives to restore balance and well-being. May Allah bless both of you for shedding light on this important topic and remind us of the great legacy Islam has in the sciences, including psychology!
So so much respect to Dr. Francesca. I am so grateful to you Paul and to the doctor for such eye-opening and important discussions and views on Psychology. This is completely fascinating and so detrimental to know nowadays. Thank you so much!
Djazakallahu Khayran. This is a treasure of information especially in an age and in a sytem where mental health is a big issue. Also very very valuable for Muslim psychologists not aware of İslamic sychology.
This is genuinely a wonderful interview! As a psychology student, this is great. You continue to remind me of my ethics teacher, Mr Williams. Have a good week and life!
Masha'Allah! What a discussion! Looking forward to the 3rd video now... JazakAllah Khair for bringing her and giving us a chance to learn our own forgotten and often ignored history!
🇵🇸Oh God, protect Gaza, its children, its women, its young and its old. Oh God, we entrust you to the people of Gaza. Oh God, protect us with your eyes that never sleep.
So far, your God has done, absolutely nothing in order to protect the people in Gaza.It’s almost as if he doesn’t care. Or maybe he just doesn’t exist. Either way, so far all the prayers to God to protect the people in Gaza have not worked.
@@rms15374 tell me. Do you think the people in Gaza are praying for help from Allah? And I believe they are. But so far Allah has done nothing. Literally nothing to protect the people in Gaza. Seems like he doesn’t care. Or maybe he doesn’t exist? Either way, in the meantime, thousands of innocent children are being killed and God sits and watches it. What kind of God is that?
They pathologize what is not a part of their own belief system. We're conditioned not to question authority and "experts", to believe everything they say. It's very harmful when they're telling people who they are, but what they're really talking about is their own narrow belief system and pathologizing something that differs from it. I wish you strength facing this, I know how difficult it can be 🙏❤
Thank You both Dr. Paul Williams and Dr. Francisca. This is very fascinating. And also to break the lecture in 3 parts, it makes easier to go through it.
Eye-opening psychological insights offered by Dr. Francesca stemming from Muslim belief in the Unseen (jinn and rukya) as opposed to western materialistic approach. Another outstanding difference is the approach to “dreams” in which human beings are considered essentially evil. Ibn Sirin’s “interpretation” of dreams is very different from Freud. Looking forward to Part 3 ❤
Amazing talk as always. I have one comment that came into my mind about psychotherapy as a job; I believe that one of the biggest barriers between the psychotherapist and the patient is actually the fees a patient pays for the service. I mean loosing money can be a source of distress. I know that psychotherapist need to be payed so they can continue but I am just sharing my mind.
This was a great discussion, MashaAllah. As a convert to Islam and an MSc candidate in Psychology of Mental Health and Wellbeing, I am deeply inspired to explore the field of Islamic Psychology, inshaAllah. My own journey into Islam has been profoundly transformative, and it has given me a unique perspective on how its message can offer healing and meaning in a world that often feels soulless and disconnected. However, I recognize that the word “Islamic” can sometimes evoke a negative or dismissive reaction in the West, where the term is often associated with the organized, politicized aspects of religion. This is unfortunate because Islam, at its core, carries universal principles and timeless wisdom that can enrich anyone’s life. My hope is to make this message more accessible and approachable to people outside the faith, especially those struggling with mental health challenges. I believe there’s a way to communicate the depth and beauty of Islamic teachings in a way that resonates with ordinary people, offering them clarity, hope, and a sense of purpose. After all, a life untouched by the essence of Islam is missing out on something truly transformative.
Masha Allah, I am currently pursuing my Graduate Diploma in Advanced Psychology, with the hope of specialising in Neuropsychology. As a Muslimah, I’ve come to realise that Islam offers profound insights into areas that psychology alone cannot address-particularly the condition of the soul and the importance of our relationship with Allah, which serves as a source of healing for many ailments. I feel deeply grateful for Islam, as it provides guidance that goes beyond the material world, addressing such as the soul and spiritual well-being. In my work with individuals experiencing mental illness, I’ve come to understand how challenging it must be to cope without the support of Allah and His divine guidance through Islam. It’s difficult to imagine navigating such struggles without the light of faith. I worked within the mental health field and I wondered what would I tell someone who lacks this connection with Allah, to uplift them from the darkness they find themselves in. SubhanaAllah. JazakumAllah Khair for this wonderful and educational video.
