Prosecution Dismantles Defense Witness Theories About Cause Of Floyd’s Death | The ReidOut | MSNBC
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ต.ค. 2024
- In stark contrast to the medical witnesses heard from the prosecution, Dr. Fowler testified that the cause of George Floyd’s death was everything but Chauvin. But Joy says the entire testimony ‘imploded’ once the prosecution picked apart his findings during cross examination. Fowler conceded multiple points, including that a lack of bruising and other injuries do not prove that Floyd did not die of asphyxia and that the weight of Chauvin's gear was not factored into his calculation of the force applied to Floyd's neck. Aired on 04/14/2021.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/Su...
About The ReidOut with Joy Reid: Joy Reid conducts one-on-one conversations with politicians and newsmakers while addressing provocative political issues both inside and outside of the beltway. Reid, who is also a best-selling author and public speaker, joined MSNBC in 2011 as a contributor. Drawing from her decades-long experience in politics, passion for addressing the intersection of race, justice and culture, as well as her signature tenacious interviewing style, Reid kicks off MSNBC’s primetime lineup by delving into American politics as it unfolds.
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, Meet the Press Daily, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House with Nicolle Wallace, Hardball, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and more.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Re...
Subscribe to MSNBC Newsletter: MSNBC.com/Newsl...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Li...
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Fo...
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/In...
#GeorgeFloyd #BlackLivesMatter #MSNBC
Prosecution Dismantles Defense Witness Theories About Cause Of Floyd’s Death | The ReidOut | MSNBC
Someone should go and research every single person Dr. Fowler ever treated.
Actually they should after what happened here
Joe Perez, a former internal affairs police captain in Prince George’s County, Maryland, who is not involved in either the Chauvin case or the Black lawsuit, said, in his opinion, Fowler’s role as a defense witness in the Chauvin case constitutes a conflict of interest, given Fowler’s stance as a defendant in an ongoing lawsuit involving an officer-involved death investigation in Maryland.
Perez, a former shift commander on a special investigative response team that conducted criminal misconduct cases involving police-involved shootings, said Fowler was known to work closely with the police.
“It appears to me that they chose Mr. Fowler as an expert witness so that he can co-sign on their version of what they say happened,” Perez told WTOP.
He said in his years of experience in internal affairs, medical examiners and police officers would often become friends over time - and that had the potential to lead to false narratives.
Other cases
Kenneth Ravenell, the lead counsel for the Black family, mentioned other in-custody death cases Fowler oversaw that he questions, suggesting there is a pattern of controversial rulings.
The Intercept article broke down the cases of four men who died while in police custody in Maryland under Fowler’s watch. None were classified as homicide.
But in the 2015 case of Freddie Gray, the high-profile death of a 25-year-old Black Baltimore man who died after suffering spinal injuries during a police van transport, Fowler did rule that death a homicide.
Fowler retired in 2019 after serving as chief medical examiner for 17 years. Before that he served as deputy chief medical examiner in Maryland from 1998 to 2002 and an assistant medical examiner from 1993 to 1998. He was the president of the National Association of Medical Examiners in 2015 and chairman of the board in 2016.
Fowler now works as a private, independent consultant in forensic pathology and medicine, according to his LinkedIn account
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Facts ! Got a feeling a few the cases he was involved in will get reopened!
Believe your EYES !
I wish they had asked this doctor if he resigned because of the investigation where he's accused of a cover up in cases just like this, involving officers killing people and him ruling the deaths accidental.
That was the white elephant in the rule. The Judge specifically told the prosecution/Jerry Blackwell not to bring up David Fowler's previous case as it would taint the jury's opinion and sway them, possibly leading to a mis-trial.
I agree. This cabal of evil police and their enablers is bad enough; the fact they are STILL trying to gaslight us and cover for each other means we need to double down on them all.
You know the look on Blackwells face lol!!!!! He probably was already saying it!!!! I wish I could have seen his face when Fowler walked in!!! I bet he says yeah this is going to be great!!!! How could u even testify when you don’t even treat living patients!!!!!
and trained during apartheid
They wouldn't be allowed to ask that.
If it was CO from the exhaust pipe, then Chauvin would still be responsible since he held him there for 9 minutes.
CO going up not down Chauvin sniffed more than GF
@@pauliusu CO is pretty neutrally-buoyant with other air molecules, from my understanding: it doesn't rise or fall to create a layer; it does mix fairly evenly with the rest of the air. But that means there wouldn't have been a higher concentration on the ground, either.
Exactly!!!
Exactly and now the exhaust pipe would also be found as the murder weapon. Either way whether it’s his knee or car exhaust pipe, the killer in charge is the same
The prosecution is supposed to be proving HOW it happened--specifically, not a bunch of "oh, maybe this--well, maybe that!"
A bunch of morons that don't understand what reasonable doubt means.
The prosecution has bumbled through every day of trial so far. Every one of their witnesses but one have conceded the defense's case in cross-examination.
The fact that they changed their case after the first couple of days shows they've got nothing but their appeal to emotion.
