ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Football Manager 2023 | How to Sell Players for BIG MONEY in FM23
Like the video?! Let's aim for... 500 likes!
Also, Subscribe? ❤️ tinyurl.com/Su...
Twitch: / clayts
Twitter: / claytsfm
Discord: / discord
My Stuff: linktr.ee/clay...
NEW!
I feel like everybody has had the same frustration in FM - when you have a player that you think is worth a certain amount but the AI just simply won't bid anywhere near it. Instead they continually low-ball and it feels unfair compared to the price it would cost to buy other players. This is a thing right?
Well recently, whilst playing a network save with some members of my discord, we noticed a member (shout out wlal) consistently manage to sell players for big prices. Was it some insane transfer hack? Was it some amazing tip? Well... this is how it's done!
__________________________________________________________________________
If you enjoy this video and we want to watch more of this save, why not join in live on twitch? ( / clayts ) I stream weekend mornings from 10am to 1pm.
__________________________________________________________________________
About Me: My name is Clayts. I'm 31 and make videos here on TH-cam as well as live streaming over on Twitch. I mainly make videos all about Football Manager. On FM23, I'll run Let's Plays, Player Profiles, Tactic Videos, Tutorials as well as Tips, Hints and Tricks. Make sure to subscribe for regular FM uploads!
⭐Join the CLAYTREON! / clayts ⭐
Football Manager 2023 | FM23 SELLING PLAYERS
Football Manager 2023 | FM23 TRANSFER TIPS
Football Manager 2023 | FM23 HOW TO SELL PLAYERS
#fm23 #FootballManager #FootballManager2023
Great one Clayts, thank you for the shoutout :)
Spdierversrintospiderversen >49 milllioner is not cheating... this video is nonsense!
I’ve also found once you accept a bid, you can offer them out for higher again and sometimes another club will offer that much. Then accept the higher offer and reject the previously accepted offer. Then do it again until you fail to get a new offer as you have already accepted the highest offer so wont scare of teams.
Yep - that’s essentially the auction video I mentioned in this 👍
For the other way, when buying a player, add 10% sell on and then exclude it from negotiation, add 10% profit from next sale then exclude from negotiation and set the value to £0 and suggest terms. Whatever they suggest, offer exactly half of that and they will accept.
Interesting
Spdierversrintospiderversen >49 milllioner is not cheating... this video is nonsense!
doesnt work
@@gytekhytk4234 think it’s been hotfixed, still works on lower div players though
@@gytekhytk4234 it does. But not always, but thats becuase of the team you are negotiating with. Ive done it hundred of times.
This channel is like FM for dummies, and I like it 😂😂😂😂😂
Needs trying with deadline day when clubs are more desperate. See if you can drive up to silly money.
I have tried this on touch and console, for some reason the AI doesn't operate in the same way compared to the PC version. Unless it is a player who has a high value the AI seems to always short the offer and won't go up
Facts I can never sell my players for any value on console
Fuck me I thought I was alone. Impossible to sell players for reasonable prices on console. Have players worth £30+m and I get offers for 15 tops or just none at all
Just tried this ony save. Had an average left back with decent (but not amazing) potential. I'm in the championship and he was wanted by a few Prem clubs. Priced between 4-6 mill. I started a low ball offer out of 2.5m. they all offered, rejected. Moved it up until I offered him out for 10 mill which teams offered and my board accepted so had no chance of negotiating. But very pleased with the outcome. Thanks for the tip 👍
This only works for high profile player, but still a nice tip.
/stonks
Great vid Clayts, I sense transfer windfalls in my future!
This has to be ur best video ever
The intro, the cinematics, the plot. Amazing bro
'plot' 🤣🤣
Yes very nice very nice except my problem is not with getting decent offers but with players constantly snubbing contract offers after I accept bids ????
Lovely video!
Great if the player is wanted - how do you clear through the deadwood that nobody wants!
Nice video for newbies, this is a must have skill to play fm, I'm amazed this comes as a surprise for anyone who's been playing the game for a while.
I think it’s the specifics of the method - the general offering out and negotiating is an obvious thing but to specifically offer out at way below value is the difference. And to specifically follow this exact pattern will maximise the results.
I get what you mean I’m not sure I’m explaining properly 😅
I consider myself as a veteran, back from CM days... But what i do is vice versa, lol, starting with high offer and lowering it turn by turn :)
PS: will try this method
@@gigidasha4475 yeah I think that’s the intuitive thing to do and what I’ve always naturally done - also a CM era vet!
me after watching this trying it in my save -
i want 10 mil for player x, team offers 2mil , i reject the offer,- player x starts a revolt - all the others players join in the mutiny and in comes the losing streak with the sack to follow.