British scientist Arthur Allison, who was head of the Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering at the University of London, also presented two important papers in the year 1985 when he came to Cairo to participate in the Islamic Medical Conference on the scientific miracle in the Qur’an and presented two research papers: methods of psychological and spiritual treatment in light of the Holy Qur’an, and another research study on the relationship between sleep and death. The relationship between death and sleep was a research study to discover the secret of the soul’s exit. He mentioned to him that an Egyptian young man believed that there was a relationship between sleep and death, and this was the reason for his scientific research. The Egyptian young man told him that there is a Qur’anic text that mentions the relationship between the exit of the soul at death and sleep, so he became interested in this topic and presented scientific research on it. He later converted to Islam
@@erique-eljovenactually it is a scientific fact. If by science you mean observable reality. But if by science you mean materialism then you are right. But that's exactly the problem. This is not a question about science but a question about ideology. Materialism is an ideology which cannot accept results or truths which are non material. Which is not a scientific question but rather a philosophical question
@@yassersharif You did not engage in what I said. The video is about psychology, 'the soul' was mentioned. Once again: the soul has no place in psychology for it is a religious concept, something that still exists after death outside of the human body. Fairytale stuff. There is not a single scientific discipine where the soul is acknowledged to exist.
This topic is extremely important. Yet, I’ve never heard someone that tackles issues of psychology the way Dr. Francesca is doing… those are points that people in the field never bring up because they are non-Muslims and this wonderful lady is Muslim and I truly appreciate the way she’s laying out things… is there a way that we can contact her and ask her some questions regarding this specific topic where it is a big part of my research please?
Still very informative however I guess we need a full explanation of basics (lecture) from Dr Franciska .. because sometimes I can't follow the structure of the conversation ,and I feel that I need more from previous points or I feel we have jumped a couple of points. And as always thanks Paul for the interesting topics .
I think it's a new field, so there's not much research/ typical principles she can refer to. The chat gpt idea below seems appropriate, psychology is more and more popular in the western/ Americanized world, so merging Islamic ideas and psychology is a logical niche.... GPT summary..... Islamic psychology is a field that seeks to integrate psychological principles with Islamic teachings and values. Here are some cornerstone ideas that define Islamic psychology: 1. Unity of the Self (Tawhid): The concept of Tawhid, or the oneness of God, extends to the understanding of the self. In Islamic psychology, the self is seen as a holistic entity that encompasses the body, mind, and spirit. This unity emphasizes that mental health cannot be separated from spiritual well-being. 2. Purpose of Life: Islamic psychology emphasizes that human beings have a purpose, which is to worship God and live in accordance with His guidance. This sense of purpose can significantly influence mental health and well-being. 3. The Nature of the Soul (Nafs): The concept of the soul (Nafs) is central in Islamic psychology. It is believed that the Nafs has different levels, ranging from the base desires to the higher spiritual state. Understanding and nurturing the Nafs is essential for personal development and mental health. 4. Balance (Wasatiyyah): Islamic teachings advocate for balance in all aspects of life, including emotional and psychological health. This principle encourages individuals to find equilibrium between their spiritual, emotional, and social needs. 5. Moral and Ethical Framework: Islamic psychology is grounded in moral and ethical principles derived from the Quran and Hadith. These teachings guide individuals in their behavior, relationships, and mental health practices. 6. Community and Social Responsibility: The importance of community and social ties is emphasized in Islamic psychology. Mental health is viewed not only as an individual concern but also as a communal responsibility, where support systems play a crucial role. 7. Spirituality and Faith: Spirituality is considered a vital component of psychological well-being in Islamic psychology. Practices such as prayer (Salah), remembrance of God (Dhikr), and reading the Quran are seen as beneficial for mental health. 8. Coping Mechanisms: Islamic psychology encourages the use of faith-based coping strategies, such as reliance on God (Tawakkul), patience (Sabr), and gratitude (Shukr), to deal with life's challenges. 9. Holistic Healing: Treatment approaches in Islamic psychology often emphasize holistic healing, incorporating spiritual practices alongside conventional psychological methods to address mental health issues. 10. Recognition of Human Dignity: Every individual is viewed as having inherent dignity and worth, which influences how they should be treated in therapeutic settings. This principle fosters compassion and respect in mental health care. These cornerstone ideas reflect a comprehensive approach to understanding human behavior and mental health through the lens of Islamic teachings, integrating spiritual, psychological, and social dimensions.
Brother Paul, you can invite Dr Sorowar Hossain of Bangladesh . He is a professor of Independent University Bangladesh. He has researched about LGBTQ issues and how it is being covertly imposed . I think he will be able express his insight in your show. He is facing a lot of threats as well.
Unfortunately as a non Muslim I have some serious gaps, chat gpt plugs a lot, but perhaps people from an Islamic background can give a clearer picture regarding one question I have. Assuming that Muslim psychologists / psychiatrists / psychotherapists are a new phenomenon, who have Moslem women traditionally turned to in order to seek help to solve spiritual / mental health problems?
