Hello guys for me yes they're both the same,and they have thier own style style for singing,but if i will choose i go for lyca why? because she just sing randomly without any practice and not prepared and still she sing almost perfect, compared to janine when she sing that is her winning piece,so she did a lot of practice so that her performance will come out excellent,but anyway this only my opinion guys and thank you for your reaction have a good time stay safe always ❤ peace and much love!
Nope hindi po nagtraining si Janine bago sya sumali sa TNT. If napanood nyo, binigyan sila ng song at gagawan nila ng sarili nilang arrangement para kantahin kinabukasan. Sarili pong rendition yung kay Janine na narinig na ni Lyca bago pa nya kantahin sa live nya. Yung sa video ni Lyca, kabisado na nya that time yung version ni Janine kasi nakanta na ni Lyca yan sa isang mall show ilang days or weeks right after nanalo si Janine sa TNT so hindi po sya random at walang practice.
Ang ibig Kong sabihin is when janine sing this song pang performance yon eh OK,Samantala Yong kay lyca nakanta lang na nakaupo at nasa bahay lang ,walang paghahanda na nangyayari kundi ito'y random lang at very Raw lang talga, parehas din nman silang magaling at nasubaybayan kodin nman journey ni janine eh OK,so kaya no hates pero kailangan pumuli base sa naka post dito,so kaya nga pinili ko yong batang kinakantahan ang puso ng mga masang pilipino,hindi lang sa pagbibirit binabase ang pagkanta ng isang tao,salamat at ingat tayong lahat peace ✌ and much love ❤
@@maritesalvarez3452 kumanta din naman si Janine from the heart. At walang masama kung pasigaw yung pagkanta nya kasi ganun talaga mag belting, specially rock yung kanta, kelangan ng power at conviction.
My ❤️ says it's Lyca..it was a raw performance but the emotion was there and the raspiness of her voice made me awe!! But they are both great singers on their own voice characterestics..
Si lyca live sa kanya si Jenine sa laban nya sa Tnt syempre ginalingan nya grand finals yan samantalang si lyca live lang sya sa bahay nila pero mas maganda pandinig ko sa pagkanta nya kaya.. Lyca pa rin kami
Both of them are good singers but they got a diffirent type of voice..Lyca is so flexible voice nd very good controling her voice too i love her husky voice..so goes to Lyca..
You're commenting with bias...you must compare two concert videos to make it fair...raw ang performance ni Lyca, nasa bahay Lang but si Janine nasa studio with state of the art effects and studio👎👎👎👎be fair to choose the right videos to compare
Para sa akin kay lyca ako naka upo lang yun ha at sa bahay Lang sya naka live Pero kuhang kuha nya Mas magaling talaga c lyca natural Lang Pag kanta nya no tune ❤️
Lyca is the winner kasi banal na aso is not her orignal version but she give a twist of it and her voice is Raw unlike janine this is her original version from tnt grandfinals performance of course mas nabibigyan niya ng kulay o suntok ang kanta.
I like lyca, with a nice voice, and pretty..janine masakit sa tainga parang nsgsisigaw palagi, at tudo practice yan, while lyca was just seating ang calm...
I vote for lyca c lyca pra sa kin pinkamgali g kgit ànung janra kya ang galing na ng boses nia grabe sv nga ni david lañas versatile singer.Ah basta pra sakin c lyca ang magaling.
Of vourse panalo si janina kasi nasa stage xa nagpakitang Giles xa Si lyca nasa kwarto lang jasama ang kapatid Kung nasa stage din xa ganon din xa kalakas kumanta .. I go for lyca ❤❤❤❤
At galing nyang kumontrol ng boses nya mula s mataas maibaba nya ng wlng sablay grabe...nabirit pero ndi pasigaw...sarp s tenga di nkakaaawang ulit ulitin pakinggan mga awitin nya❤
Un ky Lyka kc live n kantahan lng wag niong e compare ky Janine n competition sympre gagalingan nia at nag isip cia ng magandang version ng kanta nia. my only concern in opinion
Magaling din si Lyca pero inangkin talaga ni Janine yang kanta. Ginagamit na yung version nya sa mga contest sa tv o kahit sa mga amateur contests sa mga brgy.
