It is painful to see it such a heart breaking moment for all of them who survived from this bomb they didn't know what would happen next few minutes later. They saw they families died in front of their eyes. Thousands of people were injured later became disable like me. I wish those people who died in such war may them rest in peace.
I live in Tokyo and I have visited Hiroshima atomic bomb dome. I met few old survivors and talked to them. It is still painful and emotional for Japanese people living there. I cried during my visit to Hiroshima. Say NO to wars. It is not good for humanity...
@@sumansaxena2277 if you are talking about the war crimes of imperial japan in china then maybe yes but idk what you mean by racism there so, can you elaborate?
I want to appreciate Dhruv for this. Most of the times I feel spending time in TH-cam is time consuming and wasting my time. But when I watch your videos I take back good knowledge in my head I feel satisfied that I got something to know.
Worldclass documentary.! Just top-class work. The ability to retain public attention for such a long time and still able to convey a story in such a way is absolutely stunning. Everyone who worked on this one should be proud of themselves.
@@farazmubashercheema12 yeah true but using people in that statement isnt wrong either. men are people too, and everyone knows who participates in wars. men.
@@Slayer12u Lord Rama is hindu god who fought with king of demons(Ravana) in lanka...which is today's Sri lanka. It happened in like around 5000 or 6000 BCE. If you're curious for more ...You can always read...Ramayana or Ramcharitmanas.
@@mayank00764 if his a god ? Why did he fight ? What's the use of creating humans that weak that they can't fight themselves Why did he didnt created a leader who would deal with everyone who is bad ? Instead he only fight
During childhood, We read about this. We even learned the dates of attacks. But now as a grown-up man, I literally get goosebumps while watching this video. How was the feeling of died people , injured people? People who have to live with the fear of death after Hiroshima
Yes , our teacher was telling and we were thrilled some of us were also laughing after making some jokes on it But our teacher lectured us for half hour and make us feel reality
Please correct your info: America wanted to be a part of this war and sending their troops to Pearl Harbor made it possible. As they already knew sending their men to Pearl Harbor will make their men sitting ducks there and they will be attacked and which will give America a clean chance to enter this war.
That "shadow remained on floor and walls" thing just chilled my spine . Our world history is so scary and i feel that I born in very good time compared to past
@@HasanUnknown " Hum hi hum hai...Sirf aur sirf hum hi hum hai ..Jo kisi aur panth ko maane vo kuch nahi hai.. pehle ye bolkar islam apnane ke liye bolte ho fir agar koi nahi maane toh sir kalam karke Islam Kabul karvate aaye ho..Ye Kaisa dharm hua..ye toh kisi sanki ki uttejna hui jo kuch bhi karke apna panth thopna chahta hai..
Eye opener. I bet most of us did not know the reason behind all these events. This is an outstanding work to bring facts in front of everyone and have them think through right/wrong. Thanks for all your hard work.
@@chillingcatYT it is not simple man! To check the information from various news sites and to bring there collage in front of us!!!!! he is not telling the lines of Google
History itself is an never ending debate,discussion and never ending arguments because every historians,philosophers, diplomats have different interpretations And even nowadays there are experts from WhatsApp universities. But this one was really very informative and interesting
what happened, why happened, and who was responsible doesn't matter at all, the only people who truly suffers are the one who have no interest in war at all, and all the leaders enjoys their lives peacefully
You don't know anything about war Japan rules south east asia Japan robes , kills innocent and does rapes. It's important for Japan to teach a lesson A famous line As you sow so shall you reap If America did not bomb Japan , this will lead to the continuation of war and at a bigger level Atom bomb is only a lesson to be in their limits
Imagine you just siting outside because you feel bored, you said your mom I am going outside and you then sit on bench then some thousand degree temprature bomb exploded and you vaporize with it.
@@urbanquest2768 Bro unhone Military paar attack kya tha naa ki Civilian base paar and for your kind information, America ne City paar attack kya tha or wo bhi Nuclear Warheads kaa use kaar ke, agar badla lena he tha toh Neculear warheads kyu use kya tha unhone ne ?? Normal bomb se bhi toh le sakta tha. Or wo bhi Military base paar hamla kaar ke. That is why I say little knowledge is dengerous and these line perfectly suit on you people.👆
@@Nine-TenTen-Nine 😂 to kya military ki life cheap h as compared to civilian? Pahle kisne attack Kiya? Acha kiya us ne. Egoist country should learn a tough lesson.
Oh God! More than 2 lakh people have died, just think what would have happened to the animals in the city, it was not their fault. What would they have been thinking while dying…. I get goosebumps thinking about it😢
In less than 80 years , Japan has become one of the most developed countries of the world both economically and socially. Take a bow Japan 🙌🏻 And India even after not facing such a devastating attack or anything that bad, after 75 years of independence still at developing stage...We all need to join hands to make India a fully developed country..!!!
This is what happens when there is dictatorship. Democracy might have numerous flaws, but usually no two democratic countries declare war on each other.
After happening all these disasters Japanese never took revenge of war but they go for development of their country and entire people. Look today how wonderful Japan is !
they didnt because the military forces were completely abolished and Article 9 of the new constitution forbade Japan to maintain an army or go to war ever again :D
@@anhaadevoursyou still. Do you see any hostility among Japanese citizens towards U.S.? They quietly started rebuilding their nation instead of blaming everything on past.
because they are not too sentimental about religion, infact Japan is one of the world's least religious countries, that's the major reason for their development, India will take 150-200 years to reach japan's current level in terms of mindset
Puri story hi change Kardi ab achanak se Japan villain side me pahuch gya America supportive perspective. Well done dhruv rathi sir. U r almost their to make india the next Bangladesh,Sri Lanka.🎉
I began with one video and ended up binge watching this channel. So addictive in terms of content, narration and undefined capability to hold a grip with the audience. I literally looked for subscribe button although I had subscribed long ago.