Good question. Let me try answering that for you: While Muslim women can experience bouts of depression at times of loss in their lives, majority turn back to Allah and the Quran which are Healers from the Soul Levels. When Allah says, “Remember Me; I will remember you,” (humans who are willing to be healed by His Majesty), Allah is serious, not just a high status symbol like human priests or leaders)-who have been known to take advantage of vulnerable girls and women-as the Me, Too Movement has illustrated. This is why our five daily prayers to the One Majesty of the entire universe allows Muslim women (and men and children mature), to form the largest connection ever known to humans. Prayers are a direct line between the human and the Divine. And as Quran teaches before every Sura, “Allah is the Most Compassionate, Most Merciful.” (He is not a “god that man can destroy” by cruelty or whim is in polytheistic cultures of olden times). Through the process of prayers as a regular way of life, Muslim women do not “need” men or things or attachments that average people think they need to feel good about themselves. When one prays with full mind, soul, body and attitude in full submission towards the Divine/(Allah), after ablutions and purifications, a certain calm comes over the restless human soul and body that is unlike any other supposed “healing” that most people talk about. And nature itself is a witness, (not a pantheistic attribute), of God Almighty’s daily workings. If you’ve ever seen leaves and trees and flowers and gentle creatures prostrating before the Divine, it is also a healing experience on the inside of the human mind and body: Sura The Bee, 16:48, “Have they (humans) not observed all things that Allah has created, how their shadows incline to the right and to the left, making prostration to Allah, and they are lowly?” When we begin learning Quran’s Arabic at early ages -I learned at five from my blessed mother -the euphonic and mellifluous quality of it causes additional healing on the inside, mending the broken parts that we humans may have suffered at different times in human life. Finally, Muslim women are first and foremost lovers of Allah, so they are peacemakers and peacekeepers by nature: this is yet another reason that Allah blesses the innermost tranquility of the human heart. And their families and communities are like angels and guardians to us-when something bad happens, we can turn to the sisters and cousins and friends of Faith -who have deep empathy. Community is integrated with Faith practices, and some women go to mosque, while others simply pray at home: it’s a personal choice. Muslim women also do not need to act desperate for attention as many western counterparts will tend to show off their bodies and try to become popular with groups of people: this bad habit that some women have learned, who don’t know much about Quran or Islam, ends up destroying their mental health, creating havoc and tensions in their Freud-filled angst of emptiness, and craving harmful and addictive things with which they allow themselves to be abused, God forbid. If you ever noticed the high level of suicides by influencers, both male and female, their lust, urges for attention, and popularity contests become their own personal idols, killing their self-esteem and good feelings about themselves or their physicality -that no amount of yoga or bodybuilding will cure. Narcissistic attitudes that require people to help the individual end up failing themselves in the long-run, (as recent young, rich, but unfit spiritually -celebrities who have jumped off buildings or stalked people or killed themselves or others)….Sura 58:14, “Have you not seen those who take for friends a people with whom Allah is angry? They are neither of you nor of them, and they swear a false oath knowingly.” This implies that many people will lead their own so-called friends into the path of destruction and despair because: A. Misery loves company, and B. Those who cannot follow their own given Revelations, taught in earlier tribes, cannot respect your revelations-and Allah says that do not trust those “who Jest about your religion.” Healing comes from Divine Source: Allah gives so much healing that one would finally understand the dichotomies between mere human and Divine.
Hi! A very valid question! We need to look at the question from a broader perspective. If you have already read into the topic then you will have come across the various therapists talking about psychological disorders stemming many times from the big and small Ts. Big Trauma like eg natural disasters, war, horrible accidents, sexual abuse, physical abuse etc. Small Traumas are where neglect is involved and things which should have happened didn't happen - refer to attachment theory. Societies were indeed more wholesome with regards to bringing up children, support is not just through parents but also extended family and neighborhood were involved in raising new generations. Islamic psychologists weren't really needed as ppl in general were grounded well because of a wholesome upbringing. As for the big Ts... disasters and accidents are seen as destined by God in His ultimate wisdom and as Muslims generally speaking we deal with such "bad" events through patience and turning back to God. The same goes for wars. They are men made but in the end of someone fights for what he believes then the believe outweighs the negative of war. Now you will ask how about sexual abuse - I will say that with certainty this horrible thing did hardly exist before in an Islamic society just because of its horrific nature plus the penal code in an Islamic state would call for death penalty for it. I come from a Catholic background and reverted to Islam round 30 years ago. The moral decay and godlessness wether it is in western or starting to creep into Islamic societies is a big contributer to having people now with mental health issues. You will find online many therapists who will advocate in their treatments to include faith based treatment. Humans need moral guidelines and rules to live by in order to be both physically and mentally healthy.
@JDforeveralone thank you, I made an assumption that traditionally religuous leaders were turned to, that they were men and it was not appropriate for women to mix with them, but that's based on 1 - a comparison with the Catholic and orthodox church 2 - ideas about free mixing I saw Ali dawha criticised of when he had debates between men and women. I don't know much at all, and for some reason chat GPT is vague when it answers this question.
