At this point of the tour I don't think Gaga had a track with only back up vocals. Telephone was recently released. Notice that she had to cue people in the back (the audio technicians) to put in a track. Though if you listen, you can hear Gaga's live voice break through the tracks recording.
An insider recently said that there are three tracks for every song on her tours. A Track - Very minimal and quiet backing vocals. (If her voice is especially healthy that night) B Track - Typical backing vocals on chorus etc. (This is the track she uses most, apart from JWT that was mostly track A) C Track - “Lip-sync track” Most of the vocals from the studio version, usually unused vocal takes from the tracks recording sessions. (This is rarely used, unless she is very sick) They most likely pressed the wrong track, unless there weren’t a track yet like you suggested.
Lol, haters are so pathetic. We all know that Gaga can sing, just search 'Lady Gaga live' on youtube and many options will appear. But cuz she had a technical problem that day all these bastards are commenting 'playback' to feel better. Excuse me, but she is very talented and only for this episode she doesn't cease to be.
She is the greatest singer in the world I love you lady gaga and I love every single one of your songs and I love your fashion sense keep showing this world who is in the lead
Omg, imagine being the people working backstage when Gaga smashes her heels to the floor walking backstage before the song was over. She was probably piiiiiiiissed! :')
I remember when i saw this lip sync video in 2011, i literally cried 3 days bc i was so dissapointed that Gaga could do that, but I'm here after that, this literally was the only time she did that, i'm still supporting her, monster 4 life
Think about it, GaGa performs almost everynight and she has done it for the last 3 years. Who gives a shit if she lip Syncs? Is she still an amazing singer, an amazing dancer, and amazing performer? HELLZ YES!
I'll tell you a thing. She's not a liar. All of her performances are lives, and she works a lot for this. (Remember when she had to relax to continue Bad romance in New Zealand). I was there and maybe there was technical problems. But she wasn't lip sincing AT ALL. She didn't even move her lips.
One of the things that I love about GaGa is that she's more than just a singer; she's a dancer, choreographer, and artist. It wouldn't surprise me to hear that she played a recording over singing in favor of dancing in some songs, especially on a song featuring Beyonce, who isn't a part of her tour to sing the song with her.
She's not lip synching. It's a backing vocal, & you can't even see her face to make sure. It is hard to hear her voice though. (and I'm sure the person who shot the video & the audiance could hear her) Great video! The performance was awesome.
Amazing video, Thank you! I know Lady Gaga can actually sing so it doesn't bother me that she is lip syncing, mostly. On the Jonathon Ross show, she sang live, even though she had a cold. If you haven't seen that, you should. the interview is hilarious! Thanks again for the video, I loved it!
@ItsDemanding Gaga was rushing off so often that night to make up for the show running late it was unreal. She kept singing backstage like; I could see her floating away backstage with the guards and their torches XD
She is not even trying to lip synching, she just dances. It's exactly like when she dances to Marilyn Manson's Love game Remix it doesn't mean Gaga's going to do playback, maybe she migh have a break in the middle of her concert to relax her voice. on the other hand, it's great ♥
She's definitely not lip syncing as she has said numerous times in the past she will never ever lip sync. It's kind of her mission statement when it comes to performing. Look it up.
Sheesh guys, We KNOW she can sing, She has a beautiful voice. and sings live MANY times, no one can dance and sound awesome, she's probably singing but with the track.
I love how everyones trying to deffend the lip syncing even though no one made any negative cmnts to it. LOL heres the deal guys, it was the first time she sang the song live, she was kicking ass at dancing, and you know what sometimes we wanna hear an artist lipsync because theres no worry of a vocal mess up and we can just sit back and enjoy the performance. It sounds good to mee :) so we shud all just chill and enjoy GAGA's AWESOMENESSSSS
gaga doesn't lip sync.. ever. she does however sing along with backing tracks. that is what you are hearing. the backing track with Telephone just seems to be extremely heavy in this performance.
@Jammanto im not disagreeing with you. its just, she does sing good when she doesnt lipcync, like when she sings speechless, or songs with less dancing. and you can tell that she isnt lip syncing in the parts with less dancing.
+ella no nesesita cantar ella es super xvr es lo maximo asi q no rajen pes she dont need sing becose she is really amazing i loved this girl is amazing♥!gaga♥♥♥♥♥i love it
her tour today she did the same dance sequence and sang live. so there must have been some sort of teqnical difficulty becuase this was the opening night. but if you watch closely she can tell her mic is off so she doesn't even move her mouth. so...not lip syncing. Just turning it into a dance break.