I had tried myself a lot to know the exact reasons behind this attack but failed to do it. I am in awe of your efforts to search, compose and dictate sequence of historical events so well. We can't afford to miss a single word that you speak. Many congratulations to you and your team to disseminate valuable information and make it look and sound interesting and compelling. Even my nine year old son loves to watch these videos from beginning to end. Thanks for posting amazing content!
Idk how you didn't knew about the Pearl harbor incident. There's even a Hollywood movie made on it with the same name- Pearl Harbor. Japan attacked on it first so USA automatically got dragged into the war (although seems like the b@stards wanted to get involved into the war) and then USA as a revenge dropped bomb on Hiroshima & Nagasaki.
Sometimes to save millions you must kill others we don't have seen war but after what i heard and seen from movie game and noble thousands of soldiers die protecting their friends and civilians in short no matter what you say the Harsh reality of this world is you me and others will die in a war situation no matter what and to prevent that a person must have to in our place if you think it's cruel then your living in a fantasy
@@evm6177 i fully agree but problem is that time assassination was try to committed on him man times but somehow he always survived like Cuban leader Fidel Castro in short only high officials and general know his location besides his castles were with High defence and gunship weapon so bombing them without casualties was impossible so they made a easy way to make them Stop by destroying City
I'm using TH-cam for fun, But when my friend asked about dhruv rathee I'm getting so bored in first time, When I focused, Your videos are mind blowing, satisfying and full of knowledge.. Hats off for this guy...
I hoped I had a teacher like you when studying history subject in school....your videos are so informative as well as full of energy, true information, interesting to hear....
Hi Dhruv sir, I would like to say thank you for what all u have done. Whenever u post a video it always bring a smile to my face. It doesn't feel like ive wasted my time watching TH-cam videos coz u give so much knowledge, information and even raise up issues. Thank u again and God bless u♥️
It was worth watching and very informative, just imagine the scenario of you and your family present at that spot and now almost 12,705 nuclear weapons in the possession of 9 countries makes everybody vulnerable for extinction in case of severe conflict. If you study the economic scenario of Japan in 1945,they were on the brink of total collapse, and dropping could have been delayed or totally avoided.
You know why no major war has occurred in the last 70 years, because people saw the utter nuclear destruction and armed themselves for a collective suicide. Mutually assured destruction is the true reason for global peace (kind of) and not Gandhi an ideology or hippies in front of the white house.
It could not have been. You must have skipped over all history channel documentaries and other stuff about Japan's imperialist tendencies that caused a lot of loss of life and otherwise. They were infamous around that time for their massacres, illegal inhumane experiments and even forcing people to participate against their will. And not to forget Pearl Harbour.
A prolonged world war would undeniably cause millions of death and trillions of economic loss for several nations. That is why it was used as a last measure. Who knew that in retrospect, Japan would become the beacon of culture and technology and China would instead be everything anti democracy in years to come.
I am a science teacher and I love all the subjects. I discuss about history with my students. Your videos has helped me to develop interest in history in my students. Wonderful work.
ill never forget one testimony of a Hiroshima survivor who described the immediate reaction to the blast of the bomb "We didnt think it was a bomb. It was so huge, so totally destructive, we thought the world was splitting in two"
Getting chills after watching the whole perspective and consequences faced by civilians. Thanks for being the best narrator i ever came across . Didn’t feel like a 30 min video. It kept me hooked and i literally went through all the other related videos. Best way to educate people and put in the idea and importance of peace in their minds.
It is very hard to imagine the pain of Japanese citizens at that time . Air,light ,water and what not everyinch of surrounding was mercilessly attacking the innocents.Kudos to the spirit of the Japanese for their unimaginable recovery after such dangerous attacks.
No country's leaders own their citizens' lives or the land they're living in. Truly tragic how innocent people who were not involved in the war had to lose their lives in the worst way possible.
I'm addicted to your channel. Your presentation and diction are flawless. In addition, you are unbiased and never hesitate to call it like you see it. Keep up the good work!
I still remember in 10th standard how our s.s teacher taught us about world war 2 and told us the whole situation and what happened to Hiroshima and Nagasaki after the bomb blast we all students kept silent and we all were chilled to bone listening to her . Even after watching the anime grave of fireflies I just get so startled and sad knowing that it's story of most of people who suffered that time I hope the world would never face something like this again . I still remember the quote from a yt video of grave of fireflies "War is something when some rich people can't get along , and the poor peoples is the one who suffered the most "
It is painful to see it such a heart breaking moment for all of them who survived from this bomb they didn't know what would happen next few minutes later. They saw they families died in front of their eyes. Thousands of people were injured later became disable like me. I wish those people who died in such war may them rest in peace.
I know that what US did in Hiroshima and Nagasaki is wrong but why no one talks about the Pearl Harbor attack by Japan on Us Navy. Think of their Family ones.
@@burgerpizza2004 and also what about the Chinese atrocities caused by imperial japan? They probably have massacred more than even Hitler did. And the Japanese still worship those emperors. What a shame..!
@@ameer6168 Correct and which Japan never distinguished. Japanese army wreaked havoc, ravaged everything and killed millions wherever they invaded in from China, Singapore, Myanmar to Andaman.
