Last week I was playing this concert once more and a dog outside the theater barked during this song (and only in this one), almost in the part the dogs bark in the original one. I'll check the recording later, maybe I'll post it here or in my Fb page! ;)
@@Dhdhdyqha it's true I learned it, it just doesn't sound 100% like the studio version, because of course the cool guitar parts aren't there, but I can play the chords and the melodies...
@@Dhdhdyqha You know, I don't know why I'm able to do this, but it just happens naturally to me - sometimes I need some help but mostly I just have to listen and try to play along one song I like to cover often enough and then I'll work out how to play that song. However I have a, say, unusual way of playing piano. I'm not an advanced player, I just can play piano quite good. So I could never play the song like Dogs is played right here in this video. I believe the reason I'm able to do this is because I'm really bad at playing music by notes. I can read sheet music, but it's hard and I never enjoyed it. I would be better with it if I had to rely on it, but in my piano lessons I rather learned the song remembering the parts in my head than reading the sheets so I wasn't ever really forced to learn to read sheet music. It would take like maybe half a year for such a song to learn entirely by sheet music, and I would need a professional piano teacher next to me. So it has advantages and disadvantages...I guess I would be much better at playing piano if I'd stuck to just reading, because playing by ear made me develop this unusual style. But yeah the advantage of it is that I can play the music I like listening to and also I learned it's much cooler if you can play songs for your friends that they like than tryint to impress them by a classical piece you learned for a year. It's just cooler if you can play what they listened on a party a few minutes ago... It also depends on the piece of music. I rate "pigs" as a semi-hard song. But I struggled and gave up on songs like "Firth Of Fifth". I'd rather do something like "Black Dog" or "Never Going Back Again"...
Really, you're going to blame every audience member rather than the artist? It's the artist's job to capture the audience. While this is impressive, there was zero dynamic contrast in the performance, so I can see why the audience were not engaged.
It's been 7 years since you wrote this comment, and we both are older, wiser men now, so we can appreciate the fact that the performance is totally captivating and one can imagine each person in the audience totally enchanted and mentally singing along while Bruno performs his magic on the keyboards. From a personal experience, when I hear him play Floyd, I really feel it to be a form of meditation and very therapeutic indeed. 🙂
The greatest rendidition of this song i have heard in my life, This song means the world to me, abosoleutly beautiful playing Bruno, You are pure talent, Shine on you Crazy Diamond, Made my day! Unbelievable
Waters would walk up to you after the performance, nitpick the lighting director and a couple of minor keys he didn't like. He would then stalk off mumbling "that was bloody excellent". Somewhere Nick Wright would be saying "now you know how I felt".:-)
Maestro!!! Sos un genio. Reproducís la obra de arte de Pink Floyd de manera magistral! Viva el arte inmortal de Pink Floyd y tu talento! Abrazo desde Argentina
Curti e descurti só pra poder curtir de novo. Rapaz, fantástico. Toco piano também, estou recomeçando depois de 30 anos sem tocar. Você me inspira. Grande abraço,
Lá estava eu procurando minha música favorita em versão piano no TH-cam, de repente encontro um cara apresentando em minha cidade :D Que grande coincidência! Muito bom!
Fantastic job capturing the attitude of the song! In my opinion, this is a cover that stays truer to the original than just about any other multi-instrument cover I've heard. Bravo!
João Pedro Nowak Por enquanto ainda não tentei nada por aí por ser um pouco longe, e todos meus projetos são tocados por conta própria. Mas eu estou me expandindo bem rápido, então não deve demorar pra eu tentar chegar a estados como MS, GO, MT e MG... =)
Bravo sir
the audience could have at least barked
Last week I was playing this concert once more and a dog outside the theater barked during this song (and only in this one), almost in the part the dogs bark in the original one. I'll check the recording later, maybe I'll post it here or in my Fb page! ;)
Great work Mr. Hrabovsky, I love it
Deveria ser a Mademoiselle Nobs ou o Seamus. Esses conhecem a música :-). Grande trabalho Bruno, parabéns
Or even howl.
I was just thinking my dogs even love this song!lol
Stupendo
Most of those people in that audience have never even heard this song,let alone anything by Pink Floyd!!Ha!! What a super great surprise 😮!!!
Impressive!
I would love to know how to play this on piano
i try to learn it by ear because I hate to read sheets. I actually learned Pigs (Three different ones) this way.
@@leonardsimonis2376 aint no way lmao
@@Dhdhdyqha it's true I learned it, it just doesn't sound 100% like the studio version, because of course the cool guitar parts aren't there, but I can play the chords and the melodies...
