India please do other BRICS countries a favour and just pull out of BRICS. If you want to be Americans lapdog, just go ahead but don’t try to play on both sides. BRICS are a group of self determined, independent countries and apparently Indian has been acting Differently and therefore sticking out like a sore thumb.
India just offered their souls to the US on a golden platter. Not surprising since it's already in their DNA that they lack the confidence and ability to stand up and be independent mentally and economically. It's like taking one step forward and 15 backwards. Visited both India and China after a break of 5 years. The difference is incomparable. India had hardly moved while China's growth is huge. So India will be India forever regardless of who they align with .
@@katong1953 - Democracy? Free Speech? India supposedly is one and Free Speech is guaranteed in the Constitution of India. Any agency, local or Foreign, never mind agency from The Foreign Power even, if try to curtail, suppress or block Free Speech on the Public Domain simply siting their own policy, simply could banned from operating in India through SC. No power or agency should be allowed any right to negate people of India's Constitutional right. In fact they could be BANNED from operating in India.
He was not used just thrown. India is not a disposable supporter of any power. These people are just frustrated and pushing a narrative. One clue is the cited "second reason" that Modi craves a Trump summit merely for optics.
Mr Pravin Sawhney is one of few elites in India who has a sober and clear mind on international geopolitics especially on Indian relations with the US, China, and Russia.
India is in a comfortable position and should do what is best in her interest. Look at us Pakistanis trying to please America and China which left us nowhere.
It’s not India, it’s Modi who is sucking up to Trump. The fact that Modi was not at Trump’s inauguration says a lot about how Trump thinks about Indians, Vivek Ramaswamy is a good example of a lapdog to Trump
it is the bad part of DNA passed down from the colonial era, that's how they coped with foreign invaders. the Brits took them to their colonies every where that's why you find them every where.
India has not entered the vassal category yet. the empire's colonies are defeated countries in WW2, with multiple bases and thousands of mercenary boots on the ground. except for Hungary and France, most EU/NATO countries are vassals. India is just a temporary hire to contain China. Team Biden wasn't happy about India's performance, Deputy Secretary of State, Campbell said India can never be US ally and proceeded to sanction Indian companies and Modi backer, Adani before they left office. good luck to team Trump.
What is British colonial mindset? The very fact that you use English Language in every day life is a symbol of slavery. Give that up. The entire frame work of legal system, jurisprudence etc scientific discoveries from pin to plane is the contribution of the British.
This is a very good assessment. India has a long way to go before catching up with China. India does not figure high in Trump’s world view despite whatever Modi may think about his personal relationship. India is not a great power and has probably missed the bus because it lacks a coherent vision, policy and execution. US would like India to reduce its tariffs. Would India be willing to do that? And US is not going to beat the Chinese. US share of global manufacturing has fallen from 50% in 1945 to 16% today. China generates four times as much electricity as the US today. It is unlikely that the US will catch up. India’s future lies in aggressively building capabilities in AI and not pursuing populist policies at home. I am not very optimistic.
Indians are everywhere, but India is nowhere in technology, human development, the rights of minorities and investment in infrastructure, education and health care.
How India is a rising power when the fact of the matter is that we have over 800 million people living on free 5kg wheat each month by the Modis government and still increasing. Either we are deceiving ourselves or the international community. I will be leaving that's up to you to decide. We have a PM who knows Nothing except how to create and manage an international event like a bubble, which will eventually be bound to be busted. Why would the US or any other developed nation on earth do their high Tec technology transfer to India? Do you think that they are stupid? 😂
i don't think they're stupid. there's a different between stupidity and Malice. and yes, i accuse India's Government to have bad Intention to it's people.
I have always heard of people complaining about the 5kg free ration. Is it really true that the ration is given to so many people ? What's the plan to get them off it? This can't be forever, surely! 😱
India's constant asking for help from others (eg in high tech) really says it loud and clear that India is unable to do anything by itself. It loses respect. Nobody wants 'strategic alliance' with a country they don't respect. I say to Chai Wala 'Learn the basics of human behaviour first'. Really I think BJP is unsuited to power.
@@surfspark Well thank you for asking. Try AAP or even Cong. Yes, Cong has never been a revolutionary force and in fact was disgraceful for decades when running the economy. However it steered India well internationally at difficult times. Also, it's still run by the Nehru family. But voting AAP may be too much of a uphill struggle for people and time will be lost building up the party. It can however be an alternative to Cong. The BJP however is divisive internally on religion and caste. It's backed by RSS and wealthy and poor Hindus alike who want Hindu renaissance some 500 years too late. In doing this they will drag India back to the dark ages. The time of literal untouchables and widow burning. The poor, of any religion, will get nothing out of it. The rich will get richer which means the poor will get poorer. Abject poverty will be widespread. Internationally, Chai Wala is aligning India with the US. The US is now an oligarchy. As its rich are getting richer so its poor are getting poorer who are now desperate. It has NEVER helped a country unless it was for its own reasons. So Western Europe against Eastern Europe and USSR, Israel against Arab Middle East and Japan and Korea against China. The US will also not allow India to bypass it - EVER. And Israel will NEVER allow India to replace it. India needs to be closer to China. It needs to have a strategic alliance with China. India must be prepared to give a little so that it can later take a lot. China will then pull away from Pakistan. India must NOT see China as a competitor but a partner. China has produced a miracle within 40 years. This is something the US has NEVER done. Nor has any other country. The US took hundreds of years and slaves and immigrants and the murder of millions of natives. India MUST learn from the only country that knows how - China.