Best video so far in this channel. Dhruv Rathee is such a gem. I saw a lot of videos on this topic.But I never got this much in details view of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Dhruv explained it point by point and his research my godd💯💯. He connected every related event of ww2 and provided all the newspaper article and even critics solution. Big fan of you and your team effort.keep going like this Dhruv💗💗
Very true but in India fools majority hate him.. Indian's believe they have brahmastra according to Frictional story Ramayan, Mahabharat.. Still these fools don't realise Mugals ruled for 600yrs then French Portugal Dutch British till freedom.. If they had brahmastra where is it after 1k thousand years 😂😂😂😂😂
There is always a lot to learn from Dhruv's videos And as always-the analysis is well presented Absolute top notch..... Once again Amazing Work Hats off to you
OMG! You won't believe it ,yesterday i was searching on the YT for the same topic but couldn't find any video by Dhruv . Yesterday i was hoping a video of the same topic and today here you are 🙂When i saw the topic i was totally shocked and without even starting the video i thought to tell you first 😀👏🙌
अमेरिका ने उस टाइम जो बम गिराया वो उस समय एक दम सही फैसला था।। उससे पहले जापानी सैनिक अपने पड़ोस के देशों के ऊपर अत्याचार कर रहा था।। मर्दों को मार दिया जा रहा था।। औरतों को बलात्कार करके बुरी तरह से मारा जा रहा था।। जापान अपने समय में सबसे क्रूर देश रहा है।। यह बिल्कुल निर्दई थे।।
युध्दामधून कोणत्याही समस्याचे समाधान मिळत नाही....उलट जास्त प्रमाणात समस्या च निर्माण होतात...जास्त प्रमाणात मनुष्याचे,इतर भौतिक सुविधा ची हानी च होते....यावर एकच उपाय करता येते ते म्हणजे " विवेकपूर्ण शांततामय मार्गाने चर्चा "
One of the best history documentary. Most unbiased and perfectly balanced perspective. What was special is that unlike other historical documentaries on the same topic, you didn't take sides and gave a neutral view and left it for audience to decide. Looking forward for more videos on world history
What an outstanding presentation on such a sensitive topic. All details explained in such a informative and unbiased way. Piety for those who lost their life from this
main Bangladesh se hoon aapka video bahut Achcha lagta hai bro, aapka Jab pahla video mein dekha tab se bahut Achcha Laga aapka Baat,, aapka bahut bada fan Hun Main ❤🫶🫶
As I am in class 9th ,and I am reading about world war ii and Nazism, this video was very helpfull for me and literally first ten minutes were all under my syllabus. Thankyou so much for explaining so well.
Fun fact: There was a man who was on a business trip in Hiroshima on the day the bomb dropped, he then went back home, covered in bandages, to go back to work in Nagasaki 3 days later, when he was explaining to his boss what happened, the second bomb dropped, he then survived again, He would stay alive until 2010.
It is painful to see it such a heart breaking moment for all of them who survived from this bomb they didn't know what would happen next few minutes later. They saw they families died in front of their eyes. Thousands of people were injured later became disable like me. I wish those people who died in such war may them rest in peace.
@Deepmalya Chakraborty bro he didnt know that all that Hitler was such a cruel ruler he just thought that axis were enemies of allied powers so that's why they can free us from British rule even if we will get independence from British rule netaji never seen the dream of becoming ruler of India. at that time he just thought Hitler will help us for Indian independence and here you just assumed that Netaji will become puppet ruler he was wise enough about consequences and at that time noone will support us militarly other than axis so stop building just theories
Really I feeling very melancholy for the Japanese people who lost their life in this meaningless war..... They didn't even get a change to say any last word to their love ones...... Just thinking about it makes me so sad... Really it's kinda feel empty like something is missing.........
Most of the Japanese citizens and even kids were soldiers, dosent matter if they were brain washed, cuz in the end they were killing Americans, so they can't be called innocent civilians. Also it is also shown that if us didn't do the bombings, Japan wouldve Conqured the whole Asia, not in a good way. They mass killed 100,000 more Chinese civilas, and raped woman 200,000 women in Korea, phillipenes, china etc. They wouldn't even surrender, so us had to bomb them. Try to read about the JAPANESE WAR CRIMES. It will help u understand in depth :) Japanese wanted to conqure everything, and they started the fight with US by secret pearl harbour and killing many American soldiers who didn't even knew anything.
Thanks Dhruv for such a informative video...I never knew about Hiroshima Nagasaki in such a detail. my request is to please make a video on how Japan became so developed today... and how they improved themselves from those conditions to now...
"On the Day the blast [of the Horn] will convulse [creation],There will follow it the subsequent [one].Hearts, that Day, will tremble," (QS. An-Naazi'aat 79: Verse 6-8)
I am a Zoology Teacher but I have a great fascination and interest towards history. I wish I took history as my subject. You videos are really informative. Thank you Dhruv bhai❤
There was a chapter in my English textbook (while i was in school) about Hiroshima and Nagasaki incident which was mostly the perspective of Japanese .And now after knowing the US perspective and all i still can say the same words "Genocide can never be justified. " bc there are always and always other options.
I also had that chapter around 7th class i guess it was in English text book reading it was already so terrifying after knowing the truth it is more off terrifying like how for politics they can go for mass genocides it is really heartbreaking human always believed in killing for living and it's the harsh truth they kill others as well as their own kind they are seeds of there own destruction world has again started with so many wars amongs countries giving threats of nuclear bombs this is really very frightening that politics is winning against humanity
@@emergingengineer3007 the japense were not only genociding and killing sivilians but arming there own. 10 million civs would have died via mainland invasion.
Hats off to Japan 🇯🇵, after facing such a huge loss & destruction. Today you are the one of the most advanced & developed nation in the world, love from 🇮🇳.....🇮🇳♥ 🇯🇵. True inspiration ✨✨✨✨
1:48 Robert Oppenheimer's sadness, depression and utter disappointment in himself is clearly visible in his eyes. Also that line sent literal chills down my spine.
This is the longest video on the channel till now, almost documentary level. Hope you enjoy it, will eventually cover all major historical events.
First
First like 😆
To anyone who believes that this weapon should be used again, despite knowing that countless horrors will be created, shame on you.
It is painful to see it such a heart breaking moment for all of them who survived from this bomb they didn't know what would happen next few minutes later. They saw they families died in front of their eyes. Thousands of people were injured later became disable like me. I wish those people who died in such war may them rest in peace.
Nciee
I live in Tokyo and I have visited Hiroshima atomic bomb dome. I met few old survivors and talked to them. It is still painful and emotional for Japanese people living there. I cried during my visit to Hiroshima.
Say NO to wars. It is not good for humanity...
Why us did not want other asian neighbour regions to be under the japanese?. What can be the reasons you think?
@@ab-lz2gh so you wanted that india should be under japan...?
@@Hindu428 No country deserved this it's because of these powerful people, politicians, kings people suffer....I repeat Japan didn't deserved that....
