edu- at the end

[@sheehwayou]

Andrew's signature whisper singing 10/10

[@ChompyBoy]

fr

[@apples4911]

the fact that Andrew Horowitz invented analog horror

[@musicfanboy4477]

A man ahead of time both musically and film wise

[@apples4911]

@@musicfanboy4477 actually, Joe Hawley directed this video. So Joe and Andrew invented analoge horror

[@bad23r41]

@@apples4911 that’s the greatest thing I’ve ever heard

[@pho_is_not_interesting]

​@@apples4911 omg I thought it looked strangely familiar, now I know why lol

[@Prororo]

Two wuv

[@Noodles_Poodle]

What possessed joe to make this into an anolouge horror. I'm genuinely scared but equally impressed.

[@octangulastella]

the joe hawley attacked his own mind and made this

[@tally_hal]

when i was a kid i always thought black balloons were the coolest thing ever bc balloons are usually all brightly colored and black ones hard to find
and now yea i still think they're pretty cool

[@stellaoctangula9898]

I vow to one day make a song about black balloons

[@squire8323]

Omg it tally hal

[@hugeballs]

omg it tally hal

[@guavadanchiva]

do you ever reply?

[@Heartsfornone]

The video reminds me of what someone would see when they pass away

[@henryboi_hehe]

I’m pretty sure Andrew bought a ticket to the recording studio for Hawaii: part II, and Joe repaid him by directing the music video for this. Though I’m not sure.

[@DonutprodzDonutprodz]

yes

[@guavadanchiva]

thank you

[@guavadanchiva]

@@DonutprodzDonutprodz lol a recent reply

[@madlapdog2552]

he only has one singing voice and that's softly. i love it

[@ammonoideas]

this video evoked visceral feelings of terror and comfort within me simultaneously

[@tweer64]

I think Joe made it, which might explain why.

[@tuney7319]

The dichotemy between horwitz’s beautiful soft voice and the creepy music video is something i think about a lot.

[@MediumOranges1352]

I feel like this is some post-breakup sequel to "The Whole World and You", Great album Andrew.

[@_Tally_hall-fan]

Andrews voice is so calming and adorable, I just wanna squeeze him

[@llamallover1057]

the song ends on a shot of a final black balloon dissappearing into the sky. you're filled with a sense of peacefulness and quiet comprehension after what you just witnessed. all is good.
MOOOOOOOOOOO

[@StarWatcher_2024]

Andrew's singing voice is so comforting

[@zepphy]

cow jumpscare ending

[@apples4911]

😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱😱

[@robotbot192]

That was kind of creepy, andrew
I like it

[@spongecat979]

I thought the video was kinda cute and fitted the song... then suddenly 2:11 happened O-O
This is so good, though

[@GeorgeRubinsOfficial]

This is just my theory, but it almost looks lie the ballon pops and the balloon is filled with blood

[@junoismad]

@@GeorgeRubinsOfficial now replace the baloons with a person and boom, a nightmare.

[@omesta]

Great stuff, Andrew. You and the Hall never disappoint.

[@rainespiano]

2:13 JOE WHAT THE FU-

[@number2869]

SS

[@PossumEatsKids]

@@number2869IVE FOUND YOU! Muhahaha

[@Noodles_Poodle]

​@@number2869 CUSS-

[@SillyGooberEnergy]

2:12
The part when the balloons pops and red pain(?) comes out is pretty spooky

[@EmeraldFox11]

This song will never, ever get old.... its so nice and calm aaa ;w;
I watch this like every day

[@rainespiano]

It has been three years, is it old now?

[@EmeraldFox11]

@@rainespiano I sadly don't listen to it every day anymore LOL but no, i still absolutely love to listen to this one ;;

[@guavadanchiva]

hey hows life been treating ya

[@tyhamotus7310]

2:11 "BADA DA BA BAA BADA DA BABAA"

[@rainespiano]

THE SEA IS NOTTHE SEA

[@jerrycastillo9801]

@@rainespiano HAHAHA

[@29485webp]

The translate to english button thinks your saying "Giving that is not given to the father"

[@F6te_0f_th3_st6rz]

Thanks Andrew, I’m not sleeping now 🥰

[@chromactz]

i always love when andrew does an ominous and even creepy approach! rare, but i enjoy it nonetheless.
edit: and yes, I know joe directed it, but it's still freaking awesome that andrew approved!

