Well, she that's probably cuz she trained a lot since this performance. Especially considering that the show only got trainees who are not part of a company
JYP said "we prohobited any YG song on JYP audition because YG song is hard to sing and dont bring their full potential, YG song created for it member and their uniqueness and charactetristic"
If you want to sing a song from YG, make sure you 1) Have a unique vocal color 2) Have swagger 3) Great english pronunciation 4) Be a badass rapper 5) Show your side of swag + sexy + badass + a bit of bitchiness 6) Great vocals 7) Unique fashion sense It is really a risk to use YG's songs as a cover. U am not saying they are bad, it's just they need more room of improvement
Jairus Lirazan the "great English pronunciation" is so unnecessary tbh. You can't expect every idol to be good in English. It may not even be their first language. I agree with the fact that there's room for improvement tho
The show choose the songs to recognize BP is a popular girl group, y'all fill the comment section with the same "YG songs are just for YG artists" we can't even find comments about the girls. So do you want BP to be recognized or better if nobody mentions their songs ever? If you want to sing a YG song just do it, stop being annoying with the rules.
Giovanna G They chose to perform these songs from popular girl groups so their fans would tune in to the show and might snatch some of them. They performed it the way the original does it so comparisons are unavoidable
Lee Seoyeon really got that YG vibe on her and that proves that she really belongs to YG but sadly she left😢 since yg posted the future 2ne1 i saw lee seoyeon and started to wait for her to debut then suddenly I heard the news that she left yg😢
*Lee Seoyeon needs to debut. She's worked so hard for years now and with the uncertainty of ever debuting with her close friends at YG but now she has a second chance and I really want her to do well and join the group!*
honestly,,,, this performance wasn't that bad??? It wasn't the best, but it isn't terrible and horrible as y'all make it out to be. Like the vocals were good (jiwon, seoyeon + haein), the two rappers were okay and the dance was okay too, sure the sub vocalists need a lot of practice but they weren't horrible so idk y'all are on lmao
Watch Blackpink'sBoombayahor Lisa willkickyourass even then I've seen groups with a lot of members like WJSN and Pristin who are with many but aren't as messy... Whoever did the choreography for these girls didn't do a good job see @0:53 ... Too messy
+VolumePerfection you gotta know since whistle is a kind of sexy and badass song with some swag ..that is not easy to pull off and since they got that many member it's become more disadvantage
@@rini3403 Only dumb people like you would believe that lol she was nowhere near the ranks of kaeun, miru, miho. She basically just appeared in the top ranks out of the blue.
Victoria Sánchez. lmao she left yg cause he kept delaying the group's debut. also she's really talented and has improved alot and she really has the yg vibe in most of her recent performances
Truthfully BlackPink's songs are not for everyone. In my humble opinion, I love the vibes I m getting from Seo Yeon, Sae Rom and the girl in red (shes so prettyyy idk her name,sorry!!) Ji Won be serving dem vocals too. The others don't really suit this style.
I think the mess is created because they have too many members because look at playing with fire's vocal stage on produce 101 , it does great because there's only 4 members in the team .
vierra street, yes number affect anything. if they are going to perform a song that was created for 4 members at least change the choreography a little bit because this looked like a mess.
no it actually suit them because they were boys and playing with fire kinda has that boyish swag that is suitable for male and black pink can pull it out just as good as guys do... while on the other hand girl idols make it seem too girly
the vocal team succeed in pulling an amazing performance bcs they rearranged the song and dance to their own style and made it like it's theirs but the girls only did a plain/normal cover
now i know why the judges on kpop star said 'dont sing yg song if u dont have ur own voice characteristic' ah i see. idk im getting excited for this perf but- yeah just yeah i think it just a simple perf and i dont get excited at all they need more power on stage i think. okay they're still learning! fighting gurls! btw saerom visual no joke;----; btw please support Herin❤ And Jo Yuri why so kyood:'D
agree with you. idk why this perf was so plain. rose's unique voice makes this song more interesting. but i still love this perf, they are good especially jiwon, seoyeon and myungji ❤
Yg artist didn't require the so call difficult high note like the other group songs ,and I have seen they could pull off the other group song so well but I rarely see anyone who can pull off yg girl group song except yg artist themselves .,it's require a lot of charisma and swag lol
I’m upset that Jo Yuri only got like one line but damn I didn’t know that Yuri was like that before she met Yena😳 Edit: HAS YENA SEEN THIS VIDEO???? I CURIOUS MAN I WANNA KNOW IF SHE HAS OR HAS HYEWON SEEN THIS VIDEOOO??!!!?!?!?
No one can sing YG's song like the original artist. I mean this group doesn't have the carisma tho. Like no one stood out, duh they should sing a song that can be covered by everyone
I thinks it's really hard to cover YG's song bcs you need to be unique and charismatic, not only doing what's best and all. Even JYP admit that it's not an easy task to cover YG's song.
this! haha i think when TEDDY composed this song he know what to do with YG Artist, like make own colour for each artist, and sometimes even YG Artist covering other YG Artist not even good as we think
Exo-l &army Fan its mnet idol school, a new program to train ordinary people who dont have any agency and the 9 final members will debut in a group. the format is almost the same with p101 tho
Jiwon is really good, is not like i know her or something I just found her name in the comments but Many people is saying that the group was bad but i really liked her voice and two girls more but jiwon for sure was GREAT!! I dont like when people just has bad things to say at least point some good things
LisaVDawon fan ILuvThem, yes I kind of agree with you this performance was cringey but from what I see they were not trying to act cute, they wanted to look sexy but ended up being too girly and cute because they have no zero charisma.