The atomic bomb was made in silicon valley
Is wajha se to hum bol rahe hen k India Pakistan ko Jang se baaz ajana chahiye, warna dono hi atomic countries hen
This is a perfect example of how common people have to suffer because of childish mistakes made by people who have power
Exactly, but racial discrimination is also a reason for this.
@@sumansaxena2277 Now how did racial discrimination come into consideration for these bombings?
@@sumansaxena2277 Gajab logic hai bhai aapka..
ah yes the floor here is made out of floor
@@sumansaxena2277 if you are talking about the war crimes of imperial japan in china then maybe yes but idk what you mean by racism there so, can you elaborate?
Much painful story . Fault was of everyone but innocent people suffered .🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
I want to appreciate Dhruv for this. Most of the times I feel spending time in TH-cam is time consuming and wasting my time. But when I watch your videos I take back good knowledge in my head I feel satisfied that I got something to know.
Dhruv sir please go to Sandeep Maheshwari show
Same here that’s why either I watch Dhruv or Nader Ali from Pakistan
Haan pr Russia air Ukraine conflict ki video logical nahi thi, maine icon and the axe book padha tb samjhi Putin Kitna sahi hai.
Es dogle ko bolo ankita love zihad wale case pr bhi video bnaye
@@sharmapraveen3309 dono pe video banani chahiye ankita or bilkis banu pe 👍
Worldclass documentary.! Just top-class work. The ability to retain public attention for such a long time and still able to convey a story in such a way is absolutely stunning. Everyone who worked on this one should be proud of themselves.
Truly said bro , this guy is just rocking the TH-cam channel no abuse no defamation for other , just knowledge , great dhruv keep it up
Absolutely true
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@bestway22 🤡
Dhruv support Shwetabh gangwar
A great man once said "War is a place where 2 people who don't know each other fight for 2 people who know each other"
Yup brother, 100% Correct!
@@farazmubashercheema12men are people.
@@farazmubashercheema12 yeah true but using people in that statement isnt wrong either. men are people too, and everyone knows who participates in wars. men.
And the great man is you 😂
@@Aticus_92 😂💀
Excellent presentation by you Dhruv Rathi on Hiroshima & Nagasaki Bombing incidence dated 6 th August 1945.👍🙏
😂
Bhai mai bhi confuse hogaya tha 😅
"There is no right or wrong in wars, there are only pain and deaths"
Bro ram ji fought the war for justice even it took millions of lives
@mayank00764 who is ram and when did this war happened I have never heard of that 🤔🤔🧐
@@Slayer12u
Lord Rama is hindu god who fought with king of demons(Ravana) in lanka...which is today's Sri lanka. It happened in like around 5000 or 6000 BCE.
If you're curious for more ...You can always read...Ramayana or Ramcharitmanas.
@@mayank00764
And what about *MAHABHARAT*
@@mayank00764 if his a god ?
Why did he fight ?
What's the use of creating humans that weak that they can't fight themselves
Why did he didnt created a leader who would deal with everyone who is bad ?
Instead he only fight
During childhood, We read about this. We even learned the dates of attacks. But now as a grown-up man, I literally get goosebumps while watching this video. How was the feeling of died people , injured people? People who have to live with the fear of death after Hiroshima
Same
Same
Yes , our teacher was telling and we were thrilled some of us were also laughing after making some jokes on it
But our teacher lectured us for half hour and make us feel reality
Not only people but also animals around there🥲🥲
Same bro , damn
I like how he explained the story without giving a strict conclusion. Kind of giving a space for open ended discussion
Please correct your info: America wanted to be a part of this war and sending their troops to Pearl Harbor made it possible. As they already knew sending their men to Pearl Harbor will make their men sitting ducks there and they will be attacked and which will give America a clean chance to enter this war.
Kaha se ho
बहुत सही जानकारी दी गई आप के द्वारा ❤
"War is young men dying and old
men talking.
~Franklin D. Roosevelt
Hypocrisy
😮😅😮😮😅
😮😮 30:33 😅
@@raghavraj3999video band karvadi
The movie Troy
That "shadow remained on floor and walls" thing just chilled my spine . Our world history is so scary and i feel that I born in very good time compared to past
You from?
@@HasanUnknown ye dekho ek aur pagal aa gaya... Jake aur kisiko ye sab sikha
@@HasanUnknown thoda padh likh lete toh sayad aesa na bolte😀😃
@@HasanUnknown " Hum hi hum hai...Sirf aur sirf hum hi hum hai ..Jo kisi aur panth ko maane vo kuch nahi hai.. pehle ye bolkar islam apnane ke liye bolte ho fir agar koi nahi maane toh sir kalam karke Islam Kabul karvate aaye ho..Ye Kaisa dharm hua..ye toh kisi sanki ki uttejna hui jo kuch bhi karke apna panth thopna chahta hai..
@@HasanUnknown har jagah hi ghuse chale aate h ase spammer 🙄🙄🙄
Eye opener. I bet most of us did not know the reason behind all these events. This is an outstanding work to bring facts in front of everyone and have them think through right/wrong. Thanks for all your hard work.
Mandela said America commit unspeakable atrocities, he didn't tell why japan didn't do anything
mostly educated people know the exact reason, only moron dont know the truth bcz they did not read book clearly
@@chillingcatYT it is not simple man! To check the information from various news sites and to bring there collage in front of us!!!!! he is not telling the lines of Google
Yessss
History itself is an never ending debate,discussion and never ending arguments because every historians,philosophers, diplomats have different interpretations
And even nowadays there are experts from WhatsApp universities.
But this one was really very informative and interesting
Japan is living in 2050, not America
🎉😂
Than go to china
what happened, why happened, and who was responsible doesn't matter at all, the only people who truly suffers are the one who have no interest in war at all, and all the leaders enjoys their lives peacefully
Japan par nuclear bomb modi aur RSS ne gerwaya tha
101% true till date now
True brother
Bhai aise chutiyo ko leader nahi bhediye bol
You don't know anything about war
Japan rules south east asia
Japan robes , kills innocent and does rapes.