@11reinvented your reasoning and thinking is stupid as fuck.there is a reason why u idiots are not taken seriously nowadays.india doesn't need to bend to china to get anything and it will give nothing.chip technology,jet engine tech,Ai all we can get from u.s cheaply.congress and aap party are the biggest vote bank politics parties both bend any rule to keep their vote bank u hate bjp because you can't get those concession under them.the reality is u are left with bjp with no proper opposition as of now that's the truth rest of the parties will sell the country to china because they have supporters like you.
India was a great power and civilisation, nevertheless, her lack of self confidence and blind worship in the Western superiority, especially in her elite, is deeply disappointed. China recently proclaimed DeepSeek - V3 and DeepSeek - A1, opensource AI Model free for anyone and any country.
No India needs a leader like Lee Kuan Yew from Singapore Or Just learn straight from the country that taught China how to succeed in building up a country in 1 generation
Trump was told by a buddy he met at the Mar-a-Lago Bar the other day, that BRICS is a regional organization formed by 5 European states, namely Britain, Romania, Italy, Czech and Spain, as a counter weight to France and Germany.😂
"To be an enemy of USA is dangerous, but to be friend of USA is fatal" ...Modi should stop sucking up to US and Trump. Have self respect and strong will to push India out of ruins. Doing hollow promises and bak bak won't help. Immediate concrete actions need to be taken. Infact, India should get closer to China.
India should be closer to china by giving up the land..what about sovereignty then??do you understand how superpower country works..china would like to entangle india into a war like situation and never wants it to develop. How long we will seek USA help by giving them nothing in return??
@@nitishk3541 Read the first line of my comment. Do anything India has to do to find peace with China. I know as India having border conflict this is not an easy thing to swallow. I don't have coherent explanation but what learnt from watching several videos on youtube on how global financial system is working, no country in this world can survive by being friend of US or USD as global reserve currency. The system is rigged and designed to favour US. Everyone will fall prey to debt, be it Europe or Britain. If you don't believe me, watch how many economies collapse or destabilize in probably next 10 years in Europe. China is the only one which are able to deal with US since China is the only country on this planet which is self sovereign. You cutoff them from the world through sanctions, still they have everything to survive. They have their own google, own facebook, own Amazon, own AI, own chip manufacturing, only oil is something they need which they get from Russia.
A very wise speech on geopolitics. Modi and Jayashankar are not seeing the big picture. India has long been under colonisation and I am afraid will continue to be so in the years to come. It would be better for India to get out from BRICS. Many ASEAN countries are joining BRICS and India will be the odd one in this circle.
" India Offers Strategic Loyalty to Trump's America "... So much for Non-allegiance . Multi-Polar world will only work if India stay independent. By offering strategic loyalty to USA is to be subservient to America.
What about China, India always seeking peace talks with them , unlike Pakistan they want to placate China forgetting all offense by China and land grabbing.
India gave up its bulk of garment industry, gave raw materials to Bangladesh so that Bangladesh can grow and be a good neighbor. What Bangladesh is doing now?
He and his boss Gazla are China and ISI paid, he always starts with a story, in the middle he switches to same old China is great, BRI, AI, cyberspace etc
@@nirmalbhel3231are you saying, India does those things better than China?😂😂 Hes simply telling the truth, instead of telling you fantasy stories... Sadly many indians prefer to hear fantasy stories.. China is world leader in most technologies and thats the truth. Why do you think the West is so scared of China? Its because they can't compete with China.. if the West can't compete, do you really think India has any chance competing with China? Please be realistic....
Fear is the key. Fear of Chinese invasion. Fear of economic collapse. These fears have made Modi give up his Vishwa Guru and Akhand Bharat dreams and accept reality.
Mr Pravin Sawhney, you are the most misunderstood person in the country. I can feel your love for India, and the pains of your heart seeing your politicians keep barking up the wrong tree. India wants to be the regional hegemon just like the USA is the world's hegemon. She is upset because China is in the way.
@@somakchatterjee6429 , I am Malaysian. Malaysia is not in strategic competition with India. We are neutral observers. It is obvious to most people outside India, the strategic direction India is taking is mostly self defeating.
No, the basic ethos of Bharat as a nation is not to use brute force to coerce other countries to dance to its tunes but to achieve a state of mutual cooperation to thrive and survive to each population's liking of that country. But global powers are ruthless in the sense that their vision of being a power means that everyone should bow to their requirements at the cost of being barbaric to their populations. Hence it will take a lot of time for all the people of india to understand these concepts of superpower and to start engaging with the world in that manner. The business class and the elites understand this and hence are perceived to be going against the population wishes. E.g. when Europeans reached america, they annihilated the local population but in India, we don't displace the natives from the forests or their specific dwellings to do mining on those lands. So we indians have a long way to be anywhere in the reckoning. We are somehow fine with it coz we don't want the culture revolution that china went under Mao.
China attacked India several times. It supports all anti-India groups in Pak & Bangladesh. India gave more lands to Bangladesh to settle border issue, saved Sri Lanka, Maldives, why China didn't save them. No country will trust China. Like many, this guy and his boss Gazla Wahab are Chinese and ISI paid agents. They always says good things about Pak Army. He says Pak Army is much more stronger than Indian Army
@@ashwinipingle8832 , you have painted India as an angel, which it is not. You have also painted China as a boogie man, which it is not. India is a regional hegemon.
During Trump presidency party........ Khalistani activist chanting Khalistan Jindabaad Infront of Jaishankar......... So, if India is not loyal to American dollars.then, India will be North Korea..............
