NBA jump balls can go very wrong because the rules kind of forgot about them
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 พ.ย. 2024
- It's pretty weird that some pro basketball league still use a jump ball to solve tie-up situations. We're really gonna put that much trust in the athletic ability of referees? Tossing a jump ball isn't as easy as it looks! What if the ref throws the ball too soon or too far to one side?
Some basketball leagues have solved the above problem with cop-out procedures like the possession arrow, but we'd like to suggest some alternative options. What about a fan vote? No? Okay, how about a foot race for possession? Still no? Well, you can't possibly say no to SKY BALL.
Produced and hosted by Seth Rosenthal and Will Buikema
Motion graphics and illustration by Tyson Whiting
Directed and edited by Ryan Simmons
Subscribe: goo.gl/Nbabae
Enter the Secret Base: www.sbnation.co...
Follow us on Twitter: / secretbase
Check out our full video catalog: goo.gl/9pMHRV
Visit our playlists: goo.gl/NvpZFF
Explore SB Nation: www.sbnation.com
Hello you, yes you! How would you fix jump balls? We all know fan vote is the correct answer, but aside from that how would you go about it? Lots of love and see you soon
We should have an XFL style tackle for one basketball between the two players. Concussions encouraged.
I’m voting for Rock Paper Scissors
SKY BALL!
Possession arrow
Babylon 5 trivia. 10 rounds. Winner gets possession
"for sure... lifting... yeah..." Lost it at that part.
The way it cuts away too. Beautiful
for sure…lifting…yeah 😏
Ok
Went to the comments as soon as I heard that! 😂😂😂
Came here for this comment 😂
“Maybe spent too much time lifting with one arm then the other arm”
“For sure, lifting” 😂😂
the cut directly after it makes it even funnier, you can tell both burst out into laughter😂
Ha, ha, lifting.
It's the arm he wears his wristwatch on, obviously. :)
Playing a lot of disc golf.
@@jojo120997 it cut because something else was busting 🥵
The Sky Ball idea is actually pretty genius, and since all courts are inside it should have a perfect drop every time. It will allow more consistency, allowing centers and other players to specialize better in possession ball tipping, rather than the chaotic nature it is now
the drop system could also probably maneuver around the court, so that you can have a drop ball where the jump balls would have still taken place, therefore fundamentally nothing would change the game, other than the speed and accuracy of the ball coming down
And besides, who doesn't want to chant "Sky Ball" with tens of thousands of other people as a basketball falls from the ceiling?
@@anitalift7546 I do.
@@anitalift7546 It's always been a dream of mine.
Yeah the speed is kind of the problem there. How fast would a basketball falling straight down from that high be going when it got down to the players?
@@gunfighter009 You can calculate that. Also the Skyball contraption wouldn't have to hang directly under the ceiling, you could just have it get lowered down so the ball falls from 3 or 4m instead of 25 or however high the average basketball arena is.
The long arm, one strong arm ref will haunt my dreams for weeks
we've reprogrammed long arm/strong arm ref so his only desire is to clean behind and under couches, there is nothing to fear
(anymore)
Lol
@@SecretBaseSBN lol
*years
Armlong Armstrong
I say reverse the Skyball idea - have a ball under the court center, that opens up in the event of a face-off, and launches the ball into the air. I give you, the COURT CANNON!
Omg ok hows this- for added randomness nobody knows whether its gonna be a skyball or a court cannon till it falls/gets launched
THHHUMMMP!!!
@@britishcig5462 also whether it's filled with cement
@@britishcig5462 this should be determined by fan vote
This is exactly how Kolhii worked in the Bionicle movie lol
7:55 "I think basketball gets a little messy if we're playing with 5 balls"
Reminds me of my concept of "Double Basketball", the sport with (imo) the maximum amount of chaos that could still possibly function as a sport. 1 court, 4 teams playing 2 separate 1-vs-1 games, with 2 balls that are live for all teams. If you foul a player that's not in your match, your opposing team elects which player from their team takes the free throw.
Beef History: Will and Seth shooting down each other’s ideas divided the fanbase
not only divide the fanbase, it'll CONFUSE the fans.
