If they put Evan Neal in and he played well Giants fans everywhere would think "Damn, Carmen Bricillo is a freakin' genius!" Nobody would be embarrassed. Great run blocker but he's struggled in pass protection from day one.
The reason the Giants are 2-6, a few reasons come to mind. 1) The fumble against Washington - they aren't coached or led by example to finish the play, series, or game. How often do you see players standing around after a blown assignment on both offense or defense? Defensively, do you really see guys "rallying" to the ball? If they did, we might see so many back breaking runs or Y.A.C. 2) Receivers taking plays off. Yes, DJ has missed his fair share of throws. But watching the Receivers, you can see where the routes get sloppy or the aren't running hard. Has anyone noticed during the 2022 season, the Giants had drops...but the passes were well thrown. Or was it that Slayton, Hodgins, et al. ran game speed during practice and did take plays off? 3) We are getting killed not paying attention to the basics; wrapping on tackles, holding on with tackling until the cavalry (9th) comes, be the cavalry (defensively or offensively) - rally to the tackle, the tush-push, or additional blocks. I can continue but you get the right idea.
So obvious of what they are trying to do!!!!…..Daboll never takes the blame for crappy play calling and poor decision making!!!!…..he will loose the looker room for the sake of trying to gain a new QB….and taking benching Banks and taking that confidence!!!!!!!!….I am tired!!!!😢😢😢😢😢💙💙💙💙🏈
I can't imagine what we don't know. How can they be this bad year after year through multiple coaches and GMs? There's stuff they're not telling us. All I can think of it ownership is the common denominator.
@CoachGeneClemons since Bradburry, they've had to pay or lose Andrew Thomas and Dex, signed Jones to his deal, and brought in Burns for top $. I'd say 3 out of 4 are money well spent. It's still bad now because Schoen keeps missing on top 100 draft picks.
I agree with every word These are awful coaches. They are making decisions to protect their own incompetence. We have no chance with these coaching decisions .
I can't take it anymore Coach Gene.. We drafted a top 10 consensus pick at #7, and didn't ever let the guy play at LT? HE STARTED AT ALABAMA 15 GAMES IN HIS FINAL SEASON?! At left tackle?. BTW his coach was Nick Saban
I don't get why Evan Neal isn't taking snaps as Left tackle. He should be his backup and see how he does. If he plays well that's one position with depth.
Its to many quastionable decisions done by this regime that doesnt make any sense at all. And yet ppl wana trust in them drafting the next great QB. The same ppl that thinks its all on the current QB that we stink.
Beautiful stats by Barkley yesterday but I mean he fumbled a big play and it’s cost them 7 and I’ve seen him do it already a handful times in Philly in this short season. Philly is just a better team so they pull out a win, against a bad team. But in the playoffs if Barkley pulls that, it will cost them shots at a SB. It’s a one and done game in the playoffs, that can’t happen.
@ dropped passes, mental errors. Not converting 3rd and shorts. I’ve watched his Philly games. In the end Philly is a good team. They will overcome against bad teams. If he does this in the playoffs. Guarantee you those big holes he runs through will shrink significantly the further he gets in the playoffs. Which will be a problem. If I’m wrong God bless him.. I prefer Tyrone Tracey hitting the hole hard and getting 1 yard when there is nothing there, as opposed to a 6 yard loss.
@ Thank you for your response. When I say I’ve seen it a handful of times, I wasn’t talking about fumbles. The fumble was last week. The game losing dropped pass was another week.. etc. I am talking about many other errors in his game, some I listed in the previous comment. But I get the sense you love him and we may just disagree. As a Giants fan watching him all these years I was extremely disappointed in him as a high draft pick.
Yo COACH, wud up? The DUMBEST move in NYG HISTORY is not Re-Signing SAQUON BARKLEY, NYG played stupid games, they won LAST PLACE. They need to draft QB SHEDEUR SANDERS.
The Evan Neal saga is crazy. Injuries come up and he still doesn’t get in the game. I want to see him play. Giants fans want to see him play.
I agree. He can't be worse but he might be better.
If they put Evan Neal in and he played well Giants fans everywhere would think "Damn, Carmen Bricillo is a freakin' genius!" Nobody would be embarrassed. Great run blocker but he's struggled in pass protection from day one.
He's been exactly like Elumeanor on pass pro.
The reason the Giants are 2-6, a few reasons come to mind.
1) The fumble against Washington - they aren't coached or led by example to finish the play, series, or game. How often do you see players standing around after a blown assignment on both offense or defense? Defensively, do you really see guys "rallying" to the ball? If they did, we might see so many back breaking runs or Y.A.C.