Si Lyca nasa bahay lang po kumakanta Hindi Nasa crowd, piliin po sana Ang pag compare nasa stage si Janine samantalang si Lyca nasa bahay at naka upo pa. It's not fair on how you compare Lyca to Janine.
They are both good I just want to give my opinion about this battle that what you called it.... Janine was prepared and went trough training to perform so it will come out this good..I'm not saying that she's not good without proper training ..in the other hand Lyca sang it without training I think she did it randomly because if you notice it guys it was her weekend singing session with her Lil sister and she still showcased her Talent. She was just sitting there singing like she is just playing ... very raw.by the way Thank you for ur reactions.
No, Janine has no training prior to joining the contest, not even a vocal lesson. She was given less than a day to come up with her OWN rendition/arrangement for the song. Lyca has already heard Janine's version long before she sang it in one of her singing sessions. I'm actually more impressed with Janine, just by making her own rendition and she made it her own. She's also a songwriter so that explains why. I agree Lyca is also good. She covered Janine's rendition well. But don't make it sound like it was an unfair comparison in favor of Janine.
@@lynnjaro3255 it was just my opinion...don't get mad. Your vote goes to whoever u like to vote my dear. And by the way Janine was trained already in here it was her finale entry.
kay Lyca hinde pa yon concert at walang practice..ginamit na ni janine yong kanta nya sa grand final naka pag practice xa at naka tayo pa..c Lyca naka upo partida yon dba?
Wag na pagkumparahin.. Lyca's 13M views on WishBus will tell it so dika makakdecide sa iisang kanta dahil magkaibang venue at sound system ang ginamit.. belt runs squeek.. all in one on Lyca's 7mins. vid..hope janine can perform same on wish bus.
no comparison at all... how come that you compared lyca to janine , where as janine is performing in front of the crowd with her masterpiece... while lyca is just singing in her own music room... dapat patas ang labanan...
Paano d sya magpakitang gilas.. Syempre grand finals yan ng Tnt syempre gagalingan nya para manalo sa tnt.. Pero si lyca live lang sya sa Facebook page nya hahaha.. Wala pang praktis yan nakaupo lang.. Kay lyca pa rin kami
Morisette Amon queen pilipana NO.1.!!..!! Sara diva pilipina..LYCA DIVA BABY PILIIPINA.!!! filipna artis vioce beutiful..!!! Amazing n powerful..!!! I love it lyca.!!! Salam saudara dri semporna sabah malysia..!!!❤❤😘
Sana walang comparison kasi every singer or artist has its own unique of voice and singing, style , age experienced , vocal chord, voice box, also listeners, iba iba ang appreciation ng tao , so no comparison po para sa akin, akin lang pong opinion, salamat po
Don ako s original Kay Lyca,, KC xa s bahay lng xa kumakanta,, at ung gamit nya n mike d katulad ng MGA ginagamit sa concert,, may ng aayos ng mga ginagamit s stage..,,kya Kay Lyca ako...
@@mariadeleon1474 may kanya kanya tayong taste,,kya don k s gusto mo pero d mo mapipilit ang Tao s Kung cnong ang gustuhin nila,,,basta kmi Lyca prin...
@Abu Dhabi 22 Lyca was using a dynamic mic. Halos pareho lng ng ginagamit sa mga concert. At video nya mismo ginamit nilang clip. Yung kay Janine kuha lang ng isang fan gamit ang cellphone, so di gaanong na pick up ng audio yung natural voice ni Janine na napaka unique.
Goosebumps sbi nung isa.. Tungek syempre magkaiba sila ng location ng kinanta nila yan.. 😂 😂 😂 Si Janine prepared unlike Lyca nakaupo p sya.. So sino ngayon mas magaling.. 😁 😁 😁
para s akin c lyca iba KC tlaga Ang hatak nya once magsimula n syang kumanta birit manyan o ano p Yan tlagang madadala ka. Kaya tuwang tuwa ako Basta c Ovela saka David lañas Ang nagreact k baby lyca kita mo talaga Ang tuwa nila.....
