Because you can tell. If you listen to the recorded version and this performance than you will realize that it's a playback. But I don't really care...like I said I love Bill and his voice!! =DD
True it's playback... but in Europes in some tvshow and galas, artist are obliged to do playback -_-'. When they went to Montreal or Toronto, they played live!In english ;).
Gosh! I just LOVE this remake of "Instant Karma"! Playback or not!! :D This band is amazing! *v* I wish I would play at a same concert with them some day... =D (Ok... Let me daydream a little, please! XD)
Woah. i respect them. John wouldnt want us to hate... especially someone doing the honor of covering one of his songs...but people, get a grip. John lennon has more feeling... this seriously sounds like every other band.
its so cute the he looks like and does the same movements as wen he sang raining men wen he was younger ,at 0:55 he looks just like tht part on raining man and he uses that voice!
Super, amo esta version!! Personas que hablan sin saber, ellos no se burlan de John lennon con esto, mas bien creo que lo honran grabando su cancion, pedazos de retardados, dediquen tiempo a pensar y admitir que esta muy bien hecha la cancion. ♥ Los amo chicos.
oooooooooooooomg!!! this is sooo hot! xD I love the combination of the song and Bill's voice!!!! can you please send me this video!! I will be soo thankfull then!! please?? kisss
... more "super skirt bound" in this year the golden bravo petrol won, it for this birthday celebration to to frame for the action "make some noise" for msc internationally a song took up, and if it resounded now the volume in hears to then know it who comes now! here is instant Tokyo hotel with "karma"
@skateHYPE Wrong!!!! Here it is now 2011 and they have more fans then ever!! Not to mention adult fans. I'm in my 40's and I love Tokio Hotel's music! There are lots of fans of Tokio Hotel from 22 to 82!!!!
Aaaaaah na dann sach ma schöne Grüße... Ich würde von mir behaupten, Geschmack zu haben (Wenn du ne Auswahl haben willst: Muse, RHCP, The Used. Three Days Grace, My Darkest Days, Breaking Benjamin, Bob Dylan, LP - vorzugsweise die alten Sachen -, Green Day, Rise Against, Sum 41, blahblahblah) und was das Wissen angeht bin ich auch nicht ganz dumm. Ich höre also? :) btw, ich bin ein Mädchen (hallo, du bist grad auf nem TH video xD)
He looks slightly feminine, but no-one could possibly mistake him for a girl. What interviews have you seen? All of their interviews are very funny. This is their only cover and it was several years ago. I'm sure John Lennon would have liked to have his song a little more publicity through covers.
no your right i wont listen to them when im 30 and i know he wont be dressing like that in the future, but i like them now and what rude ppl say now affects me. and through your eyes you see them as a disgrace but i dont, so keep your opinons to yourself alright? i dont like starting lame internet fights.
HOLY SHOOT!!! Bill and Gustav are on FIRE!!!it was soo funny how Georg and Tom went on the front.idk why..but there was something funny about it!!!lol xD
here an example: look up "adam arcuragi" and his song "bottom of the river". that gives you shivers and its a proper singer-songwriter. wtf is this though?
It's amazing how much positive energy this song gives! And their version so much better than the original (i feel a bit sad saying this because i adore John Lennon and he is much more musical than Tom, Bill, Georg and Gustav together. but thats the truth! the original version is BORING!)
well, their fan base is so big because little 12 to 15 year old girls don't understand that all what they seem to be is just a show made by their record label.
Why are people watching videos they hate and then leave nasty comments, if you have nothing good to comment on this video (or any other video for that matter!) then DONT. tokio hotel rule!!
I am German I can it translated however I can English not well ^^:jetzt come we however from the most successful petrol winner (petrol is a price), with 9 golden otto's excellently to the current petrols winners, because they have in the most important category.....
well i don't think they know anything about john lennon and thats something that makes me sad. they may play that song if they want, but just think it's not right, because they try to satisfie their fans and not think of the spirit of this song and john lennon. maybe john would say the same. rest in peace. maybe they will realise it when they are not successful any more (that will not take too long :-D)
Well you didn't have to reply I just wanted to express how I felt about this band ..just like you are. I'm not personally trying to bring YOU down. So we can agree to disagree with eachother and leave it at that k.
tokio hotel, simply the best!!!!!!! I love Gustav!! the best drummer in the world!! kisses from Spain!!
I love their cover of this song! I love his voice.
Because you can tell. If you listen to the recorded version and this performance than you will realize that it's a playback.