@bamboozle1 Errm, that's because this was the first ever performance of this song on tour. Much of her set + costumes etc had not arrived and the show did not look how she had planned it to. There was a technical mishap which meant the music was set to the wrong track, and played louder thatn the volume her mic was set at. Go watch any other video of telephone from the monster ball and you WILL she that SHE SINGS LIVE.
love the little MJ dance at the end(: i don't think i've seen a girl do that good if a job at doing an MJ move and i'm not just saying that cause shes Lady Gaga. she is a very talented dancer and i'm very jealous :p lol
she doesn't lip sync, she does, however sing over track for the songs with heavy dance routines because it is next to impossible to dance this intensively and sing well at the same time because of your breathing. most of the time she sings the verses and sings over the chorus track. here, however was the FIRST performance she did of telephone and obviously the sound mixing is off because the track is too loud. when i went to go see her a couple of nights later, she was definitely singing live.
@@terryking3214 the new show was put together in just 4 weeks because Gaga didn't like the original version of the Monster Ball, apparently she was still putting finishing touches on the show 30 mins before the doors opened to the public, there where problems with the lighting and sound, lengthy delays caused by audio and video problems saw the show run over its allotted finish time by 30 mins and the fill in the gaps where Gaga and her team tried to fix problems interludes had to be played multiple times
@mOnzZteR19 she was not lipsyncing. The album version of the song was being played because there was a problem with the version without the vocals. this was the first time that she performed this version of the show and there were many things going wrong, watch any other video of her performing live and you will see that she does not lipsync.
Wow amazing. She did telephone. (: I think she "lip-synced" parts, but they clearly used the studio version of the songs since its a duet. Be happy she's at least performing this. I'm sure she sung along to some other parts but I guess this was just a little teaser till the real video comes out. She performed all her other songs well so stop hating on her for ONE song thats a DUET that's never been PERFORMED before
at 3:11 you can hear her singing the harmony really loud. Something must have been wrong because you can't hear her live voice at all and she knew it and was trying to work with it by singing harmony so she wasn't accused of lip syncing. Besides..if she was lip syncing on purpose maybe it was because she had a bad cold that day.
one of the few singers who actually sounds like they do in their songs when doing live performances
lady gaga has never lip synched..
NEVER has and NEVER WILL..
At this point of the tour I don't think Gaga had a track with only back up vocals. Telephone was recently released. Notice that she had to cue people in the back (the audio technicians) to put in a track. Though if you listen, you can hear Gaga's live voice break through the tracks recording.
An insider recently said that there are three tracks for every song on her tours.
A Track - Very minimal and quiet backing vocals. (If her voice is especially healthy that night)
B Track - Typical backing vocals on chorus etc. (This is the track she uses most, apart from JWT that was mostly track A)
C Track - “Lip-sync track” Most of the vocals from the studio version, usually unused vocal takes from the tracks recording sessions. (This is rarely used, unless she is very sick)
They most likely pressed the wrong track, unless there weren’t a track yet like you suggested.
@@joeyjakey Omg wait is there a source for this?
Lol, haters are so pathetic. We all know that Gaga can sing, just search 'Lady Gaga live' on youtube and many options will appear. But cuz she had a technical problem that day all these bastards are commenting 'playback' to feel better. Excuse me, but she is very talented and only for this episode she doesn't cease to be.
When she looks back at the sound crew...'Are you going to play the song or what???!!!" Priceless.
This vid has the best sounding bass.
She is the greatest singer in the world I love you lady gaga and I love every single one of your songs and I love your fashion sense keep showing this world who is in the lead
The video is going to be AMAZING! Can't wait!!
this is awesome how she dances and sings at the same time! and her dance is fabolous. i love gaga
I can't waiting more, i wanna enjoy this right now....
Lady GaGa es unica esta cancion es fantasticaaa!
GaGa La mejor siempreeee!
Thank U it is the first live video of telephone that i see. Its amazin, Gaga is amazing.
Omg, imagine being the people working backstage when Gaga smashes her heels to the floor walking backstage before the song was over. She was probably piiiiiiiissed! :')
I wish she actually sang this one live :( Her voice sounds so amazing live.
she totally redid the entire show for the second leg!!! i hope she does this version of the show in the us!! because the us tour was AMAZING
AMAZING seats you had
choreo was stunning
DAYUM lady gaga can dance ! she beast
I remember when i saw this lip sync video in 2011, i literally cried 3 days bc i was so dissapointed that Gaga could do that, but I'm here after that, this literally was the only time she did that, i'm still supporting her, monster 4 life
Your an idiot, she didn’t lip sync they played the wrong track and it had playback you could clearly her singing.