@@somregularguy uh... Maybe you should watch the video till end, it's about rule ideas to fix the league.
I love how seth is giving actual ideas to fix the jump ball and wil just says “give em a ladder and a chair and let them fight”
Maybe we can add in entrance themes and over the top persona's too.
They should have to answer basketball related trivia questions to determine possession.
What happens when the players both can’t figure it out 😳
@@thechickenman3713 the game never happens
@@thechickenman3713 They open up the question to the fans in attendance. Whoever gets it right now has to suit up for their team.
In Australian Rules Football (AFL) the umpires bounce the ball by slamming it into the ground instead of throwing it up in the air... unless the ground is wet and it won't bounce well. It has been intentionally made more random as a way of inducing fairness at the expense of repeatability.
If the ball goes out of bounds, the umpire throws the ball back into the field of play, but they throw it over their head, with their back to the players and not looking where the players are. Again, the injection of chaos results in less repeatabilty, but reduces the possibilty of bias.
Carn the Hawks!
Was thinking the exact same. Pies!
So in addition to yelling “BAAAAALLLLLL” we’ll also be yelling “SKYBAAAALLLLL” while a drone with Gil McLachlan’s face on the front of it swoops in and drops it from mid-air
Up the Eagles!
Lets go Lions!
Was scrolling looking for this.
Go dees, let's bring footy back to melbs
Now I feel left out, I don’t have an AFL team to root for :( who should I pull for?
Skyball, but with drones. RELEASE THE DRONES!
Charles Styles will find his new career flying ball drones
@@sexyohhenry4192 uh oh, someone is stealing the salt for the popcorn, is there no one in this arena that can get to the bottom of this heinous crime using all of our available cameras?
Five drones, and four of them drop balls filled with cement
Gotta look out for those damn Iraqi food carts at your basketball games.
Surely we can take SkyBall™ one step further by having it be a drone dropping the ball. People love drones, and then you can have it anywhere on the court.
So now we're giving the geriatric refs remote controls to initiate ball drops?
They can also release the cement balls
That would also make it easier to reload on balls.
i propose we have one referee sitting on the other ref's shoulders and drop the ball from there
Wasn't the "single ball in the middle and race from either end" idea what the original XFL had instead of a coin toss?
Ah yes, we should make the kickoff worse.
I go around chanting “sky ball sky ball sky ball” like everyone else and apparently I’m “not allowed back in the mini golf course” and I need to “put my clothes on”
You scarred me for life, John. I had to report you.
Yes, officer, this comment right here
I'm so glad this series is back! If you're looking for a baseball rule to cover, you should explain the time that Jean Segura stole first. It happened on April 19th, 2013, Chicago Cubs @ Milwaukee Brewers. The relevant rule in this case is 5.09(b)(10): “Any runner is out when after he has acquired legal possession of a base, he runs the bases in reverse order for the purpose of confusing the defense or making a travesty of the game.” I am a Brewers fan, and I watched this game live. It is one of my favorite live sports moments that I've ever experienced.
I mean, let's be honest, we were all thinking what Wil said at 1:30
in the moment i knew i would let y'all down if it went unsaid
And we love you for it, Will
Clearly rock paper scissors is the only correct answer here!
I don't know, needs more cement
@@joebaker2311 hear me out arm wrestling but with cement gloves
I get the rock and scissors, but how is arming yourself with paper going to win the death match to determine possession?
@@joshuamyers5326ever got a paper cut in the webbing between your fingers..?
And it HAS to be best 2 of 3.
I need Skyball both in NBA games and the Kevin Costner 90s box office bomb
The Sky Ball is ironically a pretty good idea
Cuz Seth Is not suggesting that as a serious proposal but he sold it to me, definitely we all picture ourselves yelling SKYBALL while Draymond Green and Marc Gasol wait to jump
@@twerktospec "your little fantasy" hahaha leave the crackpipe before you use your phone dumb ass kook
you trying to have half the NBA players fingers broken? lol
@@twerktospec ...are you trying to claim that basketball is a made up sport?
Ya, you need to put down that pipe.