@@MrJohnaiton you're welcome! The debates by Ali Dawah were criticised because of how they were conducted plus the dress code of some of the ladies (improper Hijab, makeup etc). Plus that it was more of an entertainment show with no real benefit. The religious leaders (imams and sheikhs) are mainly being turned to when one has got a question regarding a type of worship or a dispute between ppl, or in jurisdictional issues. And that has always been allowed for women too to go and seek advice/knowledge. You have stories from the time of the prophet Muhammad peace and blessings upon him where the women went to him to inquire. This is not considered mixing. Yes, chatgpt is very useful but has its limits.
Francesca is too eager to speak and too quick, particularly with a subject like this. And never forget that Judaism stands for light, Christianity for love, Islam for strength or powers. The three belong to each other, when there is light and no power, there is nothing amd love is the binding factor.
*A Critique of Western Psychology With Dr Francesca Bocca-Aldaqre* : Part 2
00:02 Stream begins with welcoming, and introducing the guest - Dr Francesca Bocca-Aldaqre
00:51 Precis of the Part-1 discussion : _Yes, Muslims did invent psychology_
_The discussion_
01:26 What is psychology from an Islamic perspective ?
03:50 Discussing Dr Malik Babikr Badri Mohammed's view of the Western psychology as being "soulless"
_[ book recommendation : "The Dilemma of Muslim Psychologists" by Malik B. Badri ]_
05:36 The existence of soul as an ontological reality is key to Islamic psychology
06:32 What is the difference among different schools of psychology, or psychotherapy from an Islamic perspective ?
07:38 Epistemological foundation to Islamic psychology is different
10:31 How does a Muslim psychologist operate differently ?
12:42 The stark difference between contemporary Western materialist psychology, and Islamic psychology is the "absence of God"
17:28 Are there discoveries of contemporary psychology in the West still valid for Muslims, or are we looking for a parallel system ?
20:50 Why would some reputable psychologists seek to demonstrate that the maternal/motherly instinct is a fiction, and what's the motivation behind their such research works ?
23:05 What are the main points of the academics criticising the Western psychology about the decolonisation aspect ?
23:57 Eurocentrism has been taken as normativity, and its emphasising on individualism
27:54 Paul's concluding words
28:11 Thanking Dr Francesca Bocca-Aldaqre
This sister is a gem of a person. May Allah grant her a long life in good health.
Ameen ...
Ameen
Yes! Ameen!
Fascinating topic, no doubt. May Allah increase this sister, Dr. Francesca, in beneficial knowledge. Ameen.
Ameen ...
This a revolutionary approach to psychology, a very positive one 😮
Please make sure Islamic Psychology is well protected from parasites and incompetents
Amazing talk.Dr.Francesca ,Jazaki Allahu khairan and I wish you all the best sister .
May Allah reward you Mr.Paul .Keep going the fabulous work.
agree
What a gem of a discussion. More people need to hear this..
MaashaAllah, this discussion is incredibly insightful and much needed in our community. It’s inspiring to see experts merging Islamic principles with psychology to address the challenges we face today. Truly, the Islamic society is in dire need of such initiatives to restore balance and well-being. May Allah bless both of you for shedding light on this important topic and remind us of the great legacy Islam has in the sciences, including psychology!
MASHALLAH JAZAKALLAH KHAIR,these are the sorts of topics muslim ummah needs to get inspiration,thanks
Always good to hear from Dr Francesca, thank you Paul
This sister is a very smart and articulate person. May Allah expand her knowledge and wisdom.
العلماء ورثة الاءنبياء ...... ورثوا عنهم العلم وليس المال
So so much respect to Dr. Francesca. I am so grateful to you Paul and to the doctor for such eye-opening and important discussions and views on Psychology. This is completely fascinating and so detrimental to know nowadays. Thank you so much!
Very good to see you both again very excited to listen to the dr ❤
Mashallah. A very informative discussion. ❤
Mashallah thank you for contributing this discourse to the world. May Allah swt bless you all
Masha Allah
Masha Allah
Masha Allah la Quwwata illa Billah
Islaam is in good hands Alhamdulillah.
May Allah increase you both..
I read Dr Aisha Utz book on Psychology from an Islamic Perspective. I found it so fascinating. Thanks for this video.
Can you write name of the book and full name of the author? Thank you
@velida5410 I did in the comment above.
@chelseyummali thank you, I thought maybe it has another title 😊
@velida5410 your welcome :)
Currently reading this book!
May videos and discussions like these pave the way to generations of holistic, intellectual and God cautious Muslims / people
Djazakallahu Khayran. This is a treasure of information especially in an age and in a sytem where mental health is a big issue. Also very very valuable for Muslim psychologists not aware of İslamic sychology.