Get ready for more riots. Courtesy of a media that will only tell one side of the story, are priming their audience for a 'guilty' when it's likely going to be an acquittal.
"Incredibly thorough" what a joke. "God help us all." Yeah, god help you for pushing propaganda.
The moment he started speaking on areas he isn’t an expert in, his credibility as an expert witness took a massive hit.
Didn't the pulmonologist and cardiologist do the same by not knowing what to say outside their areas ???
@@VincitOmniaVeritas. That’s crazy Lawyers are very cunning 😅. As a Digital Forensic student we did something similar to you. They also try to discredit your work.
@@biloz2988 Im not sure if I understand your question, but In order to help their clients, the experts should only speak in their area of expertise, that way the other side is unable to undermine their credibility.
@@kawhileonard9718 Hi, they really are. Even a typo can ruin your career when a Barrister is done with you. But it makes us even more due diligent. So in a sense making us better Forensic Scientists. It still doesn’t make up for the mock court we had. It was utterly brutal. 😩😁. Good luck with your studies and your career in general.
PEACE, WISDOM, FREE THINKING, KINDNESS, LOVE ONE ANOTHER, CALM, HUMANITY UNITED, PROSPERITY, BONANZA, HONESTY, RESPECT, GOOD HEALTH
His Body language does it for me!!He soo hated to tell the truth! I can’t believe how many stupid unproven theories he came up with 🤷🏽♀️ This man is clearly Drunk! I love the way he got his plate handed back to him👍🏽
He is very arrogant
Jerry Blackwell neutered him!
Derek is 10000000% innocent you racist pig.
PEACE, WISDOM, FREE THINKING, KINDNESS, LOVE ONE ANOTHER, CALM, HUMANITY UNITED, PROSPERITY, BONANZA, HONESTY, RESPECT, GOOD HEALTH
@@RiseLife I’m confused 🤷♂️ Who is a racist pig 🐷😁😁Ikn u not calling any blk ppl on here y’all name 🤔I’m confused frfr I think you just wanna be starting something 🐷😀
This prosecution team is amazing, and if it is the exhaust pipes that murder him, Chauvin is the reason he was that close to the pipes.
They aren't so amazing, they have most facts on their side. They would have to be completely incompetent to botch this case up.
@@mgm8822 Well, good thing they didn't hire Rudy Guiliani.
Very well said Akina!
I was thinking the same thing
@@mgm8822 Give credit where credit. We've seen other prosecutors with facts on their side mess it up completely.
We should be impressed Dr. Fowler didn't challenge the fact George Floyd actually died that day.
😎👍👍👍
👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Oh my lord you all r horrible 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😎🤪👍👍👍👍👍👍🍻
😎😎😎😎😎😎👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
If he was healed down by a cop, next to an exhaust pipe is that still not murder? Like thats how the nazis killed the Jews and stuff, im pretty sure it still counts as murder.
According to him, those Jews died because they had underlying conditions and sudden death, the smoke from the gas chambers, and not really the activities of the Nazis
@@oliviaturner7388 right smfh 😂
Exactly 💯 = still MURDER
Pretty sure it would still be some sort of manslaughter, it would be Floyd dying due to neglect on Chauvin’s part. Even if it was an “accident” that he put him there.
Yes but the point of this testimony was to muddy the waters, to cast "reasonable doubt" on the prosecutors case. Remember, the jury is instructed that they should not convict if there is reasonable doubt.
They know it's a lie; they aren't interested in the truth, they are interested in "winning".
The next witness for the defense is going to testify that Floyd wedged himself under his knee and it could be ruled as sucide .
😂😂😟💯
👍🏾🤣🤣
That what's it's coming into 😂👍🏾
Or died of old age.
Well, he did place himself on the ground.
In December, Fowler was named a defendant in a civil lawsuit brought by the family of Black. The lawsuit, led by the ACLU of Maryland, personally names Fowler, along with the state medical examiner’s office and a myriad of police agencies and police officers, and accuses him of concealing law enforcement’s role in Black’s death, which the lawsuit claims was at the hands of the police.
Who is Black?
@@athenasuperheldin1017 3:49 :)
@@athenasuperheldin1017 Anton Black was killed by Maryland police. Fowler testified in defense of the police in that case.
@@loralieisa wtf I never even heard about that. This breaks my heart...how many Black people have they murdered and covered up. My heart 😥😰
@@athenasuperheldin1017 Yes, it's heartbreaking to know of these things. At least now we have police cams and people can cam/livestream their encounters with police,It's not always black and brown people who are brutalized by police. There are instances of asian and white people suffering through brutal police encounters. However, I believe for the most part black and brown people are most targeted. We need police, but what we have now is not working.
Dr. Fowler got destroyed!! He didn't look confident at all. Dr. Tobin however, could not be shook. He had the defense attorney against the ropes.
It’s so hard to not look at the stark contrast. I hope every case Fowler ruled on is relitigated and he is held personally, civilly liable and sued to kingdom come.
I thought Tobin made the case. He was brilliant. Calm, decades of experience, explained everything clearly. I loved the way he kept loosening his tie and opening hid collar to physically demonstrate to the jury exactly how George Floyd was killed. Murdered. Lynched.