It was because of audio problems
@@chance4746 maybe you're the idiot because there's no live vocals on this performance lmao
@@nicholasbert4475 your the idiot actually Chance is right
She didn't lip sync deliberately, she had to
GaGa Is Diva
#ILOVEYOUGAGA
Think about it, GaGa performs almost everynight and she has done it for the last 3 years. Who gives a shit if she lip Syncs? Is she still an amazing singer, an amazing dancer, and amazing performer? HELLZ YES!
it's the first time i saw a playback of her! i wanted to hear her voice in this music! :(
she's good singing live!
do not compare her with other artists, lady gaga have talent naturally ok
Love you Lady Gaga!
she sings perfect!!!! incredible!!!!!!!!!
amazing quality loved every moment of it
AMAZING!!!! COOL! lady GAGA!
she´s doing it like she always does.
the original track is playin in the background and she sings, too.
I'll tell you a thing. She's not a liar. All of her performances are lives, and she works a lot for this. (Remember when she had to relax to continue Bad romance in New Zealand). I was there and maybe there was technical problems. But she wasn't lip sincing AT ALL. She didn't even move her lips.
she and her dancers are f*cking awesome !!! ;D i LOVE her :D
Wow tht had great quality and the real vid is the best vid I've evr seen this yr
why on earth would gaga even lip sync? she never does! she was born too sing so she will sing ALWAYS!
thanks for posting this video!
OMG I LOVE HER.
June the 3rd cannot wait!!! MANCHESTER MONSTER MADNESS!!!!!
shes amazing cant wait to her
Her back up dances killed it for me.... They not in sink at all.
I love you lady gaga ..............forever!!
meu é muito loko adorei os videos ... is gooooooooodd GTZ vlw brigado pelos videos fron Brasil hehe
i love her!!! ahh i remember the first time poker face was heard... ahhh she has come a long long long way.
I LOOOVVEE tis song
One of the things that I love about GaGa is that she's more than just a singer; she's a dancer, choreographer, and artist. It wouldn't surprise me to hear that she played a recording over singing in favor of dancing in some songs, especially on a song featuring Beyonce, who isn't a part of her tour to sing the song with her.
She kicks ass, go girl
its playback BUT i love the extra beats AND THE AMAZING DANCERS!
OMG WOW SOUND!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WAW
this is so good
She's not lip synching. It's a backing vocal, & you can't even see her face to make sure. It is hard to hear her voice though. (and I'm sure the person who shot the video & the audiance could hear her) Great video! The performance was awesome.
no matter what, she is just the very best singer sins... no one.
Amazing video, Thank you! I know Lady Gaga can actually sing so it doesn't bother me that she is lip syncing, mostly. On the Jonathon Ross show, she sang live, even though she had a cold. If you haven't seen that, you should. the interview is hilarious! Thanks again for the video, I loved it!
love it, love it
Well done ! you've achived 1.5 million views.
liindaaaaaaaa
SHE like the Queen of POP
@ItsDemanding
Gaga was rushing off so often that night to make up for the show running late it was unreal.
She kept singing backstage like; I could see her floating away backstage with the guards and their torches XD
she is soooo pretty ilove you gaggaa xxxxx
wow all of those ppl like telephone!! wow must be a kwl song!
i luv gaga
LADY GAGA THE BEST FOREVER!!!! :)
thanks for uploading! (:
She is not even trying to lip synching, she just dances. It's exactly like when she dances to Marilyn Manson's Love game Remix
it doesn't mean Gaga's going to do playback, maybe she migh have a break in the middle of her concert to relax her voice.
on the other hand, it's great ♥
She's definitely not lip syncing as she has said numerous times in the past she will never ever lip sync. It's kind of her mission statement when it comes to performing.
Look it up.
gaga is awsome
My favorite song of hers.
Sheesh guys, We KNOW she can sing, She has a beautiful voice. and sings live MANY times, no one can dance and sound awesome, she's probably singing but with the track.