@@leonardsimonis2376 thats fucking awesome dude
@@Dhdhdyqha You know, I don't know why I'm able to do this, but it just happens naturally to me - sometimes I need some help but mostly I just have to listen and try to play along one song I like to cover often enough and then I'll work out how to play that song.
However I have a, say, unusual way of playing piano. I'm not an advanced player, I just can play piano quite good. So I could never play the song like Dogs is played right here in this video.
I believe the reason I'm able to do this is because I'm really bad at playing music by notes. I can read sheet music, but it's hard and I never enjoyed it. I would be better with it if I had to rely on it, but in my piano lessons I rather learned the song remembering the parts in my head than reading the sheets so I wasn't ever really forced to learn to read sheet music. It would take like maybe half a year for such a song to learn entirely by sheet music, and I would need a professional piano teacher next to me.
So it has advantages and disadvantages...I guess I would be much better at playing piano if I'd stuck to just reading, because playing by ear made me develop this unusual style.
But yeah the advantage of it is that I can play the music I like listening to and also I learned it's much cooler if you can play songs for your friends that they like than tryint to impress them by a classical piece you learned for a year. It's just cooler if you can play what they listened on a party a few minutes ago...
It also depends on the piece of music. I rate "pigs" as a semi-hard song. But I struggled and gave up on songs like "Firth Of Fifth". I'd rather do something like "Black Dog" or "Never Going Back Again"...
Very awesome job on a difficult to play song. The audience doesn't seem to recognize it or they are a bunch of sticks in the mud.
+Analog Man I was thinking the same thing. You wouldn't have been able to wipe the grin off my face if I was in attendance.
Really, you're going to blame every audience member rather than the artist? It's the artist's job to capture the audience. While this is impressive, there was zero dynamic contrast in the performance, so I can see why the audience were not engaged.
@@gorgolyt YES.
It's been 7 years since you wrote this comment, and we both are older, wiser men now, so we can appreciate the fact that the performance is totally captivating and one can imagine each person in the audience totally enchanted and mentally singing along while Bruno performs his magic on the keyboards. From a personal experience, when I hear him play Floyd, I really feel it to be a form of meditation and very therapeutic indeed. 🙂
Very impressive
The greatest rendidition of this song i have heard in my life, This song means the world to me, abosoleutly beautiful playing Bruno, You are pure talent, Shine on you Crazy Diamond, Made my day! Unbelievable
No, this is Dogs, as the title suggests. Not shine on you crazy diamond
Genius ! I played awesome! 👍👍
wow!
this audience has never heard of floyd
DOGS, essa é minha musica preferida, são 17 minutos a trilha original, não é pra qualquer musico, parabéns, vou ficar atento quando voltar a PG.
Excellent!...... Awesome rendition of "Dogs" i wish Rodger Waters could hear this!..........
Simply too good. This is so much more than there is to listen too.
The best group Pink Floyd...
I always thought the floyd were classical and you've just proved it.My fav song. Well done!!!
Excellent job. Hard to believe nobody in the audience knew what they were hearing.
Excelente !! I miss so much the bark part
Sou fã incondicional do Pink Floyd e posso escrever que essa versão de Dogs no piano ficou incrível! Parabéns!
Waters would walk up to you after the performance, nitpick the lighting director and a couple of minor keys he didn't like. He would then stalk off mumbling "that was bloody excellent". Somewhere Nick Wright would be saying "now you know how I felt".:-)
Maestro!!! Sos un genio. Reproducís la obra de arte de Pink Floyd de manera magistral!
Viva el arte inmortal de Pink Floyd y tu talento!
Abrazo desde Argentina
Thank God this was recorded! Fucking awesome!!!!
Wow so beautiful,thankyou for that amazing experience of listening to incredible music!
Excelente!!!
How I adore this song and the ecstasy is to play it on piano
Awesome very well done
A perfeição desse garoto me remete a minha infância!
Gratidão Bruno!
Maravilhoso..bravo..bravo...
Pretty bloody amazing!... i wasnt expecting this to be this good
Exceptionnel !
Astonishing, amazing, great piano cover !
I definitetly adore it ! Thks for this discover, from an young old PF fan.
MAGISTRAL !!!!
Ca sonne tellement! l'intensite wow!
SENSACIONAL!! Pra aplaudir de pé!!
Sem palavras pra essa versão! Sensacional! Brilhante.
You of my favorite Floyd songs. This mesmerized me. Excellent.
Excellent BRAVO !
Alto vuelo Floydiano. Felicitaciones. Gustav 🍷🍷.👍.
um artista desse com assentos vagos no teatro. um pecado. venha a BH.
Charles Portilho Era uma sessão extra, a primeira estava lotada. Um dia chegarei a BH sim! =)
De caminho passe por Portugal :-)
Bravo! Bruno is the best piano player of Pink Floyd things I ever heard. It's my opinion.