Bayas kau ja kc janine talagang nag perform sa stage samantalang c Lyca naka upo lang na para lang silang nakaraoke sa hous nya w/her sister bayas ya para sa akin..
Not a fair comparison, dahil sa fancam lang yung kay Janine, di mo halos marinig ng buo yung uniqueness ng boses nya. Pangit yung kuha ng fan, basag yung audio kasi cp lang gamit.
@@celtv686 Kasi nga cellphone camera lang yung kuha kay Janine. Mas maganda kung ginamit nila yung sa contest sa abscbn. Dami nagsasabi na unfair daw e pareho lang naman sila. Si Lyca nasa bahay lang pero maganda naman yun mic nya, ok yung audio. Si Janine nasa stage nga pero kuha lng ng fan gamit ang cp camera.
Hello guys for me yes they're both the same,and they have thier own style style for singing,but if i will choose i go for lyca why? because she just sing randomly without any practice and not prepared and still she sing almost perfect, compared to janine when she sing that is her winning piece,so she did a lot of practice so that her performance will come out excellent,but anyway this only my opinion guys and thank you for your reaction have a good time stay safe always ❤ peace and much love!
Nope hindi po nagtraining si Janine bago sya sumali sa TNT. If napanood nyo, binigyan sila ng song at gagawan nila ng sarili nilang arrangement para kantahin kinabukasan. Sarili pong rendition yung kay Janine na narinig na ni Lyca bago pa nya kantahin sa live nya. Yung sa video ni Lyca, kabisado na nya that time yung version ni Janine kasi nakanta na ni Lyca yan sa isang mall show ilang days or weeks right after nanalo si Janine sa TNT so hindi po sya random at walang practice.
Ang ibig Kong sabihin is when janine sing this song pang performance yon eh OK,Samantala Yong kay lyca nakanta lang na nakaupo at nasa bahay lang ,walang paghahanda na nangyayari kundi ito'y random lang at very Raw lang talga, parehas din nman silang magaling at nasubaybayan kodin nman journey ni janine eh OK,so kaya no hates pero kailangan pumuli base sa naka post dito,so kaya nga pinili ko yong batang kinakantahan ang puso ng mga masang pilipino,hindi lang sa pagbibirit binabase ang pagkanta ng isang tao,salamat at ingat tayong lahat peace ✌ and much love ❤
Appreciate your view on this. Point taken. Dahil jan, pwede lumaban si Luca sa wild card namen. Abangan! 😉
Yes , true! Kumakanta c lyca from the heart... Hindi sigaw!
@@maritesalvarez3452 kumanta din naman si Janine from the heart. At walang masama kung pasigaw yung pagkanta nya kasi ganun talaga mag belting, specially rock yung kanta, kelangan ng power at conviction.
My ❤️ says it's Lyca..it was a raw performance but the emotion was there and the raspiness of her voice made me awe!! But they are both great singers on their own voice characterestics..
di pwede icompare.. nasa magkaibang sitwasyon sila.. pero mas gusto ko boses ni lyca kahit sa ibang pagkanta nya..
Lyca
Si lyca live sa kanya si Jenine sa laban nya sa Tnt syempre ginalingan nya grand finals yan samantalang si lyca live lang sya sa bahay nila pero mas maganda pandinig ko sa pagkanta nya kaya.. Lyca pa rin kami
LYCA IS THE BEST FOR ME.SHE SING SO WELL KHT NAKAUPO LNG SYA.ETONG ISA NSA STAGE PNGHANDAAN.I LOVE YOU LYCA.GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS!!!!!!❤❤❤💚💚💚
Bsa stage pla siya si Lyca nakaupo lnh
Hahah kompRa se lyca naka opo lang heheh elong berden denogtongan hahah
Mga tanga mga tanga tng nag rreac alam na se lyca ay nag blag lang awet kenompara gago
For me my vote goes to Lyca...why? It was raw no auto tune added. Very natural.
They sang it both raw and no autotune. What are you talking about?