So many people are saying other shouldn't cover blackpink but actually some of the members I thought were really good (I don't even watch the show by the way) I think Jiwon did a really good work as main vocal and Myeongji (I think that's how it's written) Rapped pretty well. Those two in my opinion were good ^^
Am I the only one who felt that cringe feeling? So the famous statement, "YG songs are for YG artists only", is really true. The whole song will become strange to you if someone tries to cover it 😂
Everyone wanted to cover this song also Hayong and other girls...I'm glad they didn't get it cuz I don't think it would suit anyone who are free-agented trainees, even who was yg's trainee like Soyeon could barely handle it... She did well anyway Yg's songs always get a lot of attention but nobody noticed that the more attention the more pressure
Mnet should have heard jyp saying that people shouldn't cover yg songs bc just don't, the felling can't be even close A lot of this girls are my fav on the show but no, just no :(
my opinion after watching this vid : don't cover yg's artist songs. edit: this comment got so much likes and i just want to say that im not hating on them, i just feel like they dont have the "aura" that yg artist have
Horus MMB They put so much effort on this then at the end get so criticism smh Destroy?They re just covering it don't be so harsh fgs.For me it was good,since they haven't performed that much yet.
Jiwon and Seoyeon saved this performance. Myeoungi, is that her name, got some real swag as a rapper. Gyuri tried so hard to copy Blackpink while Saerom was trying to be sexy. Siwoo was like a backup dancer, did she even have a real line?
most of the girls on the show don't have any trainee or stage experience. don't compare new trainees to a group that dedicated a long time to practice and make the song theirs. it's a cover for a reason.
This comment section is full of delulu YG stans like you. They think that blackoink is too awesome and think high of themeselves. Learn to be humble and learn that they are still trainees. okay?
+jae myung I am a YG stan and I am so embarrassed by this delusional BP fans. Seriously. They are toxic especially this newer fans. This was a good cover compared to when Produce101 covered 2ne1 Fire. I feel like they are saying this just to make Blackpink feel special LMAO
They were too busy acring pretty they didn't even try matching the vibe of the song. It was a very nice song to show charisma but unfortunately they all fell flat. PD101 S1 was a lot, lot better.
Maisha Chy Only 3 out of these 8 girls did not have any experience. It's sad that even those who had training or debuted before (lee seo yeon-ex-yg trainee, lee hae in from P101 S1 and part of IBI, lee young yoo who had some experience as a singer and competed in tribe of hip hop, park jiwon ex-jyp and competed in sixteen and myeong ji who debuted with Tiny-G) were not much better than those without some training at all.
Ysa Belle yes. and the bad ass facial expression of blackpink while performing. these girls are all smiling while also singing seems like acting cute or whatever that does not suits the swag of the song
Maybe this is why Blackpink is really unique. No one can pull off their songs better than them. And there's a lot of them on stagd hihi. But all props to this group. Hwaiting!
Saerom's visual is really no joke. I'm really falling for her. Jiwon's voice is really good and Seoyeon really suit this song. . . Yuri (I'm sorry if I spell wrong), I really want you to be you more than to be yoojung 2. Be original yuri is better than be other one's shadow.
Toon S they trying so hard to make her look like yoojung though she really does look alike. anyway im not hating on her, i really hope she, saerom, natty, jiwon, hayoung and chaeyoung will be in top 9 @ final (excuse my english)
Ayyash Kadullah At least 2:11 is one of the answers. It's really remind me of yoojung's bang bang performance. I think that she know that she has similiar face with yoojung so she has to shine her own charm. I cannot see her. I see yoojung cover her all the time in this program. I thought I can see her charm on the stage but when I see this performance, it still be yoojung's character. . . I don't have negative thinking of her (explain if you misunderstand me) but I really want to see real yuri. It's not okay if people cannot remember her as her but remember her as other person, right? . . English is not my mother language but I try to explain. I'm sorry if it has some mistakes. Hope you understand and don't mind it.
queendoyeon I'm really not hating on her too. I know that she is cute and have a talent so I want me (and other people) to see her as her not to be someone.
List of groups that are impossible to cover really well: Red Velvet, f(x), and blackpink. The bp girls have really unique voices. They also include a lot of English in their songs and three members are fluent and Jisoo is really good at pronunciation. It’s difficult to cover their songs. I think jiwon did the best
The rapping was actually good. The difference on why it didn't stood out is that they did a "flirtatious come and look at me I'm swaggy as hell" vibe while blackpink made it as a "I don't care if you look at me or not, you'll be amazed by me even just by sitting anyways, I'm too cool not to be noticed" thang.
They put their mic so far from their mouth I wonder how did the rap can be heard this clearly... And the vocal line is the best vocal line than other groups', people should at least appreciate the vocal instead of pointing out their unsuited style for this song.
Nuril Frida I think the reason people are judging is becayse this isn't a vocal performance. I sound so rude criticizing them -i know, but it's a PERFORMANCE stage and they were far from owning the song. They didn't put their style in it and they failed even harder at trying to pull off BP's charms so maybe that's why we're so judgemental.
