Really enjoyed this one. Played along didn’t do too bad. Looking forward to the rest. Would be good to see it done on other stats too. Goals, yellow cards etc
Cool concept Pingu, just a thought that as a bonus for being bang on with the answer, you can take the number off the final score(example for Antony instead of 0 it would be -78)
@@LukePinguOfc there cld be a “handicap” depending on who the guest is… If it’s someone like Andy(AJ3), you can give him players that he’s more familiar with, E.g Everton Past& Present Players. If it’s someone like Tom, maybe make him pick 3 out of the possible clubs a footballer has played for, and Luke will have to pick 1 club for him, to choose the amount of games the footballer has played!!
I think maybe you could add some additional rules like 2x scores and 1/2x scores. So if you think the person will be far away with their guess, you can play a 2x score for that guess. And if you think that your guess will be far away, you can use 1/2x score for that guess. You could get one of each per game, and maybe an additional one for getting a 0 score.
Good stuff. For the other guests try 3 life lines. 1) you can pick the club the player played for 2) you can get a time line of the length of time spent at a club 3) maybe for the forwards their number of goals and assists?
Love this! Agree with the others in terms of it making more sense to use percentages as opposed to true numbers. Super quick to calculate with spreadsheets too. I'd honestly consider making it a 5-a-side game? I know the vids would be shorter but I can see some regular guests struggling with this for 11 turns. You could ask them to make their favourite 5-a-side teams but each player has to be from a different league/country? Give future guests a "banned list" of previous players
I think it would be fun to add more stat categories! Goals for a certain club, assists, clean sheets? u could even do yellows and reds for players like Ramos, Pepe etc just to add more besides appearances! Love the content nevertheless
My suggestion for a handicap for other guests: Maybe depending on who the guest is… If it’s someone like Andy(AJ3), you can give him players that he’s more familiar with, E.g Everton Past& Present Players. If it’s someone like Tom, maybe make him pick 3 out of the possible clubs a footballer has played for, and Luke will have to pick 1 club for him, to choose the amount of games the footballer has played!!
Really enjoyed that! I feel like other creators would have a chance if the players were more modern. I spent about 30 mins trying to work out De Roon’s player face, as I completely forgot about him. Good stuff. 👊
Maybe you could work with percentages off instead of actual games off. Than small stints can also be used otherwise they won't make much sense as a choice because even if you are way off then it's still a relatively small score compared to the big ones.
Interesting series with my lack of ball knowledge could bring hints into it example “how long a player was at the club or give the opponent a choice between 2/3 clubs to pick from”
Great idea i think to give people more of a chance maybe do things like goals, assists and cleansheets at one club or maybe do something along the lines of tournaments just to make it more interesting especially for the goalkeepers
Great idea, really interesting. Your other guests might struggle. Anyway, idk if this will hurt the strategic side of things, but maybe decide the club beforehand. So that way both of you can decide whether you wanna target the teams that you know really well early or leave it out really late
Love the video please keep this series going could say pick the stat out of goals assists or appearances or clean sheets for goal keepers make it a bit more interesting
Anyone else realise they said santi cazorla played 334 games for Villarreal when its actually only 251 games for the three times he played for them so where did they get the numbers from
Maybe do percentage difference instead of just games. If you get someone with like 2 or 3 seasons it is almost impossible to mess up more than 50 while with Carzola being within 50 would have been a good guess
I like the new concept! To help the competition, why don't you get the defending team to pick a stat such as yellow cards or goals etc and the attacking team to pick the player and guess the amount. After a few picks it could be quite strategic. Hopefully that makes sense. Just an idea 👍🏼
Really enjoyed this, you'll need people with decent knowledge to maintain it though. Could you introduce other stats as well other than appearances? Goals/cards/clean sheets in particular competitions?
Maybe you should do it by percentages rather than pure offset values. For example. If X has played 1000 games for a club and I guess 800, I should get a 20 added to my score since it's off by 20%. And I'll tell you why. Do you think guessing 800 when he's played 1000 is a worse guess than guessing 200 when the player only has played 3 games for the club? As per current rule, guess 1 will have a score of 200 and guess 2 will have a score of 197, which makes it seem like a closer guess than it is, when in fact it's a horrendous guess
Great idea although it may slow down the flow a wee bit. And maybe getting a zero should actually result in a negative 10 as it's a pretty exceptional accomplishment.