@@hirshja all sport are made up
I like the skyball idea, but instead of dropping from the Jumbotron, have a drone rigged with a device that can hold and release a ball, and drop if from 20ft above the court. It could also have arms on opposing sides that beam a red dot or circle on to the court where the players who are jumping for the ball would have to stand, so they start at an equal distance to it.
Agree with this. Dropping a ball from the rafters is probably too high. Someone might legitimately get hurt trying to tap a ball with that kind of velocity. Or if no one touched it, it would probably bounce 20 feet in the air, resulting in chaos. The drone also allows jump balls to take place any place on the court. In the original skyball idea, it would always take place at center court.
it could grip it by the husk!
@@rome8180 So, looking into it a bit, the terminal velocity of a basketball is 45 miles per hour. And you can get those speeds just from relatively quick passes of the ball, so you'd probably be fine
@@kylerqaz22 I appreciate the research. Well done. I still think the drone is the better option just because you can do the drop from anywhere on the court instead of one specific spot.
also, maybe after a bounce?
“For sure. Lifting, yeah.” Freaking dead. I love this series. Sometimes I just put the playlist on in the background while I’m cleaning or whatever. It’s one of my favorite series on this channel
"maybe they were lifting too much with one hand"
"for sure, LIFTING..."
(sneaky little jumpcut)
I see you.
I have missed these videos - so glad weird rules is back.
You should make a SB bracket to determine the best alternative to jump ball but with each collaborator submitting 1 idea (i.e. Seth’s is Skyball and Will’s is Ladder Death Match) + fan suggestions. I really wanna hear what Clara, Ryan, Koffi, and Jon B would propose
Seth’s idea on how to fix this is actually incredible on all fronts.
Oh heck yeah, I just binged the Weird Rules playlist last week and am ready for more
I’ve always had the thought that jump balls are incredibly difficult to throw straight up in the air but it was just something basketball players and fans just pretend is ok
Casual fans think it’s more important than it really is. Creating a jump ball situation is usually a win for the defense, regardless of whether or not you win the tip after, because you’ve shutdown the offense’s play without fouling or resetting the shot clock.
Not just jump balls, refs have too much influence in the nba period. Look at the Kings in 2002
Absolutely right, we should bring back kings and let the monarchy decide who gets the ball
Mavs in 2006
Not just the NBA.
"Quietly filled with cement" This is gold! LOL
This video is almost like stand up comedy its hilariousness literally just made my day
the delivery of "for sure,,,lifting" was obviously great, but good on the editor for making it land so well.
I was driving when he suggested doing a Money in the Bank style tip-off. I almost wrecked cause I was dying laughing 😂😂😂
Hey Secret Base, only complaint I have is this video could’ve used more cement
"its worked for American Idol."
Name as many American Idols without looking it up.
Yes Weird Rules is what I need today!
It literally never almost goes straight up in the air between two players feel like 9 times out of 10 when they throw the ball up it always goes towards one side they need to come up with something that just holds it up there and once it gets tipped whoever gets it gets it
Oh, that's your sample size? Welp, nothing to see here. Needs to be fixed the man says. 9/10 times, great research. I'm willing to bet you didn't even realize this happens. So your research is even more valuable.
MORE FOOTBALL COLLAPSE VIDEOS PLEASE
this may be the funniest secret base video in years. seth mouthing “sky ball! sky ball!” while will talked killed me
"In the spirit of letting the players decide, just about the worst idea possible"
"okay"
I for one look forward to a future where skyball is chanted by the masses.
MORE WEIRD RULES!
WEIRD RULES IS BACK LETS GOOOOOOOOO
7:45 Love the Harden reference
The climbing to the sky ball like WWE was exactly what I was thinking when he described the initial premise.
Weird rules, beef history & dorktown are my DRUG. Can’t get enough; so so well done
So happy to see this series back. Love it
Collapse: how Lance Armstrong’s inspiring story of cancer survival became forever tarnished
Collapse: how a legendary AC Milan team was done in by injuries age and transfers
Untitled: Tony Gwynn
Untitled: Ted Williams
Collapse: how the Montreal canadiens to this day never again reached sniffing distance of Lord Stanley
Rewinder: 2014 World Cup final
Rewinder: the miracle at Istanbul
Rewinder: Mario Chalmers’ game tying shot in the national championship game
A 3 part beef history between the Red Sox and Yankees
Beef history: Real Madrid vs Barcelona
a lot of suggestions my guy
Dude, the Armstrong thing would have to be *looooooong*. That's definitely Bois material.