Great video 👍 Question though, tried signing Onel Hernandez for a fee but got beaten to his signature by another club where he signed a pre contract agreement. Where can you offer a pre contract? Just in 1st January window with players contracts expiring at end of season but can't find it anywhere.
Look for ‘approach to sign’ rather than making an offer
@@Clayts I've been looking on contract offer but some have come up and others haven't. Could it be that some players you can't offer a contract due to their existing one?
You can’t offer contracts to players in your own league until the summer, it’s probably that
@@Clayts Cheers for that 👍 Been sat for ages wondering why it wouldn't come up. Just checked France and it's allowing me. Top man 👍
It doesn’t work as I am trying to sell a player for £10-12 million and PSG keep offering me 6.5million
Send him out on loan to a trash league so they can perform then sell them when they come back
This has been in the game for the better part of 4 years now 😅 didn’t really many didn’t know about
Also, giving your players slightly higher wages to have an extraordinary high release clause, I’m talking $360M ish
So it works on fm22?
Have they patched this now so it no longer works? Selling players is nigh on impossible. If you do this method, the first offer does attract a lot of interest. But the offers that come in are usually negotiable. If you negotiate they pull out as soon as you go to his suggested value and then don't bid again. If you reject all offers and offer for higher, you get no bids. The list of interested clubs is pretty big and includes PSG, Juventus, Arsenal and Manchester United, but none of them actually bid. Player is Calvert-Lewin and he has 2 years left on his contract. I've also tried it with Alex Scott who is attracting a lot of interest anyway, but again they baulk once it goes near his suggested value and simply don't bid.
I’ve actually noticed this, that first “negotiable” offer doesn’t seem to be negotiable anymore.
The best bet to get around it is to try and incite an auction now I think but yes - it’s very tricky.
i try to use this method in my save. it is working and other clubs do keep coming with offer. but in the process of rejecting offer, the player always want to talk about not treated fairly for some reason. after accepting the bid, the player will always reject the contract offered.
how to avoid this thing?
Lower their agreed playing time and you have a better chance at persuading them to join clubs they have no interest in initially
Perhaps you should using addons
Initial price for neves might we set 30 mil
And for addons set for 20 mil, for 12 months. Try it mate.
Haha yes, I’m aware of add ons.
But I did accept a offer from Lyon for my player 12million pounds but he refused to leave my team Valencia fc
It's not worked for me. I (sassuolo) offered berardi 15m (value 31-34) newcastle and real madrid negotible offer i ask 20m and rejected two of them. And save load, i try offer 27m and two of them send negotiable offer. I try raise 30m and rejected two of them again.
This work on all FM since FM 17 I’ve been doing this
Just sold my wonder kid who had 1 year left on his contract for 95Million his worth was 10-15 million only 21 too 😂😂 unreal
how did u get the newcastle badge i cant get it
This doesn’t work for me. My striker worth 7.5 million got offered out for 1.5m but then the teams wont bid above 2 million for him
thats possible if that club was broke
Before I watched the video I sold Patrick Bamford for 50m in the January window of the first season
This nothing New, but it's good you show it for newbies
nice selling technique but u should use installments more then u will get more
Doesn’t work for me in BKT
can you do this also whit older players @clayts
You could have got 60 if you would have put 40 mil now and 1 x 20 mil in 12 months. Sometimes you can do 6 months.
No I couldn’t - I tried instalments (and everything else) by saving and reloading to test after this video
@@Clayts I do a very similar method and if I get a negotiable 20 mil. Then set it to 15 mil now and 15 mil in 6 months it works.
Yeah that’s the thing with all negotiating though, it doesn’t always work and it’s specific to the deal you’re negotiating. You can’t just say “you could have got this”, because I tested it on this deal and you literally couldn’t. Obviously asking for instalments is a thing though and you can often get more, but most of the time that’s not even better imo. I’d prefer the straight cash now, use it to get better players quicker and therein earn more by winning more games etc. and make more money in the long run anyway.
But will it work with my Dumbarton players if they’re wanted? 😂😂
I get no offers
Does this work on console ?
Yeah but mine did not work in January
My question is how long does it usally take?
Both these deals were done on about 6 continues I think. I didn’t cut any time out of the video - just the loading time between continues
Clayts, here’s the issue. People won’t be able to be as brave as you because you’re doing this in a save file you no longer use meanwhile people will probably try to use this on a save file they actually actively use.
I’m not sure that’s an issue. I get what you mean but this is instead a way to show that you can be a bit braver than you usually would if that makes sense?
Zealand did a video on this 2 years ago. Shame it didn’t circulate the community like I thought it would
Sell Rob Holding for 40m😂
49 milllioner is not cheating... this video is nonsense!
I think you may find, that your comment is nonsense.