Thought about the same but then things like saying he played 15 when he actually played 25 (could be on loan so not that far and not easy to guess) would bring an insane percentage => 40% off
I got one bang on and it was the first one Deulofeu 70 😂 my 100% record didn’t last long though! Improvement for me would be scoring negative for getting 0 away, I think it’s worth -20
i think once the answers got over 150 games differential with the actual answer you should punish that and add 200 or something even bigger to the score, and if it's on point the opponent also receive 25 score
Hey luke, great video mate, only issue i found is when choosing the club its never worth going somewhere they had a short stint or loan because a wrong guess will always be closer to the right answer (Example if you choose messi its much better to say barcelona instead of PSG because you could be relatively close and still be 50-60 off with such a huge career there)
I think it’s a fair playing field, considering that appearances aren’t really thing people would remember as much unlike goals or trophies won. Would be interesting to see how Fiago would do at this.
Rough board that Luke.. big up the northerners.. de roon for the Boro aswell!!! Got a lift home from soem Boro fans afterone game.. what a guy and shame he couldnt live up to his potential for us
Really confused by this, does wikipedia only show league games? Always thought it was all professional games played? Someone help haha Erics numbers are all higher than there wiki totals.
Maybe if you get it spot on, you should get minus points. Or have a lifeline of asking how many total career appearances they’ve had, or asking goals scored as well
Omg I guessed 211 for Xabi at Liverpool now I am a Liverpool fan but I am not old enough to remember him clearly there and didnt know when he signed tbh
Recommendation: there is imbalance to the game because some players have potentially played 20 games for a club and some players have played 300 i.e. The maximum you can lose by is so different. Potentially you need to agree on a maximum and minimum number of caps between all players
@@LukePingu percentages would make this process fairer. It would be interesting to see what the score would have been if decided on percentages. Eric still wins but by what margin
NEW SERIES IS HERE!!! If anyone has got any feedback let me know? 👍👍👍👍
Shouldn’t it be a Tom if it’s a new series 🤣🤣🤣 My only critique
@@matthewdodge3122 😅😅
Really enjoyed this one. Played along didn’t do too bad. Looking forward to the rest. Would be good to see it done on other stats too. Goals, yellow cards etc
Imagine having minutes played as a stat 😂😂😂
Cool concept Pingu, just a thought that as a bonus for being bang on with the answer, you can take the number off the final score(example for Antony instead of 0 it would be -78)
cool game, but Eric is probably the only one who has a chance compared to the other guests...
We will see 👀
@@LukePinguOfc there cld be a “handicap” depending on who the guest is… If it’s someone like Andy(AJ3), you can give him players that he’s more familiar with, E.g Everton Past& Present Players.
If it’s someone like Tom, maybe make him pick 3 out of the possible clubs a footballer has played for, and Luke will have to pick 1 club for him, to choose the amount of games the footballer has played!!
I think maybe you could add some additional rules like 2x scores and 1/2x scores. So if you think the person will be far away with their guess, you can play a 2x score for that guess. And if you think that your guess will be far away, you can use 1/2x score for that guess. You could get one of each per game, and maybe an additional one for getting a 0 score.
Fancy making that squash any weaker mate?
Will do next time for you 👍
Unlike the others, I can't predict how this one will be played.
👀👀
This is a banger series idea but may go to shit very quick when the ball knowledge of danny aarons or something tries to play
Bit harsh on danny 😅
Have him on the next episode and come back to me 😂😂@@LukePingu
May make it more entertaining...either way alot of us watch Lukes shows to play along
Good choice for a first guest for this! Brilliant watch, really enjoyed playing along. More of these for sure!
💪💪
Good stuff. For the other guests try 3 life lines. 1) you can pick the club the player played for 2) you can get a time line of the length of time spent at a club 3) maybe for the forwards their number of goals and assists?
Good idea
The 78 Luke had in is head for Beckenbauer is probably because he died at that age
Thats it! I've been wondering for days 😅
@@LukePinguwas also 25 away not 35 ;)
Eric is the goat with football quizzing - never known anyone like it.
Love this! Agree with the others in terms of it making more sense to use percentages as opposed to true numbers. Super quick to calculate with spreadsheets too.
I'd honestly consider making it a 5-a-side game? I know the vids would be shorter but I can see some regular guests struggling with this for 11 turns. You could ask them to make their favourite 5-a-side teams but each player has to be from a different league/country? Give future guests a "banned list" of previous players
Yeah % would be much better
More of this please 🙏
Banger of a series this! A total score counter could be good to see the difference otherwise great stuff
Could maybe also introduce a rule where if you get a 0 you get to choose the club to guess for your next player
I think it would be fun to add more stat categories! Goals for a certain club, assists, clean sheets? u could even do yellows and reds for players like Ramos, Pepe etc just to add more besides appearances! Love the content nevertheless
My suggestion for a handicap for other guests:
Maybe depending on who the guest is… If it’s someone like Andy(AJ3), you can give him players that he’s more familiar with, E.g Everton Past& Present Players.