The Canadiens suggestion didn't age well... I guess
"Needs more cement."
"Needs more cement, they say."
I was in the middle of typing a comment that they should drop the ball from the ceiling when you said “skyball.” Well done.
Throwing after drinking while watching this. My head is pounding but your funny ideas made me feel a bit better. Thanks for this and all your other episodes
It’s great this series is back!
This has to be one of my favorite episodes yet, had me rolling in laughter
This was such a good episode. I wasn’t ready for the god tier riffing
"God tier riffing"? Good lord you need to broaden your comedy viewing
Probably my favourite weird rules episode to date!
I love this series
I was literally just watching a different weird rules thinking, "hm, I wonder when they'll upload another one of these"
I'm a prophet
we...we never even made this episode wait what how did this end up on the channel...ratedpending willed this into existence???
@@SecretBaseSBN this is a quality comment
@@SecretBaseSBN this does mean i have the legal rights to skyball btw
@@SecretBaseSBN yeah you definitely didn't put up a community post the other day saying it would happen
Mr. Rosenthal's exasperated pause after Mr. Buikema chimed in with, "For sure. Lifting. Yeah," at 1:33 tells you everything you could ever need to know about the coworker relationship dynamics at Secret Base.
I loved how creative this episode was! Actually some pretty good ideas like sky ball!
It may not be an explicit rule, however in the NBA Official Rules 2020-2021 we have:
Page 28
RULE NO. 7-SHOT CLOCK
Section IV-Resetting Shot Clock
b. The shot clock is never reset on the following:
(3)Jump ball is retossed as a result of a *poor toss*, double violation or correctable error
Also, Page 34
RULE NO. 10-VIOLATIONS AND PENALTIES
Section V-Jump Ball
PENALTY:
(2) In (a) above, if there is a violation by each team, or *if the official makes a bad
toss*, the toss shall be repeated with the same jumpers.
[Asterisks added by me for emphasis.]
Apparently the officials *should* be looking to ensure a fair & proper toss. (Or at least not "bad" or "poor", whatever that standard may be.) Maybe it's spelled out in an officials manual of some sort rather than the rulebook.
I realise it's very different to basketball, but I always loved how the umpires in aussie rules football handle the ball in similar situations. To start the game, they bounce the football hard into the ground and then the opposing teams jump for it like in basketball. The uneven shape of the football makes the bounce pretty random, so there's little risk of an umpire being accused of not being fair. Throw-ins are also handled by the umpires. They stand on the line with their back to the playing field and then throw it as hard and high as they can backwards. Again it's somewhat random where the ball drops, but both teams have some time to adjust to make a fair go at the ball.
I just fell in love with the "skyball" idea.
When sb uploads my day becomes better
I think the skyball idea is fire. Have a hopper filled with more than enough balls to cover the game. At the end of the game, the hopper just empties itself as the bell rings raining down all the leftover skyballs
Skyball sounds legit minus the ladder shenanigans just like a jump ball but it's guaranteed to go straight down basically have a 321 count so they know when it's coming tho
Drop drone no ladder needed lol
Ok we are all thinking it, Weird Rules without my tall boi is weird, still though I love anything this channel posts
Man this video devolved into such fun
Love these videos, hope you can find a lot more of these weird rules going forward
Tyson is killing it on this one
Funfact: I’m an hockey linesman and for real, if i wouldn’t want one player to win a faceoff he wouldn’t win a single faceoff. it is really easy to throw the puck in a way that makes it impossible for one player to win the faceoff if you know what you are doing.
7:40 They kinda did this in the XFL. Two opposing players would scramble for a ball placed at midfield. Difference is it didn’t establish possession per se, instead it replaced the coin flip, so the winning team got to decide who got first possession or choose the initial direction of play.
The MAD TV Stuart reference had me rolling. It's so true.