I love how everyones trying to deffend the lip syncing even though no one made any negative cmnts to it. LOL heres the deal guys, it was the first time she sang the song live, she was kicking ass at dancing, and you know what sometimes we wanna hear an artist lipsync because theres no worry of a vocal mess up and we can just sit back and enjoy the performance. It sounds good to mee :) so we shud all just chill and enjoy GAGA's AWESOMENESSSSS
gaga doesn't lip sync.. ever.
she does however sing along with backing tracks.
that is what you are hearing. the backing track with Telephone just seems to be extremely heavy in this performance.
good song
good dance
i learnd the dance!
love lady gaga
yo, Lady GaGa is so sick, but that's how she makes herself unique. And btw, she has good vocal skills.
Nope. She's not even moving her lips. She never lip syncs.
thank u soo much
this girl is fenomenal wooowww lady gaga you love mexico
@Jammanto im not disagreeing with you. its just, she does sing good when she doesnt lipcync, like when she sings speechless, or songs with less dancing. and you can tell that she isnt lip syncing in the parts with less dancing.
+ella no nesesita
cantar ella es super xvr
es lo maximo
asi q no rajen pes she dont need sing becose she is really
amazing i loved this girl
is amazing♥!gaga♥♥♥♥♥i love it
i wanted to go to this concert- im really depressed. ^_^ gaga 4evahh!
te amo gaga ! ♥
too bad. that is my favorite song... i'd love to see it live
her tour today she did the same dance sequence and sang live.
so there must have been some sort of teqnical difficulty becuase this was the opening night.
but if you watch closely she can tell her mic is off so she doesn't even move her mouth.
so...not lip syncing. Just turning it into a dance break.
LOVE IT :D
i was sat where u wereeee haha
@bamboozle1 Errm, that's because this was the first ever performance of this song on tour. Much of her set + costumes etc had not arrived and the show did not look how she had planned it to. There was a technical mishap which meant the music was set to the wrong track, and played louder thatn the volume her mic was set at. Go watch any other video of telephone from the monster ball and you WILL she that SHE SINGS LIVE.
damn! she can sing live!! xx
it is great
LADy Gaga the BESt ... !!!!!
love the little MJ dance at the end(: i don't think i've seen a girl do that good if a job at doing an MJ move and i'm not just saying that cause shes Lady Gaga. she is a very talented dancer and i'm very jealous :p lol
she doesn't lip sync, she does, however sing over track for the songs with heavy dance routines because it is next to impossible to dance this intensively and sing well at the same time because of your breathing. most of the time she sings the verses and sings over the chorus track.
here, however was the FIRST performance she did of telephone and obviously the sound mixing is off because the track is too loud. when i went to go see her a couple of nights later, she was definitely singing live.
Really Long ,
But I love her.
GAGA ROCKS.
they killed this shit
BRAVO BRAVO
This was the first show of the revamped Monster Ball tour... a lot went wrong.
Like what?
@@terryking3214 the new show was put together in just 4 weeks because Gaga didn't like the original version of the Monster Ball, apparently she was still putting finishing touches on the show 30 mins before the doors opened to the public, there where problems with the lighting and sound, lengthy delays caused by audio and video problems saw the show run over its allotted finish time by 30 mins and the fill in the gaps where Gaga and her team tried to fix problems interludes had to be played multiple times
@@nicholasbroun985 And her she once said in an interview that her clothes got lost or smth hence why she wore the clothes and wig lol
@mOnzZteR19 she was not lipsyncing. The album version of the song was being played because there was a problem with the version without the vocals. this was the first time that she performed this version of the show and there were many things going wrong, watch any other video of her performing live and you will see that she does not lipsync.
She also had mic Vs backing track issues that night so she didn't sing over the backing here but she did on other dates.
Mto bom!
que lugar mais desanimado... queria ver e fosse mo Brasil
great
Muito massa.
i just love her this is crazy shit iluv it
I honestly don't care if she was lip syncing. I love this song
Wow amazing.
She did telephone. (:
I think she "lip-synced" parts, but they clearly used the studio version of the songs since its a duet.
Be happy she's at least performing this. I'm sure she sung along to some other parts but I guess this was just a little teaser till the real video comes out.
She performed all her other songs well so stop hating on her for ONE song thats a DUET that's never been PERFORMED before
at 3:11 you can hear her singing the harmony really loud. Something must have been wrong because you can't hear her live voice at all and she knew it and was trying to work with it by singing harmony so she wasn't accused of lip syncing. Besides..if she was lip syncing on purpose maybe it was because she had a bad cold that day.
representando o brassiil
gaga muito boom
somos seus maiorwes fas