If it’s someone like Tom, maybe make him pick 3 out of the possible clubs a footballer has played for, and Luke will have to pick 1 club for him, to choose the amount of games the footballer has played!!
Nice series for sure. Some people are going to struggle so much!
I love how you come up with new formats!
💪💪
Loving this series Luke! Keep up the great work and soon you’ll be at 100k! 🎉
Love this new concept some people are gonna be far off 😂😂😂
Really cool idea this game, very entertaining!
Cheers, glad you enjoyed!
Eric is the only guy who can humble you Luke looool some of your reactions, the disbelief, incredible.
I was so annoyed haha
Eric’s ball knowledge is 🔥 but his jokes are ☠️
Really enjoyed that! I feel like other creators would have a chance if the players were more modern. I spent about 30 mins trying to work out De Roon’s player face, as I completely forgot about him. Good stuff. 👊
Thanks 👌
Great idea of a new series, be good to see it for other stats such as goals or clean sheets
👍👍
Anyone else love seeing pingu get walloped?😂
😭😭
Good to have you back eric
Maybe you could work with percentages off instead of actual games off. Than small stints can also be used otherwise they won't make much sense as a choice because even if you are way off then it's still a relatively small score compared to the big ones.
Thats a good idea
Interesting series with my lack of ball knowledge could bring hints into it example “how long a player was at the club or give the opponent a choice between 2/3 clubs to pick from”
Yeah could do
Great idea i think to give people more of a chance maybe do things like goals, assists and cleansheets at one club or maybe do something along the lines of tournaments just to make it more interesting especially for the goalkeepers
Very good idea
Great idea, really interesting. Your other guests might struggle. Anyway, idk if this will hurt the strategic side of things, but maybe decide the club beforehand. So that way both of you can decide whether you wanna target the teams that you know really well early or leave it out really late
Eric’s knowledge man 🔥
🧠🧠
@@LukePingu Yh definitely
Love the video please keep this series going could say pick the stat out of goals assists or appearances or clean sheets for goal keepers make it a bit more interesting
Yeah was thinking that. Just kept it to appearances for first episode
@@LukePingu If you wanna be really harsh could do red and yellow cards as well
Morning sorted! #tenable
Pretty sure 103-78 is 25 not 35 😂
Quick maffs
Like the game, would be cool if the club was randomly allocated so it’s down to kick if you get one with loads or few appearances
I'd say my knowledge is on par with Eric
This Eric guy is just outrageously good. Knows way way too much about this stuff and then some.
It's crazy
Anyone else realise they said santi cazorla played 334 games for Villarreal when its actually only 251 games for the three times he played for them so where did they get the numbers from
Cool concept !
Thanks!
Can’t believe I got the Ronaldo apps bang on the nose, knew he didn’t play much for Milan. Said to myself, it will only be about 20 😂
haha good one!
That was an insane performance from Eric, difficult game this
Unreal stuff
Maybe do percentage difference instead of just games.
If you get someone with like 2 or 3 seasons it is almost impossible to mess up more than 50 while with Carzola being within 50 would have been a good guess
If you get 0 you should get -10 for sure!
Should do this with percentages instead of numbers to make it fair
God video 😊
🔥🔥
Derby back to the championship 🏆
🐏🐏🐏🐏🐏🐏
How do you 2 have so much ball knowledge
Craig Forsyth and Beckenbaur what a partnership
💪💪
I like the new concept! To help the competition, why don't you get the defending team to pick a stat such as yellow cards or goals etc and the attacking team to pick the player and guess the amount. After a few picks it could be quite strategic. Hopefully that makes sense. Just an idea 👍🏼
Yeah good idea
Really enjoyed this, you'll need people with decent knowledge to maintain it though.
Could you introduce other stats as well other than appearances? Goals/cards/clean sheets in particular competitions?
Yeah for sure
You wont be able to get angryginge or danny aarons doing this as its too hard.
Although id argue thats a blessing in disguise for the viewers
Great video mate love the new concept
Thanks 👌
I hate to be that guy but Big Massive Eric needs to touch some grass 😂😂😂 His ball knowledge is actually scary
😅😅
Surely the meta is to keep going for where they made the most appearances to increase margin for error…
I had 78 in my head for beckenbauer as well and was certain it was right. Very weird
Fun Fact: Ashely Young was my next door neighbour when he was playing at Watford.
