Big 3 Vocal ranking (SM,YG & JYP).
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 พ.ค. 2024
- -RED VELVET VOCAL ANALYSIS
• Red Velvet Vocal Analy...
-AESPA VOCAL ANALYSIS
• Aespa vocal analysis (...
-BLACKPINK VOCAL ANALYSIS
• Blackpink vocal rankin...
-BABY MONSTER VOCAL ANALYSIS
• Baby Monster Vocal Ran...
-TWICE VOCAL ANALYSIS
• Twice vocal ranking an...
-ITZY VOCAL ANALYSIS
• Itzy vocal ranking and...
-NMIXX VOCAL ANALYSIS
• NMIXX vocal ranking an...
Update-Rami above karina kyujin and giselle
Haven't finished the video yet but going to pretend to be surprised when I see Wendy ranked first.
its a giving at this point
Wendy's support range is F#3/G3-C#5/D5-G#5/A5 she has supported most of her A5s so it should be included
i give solid D5 It does change alot tho and i made a mistake with head voice
this was very stressful to make😭. I was going to do a male version, a company version and one with hybe aswell as big 3 gg big vocal analysis but no. Individual group analysis in the description
hybe needs to be its own vid cuz they get mogged by big 3 to death 💀
@@SCRIABINIST 😭😭
@@SCRIABINISTat least they have seungkwan who could compete with nct vocalist
I've yet to see anyone from 3rd - 5th generation to step up to Wendy's level of vocal greatness.
Maybe Juria. Her skills are amazing, her voice like silk, and she can use vibrato at any level, like only Wendy could
well Lily lol
Crushing aespa is such a hard chore hybe!!!
They already crushed Aespa
In making their group sing out of their comfortable range though(basically due to mediocre technique)
@@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062lmaoooo
I like it, but i really want to see a ranking with all members. Hope you will do one day.
Im worried it will be to long😭
I will watch it all!
Do one for boy groups of big 3 from 3rd to 5th gens. EXO, NCT & riize from SM, got7, stray kids & xdinary heroes from JYP, winner, ikon & treasure from YG.
We know Winter, Seulgi, Haewon, Lily, Ning Ning and Wendy are the first ones xD No one at this moment can beat them.
And we know, the whole Nmixx and Aespa are here,
You should do males next.
ill add to my list
But dont forget about bands please @@rina_core
JYP wasn’t playing when debuted nmixxx.
Btw is Lily’s tone like that or she gets constantly higher notes than she can support that she end up screaming? She’s so shouty to me. Idk, that’s why I don’t like her singing at all. I could listen to Sullyoon, Ning, Haewon for hours tho.
She gets shouty the higher she goes goes yes
Her initial tone is already high, even when she is in conversation but yes, I understand, she can be sounded shouty whenever reaching higher.
i’m not trying to be rude but saying that you don’t like someone is kind of rude. you can keep it too yourself.
Let's be frank, we all knew who would come up first
Have you ever thought about a Lily and Wendy collaboration? 😍❤️
Would insane. Lily did one with ailee and yuju tho
@@rina_core yess
I’m a little confused by how this ranking was created, especially with Yeji being last ;o;
This vid always comes to mind lol
th-cam.com/users/shortse2kRqtzQtmY?si=EOIGSE7se7SaOQTt
Tension, tightness ,straining and pushiness that whats come to my mind when i see that video. Being about to sing in a high key doesn't make you better nor does singing a highnote. Izone in general sings higher then everyone in kpop lets be real eunbi chaeyeon wonyoung nako hitomi all of them can probably do what yeji did maybe even better probably even better. Does that make them a better vocalist? No its the execution of it and yeji did not execute that well. Its like saying 'omg she did a whistle note she's the best vocalist in kpop' no she's not. Yeji lacks techniques,precision, openness ,clarity etc. Watch the vocal analysis its in the description.
@@rina_core thx for the clarification! I see what u mean haha
While high notes aren’t the main factor of being a good singer, I do think that a certain skill level is required for someone to simply hit a challenging note. The way everyone is ranked does make more sense to me now tho :3
yeji litterly screams her parts, she's bad actually @@dancingdan22
Introduction👍😂
Can I ask ine question? Why does the video starts at 24? I understand that you didn't include all the members of the groups, but why specifically 24? Shouldn't jennie and jisoo be included since they are lead vocals? Did you knly out the members that are able to support? In that case Shouldn't mina and chaeyong be included? I'm not complaining I'm just comfused, that's all
I feel she included people who aren’t underdeveloped anymore and are low weak. Mina jennie are underdeveloped. Chaeyoung regressed and jisoo doesn’t support.
