I personally like the sound effect of the P5/P5R Crit Cut-In a LOT more than P3R. Its just SO satisfying for me lol. That "ding" really does something to my brain. As for design, I think P3R is...objectively better lol but P5R has its charm that's perfect for the game and is the one I like the most when it happens in battle. Both cut-ins are goated though!
P3R critical is fucking peak. The soumd effect of the shot + glass shattering and the head bob from the Evoker recoil makes it so meaty. Can't wait for P6
@@MintTastic i mean p3 has my favorite cast and story overall, but I like p5r's characters and story just has much, not to mention p5r is still a better game to play
I wish they kept Royal’s idle and his persona summoning animation. That gun spin before shooting the head is such a nice touch. Objectively P3R looks better and clean but my pick will be P5R. P5R intentionally looks messy and edgy and I like that more.
I disagree. The P3 one just feels modern and crisp. The P5 one fits the style of the game but objectively feels worse overall. Both are great but imo the p3 one is just that extra tier beyond
@@The_Lightless the cut in should look older as it should capture the charm of the original persona 3, making it look modern kind of erases some of that charm and makes it seem like some of the personality is lost which is why its worse in comparison
Technically, it's still there, but only when you switch personas. That blue silhouette of Makoto, which is a part of UI, does it, and I think it's a cool detail. And makes switching personas very satifying.
Graphics and visuals are obviously better for Reload, but to me Royal’s art style and sound design is still unmatched. It has a strong identity, Reload’s comparatively just seems super streamlined and isn’t too similar to OG P3 (though it’s still REALLY good)
Both have style for there respected games
*their respective games
I personally like the sound effect of the P5/P5R Crit Cut-In a LOT more than P3R. Its just SO satisfying for me lol. That "ding" really does something to my brain.
As for design, I think P3R is...objectively better lol but P5R has its charm that's perfect for the game and is the one I like the most when it happens in battle.
Both cut-ins are goated though!
I totally agree both are great
One is like a Window being shoted and other looks like a manga page being teared away
P3R critical is fucking peak. The soumd effect of the shot + glass shattering and the head bob from the Evoker recoil makes it so meaty. Can't wait for P6
Do we like P3R or P5R more? I like P3R it's just so epic
Are you serious? P3R’s is in a league of its own.
I still like p5r better but p3r is goated
@@cristianoducceschi3547how do you say that but have Makoto as your pfp
@@MintTastic i mean p3 has my favorite cast and story overall, but I like p5r's characters and story just has much, not to mention p5r is still a better game to play
3, it’s ANIMATED!
I wish they kept Royal’s idle and his persona summoning animation. That gun spin before shooting the head is such a nice touch. Objectively P3R looks better and clean but my pick will be P5R. P5R intentionally looks messy and edgy and I like that more.
This.
I disagree. The P3 one just feels modern and crisp. The P5 one fits the style of the game but objectively feels worse overall. Both are great but imo the p3 one is just that extra tier beyond
When you change personas in p3r he does spin the gun in the bottom left corner you’ll see it
@@The_Lightless the cut in should look older as it should capture the charm of the original persona 3, making it look modern kind of erases some of that charm and makes it seem like some of the personality is lost which is why its worse in comparison
@@Thatcooldude_King No, it shouldn’t.
Both are better in their own themes
God Damn the P3R one is seriously in a different league
bro i miss the gun slinging he does on persona summoning so much
That's definitely swag af
Technically, it's still there, but only when you switch personas. That blue silhouette of Makoto, which is a part of UI, does it, and I think it's a cool detail. And makes switching personas very satifying.
I had to check it, you're right @@RalphFinchi
Was hoping P3R keep the gun spinning animation tho, i mean even P3P has it
Graphics and visuals are obviously better for Reload, but to me Royal’s art style and sound design is still unmatched. It has a strong identity, Reload’s comparatively just seems super streamlined and isn’t too similar to OG P3 (though it’s still REALLY good)
Yeah P3R cut ins are on anotber level compared to P5Rs