Dr. Fowler can't be trusted, as he forced the resign as Chief M.E from the state of Maryland because of his involvement in medical cover ups of some deaths. And he has a history of testifying in cases like these, where the deceased is a PoC, saying that he cause of death is anything but the police brutality and force.
How would he be confident when he knows he's not doing the right thing
@@elenalatici9568 completely agree and I think we all felt empowered and educated by his fantastic demonstrative testimony. He is like that special teacher in school that always had your attention and everything sunk in.
Also the fact that he gave his time, knowledge and expertise for free speaks volumes about this man's integrity. 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
...this witness has signed off on many cases that critically impacted someone's life!
That’s his modus operandi, a regular Dr. Mengele!
He's being sued by 2 family's
@@thomaszitting2672 Black familys
@@wolke1955 I don't know
Not this time
Eric Garner’s family deserves a new trial and that officer behind bars along with Chauvin.
Exactly 💯💯💯
Totally agree
That is a case worth re examining. ♡
Both cases are similar. DON’T RESIST AREEST
@@DannyDevitooo cow explain to me how you resist arrest yet allow the police to cuff you.🤔
The state of Maryland needs to re-examine and investigate all the cases that were responsibled by David Fowler for any foul played, dishonest, mishandled, biased, discriminated, misjudged, and etc. evidences‼️
His face and ears ...OMG...Liar Liar
Amen what a unfair world .I hope this Gentleman family dig into this
@@3rdeyelottery287 Yes George Floyd's family members did and along with protests for justice and equality.
David Fowler was a forensic doctor called by the defence attorney as a witness who lied under oath during the trial‼️ I'll not be surprised if he lied about any evidences of his previous forensic cases‼️
PEACE, WISDOM, FREE THINKING, KINDNESS, LOVE ONE ANOTHER, CALM, HUMANITY UNITED, PROSPERITY, BONANZA, HONESTY, RESPECT, GOOD HEALTH
Fowler: “George Floyd’s death is undetermined. But I can determine it was DEFINITELY NOT a homicide. Oh btw he was breathing in dangerous levels of exhaust fumes, because he was restrained for 10 mins. But def NOT DC’S FAULT” 🤡
🙄
Lol. So what do you say now a day later they called back the examiner to the stand and his carbon monoxide levels were in fact normal levels that we all have. So basically that theory has been debunked.
@@tweetybird7950 Ahh, it sounds like you were taking @Petunia Pop a tad too seriously there. P.P. was clearly and outright mocking Fowler's entire testimony - I'm not sure how they could have made it any more obvious, there's even a clown emoticon to punctuate it.
Yet you seem to be saying "well, now how stupid do you look?", when they were themselves ridiculing Fowler's claims.
Straight nonsense plus he look high...
Looking forward to the prosecutors taking these defense witnesses and exposing them for the disingenuous liars and fakers that they are!
well, they're genuinely there for the check
Facts matter. You’re just delusional. ACQUITTED
Did you not see the whole tape, chauvin did nothing wrong
@@TrumpGirl8713 or anything right which is more important!!!
@@DannyDevitooo not on Q world...
Ladies and gentlemen... class is in session! This prosecutor is dismantling this defense and it's attempt to humanize this corrupt cop and excuse his actions and behavior.
@FENTENAYL FLOYD please share your MD diploma. We will wait. Btw Hitler called he wants his attitude back.
👍
@@jancoo2029 everything FENTENAYL FLOYD said is on video it's not something he made up
Just like BLM humanizes George Floyd as a ‘gEnTle GiAnT’ ? ACQUITTED
@@DannyDevitooo boy are you gonna be disappoint
Didn't he swear to tell the truth? They need to throw out his testimony. Pull Anton Black's case! Great job on the cross examination.
Agreed. This Dr. Fowler is a South African product of apartheid. He can't be trusted.
@@1madmaxx80 his background is highly dubious but better yet he could not link many of his findings to any actual articals or known information his whole testimony was filled with assumptions and no known facts from autopsy and his testimony was pulled apart piece by piece when Blackwell came to questioning him.
Then high tailed it out of there as soon as he was done. Funny that considering prosecution still had Dr Tobin close by and a watching the trial carry on.
No one needs to worry about that devil has a hard life in front of himself. Let him alone ! Because he'll surely has he'll coming. Family please don't you morn he's already a coursed man, it never will be a good thing for him, we need to understand that the war has always been against us. You really should know the spiritual mind of all should know that they are not the people who have been good to black man or women! You need to understand that, you know that's the reasons that you should be looking for a way out of here anyway. This nation is on its way out so don't be looking for away to stay here this is written you didn't realize that this is the nation that the profits were talking about mystery Babylon so its really fulfilling the profits
@@1madmaxx80 Very good point I didn’t even give a thought but yeah,no doubt that colours(no pun intended)his outlook on a case like this without a doubt!
Blackwell is the boss!
Chauvin’s defense: “idk man maybe we can get a dude with an accent to talk about exhaust pipes to make our case sound smarter?? Do you think that’ll work??” 🤡
..."and let me write that down."