It's important for Japan to teach a lesson
A famous line
As you sow so shall you reap
If America did not bomb Japan , this will lead to the continuation of war and at a bigger level
Atom bomb is only a lesson to be in their limits
let appreciate his whole team who research deeply and present us True fact. thank you druv and his team 👍🏽
To anyone who believes that this weapon should be used again, despite knowing that countless horrors will be created, shame on you.
@@sachinbhujel909 ummm.... What?
Not team vo akele ke karta h sab Or uski Wife krti h uski help
@@Cartoon_Creation_1 no bro, he has team of editors and researchers. i think, he said that in QnA video
@@subconscious_mind last ke outro me credit bhi hai
Scariest incident on earth 😢
RIP Those souls 🕯️
Imagine you just siting outside because you feel bored, you said your mom I am going outside and you then sit on bench then some thousand degree temprature bomb exploded and you vaporize with it.
What about chernobyl 26april 1986?
@@movieh82RIP for those also...🙏🙏
@@movieh82Nothing compared to Hiroshima and Nagasaki incident ... Indians always want limelight
@@movieh82why Indians always want to have spotlight in everything ... Nothing just lundian things
कितने लोग ये मानते हैं कि, अमेरिका जैसा नीच देश कोई नहीं , उन 80000 लोगों की क्या गलती थी 😢😢😢
Japan ki galti thi perl harbar pr hamla karna jbki usne kbhi udh me hisa nhi liya
Lekin normal yudh karo utna power full to hai na America 2 lakh log kaise kya hua hoga soch nahi sakte 😢@@pardeepbeniwal8276
Pahle japan ne attack Kiya pearl harbour pr. Kya video dekhi tmne
@@urbanquest2768 Bro unhone Military paar attack kya tha naa ki Civilian base paar and for your kind information, America ne City paar attack kya tha or wo bhi Nuclear Warheads kaa use kaar ke, agar badla lena he tha toh Neculear warheads kyu use kya tha unhone ne ?? Normal bomb se bhi toh le sakta tha. Or wo bhi Military base paar hamla kaar ke. That is why I say little knowledge is dengerous and these line perfectly suit on you people.👆
@@Nine-TenTen-Nine 😂 to kya military ki life cheap h as compared to civilian? Pahle kisne attack Kiya? Acha kiya us ne. Egoist country should learn a tough lesson.
War is never justified! Dialogue is essential 😢 Peace ☮️
Tell that to the dictators, sunshine.
Very very very well explained video from both angles.. Thanks
Hello
Money waster
@@omkarrane7661 ?
Waster?
@@omkarrane7661 money waste uska hua terko kya ho rha hai free mei content mil rha hai na terko itna achaaa so mind your bussiness....
@@chinmayparab4218 to nahi samjega kido😂😂
We really can't imagine the disaster and what that people faced that time ...😔but today hats off to the amazing country and amazing people 🙌🙌❣️
Oh God! More than 2 lakh people have died, just think what would have happened to the animals in the city, it was not their fault. What would they have been thinking while dying…. I get goosebumps thinking about it😢
Chup kar sala😂
In less than 80 years , Japan has become one of the most developed countries of the world both economically and socially. Take a bow Japan 🙌🏻
And India even after not facing such a devastating attack or anything that bad, after 75 years of independence still at developing stage...We all need to join hands to make India a fully developed country..!!!
Because of corruption and religion
@@Saif1412-y1v where are you from
@@rohit_8086 why ❓
@@Saif1412-y1v 😂
@@Saif1412-y1v How you blame Hindus for being Religious is the same way I ask you are you Religious?
Itna acche se hume history teacher ne bhi nahi padaya tha jitna aache se Dhruv Rathee ne samjhaya
Alakh sir ka dekh le , ❤
Rahul sir se padh lo is se accha padhayega
Hn bhai
@@a.d375
कहां के rahul sir bro
Maine History me masters kiye hai. Maine sare details study ki thi
Thanks for explaining very well 😊
This is what happens when there is dictatorship.
Democracy might have numerous flaws, but usually no two democratic countries declare war on each other.
Absolutely correct. You are spot on
Example: Russia-Ukraine war.
Russia : Dictatorship
Ukraine : Democracy
@@daredevil30000 he said two democratic countries:/
@@anukoolgangwar535 I know. I just justified his claim by giving him the latest example.
Like usa declared war on terror against Islamic countries
After happening all these disasters Japanese never took revenge of war but they go for development of their country and entire people. Look today how wonderful Japan is !
as a shameful Fascist loser of WWII, who gives Japan the right to take revenge?
Exactly ❤️
they didnt because the military forces were completely abolished and Article 9 of the new constitution forbade Japan to maintain an army or go to war ever again :D
@@anhaadevoursyou still. Do you see any hostility among Japanese citizens towards U.S.? They quietly started rebuilding their nation instead of blaming everything on past.
What revenge? They did it to themselve
your art of explaining something is awesome . you explain the complex topics so interestingly that the audience could complete the videos in one go
Baag na chadarmod
Wanna do clash battle
War 2 name suna aj Pura details jankar accha Laga love from Bangladesh ❤❤❤
TOP CLASS WELL RESEARCHED DOCUMENTARY..!! Hats off to the entire vfx and research team..!!
VFX? Where? I didn't notice. Video is too good, but I can't see any VFX. Video clips of bombings are taken from BBC.
9:17 this what jihadi muslim scholar teach about Quran to their followers. Allah ka akhiri paigam.
9:17 this what jihadi muslim scholar teach about Quran to their followers. Allah ka akhiri paigam.
I didnt see any vfx in the video
Hats off to Japan . They have recovered and developed amazingly from that time and now one of the major member in QUAD.
Due to U.S. only...
They first destroy a nation and then support them with their own rules.... Proudly our India is independent from all such sh*t
Quad doglapan hai
because they are not too sentimental about religion, infact Japan is one of the world's least religious countries, that's the major reason for their development, India will take 150-200 years to reach japan's current level in terms of mindset
This happened because of capitalism. Go figure
America ne hi reconstruction karwaya tha Japan ka isi vajah se aaj bahut ache allies hai dono
"If we don't end war ,war will end us"
😂
Puri story hi change Kardi ab achanak se Japan villain side me pahuch gya
America supportive perspective.