Agree
bakit mo naman naisip na may autotune ang isang penerform sa singing contest?hahaha singing contest nga yun e langya ka hahaha
for me is lyca..wala xang practice jan sa fb live lang nya yan sa bahay..Lyca👏👏👏partida pa naka upo pa c Lyca.
Bati pa kayo kunwari Kay lyka kapi Naman kayo Kay be ritukada he
Lyca ♥️
Lyca for me.
Both of them are good singers but they got a diffirent type of voice..Lyca is so flexible voice nd very good controling her voice too i love her husky voice..so goes to Lyca..
You're commenting with bias...you must compare two concert videos to make it fair...raw ang performance ni Lyca, nasa bahay Lang but si Janine nasa studio with state of the art effects and studio👎👎👎👎be fair to choose the right videos to compare
Para sa akin kay lyca ako naka upo lang yun ha at sa bahay Lang sya naka live Pero kuhang kuha nya Mas magaling talaga c lyca natural Lang Pag kanta nya no tune ❤️
Isa p yan ang kinanta ni janine non final ng twag ng tanghalan nsanayan n niya yon kanta.
Si Lyca maganda ksi iniba niya ang style.
Lyca is the winner kasi banal na aso is not her orignal version but she give a twist of it and her voice is Raw unlike janine this is her original version from tnt grandfinals performance of course mas nabibigyan niya ng kulay o suntok ang kanta.
I go for lyca
For me I go for lyca..
Lyca mas ok sa akin
I like lyca, with a nice voice, and pretty..janine masakit sa tainga parang nsgsisigaw palagi, at tudo practice yan, while lyca was just seating ang calm...
Lyca ako...may puso kung kumanta..
Ilove Lyca.. nakaupo pa yan kyang kya ang high notes at ganda ng rasp ng voice nya
Solid Lyca❤️
I like Lyca coz her voice is flexible and she sings naturally. Janine is also good singer but i like the voice and simplicity of Lyca ❤️
MAS MAGALING SI LYCA
LYCA,, please don't compare Lyca sa nag perform on stage it's not fair.
For me i vote for Lyca !
I like lyca
Really love the version of lyca,,,kinakanta nya yan para lng cya naglalaro bonding with her little sister live sa you tube channel nya.
I vote for lyca
c lyca pra sa kin pinkamgali g kgit ànung janra kya
ang galing na ng boses nia grabe
sv nga ni david lañas versatile singer.Ah basta pra sakin c lyca ang magaling.
I like Lyca.👍👍👍
Of vourse panalo si janina kasi nasa stage xa nagpakitang Giles xa
Si lyca nasa kwarto lang jasama ang kapatid
Kung nasa stage din xa ganon din xa kalakas kumanta ..
I go for lyca ❤❤❤❤
tama
Kaya nga e
At galing nyang kumontrol ng boses nya mula s mataas maibaba nya ng wlng sablay grabe...nabirit pero ndi pasigaw...sarp s tenga di nkakaaawang ulit ulitin pakinggan mga awitin nya❤
I love them both but lyca is👌😉
Mas maganda Kay Lyka.d masakit s tenga.
lyca 4me idol ko yan🥰♥️♥️♥️
Of course Bebe lyca ❤️❤️
They are both good singer but for me Lyca is the best
Lyca pa rin!
I go for Janine...marami nang nakakagawa Ng Kay Lyca while Janine the quality of her voice is very unique.
Mas msrp s tenga ang boses ni lyca kh8 nabirit p at me tama s puso ng mga lisrener...so i vote lyca❤
my vote goes to Lyca....nakaupo pa yun. And come to think of it, concert yung kay Janine so ibig sabihin pinaghandaan talaga.
Yeah! That's true. For me I choose lyca forever.
galing mo talaga lyca
Unanimous decision ng reactor, but most of viewers LYCA ang votes., 🤣 Lyca pa rin!