He's from where I'm from. Im ashamed.😑
let's bring an old white guy raised in apartheid south africa, who left his homeland when black rule became imminent, to say that it's the black man's fault that he is dead. yeah, because that doesn't look bad.
@@nonyabizness.original yeah, if only everybody understood what was really going on in this section of the matter.
he has a South african accent and wh**e South africans are extremely racist towards black people so I'm not surprised by his statements
I used to sing opera and part of the training was to breathe on the floor with someone standing on top of us.
IT - IS - EXTREMELY - DIFFICULT. An untrained person couldn't do it!
Prosecutor Jerry Blackwell is an excellent attorney.
Yeah, he's excellent, a little bit too excellent according to the Washington post, and I quote: ''In private practice, Mr. Blackwell has represented corporations including Walmart, 3M Company and General Mills, according to the website for his firm, Blackwell Burke, which is based in Minnesota. He has defended companies against lawsuits by people who said they were injured by asbestos, benzene and other potentially harmful chemicals. He has also represented companies in cases involving claims of false advertising''
@@fabto555 he’s a beast. Not to be toyed with!!!!👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
@@bubble5335 he is a total machine when it comes to knowing his facts about everything. Brutal against the defense witnesses...you can just see it in their faces!
Ha!
@@bubble5335 Oh don't overstimate him, this is the problem with trials, you make heroes & villians out of people doing their job. Some of his crosses have been overruled time and time again.
Mr Blackwell is a straight savage
He is brilliant! It's amazing to watch him work.
I agree. A savage just like Floyd. Stupid democrats!
@@Happyhooker2023 ur boy died in nazi Germany ur too late buddy shoulda been born in 1920.
@@Happyhooker2023 lmao 😂 what does your political party have to do with anything here . Are you still mad your party lost . Aw you need hug buddy haha
@@masterm2k: 🤣🤣🤣
It was epic enjoyed every minute the defense has called 2 druggies , a bad cop , and this quack oh and a young cop trainer
The defense could not find credible experts that would lie on the stand for a murderer
@@musicg1696 it speaks volumes of how many cops testified against this guy, thats not something that usually happens in my recollection. Everyone wants distance from Chauvin because what he did was so vile, and he acted like he was entitled to do it. Rightfully so
Hey Thomas Z...this guy didn't like being exposed by Mr. Jerry Blackwell as a paid quack. 😄😃😅😆
That Quack was Coached by///a do you agree with anything I ask you is true Defense Attorney/// regardless if it's a lie. Wink 👁wink, nod nod, uh huh, uh huh, yes yes /// "Yes Man".
@@tdragon3573 the doctor testified he got some of the info from " what if" Nelson not facts
That 'defense expert' is just like "Where do I pick up my check?"
Dr. Folwer is faul.
and immediately flew out of the state. 100%fact
Yes same for the prosecutions “experts”
"The exhaust pipe is now on trial".... 😂😂😂 I actually watched the trial today for the first time. . And that prosecutor was tearing this guy up!!😂😂😂😂😂
I like this.
Blackwell is the man...
I wish you had watched more. The prosecution was meticulous in it's medical testimony and the witnesses were humble and sincere. The defense in contrast has been a joke. I watched the first two minutes of this so-called "expert" witness say it was drugs and a heart condition that caused George Floyd's death after a dozen or more people testified it was this SOB cop that caused his death because of a lack of oxygen, i.e. HE COULD NOT BREATHE BECAUSE A ROGUE COP HAD HIS KNEE ON HIS NECK FOR 91/2 MINUTES. Also, in the clips I remember seeing, he also had his other knee on his back! Mr. Floyd could not breathe period.
Jerry blackwell is a beast and he's a civil suit lawyer.
I love when he examine these witnesses. He does it with soul 😆.
@@trulyshanaj ikr I love his facial expressions 😁
Jerry is fking awesome.
Absolutely love it. He's doing an amazing job.
He's also very disarming. It was brilliant.
I was actually embarrassed for Dr. Fowler when he tried to pin Floyd's death on car exhaust fumes. Where is the defense getting these incompetent witnesses from?
More like what racists are willing to be on display and on national TV showing their blatant racism 🙄
Was the car even on ?
The question should be
How much did they pY this dr to make s foul of himself to save s bad cop from jail?and which should investigate hes past sworn statements for truth of content in any other deaths by police officers
From Satan, their master! This witness, Dr. Fowler, is actually under investigation for trying to cover up fir the police in MD, where in a case eerily similar to Floyd’s, he declared it an accident. The officer there also laid with his full body weight on a handcuffed 19 year old schizophrenic black child, who he’d put in the prone position. That officer killed Anton Black and after 6 minutes, they continue to press on the boy! So the defense clearly went into the pit to dig him out!
They're grasping at straws because the crime is indefensible.
i was watching it live. I could feel the doctor getting grilled so hard, even my face is burning.
what i saw was the prosecution trying really hard to discredit good testimony
the whole trial was staged. everyone were hired actors, or antifa, whatever use your imagination.