*The Modi Govt is completely delusional and out of its depth! Jaishankar should change his profession and become a comedian! The Indian media is a constant source of jokes!*
Don't worry India will get tech from US, oil from Russia, goods from China... No other country can do this... It is because how JS manages. Many country wants team like Modi and JS
@AmirWaseem-gh1dv what kind of relationship do you want with india??lol..Here you can't think of even people to people contact with india.we have far better contact with the people of west than the people of neighborhood i.e pakistan and china
@@nitishk3541 Look at your politions like BJP. Always talking shit .hindu Muslim hindu Muslim. Pakistan Pakistan . Even now Western people also not like indian.
Jaishanker went to US to offer modi’s utter and total servility to US. Apparently he has been paying frequent and long visits to US. A lot of money spent with no results to show.
Lol u.s is willing to give jet engines technology,chip technology,tax exemptions,visas why would India fight with u.s. infact India can use u.s to bring china down and rise itself up two mangoes in one shot.
India's foreign policy seems to be on crossroads and ppl in power are more concerned about their personal brand image rather then the long term vision.
hard hitting but bang on. perfect analysis. in my opinion Russia + China a far better and longer bet. With Us ...what after Trump? Even Trump can change anytime
does not augur well for india's role in BRICS (which already was not looking good). looks like the us will have a spoiler inside BRICS as long as they stay inside (yes, BRICS is the future). for modi et al, rivalry/competition with china is king which is tragic . such small minds, such an inferiority complex. in the end, india's diplomacy will diminish itself in the end.
Excellent analysis. Amongst other issues, as long as India does not radically improve its STEM education AND create millions of well paying jobs in both R&D and cutting edge technologies, we will continue to be hopelessly dependent on getting H-1B visas. India is also hopelessly dependent on china as well. Under Modi's leadership, his vacillation will cost us dear!!
Remarkable thoughts from you .i wish all govt of our region should realize the benefits of poor people of their countries and align with the emerging south asian powers . Arrogance in in ignorance shall distroy our region. You doing good job sir ..
Excellent analysis. I'm so glad that you pointed out that the "oligarchy will flourish, but the benefits will not flow to the 800 million poor Indians..." That is very true. Also, that India is a Global South nation, it must cooperate with the Global South. Exactly.
The United States and the West have played a significant role in shaping India’s defense vulnerabilities during the last three terms of the BJP government. The potential fall of Sheikh Hasina in Bangladesh appears to be a strategic move by the U.S., seemingly aimed at pushing Bangladesh further into China’s sphere of influence. Similarly, the U.S. and its Western allies are pressuring Pakistan’s military establishment toward global isolation, effectively driving it closer to China, with the risk of becoming another North Korea-like state. Once China successfully encircles India from all sides, India may find itself with no alternative but to align with the U.S. and the West, thereby becoming a more effective tool in their strategy against China. The question for India is whether it will uphold its democratic values and maintain an independent foreign policy or succumb to the U.S.’s geopolitical agenda, as nations like Germany, Japan, and much of Europe have seemingly done in recent times. Historically, India has balanced its relationships with multiple global powers, and it is likely to continue this strategy in the future. However, this approach could inadvertently accelerate India’s isolation within South and East Asia, serving U.S. interests. At this critical juncture, India requires visionary political leadership to protect its 77 years of effort to emerge as a global power. Without such leadership, India risks becoming a satellite state of the U.S. and the West, undermining its long-term aspirations for sovereignty and regional influence.
Why did India fail SAARC then .... or it was also failed by the USA and west ..... The point is India is hostile to all its neighbours and minorities under RSS cronies using the name of BJP.
excellent assesment of what could be an independent India. modi has played his part for the old Raj, his time has long come and new Indian minds have to replace modi and his old Raj/fiefdom....India is a country not a card game...👏🏽
Indian leaders never said India wants to trade only in US Dollar, instead India is promoting countries to use their own currencies in bilateral trade. Cooperation between Bangladesh and Pakistan is not a good thing because their common attraction is hatred towards Hindus.
@@Freethinker-vj4ut ap b apny brain vassals ko bara kro . Geo Politiks main interest dekha jata hy . China ko dekho wo india sy kitna aagy chala gya hy .
All ex British colonies r still loyal to West. Government departments takes notes from them and got deep roots in the system. All influential ppl, politician, Government employees, parked the black money in Westren banks. Still we r the Neo colony.
Chanakya philosophy has failed time and time again for thousand years all the kings to PMs used this and all foreigners know this philosophy. Flattery when weak and Oppression when Strong doesn't earn you respect on global stage.
Thank God we have you to give us an alternative view from the mainstream media.. May God help the 800 million poor 🇮🇳 indians 🙏 norI repeat NOT the rich 1% Indian elites
Very sad move by the modi govt. If its the fact. BRICS is an organisation of peers. The US will never accept anyone as such and will expect great sacrifices for its own interests. The border dispute with china could have been resolved if india did not take a provocative stand. I hope there is a rethink.
India shouldn't offer any olive branch to any country, even to the USA. India has a bright future. India must stand on her own feet and depend on human resources.
Modi's main aim is to bring lower caste hindus under Brahmin rule. This is costing the country hugely in all parameters of HDI and creating religious and caste divide. There is no foreign policy or long term strategic planning. He's a opportunistic cat on the wall.
Indian foreign secretary is in china that too on Republic day. If you can't understand significance of this then god help you. 😂I certainly have no expectation from Pakistan and china bots. China and India are on same page regarding dedollarisation.Mark my words chinese technology and investment is coming to India. 🎉
Dear Pravin Swahney, Please timestamp your video on the topics you discuss. There is plenty of information for us to note here and the structuring of topics would only help in understanding the subject better.
Unfortunately India ignoring history. Unrealistically emotionally against China ( jealous) overall socioeconomic development.Instead considering history priorities to socioeconomic development of country to cooperation with other developing countries.Competitions policy fine but conflict and allies with destructive groups no way better for India in future. Most of the people and countries prioritize peaceful development after long suffering by greedy nations. Good luck Indian. Thank and appreciate for your timely realistic geopolitical analysis presentation.
