Please confirm the ghustaakhe elements 1. Not denouncing his mureed reading molvi thanvi kalima? 2. Comparing the prophets gayb to that of a animals. 3. Him stating its better to think of a donkey in namaz rather than the prophet.
@@impae139 I don't get if these guys are so intelligent and have done quranic tafsir and know multiple languages and have followings of millions of people then why on earth would they write this crap?
Allah aur Nabi ke Gustaakh Deoband ke Shaitaani ilm rakhne waale 4 Maulana ke liye Bareilly ke Aala Hazrat Maulana Ahmad Raza Khan Rahmatullaahe Ta'aala Alaih akele hi kaafi they, kyun keh Chaaro Maulana ne apni kitaabon mayn Allah aur Nabi ki shaan mayn kaafi Gustaakhiyaan likhi thi jiski wajah se Aala Hazrat ne un Chaaro Maulana par Kufr ka Fatwa lagaaya aur Saudi Arab ke 294 Muftiyon ne uss Fatwa ko saheeh kaha aur uske baad Chaaro Maulana ne Tauba bhi nahi kiya aur aaj bhi woh sab Gustaakhiyaan unki kitaabon mayn maujood hai. *(1)* Moulwi Ashraf Ali Thaanwi. *(2)* Moulwi Rasheed Ahmad Gangohi. *(3)* Moulwi Khalil Ahmad Ambethwi. *(4)* Moulwi Qaasim Naanotwi. Yeh chaaron Kaafir Murtad hain. Jo in chaaron moulviyon ko musalmaan samjhe woh khud kaafir hojaayega. Aur jo in chaaron moulviyon ki paerwi karega woh bhi kaafir hojaayega. Please read Hassaamul Haramain written by Aala Hazrat Maulana Ahmad Raza Khan Rahmatullaahe Ta'aala Alaih.
A STORY by ASHRAF ALI THANVI. Ashraf Alee Thanvi says in his book Malfoozaath Volume 3 # Malfooz Number 41- Para 2 ....The third affair of strangeness is that a desciple (mureed) of Hadhrath Ghaws-al-Aadham ( referring to Shaykh Abd al Qaadir Jeelaanee rahimahullah which means Very Great Helper - This is why they invoke him in the times of need not just at his grave but anywhere, everywhere! Other Awliyaa and Saaliheen and Ambiyaa are considered just helpers but he is considered the greatest aider in the times of distress) narrated a strange incident which is quite astonishing which most probably I have come across in some book of Shaykh Abd-al-Haq Muhaddith Dehlavi. That once Hadhrath Ghaws-al-Aadham rahimahullah woke up in accordance with his mundane schedule for Salaah at-Thahajjud and stepped out of his monasterial hermitage (Khaankhaah) and this khaadim (desciple) aswell got together with him. After walking for a while they reached a town and soon afterwards entered a house in which there was a congregation and those people stood up after seeing him and he (the Shaykh rahimahullah) seated himself in a position while the desciple also seated himself in a corner. From a nearby chamber there could be heard a patient's groaning voice and after sometime this voice disappeared and four people exited (the chamber) with a janaazah and accompanied with them was an old person and this janaazah was placed in front of Hazrath (Shaykh Abd al-Qaadir) and he offered janaazah prayer soon after that congregation took the janaazah and left. The Shaykh got back to his previous position. When the congregation had left, soon after a person who was a Christian appeared. Hadhrath pulled out the cross hanging on his neck and broke its chain and made him recite the Kalimah and then addressed the congregation that he (this new muslim) is (now) such and such headed back to his hermitage. After reaching his place he became busy in Salaah at-Thahajjud. After the night passed, this mureed (desciple) questioned Hadhrath as to what the issue was concerning the incident the previous night. Hadhrath said, that the maqaam to which we had been was a town named Mawsil and that congregation was the jamaah of Abdaal ( A soofee terminology; their belief is that all the affairs of this universe are governed by Abdaal who are human beings and whenever one of them dies, there is a replacement and their number remains fixed) and that ailing person was one of them and they communicated to me spiritually (baathinee - soofees believe their saints have super natural ways to communicate that are far above general human abilities) that he shall be dying very soon and they requested him to be replaced. This is why I had been there and when he died then I requested Allaah to appoint someone in his place. Then there was an Order from Allaah that in Rome, a Christian is immersed in worshipping the cross, so he should be appointed as a replacement for the dead person. Then I asked (Allaah) as to how should his appearance here be requested? He then appeared in a strange abnormal miraculous way and immediately he was converted to a Muslim and placed on the position of abdaal and the message was conveyed that no one should be proud of one's class/elegance and everything is restricted to My (Allaah's) Fadhl.