I know it's late, but. Same as other mnet survival, this version is already auto-tuned by mnet, you can her their real if you come live. And also i noticed that this round's fancam ver is their real voice but the next round and so on is not.
Trainees in Produce Season 1 (Monster) & Season 2 (Playing With Fire & Fear) were good because they did it with new arrangement and their own style or lyrics
Lee Seoyeon's stage prescence tho. She enjoyed the performance, it shows on her face. The fierceness is natural, unlike the others. She really has the YG vibe.
When you realize nobody (here and maybe other idols) can't do what BLACKPINK does on stage 👀 this made me realize even more how colorful and unique BP is
same, seeing stuff like this makes me realize even more just how unique blackpink is when it comes to vocal tones and stage presence. every time I've seen anyone try to cover "whistle" so far it just isn't that good. Not that that the idols who have covered bp songs are untalented, no no not at all. just not suited for bp songs.
Just my opinion but many people are being ridiculous. Blackpink's their sunbae and the song is challenging enough to help them develop their skills. Just like how they cover SNSD in produce 101. Obviously they're lacking a lot and i'm sure no one dared compare them to blackpink. Please stop being extra it's really annoying to see comments like "only bp can sing this song"...
![Idol School [3회]청량미 甲! ′오늘부터 우리는′ 배은영,나띠,박소명,서헤린,유지나,이다희,이슬,장규리 @ 1차데뷔능력고사 170727 EP.3](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/K8f5PNXSYc4/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [3회]청량미 甲! ′오늘부터 우리는′ 배은영,나띠,박소명,서헤린,유지나,이다희,이슬,장규리 @ 1차데뷔능력고사 170727 EP.3](/img/tr.png)
![[Ep.03] KIM MINSOL KIM SUJUNG NAM YUJU BANG JEEMIN RYU SARANG YUI ♬WHISTLE - BLACKPINK @SeeSaw Game](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/urbuNWvbDko/mqdefault.jpg)
Oh my gosh, I can't believe this is the same Jo Yuri that's in Iz*one.
StrickenWithFear yes. That’s the Yuri that was rigged in. Fake winner
@@chicharon14344 shut up you hater
anonymous man she just saying the truth
@@chicharon14344 🙄so rude
@@anonymousman665 ya
JYP even said, YG songs is like made just for their artist, its really hard to sing their songs
Andy C jiwon trained in jyp and she slayed
Andy C erm its not THAT hard. If you want a song THAT hard it would be like a Whitney Houston or Celine Dion song.
The Queen true
The Queen I would like to see you upload a cover of this song then. I'll judge
Andy C yeaah thats true
seoyeon and jiwon actually suit this concept quite well
Yes!!
Ikr
Where are they? It is who makes the Jisoo's part in the first verse and who makes the Rosé's part in the second verse?
@@kwonderland9826 yes
Ofc seoyeon fits the concept...she literally almost debuted with Blackpink lmao
wow jo yuri here not getting much lines but look at her now ~ she's the main vocalist of izone omg so proud ❤💕
Yeah my fellow wiz*one😍
Yeah fellow wiz*one
Cause Jiwon Vocal Skill more good
@@xyuvicky1368 yeh like i care ...
Well, she that's probably cuz she trained a lot since this performance. Especially considering that the show only got trainees who are not part of a company
The YG swag really cant easily be replicated. Seo yeon showing how its done
Sacredproz who is seoyeon? i don' know clearly
Trang Trịnh Thị Hiền 1:30
Sacredproz she was singing Rose part and jennie bridge part
Jiwon and Seoyeon stood out the most to be honest, they saved this performance. The others did good but didn't fit this song.
Pepi Jinyoungie haein should've got me gustas tu after all she has already done it on pd101
Pepi Jinyoungie the others did okay, it's not like they were trash
seoyeon was a yg trainee for a reason
Devil P didn’t say they were trash, I said they did well.
Jiwon AND Seoyeon SAVED this performance from getting crapped on
Others need work BUT they will get there. Fighting
SinnedCK yes my two biases
SinnedCK
Who are they?
hi i blow flutes for a living i forgot Seoyeons part but Jiwon is at 0:51
myeongji not bad
I already know who Jiwon is but I don’t know Seoyeon..
can see the level between trainee from JYP, YG and others
yess and ex big3 dominated!
Wt do u mean
jimin jams are with me jiwon and seoyeon were ex trainees of yg and jyp smh
Then how do you explain Twice and Blackpink's nonexistent skills?
@@nikolashakos_ It’s obviously not true lol.