@@laurenpeck3609 Yes, like the exhaust was a contributing factor but didn't know if the exhaust was on or how effective it would be. Claiming to many times performing a study of putting weight on someone in a prone position yet not one whom was handcuffed with someone kneeling on his neck. Heck, the study didn't even last nine minutes. Besides, how many times did he mention, I referred to someone for their opinion. This was not expert testimony!
@@speakeasy2982 he claimed it was a fatal heart attack due to his many risk factors end of story
@@laurenpeck3609 Yet he didn't include the policeman's actions as part of the risk factors. Hmmm!
It was a beautiful thing watching the prosecution destroy this guy !!
That prosecutor is ruthless. He is very technical with his questions. He sho-nuff knows how to rip the defense apart.
You sho-nuff speak english well
Your language fully explains why you have no clue what's going on even when it's right in front of your face. Defense shredded the prosecution daily 😂😂😂
@@ryanbeshears931 you took the bait which is why I purposely used that term as my way of waiting on targets by people like you who are racist. People like your kind just stand by waiting to ASSume your ignorant thought on someone you don't even know. By the way, yes I speak English very well which is why I have a 6-figure salary, I have a college degree, and I own my brand new home which I had built from the ground up. Bye fool.
@@terryrollins1973 you took the bait which is why I purposely used that term as my way of waiting on targets by people like you. People like your kind just stand by waiting to ASSume your ignorant thought on someone you don't even know. You're entitled to your opinion about your feeling for the Defense just like I have a right on my feelings about the Prosecution. Bye fool.
He can tear it apart, especially when the defense client is guilty as hail.
The defense witness might have opened back up that case a few years back that he lied in another case of a police officer killing a Blackman in a similar fashion in Baltimore. Hmmm, two birds with one stone!
Judge would have mistrial and stopped him from killing two birds with one stone.
I had to go to work ,at work now and this trial is something else ,I didn't know that they lie the way they do ,while actually seeing the truth ,shameful ,but they have no shame
That man NEEDS TO BE CHARGED for lying under OATH. He is getting PAID WELL TO LIE. But GF attorney KILLED IT👌🤪
Fake news
Rightly said. I have a better suggestion for Dr. Fowler...Since he thinks George Floyd didn't die due to Chauvins knee. He should volunteer to lie face down and Chauvin should kneel on his neck and back for 9.5 minutes....
Lots of deaths coming and the media is to blame.
That isn’t Georges att. He is the states att. The fact that he is fighting so hard for a conviction is promising.
@@boriskarloff598 for what .they're just reporting on the trial proceedings.
Bravo State lawyers!!!
They made jerky out of this quack!!👏💪
I love Mr.Blackwell if I didn’t wanna be a doctor I would want me a lawyer like him 📌🙏🏾
Fowler's medical degree must have been one of the prizes in a gumball machine. 😳
😅🤣😂😅🤣😂
Facts!
LOL Like Rand Paul.
Or at Trump U
👏👏🤣🤣🤣🤣
Did the defense find this guy wandering around on the street dazed and confused figuring, yeah he will be considered a great expert for our side.
🤔🤣🤣🤣
Heh🤭
the chief medical examiner IS the expert. sorry to burst your bubble.
@@krayzeeryan yes but he's a disgraced chief medical examiner.
@@explorer0213 Disgraced by who? Was he disciplined, fired or did he resign? If the answer to any of those is no, then hes not disgraced.
I bet the defense is sorry they paid him $300 an hour for his testimony!!! LOL
🤣🤣
Him dont worth a dime lol
WOW!
who says they gave paid the bill yet ?? Perhaps defense will 'do a Trump' and make him sue for his fee
11,000 Smackers to get laughed at BAHA
This man got a serious lashing from the prosecution it was hilarious to watch.
From the defense? You mean the prosecution? 🥰
@@sabrina.natalie facepalm. yeah i f'd that one up, when the prosecution dismantled him
Thank you Mr. Blackwell..fine work..incredible depth of study and knowledge required for your profession.Thank you to court staff, lawyers, witnesses, judge, jurors..an honour and a privilege to serve in the community to continue to actively listen, take notes, ask applicable questions in order to reach best possible outcome.
The defense witness just embarrasses himself. I can't believe he was a chief medical officer shameless man
It’s just scary bc all they need to do is create reasonable doubt for one person on that jury!
@@slamminsam6xoxo it isn’t reasonable doubt tho this so called ‘doctor’ is already disgraced at the time of this trial he’s being sued for covering up a teens death he’s a pos and prolly only doing this cuz they’re paying him
You forgot about the best part
“Maybe you should do your homework rather than ride with your opinions” -Blackwell 😂
He has 👌.
KARTI, I'm watching ABC news and missed that part. Is that at the beginning?
Best Ive heard all yr!!!!
Took em to SCHOOL!!!
@@anthonybrowne3942 watch the Blackwell cross, he had him against the ropes!!! This "expert" spoke multiple times about seeking out others opinion. He failed to put in the work and study the case and evidence.
Yes! Homework. Starting with maff and English.