2) Receivers taking plays off. Yes, DJ has missed his fair share of throws. But watching the Receivers, you can see where the routes get sloppy or the aren't running hard. Has anyone noticed during the 2022 season, the Giants had drops...but the passes were well thrown. Or was it that Slayton, Hodgins, et al. ran game speed during practice and did take plays off?
3) We are getting killed not paying attention to the basics; wrapping on tackles, holding on with tackling until the cavalry (9th) comes, be the cavalry (defensively or offensively) - rally to the tackle, the tush-push, or additional blocks.
I can continue but you get the right idea.
I think everything you said has merit.
So obvious of what they are trying to do!!!!…..Daboll never takes the blame for crappy play calling and poor decision making!!!!…..he will loose the looker room for the sake of trying to gain a new QB….and taking benching Banks and taking that confidence!!!!!!!!….I am tired!!!!😢😢😢😢😢💙💙💙💙🏈
It's really strange.
I can't imagine what we don't know. How can they be this bad year after year through multiple coaches and GMs? There's stuff they're not telling us. All I can think of it ownership is the common denominator.
But ownership is the common denomenator throughout the winning as well.
The only thing I can think of for trading is acquiring enough capital to add to a pick swap if you want to move up in the draft.
But even then, that's not a guarantee. Someone has to be willing to play ball.
Bradburry wasn't a future move.
They had to cut $ to get under the cap, and B's conteact structure was the best option.
I think you missed my point. When is the future now? The Bradberry move was supposed to be for now. It's still bad now.
@CoachGeneClemons since Bradburry, they've had to pay or lose Andrew Thomas and Dex, signed Jones to his deal, and brought in Burns for top $.
I'd say 3 out of 4 are money well spent.
It's still bad now because Schoen keeps missing on top 100 draft picks.
I agree with every word These are awful coaches. They are making decisions to protect their own incompetence. We have no chance with these coaching decisions .
I do think there is some quality in the coaching. I can not support the decision making.
I can't take it anymore Coach Gene.. We drafted a top 10 consensus pick at #7, and didn't ever let the guy play at LT? HE STARTED AT ALABAMA 15 GAMES IN HIS FINAL SEASON?! At left tackle?. BTW his coach was Nick Saban
That part is what I do not get. Daboll coached under Saban.
I don't get why Evan Neal isn't taking snaps as Left tackle. He should be his backup and see how he does. If he plays well that's one position with depth.
At the worst he's a legit swing tackle when Thomas returns next season.
I wonder if Neal is hurt
He played TE on the left side on thw goal line in the previous game.
Its to many quastionable decisions done by this regime that doesnt make any sense at all. And yet ppl wana trust in them drafting the next great QB.
The same ppl that thinks its all on the current QB that we stink.
It's definitely not a slam dunk that they are the guys to get it done.
Beautiful stats by Barkley yesterday but I mean he fumbled a big play and it’s cost them 7 and I’ve seen him do it already a handful times in Philly in this short season. Philly is just a better team so they pull out a win, against a bad team. But in the playoffs if Barkley pulls that, it will cost them shots at a SB. It’s a one and done game in the playoffs, that can’t happen.
Philly is 6-2. They'll live with his seven fumbles-only three were lost-in 1,331 carries over his career.
@ dropped passes, mental errors. Not converting 3rd and shorts. I’ve watched his Philly games. In the end Philly is a good team. They will overcome against bad teams. If he does this in the playoffs. Guarantee you those big holes he runs through will shrink significantly the further he gets in the playoffs. Which will be a problem. If I’m wrong God bless him.. I prefer Tyrone Tracey hitting the hole hard and getting 1 yard when there is nothing there, as opposed to a 6 yard loss.
Interesting take. I think the fumble was unfortunate but he does not have a history of fumbling. That is cap.
@ Thank you for your response. When I say I’ve seen it a handful of times, I wasn’t talking about fumbles. The fumble was last week. The game losing dropped pass was another week.. etc. I am talking about many other errors in his game, some I listed in the previous comment. But I get the sense you love him and we may just disagree. As a Giants fan watching him all these years I was extremely disappointed in him as a high draft pick.
The NY Giants are the farm team for the rest of the league 😂, it’s really annoying
Definitely annoying
We should resign Slayton & if Azeez price tag isn’t to high. I’d resign him too.
Yo COACH, wud up? The DUMBEST move in NYG HISTORY is not Re-Signing SAQUON BARKLEY, NYG played stupid games, they won LAST PLACE. They need to draft QB SHEDEUR SANDERS.