예전엔 진짜 그룹도 이렇게 많지도 않고 다 인지도 높은 그룹들이라 연말무대 보면 서로 콜라보하고 되게 퀄리티 높았는데.. 요즘은 워낙 그룹이 많아서 다들 그냥 자기 노래 삼분 하고 들어가기바쁨.. 특히 일반인은 모르는 그룹이 넘 많아서 맨날 끝날때나 라인업보고 아는 그룹만 챙겨봄 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
miss a's and 4minute's songs are totally different. miss a's dance is still tiring even if you don't sing. and 4minute dance does not even shed a sweat.
uschi tuschi the dance affects singing. I'm saying miss a's dance is hard and make them sound breathless. opposite with 4minute, their song is not too upbeat so they don't have to move a lot and sounds stable
I really love 4Minute! They so awesome! I am American and am trying to learn the Korean language in hope that I may someday meet Nam Jihyun. I have such a crush on her. I love her very much.
I still don't know why Volume up is underrated. It's been years since it was released and I am still not over it. 4minute and Miss A will always be iconic. There's more than Hyuna and Suzy in their groups. Each member are amazing!!!
I love both of groups but I like 4Minute performance better,they sounds good ...and love Hyuna and Sohyun...they so cute... Miss A do a good performance too....this is just my opinion...
4Minute's outfits were beautiful O.O And their voices were surprisingly powerful! =^. , .^= (And I wish that people wouldn't just straight up say that the group is "terrible", I mean giving constructive criticism wouldn't have offended people quite as much as what was really said. D: It absolutely would have been taken the wrong way by some, but then at least a huge fight could have been avoided if the original commenter was able to state that what they had said was just things that they thought the group could improve upon. Take for example me saying this, which I do think is true: Miss A's "I Don't Need A Man" is a good song, but I think that in this performance the background that they added to it sort of cheapened the song......so.....yeah. p.s. don't throw shade!)
I was so impressed with MissA, the whole setup of the stage was literally flawless and the way they danced and sang at the same time would of been freaking hard. But even though they lacked a bit, its because of the dancing. I loved it and was so impressed
You guys didnt notice the "dance and performance" miss A did here. Y'all said they were out of breath, of course they were freaking dancing and doing stuff like standing on the desk, and yes dancing lmao look at 4 minutes' perf they were barely dancing, lmao but I love both groups. I just have to day Miss A won here
miss a's perf... jia and fei did well... min was kinda out of breath at first but recovered later.. suzy.. wasnt good ... barely hear her singing except some ad libs part
Some people may not know this, but JYP artists are taught to sing with a method that uses much more air than other artists from different companies. You know, since they're dancing the whole time and the song is sped up, it's kind of hard to keep your breath haha. It shouldn't matter much though because our miss A girls are still fierce~
Some people may not know this, but JYP artists are taught to sing with a method that uses much more air than other artists from different companies. You know, since they're dancing the whole time and the song is sped up, it's kind of hard to keep your breath haha. It shouldn't matter much though because our miss A girls are still fierce~
4minute definitely in this round. A lot of people dislike Hyuna, but that girl has stage presence. She gets into her songs and her eyes speak her mind.
actually I love them both, but we have admire that modern music and gayageum (I'm sorry to korean if I miss in write that traditional instrument name) is really rally give us a the feeling of "ghostbump", I mean it's not that bad, but its really awesome indeed, right? beside the "tough girl" image that 4minute have, can be seen clearly, and more powerful than MissA in this performance while MissA show something cutie, right? who don't like a performance like this? 4minute gave us all, "sexy tough energetic very tempting girl that hard to approach" image. I mean, listen carefully, when you boys got some girl or a girl get some boys, 1st girl is "easy to get close" and another is "hard to get close", which one do you want so badly? the one that "hard to get close" is the answer, right? cause they are more tempt to get them and they all tease us in a strange way that you like very much, right? so, admire by yourself, am I right or not?
Miss A's performance was good, I didn't like the remix though and some parts were a bit off, they sound out of breath. Still I like the choreography the most. But to be honest I prefer 4Minute more, they came out powerful. The girls did a wonderful job on singing and dancing.