If only there could be many folks like Mr. Sawhney in positions of power across in Indian govt. Thank you for the work you do, and for educating us, and keeping us informed.
Well explained sir I am just grateful you are not living in Pakistan. By now you would have been jailed by the corrupt General's. (I am Pakistani before any one makes any comment. )
India please do other BRICS countries a favour and just pull out of BRICS. If you want to be Americans lapdog, just go ahead but don’t try to play on both sides. BRICS are a group of self determined, independent countries and apparently Indian has been acting Differently and therefore sticking out like a sore thumb.
Even what china is today is due to american investment only
BRICS is the future especially when Trump is president. Modi's 56" chest is leaking air.
Do not worry brics will stay.
Sco will 🤪🤪🤪😂😂😂
True
India just offered their souls to the US on a golden platter. Not surprising since it's already in their DNA that they lack the confidence and ability to stand up and be independent mentally and economically. It's like taking one step forward and 15 backwards. Visited both India and China after a break of 5 years. The difference is incomparable. India had hardly moved while China's growth is huge. So India will be India forever regardless of who they align with .
strategic loyalty to trump? I guess india just handed trump a free all out punching bag wrapped in indian flag
India will still buy oil from Russia
ABSOLUTELY.
No country should offer loyalty of any kind to a genocide enabler.
My earlier post said no one should offer any loyalty to a country that had enabled the big G. The post was swiftly blocked by empire censors.
@@katong1953 - Democracy? Free Speech? India supposedly is one and Free Speech is guaranteed in the Constitution of India. Any agency, local or Foreign, never mind agency from The Foreign Power even, if try to curtail, suppress or block Free Speech on the Public Domain simply siting their own policy, simply could banned from operating in India through SC. No power or agency should be allowed any right to negate people of India's Constitutional right. In fact they could be BANNED from operating in India.
India must not forget how Vivek Ramasamy was used and gotten rid off!
Strategic loyalty to the USA. What is happening to the self-proclaimed superpower India? India has unlimited shame!
But patel replaced him and got anu even better and higher post
He was not used just thrown. India is not a disposable supporter of any power. These people are just frustrated and pushing a narrative. One clue is the cited "second reason" that Modi craves a Trump summit merely for optics.
@masnur7007 exactly!.
He was replaced because his past caught up with him. He basically got exposed for the way he created his wealth.
Mr Pravin Sawhney is one of few elites in India who has a sober and clear mind on international geopolitics especially on Indian relations with the US, China, and Russia.
Absolutely, he is!!!!
India is in a comfortable position and should do what is best in her interest. Look at us Pakistanis trying to please America and China which left us nowhere.
It’s not India, it’s Modi who is sucking up to Trump. The fact that Modi was not at Trump’s inauguration says a lot about how Trump thinks about Indians, Vivek Ramaswamy is a good example of a lapdog to Trump
India/Indian and loyalty/reliability does not mix, just ask the Iranians and Russians...
it is the bad part of DNA passed down from the colonial era, that's how they coped with foreign invaders. the Brits took them to their colonies every where that's why you find them every where.
True
Strategic loyalty is such a beautiful euphemism for vassal loyalty 😂
To be only gotten used.
India need Poverty alleviation programs. 🥕
Desparation wh? Modi not invited because usa doent want another assassination attemp whenever modi visit washington dc.
Jayshankar should append the agreement with usa to stop supporting khalistani separation movement and setting up of a NE christian state .
India has not entered the vassal category yet. the empire's colonies are defeated countries in WW2, with multiple bases and thousands of mercenary boots on the ground. except for Hungary and France, most EU/NATO countries are vassals.
India is just a temporary hire to contain China.
Team Biden wasn't happy about India's performance, Deputy Secretary of State, Campbell said India can never be US ally and proceeded to sanction Indian companies and Modi backer, Adani before they left office.
good luck to team Trump.
India has a history of missing boat(s) of development...
Foolish, brahmin want people poor, so brahmin never develop india
It's been missing these boats for the last 500 years. It's Hinduism.
@11reinvented irrespective of which religions Indians get into, their core behaviour remains the same.
Cong did lot of mismanagement, BJP will fix it, will take time
@@nirmalbhel3231 Wishfull thinking
Most rational geopolitical Analyst. Thank you.
India's egos and short sightedness will ruin them.
so true.
@@arthurvandemanHow plz explain
😂😂😂😂😂
True
Don't talk about it bro😂😂 Indians will abuse you
India despite almost 80 years of independence never emerged out of the British colonial mindset especially the educated elites. 😢😢😢
Unfortunately, the "elites' in most countries are the ones who harm their respective countries.
No independence, now neo colony
In what way?
All scie
What is British colonial mindset?
The very fact that you use English Language in every day life is a symbol of slavery. Give that up. The entire frame work of legal system, jurisprudence etc scientific discoveries from pin to plane is the contribution of the British.
This is a very good assessment. India has a long way to go before catching up with China. India does not figure high in Trump’s world view despite whatever Modi may think about his personal relationship. India is not a great power and has probably missed the bus because it lacks a coherent vision, policy and execution. US would like India to reduce its tariffs. Would India be willing to do that? And US is not going to beat the Chinese. US share of global manufacturing has fallen from 50% in 1945 to 16% today. China generates four times as much electricity as the US today. It is unlikely that the US will catch up. India’s future lies in aggressively building capabilities in AI and not pursuing populist policies at home. I am not very optimistic.
Well said.
India cannot grow just feeding on propaganda!!
Any solutions would be wrong, if they cannot correctly identify the problems!!
