@@alexandru5369 95% of p4 players are getting NIL. Any half decent transfer portal players are all just looking for the biggest possible bag. And I dont blame them, its the system. Id try and get paid too.
Stop u guys were saying bama type teams would never lose again because they would just buy everyone but the opposite is happening talent is being distributed amongst other teams
@@alexandru5369for now….mid tier and low tier players will only stand for so much until they break. Not to mention how this has a trickle down effect all the way to the little leagues.
The borderline kids are not developing. Look no further than DJ U, he was set to be one of the top QBs after filling in for Lawrence. Bro got that Dr. Pepper money and never did anything but lose after.
They need to keep the portal closed until after the National Championship. Then close it before week zer0.. This is ridiculous. There is no reason to open the transfer portal this early. Players can still pick their teams after the natty. Once the season starts the portal should close and stay closed until after the National Championship.
People clamored for years because they felt it was unfair .05% of college athletes weren't getting paid [top college football and M Basketball players] [even though lots of them were getting paid under the table anyway]. They didn't realize moving away from amateurism might kill college sports. It was always so shortsighted. Amateurism wasn't perfect but now the entirety of college athletics is at risk with all these lawsuits and lack of structure.
How to fix college football. 1. Move the playoffs final rankings until after the bowls 2. Play all the bowls like they were in the BCS era without the championship game though, this would prevent most opt outs 3. Get rid of the conference championship game week and just do 1v2 on down in each conference and use playoff rankings week 12 of the season. 4. Cap freshman NIL at 100k 5. Cap NIL at 1 million 6. Only allow 1 transfer from FBS to FBS unless the coach leaves 7. Limit the transfer portal to spring only, move the 2nd signing day to march and make the transfer portal open the day after the championship game. 8. 8 team playoff using the BCS system have committee do the matchups though to prevent immediate rematches, use the AP, Coaches, Committee, Computers 25 percent each, has to be an open model computer can't be secret like the FPI. 9. 8th team is replaced by the highest ranked mid major if they are in the top 16.
What difference does it make if they enroll before the second semester starts? It is not like these guys are planning on going to classes and get a degree.
@@andrewschneider2121so they'd play the spring game and do spring practices with a school they're leaving? Good luck convincing any college coach. Any team could just poach talent from a conference rival and have their spring playbook.
Well the bigger problem is trying to tie sports to university. Probably just need to go to semi pro leagues. Have the institutions sell the assets to the cities.
Your correct. Pay a fee to use Universities name. Have the schools have lower league pro football. Players don't have to go to school. The players get 4 years to get to NFL. For most this is the end of the line
NIL needs to be regulated/limited & players that transfer need to sit out a year. Its a complete mess and will keep getting worse. Its going to become the norm for players to be on 4 or 5 teams by the time they're finished.
If I was a financially struggling student, I would be pissed seeing how much money these athletes are now getting. They are already entitled with free tuition and the best dorms.
Huff wasn’t fired at Marshall. He was seeking a renewal with a low buyout clause. Marshall wanted a decent buyout incase they had to hire a new coach etc. Huff bet on himself to force extension and lost. Goes to USM for less salary, less salary pool and less NIL than Coach Gibson was offered in his contract. Gibby contract was basically similar to extension Huff was offered except Gibby accepted the Buyout amount. Agreed Portal dates need fixed. Some Tie NIL to bowl game play, that’s a good first start.
Make players empoyees. Binding contracts with transfer fees so the small teams don't get totally screwed for developing talent. Make one transfer window in February. 16 team playoff with every conference gets an auto bid. Seed it 1 through 16 regardless of aq/ at-large. All 8 games in 1st round on campuses on the same day
I don't know why they let them even discuss the portal before the season is over. I actually like the portal - but there should be a window for it. They need something like, "talk about the portal or not play in your team's bowl game - and you forfeit a year of eligibility."