What about a little air pressurized device that tosses up the ball with a constant velocity and measurably straight up? They already have these pretty much for baseball batters (those are built to throw laterally). How hard would that be to just have at every arena? Wheel it into jump ball position and then wheel it off to the sidelines. Maybe have the ball boys do the wheeling. Important part is to have it off the court ASAP while the players scramble for the ball.
1) Lower the hoop to 7ft and have each coach do their best dunk. Winner's team gets the ball.
2) The ball will be hidden under a seat within the arena. Hand out a card to each player containing a serious of clues leading to the ball's location, each clue more fiendish than the last.
3) Ball goes to the player who has been hit the least by popcorn kernels/other foreign objects being hurled at them up through this point in the game.
"Skyball! Skyball! Skyball!" This is absolute genius, Seth! How has nobody thought of this before? This should happen! :-)
shout out to the Australian Football league (aussie rules) in which one match consists of plenty of these 50/50 jump balls we call a "ball up" very similar. umpire bounces the ball on the floor in between two oppositions who take a short run up and compete to jump up and tap the ball down to a teammate. actually has a rule in which if the umpires bounce is outside of the circle and too far towards one player the ball is recalled and the umpire throws it up instead of bouncing.
I don't play or watch basketball (I've played NBA Jam a few times though) but one possible idea to fix this is to have the ref throw the ball on the ground as hard as they reasonably can and then have the players fight over the ball once it bounces into the air. The skyball thing is neat too and could work but this is just one idea I thought of that could work also.
Simple Solution: Get rid of the Jump Ball entirely.
The home team/host will start with possession of the ball in the 1st and 4th quarters (kind of like NFL kickoff and to keep the suspense late) with the away team starting in the 2nd and 3rd quarters. At the start of each quarter, each team starts at their own base line and a buzzer alerts them and the crowd that the team with possession will be rushing in to try to score.
In the case of typical jump ball scenarios and OT, the ball will be placed precisely in the middle of the court and one person from each time will be designated to get to it as quick as possible, this person will be designated the Runner, and there will be sensors on this special, not-used-during-the-rest-of-the-game basketball, which will allow us to definitely know who touched it first. Then, the teams will once again start at their own base lines for the next possession. Also, this Runner must be one of the five assigned starters or their replacements if they foul out or are injured.
Props for the Stuart reference.
"Look what I can do" 😂😂😂😂
MORE BASKETBALL COLLAPSE VIDEOS PLEASE
You do realize the “Money in the Bank” briefcase in WWE doesn’t actually have money in it… It has a contract for a guaranteed world title match which can be cashed in at any point within one year from the day they win it.
Ran to the comments to see if anyone caught that😂
You do realize how easy it is to assume what dude did, especially if you don't watch wrastlin'
WGAF. It's wrestling.
The 1st few editions had money
@@rome8180 WWE, the largest promotion in the world, has over 11 million fans in the US alone. That's just over 3% of the US population. India has over 335 million wrestling fans. So there are literally millions of people who care. A simple web search would have kept you from looking like an ass.
This channel is so awesome
I propose a flipper, like in Hungry, Hungry Hippos, but of course way bigger. The home team's mascot jumps off a trampoline onto one end, thus hurling the ball onto the court in a way that's fair enough, but which also has a bit of a random element.
Bonus: mascot proficiency is now very slightly relevant to the game.
Sky ball idea is actually ingenius. It's definitely feasible and it'll prevent a lot of disputes. And i don't think it'll cost that much. It's basically setting up three simple device on the ceiling that can hold a basketball and be lowered to about 5(for loading the ball) to 15 feet from the floor. That's pretty simple when you think about all the gizmos in an NBA arena.
And i dont think it'll require that much extra workload, since here is a ton of work put into maintenance as it is. The teams sharing the arena with hockey teams change the entire floor, seating arrangements(courtside), and all the banners before each game. Clippers and Lakers do it even more. I don't think adding one more gadget to the checklist will be a big deal. They can check it when they check the jumbotron and the lights. And the machines' position would be pre-set, so the operator would have to press a button like five times a game, which means anyone could do it.