For me lyca
For me my favor is for Lyca,why?c Janine NASA isang event syempre IBA ang ibinigay nyang performance,while Lyca NASA house Lang
Gusto ko lyca kc parang ang timing ng knta nya sarap sa tynga
Lyca baby
❤️Lyca❤️
For me si Lyka
I love lyca
Mas magling c Lyca
I go for lyca kasi maganda mga high notes nya.at mga pakulot kulot sa mga wordings nya,kahit anong kanta,kayang kaya nya
Un ky Lyka kc live n kantahan lng wag niong e compare ky Janine n competition sympre gagalingan nia at nag isip cia ng magandang version ng kanta nia. my only concern in opinion
Its Lyka, hindi kelangan sumigaw para makuha ang gandang pagkanta
Magaling din si Lyca pero inangkin talaga ni Janine yang kanta. Ginagamit na yung version nya sa mga contest sa tv o kahit sa mga amateur contests sa mga brgy.
Lyca is best I love her😘😘😘😘
Si Lyca nasa bahay lang po kumakanta Hindi Nasa crowd, piliin po sana Ang pag compare nasa stage si Janine samantalang si Lyca nasa bahay at naka upo pa. It's not fair on how you compare Lyca to Janine.
For me its lyca...shes the best She sang naturally live no practice hahaha...its unfair guyz
my vote goes to lyca
Gusto ko ung voice quality ni lyca.,nakaupo pa Yan.
Lyca pa rin kasi nakaupo lang. Siya. At sa bahay lng nila siya nag perform
Lyca galing
Lyca ako,
I like lyca is the best
They are both good I just want to give my opinion about this battle that what you called it.... Janine was prepared and went trough training to perform so it will come out this good..I'm not saying that she's not good without proper training ..in the other hand Lyca sang it without training I think she did it randomly because if you notice it guys it was her weekend singing session with her Lil sister and she still showcased her Talent. She was just sitting there singing like she is just playing ... very raw.by the way Thank you for ur reactions.
No, Janine has no training prior to joining the contest, not even a vocal lesson. She was given less than a day to come up with her OWN rendition/arrangement for the song. Lyca has already heard Janine's version long before she sang it in one of her singing sessions. I'm actually more impressed with Janine, just by making her own rendition and she made it her own. She's also a songwriter so that explains why. I agree Lyca is also good. She covered Janine's rendition well. But don't make it sound like it was an unfair comparison in favor of Janine.
Yes, I agree with your opinion, very well said talaga
@@lynnjaro3255 it was just my opinion...don't get mad. Your vote goes to whoever u like to vote my dear. And by the way Janine was trained already in here it was her finale entry.
My vote goes to lyca kc naka upo pa yon ha,samantalang c janine todo practice kc pag final nya yon eh
kay Lyca hinde pa yon concert at walang practice..ginamit na ni janine yong kanta nya sa grand final naka pag practice xa at naka tayo pa..c Lyca naka upo partida yon dba?
I choose lyca she is the best mapaupo mapatayo xa kumanta nd xa nahihirapan at gaan ng feeling proud of you lyca
Wag na pagkumparahin.. Lyca's 13M views on WishBus will tell it so dika makakdecide sa iisang kanta dahil magkaibang venue at sound system ang ginamit.. belt runs squeek.. all in one on Lyca's 7mins. vid..hope janine can perform same on wish bus.
no comparison at all... how come that you compared lyca to janine , where as janine is performing in front of the crowd with her masterpiece... while lyca is just singing in her own music room... dapat patas ang labanan...
Tama!
I agree to that.
Kay lyca ako,,,
agree..!!!100%
Lyca parin ako.
I'll go for lyca..same us other commenters reasons..😊😊😊
Janine Berdin of course!
Lyca go
Lyca the best skin
Paano d sya magpakitang gilas.. Syempre grand finals yan ng Tnt syempre gagalingan nya para manalo sa tnt.. Pero si lyca live lang sya sa Facebook page nya hahaha.. Wala pang praktis yan nakaupo lang.. Kay lyca pa rin kami
lyca parin si jannine subrang practice si lyca live na wlang practce galing2 wow
Morisette Amon queen pilipana NO.1.!!..!! Sara diva pilipina..LYCA DIVA BABY PILIIPINA.!!! filipna artis vioce beutiful..!!! Amazing n powerful..!!! I love it lyca.!!! Salam saudara dri semporna sabah malysia..!!!❤❤😘
Lyca is a good singer but Janine is so musically gifted.