College football is a meme, unfortunately. The only thing that I can think of is just fully integrating certain college programs into the NFL as an affiliated minor league team or something. Let players get drafted right out of high school, then their list of college teams is at least limited to affiliate programs
my team has become relevant for the first time in decades, loses their coach the night after losing the biggest game in program history as he was negotiating terms w his new school during prep week for the championship game. the cfp, while allowing the non p4 schools a pathway at the same time kneecaps them w nil, tramsfer portal and realignment. college football is losing interest everywhere except the top teams, which seems to be all the nc2a cares about. this isnt sustainable. i found myself simultaneously becoming interested in the sport again only to be completely disillusioned all in one season
I totally believe that the athletes who make the university tens of millions per year should get paid, but in order to keep it fair/reasonable I believe the payment across all schools per year should be capped at around 150k per year and nothing like houses/cars either. Give them a wage that they could sustain a decent quality of life while they get free college btw, plus set their futures up well. Also the transfer portal should be closed until the end of the playoffs and not open up in the postseason.
I recall some OL guy entered the portal committed to Iowa the recommitted to Alabama. It’s just dumb. I can’t be invested in any of these players when they do t give a poot about where they play.
I dont think there needs to be a salary cap because you know for a fact some teams will try to find any sort of loophole or just slide money under the table. What I think needs to happen is that there needs to be some sort of market system like international soccer (Premier League and La Liga for example). I'm thinking more for the G5 but I could image the anger it would be to recruit a guy that people overlooked and didn't scout, under your coaching they develop into a solid player, and then just dip off a year later because a team offers him a crazy amount of money (which I can't blame on the player). That would be an infuriating thing to have to repeat over and over again, there should be some sort of compensation to the school and there funds. Each player that enters the transfer portal and gets picked up by another team there should be some sort of tax that goes to that school that's getting poached on. Yes they'd still be losing their players but at least they'll get some money to use to get another guy. Many teams in European soccer leagues like Porto and Benfica in Portugal, are very known for developing players before they go to the higher leagues like Darwin Nunez or Ronaldo, it could be seen as a good recruiting tool for teams and it will at least help with development and player retention.
Cash greed lack of good rules transfer portal madness, so does Army win since Marshall can't play? Coaches do the same thing about jobs and cash too? This year has shown what could happen without enough rules . People just thought it wouldn't get this bad . Imagine getting 700k to sign and then transferring for more . Until they get some things ironed out we will continue to have craziness all around.
I wanted LSU to step in to the independence bowl, Army is a more high profile opponent than Baylor and the last time we played in Shreveport we beat Notre Dame
We want to restrict the millonaires and billionaires of how they spend their money? They are the ones paying NIL. College football is doing great. That it is in crisis is false information.
coaches should be held accountable for the ridiculous money grab college sports and in particular football has become. they have no allegiance, no respect for contracts and seemingly only care about making their ends. worse, fans encourage the behavior, providing the moral cover by declaring well theyre looking out for family etc. all while conveniently forgetting about the players and students families investing their time and money and energy in the program etc. this is a sport w no future
It’s like the NFL but instead of AFC and NFC it’s Big Ten and SEC 😂 If you wanna fix this, cut public funding to schools that pay players and set the transfer portal to after the championship game, that’d make things fair, competitive and stop questionable practices
😂college football is ruined when Ohio state looses to Mich and it doesn't matter anymore !!! They still get in the mix to win it all that used to not be the case the games mean little now
There’s some real boomer behavior in this video and the comments The sport of college football is great, parity has increased exponentially, and there is more true competition than ever before
IMO 16 team CFP with SEC & B1G getting 4 slots ; ACC & B12 getting 2 slots each; G5 1; 3 at large.Teams 1-4 get 2 byes; teams 5-8 get 1 bye. teams 9-12 host 13-16. This avoids 1 vs 16; 2 vs 15. It rewards the highest ranked teams versus give byes to top 4 conference champions.
hey dg could you maybe start to do tiktok debates about politics I can guarantee you the amount of money that you would get looking at liberals like Dean and Parker the way they blew up on there would surprise you
![County Vote SECURES All Public Funding For Rays Stadium [Highlights]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1KlEPLpT5S8/mqdefault.jpg)
College Football gradually moving towards the NFL Sports Entertainment business model.
It’s almost like NIL is killing the sport… oh wait we all knew it would
And the portal.