Not realistic
Who said it was realistic paco? It’s also not a starfish, and I didn’t claim it was a starfish either
@@Clayts 8:50 it’s a kinda realistic thing
@pacoaguilar9033 yeah you’ve completely misunderstood- I said clubs coming back with improved offeres repeatedly is kinda realistic
The Neves deal was just a bad time to sell him I think as in Feb. But the method was still there. Which was shown on Bruno's transfer.
X player has wanted Icon (hopefully by a big club)
Offer out just under value, reject offer.
Offer out top end or above value until you get the negotiable offer. Then you can get above the value
It's all about finding the ceiling without being too greedy. On my Wrexham save I managed to sell a couple of newgens with value of 60m for 100m. So really does work
It’s actually really easy. Just offer them out a little above their value and if no one bids then do it again but this time target the clubs that are interested specifically, which forces them to make a decision and are more likely than not to make a negotiable deal
Now this is game changing. 30 million for zagadou here i come 😂
I sold him for 76M€ to Chelsea on my FM22 Sporting save :D
@@MiguelAlmeida_mma criminal
@@Luka-cb7mhu think thats criminal i just started a new save and chelsea just bought asensio for 88m in the second season
Does it have an impact on the price if the "wanted" icon comes through transferlisting the player?
Well Clayts that's nice, but what can I do with the not wanted players that I want to sell?
Stop using Premier League clubs. This method is best demonstrated using clubs from lesser leagues. When you can get Inter Milan to give you $76 million for Jamie Roche from IK Sirius in SWEDEN, that's a bit better example of how powerful the method is. "Look, people overpaying for players from the Premier League" is kinda akin to "I went out in the rain and got wet". In my current Schalke save, I had Chelsea want $36m for Jude Soonsup Bell. Youth player with ZERO first team experience and no caps but Benjamin Sesko can be had from RB Leipzig for $27 million. I don't think anyone with two brain cells to rub together would argue that Soonsup-Bell is better than Sesko.
This is a decent tutorial but when you get the negotiable offers it is actually much more effective to counter with semi-locked (the yellow lock) fees since that forced the AI to show their hand. Otherwise they’ll just keep trying to lowball you until they lock the offer.
I’ve been able to get 50+m for players valued at below 10m by doing this. It’s especially effective when managing low reputation teams
Yeah it’s a little bit contextual/situational isn’t it as with anything like this, I often use the yellow lock and you’ll see that they don’t come back at all with it etc. I haven’t found it to be much more effective but it’s worth using a combination of both and factoring that into your routines for sure.
It worked very well, just sold Pickford for 54M to Bournemouth and Dwight McNeil for 59M to Newcastle 😅
Love it!
that's just a standard purchase for Bournemouth. 🤣
This will soon be patched lol
@@michaeljordan5724 often when advice is this good they will
I do this all the time 😂 sometimes you can offer a percentage of wages to get more teams interested then start an auction that way
ah excellent, now i can also in the Network Game sell players for a fair value and spend 750m per window like wlal here, in all seriousness him having me and pav stumped shows he is a genius
I just do heavy installements and I make more money over time
Used your method in the latest DB and was able to sell a player that was transfer listed for 475K for 850K. Thanks for the video
I'll try it out next time I actually have anyone of value, could be a couple of seasons :)
How to deal with player reactions though? "Why did you offer me out?", "Why did you reject the bid from X?" and similar. Or even worse he rejects the contract from the new club and you are stuck with an unhappy player.
Usually on the “why did you reject?” thing you can just say they didn’t offer enough and promise to accept a bid of ___. The valuations they ask for are usually way about anything you’d accept anyway.
On the last part if he’s unhappy he’s more like to accept the contract 😂 but also, defo something to consider. You’ll have to take that into account before looking to offload anybody anyway.
@@Clayts Yeah figured the first one out. It's just sometimes lets say club X bids 5 mil and Liverpool bid 1,5 mil. And then the player is annoyed I didn't accept Liverpool's bid and maybe even rejects club X. Then I'm basically screwed 🙃
Mostly I'm just annoyed I can't test the market without the player knowing. There are players I'd gladly sell for 20 mil, but if I can only get 5 I rather keep him. And there is no way to know in advance. In the end it's too easy to outplay the market anyway so maybe it's better this way.
i watched this video about 4 times in the last weeks, but sadly i didnt even sell once. im so bad in this game... i get always robbed with my players.
Good video, maybe make one that helps with selling non wanted players..
I seem to remember doing something similar with this in FM 22, managed to get Van de Beek out for 40 million, I think either Real Madrid or Inter.
Clayts is a Wizard
thank you
Often when i send out a transferroom offer with only a 100% upfront fee i can negotiate for a high profit clause. Most of the time 50% and they say yes
Should have started off by loading the same Newcastle save up and just offering Bruno out for £50m from the off to prove it actually did anything different
Grt video clayts, works a treat. Doing a Man U save, transfer listed Tuanzebe at the end of season 1 4 £3m, no takers. Took him off list, offered him 4 £500k. 4 premier league clubs bid
Went to Leicester 4 £15m.
stop using 4 in place of "for" when you're talking about numbers, shit is super fucking confusing
@@Fives179
Sorry for confusing you! I would rather see a 4 instead of for, instead of foul language any day.