You forgot to mention that his books are full of shirk lies bogus dreams. His book beshti zewar would make you think was written by a peadephile. He was a naqshbandi sufi which has a devient Aqueeda. Problem is you look at things with deobandi glasses and not through an Islamic perspective.
obviously he will look through a Deobandi manhaj(which is Islamic school of thought, a sub school of Ahle-Sunnah-Wal-Jama'a ) ,as you are looking through a Salafi manhaj(which is also an Islamic school of thought). We respect your Ullama because of who they are even though we have a difference of opinion on certain matters , we just ask you to respect our Ullama. I'm not saying that you cannot say that he has a lot of Shirk in his books(which is according to you not us), you can condemn or have a difference with him but just be respectful when you coin any words like devient or Pea**** whatever, because if he was not like you say he was, then my friend you are insulting a Wali of Allah and surely we all have to answer for the unjust and ignorence of our toungue to Allah. May Allah give us all Hidayath to follow the Quran, Sunnath and Seerath. _Aameen
@@muteebmujtaba754 dear brother Muteeb. They only follow Abu hanifa in fiqh not Aqueeda(do your research) that should ring alarm bells. They are naqshbandi maturidi deobandi sufis. That is not what the 4 Imams were upon. As I said to you their books are filled with all sorts of nonsense which clearly contradicts the sunna. They believe Allah is everywhere in opposition to the teachings of the Quran and Sunnah. They are a devient cult. If you read the books of tablighi jamaat all sorts of weird dreams and lies. You call them Walis. I say they distorted the religion with their false Aqueeda. Which the deobandis over look because if they question certain things the whole cult falls spart.
@@amjadfarooq8063 I never said that they follow Imam-Al-azam-Abu Hanifa(R.A)in Aqeedah all the Sunni are either Maturidis or Ash'ari or Athari doesn't matter which school of thought. Even I do have my difference of opinion with them but I commented not to say who is right or who is wrong ,I just commented so that just put your arguments in polite words. I also do agree with you on some things but who is a Wali of Allah , I think only Allah knows we cannot Judge them. Just because some of their Aqeedah is different doesn't make them devient , I think its just their different interpretations are wrong. Its just that these people have studied religion more number of years than that of our age so I think we should we very careful arguing with them , we should argue but we should I think be equal in knowledge like them then Its fair. just because we hear from some Ullama that these sects are wrong and they are deviant doesn't give us the right to say until we have done our own research. but anyways Allah-hu-aalam. AsSallam Valaikum
These people have devided the ummah with their devient beliefs. All the 4 Imams had the same Aqueeda which mirrored the sahaba. Don't you think it's very strange they don't adhere to the Aqueeda of the 4 Imams. Remember 72 sects all in the Fire except one. That 1 is the 1 that mirrors the Aqueeda of the Salaf. These guys are messed up sufis. Like brelvis
So who made moulana Thanvi a saint. Did you read Behisti Zewar. ? Such filth. According to this moulana, black magic is permissable in "permissable circumstances".
And if a man was intimate with a girl who has not reached puberty then there is no need for Ghusl.....according to the advice in Behesti Zewar. I was wondering if shaytaan was not perhaps in the publishing of his books. Maybe he never said so himself. I cannot comprehend that such things is written by a "Holy Man"????
muhammad khan . Brother, can you not see that such a "hadith" is making it permissable. Every so called hadith is NOT Hadith.its fabrications taught by so called ulama who taught magic. That is the point. There is no sense in this Tahara issue. it's absurd!
NIZAMODDIN NOORI Deary me! Ahmad Rada lambasted him, swore at him, did takfeer & tried so very hard to defame him, yet.... Mawlana Thanwi died with literally hundreds of thousands of servants of Allah having benefitted from him. Hundreds of disciples, students and successors. Today, literally millions of servants of Allah have benefited from him. Over one thousand, yes one thousand, publications from his authored and spoken teachings. Brother, you really shouldn't need to come to videos about people you hate out of taqleed, and comment in order to cure the dissonance it creates in your mind. Let's be honest & searchers of the truth when it comes to speaking of servants of Allah who have left and have been judged by Him.
![[English] Life of Hakimul Ummah Hadhrat Ashraf Ali Thanwi - Mufti Taqi Uthmani](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CDSRDd8cisQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Better English speaking than most English speakers.
ماشا ء اللہ
th-cam.com/video/Cr-Fwg7dOMw/w-d-xo.html
check this out about thanvi
Please confirm the ghustaakhe elements
1. Not denouncing his mureed reading molvi thanvi kalima?
2. Comparing the prophets gayb to that of a animals.
3. Him stating its better to think of a donkey in namaz rather than the prophet.
3rd one is actually statement of ismail dehlwi, not thanvi.
@@impae139 I don't get if these guys are so intelligent and have done quranic tafsir and know multiple languages and have followings of millions of people then why on earth would they write this crap?