Curti e descurti só pra poder curtir de novo. Rapaz, fantástico. Toco piano também, estou recomeçando depois de 30 anos sem tocar. Você me inspira. Grande abraço,
Great work.
Show de bola!!! Meu amigo da carona! 👏👏👏
wow -- magnifico!
Mês que vem você estará em BH e eu, claro, estarei lá para conferir essa maravilha.
Impressionante o que você fez cara...estou atônito
Incrível... Parabens pelo talento... muito boa essa versao de Echoes... pink floyd a melhor banda do mundo!!!
+Alex Ferreira
Is Dogs sorry
rsrs ok... na verdade o vídeo anterior que eu havia assistido era de echoes, e acabei comentando nesse aqui rsrsrs
valeu caro amigo
Thank you for the music , Floydian from egypt a big fan of you!
Apesar de não ser uma canção para piano, ficou legal!
Viajei! Fantástico! Parabéns!!!
Good stuff mate, You play piano like a god
a versão tocada em Cascavel ficou ainda superior. O feeling de Bruno chegou ao máximo.
very very nice music done of dogs on piano......respect for you....cheers..
My yamaha cp just went down the fucking stairs !!! Fuck me !!
Olá, tu vai passar por Cascavel e Pato Branco e não vai dar uma passadinha em Curitiba??? É pertinho! rs
Tem show em Curitiba dia 12 de Junho, e com Floyd no repertório, hehehe
Bruno Hrabovsky Aewww! só noticia boa ! \O/
Tamo lá então! Valeu e parabéns pelo talento!
Sem palavras cara!
Maravilhoso. Estupendo.
Let me know of you ever play Liverpool would love to come see a set by you.😁👍👍
Floripa te espera, cara. Genial. Arrepiante!
Demais,estou super ansiosa para te ver aqui em Curitiba
Nice work mate.
Bloody bravo Bruno...
Lá estava eu procurando minha música favorita em versão piano no TH-cam, de repente encontro um cara apresentando em minha cidade :D Que grande coincidência! Muito bom!
i can practically hear roger singing
"and after a while...you can put on points for style"
David sang that part. Roger sang later on in the song
Fantastic job capturing the attitude of the song! In my opinion, this is a cover that stays truer to the original than just about any other multi-instrument cover I've heard. Bravo!
fizer show aqui no Rio de Janeiro dá um alô por qui.. a final pink floyd é pink Floyd humilhouuu
Visualizei o vídeo Bike ( Pink Floyd) e já me tornei um inscrito nesse canal!!!
Ah como eu queria esse lugar vago aí na primeira fila... minha música!
Sem palavras!! Achei demais!! Fabuloso!!
Awesome, Man!!!
Sounded awesome---excellent playing, fantastic arrangement!
I really liked it, is one of my favorite songs of Pink Floyd .very well job!
Be sure I *do* enjoy it! Excellent job. Great talent. I'm pretty sure you've made many people to feel better for a while. Thank you, man...
Bruno tive o prazer de assistir ao vivo, muito bom, vou outra vez.
not a song I would think would translate well to piano, but wow, this is a real treat
sensacional!!
não minto que escorreu uma lágrima aqui
Perfect!!
Igualmente Bellas. Tú y la calidez de la melodía. Abrazo Floydiano Lori. Gustav 🍷 🌿 🌷.
excelente, acompanho todos os seus covers dos floyd e sao sempre espetaculares... principalmente da Echoes
Continue assim cara, você vai longe... Talento nato!
You captured the song amazingly on the piano! Props to you!
That was fabulous!
Talentoso demais! Parabéns! Ficou muito lindo!
Muito, muito bom!!! Very, very good!!!
Parabens!! Voce é um grande músico!!!
Muito bom! Toca essa em Maringá!
fantastyczny cover
Absolute bonkers work lad! You're a legend!!
PARABÉNS!!!
really impressive... congratulations
Excellent job.
Fantastic performance! What the hell is wrong with that audience?
Alguma chance de você se apresentar em Campo Grande - MS? Muito boa sua performance!
João Pedro Nowak Por enquanto ainda não tentei nada por aí por ser um pouco longe, e todos meus projetos são tocados por conta própria. Mas eu estou me expandindo bem rápido, então não deve demorar pra eu tentar chegar a estados como MS, GO, MT e MG... =)
Perfect. That audience is undeserving of that piece.
Just amazing!!!
sei un fenomeno, complimenti !
Fantastic!!
Perfeito! Lindo!
Fabuloso! Meus parabéns!
BRAVO,BRAVISIMO¡¡¡¡
Excellent work!
This is absolutely beauty 👏👏👏
This is fucking really really good