Before even starting the video and not seeing her in the thumbnail, i already knew who was #1 😂😂😂
Taeyeon, Jessica, Luna? SM Vocalist?
luna>tae>Jessica jung
I think only Taeyeon reminds in SM but I'm not sure
@@twice__drippin_stan4676 yes, jessica left years ago like 2012 or 2011, don't remember exactly and luna in 2019, but even though they should still be considered as sm vocalist, in my personal opinion.
Help how is chiquita above rora 😭
Because she's better
jyp and sm on top
I love that both Nmixx and Twice have 3 members inside top 10 🥰
is this just me or is there no audio 😭
its just you😭
Sometimes happen to me to, you have to go to an other video and come back, at lest that works for me
Can you explain how do you rank this because I’m quite confuse. Is this tier ranking or individual ranking? And why is the rank number different everytime ?
Based on your ranking (please correct me if I'm wrong)
1. Wendy (SM) (Red Velvet)
2. Lily (JYP) (NMIXX)
3. Haewon (JYP) (NMIXX)
4. Ningning (SM) (aespa)
5. Seulgi (SM) (Red Velvet)
6. Winter (SM) (aespa)
7. Jihyo (JYP) (Twice)
8. Sullyoon (JYP) (NMIXX)
9. Jeongyeon (JYP) (Twice)
10. Nayeon (JYP) (Twice)
11. Rami (YG) (BabyMonster)
12. Giselle (SM) (aespa)
13. Karina (SM) (aespa)
14. Kyujin (JYP) (NMIXX)
15. Rosé (YG) (BlackPink)
16. Chiquita (YG) (BabyMonster)
17. Bae (JYP) (NMIXX)
18. Rora (YG) (BabyMonster)
19. Jiwoo (JYP) (NMIXX)
20. Ahyeon (YG) (BabyMonster)
21. Lia (JYP) (ITZY)
22. Joy (SM) (Red Velvet)
23. Pharita (YG) (BabyMonster)
24. Yeji (JYP) (ITZY)
aespa is the best vocal group among listed groups because all of their members are above top 13.
The second best is NMIXX. All their members managed to enter top 19.
someone finally read the pinned comment🙇🏻🙇🏻🙇🏻
Yes spot on
Some fun facts:
-Twice and Nmixx are the groups with most members inside top 10 with three members each, followed by Red Velvet and Aespa with two members each.
- YG has no idol inside top 10
- NiziU and Vcha are sadly not included
From each company we have:
- 11 jype idols from 3 groups
- 7 SM idols from 2 groups
- 6 YG idols from 2 groups
Most members inside the top per group:
1. Nmixx with 6 members (all members)
2. Babymonster with 5 members (sorry I'm not sure if that's all members of the group)
3. Aespa with 4 members (all members)
4. Red Velvet and Twice with 3 members each
5. Itzy with 2 members
6. Blackpink with 1 member
@@twice__drippin_stan4676 niziu and vcha i forgot about them😭 Im not update with niziu vocals I'm not sure of they improved or not
can you do an EXO one? I'm curious about everyone outside ChenBaekSoo
do you mean a exo vocal ranking?
because that's on my list
@@rina_core yes 😅
@@rina_core can't wait!
and babymonster stans think baemon is the best vocalist in the indsutry LMAO
Will you dare to say the same thing after 5 years ???
They won't @@Not_a.newbie, They won't 🤠
Another jobless barker. No one said that. They say O.F. 4.T.H. G.E.N.E.R.A.T.I.O.N.
Maybe it's just reading comprehension issues? Or too much toxicity inside?
They are the best voices in the entire Kpop industry....this TH-camr has no idea what she's talking about 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Twice Top1 and 2 ..........🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤦♀
Fr, next level delulu be like
did Jiwoo really regress? and Lily more like mid/high imo
More mid
Ahhmmm! King Taeyeon?
not 3rd gen its just 3-5 gen
Jung Ahyeon ❤❤❤
Rami is high w-a???
mid w-a
Yes the lowest high W-A active for the moment
@@Hype-V-oythat’s nayeon.. not rami
@@Hype-V-oy shes not high W-A she's not full enough and doesn't have enough clarity. compare her to Stephanie who's considered the lowest high W-A or kim who's one of the highest mid W-A.