But I don't really care...like I said I love Bill and his voice!! =DD
They're awesome 😀 And Bill is just so beautiful ❤
this must have been a fun instrumental to play, and Bill looked like he really enjoyed performing this song
Ah. Bill. YOU'RE STAGE ENERGY IS SO AMAZING. How is he so beautiful. How.
I like both versions, the original and this one. Each one has it's own distinctive style.
True it's playback... but in Europes in some tvshow and galas, artist are obliged to do playback -_-'. When they went to Montreal or Toronto, they played live!In english ;).
SORRY BUT THIS IS NOT ONE PLAYBACK BILL WILL NEVER ACCEPT TO MAKE ONE PLAYBACK
awesome! I love how Bill sings! :D ♥
yeah! me encanta esta version! le qdo zuper a Tokio Hotel :D
Wow I remember watching this vid at the start of this year & became an official TH fan
is the last bit a still fram or has my window frozen?
i love this song its my favorite and bill sings the song so well
Omg, John Lennon should be proud
Tokio hotel is the best cover for instant karma XDDD
How perfect voice could have!!!!!!!!!
That was so bad I really wouldn't even know where to start.
is there anybody that hears it in 2017??
There's someone from the middle of 2019!
2020 hereeee
2024
Gosh! I just LOVE this remake of "Instant Karma"! Playback or not!! :D This band is amazing! *v* I wish I would play at a same concert with them some day... =D (Ok... Let me daydream a little, please! XD)
NOT PLAYBACK BILL WILL NEVER ACCEPT TO MAKE ONE PLAYBACK
soooo mega geiles lied ever ...ich lieb edass lied mega
the best band!!!!I love you!!!!
I Love this song
I love Tokio Hotel
I'm a italian Fan
I LOVE this song!
Woah. i respect them. John wouldnt want us to hate... especially someone doing the honor of covering one of his songs...but people, get a grip. John lennon has more feeling... this seriously sounds like every other band.
i like their version
it hAs more life
it has a cool rythem
soo coool :D
i like both versions but i cant decide whos version i like better?
they both have very different postives about it!!
I love Bill's voice!!
Also he is lip singing but oh well. He is still a great singer no matter what.
thats right. no one is allowed to preform live on german award shows. even non-german artists.
its still a great cover
if that means we love Tokio Hotel for ever i totally agree ! ^.^
I CAN`T BELIEVE I FOUND THIS SONG JUST YET!!! AFTER 5 YEARS!! FUCK!!!
After listen to this song, i don't wanna live in this World anymore....
kei mooi en goed!!!
love bill
I love this song
I like this song:XI like Tokio Hotel,is the best group....
is this playback? cos it sounds like it, it sounds exactly the same as the recording... still love bill ;P
its so cute the he looks like and does the same movements as wen he sang raining men wen he was younger ,at 0:55 he looks just like tht part on raining man and he uses that voice!
i love tokio hotel version fo instant karma
Mies :D Aber das Lied ist heute noch genauso geil wie damals! xD
j'aime bien !!! super vidéo
Super, amo esta version!! Personas que hablan sin saber, ellos no se burlan de John lennon con esto, mas bien creo que lo honran grabando su cancion, pedazos de retardados, dediquen tiempo a pensar y admitir que esta muy bien hecha la cancion. ♥ Los amo chicos.
oooooooooooooomg!!! this is sooo hot! xD I love the combination of the song and Bill's voice!!!! can you please send me this video!! I will be soo thankfull then!!
please??
kisss
マジチョーかっけえ...
Super cooooool!!!!!!
... more "super skirt bound" in this year the golden bravo petrol won, it for this birthday celebration to to frame for the action "make some noise" for msc internationally a song took up, and if it resounded now the volume in hears to then know it who comes now! here is instant Tokyo hotel with "karma"
kablex93,
Tokio Hotel is not the only or the first band to have covered a Beatles song. Did you tell all the other bands and singers the same thing?
At this moment, Tokio Hotel was still Tokio Hotel!..
coolllll i love it
great this is better than john lennon. i love tokio hotel
@skateHYPE Wrong!!!! Here it is now 2011 and they have more fans then ever!! Not to mention adult fans. I'm in my 40's and I love Tokio Hotel's music! There are lots of fans of Tokio Hotel from 22 to 82!!!!
omg I love tokio hotel forrever and always!
wow... hamma!
I can't elieve it. the best :)
i think its awesome!!
Aaaaaah na dann sach ma schöne Grüße... Ich würde von mir behaupten, Geschmack zu haben (Wenn du ne Auswahl haben willst: Muse, RHCP, The Used. Three Days Grace, My Darkest Days, Breaking Benjamin, Bob Dylan, LP - vorzugsweise die alten Sachen -, Green Day, Rise Against, Sum 41, blahblahblah) und was das Wissen angeht bin ich auch nicht ganz dumm. Ich höre also? :) btw, ich bin ein Mädchen (hallo, du bist grad auf nem TH video xD)
this song is so good!:'D love it. does someone have it and can send it to me?(a)
I can't believe it's been 5 years !