He always with some story and in the middle he starts talking China is great, BRI, cyberspace
Why is India so loyal to White people? why not Strategic loyalty to Developing Country instead to the Imperialist and colonialist?
Once indian have taste wm wiped..🇮🇳 asking more ,even modi, jayshankar is hurry to serve tea , clean 🚽🪠🚿 for wm...
Good question
because America has india now by its balls. if they dont obey they be ready to face consequences which bhagwa govt cannot withstand
Cheating opportunists will always work that way.
Some Indians wrongly believe that we are on par with the advanced western countries
India is everywhere BUT still nowhere!
Indians are everywhere, but India is nowhere in technology, human development, the rights of minorities and investment in infrastructure, education and health care.
A headless chicken without core principle.
@@zaffazad4040and Indians are eveywhere because India is nowhere.
It's Hard to digest for Indians but you can't improve unless you accept
@@zaffazad4040right of minorities 😂😂😂
Yet people from Pakistan visit india for health care. 😂@@zaffazad4040
BRICS should remove the member which has a forked tongue.
I is in the middle , all other countries will run away if I goes away. India will be happy if Russia and China removes I
How India is a rising power when the fact of the matter is that we have over 800 million people living on free 5kg wheat each month by the Modis government and still increasing. Either we are deceiving ourselves or the international community. I will be leaving that's up to you to decide. We have a PM who knows Nothing except how to create and manage an international event like a bubble, which will eventually be bound to be busted.
Why would the US or any other developed nation on earth do their high Tec technology transfer to India? Do you think that they are stupid? 😂
THEY are not stupid. They are WHITE ANGLO SAXON PROTESTANT and "browns" are servile or else...
800 million*
800 million receives free food grain of 5 kilograms
i don't think they're stupid. there's a different between stupidity and Malice. and yes, i accuse India's Government to have bad Intention to it's people.
I have always heard of people complaining about the 5kg free ration. Is it really true that the ration is given to so many people ? What's the plan to get them off it? This can't be forever, surely! 😱
India's constant asking for help from others (eg in high tech) really says it loud and clear that India is unable to do anything by itself. It loses respect. Nobody wants 'strategic alliance' with a country they don't respect. I say to Chai Wala 'Learn the basics of human behaviour first'. Really I think BJP is unsuited to power.
So who should rule us according to you can u suggest a name plz.
@@surfspark Well thank you for asking. Try AAP or even Cong. Yes, Cong has never been a revolutionary force and in fact was disgraceful for decades when running the economy. However it steered India well internationally at difficult times. Also, it's still run by the Nehru family. But voting AAP may be too much of a uphill struggle for people and time will be lost building up the party. It can however be an alternative to Cong. The BJP however is divisive internally on religion and caste. It's backed by RSS and wealthy and poor Hindus alike who want Hindu renaissance some 500 years too late. In doing this they will drag India back to the dark ages. The time of literal untouchables and widow burning. The poor, of any religion, will get nothing out of it. The rich will get richer which means the poor will get poorer. Abject poverty will be widespread.
Internationally, Chai Wala is aligning India with the US. The US is now an oligarchy. As its rich are getting richer so its poor are getting poorer who are now desperate. It has NEVER helped a country unless it was for its own reasons. So Western Europe against Eastern Europe and USSR, Israel against Arab Middle East and Japan and Korea against China. The US will also not allow India to bypass it - EVER. And Israel will NEVER allow India to replace it. India needs to be closer to China. It needs to have a strategic alliance with China. India must be prepared to give a little so that it can later take a lot. China will then pull away from Pakistan. India must NOT see China as a competitor but a partner. China has produced a miracle within 40 years. This is something the US has NEVER done. Nor has any other country. The US took hundreds of years and slaves and immigrants and the murder of millions of natives. India MUST learn from the only country that knows how - China.
@11reinvented your reasoning and thinking is stupid as fuck.there is a reason why u idiots are not taken seriously nowadays.india doesn't need to bend to china to get anything and it will give nothing.chip technology,jet engine tech,Ai all we can get from u.s cheaply.congress and aap party are the biggest vote bank politics parties both bend any rule to keep their vote bank u hate bjp because you can't get those concession under them.the reality is u are left with bjp with no proper opposition as of now that's the truth rest of the parties will sell the country to china because they have supporters like you.
India was a great power and civilisation, nevertheless, her lack of self confidence and blind worship in the Western superiority, especially in her elite, is deeply disappointed. China recently proclaimed DeepSeek - V3 and DeepSeek - A1, opensource AI Model free for anyone and any country.
Moody is incompetent he is a two-headed snake should stay out of bricks
Grow a SPINE india.
India needs a leader like Manmohan Singh again.
No
India needs a leader like Lee Kuan Yew from Singapore
Or Just learn straight from the country that taught China how to succeed in building up a country in 1 generation
@@Cheesecake99YearsAgo Singapore is size of Indore Mr Einstein!!
Modi
In fact anybody but Moldy.
no more puppet PM. India needs a leader who has spine and ready to take bold decision
Trump was told by a buddy he met at the Mar-a-Lago Bar the other day, that BRICS is a regional organization formed by 5 European states, namely Britain, Romania, Italy, Czech and Spain, as a counter weight to France and Germany.😂
Very funny
HshahA
❤😂😂😂😂
I dont understand why india would align with imperialist/colonialist nations and not China, Russia and Iran
We share more history than the Westoids
Old habits
Inferiority complex and fear
J shankar enjoys his oversize shoes
Yes
Jealously
😂
"To be an enemy of USA is dangerous, but to be friend of USA is fatal" ...Modi should stop sucking up to US and Trump. Have self respect and strong will to push India out of ruins. Doing hollow promises and bak bak won't help. Immediate concrete actions need to be taken. Infact, India should get closer to China.