@@rina_core she’s better than every mid w-a out there. She outdoes Nayeon too. Her Bb4s are clear and less nasal than Nayeons.
People need to accept that (vocally):
1. Chiquita is better than Ahyeon and Rora
2. Rami is better than Rora
3. Lia is better than Pharita
4. Bae is better than Jiwoo, Ahyeon, and Rora
5. Karina is better than Kyujjn
6. Giselle is better than Karina
7. Rami is better than Rosè
TEA 😭😭
Ahyeon > Rora, Chiquita, Pharita
@@atilapiresm chiquita>rora>ahyeon>pharita
LOUDER
@@rina_core No, definitely not, ahyeon sings better than Chiquita, Rora & Pharita.
Lack belle of kiss of life, she is the best in the industry, I swear, she is incredible, if vocals are simply unimaginable, take the time to look for her and listen to her.
Yeah, I was wondering where Mamamoo and Kiof were then I reread the title
It said big 3 groups... sm, yg and jyp
While there are certain things i disagree with overall oretty solid ranking. What i'd change is that i'd put rora higher since she was like...the official main vocalist the only confirmed one actually. Then nayeon and jeongyeon would be a bit lower too for me. And i'd switch winter and jihyo maybe. But this is pretty accurate tho not too far off
I suggested watching the analysis
When is rora confirmed?
In her mind@@HahaHaha-jx4le
@@HahaHaha-jx4le yg said so
@@muvani. im a guy lol but whatever
Rami, Chiquita,rora, Ahyeon, pharita ❤.
Idk ningning really got a veryyyy verryyy nice tone like her highnotes seems glides so smoothly and easy to listen to
3:48 huh?
4:17 HUH?
?
girl honestly I agree with u all the way as someone who goes to school for vocal and more these people need to know that Chiquita is the second best Rora is 3 and so on they think high notes mean great vocalist when it fact it's the opposite low notes are the hardest to have come out perfectly if your voice doesn't suit it and that goes for other groups u mentioned like yea people gon be like wheres Jisoo when in fact Lisa is better then Jisoo in technique so Jisoo would be last and so much more like these kpop fans are delusional to a tea
i would say jisoo above lisa only because she has little singing material but general if they had the same material lisa. I've said once ill say it again lisa is not as bad as kpop stans want her to be.
@@rina_core ong people really want lisa to be a non-singer when thats not the case
Ningning or Jessica
ning
Once jiwoo & bae let go of their stylistic choice in singing & starts following the same training system kyujin & sullyoon have, nmixx is gonna be unstoppable. Nmixx is good & strong don't get me wrong but bae & jiwoo are still notable weak especially if you compare them to sullyoon & kyujin what more to haewon & lily. I just want them to drop the nasal & half air technique & just go to the samw route as sullkyu, even better train like haely.
Real, they have boom potential(idk how to describe it LOL) but is being restricted by their stylistic choice. Theyre still great but when someone is in a group with the best vocals in 4th gen they'd need to catch up or else theyre gonna end up maybe regressing or getting less lines because they cannot support certain notes, if they do improve though... Theyre gonna break the standard which they've already broken dozens of times.
Hi! In your honest opinion do Chiquita and rora have the potential to be better than rosé
Why did you have to bring rose into this?
What did rosé do to you?
@@rina_core why are u so damn rude im just asking😭! Im still a blink since 2016
@@Hhhhgu8 how was i rude?
@@rina_core you can simply answer my question without saying "what did rosé did to u"
Its sad the focus is only kn the big 3 there are also groupd that had grwat vocal range but sonce thwir new and not under big companies not all are chexkkng them out. Try UNIS from F&F. All can sing live and always sang live. 6 out the 8 has high vocal range with the two still can carry a tune. I am sure they can also be in the same conversation as these talented girls. They just need that chance for is to als heat them
i have a unis ranking. I don't just focus on the big 3. I focus on alot of groups in very first full length video purple kiss and weekly were in it.