Jazaakumullaahu khairan brother Paul for sharing
May Allah grant you both the highest place in jannah, for the great job you are doing for Allah
This is genuinely a wonderful interview! As a psychology student, this is great. You continue to remind me of my ethics teacher, Mr Williams. Have a good week and life!
Masha'Allah! What a discussion! Looking forward to the 3rd video now...
JazakAllah Khair for bringing her and giving us a chance to learn our own forgotten and often ignored history!
🇵🇸Oh God, protect Gaza, its children, its women, its young and its old. Oh God, we entrust you to the people of Gaza. Oh God, protect us with your eyes that never sleep.
oh how touching your words , may Allah listen to all our dua's for GAZA., ameen!
Ameen.🤲
So far, your God has done, absolutely nothing in order to protect the people in Gaza.It’s almost as if he doesn’t care. Or maybe he just doesn’t exist. Either way, so far all the prayers to God to protect the people in Gaza have not worked.
@@rms15374 tell me. Do you think the people in Gaza are praying for help from Allah? And I believe they are. But so far Allah has done nothing. Literally nothing to protect the people in Gaza. Seems like he doesn’t care. Or maybe he doesn’t exist? Either way, in the meantime, thousands of innocent children are being killed and God sits and watches it. What kind of God is that?
اللهم امين يا ا الله و صل الله على سيدنا محمد و على اله و صحبه اجمعين
We need more of Dr. Francesca!
25:31, my psychiatrist believes I'm sick because when mentioning my future I'm mostly worried about missing prayers if I go to some institution.
They pathologize what is not a part of their own belief system. We're conditioned not to question authority and "experts", to believe everything they say. It's very harmful when they're telling people who they are, but what they're really talking about is their own narrow belief system and pathologizing something that differs from it. I wish you strength facing this, I know how difficult it can be 🙏❤
Asalamuliakum Jazakallah khair it was just wow of interview. May Allah bless the sister epitome of knowledge and expression.
Thank You both Dr. Paul Williams and Dr. Francisca. This is very fascinating. And also to break the lecture in 3 parts, it makes easier to go through it.
Sister is amazing, we need to recreate islamic psychology in the muslim world once more. Many in the ummah is in dire need of it
Eye-opening psychological insights offered by Dr. Francesca stemming from Muslim belief in the Unseen (jinn and rukya) as opposed to western materialistic approach. Another outstanding difference is the approach to “dreams” in which human beings are considered essentially evil. Ibn Sirin’s “interpretation” of dreams is very different from Freud. Looking forward to Part 3 ❤
Amazing talk as always. I have one comment that came into my mind about psychotherapy as a job;
I believe that one of the biggest barriers between the psychotherapist and the patient is actually the fees a patient pays for the service. I mean loosing money can be a source of distress. I know that psychotherapist need to be payed so they can continue but I am just sharing my mind.
This was a great discussion, MashaAllah. As a convert to Islam and an MSc candidate in Psychology of Mental Health and Wellbeing, I am deeply inspired to explore the field of Islamic Psychology, inshaAllah. My own journey into Islam has been profoundly transformative, and it has given me a unique perspective on how its message can offer healing and meaning in a world that often feels soulless and disconnected.
However, I recognize that the word “Islamic” can sometimes evoke a negative or dismissive reaction in the West, where the term is often associated with the organized, politicized aspects of religion. This is unfortunate because Islam, at its core, carries universal principles and timeless wisdom that can enrich anyone’s life.
My hope is to make this message more accessible and approachable to people outside the faith, especially those struggling with mental health challenges. I believe there’s a way to communicate the depth and beauty of Islamic teachings in a way that resonates with ordinary people, offering them clarity, hope, and a sense of purpose. After all, a life untouched by the essence of Islam is missing out on something truly transformative.
Masha Allah, I am currently pursuing my Graduate Diploma in Advanced Psychology, with the hope of specialising in Neuropsychology. As a Muslimah, I’ve come to realise that Islam offers profound insights into areas that psychology alone cannot address-particularly the condition of the soul and the importance of our relationship with Allah, which serves as a source of healing for many ailments.
I feel deeply grateful for Islam, as it provides guidance that goes beyond the material world, addressing such as the soul and spiritual well-being. In my work with individuals experiencing mental illness, I’ve come to understand how challenging it must be to cope without the support of Allah and His divine guidance through Islam. It’s difficult to imagine navigating such struggles without the light of faith. I worked within the mental health field and I wondered what would I tell someone who lacks this connection with Allah, to uplift them from the darkness they find themselves in. SubhanaAllah.
JazakumAllah Khair for this wonderful and educational video.
this interview is one of the best and the most useful videos i have ever seen
MashAllah, what a valuable information we truly need. Thank you all for your efforts.
mashallah thank you for this wonderful information!