Wow
Us is like that, either way u loses, friends n foes alike.
China is worse than the USA
India should be closer to china by giving up the land..what about sovereignty then??do you understand how superpower country works..china would like to entangle india into a war like situation and never wants it to develop.
How long we will seek USA help by giving them nothing in return??
@@nitishk3541 Read the first line of my comment. Do anything India has to do to find peace with China. I know as India having border conflict this is not an easy thing to swallow. I don't have coherent explanation but what learnt from watching several videos on youtube on how global financial system is working, no country in this world can survive by being friend of US or USD as global reserve currency. The system is rigged and designed to favour US. Everyone will fall prey to debt, be it Europe or Britain. If you don't believe me, watch how many economies collapse or destabilize in probably next 10 years in Europe. China is the only one which are able to deal with US since China is the only country on this planet which is self sovereign. You cutoff them from the world through sanctions, still they have everything to survive. They have their own google, own facebook, own Amazon, own AI, own chip manufacturing, only oil is something they need which they get from Russia.
India closer to China, that's most empty brain statement, first learn about geopolitics
A very wise speech on geopolitics. Modi and Jayashankar are not seeing the big picture. India has long been under colonisation and I am afraid will continue to be so in the years to come. It would be better for India to get out from BRICS. Many ASEAN countries are joining BRICS and India will be the odd one in this circle.
Absolutely, I agree 👍 💯 🙆♀️
@@stoneage6329 All ASEAN countries buy weapons from USA. at least India has balls to deal with Russia in arms, technology and supply chain.
" India Offers Strategic Loyalty to Trump's America "... So much for Non-allegiance .
Multi-Polar world will only work if India stay independent. By offering strategic loyalty to USA is to be subservient to America.
We are always ready to be a obidient COOLIE to usa or Europe😊😊
Yes, It shows our sĺavery attitude.
What about China, India always seeking peace talks with them , unlike Pakistan they want to placate China forgetting all offense by China and land grabbing.
Haa... shows in this guys loser attitude
Quora user Kanthaswamy follower?
This guy is knowledge and he outlines what Indian Is doing, and not necessarily one who is endorsing this cowardice action. This is India for you.
Modi’s India’s strategy has failed, India should mend its relationships with its smaller neighbors and stop throwing its weight around.
TTP, bla , Taliban Chinese ko phele
India gave up its bulk of garment industry, gave raw materials to Bangladesh so that Bangladesh can grow and be a good neighbor. What Bangladesh is doing now?
One of the best commentators of Indian geopolitics
He and his boss Gazla are China and ISI paid, he always starts with a story, in the middle he switches to same old China is great, BRI, AI, cyberspace etc
@@nirmalbhel3231are you saying, India does those things better than China?😂😂
Hes simply telling the truth, instead of telling you fantasy stories...
Sadly many indians prefer to hear fantasy stories..
China is world leader in most technologies and thats the truth.
Why do you think the West is so scared of China? Its because they can't compete with China.. if the West can't compete, do you really think India has any chance competing with China?
Please be realistic....
People who love their country & wish India to be great should ponder,listen & appreciate the comments & commentary delivered by the learned person.
Fear is the key. Fear of Chinese invasion. Fear of economic collapse. These fears have made Modi give up his Vishwa Guru and Akhand Bharat dreams and accept reality.
India should sell all dispued lands to China, a trillion for each disputed, remoted areas.
Win - win for both.
@@merrick6484trillion what?
Trillion rupees ?
😂
what is China invaded India for? resource? land? Indians?
US built China thinking that China will be good friend. Xi showed a bit early what China wants. Its not too late... Lets see
Mr Pravin Sawhney, you are the most misunderstood person in the country. I can feel your love for India, and the pains of your heart seeing your politicians keep barking up the wrong tree. India wants to be the regional hegemon just like the USA is the world's hegemon. She is upset because China is in the way.
@@JosephTin this is rich coming from a Chinese 😂 such hypocrisy
@@somakchatterjee6429 , I am Malaysian. Malaysia is not in strategic competition with India. We are neutral observers. It is obvious to most people outside India, the strategic direction India is taking is mostly self defeating.
No, the basic ethos of Bharat as a nation is not to use brute force to coerce other countries to dance to its tunes but to achieve a state of mutual cooperation to thrive and survive to each population's liking of that country. But global powers are ruthless in the sense that their vision of being a power means that everyone should bow to their requirements at the cost of being barbaric to their populations. Hence it will take a lot of time for all the people of india to understand these concepts of superpower and to start engaging with the world in that manner. The business class and the elites understand this and hence are perceived to be going against the population wishes. E.g. when Europeans reached america, they annihilated the local population but in India, we don't displace the natives from the forests or their specific dwellings to do mining on those lands. So we indians have a long way to be anywhere in the reckoning. We are somehow fine with it coz we don't want the culture revolution that china went under Mao.
China attacked India several times. It supports all anti-India groups in Pak & Bangladesh. India gave more lands to Bangladesh to settle border issue, saved Sri Lanka, Maldives, why China didn't save them. No country will trust China. Like many, this guy and his boss Gazla Wahab are Chinese and ISI paid agents. They always says good things about Pak Army. He says Pak Army is much more stronger than Indian Army
@@ashwinipingle8832 , you have painted India as an angel, which it is not. You have also painted China as a boogie man, which it is not. India is a regional hegemon.
In other words loyal dog
Don't be jealous, India will buy S400, oil from Russia, jets from west, will still try to improve relationship with China with care after Galwan
Strategic loyalty means puppy of USA .............
Beggars can't be chooser 😂
During Trump presidency party........