The difficulty of this surpasses Bingo imo
💪💪
Maybe you should do it by percentages rather than pure offset values. For example.
If X has played 1000 games for a club and I guess 800, I should get a 20 added to my score since it's off by 20%.
And I'll tell you why. Do you think guessing 800 when he's played 1000 is a worse guess than guessing 200 when the player only has played 3 games for the club?
As per current rule, guess 1 will have a score of 200 and guess 2 will have a score of 197, which makes it seem like a closer guess than it is, when in fact it's a horrendous guess
Very true 👍
Great idea although it may slow down the flow a wee bit. And maybe getting a zero should actually result in a negative 10 as it's a pretty exceptional accomplishment.
Thought about the same but then things like saying he played 15 when he actually played 25 (could be on loan so not that far and not easy to guess) would bring an insane percentage => 40% off
@@deoganchev5806 that's also very true. At the end of the day there just needs to be a way to normalize the scale a bit better.
Certified capgun banger
🎉🎉
I got one bang on and it was the first one Deulofeu 70 😂 my 100% record didn’t last long though!
Improvement for me would be scoring negative for getting 0 away, I think it’s worth -20
“A nice round” then doesn’t say a round number 😂
hahahah
i think once the answers got over 150 games differential with the actual answer you should punish that and add 200 or something even bigger to the score, and if it's on point the opponent also receive 25 score
Yeah true
Hey luke, great video mate, only issue i found is when choosing the club its never worth going somewhere they had a short stint or loan because a wrong guess will always be closer to the right answer
(Example if you choose messi its much better to say barcelona instead of PSG because you could be relatively close and still be 50-60 off with such a huge career there)
Yeah true
Let’s get it
🔥🔥
368 is my score in Eric guy has great knowledge
Need an overall score counter to keep up as you go along
Yeah might do that
This is gonna be a great video I can just tell
👀👀
Yooooo the Dominican Republic is where I was born. Nice shoutout
Very nice 👌
guessed along, was pretty far away from most of them but somehow i managed to guess morientes spot on for some reason.
haha nice one
I think it’s a fair playing field, considering that appearances aren’t really thing people would remember as much unlike goals or trophies won. Would be interesting to see how Fiago would do at this.
Yeah other guests will be interesting!
13:52 if ever there was a need for Danny Shittu
Hahhaha
Rough board that Luke.. big up the northerners.. de roon for the Boro aswell!!! Got a lift home from soem Boro fans afterone game.. what a guy and shame he couldnt live up to his potential for us
haha great story
Hi pingu, I think you might be thinking of the age beckenbauer was when he passed
I was actually, someone commented it earlier!
Hey luke, if u make indonesia edition it will have many viewers😊🎉
Couldve been a bit more harsh to Eric as he wasnt giving you an easy time😉
I will have my revenge
You should go with clubs with more appearances, higher chance for big mistakes
Yeah learnt my lesson tbh
This is my favourite kind of autism - just joking ofc, my jaw dropped when he got Anthony’s amount spot on. Amazing 👏
the maths aint mathing? lol he had 251 for villareal
Is it 18:00 yet come on Pingu 👀👀
👀👀
Really confused by this, does wikipedia only show league games? Always thought it was all professional games played?
Someone help haha Erics numbers are all higher than there wiki totals.
Go to the stats part at the bottom of the players page. Will have all games.
no way we both said 137 for lucio 😭
Maybe if you get it spot on, you should get minus points. Or have a lifeline of asking how many total career appearances they’ve had, or asking goals scored as well
Yeah true!
Hi Luke pingu I haven’t seen you for a year
😭😭
Omg I guessed 211 for Xabi at Liverpool now I am a Liverpool fan but I am not old enough to remember him clearly there and didnt know when he signed tbh
Nice one!
Why not use transfermrkt?
Probably should tbh 😅
Recommendation: there is imbalance to the game because some players have potentially played 20 games for a club and some players have played 300 i.e. The maximum you can lose by is so different. Potentially you need to agree on a maximum and minimum number of caps between all players
Yeah might do % going forward so it's not the number of apperances but the % away
@@LukePingu percentages would make this process fairer. It would be interesting to see what the score would have been if decided on percentages. Eric still wins but by what margin
q grand eric la rompio toda y encima tiene la casaca de almirante brown, la cabra
woah
🤯🤯
Sorry Eric but 103-78 = 25 not 35
I've been robbed 😭😭
Big ups Luke for making a living Googling football stats 🎉
what website are you guys using to see this?
Wikipedia
@@LukePingu I was just watching along with having Wikipedia open and didn’t get the same results, but damn it’s a good series idea, keep it up