The portal is the true problem. NIL really only benefits the top 10% to 15% of players
@@alexandru5369 95% of p4 players are getting NIL. Any half decent transfer portal players are all just looking for the biggest possible bag. And I dont blame them, its the system. Id try and get paid too.
Stop u guys were saying bama type teams would never lose again because they would just buy everyone but the opposite is happening talent is being distributed amongst other teams
@@alexandru5369for now….mid tier and low tier players will only stand for so much until they break. Not to mention how this has a trickle down effect all the way to the little leagues.
It used to be that you got a free college education and a chance to play at a high level. That was enough for 100 years.
And then players started to get caught accepting money from donors, schools lost scholarships and so on. NIL, enter stage left…..
The borderline kids are not developing. Look no further than DJ U, he was set to be one of the top QBs after filling in for Lawrence. Bro got that Dr. Pepper money and never did anything but lose after.
Marshall didnt fire their head coach. He didnt want to re-sign after numerous meetings w the AD and university.
They need to keep the portal closed until after the National Championship. Then close it before week zer0.. This is ridiculous. There is no reason to open the transfer portal this early. Players can still pick their teams after the natty. Once the season starts the portal should close and stay closed until after the National Championship.
the portal has to be open before the playoffs because the player needs to enroll into their new school before the 2nd semester starts.
$700K upfront for you to produce 8 catches is an absolute finesse.
People clamored for years because they felt it was unfair .05% of college athletes weren't getting paid [top college football and M Basketball players] [even though lots of them were getting paid under the table anyway].
They didn't realize moving away from amateurism might kill college sports.
It was always so shortsighted.
Amateurism wasn't perfect but now the entirety of college athletics is at risk with all these lawsuits and lack of structure.
How to fix college football.
1. Move the playoffs final rankings until after the bowls
2. Play all the bowls like they were in the BCS era without the championship game though, this would prevent most opt outs
3. Get rid of the conference championship game week and just do 1v2 on down in each conference and use playoff rankings week 12 of the season.
4. Cap freshman NIL at 100k
5. Cap NIL at 1 million
6. Only allow 1 transfer from FBS to FBS unless the coach leaves
7. Limit the transfer portal to spring only, move the 2nd signing day to march and make the transfer portal open the day after the championship game.
8. 8 team playoff using the BCS system have committee do the matchups though to prevent immediate rematches, use the AP, Coaches, Committee, Computers 25 percent each, has to be an open model computer can't be secret like the FPI.
9. 8th team is replaced by the highest ranked mid major if they are in the top 16.
Capping NIL at any number is just like capping it at zero. Schools will just go back to cheating their asses off.
The reason the portal is open before the playoffs is because the player needs to enroll into their new school before the 2nd semester starts.
This isn’t sustainable
It shouldn’t happen between semesters. Wait for the year to finish.
You act like they can’t change this and let’s be honest do any of the players care…….. No
What difference does it make if they enroll before the second semester starts? It is not like these guys are planning on going to classes and get a degree.
@@andrewschneider2121so they'd play the spring game and do spring practices with a school they're leaving? Good luck convincing any college coach. Any team could just poach talent from a conference rival and have their spring playbook.
Well the bigger problem is trying to tie sports to university. Probably just need to go to semi pro leagues. Have the institutions sell the assets to the cities.
Your correct. Pay a fee to use Universities name. Have the schools have lower league pro football. Players don't have to go to school. The players get 4 years to get to NFL. For most this is the end of the line
Problem is 99.9% of the players will not make the nfl, so they actually do need to be in school
NIL needs to be regulated/limited & players that transfer need to sit out a year. Its a complete mess and will keep getting worse. Its going to become the norm for players to be on 4 or 5 teams by the time they're finished.
I had Rutgers season tickets from 1976 through 2022.
I saw this disaster coming and stopped.
I loved college football in 90s and 00s. Don't watch or care anymore
Yeah…I wouldn’t want to go to Shreveport either.
MLB needs to listen to the purists when they say don’t change the game.
game has already changed quite a bit.
If I was a financially struggling student, I would be pissed seeing how much money these athletes are now getting. They are already entitled with free tuition and the best dorms.