Allah aur Nabi ke Gustaakh Deoband ke Shaitaani ilm rakhne waale 4 Maulana ke liye Bareilly ke Aala Hazrat Maulana Ahmad Raza Khan Rahmatullaahe Ta'aala Alaih akele hi kaafi they, kyun keh Chaaro Maulana ne apni kitaabon mayn Allah aur Nabi ki shaan mayn kaafi Gustaakhiyaan likhi thi jiski wajah se Aala Hazrat ne un Chaaro Maulana par Kufr ka Fatwa lagaaya aur Saudi Arab ke 294 Muftiyon ne uss Fatwa ko saheeh kaha aur uske baad Chaaro Maulana ne Tauba bhi nahi kiya aur aaj bhi woh sab Gustaakhiyaan unki kitaabon mayn maujood hai.
*(1)* Moulwi Ashraf Ali Thaanwi.
*(2)* Moulwi Rasheed Ahmad Gangohi.
*(3)* Moulwi Khalil Ahmad Ambethwi.
*(4)* Moulwi Qaasim Naanotwi.
Yeh chaaron Kaafir Murtad hain.
Jo in chaaron moulviyon ko musalmaan samjhe woh khud kaafir hojaayega.
Aur jo in chaaron moulviyon ki paerwi karega woh bhi kaafir hojaayega.
Please read Hassaamul Haramain written by Aala Hazrat Maulana Ahmad Raza Khan Rahmatullaahe Ta'aala Alaih.
A STORY by ASHRAF ALI THANVI.
Ashraf Alee Thanvi says in his book Malfoozaath Volume 3 # Malfooz Number 41- Para 2
....The third affair of strangeness is that a desciple (mureed) of Hadhrath Ghaws-al-Aadham ( referring to Shaykh Abd al Qaadir Jeelaanee rahimahullah which means Very Great Helper - This is why they invoke him in the times of need not just at his grave but anywhere, everywhere! Other Awliyaa and Saaliheen and Ambiyaa are considered just helpers but he is considered the greatest aider in the times of distress) narrated a strange incident which is quite astonishing which most probably I have come across in some book of Shaykh Abd-al-Haq Muhaddith Dehlavi.
That once Hadhrath Ghaws-al-Aadham rahimahullah woke up in accordance with his mundane schedule for Salaah at-Thahajjud and stepped out of his monasterial hermitage (Khaankhaah) and this khaadim (desciple) aswell got together with him. After walking for a while they reached a town and soon afterwards entered a house in which there was a congregation and those people stood up after seeing him and he (the Shaykh rahimahullah) seated himself in a position while the desciple also seated himself in a corner.
From a nearby chamber there could be heard a patient's groaning voice and after sometime this voice disappeared and four people exited (the chamber) with a janaazah and accompanied with them was an old person and this janaazah was placed in front of Hazrath (Shaykh Abd al-Qaadir) and he offered janaazah prayer soon after that congregation took the janaazah and left. The Shaykh got back to his previous position.
When the congregation had left, soon after a person who was a Christian appeared. Hadhrath pulled out the cross hanging on his neck and broke its chain and made him recite the Kalimah and then addressed the congregation that he (this new muslim) is (now) such and such headed back to his hermitage.
After reaching his place he became busy in Salaah at-Thahajjud. After the night passed, this mureed (desciple) questioned Hadhrath as to what the issue was concerning the incident the previous night. Hadhrath said, that the maqaam to which we had been was a town named Mawsil and that congregation was the jamaah of Abdaal ( A soofee terminology; their belief is that all the affairs of this universe are governed by Abdaal who are human beings and whenever one of them dies, there is a replacement and their number remains fixed) and that ailing person was one of them and they communicated to me spiritually (baathinee - soofees believe their saints have super natural ways to communicate that are far above general human abilities) that he shall be dying very soon and they requested him to be replaced. This is why I had been there and when he died then I requested Allaah to appoint someone in his place. Then there was an Order from Allaah that in Rome, a Christian is immersed in worshipping the cross, so he should be appointed as a replacement for the dead person.
Then I asked (Allaah) as to how should his appearance here be requested? He then appeared in a strange abnormal miraculous way and immediately he was converted to a Muslim and placed on the position of abdaal and the message was conveyed that no one should be proud of one's class/elegance and everything is restricted to My (Allaah's) Fadhl.
Ahmed Reza Khan .....asraf ali tanbi.....who is best
Both of them
After all this filth recorded in books, these scholars are supporting and loving these people. Look at their faith and eeman. Asthagfirullah.
what the hell are talking about
th-cam.com/video/Cr-Fwg7dOMw/w-d-xo.html
check this out about thanvi
You forgot to mention that his books are full of shirk lies bogus dreams. His book beshti zewar would make you think was written by a peadephile. He was a naqshbandi sufi which has a devient Aqueeda. Problem is you look at things with deobandi glasses and not through an Islamic perspective.
obviously he will look through a Deobandi manhaj(which is Islamic school of thought, a sub school of Ahle-Sunnah-Wal-Jama'a ) ,as you are looking through a Salafi manhaj(which is also an Islamic school of thought).