JYP said "we prohobited any YG song on JYP audition because YG song is hard to sing and dont bring their full potential, YG song created for it member and their uniqueness and charactetristic"
BPunisherFox wowww.. i was speechless .. did jyp said that ??
yes in kpop star
BPunisherFox What ep? And who was it for?
its the last kpop star, i dont remember what eps since it have 25 eps but theres someone peforming YG song
not so well and JYP said that
Well JYP ex-trainee Park Jiwon was the best vocalist here and her vocal was stable till the end even tho this is an YG song❤
"can you heal that" hahaha
shhh hahahaha
MAMA YG announce BLACKPINK COMEBACK JUNE 22 6PM KST hahahaha
omg 😂
😂😂😂
Seriously? Hahahaha. Because of you I endured the whole vid just to hear this. Lmao.
saerom's "Hey boy" and smirk killed me
seoyeon and jiwon really suits this song, especially Seoyeon
Omfg Yuri twerking is something i dID NOT EXPECT WHAT IS SHE DOING SHE'S LIKE 15
They took her vocals away and left her with twerking 😹 She's so adorable
Lol thats not even a proper twerk. She was moving her back instead of her booty
@@chicharon14344 shut up you're hater
@@rini3403 shut up stupida
@@chicharon14344 tell us how to do it then,you a dancer rIgHt
wow... lee seoyeon...😍😍
you're so good.. and i think she looks like with jisoo unnie.. 😄
and she has YG vibe... seoyeon ahh... fighting... !!!!
suin.96 블링크 yea her hairstyle and her outfit!
and she has YG vibe..😄
she's so pretty...
suin.96 블링크 she also has a same singing technique with jisoo I'm in love with Lee Seo yeon let's make her debut
Karina Tam yeah... you're right.. and her voice..😍😍 I'm so in love with her..
suin.96 블링크 same here I just love her so much from the beginning omg
If you want to sing a song from YG, make sure you
1) Have a unique vocal color
2) Have swagger
3) Great english pronunciation
4) Be a badass rapper
5) Show your side of swag + sexy + badass + a bit of bitchiness
6) Great vocals
7) Unique fashion sense
It is really a risk to use YG's songs as a cover. U am not saying they are bad, it's just they need more room of improvement
Jairus Lirazan the "great English pronunciation" is so unnecessary tbh. You can't expect every idol to be good in English. It may not even be their first language. I agree with the fact that there's room for improvement tho
The show choose the songs to recognize BP is a popular girl group, y'all fill the comment section with the same "YG songs are just for YG artists" we can't even find comments about the girls. So do you want BP to be recognized or better if nobody mentions their songs ever? If you want to sing a YG song just do it, stop being annoying with the rules.
Soo true .
Giovanna G They chose to perform these songs from popular girl groups so their fans would tune in to the show and might snatch some of them. They performed it the way the original does it so comparisons are unavoidable
Agreed. And I thinks if they really wanted to cover a BP song they could've chosen playing with fire, idk why just feel like its easier so cover
JYP trained Park Jiwon well❤ I'm proud of her! Her vocal was the most stable and strong till the end🖒
it's ok. but ' bomb bomb ' .
SSN Sen Se Nightcore lol
SSN Sen Se Nightcore that turn me off
Lee Seoyeon really got that YG vibe on her and that proves that she really belongs to YG but sadly she left😢 since yg posted the future 2ne1 i saw lee seoyeon and started to wait for her to debut then suddenly I heard the news that she left yg😢
Mind about Yoongi's booty where is she?
Mind about Yoongi's booty Yes! She really has that vibe that she was from YG. Her voice really suits this song.
*Lee Seoyeon needs to debut. She's worked so hard for years now and with the uncertainty of ever debuting with her close friends at YG but now she has a second chance and I really want her to do well and join the group!*
loonaverse to be honest she fits YG style , i wish that she will debut . Plus she is in my faves list now because of this song
Jo Yuri main dancer in idol school and main vocal in produce 48- Iz*one i'm so proud! She deserved the success!
honestly,,,, this performance wasn't that bad??? It wasn't the best, but it isn't terrible and horrible as y'all make it out to be. Like the vocals were good (jiwon, seoyeon + haein), the two rappers were okay and the dance was okay too, sure the sub vocalists need a lot of practice but they weren't horrible so idk y'all are on lmao
queen bom I think so. Wtf they are talking??
Cause there are Blinks everywhere ;)
And they're cover YG's song which has no swag in it :)
ikr rookie was bad (except for that nayeon girl) but this one is fine idk why ppl were pressed about it???
IKR! The twerk at the end killed me
Don't cover YG's songs if you're not from YG.
Seoyeon: just do it. I was in YG.
Sengin Wong and jiwon because shes voıce- so good
Army&once Jen Jiwon did well too but the ultra boss is still Seoyeon
which one is seoyeon
b ____9 the one that singing at 00:17
Sengin Wong yees "stil" vocal jiwon> seoyeon but stil and charm seoyeon>jiwon
Wish they had chosen a different song. Nobody stood out to me...
I do think it's become a mess because there is too many members in the group
Same thoughts
Watch Blackpink'sBoombayahor Lisa willkickyourass even then I've seen groups with a lot of members like WJSN and Pristin who are with many but aren't as messy... Whoever did the choreography for these girls didn't do a good job see @0:53 ... Too messy
+VolumePerfection you gotta know since whistle is a kind of sexy and badass song with some swag ..that is not easy to pull off and since they got that many member it's become more disadvantage
choreo is kinda messy. or its just that we are used to blackpink being 4 haha idk
Go Yuri!! Every time I show up blow up (uh)..But Yuri now is a part of IZ*ONE she is the main vocalist I'm so proud of Yuri.
Thank god she didnt win here but in pd48 instead
KiNG JoKeRZ She also didn’t technically win in P48. She was rigged in. So it was a fake win lol
@@chicharon14344 and what about it?