Well done dhruv rathi sir.
U r almost their to make india the next Bangladesh,Sri Lanka.🎉
I began with one video and ended up binge watching this channel. So addictive in terms of content, narration and undefined capability to hold a grip with the audience. I literally looked for subscribe button although I had subscribed long ago.
mee too...
Exactly
Same here
Same here😊
same bro
I had tried myself a lot to know the exact reasons behind this attack but failed to do it. I am in awe of your efforts to search, compose and dictate sequence of historical events so well. We can't afford to miss a single word that you speak. Many congratulations to you and your team to disseminate valuable information and make it look and sound interesting and compelling. Even my nine year old son loves to watch these videos from beginning to end. Thanks for posting amazing content!
Japan ke Raja ke palace ke upar Surgical strike karna tha USA ko. Maybe if Rossavelt was still alive things would have played out much different.
Idk how you didn't knew about the Pearl harbor incident. There's even a Hollywood movie made on it with the same name- Pearl Harbor. Japan attacked on it first so USA automatically got dragged into the war (although seems like the b@stards wanted to get involved into the war) and then USA as a revenge dropped bomb on Hiroshima & Nagasaki.
Sometimes to save millions you must kill others we don't have seen war but after what i heard and seen from movie game and noble thousands of soldiers die protecting their friends and civilians in short no matter what you say the Harsh reality of this world is you me and others will die in a war situation no matter what and to prevent that a person must have to in our place if you think it's cruel then your living in a fantasy
@@evm6177 i fully agree but problem is that time assassination was try to committed on him man times but somehow he always survived like Cuban leader Fidel Castro in short only high officials and general know his location besides his castles were with High defence and gunship weapon so bombing them without casualties was impossible so they made a easy way to make them Stop by destroying City
The video doesn't portray Imperial Japan's warcrimes
I'm using TH-cam for fun,
But when my friend asked about dhruv rathee
I'm getting so bored in first time,
When I focused,
Your videos are mind blowing, satisfying and full of knowledge..
Hats off for this guy...
Binod
T
@@BinodTharu-Official your time is over bro
@@BinodTharu-Official bro it's 2022
@@BinodTharu-Official you are dead meme
Sm bro
I hoped I had a teacher like you when studying history subject in school....your videos are so informative as well as full of energy, true information, interesting to hear....
Bro aapka content itna quality wala hota hai hatts off to u
Hi Dhruv sir,
I would like to say thank you for what all u have done. Whenever u post a video it always bring a smile to my face. It doesn't feel like ive wasted my time watching TH-cam videos coz u give so much knowledge, information and even raise up issues. Thank u again and God bless u♥️
To anyone who believes that this weapon should be used again, despite knowing that countless horrors will be created, shame on you.
100 rupee
Mera account me dal do
@@sachinbhujel909 just get out from the comment section.
@@FIFA.qatar2022.official make such a wonderful video,he will.
You are lucky thooo
Getting heart from Dhruv Rathee bhaiya is very rare 😅😅
Awesome historical stories
It was worth watching and very informative, just imagine the scenario of you and your family present at that spot and now almost 12,705 nuclear weapons in the possession of 9 countries makes everybody vulnerable for extinction in case of severe conflict. If you study the economic scenario of Japan in 1945,they were on the brink of total collapse, and dropping could have been delayed or totally avoided.
Not without a much higher human cost. Your view is in retrospect
You know why no major war has occurred in the last 70 years, because people saw the utter nuclear destruction and armed themselves for a collective suicide. Mutually assured destruction is the true reason for global peace (kind of) and not Gandhi an ideology or hippies in front of the white house.
We are sitting on a volcano
It could not have been.
You must have skipped over all history channel documentaries and other stuff about Japan's imperialist tendencies that caused a lot of loss of life and otherwise. They were infamous around that time for their massacres, illegal inhumane experiments and even forcing people to participate against their will. And not to forget Pearl Harbour.
A prolonged world war would undeniably cause millions of death and trillions of economic loss for several nations. That is why it was used as a last measure.
Who knew that in retrospect, Japan would become the beacon of culture and technology and China would instead be everything anti democracy in years to come.
No words i have for such a great person🙏
I am a science teacher and I love all the subjects. I discuss about history with my students. Your videos has helped me to develop interest in history in my students. Wonderful work.
yeah history is better I never pass science subject.
I would live ...
Informative 👌
ill never forget one testimony of a Hiroshima survivor who described the immediate reaction to the blast of the bomb "We didnt think it was a bomb. It was so huge, so totally destructive, we thought the world was splitting in two"
Aww 😢😢😢
Getting chills after watching the whole perspective and consequences faced by civilians. Thanks for being the best narrator i ever came across . Didn’t feel like a 30 min video. It kept me hooked and i literally went through all the other related videos. Best way to educate people and put in the idea and importance of peace in their minds.
Wish such videos exist while I was in school.
They help a lot to understand and visualize the whole ordeal. And not to mention, learn from them.
Yes
Bhai Video Ko Upload huye 10 minute bhi nhi huye usse pehle tu yeh statement kaise de rha hai ?? Mtlb Bina Dekhe Like Ke Liye Kuch bhi ??
Hana
Yep i think story learning style its very helpful.
I have also commented same ,😀
Thank u for providing so much info !!
He could be the best history teacher of the decade
Well explained sir 👍
It is very hard to imagine the pain of Japanese citizens at that time . Air,light ,water and what not everyinch of surrounding was mercilessly attacking the innocents.Kudos to the spirit of the Japanese for their unimaginable recovery after such dangerous attacks.
What about the Americans who died?
@@gamingzoneS19 h bhai American ki jindagi jindagi
Indeed, but the Japanese citizens likely would have experienced significantly more pain if the US would have had to invade the mainland.