Prosecution was brilliant! Exposed the charade, man got down to brass tacks.
Jerry Blackwell is VERY good 👍👏👏👏👏
@@springerworks002 I did. He dismantled the defenses expert witness and even got him to agree that Floyd did not resemble a man on fentanyl. By the way 3 experts of the prosecution all agreed that based on the evidence stated the same thing before Fowler's statement. Fowler said that the officers should've tried to revive Floyd from cardiac arrest because someone in that condition could've been saved. Thus agreeing that they were negligent. Also the prosecution made him walk back and clarify statements that were misleading yesterday. Earlier today the prosecution called Toobin the pulmonary expert to the stand and he refuted the carbon monoxide statements from David Fowler. He also dimantled the statements of Fowler as to use of force in the prone position not being dangerous. Toobin said that there was literature on the subject that Fowler said didn't exist. Fowler was also exposed yesterday as to a statement he made of an expert he cited as saying the prone position was dangerous and that the expert retracted that statement and believed it to be non threatening, The prosecution read a statement to Mr. Fowler of the expert in his own words stating that people had misinterpreted him So what did i miss? I could give you more. The prosecution was brilliant. I stand by my statement. maybe you should watch it?!
@@stalker7892 couldn't have said it better myself. This entire trial has been a thorough disarming of racist tropes, even before the defense expert testimony. It's a shame that the actually takes this much just to take one of these m************ down. Even with video start to finish you have to slow walk them through it, it's like they're preconceived notions are made out of vibranium or something
@@stalker7892 it's like they forced them to choose between hang on to their racism ignoring the evidence at the risk of possible perjure, or concede you have to ignore key facts to come to your conclusions, and have to agree with current science. Finally it's enough evidence that they can't easily lie their way out of.
They were terrible, that is why they presented the evidence that was not allowed by the judge possibly causing mistrial. They know they did not prove a murder case and did this to start all over again. Very dirty tactic, should be fired. Even prosecution witnesses stated they would call the cause of death heart failure or overdose if they were not exposed to the video. Bias is strong in this case.
These prosecutors deserve medals because they totally dismantled every single argument thoroughly. Defense had no case and they knew it.
Next the defense is gonna say it was the tire that killed him... he had an anaphylactic shock because he was allergic to the rubber from the tire😂😂😂
"DR FOWL UP"
Youre definitely known now.
Or foul up
This should trigger a review of ALL his previous testimony, I smell more cover up and corruption.
Maybe dr foulplay
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Wow!!! Lmao that was good
That "doctor" could possibly convince some that Floyd is still alive.
😀😀😀😀😀😁😁😁😁😁😁
Game, set, match. It’s not a matter of guilt or innocence it’s about how long Chauvin is spending in prison. Anything less than 15 years is unacceptable.
I think he’ll get close to 40
@@godzillamanstreb524 that sounds about right... I'd like life, but they won't give him that I don't believe
If he walks, we're all back in 92' LA- Minneapolis will burn
@@sing151 that's what you all do best
@@laurenpeck3609 you’re funny, 😂. And really stupid. But funny, nonetheless.
This Dr. needs to be investigated. How many deaths has he covered up???
This guy will be used in the Dante Wright murder trial. He'll claim Dante died from the car crash not from the bullet to his heart.
Absolutely, if he does i believe he will say that. I like your Comment.
He is pathetic
I watched it, and it was awesome!! Blackwell dismantled him 😁😁😁😄😄
Remind me: don't defense witnesses get paid handsomely for their testimony? Well, there go a few bucks down the drain.
Made me laugh ,in a horrific situation
He made approximately 2500 to 2800 today not counting travel
@@thomaszitting2672 thats the market for infamous murderers with most of a country against him. All the money in the world can't buy them a professional manipulator who can lie straight faced on the stand
The cardiologist for the state was Definitely getting paid, he would have said absolutely anything the state wanted him to, and basically did
🤣🤣🤣
How big was the check to side with the defense..
The fact that you can always find an expert witness to support your side of the case, no matter what, is one of the reasons our court system is so messed up.
Good question
This defense CLOWN quack gets paid $300 an hour for his lying testimony stories.
@@michaelanderson-sr5uv $300 an hour for his testimony.
Jerry Blackwell is a great attorney. My God he roasted the mess out of him 😆
I love Jerry Blackwell, he is my HERO also Dr Tobin!👍👏❤
That doctor ain no doctor he wanted the bread 🍞 ☺️☺️😜😜😜😜😂
Let's talk that bread is moldy yuck.😝
I think she was polite when she said "picked apart his findings". From what I could tell there were no findings, I think he watched the main officers' body cam footage one time through and decided what he would say to make his clients happy.
I dont think he comprehended how much video evidence there was and how easy it is to challenge him.
Yes I think he underestimated the prosecutor and didn’t consider the gear on Derek Chauvin as additional weight🙄. He certainly didn’t prepare himself well for this kind of cross-examination
Oh, and you forgot about all the time it took to make that Powerpoint
@@grazianalu76 how can you morons not think it is heart-related??? 90% blockage on one side and 75% on other, meth and stress. No one cut off his arteries in his neck.