All I can say is with the eligibility I better have some time once I transfer from CC
I’m sure you will have plenty of time……..LOL.
Coach got a guaranteed 4 year contract for more money and a bigger staff budget. Can't blame him.
Huff wasn’t fired at Marshall. He was seeking a renewal with a low buyout clause. Marshall wanted a decent buyout incase they had to hire a new coach etc. Huff bet on himself to force extension and lost. Goes to USM for less salary, less salary pool and less NIL than Coach Gibson was offered in his contract. Gibby contract was basically similar to extension Huff was offered except Gibby accepted the Buyout amount.
Agreed Portal dates need fixed. Some Tie NIL to bowl game play, that’s a good first start.
Transfer portal hasn't ruined college football but it's made me care a hell of a lot less about it. Sad.
the destruction of fan experience for non p4 schools is so bad it seems like it's planned
Its even worse for FCS, Furman lost their star QB and has 10 less wins this year
Make players empoyees. Binding contracts with transfer fees so the small teams don't get totally screwed for developing talent. Make one transfer window in February. 16 team playoff with every conference gets an auto bid. Seed it 1 through 16 regardless of aq/ at-large. All 8 games in 1st round on campuses on the same day
I don't know why they let them even discuss the portal before the season is over.
I actually like the portal - but there should be a window for it.
They need something like, "talk about the portal or not play in your team's bowl game - and you forfeit a year of eligibility."
4:44, personal driver sounds nice for a college kid 😊
Well to be fair, I’m sure the kid doesn’t know how to drive unless it’s on XBOX. So he probably needs a driver…….
Autobids for any conference is a terrible idea.
Agreed. Nothing better than a chit conference having a 3 loss champion or runner up and getting an auto bid.
Auburn had 3 qbs leave in the portal. Theyre screwed next year
They got Jackson Arnold and Ashtyn Daniels. They upgraded. Not by much though. Not sure what Freeze is cooking
College football is a meme, unfortunately. The only thing that I can think of is just fully integrating certain college programs into the NFL as an affiliated minor league team or something. Let players get drafted right out of high school, then their list of college teams is at least limited to affiliate programs
my team has become relevant for the first time in decades, loses their coach the night after losing the biggest game in program history as he was negotiating terms w his new school during prep week for the championship game.
the cfp, while allowing the non p4 schools a pathway at the same time kneecaps them w nil, tramsfer portal and realignment. college football is losing interest everywhere except the top teams, which seems to be all the nc2a cares about. this isnt sustainable.
i found myself simultaneously becoming interested in the sport again only to be completely disillusioned all in one season
Need to do something about the Transfer Portal and need to install age limits. I don’t want to see a 25yo playing college sports.
You mean like the Buffs QB………LOL.
Leaving before bowl games( or playoff games) should result in punishment
Seeing Marshall having to drop out is pretty sad
They have let greed run the show, a recipe for disaster everytime!
Good, we dont need 36 bowls. Just the playoff bowl and major non playoff bowls.
I totally believe that the athletes who make the university tens of millions per year should get paid, but in order to keep it fair/reasonable I believe the payment across all schools per year should be capped at around 150k per year and nothing like houses/cars either. Give them a wage that they could sustain a decent quality of life while they get free college btw, plus set their futures up well. Also the transfer portal should be closed until the end of the playoffs and not open up in the postseason.
I recall some OL guy entered the portal committed to Iowa the recommitted to Alabama. It’s just dumb. I can’t be invested in any of these players when they do t give a poot about where they play.
I dont think there needs to be a salary cap because you know for a fact some teams will try to find any sort of loophole or just slide money under the table. What I think needs to happen is that there needs to be some sort of market system like international soccer (Premier League and La Liga for example). I'm thinking more for the G5 but I could image the anger it would be to recruit a guy that people overlooked and didn't scout, under your coaching they develop into a solid player, and then just dip off a year later because a team offers him a crazy amount of money (which I can't blame on the player). That would be an infuriating thing to have to repeat over and over again, there should be some sort of compensation to the school and there funds. Each player that enters the transfer portal and gets picked up by another team there should be some sort of tax that goes to that school that's getting poached on. Yes they'd still be losing their players but at least they'll get some money to use to get another guy. Many teams in European soccer leagues like Porto and Benfica in Portugal, are very known for developing players before they go to the higher leagues like Darwin Nunez or Ronaldo, it could be seen as a good recruiting tool for teams and it will at least help with development and player retention.