جزاكما الله خيرا و اجعله في ميزان حسناتكم
اللهم نساله حسن الخاتمة و صل الله على سيدنا محمد و على اله و صحبه اجمعين
Very interesting. Thank you.
I'm reminded that Buddhism, which is very much its own style of Psychology, originated during the 400s (5th century).
Brilliant, simply brilliant!
Brava Francesca e grazie per il tuo incredibile lavoro.
Very interesting, thank you for this presentation.
Masha Allah dear sister, beautiful talk
British scientist Arthur Allison, who was head of the Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering at the University of London, also presented two important papers in the year
1985 when he came to Cairo to participate in the Islamic Medical Conference on the scientific miracle in the Qur’an and presented two research papers: methods of psychological and spiritual treatment in light of the Holy Qur’an, and another research study on the relationship between sleep and death.
The relationship between death and sleep was a research study to discover the secret of the soul’s exit. He mentioned to him that an Egyptian young man believed that there was a relationship between sleep and death, and this was the reason for his scientific research.
The Egyptian young man told him that there is a Qur’anic text that mentions the relationship between the exit of the soul at death and sleep, so he became interested in this topic and presented scientific research on it.
He later converted to Islam
The soul has no place in psychology, it is a religious concept.
@@erique-eljovenactually it is a scientific fact. If by science you mean observable reality. But if by science you mean materialism then you are right. But that's exactly the problem. This is not a question about science but a question about ideology. Materialism is an ideology which cannot accept results or truths which are non material. Which is not a scientific question but rather a philosophical question
Which of the existing qurans is the holy one: Hafs, Walsh, Sannaa, Topkapi, Samarkant, Birmingham, Csiro edition….?
@@a.e.2990 troll.
@@yassersharif You did not engage in what I said. The video is about psychology, 'the soul' was mentioned. Once again: the soul has no place in psychology for it is a religious concept, something that still exists after death outside of the human body. Fairytale stuff.
There is not a single scientific discipine where the soul is acknowledged to exist.
Fascinating! There is so much need for Islamic psychology to be revived & built upon further...
Paul thank you for enlightening us. ❤
First time watching her speaking. Brilliant.
MashaAllah JazakAllah Khair
Interesting topic Thank you so much sister may Allah bless you more
Thanks dr Poul and my sister Francesca
This is very helpful, thank you
Francesca is great, masha2Allah
Malik Bardri was a great Sudanese thinker
I’m proud to be Sudanese
Fantastic discussion
I love her , i feel like she’s my mother
Mashallah thank you for this informative video
Keep educating the nation 🇵🇰
This topic is extremely important.
Yet, I’ve never heard someone that tackles issues of psychology the way Dr. Francesca is doing… those are points that people in the field never bring up because they are non-Muslims and this wonderful lady is Muslim and I truly appreciate the way she’s laying out things… is there a way that we can contact her and ask her some questions regarding this specific topic where it is a big part of my research please?
Still very informative however I guess we need a full explanation of basics (lecture) from Dr Franciska .. because sometimes I can't follow the structure of the conversation ,and I feel that I need more from previous points or I feel we have jumped a couple of points.
And as always thanks Paul for the interesting topics .
I think it's a new field, so there's not much research/ typical principles she can refer to. The chat gpt idea below seems appropriate, psychology is more and more popular in the western/ Americanized world, so merging Islamic ideas and psychology is a logical niche....
GPT summary..... Islamic psychology is a field that seeks to integrate psychological principles with Islamic teachings and values. Here are some cornerstone ideas that define Islamic psychology:
1. Unity of the Self (Tawhid): The concept of Tawhid, or the oneness of God, extends to the understanding of the self. In Islamic psychology, the self is seen as a holistic entity that encompasses the body, mind, and spirit. This unity emphasizes that mental health cannot be separated from spiritual well-being.
2. Purpose of Life: Islamic psychology emphasizes that human beings have a purpose, which is to worship God and live in accordance with His guidance. This sense of purpose can significantly influence mental health and well-being.
3. The Nature of the Soul (Nafs): The concept of the soul (Nafs) is central in Islamic psychology. It is believed that the Nafs has different levels, ranging from the base desires to the higher spiritual state. Understanding and nurturing the Nafs is essential for personal development and mental health.
4. Balance (Wasatiyyah): Islamic teachings advocate for balance in all aspects of life, including emotional and psychological health. This principle encourages individuals to find equilibrium between their spiritual, emotional, and social needs.
5. Moral and Ethical Framework: Islamic psychology is grounded in moral and ethical principles derived from the Quran and Hadith. These teachings guide individuals in their behavior, relationships, and mental health practices.
6. Community and Social Responsibility: The importance of community and social ties is emphasized in Islamic psychology. Mental health is viewed not only as an individual concern but also as a communal responsibility, where support systems play a crucial role.