@@laurenpeck3609 how could you (🤡) not realize that even accounting for the factors you mentioned, Chauvin exacerbated any health-related traumas? And you have the nerve to call other people idiots? I get the impression you aren’t very smart.
You got that right.
I'm hand cuffed! My hands are behind my back! What possible threat can I be too you! At this point! I'm A Victim!
SO YOU CAN'T KICK? YOU CAN'T GET UP, YOU CAN'T ROLL?
🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@johnnylawrence7509You try doing it. Bet you can't even get up.
@@anthonybrowne3942 Already done and here I am. Why won't you try it? 🤡🤡🤡🤡
@@anthonybrowne3942 STEVEN CROWDER HAD RECREATED THE RESTRAINT KNEEL ON HIS NECK/SHOULDER AND LEGS FOR 9:32... HE DIDN'T PASS OUT. HE DIDN'T HAVE TROUBLE BREATHING... HE DIDN'T DIE.
DMX DIDN'T HAVE ANYONE KNEELING ON HIM. 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡
Maybe MSM hosts should take enough pills to result in a toxicology report on 11 Ng/ml of FENTENAYL and 19 Ng/ml of METHAMPHETAMINE.
A STUDY OF OVER A MILLION ARRESTS SHOWED 3000 USES OF THE NECK RESTRAINT AND OUT OF THEM 0 DEATHS.
3.5 FENTENAYL- Average overdose death.
7- Double the average overdose death.
11- George Floyd.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It's like blood alcohol levels. .08% is a DWI. .40%-.50% is lethal. George Floyd would have been 1.5% BAC.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
👋🤡👋
@@johnnylawrence7509 You can lie to yourself, but you can't lie to me.
If I was the defense I would be like why the heck were you answering the questions like you were wrong! 🤣😂
When Mr. Blackwell gave his opening statement Chauvin should have stood up and told the court I am guilty.
This class is what u called OWNED
Hybrid: Gas engine only runs while moving, and shuts down when at rest, while vehicle keeps running silently on electric. No exhaust.
Right? Didn't they prove that last week they couldn't figure out if the car was on.
Exactly. But they couldn’t even prove if the car was on or off.
Ok I see you...did ur homework.
Lord then he's a terrible expert and they need to go back and investigate all of his cases
My thoughts also
Absolutely. In a hurry go back and see.
“Was the car even on” 🤣 sorry that was too funny. Anything I guess to prove he is innocent.
Shameful this man can even call himself a doctor. Very very sad.
Q:What Blackwell ate for lunch today.....
A: Fowler!!!!!!😖😖😖😖😖😖
I like this.
dude is a quack, how can he and nelson live with themselves. we saw the murder. i guess dont believe my lying eyes.
And they are watching the murder over and over again in trial if the jury goes any other way I will be distraught 😭 This can’t keep happening.
Apartheid South Africa trained
This fool is so brilliant he could totally have a long and successful career as a Republican politician.
You are an a******
How the f*** do you put him and Republican together in this context you f****** moron
Lol agree 1000% 😎🤣🤣🤣
@@wolke1955 isn't it unbelievable someone could put politics into that context
A politician period....I don’t think it matters which side😂😂
That woman is trying so hard to not laugh sometimes that she's making me laugh!
The Chauvin defense team felt putting a professional liar on as a witness would work!? 🤯 Pathetic!
A doctor in our town works for the local cops and always finds in their favour, a man I knew had his skull smashed by two cops who rammed him headfirst into the cell bars, his skull was equated to a crushed egg shell by the medicos at the hospital, yet the local doctor signed off saying the injuries were self inflicted , which was physically impossible considering the injuries he suffered, his death was not investigated and two cops got away with murder, the cops thought he'd molested his step daughter but later found out the step daughter's boyfriend had been spreading lies, which the cops believed and acted on.
GTFO FOREIGNER. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'm living for Joy's smile!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
As a black man who doesn't want to interact with cops at all because of stuck like this I gotta take this time to shout out the force in Pottstown, Pennsylvanian. They are stand up men with morals and ethics.
cops or white cops?
@Omertà Don83 ok
Joy: "Please. Carbon monoxide poisoning is not poisonous, y'all."
Carbon Monoxide: "Hold my beer." 🍺
Where did she say that? Time stamp.
Huh?
All his cases need to be investigated!
Ha Ha 🤣 LOL.I feel sorry for this doctor's patients. They better run.
I was thinking the EXACT same thing. Now I am skeptical about my doctor. 😂
Medical examiner usually examines dead people :-)
@@abocas he is retired now as well.
He doesn't have any patients. His license to.practice was revoked.
Keep watching msnbc, your ignorance and stupidity will not be challenged.
Fowler's previous case involved the death of a 19 year old teen. Heartbreaking.
Lest jury hope and pray that the jury will be as professional as the prosecution team.
1) NOTICABLY HIGH IN THE STORE.
2) 5 MINUTES LATER PASSED OUT /ODING IN HIS VEHICLE.