Cash greed lack of good rules transfer portal madness, so does Army win since Marshall can't play? Coaches do the same thing about jobs and cash too? This year has shown what could happen without enough rules . People just thought it wouldn't get this bad . Imagine getting 700k to sign and then transferring for more . Until they get some things ironed out we will continue to have craziness all around.
The portal being open rn is crazy
I wanted LSU to step in to the independence bowl, Army is a more high profile opponent than Baylor and the last time we played in Shreveport we beat Notre Dame
NIL is here to stay due to legal rulings. The real problem is the transfer rules.
Only allow the players to transfer 1 time.
Cam rising coming back to Utah is insane
We want to restrict the millonaires and billionaires of how they spend their money? They are the ones paying NIL. College football is doing great. That it is in crisis is false information.
This will move to the fans to pick up the tab real soon. Tennessee has already upped their prices for a “talent fee” to pay for these players.
coaches should be held accountable for the ridiculous money grab college sports and in particular football has become. they have no allegiance, no respect for contracts and seemingly only care about making their ends. worse, fans encourage the behavior, providing the moral cover by declaring well theyre looking out for family etc. all while conveniently forgetting about the players and students families investing their time and money and energy in the program etc.
this is a sport w no future
"We Are NOT Marshall"
I'm a Kentucky fan so i have nothing to worry about ever. lol
I think college sports (like everything else) needs a reset.
In defense of Marshall players, who in their right mind wants to go to Shreveport?
And they said it will be a great idea to bring money into amateur sports. 🙄
Lanorris sellers has oregon written all over him after next season
Quinn sewers can jump right on the portal
Right on
Did you even watch it?
They need to just get rid of bowls. We should not be rewarding mediocre teams just so a bunch of corporate sponsors can give the NCAA money
Nah
It’s like the NFL but instead of AFC and NFC it’s Big Ten and SEC 😂
If you wanna fix this, cut public funding to schools that pay players and set the transfer portal to after the championship game, that’d make things fair, competitive and stop questionable practices
All facts. An absolute mess
why are they trying to copy march madness and destroy the bowl culture
Yeah the portal gotta go
😂college football is ruined when Ohio state looses to Mich and it doesn't matter anymore !!! They still get in the mix to win it all that used to not be the case the games mean little now
Hoards of Michigan fans were trolling and heckling, living their best lives only to find out OSU fans didn’t care.
@@conservatronit was their Super Bowl due to the fact they lost 6 games this year.
No interest in boxing?
16 seed could be 8-4 from sec or b1g
The playoff needs to be 32 teams. Get college games back to 10 games, and eliminate conf. championships.
Oh crappppp 😂💯
There’s some real boomer behavior in this video and the comments
The sport of college football is great, parity has increased exponentially, and there is more true competition than ever before
Its disgusting
You will complain about there being a problem in College Football. Your going to sit back do nothing and like it
Okay claiming oregon isnt developing players is a little much.
IMO 16 team CFP with SEC & B1G getting 4 slots ; ACC & B12 getting 2 slots each; G5 1; 3 at large.Teams 1-4 get 2 byes; teams 5-8 get 1 bye. teams 9-12 host 13-16. This avoids 1 vs 16; 2 vs 15. It rewards the highest ranked teams versus give byes to top 4 conference champions.
I'd love it if you would niche down to reporting on geopoliticcs. Id sub and watch for sure.
More crypto bro, this does nothing for anyone. Thanks for being cool tho
“Those players are entertaining me but don’t pay.”…. yea ok
More crypto
hey dg could you maybe start to do tiktok debates about politics I can guarantee you the amount of money that you would get looking at liberals like Dean and Parker the way they blew up on there would surprise you
First
Band, BFD, what can you do?