7. Spirituality and Faith: Spirituality is considered a vital component of psychological well-being in Islamic psychology. Practices such as prayer (Salah), remembrance of God (Dhikr), and reading the Quran are seen as beneficial for mental health.
8. Coping Mechanisms: Islamic psychology encourages the use of faith-based coping strategies, such as reliance on God (Tawakkul), patience (Sabr), and gratitude (Shukr), to deal with life's challenges.
9. Holistic Healing: Treatment approaches in Islamic psychology often emphasize holistic healing, incorporating spiritual practices alongside conventional psychological methods to address mental health issues.
10. Recognition of Human Dignity: Every individual is viewed as having inherent dignity and worth, which influences how they should be treated in therapeutic settings. This principle fosters compassion and respect in mental health care.
These cornerstone ideas reflect a comprehensive approach to understanding human behavior and mental health through the lens of Islamic teachings, integrating spiritual, psychological, and social dimensions.
Really great analysis. Thanks a lot.
Very good discussion 🎉😊
Mashallah, alhamdulillah.
Let's give Islam another 1400 years to discover the energy body and why it's relevant for health and spirituality
Alhamdulillah ☝🏻🌹❤️🥰
Loved the video. Keep it going.
It would be wrong to refer to this clip as educational.. a more appropriate description is that I found it to be enriching not just educational
I didn't listen to this but I have no doubt that Islam psychology is the clear winner over Western psychology.
the lady emphasised the moral aspect of the soul rather than a metaphysical soul
very interesting, thank you
Wonderful video!
Glad you liked it!
سبحان الله وبحمده
سبحان الله العظيم
❤i enjoyed a lot thanks
I must go more than once..so that I grasp..
Very insightful ❤
Sir & Madam, islam overwhelmed
by west.
The NEW Muslims ❤
May Allah protect the old and the new members of our Beloved Prophets Ummah saw
MashaALLAH
Waiting for part 3
next week inshaAllah
Is this the first female guest on your channel? جزاك اللهُ
I need to report religious misconduct and abuse of power. Who do I report it to?
Brother Paul, you can invite Dr Sorowar Hossain of Bangladesh . He is a professor of Independent University Bangladesh. He has researched about LGBTQ issues and how it is being covertly imposed . I think he will be able express his insight in your show. He is facing a lot of threats as well.
Enriching experience.
Thanks
السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ
Assalamu’alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh
❤❤
Unfortunately as a non Muslim I have some serious gaps, chat gpt plugs a lot, but perhaps people from an Islamic background can give a clearer picture regarding one question I have. Assuming that Muslim psychologists / psychiatrists / psychotherapists are a new phenomenon, who have Moslem women traditionally turned to in order to seek help to solve spiritual / mental health problems?
Good question. Let me try answering that for you: While Muslim women can experience bouts of depression at times of loss in their lives, majority turn back to Allah and the Quran which are Healers from the Soul Levels.
When Allah says, “Remember Me; I will remember you,” (humans who are willing to be healed by His Majesty), Allah is serious, not just a high status symbol like human priests or leaders)-who have been known to take advantage of vulnerable girls and women-as the Me, Too Movement has illustrated.
This is why our five daily prayers to the One Majesty of the entire universe allows Muslim women (and men and children mature), to form the largest connection ever known to humans. Prayers are a direct line between the human and the Divine. And as Quran teaches before every Sura, “Allah is the Most Compassionate, Most Merciful.” (He is not a “god that man can destroy” by cruelty or whim is in polytheistic cultures of olden times).
Through the process of prayers as a regular way of life, Muslim women do not “need” men or things or attachments that average people think they need to feel good about themselves.
When one prays with full mind, soul, body and attitude in full submission towards the Divine/(Allah), after ablutions and purifications, a certain calm comes over the restless human soul and body that is unlike any other supposed “healing” that most people talk about. And nature itself is a witness, (not a pantheistic attribute), of God Almighty’s daily workings. If you’ve ever seen leaves and trees and flowers and gentle creatures prostrating before the Divine, it is also a healing experience on the inside of the human mind and body:
Sura The Bee, 16:48, “Have they (humans) not observed all things that Allah has created, how their shadows incline to the right and to the left, making prostration to Allah, and they are lowly?”
When we begin learning Quran’s Arabic at early ages -I learned at five from my blessed mother -the euphonic and mellifluous quality of it causes additional healing on the inside, mending the broken parts that we humans may have suffered at different times in human life.