@@chicharon14344 it has been said many times that the last ranking of seats wasn't falsified
@@rini3403 Only dumb people like you would believe that lol she was nowhere near the ranks of kaeun, miru, miho. She basically just appeared in the top ranks out of the blue.
The "YG songs are only for YG artists" thing is, FOR REAL, TRUE.
@Giselle A if she didn't make it to debut on YG is for a reason...
Victoria Sánchez. lmao she left yg cause he kept delaying the group's debut. also she's really talented and has improved alot and she really has the yg vibe in most of her recent performances
Victoria Sánchez. she was the one who left yg dumbass💀
Truthfully BlackPink's songs are not for everyone. In my humble opinion, I love the vibes I
m getting from Seo Yeon, Sae Rom and the girl in red (shes so prettyyy idk her name,sorry!!) Ji Won be serving dem vocals too. The others don't really suit this style.
thank you! :))
Angeline Thorne
The girl in red is just.... ❤
Angeline Thorne Her name is Kim Myung Ji (the red one) position: rap 2
myungji ex idol right?
Im Nur A yup, she's former member of Tiny-G
that girl who sang "everytime i show up, blow up uh" really had me blow up...(in a bad way)
Sarah xoxo i couldnt agree more
Sarah xoxo I think between all the girls she did the best though
ikr
mellymolly132 jo yuri did the best? wtf? seoyeon saved this whole stage lol
GOING KOKOBOP sry I thought she was talking about jiwon. Didn't read it properly
Seoyeon and Jiwon part is the only the that I like TBH
the girl who sings at 0:54 is really good! i really think she's the best here
She is Jiwon❤
I also like her❤️
Jiwon from JYP ❤️❤️❤️
I think the mess is created because they have too many members because look at playing with fire's vocal stage on produce 101 , it does great because there's only 4 members in the team .
Need Xiumin in my opinion i think that this is better than produce 101 , number does not affect anything
vierra street, yes number affect anything. if they are going to perform a song that was created for 4 members at least change the choreography a little bit because this looked like a mess.
no it actually suit them because they were boys and playing with fire kinda has that boyish swag that is suitable for male and black pink can pull it out just as good as guys do... while on the other hand girl idols make it seem too girly
vierra street this isn't even get the half of produce 101 boys's performance . it's a mess here omgggg
the vocal team succeed in pulling an amazing performance bcs they rearranged the song and dance to their own style and made it like it's theirs but the girls only did a plain/normal cover
Jiwon, Her voice is amazing 👍👍👍👏❤❤❤
Nhat Luong I really like her voice too.
same, I like her voice
Nhat Luong I like it too~
Look back at this video of Yuri:
Idol school: in dance line
Produce 48: placed 3rd as a main vocal in IZ*ONE
So proud ❤
Jackey Slimey placed 3rd but that was a fake result. Lol she was rigged in
Was it her fault? NO
Was it Msnake fault? YES
@@ssukrt8665 Do they rightfully own the winning spots in the group? NO
What are those girls ranking then
@@wizone_once8832 72nd
Seoyeon and jiwon nailed it
now i know why the judges on kpop star said 'dont sing yg song if u dont have ur own voice characteristic' ah i see. idk im getting excited for this perf but- yeah just yeah i think it just a simple perf and i dont get excited at all they need more power on stage i think. okay they're still learning! fighting gurls! btw saerom visual no joke;----; btw please support Herin❤ And Jo Yuri why so kyood:'D
agree with you. idk why this perf was so plain.
rose's unique voice makes this song more interesting.
but i still love this perf, they are good especially jiwon, seoyeon and myungji ❤
Defi Tamia omg i forgot, soyeon too! she's the queen in this perf -for me lol-😂 they are all pretty. but yg style needs charisma like Soyeon
Yg artist didn't require the so call difficult high note like the other group songs ,and I have seen they could pull off the other group song so well but I rarely see anyone who can pull off yg girl group song except yg artist themselves .,it's require a lot of charisma and swag lol
jihoonable agree
I couldn't agree more! 🙌🏻
I appreciate the hard work, but I don't think whistle is a song for this kind of show. They're trying to sound like BP instead of being themselves :(
people saying "only yg artists can cover yg songs" are so cringy
like calm down stephanie it's just a song and this is called idol SCHOOL for a reason
OMG JO YURI TWERKING.KSKRLFEK I DIDN'T EXPECT THAT.
better not choosing YG song, seriously. I feel that they don't suit this song
im i the only one who hear "can u heal that" instead of "can u hear that"
me too
I’m upset that Jo Yuri only got like one line but damn I didn’t know that Yuri was like that before she met Yena😳
Edit: HAS YENA SEEN THIS VIDEO???? I CURIOUS MAN I WANNA KNOW IF SHE HAS OR HAS HYEWON SEEN THIS VIDEOOO??!!!?!?!?
Yuri got a short line because her voice didn't match for this song.
Seoyeon and Jiwon were amazing. They truly saved this performance.
i like a girl who wear red. her visual is no joke.
Her name is kim myeongji... glad u notice her
Jedapa Wong ikrrrrr shes so prettyyyyy
Yesssssss
kim myung jiii
same she stood out.
Jiwon,The two rappers who covered Jennie's part,and Seoyeon saved this performance tbh.
The 2.1M of views must be because they cover Blackpink's song because I do not see any spark in their performance.