Miss A had tougher choreography than 4MINUTE which is probably why they were out of breath the entire performance which tbh takes away from the entire performance. Hyuna seemed to be the only to really struggle during the 4minute performance while the entire of Miss A struggled. 4minute did way better than Miss A for this performance.
kyouandkiba in my opinion, i think hyuna did not struggle for anything, she's good at solo too remember, i think she didn't even bother to try. I'm giving a point for Miss A.
Wow this was nearly a year and a half ago? The typewriter concept on the big screens were great, but the 10 women playing that traditional instrument and those dancers that opened for 4 minute,. What a great show was put on by both groups. Always something over the top performances coming from SK.
I loved 4Minute's performance **v** and it felt like a special performance with the intro and such. The arrangement was beautiful both visually and musically. Their performance was tidy and simple yet was captivating to watch. Even the audience cheered loudly for them! ^^ 4Minute are my Queens! And they are consistent yet always improve. Proud of these lovely ladies!!
![[Music Bank Special Stage] Sistar & Secret & f(x) & 4minute (2011.7.1)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/aSXiOZXF3DU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[DVD] 4Minute - Volume Up M/V (Making Movie)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bCQuG2GTJa0/mqdefault.jpg)
현아 썸네일 너무 이뻐서 놀래서 들어옴ㅋㅋ 현아랑 수지 지금은 워낙 세련됐고 진짜 여자들이 됐지만 저렇게 살짝 젓살있고 풋풋한것도 기엽구 예쁘닷ㅎ
수지원탑그룹 vs 현아원탑그룹 이네... 한사람이 너무 원탑이니 그룹 운명은 결국 비슷한 결말이었던 ...
Hannah ㄹㅇ 포미닛 리던가 걔도 해체하고나서 인터뷰에 은근 뒷담까고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 현아만 불쌍
@@김예죄 포미닛리더가 진짜 능력 꽝인데... 노래 춤 비주얼 스타성 모두 별로
@@성이름-s2z5l 근데도 불구하고 팀맥여살리던 현아 뒷담깠다는게 웃김 그전에도 이미 아니꼬운 감정이 있었다는거죠
ㄹㅇ.. 그 원탑인게 원탑멤버만 유독밀어준게아니라 팀내에서 원탑멤버만 유독 실력이나 끼나 어떤면에서든 대중들한테 먹히는게 독보적이여서 원톱멤버로 팀을 이끌어간건데 두 그룹다 나머지 멤버들이 질투가 심했던거같음 해체 후 인터뷰같은거보고 실망스러웠음
수지랑 현아만 고생했지
1티어 현아를 뒷담하다니 ㅋㅋㅋ
솔직히나는 포미닛하면 현아만 생각나고 나머진 생각조차 안듬 이름도 모르고 포미닛은 솔직히 현아만 개성이 뚜렷한게 단점임
예전엔 진짜 그룹도 이렇게 많지도 않고 다 인지도 높은 그룹들이라 연말무대 보면 서로 콜라보하고 되게 퀄리티 높았는데.. 요즘은 워낙 그룹이 많아서 다들 그냥 자기 노래 삼분 하고 들어가기바쁨.. 특히 일반인은 모르는 그룹이 넘 많아서 맨날 끝날때나 라인업보고 아는 그룹만 챙겨봄 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
그때도 마찬가지였는데... 지금은B군그룹? 이 많이없어진듯... 지금도 블랙핑크.트와이스.레드벨벳A군은 있는데 B군 그룹이 많이없어진듯
저때는 인기 없는 애들을 걍 안 불렀음.. 2012년 아이돌 존나 많았는데 뭔 소리하는 거임 지금보다 많았음.. 걍 인지도 있는 그룹 아니면 아예 초대를 안 시킨 거
o o 어멐ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ그런가여 전 당시에 몇그룹 없는줄알았어여...
렌즈미 팩트는 저 때 b군 그룹이 지금 a군 그룹만큼 화제성가지고 들어갔음. 포미닛 미쓰에이 노래 대중성은 a군 급인데 팬덤이 둘다 약해서....