[@tally_hal]

im just gona pretend i didnt see the blood at 2:11
thanks andrew or joe or whoevers idea that was :D

[@luigigaming3713]

Joe just killed someone, run.

[@shasta_le_bab]

@@luigigaming3713 when joe hawley attacks, no one gets out alive

[@EliasPluto]

@@shasta_le_bab joe hawley joe hawley joe hawley joe hawley joe hawley joe hawley joe hawley joe hawley

[@stellaoctangula9898]

@@EliasPluto black people

[@river3604]

@@stellaoctangula9898 white people

[@rainespiano]

A lot of “Being Joe Hawley” energy here. And rightfully so

[@mrfreelove]

BECAUSE THIS WAS DIRECTED BY JOE HIMSELF!

[@andrewblodgett1]

Great stuff, really creative. Never really heard anything like it. :)

[@AwesomeJediE]

lesson learned
Don’t watch this at 2am

[@Krispy-Klips]

lol, agreed

[@pencrash9289]

5am it is

[@AwesomeJediE]

@@pencrash9289 oh nO

[@themax9060]

I watched it at 2am

[@Qonfuze]

This song is so good

[@eggyindy9227]

Good job, Andrew! I loved it ^^

[@etony662]

Great work you're extremely talented
Please keep it up and I can't wait to hear more from you and TH

[@octangulastella]

about the tally hall part..

[@etony662]

@@octangulastella 😢😢😢

[@ToiletDash]

I have no clue if this was intentional or not, but this music video always kinda creeps me out, but that’s not bad at all, I always thought this song would fit something like this and the fact it was made before Sketches 3d even came out fascinates me.
absolutely amazing work Andrew, even 10 years later still a amazing video!

[@vampireculture.]

AAAAHHH i love his voice so much its so NICE and COMFORTING and i LOVE it

[@thatonedadjoke42tm]

i am in love with this song

[@IsabellaHall-d6h]

The chord progression in the verse oh my gooooood its so good.

[@eowynmb]

just found my new favorite song :')

[@ethan-loves]

Beautious.

[@confettibunny548]

did joe hawley direct this?

[@loudcloud505]

lullaby skitty apparently; joe commented so on one of his instagram posts

[@rainespiano]

Cakkuu Thats true-

[@jackieweidus9241]

Interesting to find this song as my marriage is ending. Perfectly describes how I feel….even the video. Just. Wow.

[@jasdrawssometimes4660]

I’m the cow

[@goodnightseamajor]

I’m the grass

[@DonutprodzDonutprodz]

I’m the balloon

[@oipropqewe]

I'm the camera

[@Noodles_Poodle]

I'm the blood (or jam!! It could be jam.. )

[@alecboi777]

when i first heard this i thought it was “you” from good & evil

[@cloudycleric]

i genuinely love this music video so much idk just something about it

[@the_person]

literally me

[@dead_acc_t]

scary

[@RT-dg6sk]

yes

[@achoo3001]

this makes me so sad :( idk why

[@grub_bugg]

Andrew are you okay

[@computerfighter2000]

my sleep song :) a wonderful peaceful song

[@g00blerz]

i’m not crying you are

[@Fizzymilkshakee]

Excuse me mr Horowitz where did you get the blood

[@Sshika63]

There's no way Joe didn't make this

[@h4zrds]

joe directed this i believe

[@Explosive_Ukulele]

Guess what dude

[@DonutprodzDonutprodz]

joe directed this

[@juniperjabber]

this feels very nostalgic! also how are there only eighty-ish comments??

[@sparkliecharlie]

2:12 wjat the HELL is goibg on here .???????

[@the_person]

oh okay

[@esben_eira_10Esben]

Nice music Andrew

[@sel_sel7523]

Hehe..

[@ilovemenwithlonghair]

this song makes me feel something

[@shipmates.journal]

Why have I just found this song...
The lyrics precisely describe my current state.
How? Why?