This video is better, comparing it to john lennon's song i love th they 'r the best
Better than the original *-*
3:07 lol so cute haha
Did he sing with playback ??
I'm not sure that it's live, 'cause it sounds the same like in the song
He looks slightly feminine, but no-one could possibly mistake him for a girl.
What interviews have you seen? All of their interviews are very funny.
This is their only cover and it was several years ago.
I'm sure John Lennon would have liked to have his song a little more publicity through covers.
oh thank you for charing that:)
no your right i wont listen to them when im 30 and i know he wont be dressing like that in the future,
but i like them now and what rude ppl say now affects me.
and through your eyes you see them as a disgrace but i dont,
so keep your opinons to yourself alright?
i dont like starting lame internet fights.
HOLY SHOOT!!! Bill and Gustav are on FIRE!!!it was soo funny how Georg and Tom went on the front.idk why..but there was something funny about it!!!lol xD
um get your facts straight hes NOT emo,
for christs sake,
and why are you watching this just to leave rude comments huh?
to:skateHYPE
they should make a book with this title.
I love bill
i love when bills voice cracks its so hot!
i don´t think so
the john lennon´s version is the best
but thats a great cover, sound great
The voice and performance at Bill as always are grandiose! But the song at all does not approach him! Brr....
This is not a Beatles song. This is John's song ;)
here an example: look up "adam arcuragi" and his song "bottom of the river". that gives you shivers and its a proper singer-songwriter. wtf is this though?
They don't always do playback. Did anyone think that this may have been before his surgery?
nekem nagyon teccík
It's amazing how much positive energy this song gives!
And their version so much better than the original (i feel a bit sad saying this because i adore John Lennon and he is much more musical than Tom, Bill, Georg and Gustav together. but thats the truth! the original version is BORING!)
Perfect
what's up with instant karma? what is it? can anyone explain...
U can ask the transformation :)))
what is the name of the song? please i'm french...
well, their fan base is so big because little 12 to 15 year old girls don't understand that all what they seem to be is just a show made by their record label.
I think Lennon would cry. What's up with the Wii commercial on that screen?
john Lennon was all about peace and love he would not like the hate for this great boy (love)
My God! John Lennon wrote that song
@aspannas "I adore" ??? i DON'T UNDERSTAND !!!!
LOL!
yeah
it looked like they skipped together to
the front
=D
wa...amO la canciOn y mas cOn ellos...
pOes me wustO muxhO aunk alla sidO "playback"
ahaha...
i.luv.bill.♥
se la riifa bn bOniitO n____n
It's good to see new bands playing John... but the original is better.
Why are people watching videos they hate and then leave nasty comments, if you have nothing good to comment on this video (or any other video for that matter!) then DONT.
tokio hotel rule!!
The thing with the fire is so damn hotttt :DD
I LOVE *_______________*
I couldn't understand half of what he was saying, but damn that was hot
yeah and its originally made by John Lennon and not by this emoband!! bear that in mind please!! RIP Lennon luckily you don't need to hear this..
Bill is sure as hell instant karma
this voice OMG *-*
wait bill already had his puffy hair like that in 2006 i dont remember that?!
That's Nina Hagen, a very famous german star! (crazy as hell, but quite good!)
I am German I can it translated however I can English not well ^^:jetzt come we however from the most successful petrol winner (petrol is a price), with 9 golden otto's excellently to the current petrols winners, because they have in the most important category.....
lolz bill is... superBILL ...
he sings like a angel and came go thro the fires lolz THis was cool or hot actually lolz
It's better that Hello Goodbye by the jonas brothers. Anyway John Lennon ROCKs!
funny but i luv TH
well i don't think they know anything about john lennon and thats something that makes me sad.
they may play that song if they want, but just think it's not right, because they try to satisfie their fans and not think of the spirit of this song and john lennon. maybe john would say the same.
rest in peace. maybe they will realise it when they are not successful any more (that will not take too long :-D)
Gees, sounds like Marrlyn Manson backing band outtakes with monday night karaoke.
Must try harder.
you're right!!!!!
There are covers and then...there is this....
What do you mean?
Oni są cudowni ;) ;*;*;**
Well you didn't have to reply I just wanted to express how I felt about this band ..just like you are. I'm not personally trying to bring YOU down. So we can agree to disagree with eachother and leave it at that k.