The rating booklet suggests using the Rtot/yr statistic (available from Baseball-Reference) for position player defense. Galarraga's Rtot/yr statistic for 1987 was "5", which is a Neutral (consistent with the booklet). I have developed a spreadsheet to determine ratings. For Galararraga, my ratings align with yours. I have found Power ratings to be the most difficult to get to match the Plaay ratings. I have two methods, but I don't know which is better.
The rating booklet suggests using the Rtot/yr statistic (available from Baseball-Reference) for position player defense. Galarraga's Rtot/yr statistic for 1987 was "5", which is a Neutral (consistent with the booklet). I have developed a spreadsheet to determine ratings. For Galararraga, my ratings align with yours. I have found Power ratings to be the most difficult to get to match the Plaay ratings. I have two methods, but I don't know which is better.
do you know where this file resides now? It's no longer at the plaay site.
Love creating teams!!
How did the stats in your replay work out?
How do you print the cards?