Khalistani activist chanting Khalistan Jindabaad Infront of Jaishankar.........
So, if India is not loyal to American dollars.then, India will be North Korea..............
*The Modi Govt is completely delusional and out of its depth! Jaishankar should change his profession and become a comedian! The Indian media is a constant source of jokes!*
He already is one.
Don't worry India will get tech from US, oil from Russia, goods from China... No other country can do this... It is because how JS manages. Many country wants team like Modi and JS
" YOU HAVE TO DEPEND ON YOUR SELF TO BE STRONGER"; AND NOT TO DEPEND ON ORDERS....
This is saying diplomatically that we removed our clothes, please do whatever you want to do, but show in public that Modiji is your favorite lap dog.
Indian pakistani must Listen to this man . Brilliant Analyse sir
Pakistan??
@nitishk3541 open your mind and heart then you can understand.
@AmirWaseem-gh1dv what kind of relationship do you want with india??lol..Here you can't think of even people to people contact with india.we have far better contact with the people of west than the people of neighborhood i.e pakistan and china
@@nitishk3541 Look at your politions like BJP. Always talking shit .hindu Muslim hindu Muslim.
Pakistan Pakistan .
Even now Western people also not like indian.
@nitishk3541 both side have small minded people. And politions.
Jaishanker went to US to offer modi’s utter and total servility to US. Apparently he has been paying frequent and long visits to US. A lot of money spent with no results to show.
Lol u.s is willing to give jet engines technology,chip technology,tax exemptions,visas why would India fight with u.s. infact India can use u.s to bring china down and rise itself up two mangoes in one shot.
Ah..the The White Sahibs are so benevolent...😊
India's foreign policy seems to be on crossroads and ppl in power are more concerned about their personal brand image rather then the long term vision.
In other words, aping the Americano
@@ahsoontan1219lol china used to align with u.s when it fought against soviet.why is it wrong for india to do the same.
hard hitting but bang on. perfect analysis. in my opinion Russia + China a far better and longer bet. With Us ...what after Trump? Even Trump can change anytime
The puppy wagging its tail to the new master.
🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
🦮🦮🦮😂
"Strategic loyalty" offer. A new term for supplication in subservience.
Loyalty? ❌
Obedience?✅
The power of sugarcoating words.😏
does not augur well for india's role in BRICS (which already was not looking good). looks like the us will have a spoiler inside BRICS as long as they stay inside (yes, BRICS is the future). for modi et al, rivalry/competition with china is king which is tragic . such small minds, such an inferiority complex. in the end, india's diplomacy will diminish itself in the end.
Excellent analysis. Amongst other issues, as long as India does not radically improve its STEM education AND create millions of well paying jobs in both R&D and cutting edge technologies, we will continue to be hopelessly dependent on getting H-1B visas. India is also hopelessly dependent on china as well. Under Modi's leadership, his vacillation will cost us dear!!
India 1 leg on America & 1 leg on BRICS liken to stepping on both boats.
Remarkable thoughts from you .i wish all govt of our region should realize the benefits of poor people of their countries and align with the emerging south asian powers .
Arrogance in in ignorance shall distroy our region.
You doing good job sir ..
Small minds, small thinking!!
🎉
Slyumdyug braan
BRICKS is better of with out India.
India's heart is not in BRICS, but it wants to stay on to act as the Trojan horse for the USA when the master wants to act on BRICS.
Brilliant analysis!
Excellent analysis. I'm so glad that you pointed out that the "oligarchy will flourish, but the benefits will not flow to the 800 million poor Indians..." That is very true. Also, that India is a Global South nation, it must cooperate with the Global South. Exactly.
800 million 😂😂😂😂😂
International bhikhari pakistani.
800 million? 😂 making your own numbers
Ok fine then 80 crore makes sense.
Endia likes to strutting around with the White sahib to say she is better the global south 😂😂
Loyalty ??? Is it a master and slave relationship 😮
Modi should listen & take the right steps rather than focussing on petty matters
Whatever India needs from the US, India can get it easily from China, Japan, Taiwan, Singapore and Korea Russia, Germany, France.
Can China give Windows, Oracle, C++, AI... China's industry will collapse without US or West. Don't forget Galwan, 62, 67 when India defeated China
India will obey America their masters 😂
Bruh your a pakistani, have some shame before you call India on its foreign policy.
The United States and the West have played a significant role in shaping India’s defense vulnerabilities during the last three terms of the BJP government. The potential fall of Sheikh Hasina in Bangladesh appears to be a strategic move by the U.S., seemingly aimed at pushing Bangladesh further into China’s sphere of influence. Similarly, the U.S. and its Western allies are pressuring Pakistan’s military establishment toward global isolation, effectively driving it closer to China, with the risk of becoming another North Korea-like state.
Once China successfully encircles India from all sides, India may find itself with no alternative but to align with the U.S. and the West, thereby becoming a more effective tool in their strategy against China. The question for India is whether it will uphold its democratic values and maintain an independent foreign policy or succumb to the U.S.’s geopolitical agenda, as nations like Germany, Japan, and much of Europe have seemingly done in recent times.
Historically, India has balanced its relationships with multiple global powers, and it is likely to continue this strategy in the future. However, this approach could inadvertently accelerate India’s isolation within South and East Asia, serving U.S. interests. At this critical juncture, India requires visionary political leadership to protect its 77 years of effort to emerge as a global power. Without such leadership, India risks becoming a satellite state of the U.S. and the West, undermining its long-term aspirations for sovereignty and regional influence.
Lol....pure hallucinations that pak will not follow its own strategy than US dictates which they have rejected since last 10 yrs
What visionary leader will do good by giving lands to china for the sake of sovereignty??👏👏
Why did India fail SAARC then .... or it was also failed by the USA and west ..... The point is India is hostile to all its neighbours and minorities under RSS cronies using the name of BJP.