You're blind then
you don't have a good taste
So true. hahahaha
*seoyeon's the only one who suits the song*
and 1:08
Can i know which one is she?
EXO.ASTRO.NCT_thnkyouformademysummerexciting shes the one that starts singing at 0:16
@@snowminL485 0:17 she's an ex yg trainnee that's why it suits her voice
@@hyewonthecakeslayer3166 yes, now i remembered yg posted vid her alone w other trainee n named them future 2ne1,right?
1:26 "Can you heal that?"
what im i going to heal? @_@
your ears DUH
BLACKPINKINMYAREA my ears are fine :)
HAAHHAHAHA IKR!!!
What exactly are we gonna heal???
Jake M kwkwkw
Jake M XDDDDDDDDDDD
No one can sing YG's song like the original artist. I mean this group doesn't have the carisma tho. Like no one stood out, duh they should sing a song that can be covered by everyone
2:08 yuri is on fire 🔥 🔥🔥💞💞
the girl who sang jisoo's lines oh god im mesmerized by how clear her voice is. its soothing and deep at the same time
this comment’s from a literal year ago so don’t mind me but that’s jiwon!!
Even Teddy said he made this song for Blackpink...
Aoi Kawagishi wasnt it supposed to be a 2ne1 song first? but they didnt release it?
Hugo no, all the songs they released were songs for blackpink.
Blackpink's manager ooh im sorry i must of read wrong information :/ :)
Hugo its alright lol
I dont blame you since many haters spread this rumor and called Blackpink 2ne1 copies :/
infireskook no its not, a part of the song sounds like a 2ne1 song. But its mostly because 2ne1 and blackpink have the same producer
I thinks it's really hard to cover YG's song bcs you need to be unique and charismatic, not only doing what's best and all. Even JYP admit that it's not an easy task to cover YG's song.
Saerom part 'hey boy', seoyeon bridge part,and jiwon highnote really slay this performance
i came here for jo yuri, oh god my eyed turn heartshape 2:08
Lee seoyeon with that style looks like jisoo... am I the only one? -_- haha I love her voice... I hope this performance is more longer
no you're not.
yes i think same with u
I'M MultiFandom Is Seoyeon from YG?
loceanlee 1515 yes
loceanlee 1515 yas she's ex yg trainee. you can check her vid on "YG Future 2ne1" or i forgot the title. she really kyood and so sm00l
I feel like YG are hard to cover cause they are composed for them 😛😛😛
My baby Seoyeon still slayed tho 💕💕💕
this! haha i think when TEDDY composed this song he know what to do with YG Artist, like make own colour for each artist, and sometimes even YG Artist covering other YG Artist not even good as we think
The songs are mostly composed BY them. Except for Blackpink.
kiysumi
Teddy personally said he had been stacking up songs for BlackPink 😂
It makes sense cause their debut has been delayed so many times.
Daysi I where is seoyeon ? what clothes she wore ? im confused 😂
+Nila Vania 0:17 black one
1:12 the judge made the „oh“ sound better than the girls lmao
Jiwon, Myeongji, and Seoyeon saved this
Lee Seoyeon let's debut ❤
Please can i ask you something ??? I really don't understand any thing .is it produce 101 or what please explain to me
Exo-l &army Fan its mnet idol school, a new program to train ordinary people who dont have any agency and the 9 final members will debut in a group. the format is almost the same with p101 tho
Neeva Stha the one at 0:18
yesss, my lovee💜
I'm not really familiar with their faces so I don't know where she is there but I heard she is good
To be honest, only Seoyeon and Jiwon fit this stage..... Especially, Seoyeon really had a YG vibe and also YG special voice tone (like Rose and Bom).
agree
👍
Personally, to be honest, none fit this stage
Agree
@asodear2 exactly!
Seoyeon!!! Slayed this! She got the YG vibeds but too bad she left😭💕
Jiwon is really good, is not like i know her or something I just found her name in the comments but Many people is saying that the group was bad but i really liked her voice and two girls more but jiwon for sure was GREAT!! I dont like when people just has bad things to say at least point some good things
Lee haein 😍😍😍😍💕
wanna be suit with this song?
1. stop acting cute
2. be queen n slay
they were not acting cute, they tried to imitate blackpink but failed because they have zero of charisma and team work, this was a mess
gong gong they weren't acting cute? Where bish? Where? All their gestures while on stage is too extra.. and cringeyyy
LisaVDawon fan ILuvThem, yes I kind of agree with you this performance was cringey but from what I see they were not trying to act cute, they wanted to look sexy but ended up being too girly and cute because they have no zero charisma.
S Wiggins this is my opinion, if u hav ur own opinion, just post ur own comment... tq..
gong gong sexy my ass.. it doesn't coordinate with their expression, gesture and tone. Like wth.
Yuri is in this team? I just noticed her when she got closed up at the last part
So many people are saying other shouldn't cover blackpink but actually some of the members I thought were really good (I don't even watch the show by the way)
I think Jiwon did a really good work as main vocal and Myeongji (I think that's how it's written) Rapped pretty well. Those two in my opinion were good ^^
Am I the only one who felt that cringe feeling? So the famous statement, "YG songs are for YG artists only", is really true. The whole song will become strange to you if someone tries to cover it 😂
Crizea S. i feel like jiwon did the best and it wasn't her best performance but she saved it
Crizea S. tbh idk why they won im really sick of the voters only voting because lee hae in is there. The gfriend one did excellent, perfect.