그때가 그룹 더 쏟아져 나왔지 ㅋㅋ 아이돌 시장 전성긴데.. 그래서 연말무대 더 볼맛 났던거고
와 이때는 진짜 라이브넼ㅋ쌩목소리야
우와 미쓰에이 라이브 애진다 누가 중국인인줄 모르겠음 솔직히 미쓰에이 라이브 할 때마다 다는 댓글같긴 한데 진짜 발음 개좋음
맞음 말할땐 모르겠는데 노래부를때 발음은 진짜 확실함......그리고 미쓰에이 노래 구멍이없음 비쥬얼멤버 수지마저도 노래잘함....
비주얼멤버보다 원래 수지가 메인보컬아님?
@@김민경-j2d1y 메보 민인걸로 알고있음.....민아님??
수지가 메인이고 민이 리드래여
@@김민경-j2d1y 놉.. 활동초중반까진 민이 메보 다른 남자 말고는 수지
진짜 이때 연말 가요프로 꿀잼이였는데ㅠㅠ 요새는... 진짜 몇 그룹 빼고는 다 모르는 그룹에.. 개인 콘서트 보는 느낌임
에이얼이고 뭐고 까는 것보다 저런 라이브가 훨씬 듣기 좋다,,에이얼 깔고 립싱크 할거면 그냥 녹음 음원듣지 뭐하러 라이브를 보냐
음원처럼 완벽하지 않아도 라이브인 맛이 았는데 요즘 아이돌들은 저만큼의 라이브도 못하는 듯
근데 신기한게 원더걸스 현아로썬 현아 jyp 후배 그룹 아닌가 너무 신기하다
The intro to 4Minute's performance was beautiful.
다른 멤버들이 노래는 다했지만 현아의 독보적은 감출수가.........없군
4minute!!!!
colorful_fish 07 .vaquibiO/ F2f?fq'Mk
옛날가수들과 옛날노래들 하나같이명곡이네
4Minute 4EVER!!! ❤❤❤❤
JiA's outfit and hairstyle is so cool, she's really swaggg
수지는 노래도 잘해 얼굴도 예뻐 이기적이야...
miss A forever!! miss A is a group full of talents... Acting, singing and dancing.. :) miss A hwaiting!!
Jia killed this performance
vote for 4minute 4nia 4ever
4minute fighting!!! I go for 4minute :)
miss a's and 4minute's songs are totally different. miss a's dance is still tiring even if you don't sing. and 4minute dance does not even shed a sweat.
this was not a dance battle
uschi tuschi the dance affects singing. I'm saying miss a's dance is hard and make them sound breathless. opposite with 4minute, their song is not too upbeat so they don't have to move a lot and sounds stable
+Salva Ditsharah for a performance battle 4Minute wins! ^v^
Hyuna *O*
4minute😊
Okay Miss A is just amazing though they sounded out of breath they rocked it!! And I'm not really A fan of 4minute but Wow they looked great! :D
You fantastic
4minute ~ 4ever~ 4nia♥ Saranghae ~~ Jihyun♥Hyuna♥Gayoon♥Jiyoon♥Sohyun♥
I really love 4Minute!
They so awesome!
I am American and am trying to learn the Korean language in hope that I may someday meet Nam Jihyun.
I have such a crush on her. I love her very much.
I still don't know why Volume up is underrated. It's been years since it was released and I am still not over it. 4minute and Miss A will always be iconic. There's more than Hyuna and Suzy in their groups. Each member are amazing!!!
4minute definitely won!!!
My favourite 4MINUTE outfits for Volume Up
Miss A forever
I'm Sana Trash 💔
me too XD
Yessss! ♡
남자없이 잘 살아 진짜 좋아ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ내가 제일 좋아하는 노래 이거 들으면 자신감이 진짜 높아짐
I love both of groups but I like 4Minute performance better,they sounds good ...and love Hyuna and Sohyun...they so cute... Miss A do a good performance too....this is just my opinion...