3) 3 MINUTES LATER ON CAMERA WITH PILLS IN HIS MOUTH IN HIS OWN VEHICLE.
4) 10 MINUTES LATER SAYING HE'S CHOKING AND CAN'T BREATHE 7X AS PILLS FALL OUT OF HIS MOUTH IN THE BACK OF THE POLICE CAR.
5) MINUTES LATER SAYING HIS STOMACH HURTS ANOTHER SYMPTOM OF OVERDOSE.
6)NEVER ONCE COMPLAINED OF SEVERAL MINUTES OF COMPLAINING ON THE GROUND OF ANY RESTRAINTS ANY PAIN IN HIS NECK ANYTHING OTHER THAN HE CAN'T BREATHE. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Many. He's under investigation now.
Professional witness didn’t do his homework and got shredded!
The defense has been embarrassing themselves from the beginning.
Joy is just beautiful!! All that Melani 🥰
Love her natural hair too - the real Joy Reid
@@sheilaboston7051 Nope that's a weave. I had something similar one year on a Superbowl Cruise. I was never for all the straight inches, I wanted as close to my natural hair texture, so you'd think it was me🤣🤣
Anton Black was 19. Fowler said died from cardiac arrest due to him struggling. The cops said Anton was high and exhibiting super human strength. Anton was bipolar.
My son went to school with Anton. It was a tragic
The little boy that was with Anton Black told police he was Schizophrenia. Which the police officers should've called for medical assistant instead of handcuffing him and holding him down in the prone position
anton was autistic and was introvert, not bipolar
Chaven wearing a diaper during cross examinations of defense star witness
😅🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣😂😂🤣😂
Just think he only weighs 140 pounds. How short is he?
As an Irishman, I'm proud of Dr Tobin. Fowler here being an English 'Cnut' is typical of our lack of justice for the Irish over 100's of year.
Is he not SOUTH AFRICAN?
Joy, I could see how happy you were to report this. Are we getting closer to justice here? Lets hope the verdict supports truth and justice and you can report it here.
I cannot see how Chauvin could possibly walk away from this. I realize it all hangs on the jury, but I just do not see how they could have a shadow of a doubt in this. The prosecution has been consistently buttoning it up. Haven't seen a single loose end left behind by prosecution.
I completely agree! I really don’t see how the jury could come to the conclusion of a “not guilty” verdict. The video speaks for itself. He was clearly murdered, and Derek needs to be held accountable for what he did. For the life of me, when Casey Anthony was found not guilty, I was completely stunned! So it can happen. It’s been causing me so much anxiety, and I’ve been losing sleep because I’m so worried that he’ will get off. 🙏🏽🤞🏽 I really pray he goes to prison. We shall see...
They had help from on high.
Spiritual cleansing is needed in America right now. Help us Lord
One of your country's major problems is far too much religion and an apparent absence of critical thinking. It is past time that you leave the bronze/iron age fairytales behind. Magical thinking is doing significant damage to your country.
Erick Nelson literally just pick a random person on the hood and say “ hey I’ll pay u can u testify as a doctor 👨⚕️ “ his goofy aihhh
He picked someone who he knew had no moral values. He knew who and why he picked that quack.
Looks like it's needed to check his past medical history for protental medical fraud case whit his work whit the police
Living in Maryland I'm so glad I haven't died yet under this guy's watch.
Hogans gotta open an investigation into any case he’s been involved in
😂😂😂Dr, Fowler was obviously a secret agent of the prosecution lol, where did they even find this dude?!
😀😀😀😀😀😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
Prolly the Baltimore harbor😭
Hmmmm something sounds fowl about Mr. Fowler's testimony 🤔
The ‘head next to the exhaust pipe’ defense is something else. Trying extremely hard to blame everything except the knee for his death. Smh...
Sure, you are right.
This doctor left South Africa and moved to the US after Apartheid ended in South Africa, in simple words: he is racist
Unbelievable, unbelievable!!!!! . A doctor would lie like this ... wow sad .
9.29 min.
Takes a while for all the drugs
Basic thug died like a basic thug
FAKE account
The judge: "Get this lying, fraudulent, sock of.. out my court room, no, send it back to Maryland, Now!"
At time you gotta ask....is the defense even trying?
There is no real defense for what happened. They are trying the usual arguments, which usually succeed because of the social bias that cops are somehow more likely to tell the truth, have a hard job, should be excused for overreacting, etc. However in this case "business as usual" may not succeed. The prosecutor is not fooling around, unlike many of these situations. Plus, as many have noted, the fact that the top brass in the police department testified that this was not acceptable behavior on Chauvin's part is practically unheard of. So the Blue Line has failed in this case. We'll see, but the circumstances here are not typical.
@@victoriabaker4400 yep, its hard to defend the indefensible, especially to the entire country, id be willing to bet 90 % of the adults in this country saw it, any of these "experts" are basically selling their soul for a huge check, and their testimony is pitiful as well
He grew up in apartheid South Africa. That tells a lot about him.
The "Defense" ..if he would of got in the squad car he would still be alive??? Are you kidding me, since when does petty crimes equal death??