You are not the only one.. especially the 1st verse up until the 2nd verse..
Crizea S. i feel that too. i dont know why.
They did their best but nahhh.
Everyone wanted to cover this song also Hayong and other girls...I'm glad they didn't get it cuz I don't think it would suit anyone who are free-agented trainees, even who was yg's trainee like Soyeon could barely handle it... She did well anyway
Yg's songs always get a lot of attention but nobody noticed that the more attention the more pressure
Jiwon slaying
When Jo Yuri that time is getting hate for being dubbed as the Choi Yoojung 2.0 😂
Mnet should have heard jyp saying that people shouldn't cover yg songs bc just don't, the felling can't be even close
A lot of this girls are my fav on the show but no, just no :(
Perla D. Ramírez when jyp said that ? is there a video of it ?
I think so. :(
Hà Phương Dương in kpop star 6
Perla D. Ramírez yes because yg songs are more to empower unique voices.
True I mean bp clothes it self make everything completely hard "-"
my opinion after watching this vid : don't cover yg's artist songs.
edit: this comment got so much likes and i just want to say that im not hating on them, i just feel like they dont have the "aura" that yg artist have
Yuri Arianna I'm not a bp stan but they destroyed Whistle
Yuri Arianna I love your profile
Horus MMB They put so much effort on this then at the end get so criticism smh Destroy?They re just covering it don't be so harsh fgs.For me it was good,since they haven't performed that much yet.
Yuri Arianna RT
More like don't cover anything at all😂
The only people I know in the show are Natty, Haerin, and Seoyeon
Seoyeon did pretty well, but Jiwon did very well!
Jiwon and Seoyeon saved this performance. Myeoungi, is that her name, got some real swag as a rapper. Gyuri tried so hard to copy Blackpink while Saerom was trying to be sexy. Siwoo was like a backup dancer, did she even have a real line?
Gyuri is not in this team???
Blackpink must have been too awesome to the point where this performance didn't really meet my expectation but its cool.......they tried
👌👌👌👋
most of the girls on the show don't have any trainee or stage experience. don't compare new trainees to a group that dedicated a long time to practice and make the song theirs. it's a cover for a reason.
jinlissul ....calm down I didn't mean to sound rude or offensive to have u all fired up about it lmao😂✌
This comment section is full of delulu YG stans like you. They think that blackoink is too awesome and think high of themeselves. Learn to be humble and learn that they are still trainees. okay?
+jae myung I am a YG stan and I am so embarrassed by this delusional BP fans. Seriously. They are toxic especially this newer fans. This was a good cover compared to when Produce101 covered 2ne1 Fire. I feel like they are saying this just to make Blackpink feel special LMAO
They were too busy acring pretty they didn't even try matching the vibe of the song. It was a very nice song to show charisma but unfortunately they all fell flat. PD101 S1 was a lot, lot better.
agree omgs
👍👍👍👍
Paul Park but tbh you gotta remember that they don't have any company training backing them..most of them anyway.
Paul Park ikr? I can see Chungha, Somi, and other PD101 slaying this cover. Dang.
Maisha Chy Only 3 out of these 8 girls did not have any experience. It's sad that even those who had training or debuted before (lee seo yeon-ex-yg trainee, lee hae in from P101 S1 and part of IBI, lee young yoo who had some experience as a singer and competed in tribe of hip hop, park jiwon ex-jyp and competed in sixteen and myeong ji who debuted with Tiny-G) were not much better than those without some training at all.
Who's the one at 1:04? She's actually pretty good! (the one in a high ponytail and a grey/purple sweater)
got7 more like god I want all seven of them That's Jiwon, a former JYP trainee who also appeared on Sixteen which is the show that made Twice.
Oh damn, no wonder she's so good.
my seoyeon still got that yg style on her nerves. 😍
lee saerom's smile lights up my mood 😭
koo junhoe me too
yes oh my god. she's an angel ❤
so sweet and cute to me
there's something missing. idk. maybe it's the swag and the energy of blackpink
Ysa Belle yes. and the bad ass facial expression of blackpink while performing. these girls are all smiling while also singing seems like acting cute or whatever that does not suits the swag of the song
And the unity. The performance was all over the place. I didn't know where to focus.
I also think they are lack of charistma .
This is why blackpink is blackpink and this succsesfull
i think their vocals arent very unique at the first place. so despite they have good vocal skills the song wasn't as catchy as BP~!
my seoyeon is slayying
I'm just glad that Yuri debuted in IZ*ONE, she improved a lot💖
The only one moral lesson from this is
"DO NOT TRY TO COVER YG SONGS" their songs is like other level
Ikr :) lol
Vanessa Amanda tbh this is fantastic compared to the actual dumpster fire that was their cover of rookie
Maybe this is why Blackpink is really unique. No one can pull off their songs better than them. And there's a lot of them on stagd hihi. But all props to this group. Hwaiting!