If you guys take suggestions for weird rules…there’s kind of a strange one for high school football. In the NFHS’s 2021 Football Rules Book…rule 4-2-2l: “The ball becomes dead and the down is ended when a prosthetic limb comes completely off the runner.” My heart tells me that this rule only exists because it’s happened before, and nobody quite knew how to react to it. I’d love to hear the story behind it in one of your videos if you can find it.
Best idea of all is the 4/5 cement balls. Genius.
seth’s smile 🥰
I'd make the ref throw it downwards to bounce it upwards between 2 opponents a specific amount separating.
Once the ball leaves the ref's hands they can move in to attain possession.
This gives the ref the ability to claim upon striking ground "god/physics" gives the ball its final trajectory upwards.
And due to the players allowed a brief moment having been separated further away, while moving in from a few feet/metres/whatever to then both be able to equally re-orient their approach to best gain, or at least steal possession/position a defense.
How 'bout it?
@ffejpsycho
I don't know if you are serious with this suggestion, but that would be a terrible way to do it. It is much more difficult to get a ball to go relatively straight up into the air if you have to bounce it into the air off the ground. Plus, instead of being off-center to the left or right, it will instead almost always go forward & occasionally back towards the referee [almost always hitting them in this situation or otherwise leading to the referee interfering with the play.] In cases that it goes forward it also has a not insignificant chance of going out of bounds. Also, I would imagine that they would actually end up with less time to react/reorient themselves because the referees will find it much more difficult to dial in on exactly how much force to use to make sure it bounces high enough & most of the time using too much making it rather fast.
Ultimately, the only viable changes would be some rules in terms of what the referee does during a jump ball [i.e. to control for like the timing issue like we saw,] or at most hire people whose job is specifically just to come in to throw a jump ball up.
7:38 "can they also have chairs" makes me think of the coach throwing one across the court
Oh man, the flashbacks. When I was in high school, whatever body governs basketball at that level in my state still used an ancient rule set where practically _every_ stoppage of play involved a jump ball to resume. Every occasion where modern basketball would use the possession arrow? Jump ball. Every single time. There was no shot clock, either. High school games back then took for, EV, er. Doubly torturous for me since I didn't even _like_ basketball. I was only there was because I was in the band.
If the throw isn’t straight, you blow the whistle, set back up and throw it again. If time is a factor, then reset to the time prior to the throw. This is what happens in a line out in rugby when the throw isn’t straight. You just reset and do it again until it’s straight.
My idea for this: determine which team last had possession. Then make the two players in the Jump Ball have a 1v1 from half court. Last team with possession is on offense. If they Make it then they keep it, if they miss, the other team gets it. Also, instead of a Jump ball to begin the game, they do this with any two starters, the home team gets the ball in the 1v1.
A specific jump ball ref is brought on to the field while blindfolded and unable to hear. The main ref positions them at the jump position. The jump ball ref spins around to ensure no bias can be considered and throws the ball up after a random time. Both players are able to move freely and can stand wherever they like while the jump ball ref is spinning.
Okay so actually the five basketballs "dodge ball style" one is kind of a good idea for opening tip offs? Everyone charges, everyone is allowed to touch one (and only one!) ball, no crossing the line allowed, and whichever team has more balls on their side of the court at the end of it gets possession (and you return to the usual single ball). This means that the athletic prowess of every member of the team matters. You can do this for every jump ball, but in the case of a held ball you could also only have one ball and the two players involved in the held ball situation both rush for it.
Sky Ball is also amazing.
I like the two players are on the jump ball spots yes there are spots on the court, but instead of a toss up for the ball they have to have the ball released from the top to be more fair, that also being used for the ball drop at the beginning of the game and then any time it is needed.
I feel like 5 balls at center court, each player lines up on opposite ends, whichever team gets most of the basketballs wins the “jump ball”. It will at the very least be 3-2
That was my first thought when he started with the 'five balls in the centre' idea. Probably simplest just to have one ball, but five balls works too
Surely rock-paper-scissors for possession is the obvious option.
I genuinely love yalls videos. #Skyball
In hockey they just awkwardly stop play immediately and redo it. that's.... better?
Our highschool gym class played dodgeball rules to decide jumpballs, it sits at the centre circle and 2 players run and slide into it to fight for possession, usually leading to a series of "jumpball" calls