Imagen all the work that someone have to put to do a video considering the whole kpop industry, like wow, months? A year? More? I don't know but has to be a hella of work
Ahyeon and Rora both above chiquita they're arguably Mid W-A, Ahyeon is nothing below Low/Mid W-A idk why she's listed Low here...
Also why aren't mina and Jennie listed ?? They're both Low Weak, also Rami way too Low she should be above Nayeon since Nayeon is Mid W-A and Rami is High W-A
And you could've add jisoo,Irene and Tzuyu into the ranking since those 3 got inconsistent and shallow supports
Nayeon is high weak to average not rami.
Nayeon is always underrated. People always wanna put her lower than her real ranking
Ahyeon low she's below jiwoo who's regressed to low w-a and bae who's above rora, rora is barely making it out of low W-A with Bb4 with all that nasality and tension nope ,This video was made weeks ago which is why jennie and mina aren't in it. If anyone ever bothers to read the pinned comment i said she's above karina kyujin and giselle as an update and no don't ever drag nayeon that low. Nation is high W-A rami is mid, even in quality nayeon>rami, mid belts nayeon>rami , upper belts nayeon>rami, lows nayeon>rami , pitch accuracy nayeon ,agility nayeon. Overall nayeon is bettet in support quality and very other technical aspects. Irene tzuyu and jisoo are underdeveloped theyre not worth ranking them.
@@laracosta7882 Nayeon is Mid W-A nothing higher than Mid/High
@@rina_core First of all who said Ahyeon was below jiwoo ?? Well i'm not a vocal analyzer but Ahyeon is listed Low/Mid W-A in @Minjivocal and @Jichu_trq Rora is also listed Low/Mid W-A in sootzubae, so both are definitely AT LEAST above jiwoo, and I don't think they're lower than bae tho, also Rami is listed Mid/High W-A in sootzubae and High W-A in jichu_trq so she's defo above Nayeon since Nayeon is only a Mid W-A,(she's listed Mid W-A in @Chewieqtpie) so nowhere above rami
Does Rosé not support C5?
No😭😭
Were are people getting this information from
@@rina_core So she didn't get better?
@@L....F Nopw
She actually regressed😭
Hae has a solid C#5 I think
I have such huge problem with stylistic vocalists. Most of the time they're a huge miss with only few who sound good & has a healthy technique of singing. Because who told them that its alright to sing like they have speech stutter?? Who told them its alright to sing sounding like they're out of breath??? Who told them its alright to sing like they have a food stuck in their mouth that they forgot to chew??? Are they aware that they don't need ti gave a stylistic vocalist just to add a "twang" in the groups vocals. There's a lot of ways to add a certain oomph in a song without sounding like stuttering, out of breathe or chewing.
Rami, Karina mid-high and Giselle is solid high!
no rami ,karina and giselle solid mid
There ain’t no way giselle is a better vocalist than rami😂
read the pinned comment which i have to see before typing a comment. Stop being a keyboard warrior and read before typing
There are errors in the video like Giselle and Nayeon are not better singers then Rosé and Rami.
No errors
They are :)
they are
Yeji Top 2 and Pharita Top 5 Is this a joke? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Ahyeon Top 5? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Twice Top 1 and 2 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Aespa Top 1 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Is yeji not the second best vocalist in itzy? Id pharjta not the the 5th ahyeon the 4th in their groups? Are u confused or something?
@@rina_core Are you telling me that the ranking starts from the last? I mean, Yeji is the last one, right?
And you put Pharita second to last? 😂😂 When BamyMonster should be the top 7 in the ranking....🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@Alexia-gm9pd Girl stop being delusion baby monster aren't that good and yes after yeji its pharita the rest of the members of these groups aren't in the ranking as you can see from yeji being last. The only laughable part is the baby monster one😂😂 you guys are really setting your faves up
@@rina_core You have no idea what you're talking about......just the video you posted of Ahyeon is enough to put her on Top1....None of them are capable of singing that song like that...wtf?
And please, remove Twice from the ranking....😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@Alexia-gm9pd like said if you came here for me to valid your opinions please leave ahyeon is barely beating a sub vocalist in nmixx. She's not even beating her own members stop the delusional and go on with your day. Im not feeding your delusion either come back to reality or leave my comment sections with your delusion and its my fault twice is vocal line are outdoing your faves. Face the facts please