Erie Bee Wow good confession 🙌🙌
Erie Bee DUH their the original artist but I agree few might have the vibe but no one can pull it off like BP does
Jo Yuri in a deep voice, im----
0:17 Seoyeon really got that YG slang lmao 🤣
Well now I know why Knetz think blackpink doesn't feel like a rookie
Cat Bit My Tongue I can't agree with you more ❤️
Cat Bit My Tongue true
Cat Bit My Tongue agree
Cat Bit My Tongue these aren't even trainees. Didn't Jennie train for like 6 years of course don't won't feel like rookies
Yup that's why they don't feel like rookies when they debuted. They feel like artists who has been in the industry for years.
Saerom's visual is really no joke. I'm really falling for her. Jiwon's voice is really good and Seoyeon really suit this song.
.
.
Yuri (I'm sorry if I spell wrong), I really want you to be you more than to be yoojung 2. Be original yuri is better than be other one's shadow.
Toon S how is yuri the "yoojung 2"? beside their similiar face?
Toon S they trying so hard to make her look like yoojung though she really does look alike. anyway im not hating on her, i really hope she, saerom, natty, jiwon, hayoung and chaeyoung will be in top 9 @ final (excuse my english)
Ayyash Kadullah At least 2:11 is one of the answers. It's really remind me of yoojung's bang bang performance. I think that she know that she has similiar face with yoojung so she has to shine her own charm. I cannot see her. I see yoojung cover her all the time in this program. I thought I can see her charm on the stage but when I see this performance, it still be yoojung's character.
.
.
I don't have negative thinking of her (explain if you misunderstand me) but I really want to see real yuri. It's not okay if people cannot remember her as her but remember her as other person, right?
.
.
English is not my mother language but I try to explain. I'm sorry if it has some mistakes. Hope you understand and don't mind it.
queendoyeon I'm really not hating on her too. I know that she is cute and have a talent so I want me (and other people) to see her as her not to be someone.
Toon S yuri itsnot her fault if she look like yoojung everyone is so unfair to her.
List of groups that are impossible to cover really well: Red Velvet, f(x), and blackpink. The bp girls have really unique voices. They also include a lot of English in their songs and three members are fluent and Jisoo is really good at pronunciation. It’s difficult to cover their songs. I think jiwon did the best
The rapping was actually good. The difference on why it didn't stood out is that they did a "flirtatious come and look at me I'm swaggy as hell" vibe while blackpink made it as a "I don't care if you look at me or not, you'll be amazed by me even just by sitting anyways, I'm too cool not to be noticed" thang.
They put their mic so far from their mouth I wonder how did the rap can be heard this clearly... And the vocal line is the best vocal line than other groups', people should at least appreciate the vocal instead of pointing out their unsuited style for this song.
Nuril Frida agree..=)
Nuril Frida I think the reason people are judging is becayse this isn't a vocal performance. I sound so rude criticizing them -i know, but it's a PERFORMANCE stage and they were far from owning the song. They didn't put their style in it and they failed even harder at trying to pull off BP's charms so maybe that's why we're so judgemental.
I know it's late, but. Same as other mnet survival, this version is already auto-tuned by mnet, you can her their real if you come live. And also i noticed that this round's fancam ver is their real voice but the next round and so on is not.
Nuril Frida This isn’t the best vocal line in all groups...
no offense but after watching these I realized how great blackpink was especially in performing live...
did i see jo yuri?
Yea
"bLoW uP Uh" im crying😭😭😭
aurora yeahh, me too 😂😂😂
"dont cover YG artist song in any survival show, YG song is made for YG artist, other singer outside YG will fail to cover YG songs" = JYP
Well, Produce 101 season 2 did cover playing with fire and it was amazing.
also produce 101 s1's monster was good, too.
Trainees in Produce Season 1 (Monster) & Season 2 (Playing With Fire & Fear) were good because they did it with new arrangement and their own style or lyrics
couldnt agree more.
Fart Sheep DARN that 101 ... DON'T U KNOW? THEY RE ARRANGED THE SONG ... IT AIN'T NO ORIGINAL... DO U STILL HAVE TO DEBATE ABOUT THIS?
Lee Seoyeon's stage prescence tho. She enjoyed the performance, it shows on her face. The fierceness is natural, unlike the others. She really has the YG vibe.
i like seoyeon and the one with that glittery black see through long sleeve with bangs. idk her name
YG's song is for YG's artists,don't never ever cover it
Racist
@@agoy7314 wtf?
seoye9n is trainee YG can't she sing it?:v
Rude
Are you YG staff? Lmfao
When you realize nobody (here and maybe other idols) can't do what BLACKPINK does on stage 👀 this made me realize even more how colorful and unique BP is
same, seeing stuff like this makes me realize even more just how unique blackpink is when it comes to vocal tones and stage presence. every time I've seen anyone try to cover "whistle" so far it just isn't that good. Not that that the idols who have covered bp songs are untalented, no no not at all. just not suited for bp songs.
IN YOUR AREA BLINK overact
Sekarayu Kinasih Mesyamayondri 👈 blackhead get jealous 😂😂
sekarayu kinasih Mesyamayondri u jealous?
IN YOUR AREA BLINK unique!? Hahhaha
JIWON LOOKS FREAKING PRETTY OMG!
izone yuri at the very end yaaa 💕
Just my opinion but many people are being ridiculous. Blackpink's their sunbae and the song is challenging enough to help them develop their skills. Just like how they cover SNSD in produce 101. Obviously they're lacking a lot and i'm sure no one dared compare them to blackpink. Please stop being extra it's really annoying to see comments like "only bp can sing this song"...