Suzy and Hyun Ah are so cute ! ♥♥♥
4minutes performance was beautiful seriously!
a a fan of neither group, I say I'm more impressed with 4minute's performance
4Minute's outfits were beautiful O.O
And their voices were surprisingly powerful! =^. , .^=
(And I wish that people wouldn't just straight up say that the group is "terrible", I mean giving constructive criticism wouldn't have offended people quite as much as what was really said. D: It absolutely would have been taken the wrong way by some, but then at least a huge fight could have been avoided if the original commenter was able to state that what they had said was just things that they thought the group could improve upon. Take for example me saying this, which I do think is true:
Miss A's "I Don't Need A Man" is a good song, but I think that in this performance the background that they added to it sort of cheapened the song......so.....yeah. p.s. don't throw shade!)
4MINUTE's intro is so beautiful!!
JiYoon's high chords really dope!
4Minute !! (Hyuna ♥-♥ I Love You)
HyunA ❤❤
I was so impressed with MissA, the whole setup of the stage was literally flawless and the way they danced and sang at the same time would of been freaking hard. But even though they lacked a bit, its because of the dancing. I loved it and was so impressed
Miss A was very good, but Jiyoon and Gayoon were AWESOME!
4 minute hwaiting -Amazing performance!!!!
4 Minute. Nice intro - amazing uniforms.
MISS A MISS A MISS A MISS A
You guys didnt notice the "dance and performance" miss A did here. Y'all said they were out of breath, of course they were freaking dancing and doing stuff like standing on the desk, and yes dancing lmao look at 4 minutes' perf they were barely dancing, lmao but I love both groups. I just have to day Miss A won here
Intro, music, fanchant, vocals, outfits => 4minute won it clearly ♥ ♥ ♥
Miss A Min will always be my Dancing Queen.
songs from miss A always have good lyrics! miss A is magnificent!!
SUZY
MISS A !
4minute such an elegant w/ their outfit!, love them..
the good old days! 2012/2013 will always be the best years in kpop with the early 2000 for me!
2011-2013 WERE GOLDEN!
Basically the second generation! ❤
Gotta say, 4 min won that one. It was just a more interesting performance. And Hyuna just has good presence by herself.
I can't pick one..
They're both good
Miss A and 4Minute
Feeling nostalgic
Missing this era so much
Suzy and Hyuna 🙌🙌
oh my god.the best performans of 4minute!! miss A's song is like a kids song :)
4 minute forever
4minute
4Minute did so well, love how they put a twist on the intro
4 minute needs to come back !! they are always going to be the best Korean girl group to exist
4MINUTE JIYOON GAYOON HYUNA SOHYUN JIHYUN
MissA!
Miss A all the way
miss a's perf... jia and fei did well... min was kinda out of breath at first but recovered later.. suzy.. wasnt good ... barely hear her singing except some ad libs part
Suzy wasn't good? are you hearing yourself?
I agree Suzy's performance was lack luster. She was more like the pretty back up for a missing singer in the group.
Well there was a lot of dancing in Miss A's one so would have short breaths while 4minute had little dancing.
Some people may not know this, but JYP artists are taught to sing with a method that uses much more air than other artists from different companies. You know, since they're dancing the whole time and the song is sped up, it's kind of hard to keep your breath haha. It shouldn't matter much though because our miss A girls are still fierce~
Some people may not know this, but JYP artists are taught to sing with a method that uses much more air than other artists from different companies. You know, since they're dancing the whole time and the song is sped up, it's kind of hard to keep your breath haha. It shouldn't matter much though because our miss A girls are still fierce~
배수지 진짜 너무 이쁘다 !!
Me encanta miss a pero esta ves estubo mejor 4minute volume up ♡♡♡♡♡ 5/5
4 minute is the best i love them waaahhhh!!!!!!