What about chinese and vietnames people who died due to japanese
@@gamingzoneS19 American soldiers died not innocent people (sala America ka choda)
No country's leaders own their citizens' lives or the land they're living in. Truly tragic how innocent people who were not involved in the war had to lose their lives in the worst way possible.
Awesome documentary! Say no to war .. Any war!
I'm addicted to your channel. Your presentation and diction are flawless. In addition, you are unbiased and never hesitate to call it like you see it. Keep up the good work!
Binod
D
Binod
Z
Unbiased ? In terms on non political videos yes, but in terms of indian political videos, u can't trust him completely.
@@mightywizard1862 well if yo knew literal meaning of politics, you would know Dhruv ain't wrong !
@@rvparthiban6202 Exactly!!!!
I still remember in 10th standard how our s.s teacher taught us about world war 2 and told us the whole situation and what happened to Hiroshima and Nagasaki after the bomb blast we all students kept silent and we all were chilled to bone listening to her .
Even after watching the anime grave of fireflies I just get so startled and sad knowing that it's story of most of people who suffered that time
I hope the world would never face something like this again .
I still remember the quote from a yt video of grave of fireflies
"War is something when some rich people can't get along , and the poor peoples is the one who suffered the most "
Grave of fireflies🥺
Yup I remember too..it was very interesting but the current 10std history book doesn't have this in their syllabus
I mean world war 1 and 2..
@@bitminers1379 what a anime😌.
Thanks for this. Just watched the movie. Made me cry
@@bitminers1379 please 🙏 Seve me
You have really summed up everything in a perfect way. I usually send your videos to different groups. 👍🏽
Indeed the video was great! but he didn't mention the war crimes committed by imperial Japan, so it portrays only one side of the coin.
@@UDHAV79 Well, does it mean what USA did was justified?. what you're saying is a different topic.
Thank you so much 👍
It is painful to see it such a heart breaking moment for all of them who survived from this bomb they didn't know what would happen next few minutes later. They saw they families died in front of their eyes. Thousands of people were injured later became disable like me. I wish those people who died in such war may them rest in peace.
😭😭😭😭
I know that what US did in Hiroshima and Nagasaki is wrong but why no one talks about the Pearl Harbor attack by Japan on Us Navy. Think of their Family ones.
@@burgerpizza2004 and also what about the Chinese atrocities caused by imperial japan? They probably have massacred more than even Hitler did. And the Japanese still worship those emperors. What a shame..!
@@burgerpizza2004 civilians and army are two different things
@@ameer6168 Correct and which Japan never distinguished. Japanese army wreaked havoc, ravaged everything and killed millions wherever they invaded in from China, Singapore, Myanmar to Andaman.
Brilliant and better quality as always Dhruv. The whole 30 minutes felt like it was 10 minutes. The longer your video the better!
Thats what she said
@@priyanshu-7351 😣😆
@@priyanshu-7351 aww 🥺😆
@@priyanshu-7351 Bro 💀💀
The atomic bomb was made in silicon valley
Best video so far in this channel. Dhruv Rathee is such a gem. I saw a lot of videos on this topic.But I never got this much in details view of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Dhruv explained it point by point and his research my godd💯💯.
He connected every related event of ww2 and provided all the newspaper article and even critics solution. Big fan of you and your team effort.keep going like this Dhruv💗💗
Good bohat acha samjaya
What happened to the civilians was totally painful but anyway Japan is one the best country 🇯🇵 Life is one, let’s live together peacefully.
Love and respect for this genius man of India,,, from Pakistan,
Very true but in India fools majority hate him.. Indian's believe they have brahmastra according to Frictional story Ramayan, Mahabharat.. Still these fools don't realise Mugals ruled for 600yrs then French Portugal Dutch British till freedom.. If they had brahmastra where is it after 1k thousand years 😂😂😂😂😂
Once a great warrior Achilles said “ War is young man dying and old man talking “ .
You're a Diamond of India, Druve Rathe
Love You from Pakistan ❤
There is always a lot to learn from Dhruv's videos
And as always-the analysis is well presented
Absolute top notch.....
Once again Amazing Work
Hats off to you
OMG! You won't believe it ,yesterday i was searching on the YT for the same topic but couldn't find any video by Dhruv . Yesterday i was hoping a video of the same topic and today here you are 🙂When i saw the topic i was totally shocked and without even starting the video i thought to tell you first 😀👏🙌
Same but i was searching a few days ago hahaha
Same but i was searching few days ago
Jhoot bolo, aur jhoot bolo..
Today our teacher was telling about the same topic🙂
@@abubakkarkhanshired7189 😂
I love this man... The way he explained everything here was epic.
अमेरिका ने उस टाइम जो बम गिराया वो उस समय एक दम सही फैसला था।।
उससे पहले जापानी सैनिक अपने पड़ोस के देशों के ऊपर अत्याचार कर रहा था।।
मर्दों को मार दिया जा रहा था।।
औरतों को बलात्कार करके बुरी तरह से मारा जा रहा था।।
जापान अपने समय में सबसे क्रूर देश रहा है।।
यह बिल्कुल निर्दई थे।।
युध्दामधून कोणत्याही समस्याचे समाधान मिळत नाही....उलट जास्त प्रमाणात समस्या च निर्माण होतात...जास्त प्रमाणात मनुष्याचे,इतर भौतिक सुविधा ची हानी च होते....यावर एकच उपाय करता येते ते म्हणजे " विवेकपूर्ण शांततामय मार्गाने चर्चा "
One of the best history documentary. Most unbiased and perfectly balanced perspective. What was special is that unlike other historical documentaries on the same topic, you didn't take sides and gave a neutral view and left it for audience to decide. Looking forward for more videos on world history
great information brother.... love from Pakistan
Been to Hiroshima in 2019, it is such a beautiful place and place like stuck in time before 100 years.
What were you doing in hiroshima??
@@Manish_introvert i was working in Japan, so planned to visit there.