Does this work for lower value players? Ie 200k-2Mill?
No way in god's green earth how have I just sold gvardiol for 113 million pounds thank you so much
9:38 Estimated transfer value: £64M - £70M.
12:41 Final offer: £50M
I mean....25yo key player sold for less than his estimated value, that's some business I'll never do XD
But sure the trick/method does work when trying to boost AI bids.
8:43
Doesn't seem to work with my lower reputation save - just got promoted with Fuenlabrada to LaLiga, but can't get rid of my backup players even close to their price (e.g. Canete suggested price is 2mil, but noone offers, since they "are only prepared to pay 875k". Same for other players - I offer them low, I get an offer from a club or two, reject, then the bigger offerings I make lead to silence from other clubs.
Same here, the problem here is that players usually angry when you transfer list them. And then force you to set certain price.
We need a guide to make players on want but still generally happy to go, which is extremely rare
Does it work on FM22 aswell?
do it in the non league games
For me, when I sell players, since I don't need the money immediately(my club is too rich and I have no players to buy) , I negotiate and sell them for only installments, I managed to sell a player to liverpool whose value is about 40m for 94m and he wasn't even a starter for my team, now Liverpool got to pay me 30m each for 3 years 😂
Criminal
You did nothing
Could do this for promising players in league 1 league 2 etc etc
Dude, just a tips
When you want to choose an amount of money you can use you mouse scroll to adjust it instead of clicking up and down !
I’m very aware
And here I am selling them for 20 mil...
Newton's Third Law.
It works very well!😀
Sucks that the game forces you to fuck with the AI like this otherwise you always get lowballed.
Doesn't work for me, or is it just impossible to sell Man Utd players? Early in the transfer window, Everton, AC Milan and Napoli interested in Dalot. Offered out for 10mil, non-negotiable offers come in from Milan. Try again for 30mil, nothing. Went down in 2mil increments with no offers all the way back down to 10mil again when Napoli came in with a non-negotiable 8.25mil offer...
Late to this vid but as I've just done a season in a Wolves save, I can conform that I sold him with one year left on his deal, to Liverpool during the transfer window for £69m pounds. That was even their first bid and no-one else got close. They wouldn't pay a penny more, so he went. Guide price was something like £58m-£64m.
This isn't currently working for me, perhaps I'm doing something wrong? Before watching this video I offered Pulisic out for an unspecified fee and Bayern came back with 2.5m. Then, after watching this video I offered him out for a low price of 5m and no one even came back for him.
Then I tried it with Kovacic, offered him out for 10m and managed to get his price up to just 30m, despite his market value being over 60m. Also tried this with Lukaku, started at 7.5m with hopes of getting around 40m and no one even wanted him for that price. Any tips?
Bruh, Man City just offered my Gvardiol at 128M. And before that, Real Madrid offered Palini (AP CM) 98M.
Seems AI wanted to put all money on high rating and star player. Like my Dybala got offered 78M, but listed as 56M. Just because his standing at 8.13 rating and 5* star tho, even he's 33yo
I'd be very surprised if even this (admittedly) decent method worked with players with ridiculous weekly wages, like Lukaku and Sterling at Chelsea for example.
Give that a go and see how you get on, I bet you'll struggle as much as I did to shift them......
Great guide, worked straight away
Can't get this working for me. Just no movement after that first low ball bid :( Maybe doesn't work anymore on current version.
Wow this is brilliant I’ve struggled so much with selling players, the AI always robs me.
I just tried this and Real Madrid made a 50million€ offer for Nathan Ake at the start of the save😂
Yeah, this year selling players became much more difficult for me. Before this video😅
Every time I try to sell Lukaku he rejects the contract. How do I get him off the books??
When trying this the board took reigns and "accepted the offer on my behalf" how can i prevent this?
Does this work on fm20 or older fm versions ?
I always offer 0$ first to bring as much as interest i can, after that just do the same as yours.
Would this work on cheaper players and also will this work to the same extent on ps5?
Thanks managed to get an extra 500k in the english lower league. it'll come handy
wonder will it work for my team selling for 40/50/100k and not million/ :)
Don't look AROUND the eyes don't look AROUND the eyes look into my eyes
class sold a player worth500k-850k for 975k small bit of profit :)
Do it with Harry maguire or Fred n I’ll be impressed
They're not offering me that much tho they keep offering under
Is this method also working in fm23 touch?
however how can i sell players that it isn't wanted yet?
first you need teams to get interested in your players...
Offer them to chinese farmer team ussually work