Finally, Muslim women are first and foremost lovers of Allah, so they are peacemakers and peacekeepers by nature: this is yet another reason that Allah blesses the innermost tranquility of the human heart. And their families and communities are like angels and guardians to us-when something bad happens, we can turn to the sisters and cousins and friends of Faith -who have deep empathy. Community is integrated with Faith practices, and some women go to mosque, while others simply pray at home: it’s a personal choice. Muslim women also do not need to act desperate for attention as many western counterparts will tend to show off their bodies and try to become popular with groups of people: this bad habit that some women have learned, who don’t know much about Quran or Islam, ends up destroying their mental health, creating havoc and tensions in their Freud-filled angst of emptiness, and craving harmful and addictive things with which they allow themselves to be abused, God forbid. If you ever noticed the high level of suicides by influencers, both male and female, their lust, urges for attention, and popularity contests become their own personal idols, killing their self-esteem and good feelings about themselves or their physicality -that no amount of yoga or bodybuilding will cure. Narcissistic attitudes that require people to help the individual end up failing themselves in the long-run, (as recent young, rich, but unfit spiritually -celebrities who have jumped off buildings or stalked people or killed themselves or others)….Sura 58:14, “Have you not seen those who take for friends a people with whom Allah is angry? They are neither of you nor of them, and they swear a false oath knowingly.” This implies that many people will lead their own so-called friends into the path of destruction and despair because: A. Misery loves company, and B. Those who cannot follow their own given Revelations, taught in earlier tribes, cannot respect your revelations-and Allah says that do not trust those “who Jest about your religion.”
Healing comes from Divine Source: Allah gives so much healing that one would finally understand the dichotomies between mere human and Divine.
Hi!
A very valid question!
We need to look at the question from a broader perspective.
If you have already read into the topic then you will have come across the various therapists talking about psychological disorders stemming many times from the big and small Ts.
Big Trauma like eg natural disasters, war, horrible accidents, sexual abuse, physical abuse etc.
Small Traumas are where neglect is involved and things which should have happened didn't happen - refer to attachment theory.
Societies were indeed more wholesome with regards to bringing up children, support is not just through parents but also extended family and neighborhood were involved in raising new generations.
Islamic psychologists weren't really needed as ppl in general were grounded well because of a wholesome upbringing.
As for the big Ts... disasters and accidents are seen as destined by God in His ultimate wisdom and as Muslims generally speaking we deal with such "bad" events through patience and turning back to God.
The same goes for wars. They are men made but in the end of someone fights for what he believes then the believe outweighs the negative of war.
Now you will ask how about sexual abuse - I will say that with certainty this horrible thing did hardly exist before in an Islamic society just because of its horrific nature plus the penal code in an Islamic state would call for death penalty for it.
I come from a Catholic background and reverted to Islam round 30 years ago.
The moral decay and godlessness wether it is in western or starting to creep into Islamic societies is a big contributer to having people now with mental health issues.
You will find online many therapists who will advocate in their treatments to include faith based treatment.
Humans need moral guidelines and rules to live by in order to be both physically and mentally healthy.
All this said, it's not just muslim women but also men who struggle
Have a nice day :)
@JDforeveralone thank you, I made an assumption that traditionally religuous leaders were turned to, that they were men and it was not appropriate for women to mix with them, but that's based on
1 - a comparison with the Catholic and orthodox church
2 - ideas about free mixing I saw Ali dawha criticised of when he had debates between men and women.
I don't know much at all, and for some reason chat GPT is vague when it answers this question.
@@MrJohnaiton you're welcome!
The debates by Ali Dawah were criticised because of how they were conducted plus the dress code of some of the ladies (improper Hijab, makeup etc). Plus that it was more of an entertainment show with no real benefit.
The religious leaders (imams and sheikhs) are mainly being turned to when one has got a question regarding a type of worship or a dispute between ppl, or in jurisdictional issues. And that has always been allowed for women too to go and seek advice/knowledge. You have stories from the time of the prophet Muhammad peace and blessings upon him where the women went to him to inquire.
This is not considered mixing.
Yes, chatgpt is very useful but has its limits.
❤
Because it is too undefined and critical
Who is this smart sister?
Could a newborn baby's talk/speak by itself without mimicking their ancestor ??!! Peace be upon us all and assalamualaiqum wmt
I always think about the psychology of islam how its facinated
Fantastic discussion. May Allah preserve them both. Ruqiyah is part of phycology.
Would looove if sister makes an e learning Islamic psychology... inchallah
The first " like"
OH wow, thats debunk a lot of convos in twitter tweet war...
Thank you Paul.
رحمه الله رحمة واااااسعة واسكنه فسيح جناته
MashaAllah❤
🌹🌹🌹🍉🍉🍉🤲🤲❤️❤️❤️
Francesca is too eager to speak and too quick, particularly with a subject like this. And never forget that Judaism stands for light, Christianity for love, Islam for strength or powers. The three belong to each other, when there is light and no power, there is nothing amd love is the binding factor.
Clean and repair your gut, the stomach is your second brain
Abrahamic religion is the origin of reductive materialism. It makes no sense to critique this from an abarahamic perspective.