I like Miss A but 4minute always 💕
4minute!!!! The best
4 minute hyuna love 😘😘😘😍
4MINUTE IS THE BEST!!!!!!!4444 4MINUTE
4Minute verygood♡love♡
MISS A ♥♥♥ 1:42 BEAUTIFUL
2:42 BEAUTIFUL RAP
4 MINUTE
4minute definitely in this round. A lot of people dislike Hyuna, but that girl has stage presence. She gets into her songs and her eyes speak her mind.
I miss you 4minutes 나는 그것이 아직 실현되지 않은 단지 꿈이었으면 좋겠다 나는 당신을 다시 함께 데려 오고 싶다 하지만 괜찮아요 당신은 내 모든 팬들에 살고 있다 당신은 항상 함께있을거야, 강한 소녀 A. ING ARMY EXOL FOR EVER
Jiyoon saves the day in every live performance of VU... I love Miss A as well but 4minute slayed.
So. I vote the 4minute intro dancers and musicians as the winner tbh xD
Aki-is- Dancing true haha
I'm still waiting for the rest of 4minute members to come together... missing 2yoon's voices 😭
actually I love them both, but we have admire that modern music and gayageum (I'm sorry to korean if I miss in write that traditional instrument name) is really rally give us a the feeling of "ghostbump", I mean it's not that bad, but its really awesome indeed, right? beside the "tough girl" image that 4minute have, can be seen clearly, and more powerful than MissA in this performance while MissA show something cutie, right? who don't like a performance like this? 4minute gave us all, "sexy tough energetic very tempting girl that hard to approach" image.
I mean, listen carefully, when you boys got some girl or a girl get some boys, 1st girl is "easy to get close" and another is "hard to get close", which one do you want so badly? the one that "hard to get close" is the answer, right? cause they are more tempt to get them and they all tease us in a strange way that you like very much, right?
so, admire by yourself, am I right or not?
4minute is the best !!!!
4Minute!
Miss a~♡♡♡♡
Hyuna
SOHYUN, simply beautiful.
Miss A's performance was good, I didn't like the remix though and some parts were a bit off, they sound out of breath. Still I like the choreography the most. But to be honest I prefer 4Minute more, they came out powerful. The girls did a wonderful job on singing and dancing.
for epicness skip to 3:32
4minute hands down Won this battle. bittersweet considering Hyuna and Jia are like Besties.
miss A..4 minute !!! wow you all are great !!!
Miss A had tougher choreography than 4MINUTE which is probably why they were out of breath the entire performance which tbh takes away from the entire performance. Hyuna seemed to be the only to really struggle during the 4minute performance while the entire of Miss A struggled. 4minute did way better than Miss A for this performance.
kyouandkiba in my opinion, i think hyuna did not struggle for anything, she's good at solo too remember, i think she didn't even bother to try. I'm giving a point for Miss A.
kyouandkiba No miss a did wayy better then them!
+One Of A kind No 4minute did way better hahaa :P GAME OVER !!!
miss A out of breath in the first 20s when they only stood
kyouandkiba -
Wow this was nearly a year and a half ago? The typewriter concept on the big screens were great, but the 10 women playing that traditional instrument and those dancers that opened for 4 minute,. What a great show was put on by both groups. Always something over the top performances coming from SK.
I Love Miss A.
4minute!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Miss A had better choreography and 4minute had better stage presence (more seductive). Both were good performances.
I loved 4Minute's performance **v** and it felt like a special performance with the intro and such. The arrangement was beautiful both visually and musically. Their performance was tidy and simple yet was captivating to watch. Even the audience cheered loudly for them! ^^ 4Minute are my Queens! And they are consistent yet always improve. Proud of these lovely ladies!!
HelloHwaitingBuhBye Long live 4minute!
Why would you even bring Twice here ? I saw you on other videos trying to start fanwars, you're ridiculous
Commander Of Twiceland twice is girlgroup lack of talent
Iksan Azhari sure Jan
4minute were so amazing and sung very well !! I miss them 💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝😭😭😭😭
miss a 's performance was nice but the remix ver didn did well for them.. they sound out of breath...
both performances are amazing! fei's voice is always so strong
4minute love cute
4minute is the best (Y)
4minute outfits look a lot like sistar's i like that outfit style
miss A