Sana walang comparison kasi every singer or artist has its own unique of voice and singing, style , age experienced , vocal chord, voice box, also listeners, iba iba ang appreciation ng tao , so no comparison po para sa akin, akin lang pong opinion, salamat po
Lyca po
Lyca for sure
Don ako s original Kay Lyca,, KC xa s bahay lng xa kumakanta,, at ung gamit nya n mike d katulad ng MGA ginagamit sa concert,, may ng aayos ng mga ginagamit s stage..,,kya Kay Lyca ako...
Hindi kayo marunong mag judge ng mas magandang boses he
@@mariadeleon1474 may kanya kanya tayong taste,,kya don k s gusto mo pero d mo mapipilit ang Tao s Kung cnong ang gustuhin nila,,,basta kmi Lyca prin...
agree ako jan sa original,🤣lahat kay lyca original walang fake ❤️❤️❤️
@Abu Dhabi 22 Lyca was using a dynamic mic. Halos pareho lng ng ginagamit sa mga concert. At video nya mismo ginamit nilang clip. Yung kay Janine kuha lang ng isang fan gamit ang cellphone, so di gaanong na pick up ng audio yung natural voice ni Janine na napaka unique.
Goosebumps sbi nung isa.. Tungek syempre magkaiba sila ng location ng kinanta nila yan.. 😂 😂 😂 Si Janine prepared unlike Lyca nakaupo p sya.. So sino ngayon mas magaling.. 😁 😁 😁
For me lyca is the best.
Khit anung janra pede.
Her voice isamazing and
lyca is versatile singer.
I vote for Lyca
I go for Lyca kc she's singing from her heart
I still go for lyca... There's nothing to compare in the first place. You should atleast chose the right video.
My vote goes to baby Lyca
Lycagrnd lang sakalam🏆💪
Janine siyempre one of the best
song na kinanta ni janine ang banal
na aso nun tnt journey niya sobrang
nagalingan na ako sa kanya
For me, lyca nkaupo lng yan uh.
para sa akin si lyca kasi naka upo at wala sa consert.
para s akin c lyca iba KC tlaga Ang hatak nya once magsimula n syang kumanta birit manyan o ano p Yan tlagang madadala ka. Kaya tuwang tuwa ako Basta c Ovela saka David lañas Ang nagreact k baby lyca kita mo talaga Ang tuwa nila.....
Lyca best
to think of it,version ang ginamit ni lyca,.that means,janine's original version is much better...
Bayas kau ja kc janine talagang nag perform sa stage samantalang c Lyca naka upo lang na para lang silang nakaraoke sa hous nya w/her sister bayas ya para sa akin..
lyca is the best..no one cud beat her unique voice
Lyka,dahil nakaupo lang siya samantala si Janine nasa concert syempre.practisado.
Not a fair comparison, dahil sa fancam lang yung kay Janine, di mo halos marinig ng buo yung uniqueness ng boses nya. Pangit yung kuha ng fan, basag yung audio kasi cp lang gamit.
tama
Korek Di mo maintindian kanta clean I hear lyca kahit nakaupo siya yong birit niya ramdam mo kanta.
@@celtv686 Kasi nga cellphone camera lang yung kuha kay Janine. Mas maganda kung ginamit nila yung sa contest sa abscbn. Dami nagsasabi na unfair daw e pareho lang naman sila. Si Lyca nasa bahay lang pero maganda naman yun mic nya, ok yung audio. Si Janine nasa stage nga pero kuha lng ng fan gamit ang cp camera.
FOR US HERE IS WAS LYCA...
I both like them but how can you compare Lyca has no audience,so no adrenaline,I still love and like Lyca
No comparison at all.Because Lyca was sitting down in a room while singing. And Janine was performing infront of a big crowd.
You can't compare kasi yong kay lyca nasa bahay lng yon,,yong kay Janine grabing practice na yon.
Mas may angas yong kay lyca.