We respect your Ullama because of who they are even though we have a difference of opinion on certain matters , we just ask you to respect our Ullama. I'm not saying that you cannot say that he has a lot of Shirk in his books(which is according to you not us), you can condemn or have a difference with him but just be respectful when you coin any words like devient or Pea**** whatever, because if he was not like you say he was, then my friend you are insulting a Wali of Allah and surely we all have to answer for the unjust and ignorence of our toungue to Allah.
May Allah give us all Hidayath to follow the Quran, Sunnath and Seerath.
_Aameen
@@muteebmujtaba754 dear brother Muteeb. They only follow Abu hanifa in fiqh not Aqueeda(do your research) that should ring alarm bells. They are naqshbandi maturidi deobandi sufis. That is not what the 4 Imams were upon. As I said to you their books are filled with all sorts of nonsense which clearly contradicts the sunna. They believe Allah is everywhere in opposition to the teachings of the Quran and Sunnah. They are a devient cult. If you read the books of tablighi jamaat all sorts of weird dreams and lies. You call them Walis. I say they distorted the religion with their false Aqueeda. Which the deobandis over look because if they question certain things the whole cult falls spart.
@@amjadfarooq8063 I never said that they follow Imam-Al-azam-Abu Hanifa(R.A)in Aqeedah all the Sunni are either Maturidis or Ash'ari or Athari doesn't matter which school of thought.
Even I do have my difference of opinion with them but I commented not to say who is right or who is wrong ,I just commented so that just put your arguments in polite words.
I also do agree with you on some things but who is a Wali of Allah , I think only Allah knows we cannot Judge them.
Just because some of their Aqeedah is different doesn't make them devient , I think its just their different interpretations are wrong.
Its just that these people have studied religion more number of years than that of our age so I think we should we very careful arguing with them , we should argue but we should I think be equal in knowledge like them then Its fair. just because we hear from some Ullama that these sects are wrong and they are deviant doesn't give us the right to say until we have done our own research.
but anyways Allah-hu-aalam.
AsSallam Valaikum
These people have devided the ummah with their devient beliefs. All the 4 Imams had the same Aqueeda which mirrored the sahaba. Don't you think it's very strange they don't adhere to the Aqueeda of the 4 Imams. Remember 72 sects all in the Fire except one. That 1 is the 1 that mirrors the Aqueeda of the Salaf. These guys are messed up sufis. Like brelvis
@@amjadfarooq8063 You may be right.
So who made moulana Thanvi a saint. Did you read Behisti Zewar. ? Such filth. According to this moulana, black magic is permissable in "permissable circumstances".
Not only that .in this book, beheshti zewar there is a prescription (nus'kah) to increase the length and hardness of the penis.
And if a man was intimate with a girl who has not reached puberty then there is no need for Ghusl.....according to the advice in Behesti Zewar. I was wondering if shaytaan was not perhaps in the publishing of his books. Maybe he never said so himself. I cannot comprehend that such things is written by a "Holy Man"????
muslimah
Not only that , there are many dirty 'fatwas' which are too dirty to be quoted.
muslimah that is a fatwa given on hadith no one is saying to do that is right he's just giving the fatwa of taharah
muhammad khan . Brother, can you not see that such a "hadith" is making it permissable. Every so called hadith is NOT Hadith.its fabrications taught by so called ulama who taught magic. That is the point. There is no sense in this Tahara issue. it's absurd!
Lol.
Thanvi was Totally Destroyed by Imam Ahmed Raza.
😂
NIZAMODDIN NOORI
Deary me! Ahmad Rada lambasted him, swore at him, did takfeer & tried so very hard to defame him, yet....
Mawlana Thanwi died with literally hundreds of thousands of servants of Allah having benefitted from him. Hundreds of disciples, students and successors.
Today, literally millions of servants of Allah have benefited from him. Over one thousand, yes one thousand, publications from his authored and spoken teachings.
Brother, you really shouldn't need to come to videos about people you hate out of taqleed, and comment in order to cure the dissonance it creates in your mind.
Let's be honest & searchers of the truth when it comes to speaking of servants of Allah who have left and have been judged by Him.
The Critic some people hate others for a living. You honestly have no life. Go find one
Lol... Ulema in the UK????? What ulema!!! There isn't any in the western world, especially from the darol uloom
Fear allah and delete this comment u have no business saying such things
Shaykh Asrar Rashid
Dr Shadee al masri
And plenty more. Avoid spesking on which u have no knowledge of