@@sidsinp2487 nice bro
@@sidsinp2487 bro i m also want to work in Japan as a 3d artist what should I do bro
@@sidsinp2487 😂😂🇵🇰🇵🇰🎶
This explanation teach us that in every war there is only one group who mostly suffer that is common people or civilians😔💔
Sir aap bahut acha kaam kar rahe ho. Thanku sir
Respect you for not going into gruesome details. Shows your humanity. 👍🙏
Mbbs ? Or bds please tell
@@leelabhalse8334 Mbbs ✓ because bds have no scope
Big operation on humanity! Cruelty by ........
What an outstanding presentation on such a sensitive topic. All details explained in such a informative and unbiased way. Piety for those who lost their life from this
❤❤
I know about this story but I was not know what was reason behind this attack.
After watching this video I understand perfect explanation 👍
9:17 this what jihadi muslim scholar teach about Quran to their followers. Allah ka akhiri paigam.
main Bangladesh se hoon aapka video bahut Achcha lagta hai bro, aapka Jab pahla video mein dekha tab se bahut Achcha Laga aapka Baat,, aapka bahut bada fan Hun Main ❤🫶🫶
"now I am become death, the destroyer of the worlds." GOOSEBUMPS 🔥
Only the dead have seen the end of war.” Great Dhruv bhai.... 👍❤️
Hope that u will always be safe and happiness and healthy
I recently watched the movie "Eyes in the Sky" and I realized how difficult it was to take such a human-destroying decision at that time.
I was expecting this content from Dhruv, definitely one day he will upload with his deeply analysis and today uploaded. Really great work again 👍👍👍
War doesn't determine who is right, it determines who is left.
- Bertrand Russell
Just awesome explanation... I always gain knowledge in details on your videos...
Thank you 🙏
From Nagaland, North-east India
As I am in class 9th ,and I am reading about world war ii and Nazism, this video was very helpfull for me and literally first ten minutes were all under my syllabus. Thankyou so much for explaining so well.
1:10 80,000 🥺 log pura Hiroshima chala gaya usme 😔
Fun fact: There was a man who was on a business trip in Hiroshima on the day the bomb dropped, he then went back home, covered in bandages, to go back to work in Nagasaki 3 days later, when he was explaining to his boss what happened, the second bomb dropped, he then survived again, He would stay alive until 2010.
It is painful to see it such a heart breaking moment for all of them who survived from this bomb they didn't know what would happen next few minutes later. They saw they families died in front of their eyes. Thousands of people were injured later became disable like me. I wish those people who died in such war may them rest in peace.
Luck ×100
He was so lucky to witness such a big incident and remain alive
@Deepmalya Chakraborty Wow brother, I never looked in that way. Thankyou man
@Deepmalya Chakraborty bro he didnt know that all that Hitler was such a cruel ruler he just thought that axis were enemies of allied powers so that's why they can free us from British rule even if we will get independence from British rule netaji never seen the dream of becoming ruler of India. at that time he just thought Hitler will help us for Indian independence and here you just assumed that Netaji will become puppet ruler he was wise enough about consequences and at that time noone will support us militarly other than axis so stop building just theories
Best explanation bhai ❤
Really I feeling very melancholy for the Japanese people who lost their life in this meaningless war..... They didn't even get a change to say any last word to their love ones...... Just thinking about it makes me so sad... Really it's kinda feel empty like something is missing.........
Most of the Japanese citizens and even kids were soldiers, dosent matter if they were brain washed, cuz in the end they were killing Americans, so they can't be called innocent civilians.
Also it is also shown that if us didn't do the bombings, Japan wouldve Conqured the whole Asia, not in a good way. They mass killed 100,000 more Chinese civilas, and raped woman 200,000 women in Korea, phillipenes, china etc. They wouldn't even surrender, so us had to bomb them. Try to read about the JAPANESE WAR CRIMES. It will help u understand in depth :) Japanese wanted to conqure everything, and they started the fight with US by secret pearl harbour and killing many American soldiers who didn't even knew anything.
Thanks Dhruv for such a informative video...I never knew about Hiroshima Nagasaki in such a detail. my request is to please make a video on how Japan became so developed today... and how they improved themselves from those conditions to now...
War to govt me bich hoti hai lekin marte masoom log hai innocent 💔
"On the Day the blast [of the Horn] will convulse [creation],There will follow it the subsequent [one].Hearts, that Day, will tremble,"
(QS. An-Naazi'aat 79: Verse 6-8)
Dhruv Sir, Great Explanation 👍❤️
Well explained Dhruv!!!
Long live Dhruv❤
I am a Zoology Teacher but I have a great fascination and interest towards history. I wish I took history as my subject. You videos are really informative. Thank you Dhruv bhai❤
againt of huminity..
There was a chapter in my English textbook (while i was in school) about Hiroshima and Nagasaki incident which was mostly the perspective of Japanese .And now after knowing the US perspective and all i still can say the same words "Genocide can never be justified. " bc there are always and always other options.
There is no rule killing civilians in war . It was against morality.
I also had that chapter around 7th class i guess it was in English text book reading it was already so terrifying after knowing the truth it is more off terrifying like how for politics they can go for mass genocides it is really heartbreaking human always believed in killing for living and it's the harsh truth they kill others as well as their own kind they are seeds of there own destruction world has again started with so many wars amongs countries giving threats of nuclear bombs this is really very frightening that politics is winning against humanity
@@emergingengineer3007 the japense were not only genociding and killing sivilians but arming there own. 10 million civs would have died via mainland invasion.
but some times, war is the only way and solution. due to few people, it is done.
@@andred3299 I am sorry for your loss but you can never justify bombing two crowded cities.
Hats off to Japan 🇯🇵, after facing such a huge loss & destruction. Today you are the one of the most advanced & developed nation in the world, love from 🇮🇳.....🇮🇳♥ 🇯🇵.
True inspiration ✨✨✨✨
1:48 Robert Oppenheimer's sadness, depression and utter disappointment in himself is clearly visible in his eyes. Also that line sent literal chills down my spine.
Christopher Nolan's upcoming film is about him.
@@IamRuppesh movie name.??
@@mubarakhussain6606 oppenheimer movie name
@@IamRuppeshyes, saw that. its a masterpiece.