India is flip flopping around.😂😂😂😂
Salute Pravin Sauhney
India is everywhere. But doesn't know where it wants to be
India is always in favour of might.
As it is always right 😂😂😂
excellent assesment of what could be an independent India. modi has played his part for the old Raj, his time has long come and new Indian minds have to replace modi and his old Raj/fiefdom....India is a country not a card game...👏🏽
Thanks a lot' u give the viewers a lot of information
Indian leaders never said India wants to trade only in US Dollar, instead India is promoting countries to use their own currencies in bilateral trade. Cooperation between Bangladesh and Pakistan is not a good thing because their common attraction is hatred towards Hindus.
Brilliant insight Sir ❤
JAI ABANI JAI ADANI😢 CHEAP OIL FOR FRIENDS ...TAXES LOANS FOR CITIZENS...
Brahmin hate soodar
Love and respt to Sawney saab !
Sounds like India is offering itself to God Trump as a sacrifice 😢
Spot on. No backbone.
How stupid is this defence act? US sells you a plane but will then tell you when n where you can fly it. You will be pull by the nose
Strategic loyalty should be with region not for others country' s interest .
We r not the theekedar of the region..we will look after our own well being and prosperity
Afghanistan belongs to Afghan people, Pakistan belongs to Pakistani people. Indians having nothing to do with region.
Trade is better for evry one .
Says a country which has been American vassals since 47😂
@@Freethinker-vj4ut ap b apny brain vassals ko bara kro . Geo Politiks main interest dekha jata hy .
China ko dekho wo india sy kitna aagy chala gya hy .
❗ Everyone is saying India missed the Bus,
Actually their is No Bus remain after 2014..😔
All ex British colonies r still loyal to West. Government departments takes notes from them and got deep roots in the system. All influential ppl, politician, Government employees, parked the black money in Westren banks. Still we r the Neo colony.
Thank you, sir. We appreciate your contact in America and we look forward to working with India very closely and being very prosperous. 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Sir, excellent analysis.
excellent analysis.
India is being myopic as it goes with short term wins instead of working with regional economic and defense centers
It is very dangerous for region specific for Pakistan and china.
Pakistan and china r our biggest enemy..do you want to listen anything more??
Yeah we are not so far thinking as pakistan 😕🤡
Once Russia opens up the northern route, china can go to Europe n ASEAN without passing India.
Access Europe and Africa via North Pole route.
Just when I thought India grew a spine to be independent!!!
They withdrew in fear...and obedience.
Don't kid yourself...it is not loyalty....but fear.
Do US trust India upto that level? with India's love stories with Russia.
No.
Chanakya philosophy has failed time and time again for thousand years all the kings to PMs used this and all foreigners know this philosophy. Flattery when weak and Oppression when Strong doesn't earn you respect on global stage.
Brilliant analysis
Thank God we have you to give us an alternative view from the mainstream media.. May God help the 800 million poor 🇮🇳 indians 🙏 norI repeat NOT the rich 1% Indian elites
India must cooperate with its neighbours in all fields including defence and military. Must improve and build relations with China and Russia.
Is India ready to leave BRICS?
EXCELLENT ANALYSIS
India can prove its loyalty to the US by getting out of BRICS and conduct trade in US dollars.
Very sad move by the modi govt. If its the fact. BRICS is an organisation of peers. The US will never accept anyone as such and will expect great sacrifices for its own interests. The border dispute with china could have been resolved if india did not take a provocative stand. I hope there is a rethink.
India shouldn't offer any olive branch to any country, even to the USA. India has a bright future. India must stand on her own feet and depend on human resources.
Chanakya connivance/monstrosity has its limits!
80 crore indians can afford 2 meals a day.
Strategic is being abused !!...cowardice is not to be confused with strategic behaviour...!!!
Great Informative Video 👍 🥰
It's Donkey and Carrot strategic Loyalty
You r forgetting Saudi Arabia.India is dependent on Saudi Arabia for oil.This country is a big power
Modi's main aim is to bring lower caste hindus under Brahmin rule. This is costing the country hugely in all parameters of HDI and creating religious and caste divide. There is no foreign policy or long term strategic planning. He's a opportunistic cat on the wall.
Indian foreign secretary is in china that too on Republic day. If you can't understand significance of this then god help you. 😂I certainly have no expectation from Pakistan and china bots. China and India are on same page regarding dedollarisation.Mark my words chinese technology and investment is coming to India. 🎉
Dear Pravin Swahney,
Please timestamp your video on the topics you discuss. There is plenty of information for us to note here and the structuring of topics would only help in understanding the subject better.
Unfortunately India ignoring history.
Unrealistically emotionally against China ( jealous) overall socioeconomic development.Instead considering history priorities to socioeconomic development of country to cooperation with other developing countries.Competitions policy fine but conflict and allies with destructive groups no way better for India in future.
Most of the people and countries prioritize peaceful development after long suffering by greedy nations.
Good luck Indian.
Thank and appreciate for your timely realistic geopolitical analysis presentation.
If only there could be many folks like Mr. Sawhney in positions of power across in Indian govt. Thank you for the work you do, and for educating us, and keeping us informed.
So china can easily claim our lands right.
Don't forget how US has used and thrown all his allies ... Their lappy Pak is a glaring example 😅
That is Pakistan.
You know that is Pakistan.
You know that is Pakistan 😂😂😂
Well explained sir
I am just grateful you are not living in Pakistan. By now you would have been jailed by the corrupt General's. (I am Pakistani before any one makes any comment. )
Youthia Megalomania 🤣